When Two Runaway Fiancés Collide: The Extraordinary Train Journey That Rewrote a Royal Romance
If you tell my father where I am, I shall scream. >> Could you wait until we leave the station? My mother is on the platform more. >> Anora Bramwell stared at him until this morning in June 1893. She had thought she knew every possible disaster that could attend a wedding. His dark morning coat was unmistakable.
So was the white carnation crushed against his waistcoat and the face she had spent 8 weeks attempting to imagine beside her at breakfast for the rest of her life. Your grace, Miss Bramwell. Her wedding veil slid off her shoulder and landed between them. For three dreadful seconds, neither moved. Outside a porter slammed a door.
Somewhere along the platform, a woman called for a missing hatbox. The ordinary world appeared determined to continue, although the Duke of Westeran and his bride were sitting opposite one another on a train scheduled to leave the town in which they were supposed to be married that afternoon. Then Anora looked at his vis.
Were you looking for me? No. There was no gallantry in the answer, no possible misunderstanding. He had packed shirts. She sat down very carefully. Oh, Piers Tregarth, who had delivered speeches before rooms full of impatient men without once losing his place, discovered that he could not think of a single decent thing to say to a woman in a wedding dress.
The engine gave a long whistle, Honora reached for the door handle. Pier stood at the same instant, catching the veil before it slipped beneath her boot. They collided in the narrow space, his elbow against her shoulder, her small traveling bag striking his knee. By the time they had disentangled themselves, the carriage had begun to move.
She looked out at the platform sliding away. He looked at the veil in his hand. “Well,” she said. “We appear to have improved matters. It was the first unkind thing he had ever heard her say. For some reason, it made him feel less like a murderer. The train gathered speed. Belwick station disappeared behind a goods shed, taking with it the last chance of stepping quietly down and pretending nothing had happened.
Anora leaned back against the seat. Beneath her cloak, white silk spread across the faded upholstery in an absurdly magnificent pool. Piers offered the veil. Thank you. You may put it anywhere. I have developed a dislike of it. He folded it across his vise. Her hands were shaking. She tucked them under her cloak before he could offer sympathy. Sympathy would finish her.
She had expected fury from her father, tears from her sister, and perhaps a brief formal expression of disappointment from the man she was abandoning. She had not prepared for the discovery that he had been making precisely the same escape. At 31, Anora had thought herself too old for a fresh species of humiliation.
Where were you going? She asked. Lindmouth, she closed her eyes. Of course you were. You, too. My sister has taken rooms there. I thought she would let me in. I have a house. Naturally. It would have been inconvenient if you had needed to ask somebody. He accepted that in silence. She wished he would argue.
His steady courtesy had been one of the things she thought she could build a marriage upon. Now it seemed a polished surface beneath which she had never bothered to look. After a moment he said, “I left a letter. So did I. That is something. Do you think so?” Mine began with a sentence about how grateful I was. It was an appalling letter.
I had to write three versions before I could make it sound sufficiently unlike a refusal. The Duke looked at her. What did it sound like? A woman who had been abducted by her own regrets. He sat down. The little movement brought his face into the light from the window. There were dark hollows beneath his eyes.
She had noticed them at dinner the previous evening, and assumed he was attending to important business. She had been grateful for his distraction. It had allowed her to swallow almost nothing without being observed. I said I was unequal to the occasion. He told her. Were you? Yes. So was I. They looked at one another across the distance.
The wedding breakfast was supposed to have closed. It had not been a forced marriage. That was the difficulty. There was no cruel guardian to blame. No debt collector at the door. No threat hanging over either family. Anora’s father had money enough. Peers had considerably more. Two sensible adults had considered a sensible arrangement and agreed to it.
While a procession of delighted relatives mistook their willingness for joy, Anora had liked him. She liked him still, though she would rather have bitten her tongue than admit it at that moment. He was attentive without being familiar. He never interrupted her father, even when her father deserved it.
His letters were beautifully punctuated. At their first dinner, when she had caught her sleeve on a chair, he had quietly freed it before anyone could remark upon her clumsiness. None of those things explained how to marry him. “What time is it?” she asked. He consulted his watch. “A4 10. The wedding was at 2. My father will have found the letter.
My secretary will have found mine. You did not give it to your mother.” No, Hanora let out a small miserable breath. I left mine with my maid. She’s 19. I told her not to let Peppa read it until 11, as if making her wait would improve anything. Piers put away his watch. We must send word from the next station. Yes.
She said it without looking at him. The relief she had imagined on the train had failed to arrive. Instead, she could see the wedding flowers, her sister’s carefully altered dress, the girl sitting outside her bedroom with an envelope. She would be frightened to deliver. I cannot go through with it, Hanora said. He went very still.
I am not asking you to. No, but if we go back, everyone will ask. They will say we are frightened. They will tell us people are waiting. People are waiting. I know. Her voice broke on the last word. She hated that more than the veil, more than the dress, more than the sight of his packed val. I know they are. Piers moved his hand toward the space between them, then stopped.
He had taken her hand exactly four times during their engagement. Every occasion had been supervised, appropriate, and almost entirely without warmth. “I cannot marry you today either,” he said. There it was, plainly spoken. She had wanted the wedding stopped. She had not wanted to hear that she was a woman.
A man could not bear to marry. He saw her expression change. Hanora, I did not mean. You needn’t soften it. I have just said the same thing. Yes, it is still a dreadful thing to hear. She looked at him then. The train ran between fields bright with the particular green of early June. A man in a cart waited at a crossing.
Cows continued to graze, unconcerned with the collapse of two respectable lives. Why did you ask me? She said. Pier rubbed a thumb over the edge of his watch chain. I thought we should suit. Because I am quiet, among other things. Name one. You are kind to my mother. I am kind to most elderly women. It isn’t a marriage proposal.
His mouth moved almost a smile, then settled. I know that now. At their second meeting, his mother had fallen asleep in her chair. Anora had continued talking softly about the garden until the older woman woke, sparing her the embarrassment of finding a room full of people staring at her. Peers had watched from the doorway, something in his chest, worn thin by months of being told what his life required had loosened.
He had mistaken gratitude for certainty. And you, he asked, why did you accept? She might have said that she respected him. She did. She might have spoken of affection developing in time, of common interests, of the wish to make a useful home. All the phrases had served her well before. Instead, she said, I was tired of being the one for whom nothing happened.
He did not rescue her from the sentence. My sister married, my cousins married. Even the girls I was asked to chaperon began having babies. I know there are worse things. I know I have been fortunate. But when you asked, everyone looked so pleased,” Papa cried. “I had not seen him cry since my mother died, and you were kind.
I thought perhaps I could step into the happiness they had already made for me.” Piers lowered his eyes. The more they spoke of it, the less room there seemed to be for anything else,” he said. She nodded once. The wheels struck a change in the rails. The rhythm slowed ahead beyond a stand of trees. The next station came into view.
Anora stood before she could lose her nerve. Pier lifted her small bag from the seat. “We can send the telegrams and take a carriage back,” he said. She looked at him sharply. “To stop it,” he added. “We should at least do that ourselves.” At the door, she turned. “Will you stand beside me when they ask?” “Yes, even if your mother cries,” he glanced toward the platform, his face suddenly older than 38. Yes, he said again less easily.
The train stopped. He stepped down first, then offered his hand. For the first time since she had accepted his proposal, Anora took it because she actually needed help. Her skirts caught on the step. He bent to free them, and she heard him say something under his breath. “What? Your dress appears more determined to attend this wedding than either of us.
A laugh escaped her, sudden and wholly inappropriate. Then she began to cry. There was nothing graceful about it. She cried on the little platform beside a stack of empty milk churns, while Piers stood holding a bridal veil, and looking as though he would rather face a firing squad than select an appropriate response. At last he offered his handkerchief.
“It is clean,” he said with unnecessary semnity. That made everything worse. Anora laughed into the linen and cried harder. A porter approached, took in the dress, the juke, and the veil, and quietly decided that the milk churns needed moving elsewhere. Piers waited. He did not tell her she must be brave. Eventually the fit passed, leaving her cold and exhausted.
“I am not crying because you will not marry me,” she said. “I didn’t think you were. I might be a little.” He looked away, giving her the privacy his presence could not otherwise offer. I am not enjoying being unwanted either, he admitted. She blew her nose. How ridiculous we are. Yes, they sent separate telegrams. Pier is said that he was safe, that the ceremony must not proceed, and that he was returning. Anoras said much the same.
She added a request that nobody blame Nelly, who had only done what she was told. When the cler asked for payment, Anora discovered that she had brought three pairs of gloves and no purse. Peers paid without comment. She hated how grateful she felt for the absence of one.
Finding a carriage took nearly half an hour. During the wait, Anora bought nothing, ate nothing, and watched a sparrow attack a piece of string beneath a bench. The Duke stood a few feet away, exchanging practical sentences with the station master. He seemed to have recovered his competence now that the problem involved horses rather than marriage.
By the time they reached Belwick, the bells had not begun to ring. The relief of that nearly undid her again. Her father was waiting in the entrance hall. Behind him stood her sister Rowena in pale blue silk, one cuff still pinned, where the dress maker had been making a final adjustment. Piers’s mother sat in the drawing room beyond the open doors.
Somehow the two households had already combined their fear into a single gathering. “Where have you been?” Mr. Bramwell demanded. “On the train.” “I know that.” Why? Hanora opened her mouth. Nothing came out. The familiar carpet was beneath her feet. Her father was wearing the waste coat she had chosen for him. On the table stood the silver tray her mother used to bring out at Christmas.
Everywhere she looked was something that asked her to make this right. Piers put her bag down. We both left independently, he said. Neither knew the other was going. We met on the train. Mr. Bramwell stared at him. You left? Yes. On your wedding morning? Yes. [snorts] The older man’s face darkened instinctively. Anora stepped forward.
He was not abandoning me. I was already abandoning him. Rowena made a strangled sound and pressed a hand to her mouth. It was not amusement. It was astonishment, looking desperately for somewhere to go. You can discuss this after the wedding, Mr. Bramwell said. No, Papa. You are upset, both of you. There is still time. No.

The second refusal came out more clearly. She heard it cross the hall, striking objects she had always been careful not to disturb. Her father looked at her as though she had become a stranger. From the drawing room, the Daager Duchess said her son’s name. Piers turned at once. Anora watched him go to the chair, kneel awkwardly beside it, and take his mother’s hand.
She waited for him to tell the older woman that it had been a misunderstanding. That was how such things were repaired. Someone surrendered and everyone else agreed not to discuss the cost. “I am sorry,” he said. His mother had dressed with particular care. Tiny pearls trembled against her gray hair. She had been ill during the winter, and the recovery had left her thinner, easily tired, fiercely resentful of being treated as an invalid.
Her name was Eglantine, though almost nobody had called her that in 30 years. I was at the station to meet your godfather, she said. I thought I saw you through a window. Then I thought I must have been mistaken. Pier lowered his eyes. I saw your hat. I hid behind the newspaper. She looked at him for a long moment. Did you quarrel? She asked. No.
Then what happened? I was going to marry a woman I scarcely know. I thought it would become easier if I went on arranging things. It became more frightening. Marriage is frightening. I know. I should still have wanted this one. Hanora stood in the doorway. Peers looked up at her, and for a moment she saw the effort it cost him to leave the sentence where it was.
The daager drew her hand back. I had hoped to see you settled. I know, Mama. He did not offer her a new promise. Anora found herself loving him a little for that, though it was an inconvenient time to begin. Mr. Bramwell wanted an explanation that could be given to the guests. A sudden indisposition would do.
An urgent family matter. Anything that did not require him to tell people he had spent weeks inviting that the two principal participants had fled in opposite directions and landed on the same train. Peers would not claim illness. Anora would not let him take the whole blame. Eventually, they agreed that both had reconsidered and that there would be no wedding.
The words looked pathetically small when the butler wrote them down. Then came the practical work. A message went to the church. Carriages were sent to meet arriving guests. Rowena found Hanora’s aunt weeping in a corridor and gave her something to do. The cook, told that the meal could still be served to those who had traveled, announced that somebody would eat it, even if she had to carry the dishes into the road herself.
Anora went upstairs and let Nelly unfasten her dress. The girl was pale with anxiety. Did he read it too soon, miss? No. You did exactly as I asked. I was afraid I had spoiled something. Hanora caught her hand. You did not spoil anything. I should have spoken to him myself. With the gown removed, her body seemed suddenly her own again.
There were red marks at her waist. She had imagined keeping the dress for the rest of her life. Now she could hardly bear to have it in the room. Put it away, please, she said. Then when Nellie’s face fell, she added, “Not the work you did. That was lovely. The dress has merely had a difficult morning.” downstairs peers were speaking to her father alone.
She heard their voices through the study door and stopped despite herself. She would have made you a good wife, Mr. Bramwell said. I believe she would. You have made her look a fool. A pause. Pier said, I should have spoken before today. Hanora opened the door. So should I, Papa. I won’t have him punished because you cannot bear to be angry with me.
her father turned away. On his desk lay the order of service, the names printed together beneath the date. “I don’t know what you want,” he said. The helplessness in his voice hurt more than anger would have done. “Neither do I,” she answered. “I thought that meant I ought to accept what was offered.” Pierers left before the guests sat down to eat.
He had other explanations to make at his own house, other people to disappoint. At the door he gave Anora her small bag and the folded veil. She took them. Thank you for coming back. I had help. You could have stayed on the train. So could you. She studied him without the terrible necessity of becoming his wife that afternoon. She found she could look at his face properly.
There was a shallow scar beside his eyebrow, almost concealed by the shape of it. She had never noticed it before. Did you truly mean to go to Lindmouth? Yes, I hope you don’t. Not yet. I think I should like to be the only runaway at my sister’s breakfast table. Of course, he hesitated, then bowed. It was the bow he had given her after every carefully managed visit.
She almost asked him not to do it. Then he was gone, and she had missed another opportunity to say what she meant. Her father did not speak to her at supper. That evening she found him in the garden, still wearing his wedding waste coat, smoking a cigar he had allowed to go out. Honora sat beside him. I liked him, he said eventually. So did I.
You were never to be sold, you know. I know. I would have let you refuse. She looked at the dark end of his cigar. I did refuse. It has not been easy for you to let me. He flinched, then nodded. They sat without speaking until the evening grew cold. When she rose, he caught her wrist as gently as he had when she was small.
Tell your sister not to keep you at the seaside forever. It was not forgiveness for everything. It was enough for her to lean down and kiss his cheek. 3 days later, Anora traveled to Lindmath in an ordinary brown dress. Rowena met her on the platform with a fierce embrace and an immediate complaint about the wind. Her husband Lucius had returned to London on business, leaving rooms that looked directly over the sea, and a sitting room in which nobody had arranged white flowers.
For the first week, Anora slept late, ate more than she expected, and discovered that freedom could be very quiet. Nobody proposed to her. Nobody discussed her future. A boy selling postcards called her madam, and did not know whom she had failed to marry. On the ninth morning she reached for a second cup at breakfast before remembering there was nobody for whom she needed to pour it.
She sat with her hand suspended over the table. She had not wanted that wedding. It was becoming inconveniently clear that she wanted to know what had happened to the man. She wrote him a note that afternoon. It began with an inquiry after his mother, continued with a description of the sea, and ended with a sentence she crossed out so heavily that the paper nearly tore.
Rowena found her making a fresh copy. What did the first one say? Nothing. An unusually violent nothing. Hanora laid down the pen. I should like to see him then say that. He may think I am trying to get him back. Are you? I never had him. Rowena sat on the edge of the desk dislodging three postcards. Write the note you wish to write. You need not submit it to a committee of imaginary aunts. So Anora did.
She told peers that she hoped he was well, that she had discovered a bakery which ought to be protected from all sensible advice about moderation, and that if he still wished to visit his house in Lindmouth, she would be pleased to have tea with him. After she posted it, she spent 2 days wishing she could recover it from the bottom of the sea.
His reply arrived on the third morning. He was well. His mother was alternately cross with him, and anxious that he was not eating enough, which he thought a hopeful sign. He would come to Lindmouth the following Thursday. He had once lived there for a summer as a boy, and remembered the bakery, though he was sorry to learn that its influence had spread.
Then beneath the formal conclusion, he had added a line. I should like to see you too. Hanora read it three times. Rowena, watching from the other side of the breakfast table, said nothing at all. Peers arrived without flowers. She had not expected them until she felt relief at their absence.
He came to the hotel sitting room in a light summer suit, carrying his hat as if he did not know where it belonged. The scar beside his eyebrow was more visible in daylight. “You look rested,” he said. “I have been practicing successively, almost professionally.” Rowena gave them both tea and remained for the entire visit. Anora was grateful.
The presence of a third person relieved them of the obligation to turn every sentence into an explanation of the past. They discussed the beach, the hotel, a disagreement Rowena had had with Lucius over the purchase of an entirely unnecessary rug. Piers asked why it was unnecessary. Because we possess flaws already, Rowena said, “Surely the rug is intended to conceal them.
” Hanora looked at him over her cup. He had made the remark so seriously that her sister had begun to explain the nature of the objection before catching herself. You have hidden a disposition to mischief, Anora said after Rowena went to fetch a letter from upstairs. Not successfully. My sisters used to find it intensely irritating.
He had two married sisters, both living some distance away. She knew their names, the ages of their children, and almost nothing about the boy who had grown up with them. What else did you do? Disappoint my dancing master? That is not difficult. and learn a number of tricks with coins. She set down her cup. I beg your pardon.
My youngest sister was ill one summer. I had exhausted my conversation. Show me. He looked toward the door. Now, unless you have an engagement to deceive somebody more important. He took a coin from his pocket. His hands were good, she noticed, capable, and slightly scarred at the knuckles. He displayed the coin, closed one hand, tapped it with the other, and opened both palms.
The coin fell out of his sleeve and struck the tea tray with a sharp little ring. Anora stared at it. “I had rather more practice when I was 15,” he said. Her laugh arrived before she could consider whether it was kind. Piers looked at her, then down at the coin, and began to laugh himself. When Rowena returned, they were both red-faced and trying to appear composed.
“What have I missed?” “Nothing you would pay to see,” Pier said. He stayed in Lindmath for 10 days. His house stood above the west end of the beach, small by the standards of his other properties, with windows that rattled when the wind came in from the sea. He had not visited it for years. Now, for once, he had no urgent reason to leave.
Anora and Rowena walked with him in the mornings. Sometimes Lucius joined them when he came down for the weekend. They visited the bakery where peers bought a bun that promptly shed sugar over his coat. They watched children dig a trench against the advancing tide. They sat through a band performance in which the loudest instrument appeared, determined to win an argument with all the others.
Anora discovered that Piers disliked being asked to speak immediately after a large meal, remembered the names of horses long dead, and became unexpectedly stubborn when he thought he had identified a bird. Piers discovered that Anora was not quiet. She was quiet with people she was trying to please, with Rowena, or while speaking about something that genuinely interested her.
She could be vigorous, absurd, impatient, and occasionally unfair. She apologized when she realized it. Sometimes the realization took longer than it ought. One afternoon they watched a man on the prominard demonstrate a mechanical toy. A wooden bird pecked at a tin dish while a small dog chased its own tail beside it.
Anora stood looking until Rowena was ready to move on. “You want it?” Pier said. “Certainly not.” “Why? because it is ridiculous. He studied the dog which had become stuck halfway round. That appears to be its principal advantage. She bought it herself. The vendor wrapped it in paper and she carried it back to the hotel, feeling peculiarly happy.
No one suggested it belonged in a nursery she did not yet possess. It could be ridiculous simply for her. Later that evening, Pierers heard the little mechanism rattling through the open sitting room window. He stopped outside long enough to hear Anora complain that the dog was losing again, and Rowena tell her to stop taking sides.
He walked home smiling. On Sunday, the four of them hired a boat on the sheltered water near the harbor. Lucius claimed considerable experience and provided very little evidence of it. Pierers took the oars, misjudged the first stroke, and splashed Anora’s skirt. She looked down at the wet patch, a remarkably original courtship technique.
The word hung between them. Lucius became deeply interested in a mooring rope. Rowena looked out toward the shore. Peers kept his hands on the oars, his ears growing red. “Is that what this is?” he asked. Anora had meant to make a joke, or had meant to make a joke she could withdraw if necessary, for once she left herself no retreat. I think it might be.
The boat turned gently on the water. Somewhere behind them a gull gave an objectionable cry. I had hoped so, he said. It was a small reply spoken without ceremony. Anora felt it all the way down to the wet hem against her ankle. They returned to shore with nobody drowned, and Lucius’s reputation as a sailor permanently diminished.
Rowena declared that she needed tea. Her husband went with her to secure a table, leaving Anora and Peers to follow along the path above the beach. He took her hand where the path narrowed. She kept hold after it widened again. “Do you wish me to call you your grace?” she asked.
“Not while you are holding my hand, peers.” Then he looked at her when she said it. She wished she had tried it long before. They stopped beneath a wooden shelter overlooking the water. There was nobody close enough to hear them. Although Anora could see her sister’s blue parasol moving toward the T-rooms. I am going to Italy in September, she said.
He blinked at the abruptness with Ruina and Lucius. We were arranging it before you asked me to marry you. I gave it up. Now we have begun arranging it again. For how long until January? We think he looked out at the sea. It was a perfectly ordinary journey for people with time and money. It was also 4 months in which you would be somewhere he was not. I see, he said.
I wanted you to know before this went any further. Peers turned back. I am glad you told me. The answer was correct. The disappointment beneath it was considerably more interesting. Are you? No, he admitted. I would rather you stayed. But I don’t think I am entitled to pretend September has not been mentioned.
She smiled and his gaze fell to her mouth. For a moment they stood without moving. There were people on the prominard below. There was a boat coming in. This was not a deserted garden in a novel, but a public afternoon with sand in Anora’s shoe and a damp patch on her skirt. “May I kiss you?” he asked. Yes. He leaned toward her slowly, giving her time to change her mind. She did not.
The first touch of his mouth was warm and uncertain. Then she moved closer, her hand tightening in his, and uncertainty became something that made the noise of the prominard seem far away. When they drew apart, she was smiling in a way he had never seen before. “Oh,” she said softly. He laughed a little breathlessly.
“I hope that is favorable. It is insufficiently descriptive. I shall try again later. They walked to the tea rooms without speaking much. Rowena took one look at them and ordered another pot. That night Anora lay awake listening to the sea. She had been engaged to this man without once imagining the weight of his hand at her waist.
Now she could remember almost nothing else. Across the town, Pierers stood at the window of his small house and attempted a trick with a coin until it vanished where it was meant to vanish. When he succeeded, there was nobody there to admire it. For the first time that evening, he stopped smiling. When Anora returned to Belwick in July, her father met her carriage himself.
He asked after Rowena, complained about the expense of seaside lodgings, and carried Anora’s smallest bag into the house, although a footman stood waiting to take it. At dinner, he mentioned that he had seen Westerroden the previous week. He looks better, he said. Does he? I thought so. Neither looked at the other.
Hora found herself smiling into her soup. Piers called 2 days later. This time she did not rehearse questions about the garden. She showed him the mechanical bird which had suffered damage during the journey and he spent 20 minutes on the drawing room floor attempting to persuade its dog to turn again. Mr.
Bramwell came in, surveyed the scene and said he hoped this was not an indication of how the Duke managed his estates. It is precisely how peers replied. Only the repairs are generally more expensive. Her father laughed. Anora watched his shoulders ease and felt the dangerous pleasure of having made everyone happy. The visits continued.
Piers brought her a book with a particularly bad ending because he wanted someone with whom to be indignant. She persuaded him to come to a small concert and admitted afterwards that she had disliked the second half. He was so relieved that he took her to supper, where they quarreled over whether to order another dish, and discovered that neither was good at surrendering an argument about food.
Sometimes they kissed in the narrow space beside the garden door, listening for footsteps. Once her father opened it, while Peers still had a hand against her cheek, Mr. Bramwell shut it again loudly and remarked to the hall that the roses appeared to be flourishing. Anora had never felt so happy in his house.
People began to notice. A cousin wrote with cheerful congratulations on the apparent reconciliation. A neighbor said she had always thought the little interruption in June would prove beneficial. An aunt told Anora that nervous brides were often foolish, and that fortunately a sensible man knew when to persevere.
Anora ought to have corrected her. Instead, she let the remark pass. It was agreeable to hear herself described as temporarily foolish rather than permanently rejected. Later, walking home, she disliked herself for how agreeable it had been. In August, the daager invited her to lunchon. Piers mentioned the invitation with careful lightness.
His mother had not withdrawn her courtesy, but she was slower to relinquish her hurt. She had asked him three times whether Anora was staying in Belwick for the rest of the summer. [snorts] Three times he had said yes, which was true as far as it went. He had not mentioned Italy. Anora arrived in a blue dress she knew the daager admired.
Piers noticed it. He also noticed that she had put away the little pin shaped like a running dog, which she had worn almost every day at the seaside. The meal began well. His mother asked about Rowena, listened to a story about the boat, and even smiled at Lucius’s alleged seammanship. Anora answered prettily. She did not interrupt.
When the daager described the excellent work of a local committee, Hanora said she should be glad to assist. Piers knew she had just accepted a duty without asking what it involved. He had done much the same thing twice that morning. After lunchon, his mother took them into the smaller drawing room.
On a table lay a box lined with tissue paper. Inside was a length of old lace carefully cleaned and folded. I was going to have it put away, she said. But perhaps there is no need to trouble anybody. Hanora looked at it. The lace had been intended for her wedding dress. Piers could have spoken. His mother had not asked an impossible question.
He could have said that they were seeing one another and had made no other arrangement. Instead, he watched Anora, afraid that if he spoke too firmly, she would think he did not want to marry her. “It is very beautiful,” Anora said. “I wore it myself. It would please me to see it used.” “Of course, of course.” The little phrase settled into the room as comfortably as a household pet.
The dowager closed the box. Nobody had promised anything. Somehow a promise had been made. On the drive home, Anora kept her hands folded in her lap. You were quiet, Pier said. I was trying to be pleasant. You needn’t try quite so hard. The moment the words were out, he wished them back.
Did I embarrass you? No, that isn’t what I meant. Your mother was kind enough to ask me. I know. They rode the rest of the way in an uncomfortable silence. At her gate, he kissed her hand instead of her mouth. She went upstairs and wrote to Rowena that she was considering staying in England after all. It was a thoroughly reasonable letter. Travel could be exhausting.
Their father would miss both daughters. Perhaps January was too long to be away. She never once wrote Piers’s name. Her sister came to Belwick instead of replying. I thought this conversation might be quicker in person, she said, removing her hat. Honora looked at the bag beside her.
You came all this way to interfere. Yes. Lucius was grateful to be excused. They sat in Anora’s bedroom where the large wardrobe still contained the wedding dress. Do you want to stay? Ruina asked. I don’t know. Do you want to go? Yes. Then there seems to be rather more information than you are admitting.
Hanora stood and moved to the window. I am not a child, Rowena. People do give things up for one another. Has he asked you to? No. Does he know you are considering it? No. Her sister waited. His mother is older than Papa. Anora said he has responsibilities here. I cannot expect him to carry on exactly as though he had never met me.
Four months in Italy does not prevent him from having responsibilities in England. You make it sound so easy. I have been married 12 years. I know how often a sacrifice is presented afterwards as a bill nobody remembers agreeing to pay. Hanora turned. Rowena was no longer smiling. I wanted to live near the sea once.
Her sister said before the children. Lucius thought London more practical. So did I. after I had explained it to myself often enough. Then, for several years, whenever he was thoughtless, I remembered the house we never took. He could not understand why I was angry about an empty jug or a late arrival. Sometimes, neither could I.
You never told me. It wasn’t an interesting story. We had to have it out eventually. There was a great deal less dignity involved than I should have preferred. Hanora sat beside her. Are you happy? Yes, that doesn’t mean I wish you to repeat every stupid thing I did on the way. Pier came that afternoon. He had brought no broken toys to mend, no book to quarrel over.
He asked to walk in the garden, and the somnity of his voice told Anora what he intended before they reached the end of the path. He had imagined it differently all morning. Now he could see her hands closing tightly around one another, and fear made him reach for the speech he knew. I believe we could make one another very comfortable, he began.
Anora stopped walking. He heard the sentence a moment after she did. It was what he had said when he proposed the first time. For an instant he could have laughed, apologized, started again. Then he saw tears in her eyes, and his own face closed with a miserable defensiveness. That came out badly. Yes, you know I care for you. I thought I did, Anora.
I am wearing the blue dress your mother likes. I have agreed to join a committee I know nothing about. I have written to Rowena that I may not go to Italy, and you are telling me how comfortable we shall be. You have canled Italy. No, not quite. Why didn’t you tell me? Because I thought you would be pleased.
He looked away down the path. I would have been. The honesty hurt. Then what are we doing? She asked. I don’t know. I thought I was asking you to marry me. Because you want to. Or because everybody has begun putting the lace back on the table. That is unfair. Yes, she said. It is. You are not the only one who has been hoping to avoid another embarrassing conversation.
A bee moved through the lavender beside them. Pierers watched it land, rise, and land again. He had spent weeks wanting to kiss her, thinking of remarks she would enjoy, feeling the shape of her absence after every visit. None of that was false. Neither was the relief he had felt when his mother mentioned the lace, and Onora did not object.
“I didn’t tell her you were leaving,” he said. Hanora looked up. “I meant to. Then she seemed pleased about us, and I thought it could wait until after lunchon. And after that, after something else probably, she sat on the bench. He remained standing as though he were waiting to be dismissed. “I do want you,” he said.
“It is not gratitude this time, or a wish to get it settled. I think about you in rooms where you have never been. I see something ridiculous and resent everyone present because you are somewhere else.” She lifted her face toward him. But I also want an easy life, he continued. And I am beginning to suspect that when something frightens us, we both smile until it becomes impossible.
Hanora moved over on the bench. He sat beside her, leaving a small space between them. I thought falling in love would make me less frightened, she said. Pier turned. Has it happened then? Yes, inconveniently, he reached across the space. This time he did not stop before taking her hand. It has happened to me, too. She closed her eyes.
He pressed his mouth to her knuckles, and neither of them spoke for a while. At last, she said, I am still going to Italy. I know, and I am not answering a proposal, while I am wondering whether your mother will be upset. I haven’t managed to make a proposal yet. No, it was rather a poor beginning.
He laughed unwillingly, and she leaned against him. The happiness was there under everything that frightened them. It had not disappeared because they had spoken badly. It might, she thought, be able to survive being spoken to at all. They went to see his mother together the following afternoon. Hanora suggested it, then spent the journey, wishing she had suggested something less virtuous.
The daager listened to the news about Italy without interrupting. When peers finished, she looked at Anora. Had you intended to tell me yourself? Yes. When? Hanora felt the familiar answer rising at a suitable moment. When she had been certain of the arrangements, when the older woman was feeling stronger, “I kept hoping Piers would do it first,” she said.
The dowager’s gaze shifted to her son. “So did I,” he admitted. His mother sat back. For a moment, Anora thought she might smile. Instead, she said, “I appear to have become a rather frightening person. You were disappointed,” Pier said. “I didn’t want to give you something else to be disappointed about.
” “Then you had better find a more effective method than keeping me ignorant.” There was no answer to that. The daager picked up the letter lying beside her chair, then put it down again. I am not asking you to abandon your journey, Anora. I had not known there was a journey to abandon. I should have told you. Yes, you should.
Anora accepted the rebuke. It was deserved and somehow easier to bear than the imagined catastrophe that had kept her silent. His mother did not ask whether there would be a wedding. She inquired about their route instead. When Anora described the months they hoped to spend abroad, the older woman mentioned a visit she had made to Italy before Piers was born.
She remembered a staircase, a quarrel about luggage, and a hotel dining room in which her husband had mistaken someone else’s hat for his own. Piers had never heard the story. You never told me father did that. He did a number of things before becoming your father. Her voice was dry. He laughed, surprised, and she looked at him with the old affection briefly unclouded.

After Anora had gone to fetch her gloves, Piers lingered beside the chair. “I cannot promise how it will end,” he said. His mother looked at his hands. He had them clasped behind his back, exactly as he had as a boy, waiting to confess broken glass. “Neither could I,” she said.
When I married your father, we merely had fewer people asking us to supply a satisfactory account of our feelings. He bent and kissed her cheek. She caught his sleeve before he straightened. I should like to be invited to lunchon sometimes when there is no announcement to make. I should like that, too. She did not forgive every disappointment that afternoon, nor did she ask him to repair them all before he left.
Anora departed in September. Her father came to the station with Rowena’s gloves, which Rowena was already wearing, and a parcel of food nobody needed. He complained about the number of trunks. Then he kissed both daughters and told them to send proper letters, not pictures of buildings with three words on the back. Peers stood a little apart until the porter had finished loading.
Anora went to him. You have brought novel, she observed. I am practicing remaining where I said I would. Will you write? Yes. Even if nothing has happened, especially then, you may regret asking. She wanted him to kiss her. She also wanted her father, the porter, three elderly ladies, and a man eating a pair to vanish temporarily.
Neither wish seemed likely to be fulfilled without assistance, so she stepped forward and kissed him herself. Mr. Bramwell developed an urgent interest in the timetable. On the train, Rowena offered Anora a corner of the food parcel. “Are you crying?” “No,” her sister waited. “Yes, a little. It is possible to wish to go and still dislike leaving.
I had hoped to be simpler than that. Rowena handed her a sandwich. Then you chose the wrong family. The first fortnight abroad was sufficiently busy to make missing peers an occasional inconvenience. By the third week, it had become a companion with particular habits. It appeared beside an ugly ornament in a shop at the end of a good dinner.
Halfway through a story in Nora, could imagine him telling better, she wrote to him about all of it. At first she described the admirable things she had seen. Then she began to describe the things she had actually noticed. Lucius losing his temper with a trunk. Rowena’s disastrous attempt to bargain over a piece of lace, the embarrassment of finding that she preferred an unremarkable church to the famous one everyone had told her to admire.
Piers replied that a committee meeting had lasted so long he had begun to envy the furniture, which at least was not expected to speak. His oldest horse had acquired a dislike of a particular gate. His mother had invited a friend to stay and had told the housekeeper to remove the room’s most uncomfortable chair before the friend arrived.
He wondered how many previous guests had suffered in it out of respect. He did not turn every letter into a declaration. Once he wrote only two pages, most of them about rain. Anora read those pages in bed and missed him so fiercely that she had to put them down. In October they quarreled by post. He suggested visiting in November and named dates without asking which would suit.
She had just been invited elsewhere with Rowena and Lucius. Instead of telling him that, she wrote that his arrangements sounded agreeable. Then grew cross when his next letter assumed they were settled. She began a sharp reply. Halfway through she stopped. There was something deeply unpromising about accusing a man of failing to divine the objection she had concealed.
She tore it up and wrote again. She wanted him to come. Those dates were inconvenient. She had said they were agreeable because she had been afraid he might not be able to come at all if she made difficulties. His reply was waiting when they returned from their visit. He could come a week later. He was sorry he had presented the dates as though the rest of the world had been waiting for his calendar.
He would have preferred to discover her annoyance before traveling across Europe to meet it. Anora laughed aloud over the last sentence. It was not a perfect exchange. It was, however, followed by a better visit. He came to Florence in November and stayed at a hotel near the rooms the littens had taken. On the first afternoon, Anora found herself shy.
She had constructed him out of handwriting for two months. The living man was taller, warmer, and considerably more distracting. They walked with Rowena until her sister announced that she had no intention of watching them attempt a third conversation about the weather. “Lucius is in that shop,” she said. “I shall rescue the proprietor.
Do not wander beyond retrieval.” Piers offered Anora his arm. “Have I disappointed you?” he asked when her sister had gone. “No, you are very quiet. I am trying to remember how I used to speak to you.” He stopped walking. “I have brought no proposal speech. That may help.” She looked up at him, and the tension broke.
When she laughed, he drew her briefly closer, his fingers pressing against the hand on his arm. By evening they were themselves again, or more nearly themselves than they had ever been, during the eight weeks of their first engagement. They disagreed about where to walk, became tired, admitted it, and returned earlier than planned, without turning the decision into evidence that either had failed the other.
On his last evening, they sat with Rowena and Lucius after supper. Piers attempted the coin trick for their entertainment. This time the coin disappeared, remained absent, and reappeared beneath the edge of Lucius’s plate. Lucius protested that he had been watching the wrong hand. “That is rather the point,” Pier said.
Hanora watched him smile. She had seen him tired now, irritable, occasionally foolish, stubborn about matters he later discovered were unimportant. She had also seen him come back to a difficult conversation after having had time to choose an easier one. The sum of those things was considerably more reassuring than his beautiful punctuation.
Later at the door, she put a hand against his coat. I shall be home in January, she said. I know. I should like you to ask me then. He went very still. You needn’t answer now, she added, suddenly flustered. I have done that thing again. arranged the next part without. He kissed her before she could make matters tidier.
When he drew back, his face was very close to hers. “January,” he said. “The remaining weeks did not become a waiting room. Anora traveled with her sister, bought a coat she could not possibly wear in the English summer, and stayed awake one entire evening arguing with Lucius about a novel neither had finished.
She was not living the wrong life until a man arrived to begin the right one. Still, when January came, she was glad to go home. Peers called the day after her return. There were no flowers on the drawing room table. Her father had gone out with an ostentatious remark about having a great deal to do in town.
The mechanical bird sat on the mantelpiece, its small wooden dog now permanently stuck in pursuit. Anora did not sit down, neither did Peers. He had spent the journey rejecting speeches. Everything sounded either too solemn or too little. Now he looked at her, really looked, and found the question beneath the phrases.
I want to be the person you tell, he said. She waited. When you like something, when you hate it, when you have agreed to something foolish and wish you hadn’t, I want to know where the ridiculous dog has broken and why you are awake, and whether you would rather be somewhere else. I cannot promise I shall always enjoy hearing the answer. Hanora’s eyes filled.
I should be alarmed if you did, he took her hands. Will you marry me? Yes, she said. Then because he was watching her with a seriousness she had once mistaken for distance. She added peers. Yes, that is the whole answer. He laughed once unsteadily and pulled her toward him. Her father returned 20 minutes later. He looked at their faces, set down his hat, and sat rather heavily in the nearest chair. Before I say anything, he began.
Am I permitted to be pleased? Hanora went to him. Yes, Papa. He held her close. This time his tears did not feel like an obligation she must spend the rest of her life fulfilling. They married in May in the church where they had failed to marry the previous June. The guest list was shorter, although not because everyone had become more understanding.
One cousin remained offended at the inconvenience of the cancelled journey. An aunt insisted upon referring to the episode as Anora’s little adventure. Anora disliked it and said so. The aunt changed the subject and continued to attend. The dowager offered the lace again. Anora used a small length at her cuffs and asked to keep the rest uncut.
It was too beautiful to spend entirely on a single morning. Piers’s mother agreed. After examining precisely what was to be done with it, there was still arrangements to make. Piers had work that could not simply be abandoned. Anora wanted more time in London than he usually spent there.
They had discussed it, disagreed, and settled on a plan they would try for a year. Neither called it a final solution to the rest of their lives. On the wedding morning, Anora woke before Nelly came in. For several minutes she lay listening to the house begin its work. She was frightened, not of an unwanted man or an approaching prison, but of how much happiness she now had to lose.
Then she got up at the church door. Her father asked whether she was ready. Nearly, she said. My glove is caught. He helped free it. Neither treated the delay as an omen. Peers waited inside, pale and smiling. When she reached him, his hand trembled as it closed around hers. Anora felt an answering tremor in her own, and was glad neither had managed to conceal it.
That afternoon they took the train to Lindmouth. Their luggage had been sent ahead. They sat opposite one another at first, amused by the familiar arrangement. Anora wore a traveling dress and a hat that had resisted every attempt to sit straight. Peers had forgotten to remove his carnation. She looked at it. You might take that off.
People will know. I rather hope so. Outside, the platform began to move. Anora watched it slide away, remembering the sick plunge of the previous journey. the veil on the seat, the discovery of a man equally unable to be what everyone expected. Pierers reached into his pocket and took out a coin. “Have you been practicing?” she asked relentlessly.
He displayed it, closed his hand, tapped the knuckles, and opened both palms. The coin landed on the floor. Anora bent forward at the same instant he did. Their foreheads met with a small, painful knock. For a moment, they remained perfectly still. Then she began to laugh. He sat back rubbing his head and watched his wife laugh until she could scarcely breathe.
There would be mornings when neither of them found anything funny. There would be letters poorly worded, plans made carelessly, times when the effort of understanding another person felt less like romance than work. But she was here with her crooked hat and her lovely unguarded face on a train she had chosen to take with him.
Piers left the coin where it lay and moved to the seat beside her. This time when Anora reached for his hand, neither of them was getting