The Entire Truth of Jayne Mansfield’s Fatal Crash and the Safety Myth That Outlived Her
On the 15th of May, 1952, a federal agency in Washington published a short technical rule about the back of trucks. It said that every heavy truck, trailer, and semi-trailer built after the 31st of December that year had to carry a guard across the rear. The guard could sit no more than 30 in above the ground when the vehicle was empty.
It had to be, in the language of the rule, “substantially constructed and firmly attached.” The reason for the rule was simple, and it was already well understood. When a car strikes the back of a loaded trailer, the trailer bed sits at roughly the height of the car’s windows. The car does not crumple against the truck. It passes underneath it.
Everything above the level of the trailer bed is removed. The engineers had a word for this. They called it underride. 14 years and 6 weeks after that rule took effect, at about a quarter past 2:00 in the morning on the 29th of June, 1967, a gray Buick carrying six people struck the back of a slow-moving tractor-trailer on United States Highway 90 east of New Orleans.
The car passed underneath it. The three adults in the front seat were killed where they sat. One of them was a 34-year-old woman who had been, 10 years earlier, the most photographed news star in American cinema. The three children asleep on the back seat were below the level of the trailer bed, and all three of them lived.
You have almost certainly heard something about this crash. What you have heard is that it was so horrifying that it changed the law, that it is the reason trucks now carry a steel bar across the back, and that the bar is named after her. Almost none of that is true. The requirement was already 14 years old when she died. It did not save her.
And the rule that might have, the one that specified how strong the guard had to be, and how much energy it had to absorb, was not issued for another 29 years. This is the story of how Vera Jayne Palmer became Jayne Mansfield. How the machine that made her famous put her in a car on a dark highway at 2:00 in the morning.
And what the paperwork actually says about what happened to her. It is also the story of a safety rule that existed and was required and was useless. We are going to start 15 years before she died and not with her. In 1952, responsibility for the safety of commercial trucking in the United States sat with the Interstate Commerce Commission and within it with a body called the Bureau of Motor Carriers.
On the 15th of May that year, the Bureau published [music] a rule in the Federal Register at volume 17, page 4,445. It required a rear end protection device on heavy trucks, trailers, and semi-trailers manufactured after the 31st of December, 1952. The device had to sit no more than 30 inches above the ground, measured with the vehicle empty, and it had to be substantially constructed and firmly attached.
Substantially constructed and firmly attached. That is the entire engineering specification. There is no figure for strength in it. No load it has to withstand. No test it has to pass. No measurement of how much energy it has to absorb before it folds. It is a sentence written by people who knew what the problem was and had not yet decided what the answer had to be able to do.
Because by 1952, the underride problem was not a mystery. It was arithmetic. A loaded trailer bed in that era sat somewhere between 40 and 50 inches off the road. The roofline of an American passenger car sat at about 55. The windows sat below that. So, a car striking the back of a trailer did not hit a wall.
It hit nothing at all until the trailer bed reached the windscreen pillars, and then it kept going. And the trailer bed traveled through the passenger compartment at whatever speed the difference between the two vehicles happened to be. 30″was chosen because 30″ is below the bonnet line of a 1950s car. A bar at 30″gets hit by the strongest part of the vehicle, the frame and the engine.
Rather than letting the trailer in at head height, the physics was understood. The rule was written. The date was the 15th of May, 1952. Everything else in this film happens after it. United States Highway 90 runs east out of New Orleans across the marshes towards the Mississippi coast. In 1967, it was a two-lane road through that stretch, narrow, flat, dark, and in late June in Louisiana, thick with mosquitoes.
A gray 1966 Buick Electra was traveling west towards New Orleans with six people in it. Driving was Ronald B. Harrison, a driver who worked for the Gus Stevens Dinner Club in Biloxi, Mississippi. Beside him in the front seat were Samuel S. Brody, a Los Angeles attorney, and Jayne Mansfield, 34 years old. On the back seat, asleep, were three of her children.
Miklós Hargitay the younger, who was eight. Zoltán Hargitay, who was six. And Mariska Hargitay, who was three and a half. There were also dogs in the car. They had come from Biloxi, where Jayne Mansfield had been performing at a supper club. She was due in New Orleans for a television appearance the following day.
Somewhere ahead of them on that two-lane road, a tractor-trailer was moving slowly. It was moving slowly because ahead of it was a municipal truck spraying insecticide for mosquitoes, a fogging machine pumping a dense white cloud across the highway, a wall of white. The accounts agree on this. The fog from the mosquito sprayer obscured the road and the tractor-trailer that had slowed down inside it.
The Buick struck the rear of the trailer at speed and went underneath it. The top of the car was torn away. Harrison, Brody, and Mansfield were killed instantly. All three were in the front seat. All three were above the level of the trailer bed. The three children on the back seat were below it. All three survived with injuries that contemporaneous reporting described as minor.

It was about a quarter past two in the morning. She had been on stage a few hours earlier. There are two versions of this story in circulation and they are not the same film. The first version is the one you have heard. It is about a body. In that version, the detail that matters is what happened to Jayne Mansfield’s head and the version most people have been told is that she was decapitated.
That claim has been repeated for nearly 60 years in books, in documentaries, in comment sections, and it is false. We are going to deal with it properly later in this film because the way it became false is more interesting than the fact that it is. The second version is about a rule. In that version, the detail that matters is that a federal regulation requiring exactly the device that would have changed the outcome had been in force for 14 and a half years on the night she died.
This is the second film that the thing which is worse than you think about Jayne Mansfield’s crash is not the injury. It is that nothing about it was unknown. The problem was understood. The physics had been worked out. The regulation had been written and published [clears throat] and had a date and a page number. The required device was legally mandatory on the vehicle she hit if that vehicle was built after the 31st of December 1952 and a car still went underneath a trailer on Highway 90 and three people in the front seat died.
And then for the next 30 years, almost nothing happened. The rule that specified how strong a rear guard actually had to be, how much force it had to take, how much energy it had to absorb before it collapsed, was not published until the 24th of January 1996 and did not apply to a single trailer until the 26th of January 1998.
30 years and 7 months after she died, the other half of this is the woman. Because to understand why she was in a car at 2:00 in the morning on a highway in Louisiana, you have to understand what had happened to her career. And what had happened to her career is a story about a publicity machine that worked exactly as designed and then destroyed the thing it had built.
She was not a has-been doing a sad gig. In 1960, she was the highest paid nightclub performer she would ever be earning $35,000 a week in Las Vegas. By 1967, the same skillset was worth a supper club in Biloxi and a drive through the night to make a morning television slot. The booking is what put her on the road.
The road is what killed her. And the device that was supposed to stop the road from killing her that way had been required by federal law since before she ever stood in front of a camera. She was born Vera Jayne Palmer on the 19th of April 1933 at Bryn Mawr Hospital in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania. She was Vera.
The Jane was her middle name, and for part of her childhood, she was known by a different surname altogether. Vera Jayne Peers, after her mother remarried, because the name Jayne Mansfield is not a name anybody was born with. The Jane came from the middle of her birth name, and the Mansfield came from her first husband. Everything the public eventually knew her as was assembled.
The family moved, and she grew up in Dallas. She graduated from Highland Park High School in 1950, and she attended the University of Texas at Austin. She claimed an intelligence quotient of 163, and she said so often and in public [music], and it became part of the act. She also spoke, by her own account and by several others, English plus four other languages, French, Spanish, German, and Italian.
The 163 figure is a claim she made. We cannot verify it against the test result, and nobody else has, and it does not matter very much either way. What matters is why she kept saying it. The woman being marketed entirely on her body was telling interviewers her test score [music] over and over for years. That is somebody trying to introduce a second fact about herself into a conversation that had room for only one.
It did not work. It became another item in the publicity file. The blonde who says she is a genius, and it got quoted the way the measurements got quoted. On the 6th of May, 1950, in Fort Worth, Texas, she married Paul Mansfield. She was 17 years old. Six months later, on the 8th of November, 1950, her first child was born, a daughter, Jayne Marie.
She was 17 when she married, and 17 when she had her first child. And the pregnancy preceded the wedding. That is the single most ordinary fact in this entire film and it is the reason the rest of it happens. A teenager in Dallas in 1950 with a baby and a husband and an ambition to act had one route available to her and it was not a route that involved anybody asking about her intelligence quotient.
In 1954, Paul and Jane Mansfield moved to Los Angeles. She was 21. She had a 3-year-old daughter. She sold popcorn. She taught dancing. She did part-time modeling because the version of Jane Mansfield that exists in public memory is a woman who was handed fame for her figure and the actual record of 1954 is a 21-year-old mother working three jobs in a city where she knew nobody.
Her first professional engagement was a commercial for General Electric. It was cut. The reason given was that she was considered too sexy to advertise a refrigerator. The first time anybody in the industry made a decision about Jane Mansfield, the decision was that her body was a problem. Within 18 months, the same industry would decide her body was the only thing about her worth paying for.
Nothing about her had changed in between. What had changed was that somebody worked out how to sell it. Her first acting role was an episode of a CBS anthology series called Lux Video Theatre. The episode was broadcast on the 21st of October, 1954 and it was titled An Angel Went AWOL. She was paid $300.
Her first film was a low-budget picture called Female Jungle. She was paid $150. $300 for a television episode in 1954. $150 for a feature film. In February 1958, 3 years and 4 months later, she would be paid $25,000 a week to stand on a stage in Las Vegas. In December 1960, she would be paid $35,000 a week. That is the arc. It takes about 6 years start to peak.
And the thing to understand about the second half of this film is that the arc has a down slope of exactly the same shape. From late 1954 until the end of 1961, Jayne Mansfield’s publicity was handled by a publicist named James Byron. That is the entire span of her fame. Byron arrived at the beginning of it and left at the end of it.
And what happened in between is one of the most effective publicity campaigns in the history of the American film industry. The campaign had a single idea executed relentlessly. The idea was that Jayne Mansfield would appear in a photographable state of near undress at events where photographers were already standing. Not at her own events, at other people’s.
In January 1955, she attended a press event at Silver Springs in Florida wearing a bikini that was too small for her. Out of that single appearance came an offer from Warner Brothers and an approach from Playboy. The 21-year-old who had been selling popcorn the previous year put on the wrong swimsuit in front of a room of photographers and converted it into a studio contract and a magazine career inside a few weeks.
The campaign was not stupid and she was not a passive participant in it. The record is clear that she understood exactly what the mechanism was and operated it deliberately for years. She was Playboy’s Playmate of the Month in February 1955. The magazine would run features on her in February of ’55, ’56, ’57, and ’58.
And again in 1960, it reprinted the 1955 pictorial in 1964. In February 1955, Warner Brothers signed her to a 7-year contract at $250 a week, almost nothing. She appeared in three Warner pictures that year, Pete Kelly’s Blues, Hell on Frisco Bay, and Illegal, in parts small enough that you can watch all three and not be certain which woman she is. She got out of the contract.
She got out of it to take a part on Broadway in a play about a Hollywood sex symbol, and it is the single best decision anybody made on her behalf in the whole of her career. In 1955, she joined the Broadway cast of a comedy called Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter. She played a character named Rita Marlowe.
Rita Marlowe is a Hollywood sex symbol. Specifically, she is a parody of Marilyn Monroe, a blonde film star whose entire public existence is a manufactured publicity object. The 22-year-old woman who had been built deliberately over the previous 12 months as a Marilyn Monroe substitute, went to Broadway to play a satire of a Marilyn Monroe substitute, and she was very good at it.
That is the part nobody expects. She played opposite Walter Matthau and Orson Bean. Matthau was 4 years from his first Tony and 11 from his Academy Award. Bean was one of the sharpest comic performers working in New York. She held the stage with both of them, eight shows a week. In 1956, she won a Theatre World Award in the category the Theatre World Awards then described as promising personality.
[music] It is given by New York theater critics for a debut performance. It is not a publicity prize and it cannot be bought with a bikini. Somebody who watched her do comedy for 2 hours night after night gave her an award for it. Where you can see the career she could have had. She was a trained, capable comic actress with professional stage discipline and a critic’s award for her debut.
That is a foundation. Walter Matthau built 40 years on a narrower one, because the machine that had put her on that stage had no use for a comic actress. It had a use for a photograph. Within a year, she would be under contract to a studio that had signed her for one reason, had written it down and had announced it in public.
She performed Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter on Broadway roughly 450 times. Eight performances a week, allowing for the standard schedule, is about 56 weeks of work. More than a year of turning up six evenings and two afternoons and doing the same two hours. Because the entire public understanding of Jayne Mansfield is that she was not a worker, the story is that she was a body that got lucky.
That the talent was a rumor she spread about herself. That the intelligence quotient was a lie and the acting was a joke. 450 performances is not a rumor. It is a timesheet. On a film set, a performance can be assembled. 30 takes become one. A director and an editor can construct a performance out of a person who cannot give one.
On a stage, in front of 900 people for two hours with no cuts, that is not available. You either have the timing or the audience watches you not have it in real time on a Tuesday. She did it for a year. When the play was adapted for the screen in 1957, she played Rita Marlowe again. The best thing she ever did was play a woman whose career was being destroyed by her own publicity, and her publicity then destroyed her career.
At the time it was just a good year. She was 23. She had a hit play, a critics award, a film contract, and a studio announcing her as the next big thing. On the 3rd of May, 1956, Jayne Mansfield signed a 6-year contract with 20th Century Fox. It was intended to make her the successor to Marilyn Monroe. That was the plan.
Understood and recorded at the time. Fox had a difficult relationship with Monroe. Monroe had walked out on the studio and formed her own production company, and Fox wanted a blonde it owned. They signed one. She was hired to be a copy of a living woman who worked 4 miles away, not to be an actress who happened to be blonde.
To occupy a slot that another person had vacated, and to be measured for the next 6 years against the original. Because the comparison is the product. Every photograph, every review, every piece of copy exists to invoke Monroe, which means every one of them reminds the audience that she is not Monroe. A good performance does not help.
A bad one confirms it. There is no outcome inside that contract that ends with Jayne Mansfield being taken seriously as Jayne Mansfield. Of course, she did. She was 23. She had two children by then. And it was a major studio contract until 1962. 6 years as written. Fox did not tear it up. They did something slower and harder to point at, which we will get to.
During those 6 years, Fox loaned her to British and Italian productions. A studio lending a contract player abroad is a studio that has decided it does not have a use for her at home. The Girl Can’t Help It was released in 1956. It is a rock and roll comedy. She plays a gangster’s girlfriend being pushed into a singing career she does not want and has no voice for.
Not good for what it is. Good. The film has survived. It gets revived. It gets written about and the reason is partly the music. It contains performances by Little Richard, Fats Domino, Gene Vincent and others shot in color at the moment rock and roll arrived in American cinema and partly her.
She plays the comedy of being looked at. The joke of the film is that every man who sees her loses the capacity for speech and she performs the woman on the other side of that, tired of it, patient about it, wanting something else entirely. Again, for the second time in two years, she had now played twice a woman being destroyed by exactly the apparatus that was being used on her.
And she had played it knowingly. Nobody performs that part twice well by accident. She knew precisely what was being done to her and what it was going to cost and she could render it on screen as comedy and the people watching took the comedy as confirmation of the thing it was mocking. The film did reasonable business and she came out of it with her reputation as a comic performer intact.
Everything good in her professional life is inside those two years. She is 23 and 24 years old. The Wayward Bus was released in 1957. It is an adaptation of a John Steinbeck novel. It is not a comedy. It is not a vehicle and she is not the blonde in it for decoration. A Golden Globe for new star of the year.
A Theatre World Award in 1956 for the Broadway debut. A Golden Globe in 1957 for a Steinbeck adaptation. By the age of 24, Jayne Mansfield had won a New York Critics Award for stage comedy and a Golden Globe for a dramatic film role. She is remembered for a bikini in Florida, a dinner with Sophia Loren, a pink house, and a car crash.
The gap between the professional record and the public memory of Jayne Mansfield is the widest of anybody in this period of American cinema, and it is wider than Monroe’s because Monroe at least got reevaluated. Monroe became a tragic artist. Mansfield became a punchline and then a crash photograph. Partly timing, partly that Monroe died in a bedroom and Mansfield died on a highway with her children in the car, and one of those produces a myth and the other produces a rumor about a body because 1957 is also the year the publicity machine stopped
helping. In April 1957, at a dinner in Beverly Hills held to welcome Sophia Loren to Hollywood, a photograph was taken. Loren is seated at the table. Mansfield leans in beside her in a very low-cut dress. Loren is looking sideways at Mansfield’s chest with an expression that has been described, accurately, as appalled.
It is still reproduced. It will outlive everybody who was at that table. In the short term, everything. It was a worldwide sensation. It ran everywhere, and it made her face and her body known in countries where her films had never opened. It fixed her, permanently, as the woman in the background of somebody else’s dinner.
Loren is the guest of honor. Loren is seated, central, poised. Mansfield has arrived into the frame from outside it and is leaning. The picture is a visual argument about status, and Mansfield loses it. She is the one trying. The great movie star is the one who does not have to. Up to April 1957, the publicity campaign generated images that made her famous.
From April 1957, it generated images that made her ridiculous. And the two kinds of image are impossible to separate because they are produced by exactly the same method. And here is the trap. The method had worked. It had taken a popcorn seller to a Fox contract in 18 months. It was the only mechanism she had ever had, and she was 24.
And the alternative was to be a serious actress at a studio that had signed her to be a photograph. So, it kept going, and each new stunt bought a little less and cost a little more. On the 25th of September, 1957, Jayne Mansfield left on a tour of England and Europe until the 6th of November, 40 days, to launch her internationally as 20th Century Fox’s new bombshell.
40 consecutive days of a studio-funded international publicity operation built around one 24-year-old woman. It is the reason she was known in countries where her films barely played. It is the reason that, 10 years later, a local newspaper on the Mississippi coast still thought her appearance at a supper club was worth remembering 33 years afterwards.
The fame that the tour manufactured outlasted everything else about her career by decades. It is still working now, which is why you are watching this. 1957 is the year of The Girl Can’t Help It for the Wayward Bus. It is also the year of Kiss Them for Me, which failed. It is also the year of the Lauren photograph in April, which made her a worldwide spectacle.
And it is the year she bought the house on Sunset Boulevard in November, two weeks after getting back from Europe. An award for a dramatic performance. A commercial failure opposite Cary Grant, the most reproduced publicity photograph of the decade, a 40-day European tour, and a 40-room mansion. She was 24 years old for most of it, which is the thing that is hard to see from inside a life.
Every single one of those five events felt like ascent. Two of them were. Three of them were the mechanism that would make her unemployable as a serious actress within four years. Nobody could. The Golden Globe and the Lauren photograph arrived in the same calendar year from the same career, and the photograph was worth a thousand times more attention.
If you were 24 and the market gives you that information, you learn the obvious lesson. In February 1958, she opened at the Tropicana for $25,000 a week, and that was the high-water mark of her standing as a film star, and it happened in a casino. In November 1957, she bought a house at 100100 Sunset Boulevard in Holmby Hills.
Inheritance money. In 1958, she received more than $90,000 from her grandfather’s estate and more than 36,000 from her grandmother’s. 40 rooms, Mediterranean style. It had previously belonged to the singer Rudy Vallee. She painted it pink. Inside, there was pink fur. There was a heart-shaped bathtub. There was a fountain that ran pink champagne.
Outside, there was a pink Cadillac Eldorado Biarritz. If you know one thing about Jayne Mansfield that is not the crash, it is the pink house, the vulgar blonde and her pink champagne fountain, the tackiest house in Los Angeles. A 24-year-old from Dallas who had been selling popcorn three years earlier, who had been told by the first people to employ her that her body was too much, and by the next people that her body was all there was, inherited some money and bought a 40-room house and painted the entire thing the single most unmistakable color available.
That is not confusion about taste. That is a statement made very loudly by somebody who had worked out that the only language the industry would hear from her was visual excess. The house got more coverage than the Golden Globe did. Every time she did something serious, it was noted politely.
Every time she did something pink, it went around the world. A person who learns that lesson for 7 years running ends up where she ended up. In June 1955, at a public event, Jayne Mansfield’s dress fell to her waist twice in one evening. Nobody was meant to, January 1955, the bikini at Silver Springs. June 1955, the dress, twice.
April 1957, the Loren dinner. February 1958, topless at a carnival party in Rio de Janeiro. Executed at intervals in different countries in front of photographers with the same outcome every time. Her wardrobe designer was a man named Richard Blackwell, later famous in his own right, for publishing an annual list of the worst-dressed women in America.
Blackwell dropped her as a client. He stopped working with her over the repeated wardrobe failures. A designer whose entire later career was built on being publicly rude about women’s clothing decided that Jayne Mansfield’s clothing decisions were professionally embarrassing to him. He was not objecting to immodesty.
He was objecting to being the credited designer on garments that were engineered to fail. There is a long-running story that she exposed herself at the 1957 Academy Awards. It was investigated and found to be baseless. It did not happen. A woman who genuinely did arrange four or five public undressings across four years also had a fictional one attached to her at the most prestigious event in her industry.
Once the file exists, things get added to it. That is going to matter enormously in the last third of this film. Of the way the press came to treat her, one of the people around her career, a man named Shiffrin, said four words. She became a freak. He meant that the coverage changed category. For about 2 years, the press wrote about Jayne Mansfield as a new star.
After that, it wrote about her as a spectacle, an item, a curiosity, a recurring joke with a reliable shape. Once a newspaper has established a comic register for a person, it does not go back. Every subsequent fact gets written in that register, including the serious ones, including the awards, including eventually the death, which is the point we are building to.
The reason an untrue story about her body circulated for 60 years is that by 1967, she was a person about whom lurid things were simply expected to be true. Nobody checked because checking was not the relationship the press had with her. By the start of the 1960s, she was, in box office terms, finished as a film star.
Three things did it at once. Her 1957 films underperformed commercially. There was a backlash against the publicity itself. The stunts had become so frequent and so obviously manufactured that the press turned on the method, and the culture moved. The blonde bombshell as a category was going out of fashion. The look that had been the single most marketable thing in American cinema in 1965 was by 1961 dated.
That is the number that should stay with you. Her film career was effectively over at 28. She would live another 6 years and she had four children by then and would have one more. Kiss Them for Me was released in 1957, a Fox picture with Cary Grant. It failed critically and commercially. Because this is the hinge, a new star’s first flop opposite an established leading man is the moment a studio decides what it actually thinks.
The studio does not announce the decision. It simply starts making different choices. She had signed in May 1956 to be the next Marilyn Monroe. Roughly 18 months later, the studio stopped treating her as a major star. The contract still had 4 and 1/2 years to run. You stay on salary. You are still owned. You cannot go and work for anybody else.
But the pictures that come to you get smaller and then they get made abroad and then they stop being pictures Fox is particularly interested in releasing well. The Sheriff of Fractured Jaw, shot in Spain, 1958. Too Hot to Handle and The Challenge, both shot in Britain, 1960. A 20th Century Fox contract player under a 6-year deal in Los Angeles is by 1958 working in Spain and by 1960 in Britain.
She was being parked. And parking is worse than firing because a fired actress can sign somewhere else. A parked one waits out the contract while the thing she is being sold on gets a year older every year. In February 1958, Jayne Mansfield opened a stage show at the Tropicana in Las Vegas called the Tropicana Holiday, $25,000 a week. $2,500 a week.
Her film studio, which had signed her 18 months earlier to be the biggest female star in American cinema, valued her at 2 and 1/2 thousand dollars a week. A casino in Nevada valued her at 10 times that because it determines everything that happens for the next 9 years, including the road she died on. Because the casino was not selling a performance, it was selling proximity.
The film studio needs an actress who can carry a picture through 2 hours of narrative, and Fox had decided she could not. A Las Vegas showroom needs a famous body in a room where people are drinking, and at that she was demonstrably the best in the world. Mickey Hargitay, a former Mr. Universe, was part of the stage show.
It involved him lifting her. She held a Lloyd’s of London policy worth a million dollars against the possibility that Hargitay would drop her during the act. A million dollar insurance policy against being dropped by her own husband on stage. That is the economics of her life in 1958. The film career is nominally the career.
The real money is in a room in Nevada, and the real risk is physical, and she knew it well enough to insure against it. In December 1960, she opened a show at the Dunes Hotel in Las Vegas called The House of Love, $35,000 a week. Nothing she ever earned before or after, in any medium, came close. December 1960.
She was 27 years old. Her film career, as we have just established, was already finished in everything but name. The peak of Jayne Mansfield’s earning power arrived after the collapse of the thing that had made her famous. Because fame and film careers are different assets, and they decay on different schedules, her usefulness to Fox depended on whether audiences would buy tickets to a narrative film because her name was on it.
That stopped being true around 1958. Her usefulness to a casino depended on whether her name was known. That stayed true for years afterwards. She was earning more than she ever had from work that could only decline in a market with no ceiling on how far it could fall. A film career has a floor. A character actress in her 40s still gets parts.
A fame-based live career has no floor at all because the asset being sold is the public’s memory of you at 24. Three years after the Dunes, the venues are the Plantation Supper Club in Greensboro, North Carolina and Iroquois Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky. $35,000 a week at the Dunes in 1960. Greensboro and Louisville in 1963.
Fremont Street in 1966, which in Las Vegas terms is not the Strip. Biloxi in 1967. In 1958, during a dispute over child support, Jayne Mansfield and Mickey Hargitay publicly claimed poverty. She said she was sleeping on the floor of her mansion. 1958 is the year she was paid $25,000 a week at the Tropicana.
It is also the year she received more than $90,000 from her grandfather’s estate and more than 36,000 from her grandmothers. It is also the year she was being paid up to $20,000 for a single television episode. It was a legal position in a support dispute and we are not going to pretend to know what was in the accounts.
Which is that the money was never organized. Enormous sums arriving irregularly. A week in Vegas, an inheritance, a television fee against a 40-room house, five children by three men, a staff, three divorces, and the running cost of maintaining a public image built on visible luxury, there is no stable income anywhere in Jayne Mansfield’s adult life.
The Fox contract was the only predictable money she ever had, and it was the smallest number on the page, and it ended in 1962. This is the mechanism we need established before the last act of the film, so we are going to state it plainly. By the middle 1960s, Jayne Mansfield’s income was a function of how many nights a year she stood on a stage, not how good she was.
How many nights? And the venues that would book her were further apart and further down, which meant more travel in cars between cities at night, because the show finishes at midnight and the next thing starts in the morning. The Fox contract ran its 6 years and ended in 1962. It happened in Athens. The George Raft story, neither did anything for her, and by then nobody expected them to, any of it.
She did not get a renewal. She did not get a serious dramatic vehicle. She did not get the second act that Monroe got with*Some Like It Hot*, and she did not get the thing that an actress with a Golden Globe and, a Critics Award, and 450 Broadway performances might reasonably have got, which was to be thought of as an actress: 29 years old, out of contract, with a public image that had been intensively ridiculed for 5 years, and a skill set that two different sets of critics had taken seriously.
It would be easy to tell this as a story about a woman who was destroyed by the industry [music], and there is a lot of truth in it. But she was not passive. She ran the publicity machine herself with a professional for 7 years, deliberately. She chose the bikini and the dress and the leaning in at the Lauren dinner. She painted the house pink.
The honest version is that she made a trade with her eyes open at 21 because it was the only trade available to a teenage mother from Dallas with no connections. The trade worked. It took her from selling popcorn to a Fox contract in 18 months, which nothing else would have done. And then the trade came due. The asset she had borrowed against was her youth, and the interest was that nobody would ever again take seriously anything else she could do.
That changes in 1966. She married Mickey Hargitay on the 13th of January, 1958, at the Wayfarers Chapel in Rancho Palos Verdes, California [music]. A Hungarian-born bodybuilder, a former Mr. Universe, and for several years her stage partner. They had three. Miklós the younger, born the 21st of December, 1958.
Zoltán, born the 1st of August, 1960. Mariska, born the 23rd of January, 1964. She obtained a divorce in Juárez, Mexico, on the 30th of April, 1963. It was not recognized until the 26th of August, 1964. For 16 months she was divorced in one jurisdiction and married in another. A Mexican divorce was a standard device for Americans in that era who wanted out faster than their own state would allow. It was quick.
It was available, and its legal standing back home was uncertain until somebody tested it. She married Matt Cimber on the 24th of September, 1964, in Mulegé, in Baja California Sur. The Hargitay divorce was recognized on the 26th of August, 1964. She married Cimber on the 24th of September, 29 days, which means the third child of the second marriage was 8 months old when her mother married the third husband.
Not for the soap opera, for the chronology, because the 3 years from 1963 to 1966 are the years when her professional life collapsed, her personal life became a series of overlapping legal problems, and the number of people financially dependent on her went up. They separated on the 11th of July, 1965. She filed for divorce on the 20th of July, 1966.
In 1963, she appeared in a film called Promises. Promises. She appeared nude in it in a starring role. In 1963, an American film actress with a studio history did not do that. The production code still governed what could be released in the United States, and nudity was outside it. It briefly revived her box office standing.
A woman whose film career had been destroyed by being sold entirely on her body recovered her commercial position, temporarily, by taking off all her clothes. There was precisely one thing the market would still pay her for, and in 1963, she found the last unsold increment of it. In June 1963, Playboy published nude photographs taken on the set.
The publication led to obscenity charges against Hugh Hefner. Hefner, the publisher. The actress who was in the photographs was not the defendant. The prosecution was about the distribution of the image, not about her. The image of Jayne Mansfield was a commodity with a legal status, a market value, and a regulatory history, and it was owned and litigated by other people.
A short commercial reprieve and a permanent reclassification. After 1963, she was not a film star who did publicity. She was a woman who had done a nude film. And in the American market of 1963, that was a one-way door. L’Amore Primitivo, Panic Button, both 1964, both made in Italy, obscure. Several of her films from this period are now considered lost or close to it.
A film is lost when no complete print is known to survive, which happens when nobody at the time thought it was worth keeping a copy. 31 years old, out of her Fox contract, making films in Italy that nobody would bother to preserve. Mariska was born in January 1964. Single Room Furnished was made in 1966 and not released until 1968, which is to say after she died.
Matt Cimber, her third husband, from whom she had separated in July 1965 and filed for divorce in July 1966. It is the film in which she was attempting to be taken seriously as a dramatic actress. Directed by the man she was divorcing, shelved for two years, and released to an audience that by then knew her only as a woman who had died in a car.
A cameo in A Guide for the Married Man, 1967. A guest appearance. A few minutes. Playing, in effect, herself. An appearance on the Joey Bishop Show in June 1967, the month she died. In 1964, Jayne Mansfield was offered a part in a new television comedy and turned it down. The program was Gilligan’s Island, the role of the film star marooned on the island.
The part eventually played by Tina Louise as Ginger Grant. It has been in continuous syndication for 60 years. Tina Louise is still identified with it because in 1964, taking a part on a network sitcom was understood in Hollywood as the end of a film career and she was 31 and still trying to have one.
The decision was reasonable on the information she had. Weekly television money, a steady schedule, work in Los Angeles where her children were, a character that was again a satire of a Hollywood blonde. The third time that part had been offered to her and the one time she said no, the supper club circuit. She had earlier turned down Bell, Book and Candle and Kiss Me Stupid.
Both of those were because she was pregnant. Jayne Mansfield was pregnant five times and had five children between the ages of 17 and 32 across the entire span of her working life and she declined film roles because of it. That is a fact about her career that nobody includes in the story of her career. The standard version is that her career failed because the public got tired of the publicity.
The fuller version is that it failed while she was having five children, divorcing three husbands, holding down a stage act in Nevada and running a 40-room house. She married him on the 24th of September, 1964. They separated on the 11th of July, 1965. She filed for divorce on the 20th of July, 1966. Antonio, called Tony, was born on the 18th of October, 1965.
They separated in July, 1965. The child was born in October, 1965. Three things are given. Her alcohol abuse, infidelity, and alleged abuse by Simber. The third is an allegation that appears in the record. We are not in a position to adjudicate it and we are not going to narrate it as though we were in the room. The second is the kind of thing that gets said about every collapsed marriage of that era, and we have no documentary basis to apportion it.
The first is the one that matters for this film. Her drinking is part of the record of 1965 and 1966, and it is going to be relevant again in a different way when we get to the crash and the question of who was driving and why. That is where she is at the end of 1965. Jayne Marie is 15. Miklós is 7. Zoltan is 5. Mariska is 1. Tony is a newborn.
There is no other earner in that list. Everything depends on her standing on a stage somewhere, and the stages are getting smaller. Jayne Mansfield’s alcohol use appears in the record of her last years as a documented factor in the end of her third marriage. Any medical record, any diagnosis, any treatment, any measurement.
She was drinking heavily enough in the middle 1960s that it is named in the accounts of her marriage ending, and we are not going to pretend otherwise. We are also not going to turn it into a cause of anything because the evidence does not support that, and because the specific temptation here is enormous.
The temptation is to arrive at a dark highway at 2:00 in the morning with a woman in a car and reach for the explanation that everybody in that car had been drinking. She was not driving. The driver was a man employed by the club. Whether anybody in that car had been drinking is not something we found documented in a form we can stand behind, and we are not going to assert it, and we are specifically not going to assert it about the dead driver who has been dead for 59 years and cannot answer it.
She had performed at a supper club that evening. The crash was at about a quarter past 2:00 in the morning. That is the ordinary shape of a working night for a cabaret performer in 1967. We do not need intoxication to explain a car hitting a slow truck inside a wall of insecticide fog on an unlit two-lane road at 2:00 in the morning.
The fog explains it. The contemporaneous accounts say the fog explains it. Adding a drink to the story is not an explanation. It is a flourish because the boring true version is the one that leads somewhere. And where it leads is a regulation published in 1952. In July 1966, Jayne Mansfield began living with her attorney, Samuel S.
Brody. His [music] wife, Beverly, sought a divorce. The accounts describe frequent drunken brawls. They also describe his conduct towards Jayne Mansfield and towards her eldest daughter as abusive. Jayne Marie Mansfield was 16 years old in 1967 and we are not going to narrate what the record says was done to a child who may still be alive.
The bare fact is in the historical record and we have stated it. The details are not ours to broadcast. He was her lawyer and he was her partner simultaneously, which is a conflict that any bar association in the country would recognize. He acted for her family in litigation. He lived in her house.
He traveled with her to her engagements. He was in the front seat of the car by the last year of her life. The person who handled Jayne Mansfield’s legal affairs, the person who shared her home, and the person who accompanied her to work were the same man and there was nobody else in the arrangement. In 1955, she had a studio, a publicist, an agent, a designer, and a husband and they were five different people with five different interests and at least two of them would tell her no.
By 1966, that had collapsed into one man who was all of it. An arrangement built entirely on one person’s loyalty has no mechanism for telling the truth upwards. There is nobody to say that a 34-year-old woman with three small children asleep on the back seat should not be driven between two states through the night after a midnight show.
A supper club was a restaurant with a stage. People came for dinner and drinks and watched a performer who was not quite famous enough to fill a theater. The Plantation Supper Club in Greensboro, North Carolina, Iroquois Gardens in Louisville, Kentucky, both 1963. Fremont Street in Las Vegas in 1966, which is downtown and not the strip.
The Latin Quarter in New York, 1966, and in June 1967, the Gus Stevens Supper Club in Biloxi, Mississippi. Greensboro, Louisville, downtown Las Vegas, Biloxi, Los Angeles. The work was not where she was. The work was wherever somebody would pay. And the places that would pay were spread across the southern and eastern United States, and getting to them meant airplanes to regional airports and then cars.
This is the detail that reframes the whole thing. Three of her children were in that car because she brought them with her to Biloxi. Because you are a working mother with five children, the work is in another state and the alternative is not seeing them. There is a version of this story in which a vain actress dragged her children around the country after her fading career, and it is a cheap version.
A woman whose income depended entirely on live appearances in distant cities took three of her young children with her to a booking in Mississippi because she was their mother and she was going to be away otherwise. Because they were asleep on the backseat below the window line when the trailer came through the front of the car. The decision that looks careless from the outside is the decision that saved all three of them.
Her last nightclub act was a show called French Dressing at the Latin Quarter in New York. A real venue with a real history on Broadway where Frank Sinatra and Milton Berle had worked. [music] New York, a famous room, a titled show of her own. In 1966, that is still a professional booking. French Dressing, the Tropicana Holiday, the House of Love, French Dressing.
They are not the titles of acts. They are the titles of a single ongoing act that had one idea in it, and the idea had been the same since the bikini in Florida in January 1955. 11 years of the same idea in progressively smaller rooms. That is the thing that is hard to hold in your head. Everything in this story, the rise, the peak, the collapse, the circuit, the last booking, happens to a woman between the ages of 21 and 34.
There is no later period of Jayne Mansfield’s life. There is no television comeback at 40 [music], no character parts at 50, no reevaluation at 60 with an interviewer asking her about the 1950s. Monroe got reread because the culture had decades to do it, and she had become a symbol. Mansfield did not become a symbol. She became a crash.
1966 is the last full year of her life, and it contains the Latin Quarter, a divorce filing, a new man living in her house, and one more thing we have not mentioned yet. There was an animal park in Thousand Oaks, California, called Jungle Land USA. It supplied animals to the film industry, and it was open to the public. [music] A lion attacked Jayne Mansfield’s son, Zoltan, born the 1st of August, 1960 [music].
He was six. The lion bit his neck. He suffered severe head trauma. He underwent three surgical operations, one of which was six hours of brain surgery. He contracted meningitis. He survived all of it. The 23rd of November, 1966, the 29th of June, 1967, seven months and six days, a six-year-old boy was mauled by a lion, had brain surgery, developed meningitis, recovered, and then was asleep on the back seat of a car when it went under a tractor trailer and his mother was killed in the seat in front of him.
He had a birthday on the 1st of August, 1966. So, at the crash, he was six, [music] turning seven five weeks later. We are not going to tell you it means anything. It does not mean anything. It is two separate catastrophes that happened to the same child inside eight months because the world does not ration these things.
In the last year of Jayne Mansfield’s life, her six-year-old was in a hospital having brain surgery, her 16-year-old was living with a man the record describes as abusive, her third marriage was in a divorce filing, her film career had been over for five years, and her income depended on supper clubs in other states.
She was 33 years old. Sam Brody sued Jungleland USA for $1.6 million on behalf of the family. The publicity contributed to its closure. A lawyer acting for a famous family generated enough attention to finish a business. We should say [music] that because this film is about to be very hard on him by implication, and the record ought to be complete.
A child was badly hurt by a negligent animal park and Brody went after it hard and publicly and the park shut. The method was publicity. Her publicist used it to build her. She used it to stay visible. Her lawyer used it to sue an animal park. Publicity was the household’s entire operating system for 12 years and it is the reason the untrue story about her death survived so long.
The press had been handed Jayne Mansfield material for over a decade and had never once needed to verify any of it. [music] We do not know what the Jungleland case produced, if anything. We have not found a settlement figure we can stand behind and we are not going to invent one. Very little, honestly. The pattern across her adult life is irregular money against fixed enormous costs and five children and three divorces, which is the only financial fact we actually need.
A 34-year-old woman with five children was taking supper club bookings in Mississippi in June 1967. People who do not need the money do not do that. Her last film appearance was a cameo in a comedy called A Guide for the Married Man, released in 1967. A brief appearance, trading on recognition. The audience is meant to enjoy identifying the person rather than watching them act.
11 years after the Theater World Award, 10 years after the Golden Globe. The last thing she did in a motion picture was walk through a few minutes of somebody else’s comedy so that the audience could recognize her. An appearance on the Joey Bishop Show in June 1967. She died on the 29th of June, 1967. A chat show appearance. A supper club engagement in Biloxi.
And a television booking in New Orleans that she was driving through the night to make. None of them is acting. All three are appearances. Being present. Being recognized. Being Jayne Mansfield in a room. And was still doing in the last month of her life at 34. For less money, further from home. Single room furnished was already made.
It was sitting on a shelf. It would not be released for another year and a half. And when it was, nobody would care. [music] Because by then she was the woman from the crash. The one piece of work she made in order to be taken seriously was released after her death to an audience that had been told she was decapitated.
Gus Stevens ran a seafood restaurant and supper club in Biloxi on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. In late June 1967, Jayne Mansfield was performing there. In June 2000, the Sun Herald wrote that Mansfield had entertained at the Gus Stevens Supper Club in Biloxi 33 years earlier that same week. Not from a Hollywood archive, from a Gulf Coast newspaper marking an anniversary.
The last engagement of a woman who had been under contract to 20th Century Fox as the designated successor to Marilyn Monroe is documented principally [music] by a local paper in Biloxi remembering it in passing. Ronald B. Harrison drove for the Gus Stevens Dinner Club. The man at the wheel of the car was not her chauffeur. He was not her employee.
He was a driver who worked for the restaurant. The venue provided the transport. That is what happens at that level of booking. A performer arrives, works [music], and the club gets them to the next place. Nobody in that car was in charge of the journey in any meaningful sense. Not the performer who had worked that night.
Not her lawyer who was her partner. Not the driver who was doing a job for a restaurant in another state. There was a television appearance in New Orleans the next day. That is the entire reason six people were on Highway 90 at 2:00 in the morning. Jayne Mansfield died traveling to a promotional appearance. Not to a film.
Not to a role. To an appearance. To stay visible [music]. Because staying visible was the only asset she had left. She performed in Biloxi. Six people, a driver, her lawyer, herself, three of her children [music], and dogs. Miklós, eight. Zoltán, six. Mariska, three and a half. Biloxi to New Orleans along the coast and across the Rigolets [music] on United States Highway 90.
Two lanes through the marsh. Unlit. Flat. [music] In late June in Louisiana. In the small hours. Hot and thick with insects. Mosquito control in that part of the country in that era meant a municipal vehicle driving the roads at night pumping insecticide into the air. At night because that is when the mosquitoes are active and when the traffic is light.
Somewhere ahead, a slow municipal truck laying down a dense white cloud across a two-lane highway. Behind it, a tractor trailer that has come into the cloud and slowed down because the driver cannot see. And behind that, a 1966 Buick Electra traveling at highway speed towards New Orleans with three adults in the front and three sleeping children in the back.
That is what we want you to sit with before the next act. The fog truck was doing public health work. The trailer slowed down correctly because visibility had dropped [music]. And the Buick was driving the speed limit on a federal highway. There is a geometry problem that had been identified, written down, and legislated against 14 and a half years earlier.
Three people died in the front seat of that Buick and we have spent this film on two of them, Ronald B. Harrison. He drove for the Gus Stevens Dinner Club in Biloxi, Mississippi. That is very nearly the entire documentary record of the man at the wheel. We could not establish his age with confidence.
We could not establish how long he had worked for the club, where he was from, whether he had a family, or whether anybody ever paid him any attention at all after the 29th of June, 1967. There are accounts that give him an age and we are not confident enough in them to put a number in your head about a dead man because the asymmetry is the subject of this channel.
Jayne Mansfield’s death produced a police report that has been quoted for 59 years, a death certificate that has been transcribed into dozens of books, a photograph reproduced worldwide, a nickname on a piece of safety equipment, a documentary made by her daughter, and this film [music]. Ronald Harrison’s death produced a line in the same reports.
He was driving a restaurant’s car between two cities at 2:00 in the morning because a performer had a television booking. He came upon a slow truck inside a cloud of insecticide on an unlit two-lane highway. And the thing that happened to him happened to him first because he was in the driver’s seat, implicitly, every time [music].
Every retelling of this story the sentence that the driver did not see the truck. Nobody could [music] see the truck. That is what the fog was. What we can do is use his name, which was Ronald B. Harrison, and say that he [music] was the third person who died on Highway 90 that night and that nothing in the record suggests he did anything wrong.
The car was a gray 1966 Buick Electra, Buick’s full-size car. A long, heavy, soft-riding American sedan. The kind of vehicle a restaurant would own to move people between cities in comfort. This is a detail that gets lost in every telling. The Buick was not Jayne Mansfield’s car. She did not own it. She was not driving it.
And the man at the wheel worked for the club in Biloxi. Because the story is usually told as though it happened to her. As a consequence of her life. It happened to her in a vehicle she had no control over, driven by a man she had not hired, on a route she did not choose, towards an appearance that existed because she needed to stay visible.
Drum [music] brakes, no antilock system, a steel dashboard. A collapsible steering column was a new idea. Lap belts [music] had only been required in all new American cars from 1964. And in 1967, almost nobody wore them. We want to be precise here, because this is the heart of the film. Three people died in the front seat of that Buick, and not one of the deaths was caused by a failure of the car’s brakes, or [music] its steering, or its seat belts, or its construction.
In a conventional high-speed collision, a [music] car into a wall, a car into another car, the front of the vehicle crushes. That crushing absorbs energy. The passenger compartment decelerates over a distance, and that distance is what people survive. In an underride collision, the front of the car does not crush, because there is nothing in front of it at bonnet height to crush against.
The car’s bonnet passes under the trailer bed. The car’s engine passes under the trailer bed. The car keeps traveling at close to its original speed. And the first thing the trailer touches is the windscreen pillars in the roof. Every piece of safety engineering in that Buick was designed to protect people in a frontal impact.
In this impact, the front of the car never hit anything. That is the phrase used in the accounts. The impact tore off the top of the car. Everything above the trailer bed was removed. Everything below it was not. Three adults were sitting above that line. Three children were asleep below it. That is why three people are dead and three people are alive, and it is not luck, and it is not fate.
It is a measurement. In the 1960s, mosquito control along the Gulf Coast and the Louisiana marshes was done by fogging. A municipal truck drove the public roads emitting a dense aerosol cloud. This was not unusual or improper. It was standard public health practice across the American South, and it was done at night because that is when mosquitoes feed and when there is least traffic to inconvenience.
It produced a thick white cloud across the highway. The reporting at the time said that the driver of the Buick apparently did not see the truck because of the heavy white chemical fog from the mosquito fogging machine. The fogging machine was some distance ahead. It was not what the Buick hit. What the Buick [music] hit was a tractor trailer that had itself come into the cloud and slowed down.
The trailer driver did the correct thing. Visibility dropped, and [music] he reduced speed. That is what a careful driver does, and it is what any investigator would want him to have done. Because a slow vehicle inside a cloud on an unlit two-lane road is almost invisible to traffic arriving behind it at speed.
The trailer was not hidden by the night. [clears throat] It was hidden by the thing that made the trailer slow down. A public health department sprays for mosquitoes at night, correctly. A truck driver enters the resulting cloud and slows down, correctly. And a driver taking a performer and her children to New Orleans travels at the speed limit on a federal highway, correctly [music].
Nobody has to be negligent for this crash to happen. That is what makes it a regulatory failure, rather than a human one. A safety standard exists for the case where everybody behaves reasonably and the outcome is still catastrophic. That is the entire theory of vehicle safety regulation. You do not design a road system on the assumption that nobody will ever come upon a slow truck in fog.
You design it so that when they do, the car does not go underneath. 15 years before this happened and written [music] it down. It was a tractor trailer. It was moving slowly. It was ahead of the Buick on highway 90. And this is important, so we are going to be explicit. We do not know the year it was manufactured. We do not know the operator.
We do not know whether it carried and protection device, and we do not know whether, if it did, that device met the 30-in requirement. Because there is a version of this film that asserts the trailer was illegally equipped, and that version would be much more satisfying, and we cannot support it. The 1952 rule applied to heavy trucks, trailers, and semi-trailers manufactured after the 31st of December, 1952.
The crash was in June, 1967. A trailer in commercial service in 1967 was overwhelmingly likely to have been built after 1952, which means the rule very probably applied to it, which leaves two possibilities, and we cannot tell you which one it was. The trailer had no guard, [music] in breach of a 15-year-old federal rule, and nobody involved in the aftermath established that or made anything of it.
The trailer had a guard that complied with the rule as written, a bar no more than 30 in off the ground, substantially constructed and firmly attached, and the Buick went under it anyway because the rule did not say how strong the bar had to be. And we want to be honest that this is an inference and not a finding.
But here is the reasoning. The 1952 rule specified a height and a phrase. It did not specify a load, a test, or an energy absorption figure. [music] A guard could satisfy it completely and still fold like paper when struck by 2 tons of Buick at highway speed. We know [music] it because of what happened next in the regulatory history, which is that the government spent the following decades trying to write the strength requirement that the 1952 rule had left out. The device was mandatory.
[music] The device was not required to work. Ronald B. Harrison, driver. Samuel Less Brody, attorney. Jayne Mansfield, 34. All three killed instantly. Miklós Hargitay the younger, eight. Zoltán Hargitay, six. Mariska Hargitay, three and a half. All three survived with injuries described in the reporting as minor.
Nobody in the front was careless. Nobody in the back was lucky. A 1966 Buick Electra’s front bench seat put three adults’heads somewhere around 50 in off the road surface. Three small children lying asleep across a rear bench seat put their heads below the level of the seat backs. The trailer bed came through at the height of the trailer bed.
That is the entire difference between the people who died and the people who lived in this crash because the measurement is the whole story. A guard at 30 in would have been struck by the Buick’s bumper and engine block, the strongest, lowest, heaviest part of the car. The deceleration would have happened in the engine bay, where every car is designed for it to happen.
The three adults in the front seat would have been in a severe frontal collision in a 1966 American car with lap belts they were probably not wearing. [music] It would have been very bad. That is the only claim we are making. We are not telling you a bar would have saved them. We do not know that and nobody can. We are telling you that the specific mechanism that killed them, the passenger compartment being sheared off at trailer bed height, is the exact mechanism that a rear-end protection device exists to prevent, and that such
a device had been federally required for 14 and a half years. And the reason we can say that with confidence is sitting on the back seat, three children in the same car, in the same crash, at the same speed, with no seat belts and no safety seats and nothing protecting them at all except their height, walked away.
That is what the children tell us. It was a survivable collision for anybody positioned below the trailer bed. Three people were above it, and the thing designed to stop that from happening had been law since 1952. And we are going to do it once in the plainest possible language, and then we are going to explain where the famous story came from, and we are not going to return to it.
[music] The police report on Jayne Mansfield’s death contains this phrase, “The upper portion of this white female’s head was severed.” That sentence is in the police report. The upper portion of her head, not her head, the upper portion of it. It is a trained officer describing, in the flat vocabulary of an incident report, that the top of the skull was separated.
Decapitation means the head is severed from the body at the neck. The police report does not say that. It says the upper portion of the head was severed, which is a different injury in a different place, consistent with a roof being torn off a car at the height of a trailer bed. And yet that sentence is almost certainly the origin of the story [music].
A police report is a document written for a file. It is read by officers, insurers, lawyers, and journalists, and it is written in a register that assumes technical competence in the reader. A journalist reads the word severed next to the word head in a report about a famous woman killed under a truck in 1967.
Head was severed becomes she was beheaded becomes she was decapitated, and each step is a small understandable compression of the previous one, and the end of the chain is false. That is [snorts] the part we find genuinely important. There is no fabricator in this story. There is a true sentence in an official document written for one audience, read by another [music], and compressed by repetition into a claim the document does not make.
The record is usually there. What goes wrong is what happens to the record afterwards. Jayne Mansfield’s death certificate records the cause of death. Crushed skull with avulsion of cranium and brain. Crushed skull is self-explanatory. Avulsion is a medical term for a forcible tearing away or detachment of a structure from its normal position.
Cranium is the part of the skull that encloses the brain. The skull was crushed, and the brain case and brain were torn away. Decapitation would be recorded as decapitation. It is not a coy injury, and no medical examiner in 1967 would have euphemized it. A death certificate saying crushed skull with avulsion of cranium and brain is a death certificate describing catastrophic injury to the head with the head still attached.
This is horrific, and we are not going to dwell in it. It is in the film because a false claim has circulated for 59 years and the only thing that kills a false claim is the document. It tells you the crash mechanism. Crushed skull with avulsion of cranium and brain is what happens when a structure moving at speed passes through a space at head height.
It is the signature of an underride collision written in medical language on a public record in Louisiana in June 1967. That is the thing nobody ever does with this document. It gets quoted to settle an argument about whether she was decapitated. It never gets read as what it actually is, which is a contemporaneous official record of exactly what a missing rear underride guard does to a human being.
Harrison, Brody, [music] Mansfield. Three certificates, three sets of front seat injuries, one trailer bed. There is a photograph of the wreck taken at the scene and it has been reproduced for decades. The crushed front of the Buick under the back of the trailer and on the wreckage, a pale clump of something that looks like hair.
59 years of people believing Jayne Mansfield was decapitated rests visually on one indistinct object in one news photograph. Nobody can say with certainty and the people who have examined it carefully do not agree. It could be the top of her head. It could be a wig she was wearing. It could be a wig she was carrying.
She traveled with them. As a performer whose appearance was her trade, it could be something else entirely. It is an unresolved object in a photograph and the debate about it continues. An ambiguous blonde shape in a crash photograph was read by a public that had been told for 12 years that Jayne Mansfield was a joke about hair and a body as her severed head.
The photograph is best known from its reproduction in a book called Hollywood Babylon by Kenneth Anger. It is a collection of scandalous stories about the American film industry published in the United States in the 1970s, and it is one of the least reliable widely read books about Hollywood ever written. Researchers have spent 50 years documenting the things in it that are invented, exaggerated, or impossible.
A true sentence in a police report, an ambiguous object in a news photograph, and a book with a documented record of fabrication, which put the two next to each other for a mass readership. Not by anybody deciding to lie, by three separate things each defensible on its own being assembled into a claim that none of them individually supports.
Every subsequent telling cited the previous telling. Nobody went back to the certificate because the certificate was boring and the story was not. Lots of famous people have died in car crashes and had inaccurate things said about them. Why did this particular false claim about this particular woman last for six decades? Because of what the press had spent 12 years teaching its readers to expect from Jayne Mansfield.
She became a freak. If a newspaper has spent a decade writing about a woman as a spectacle, as a body that keeps falling out of dresses, as the woman leaning into Sophia Loren’s dinner, as the pink champagne fountain, then the register for writing about her is already set, and a grotesque claim about her body after her death arrives into that register and fits perfectly.
That is the sentence we want to land. There had never been a point in 12 years of coverage at which a journalist writing about Jayne Mansfield needed to verify anything. The whole arrangement had been that her people supplied the material and the press printed it. When she died, the arrangement did not change.
Material arrived. A photograph, a phrase from a report, a book, and the press printed it. Marilyn Monroe died 5 years earlier and the claims about her death have also circulated for 60 years, but Monroe’s claims are about powerful men and institutions. They are conspiracies. [music] They flatter her by making her important.
The false story about Monroe is that the Kennedys had her killed. The false story about Mansfield is that her head came off. The posthumous myth each woman received is the myth her public image had already made available. Monroe had been sold as a tragedy, so she got a conspiracy. Mansfield had been sold as a body, so she got a mutilation.
She traded her body for a career and the career ended at 28. [music] And the body carried on being the only thing anybody said about her for 5 more years while she was alive and for 59 years after she was not. If you are behind a large articulated truck, there is a steel bar across the bottom of the rear, a foot or two above the road.
In the United States, it is widely known as a Mansfield bar because of her, because of the crash on Highway 90. The story is that the horror of what happened to Jayne Mansfield forced the government to require that bar and so the device carries her name. That part is true. The informal name does come from the crash and people in trucking, in insurance, and in personal injury law use it.
There is no regulation anywhere that uses the word Mansfield. It is not a legal term. It is a nickname that attached itself to a device because of a famous death. The rest of it, that her death produced the requirement, is false, and it is false in two separate directions at once. The requirement already existed.
It had existed since the 15th of May, 1952, and it had applied to every heavy trailer built after the 31st of December that year, 14 and 1/2 years before she died. And the rule that actually made rear guards work, the one with strength requirements and energy absorption tests, the one that is the reason a modern bar will stop a modern car, was not issued until the 24th of January, 1996, and did not apply to any trailer until the 26th of January, 1998.
It did not create the first rule. The first rule was already there, and it did not create the second rule, which arrived 30 years and 7 months later, after decades of engineering research, insurance industry crash testing and campaigning by people who were not thinking about Jayne Mansfield at all. A nickname, the most famous safety legacy in the history of American road transport, attached to the most famous crash of the 1960s, consists of a piece of slang.
Volume 17 of the Federal Register, page 4,445. The Bureau of Motor Carriers of the Interstate Commerce Commission, rear end protection required on heavy trucks, trailers, and semi-trailers manufactured after the 31st of December, 1952, not more than 30 inches above the ground, unladen, substantially constructed and firmly attached.
It is still in force. It survived the transfer of motor carrier safety authority from the Interstate Commerce Commission to the Department of Transportation, which happened under the Department of Transportation Act on the 15th of October, 1966, 8 months before the crash. It survived the creation of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in 1970.

It sits today in the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Section 393.86. [music] The rule that is supposed to be Jayne Mansfield’s legacy is older than she would be if she had lived. She would be 93. The rule is 74 because of five words. That is the whole specification. How much force must the guard withstand before it bends? How much energy must it absorb? How far from the rear of the trailer must it sit? So that the car’s bumper reaches it before the trailer bed reaches the windscreen? How wide must it be? So that a car striking the corner of the trailer still
hits it? Not one. The 1952 rule gives a maximum height and a figure of speech. A bar at 28 in bolted on that a Buick folds flat in a tenth of a second satisfies the rule completely. The vehicle is legal. The occupants are dead. For 44 years, from 1952 to 1996, the United States required a device to prevent underride without ever specifying that it had to be strong enough to prevent underride.
15 years in, 29 years from the fix [music], on the 24th of January 1996, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration published a final rule at Volume 61 of the Federal Register, page 2004. Two Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, [music] number 223 and number 224. 223 sets the performance standard for the guard itself, the strength it must have, the energy it must absorb, how it must be tested.
224 says which trailers must carry one. Trailers and semi-trailers with a gross vehicle weight rating of 10,000 lb or more. The 26th of January, 1998, from the 29th of June, 1967 to the 26th of January, 1998. 30 years and 7 months. The maximum ground clearance came down from 30 in to 22. The guard had to sit no more than 12 in from the rear of the trailer.
And it had to be between 94 and 102 in wide, so that a car hitting the corner of a trailer could not slip past the end of it. Height lowered. Setback specified for the first time. Width specified for the first time. Strength and energy absorption specified for the first time. On the 1st of September, 1999, the Federal Highway Administration amended the motor carrier regulations, so that operators, not just manufacturers, [music] had to have guards meeting the new standard.
In November 2004, there were two further amendments. [music] And on the 9th of November, 2021, nearly 54 years after the crash, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration finally added rear impact guards to the list of items that must be checked on a commercial vehicle’s annual inspection. So, until December 2021, the annual safety inspection of an American commercial trailer did not require anybody to look at the underride guard.
A rule in 1952 with no teeth. Jayne Mansfield in 1967. A real standard in 1996 and an inspection requirement in 2021. 54 years from her death to the point where somebody was obliged to check. The 1952 rule said a rear guard could sit no more than 30 inches above the ground. The 1996 standard said 22. That is the [music] difference, and it took 44 years because the guard has to be low enough that the strong part of a car reaches it.
[music] At the bottom, there is a bumper, and behind the bumper, there is structure, frame rails, the engine, the parts designed to absorb a frontal impact. Above that, there is a bonnet. And behind the bonnet, there is nothing much. Sheet metal and air. 30 inches off the road on many cars is at or above the top of the bumper. It can be at bonnet height.
A car striking a bar at bonnet height does not engage its crash structure. The bonnet crumples, the bar rides over or through it, and the car keeps going. 22 inches is bumper height on almost every passenger car ever built. It is the height at which the strongest, lowest, heaviest part of the vehicle arrives first.
[music] 8 inches is the difference between a bar the car hits with its face and a bar the car hits with its fist. It required the guard to sit no more than 12 inches from the rear of the trailer because a guard set too far forward lets the car travel under the trailer before it reaches the bar, by which time the trailer bed has already arrived at the windscreen.
It required the guard to be between 94 and 102 inches wide because a narrow guard lets a car striking the corner of a trailer slide past the end of it entirely. And it required the guard to pass strength and energy absorption tests because a bar that folds is a bar that is not there. Four requirements. The 1952 rule had one of them, set 8 inches too high, and a figure of speech instead of the other three.
That was the entire body of federal engineering requirement standing between a 1966 Buick Electra and the back of a trailer on United States Highway 90. Here is what circulates about Jayne Mansfield’s death that the record does not support. She was not. The death certificate records crushed skull with avulsion of cranium and brain.
The police report says the upper portion of the head was severed, which is a different injury in a different place. It did not. The requirement was published on the 15th of May, 1952 and applied to trailers built after the 31st of December that year, 14 and 1/2 years before she died. It did not [music]. Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 223 and 224 were issued on the 24th of January, 1996 and bound trailers built from the 26th of January, 1998, 30 years and 7 months later after decades of separate engineering and advocacy.
It is not. No regulation uses the word. The nickname is real. [music] The naming never happened. She was not. Ronald B. Harrison was driving. He worked for the Gus Stevens Dinner Club in Biloxi. It did not. The fogging machine was further ahead. The Buick struck a tractor-trailer that had slowed down inside the fog.
They were not [music]. The contemporaneous reporting describes the three children on the back seat as having minor injuries. All three survived. This one is subtler and it is still wrong. She had a Theatre World Award, a Golden Globe, 450 Broadway performances, and she had been the highest-paid nightclub performer in Las Vegas at $35,000 a week 7 years earlier.
Her film career was finished. Her career was not. She was working. She died on United States Highway 90 east of New Orleans, between New Orleans and the Mississippi coast in Louisiana, not in the city. The time. Most detailed accounts put the crash at about a quarter past two in the morning. Some give a slightly later time.
We have used a quarter past two, and we have told you there is a variation. We do not know whether the trailer carried a rear-end protection device. We do not know if it did [music] whether that device met the 30-in requirement or how it was built or how it failed. We do not know the year the trailer was manufactured or who operated it.
We do not know whether anybody in the Buick had been drinking, and we have declined to speculate. We do not know the exact speed of either vehicle. We do not know whether any investigation was made into the adequacy of the trailer’s rear protection, and we have found no evidence that one was [music]. We do not know what the pale object in the photograph is.
We do not know what the Jungle Land litigation produced. And we do not know what Jayne Mansfield’s finances actually looked like in June 1967, because the question underneath this entire film is why a 34-year-old woman with five children was working a supper club in Biloxi and driving through the night to make a television slot.
We can show you the shape of the answer, irregular income, no salary since 1962, five dependents, a career that only paid when she was physically present somewhere. We cannot show you the bank statement, the date and the time, the road, [music] the car, the fog, the trailer, who was in the front and who was in the back, the two documents in the regulatory history, which is public, dated and citable to the page.
Everything else about this crash has been argued about for 59 years. The one part nobody argues about because nobody has ever looked at it is the part with the page numbers. Miklós Hargitay the younger [music], eight. Zoltán Hargitay, six. Mariska Hargitay, three and a half. Mickey Hargitay, their father, and his third wife Ellen Siano.
The Hungarian bodybuilder who had lifted their mother above his head on a stage at the Tropicana in 1958 and who had been insured against dropping her for a million dollars. He died in 2006, aged 80. Which means he spent more than twice as long raising their children after her death as he had spent married to her.
The youngest of the three in the car was three and a half years old and asleep. She has a zigzag scar on her head from that night. She is alive. She is one of the most recognizable actresses in American television. And she has spoken about her mother publicly over many years. We are going to use only what she has chosen to say.
[music] Speaking to Good Housekeeping, she described the loss of her mother as a hole in my life that won’t ever be filled. She said, “I will never get over it. I will always be a girl who lost her mom.”She has no memory of her mother to lose. That is the particular shape of it. The hole is not where a person used to be.
It is where a person was supposed to go. She released a documentary film about her mother, which she directed herself, her first time directing. It was her film about her family made on her terms. And it is the one place this story has ever been told by somebody who was in the car. We have made a film about a road, two documents, and a federal regulation.
The family story belongs to the family, and one of them has now told it. If you want that, watch hers. Jayne Mansfield had five children and three of them were in the car. Jayne Marie Mansfield, born the 8th of November, 1950, when her mother was 17. She was 16 years old in June 1967, and she was not [music] in the Buick.
Antonio, called Tony, born the 18th of October, 1965, to Jayne Mansfield and Matt Cimber. He was 1 year old and he was not in the Buick, either. Both may be living and neither chose any of this. And the thing this channel will not do is build a film out of a stranger’s family. [music] Because the standard telling says her children were in the car and that is three of five.
A 16-year-old and a 1-year-old were somewhere else while their mother worked a supper club in Mississippi with the middle three. Five children. Three fathers, three divorces, a 16-year-old in a house with a man the record describes as abusive, a 6-year-old 7 months out of brain surgery, and a mother earning the whole of the family’s income by appearing in rooms in other states.
We keep [snorts] saying it because it keeps being the answer to the question people actually have about her, which is why she behaved as she did. She was 21 when she put on the wrong swimsuit in Florida. She was 24 when she bought the pink house. She was 28 when her film career ended. She was 34 when she died.
Every decision in this film was made by somebody in their 20s with children to support and one marketable asset in an industry that had told her exactly what that asset was and exactly how long it would be worth anything. That is the part that should unsettle you. She behaved like somebody who knew the clock was short. She was dead at 34.
[music] Jayne Mansfield is buried at Fairview Cemetery in Pen Argyl, Pennsylvania, a small borough in the slate belt of eastern Pennsylvania in the northeast corner of the state. Not Hollywood forever. Not Westwood Village where Marilyn Monroe is. A town of a few thousand people, 40 miles from where she was born.
Her father’s family was from that area. Her body was prepared and shipped from Louisiana to Pennsylvania for the funeral and burial. Born at Bryn Mawr hospital in Pennsylvania in 1933. Dallas, Los Angeles, Broadway, Las Vegas, Spain [snorts], Britain [music], Italy, Rio de Janeiro, Greensboro, Louisville, New York [music], Biloxi, and then back to a cemetery in Pen Argyl, Pennsylvania.
About 60 miles from the hospital she was born in. The house on Sunset Boulevard with the heart-shaped bath and the champagne fountain [music] was demolished in 2002. The grave in a small town in Pennsylvania, a handful of films, two of which are genuinely good, a photograph of a dinner in 1957 that will never stop being reproduced, and a steel bar on the back of every articulated lorry in the United States which people call a Mansfield bar which was required by law 15 years before she died and which did not save her. The nickname on a device
that failed because every person who looks at that bar and asks why it is called that has for a moment remembered that a woman died under a truck in Louisiana in 1967. The nickname is wrong about the history. It is right about the fact that somebody should have to remember. We want to say why we made this because it is different from the others on this channel.
We expected to find the standard story. [music] A horrifying crash, a public outcry, a government response, and a safety bar named after a dead film star. [music] The tidy version, where something good comes out of something terrible, because we wanted to name the rule her death had produced, and the date it was signed. Instead, there was a rule from 1952 that was already law when she died.
And a real standard from 1996 that had nothing to do with her, because it meant the comforting part of the story was the invented part. A woman who made a trade at 21, because it was the only trade on offer to a teenage mother from Dallas who wanted to act. The trade worked. It took her from selling popcorn to a Fox contract in 18 months, to Broadway, to a Critics’ Award, to a Golden Globe, to $35,000 a week in Las Vegas.
And then it came due, because what she had borrowed against was her youth, and the interest was that nobody would ever take anything else about her seriously again. Not the 450 Broadway performances, not the languages, not the comedy, not the Steinbeck adaptation. Her income depended on being physically present in rooms that would pay to have her in them.
And by 1967, those rooms were in Greensboro and Louisville and Biloxi, and getting to them meant driving at night. A rule that set a bar. A rule that did not say how strong. We have now made four films about famous American deaths, and the pattern is not that the truth was hidden. The truth was written down every single time. On a death certificate, in a police report, in a toxicology result, in the Federal Register.
It is all there, with dates and page numbers, in public. What goes wrong is that nobody reads it, and a better story arrives, and the better story wins. She was born Vera Jayne Palmer on the 19th of April, [music] 1933 at Bryn Mawr Hospital in Pennsylvania. She was a comic actress who won two awards for it before she was 25, and she spent the following 9 years being photographed instead.
So, what was worse about Jayne Mansfield’s crash than you think? Not the injury. The injury is horrific, and it has been exaggerated for 59 years into something it was not. She was not decapitated. The death certificate says crushed skull with avulsion of cranium and brain, [music] and the police report says the upper portion of the head was severed, and the famous version came from a true sentence, an ambiguous photograph, and a book with a documented record of invention.
What is worse is that nothing about this crash was unknown. The geometry had been understood since before she was famous. A loaded trailer bed sits at the height of a car’s windows. A car that [music] strikes it does not crumple. It passes underneath, and everything above the trailer bed is removed. The engineers had a word for it.
They called it underride. And on the 15th of May, 1952, the United States federal government published a rule requiring a guard across the back of every heavy trailer built from the end of that year, no more than 30 in above the road, substantially [music] constructed and firmly attached.