News

What Was Life Like for Mary Boleyn After Henry VIII Was Done With Her

On the morning of the 19th of May, 1536, a swordsman brought over from Calais stepped onto a scaffold inside the walls of the Tower of London.

Queen Anne Boleyn knelt in front of him.

It was over with a single stroke.

Two days earlier, Anne’s brother, George Boleyn, Lord Rochford, had been beheaded on Tower Hill on charges that hardly anyone believes today.

The Boleyns, who only a few years before had seemed to own the future of England, were finished.

Almost finished.

Somewhere far from London, away from the court and away from everything the Boleyn name had once meant, the queen’s older sister was still alive.

Her name was Mary.

She had once shared the king’s bed.

She had stood close enough to Henry VIII to learn exactly what his favor was worth, and by 1536 she had already lost almost everything that closeness had ever touched.

Her money was gone.

Her family had thrown her out.

Her name opened no doors at court.

But she was breathing, and Anne and George were not.

—

## The other Boleyn girl

This is usually the point where Mary Boleyn’s story stops.

In most histories she is a footnote, the sister who came before, the one who went to the king’s bed and came away with nothing.

But Mary did not simply vanish when the king lost interest in her.

What happened to her afterward is stranger and harder than the famous version, and in some ways it says more about the Tudor court than Anne’s story ever could.

She was left in debt and refused help by her own father.

She watched her small son handed into the care of her younger sister.

She was banished from court for marrying a man with no title and no fortune, and she was reduced to writing letters asking for the most basic help.

She sank about as low as a woman of her birth could sink in Tudor England without actually going to the block.

And then, quietly, she outlived almost every person who had ever used her.

To understand how, you have to start not at the Tower, but across the Channel, in France.

—

## A teenager at the French court

Mary Boleyn was probably born around 1499, most likely at Blickling Hall in Norfolk.

Nobody recorded the date, and historians still argue over whether she or Anne was the elder, though most now believe it was Mary.

Her father, Thomas Boleyn, was a clever, ambitious courtier and diplomat who had served the crown at several foreign courts.

Her mother, Elizabeth, was a Howard, the daughter of one of the greatest noble families in England.

The Boleyns were rising, and Thomas meant to keep rising.

His children were part of the plan.

In the autumn of 1514, when she was about fifteen, Mary crossed the Channel in the train of Princess Mary Tudor, Henry VIII’s younger sister.

The princess was being sent to marry King Louis XII of France, a sickly man more than thirty years older than she was.

She went unwillingly.

Before she left, she is said to have made her brother promise that if she outlived Louis, she would be free to choose her next husband herself.

Soon after the wedding, Louis sent most of the princess’s English attendants home.

Only a handful were allowed to stay, and among them, according to the list that survives, was a young Mistress Boleyn, almost certainly Mary.

For a girl of her age and family, it was a remarkable place to be.

It was also not an accident.

—

## A reputation she never got to answer

The marriage did not last long.

Louis XII died on the 1st of January, 1515, less than three months after the wedding.

His young widow wasted no time.

Within weeks she had secretly married Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, the man she had wanted all along, and she went home to face her brother’s anger.

Mary Boleyn seems to have stayed behind in France, probably in the household of the new queen, Claude, the wife of the new king, Francis I.

Francis was twenty years old, tall, athletic and famous for his interest in the women of his court.

And it is from these years that the worst of Mary’s reputation comes.

In 1536, the year of Anne’s fall, a papal envoy in France, Rodolfo Pio, Bishop of Faenza, wrote a letter repeating what he had heard about the English queen’s sister.

In his Italian, he called her a very great whore, the most infamous of all.

He was writing at second hand, about events twenty years old, at the very moment when the Boleyn name was being dragged through the mud.

Later tellings added an uglier detail, claiming that Francis had boasted of riding her and called her his hackney, or his English mare.

Those stories passed through many hands before they reached English history books, and their reliability has been argued over ever since.

Some historians accept that Mary had an affair with Francis.

Others point out that the French king boasted about a great many women, that the sources are thin, and that the people repeating the story had every reason to blacken the Boleyns.

At least one recent biographer has gone further, arguing that the bishop’s letter may not even have been about Mary at all.

Nobody can now prove it either way.

What is certain is that the damage was done centuries ago, and that it was done by men she never had a chance to answer.

—

## A wedding the king attended

By 1519 or 1520, Mary was back in England, serving as a maid of honor to Queen Catherine of Aragon.

On the 4th of February, 1520, she married William Carey in the Chapel Royal at Greenwich Palace.

Carey was a good match for her.

He was well born, distantly related to the king, and a gentleman of the king’s Privy Chamber, one of the small group of men who attended Henry in his private rooms.

The king himself came to the wedding.

The royal accounts record that he made an offering of six shillings and eight pence.

Within two years, by most historians’ reckoning, the king was sleeping with that bride.

—

## The affair nobody wrote down

Here is the strangest thing about Mary Boleyn’s relationship with Henry VIII.

It left almost no trace.

The historian Alison Weir has pointed out that there is no record of when it began, how long it lasted or when it ended.

No love letters survive.

No ambassador sent home a detailed account.

The king never acknowledged it while it was happening.

The best estimate puts it somewhere between about 1522 and 1525.

And the main reason we can be sure it happened at all is a piece of church law.

In 1527, when Henry was preparing to marry Anne, he asked the pope for a dispensation.

Under the rules of the church, a man who had slept with a woman was barred from marrying her sister, just as if the two women were his own relatives.

The request Henry’s agents drew up covered exactly that problem: an impediment of affinity arising from illicit intercourse, in the first degree.

Years later, a story came out of a private conversation that comes as close as anything to a confession.

Sir George Throckmorton, a member of Parliament who opposed the king’s marriage to Anne, later recalled telling Henry that people said he had meddled with both Anne’s mother and her sister.

The king’s answer was short.

“Never with the mother.”

Thomas Cromwell, standing nearby, is said to have added, “Nor never with the sister either,” and told Throckmorton to put the idea out of his mind.

The king had already said enough.

—

## Everything in his name

So what did Mary receive for those years in the king’s bed?

In her own name, almost nothing.

The rewards went to her husband.

Through the early and middle 1520s, the records show a run of grants to William Carey: keeperships of royal houses and parks, an annuity, and by 1526 a spread of manors across several counties.

But under English law, a married woman could not hold property in her own right while her husband was alive.

Everything belonged to Carey.

Her father did rather well out of those years too.

Thomas Boleyn was made Viscount Rochford in June 1525, and a few years later Earl of Wiltshire and Ormond, though by then it was Anne, not Mary, who had the king’s attention.

Now compare Mary’s fate with that of Elizabeth Blount, known as Bessie, the king’s other known mistress.

In 1519, Bessie gave Henry a son.

Henry acknowledged the boy openly and gave him the surname Fitzroy, meaning son of the king.

In June 1525, when Henry Fitzroy was six years old, the king made him Duke of Richmond and Somerset in a grand ceremony at Bridewell Palace.

On the very same day, in the very same ceremony, Thomas Boleyn was raised to his viscountcy.

The little duke was given a household of well over two hundred people, and his father took a close interest in his education.

Mary’s children received nothing like it.

Henry never said a public word about them.

—

## The sister who said no

By the middle of the 1520s, the affair was over.

The king’s eye had moved on, and it had landed on the one woman at court who had watched Mary closely enough not to repeat her mistake.

Anne Boleyn refused to become the king’s mistress.

She had seen what happened to her sister: used, set aside and left with nothing to show for it.

Anne held out for the one prize that could not be taken back.

She would be his wife, or nothing.

Henry was desperate for a legitimate son, and Anne’s refusal turned that desperation into a force that would break England’s ties with the Catholic Church, close the monasteries and reshape the country for centuries.

In the middle of it all, Mary was simply no longer useful.

Nobody at court had any reason to pretend otherwise.

—

## Widowed, in debt and on her own

Then, in the summer of 1528, the sweating sickness came back to England.

The sweat was one of the most frightening diseases of the age.

It struck without warning, and it could kill a healthy adult within hours.

On the 22nd of June, 1528, it killed William Carey.

Mary was left with two small children, a daughter, Catherine, who was about four, and a son, Henry, who was two.

She was also left with her husband’s debts, and with no income of her own.

Her father would not help her.

Thomas Boleyn had climbed from knight to viscount, partly on the back of the connections his daughters gave him, and now that his widowed daughter needed him, he turned away.

It was the king who stepped in.

In one of his surviving love letters to Anne, Henry mentions what he called her sister’s matter.

He wrote that he had told her father his mind, so that, in his words, “Eve shall not have power to deceive Adam.”

Thomas, the king said, could not in honor refuse to take in his own natural daughter in her extreme necessity.

The king also arranged for Mary to receive the annuity of one hundred pounds a year that Carey had once held.

It was very nearly the only thing Henry ever gave Mary in her own name, and he gave it not out of love, but because a dead servant’s widow was in need.

At the same time, Anne was granted the wardship of Mary’s little son, Henry Carey.

She paid for his education, and later the boy studied under Nicholas Bourbon, a French poet and scholar whom Anne had helped to bring to England.

It was a generous thing to do.

But it also meant that Anne, not Mary, now controlled the boy’s future: his schooling, his friends and one day his marriage.

—

## A servant in her sister’s household

For the next few years, Mary lived on the edges of one of the most dramatic courts in English history.

She watched her sister climb from royal favorite to queen-in-waiting to queen.

There are small glimpses of her in the records.

In November 1530, the king’s privy purse accounts show a payment of twenty pounds to Anne to redeem a jewel that belonged to Mary.

Nobody knows how the jewel came to be pawned, but it is a telling detail: one sister borrowing against her trinkets while the other was being showered with gifts by the king.

In October 1532, Mary is said to have been among the ladies who went with Anne to Calais, where Henry met Francis I, the same French king whose name had already been tied to Mary’s.

And when Anne was crowned in Westminster Abbey on the 1st of June, 1533, Mary was among the ladies who attended her.

Think about what that meant in practice.

Mary waited on her younger sister.

She served in a household that existed largely because Anne had studied Mary’s failure and chosen to play the game differently.

Foreign observers noticed that Anne and George were close, and that neither seemed to have much time for Mary.

She was tolerated rather than valued.

—

## The man with nothing

And then, sometime in 1534, Mary Boleyn did the one thing nobody at court expected.

She fell in love, and she married for it, in secret.

The man was William Stafford.

He was a soldier, probably with service at Calais behind him, and a younger son of a minor gentry family.

He was younger than Mary, possibly by ten years or more, though the records disagree on his birth year.

He had no title.

He had no inheritance to speak of.

He had no land, no real income, and no political future that anyone serious would have noticed.

In the cold arithmetic of Tudor marriage, where every match was weighed for what it would bring the family, Mary had thrown herself away.

The secret did not keep.

By the late summer of 1534 it was obvious that Mary was pregnant, and the truth came out.

The reaction was swift and complete.

The queen was furious.

The Boleyns cut Mary off for the second time.

She and her husband were sent away from court.

In December 1534, the imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, reported that the queen’s sister had been banished some three months earlier, partly for her misconduct and partly because it would not do for the queen’s sister to be seen at court pregnant by a man of no standing.

Why was Anne so harsh?

Several historians have pointed to her own position.

By late 1534, Anne had given Henry only a daughter, the future Elizabeth I, born in September 1533.

There was still no son.

She had lost at least one pregnancy, and she could feel the ground beginning to move beneath her.

And here was her older sister, pregnant by a man she had chosen for love, and apparently happy, when happiness was the one thing Anne’s own marriage was failing to give her.

The contrast may have been more than she could bear.

—

## “Rather beg my bread”

Banished, with no money and a baby on the way, Mary did something that still surprises historians.

She wrote a letter.

She addressed it to Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, as Master Secretary, and she signed it Mary Stafford.

The letter was kept among Cromwell’s papers, and in 1846 it was printed by Mary Anne Everett Wood in her collection Letters of Royal and Illustrious Ladies of Great Britain.

It is one of the most personal documents to survive from the Tudor court.

Mary did not pretend she had been sensible.

She admitted that she could have married a greater man of birth and a higher, and she accepted that her family had reason to be angry.

But she wrote that she could never have had one who loved her so well, nor a more honest man.

She asked Cromwell to plead with the king and queen on her behalf.

She asked him to speak to her father, to her uncle, the Duke of Norfolk, and to her brother George.

She asked for help in getting her husband back into royal service, so that they would have something to live on.

And then she wrote the line that has echoed through nearly five centuries.

If she were free to choose, she told Cromwell, “I had rather beg my bread with him than to be the greatest queen christened.”

Whether Mary had her sister in mind when she wrote those words is something no historian can prove.

The greatest queen christened, at that moment, was Anne.

It is very hard to read the sentence any other way.

It sounds like a woman saying: you took the crown, I took the man, and I would make the same choice again.

—

## No way back

Cromwell does seem to have tried.

But appeals to Thomas Boleyn, to the Duke of Norfolk and to George Boleyn came to nothing.

The king showed little interest.

Anne relented a little, and she is said to have sent her sister a gold cup and a sum of money.

She did not restore Mary’s place at court.

She did not invite her back.

As far as anyone knows, the two sisters never saw each other again.

Less than two years later, the family that had cast Mary out was destroyed in a matter of weeks.

—

## May 1536

On the 2nd of May, 1536, Anne was arrested and taken to the Tower.

George was arrested the same day.

He was accused of treason, and of incest with his own sister, a charge almost no historian now believes.

He was tried on the 15th of May and executed on Tower Hill on the 17th, alongside four other men accused of being the queen’s lovers.

On the 19th, Anne followed him.

She was somewhere between twenty-nine and thirty-five years old, depending on which birth date you accept.

Most historians today believe the charges against both of them were false, and that the case was built by Thomas Cromwell, the same man Mary had begged for help, to clear the way for the king’s marriage to Jane Seymour.

It made no difference.

George and Anne were dead.

Mary was now the only surviving child of Thomas and Elizabeth Boleyn.

And here the records fall silent.

There is no evidence that she visited either of them in the Tower.

There is no record of how she heard the news, or of what she felt when she did.

She had grown up with them.

She had served at court beside George and lived in Anne’s household.

And she left no word about their deaths that any historian has ever found.

We do not even know for certain where she was living.

She may have been on Stafford family land, or across the Channel at Calais, where her husband had connections.

It is as if she stepped behind a curtain.

—

## The quiet years

Her mother, Elizabeth Boleyn, died on the 3rd of April, 1538, in London, and was buried in the Howard family chapel at St Mary’s Church in Lambeth.

There is no record that Mary was there.

Her father, Thomas Boleyn, died on the 12th of March, 1539, at Hever Castle in Kent, the house where his children had grown up.

He was buried in the parish church of St Peter at Hever, where his fine brass memorial can still be seen.

With Anne and George dead, Mary was now his only surviving heir, and at last she came into a share of the family property.

Whether that was a deathbed change of heart or simply the law taking its course, nobody can say.

—

## A slow way back

What followed was a slow, partial return to respectability.

The king seems finally to have let the matter drop.

Around 1540, William Stafford was appointed one of the king’s gentlemen pensioners, the mounted guard of gentlemen who rode with the king, and by 1541 he was an esquire of the body.

The couple also acquired some land of their own in Kent.

Hever Castle itself, the house where Mary, Anne and George had all grown up, passed out of Boleyn hands entirely.

The crown took it, and in 1540 the king gave it to Anne of Cleves as part of the settlement when he ended their brief marriage.

Mary did keep one Boleyn house.

She came into Rochford Hall in Essex, an old family property, and it seems to have been there that she spent her last years.

—

## Rochford Hall

Mary Boleyn died on the 19th of July, 1543.

She was about forty-three or forty-four years old.

The cause of her death was not recorded.

The inquiry into her lands held after her death, the inquisition post mortem, described her by the name of her first husband, Mary Carey, late the wife of William Stafford.

Even in death, the official record gave her the name of the husband the king had approved, not the one she had chosen for herself.

Nobody knows where she was buried.

Alison Weir has suggested she may lie in the church of St Andrew at Rochford, close to the hall, but the parish records do not go back that far, and the building has been heavily restored since.

Her grave has never been found.

—

## The man she left behind

William Stafford outlived her by thirteen years.

He married again, a woman named Dorothy Stafford, a distant cousin from the grander branch of the family, the granddaughter of the executed Duke of Buckingham.

He was knighted in 1545, during the king’s last wars in France.

Under the Catholic Queen Mary I, he and Dorothy, both committed Protestants, went into exile in Geneva.

He died there in May 1556.

Whatever he and Mary had built together in their nine years of marriage, it left no diary, no memoir and no bundle of letters.

There is only the one letter to Cromwell.

And there is the fact that she stayed with him, when staying meant losing everything else.

—

## Catherine

But Mary Boleyn’s story does not end in that lost grave.

Her two children became two of the most important figures at the court of Elizabeth I.

And the way the queen treated them has kept historians arguing for more than four hundred years.

Catherine Carey, Mary’s daughter, married Sir Francis Knollys around 1540.

They had a very large family, some fourteen or more children by most counts, and sixteen by some.

During the reign of Mary I, the Knollys family, staunch Protestants, went into exile in Germany.

They came home after Elizabeth became queen in 1558.

Catherine became one of the queen’s most trusted women, a lady of the Privy Chamber and of the bedchamber, with the kind of access to Elizabeth that only a handful of people ever had.

That kind of position required complete trust.

When Catherine died at Hampton Court Palace on the 15th of January, 1569, Elizabeth was said to be grief-stricken.

The queen paid for the funeral herself, at a cost recorded as six hundred and forty pounds, two shillings and eleven pence.

To put that in perspective, a skilled craftsman in Elizabethan England might earn something like ten or fifteen pounds in a year.

The funeral cost decades of a working man’s wages.

Catherine was buried in Westminster Abbey, a place usually reserved for royalty and the very highest of the nobility.

Her daughter, Lettice Knollys, would later anger the queen badly.

In 1578, nearly ten years after Catherine’s death, Lettice secretly married Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, the man widely believed to have been the great love of Elizabeth’s life.

The queen never forgave her.

Catherine did not live to see it.

—

## Henry, Lord Hunsdon

Mary’s son, Henry Carey, was born on the 4th of March, 1526.

That date matters.

It falls right at the end of his mother’s affair with the king, or very soon after it, and it has made the question of his father one of the great unsolved puzzles of Tudor history.

Soon after Elizabeth became queen, she made her cousin Baron Hunsdon.

He became a Knight of the Garter, a member of the Privy Council and, in time, Lord Chamberlain of the Household, one of the great officers of the court.

In 1588, the year of the Spanish Armada, he was given command of the army raised to protect the queen’s own person.

He was also a soldier who could fight.

When the northern earls rose against Elizabeth in 1569, Hunsdon was at Berwick on the Scottish border, and early in 1570 he met and defeated the rebel Leonard Dacre in a fierce fight by the River Gelt.

The queen wrote to thank him in her own hand.

For nearly forty years he was one of the people she trusted most.

—

## The king’s son?

So was he Henry VIII’s son?

The evidence points in both directions.

In 1535, John Hale, the vicar of Isleworth, was questioned about treasonous talk, and he admitted that he had been shown young Master Carey and told that the boy was the king’s son.

Elizabeth certainly treated both of Mary’s children with a warmth and generosity well beyond what Tudor monarchs usually showed their cousins.

She gave them titles, land and trusted places at her side, and she grieved for them when they died.

But she always called them cousins.

Never brother.

Never sister.

Historians have split over the question.

The biographer Josephine Wilkinson has argued that it is highly probable Henry Carey was the king’s son.

Others, including Antonia Fraser, have thought it very unlikely.

The usual argument against is simple: a king so desperate for sons would surely have acknowledged a healthy boy, as he had acknowledged Henry Fitzroy.

The most honest answer is the simplest.

We do not know.

—

## A title refused

What we do know is how Henry Carey handled the question at the very end of his life.

In July 1596, he lay dying at Somerset House in London.

According to a story told not long afterward, Elizabeth came to his bedside and offered to make him Earl of Wiltshire.

It was the title his grandfather, Thomas Boleyn, had once held, the title that had marked the very peak of the Boleyn family’s rise.

Hunsdon is reported to have turned it down.

“Madam,” he is said to have answered, “as you did not count me worthy of this honour in life, then I shall account myself not worthy of it in death.”

He died on the 23rd of July, 1596.

If he was the queen’s half-brother, his refusal reads as a rebuke: a dying man telling his sister that she had waited too long.

If he was only her cousin, it reads as pride.

Either way, it was pure Boleyn stubbornness, delivered at the one moment when nobody could answer back.

—

## The sister who lasted

Anne Boleyn changed the course of English history.

Her marriage set off the break with Rome, the creation of the Church of England and the English Reformation.

She was brilliant and ambitious, and she paid for that ambition with her life before she was forty.

She is one of the most studied women who ever lived.

Mary was forgotten for centuries.

When she was remembered at all, it was as the loose sister, the one the French king supposedly boasted about, the one who made the mistake of going to the king’s bed without demanding a crown in return.

Philippa Gregory’s 2001 novel, The Other Boleyn Girl, brought her back into public view, though it took great liberties with the historical record.

More recent historians have begun to paint a more complicated picture.

They describe a girl who may have had very little choice at the French court, a woman used by her family and her king as a piece in games she did not design, and a woman who, when she was finally free to make one choice for herself, chose love over power and paid for it with everything she had.

Even her face is uncertain.

No portrait of Mary Boleyn has ever been securely identified.

In 2020, researchers announced that a seventeenth-century copy of a lost portrait in the Royal Collection, showing a woman in the dress of the 1530s with ermine at her sleeves, was very probably her, and a version of it hangs today at Hever Castle.

It may well be Mary.

But nobody can be completely sure.

Anne won the crown, and lost her head.

Mary lost everything at court, and kept hers.

She married a man she loved.

And she died at around forty-three, in her own bed, in a house that belonged to her.

She left behind one letter and a few lines in other people’s records.

But through her children and their children after them, the Careys and the Knollyses and all their descendants, Mary Boleyn’s blood ran on through the English nobility for centuries.

The sister who was thrown away turned out to be the one who lasted.

You Might Also Enjoy