News

“Untie Her!” The Nameless Gunslinger Warned Custer City’s Most Notorious Thugs… But They Ignored Him

They tied her to the old signpost in the middle of Stockade Street a little before noon, when the sun over Custer City was so white it seemed to bleach the color out of everything it touched.

It was July of 1878, in the southern Black Hills of Dakota Territory, and the town had not seen rain in nineteen days.

The false fronts along the street had gone the gray of driftwood.

The dust lay ankle-deep and pale as flour, and every hoof that crossed it raised a little ghost that hung in the air and would not settle.

The signpost had gone up in the spring of ’76, when Custer City was the first gold camp in the Hills and the busiest place between the Missouri River and the Rockies.

It was a squared pine trunk as thick as a man’s waist, sunk deep in the middle of the street, with two long arms bolted across it, one high and one low.

In those days the arms had carried painted boards that pointed the way to the stage office, to Cheyenne, to the diggings on French Creek.

Then word of the strike at Deadwood Gulch had come down the trail, and six thousand people had left Custer City in a single month, and the painted boards had gone into somebody’s stove.

The post had stood there ever since, a signpost pointing nowhere.

Now there was a woman on it.

Her name was Lucinda Penhallow, and she was twenty-seven years old.

They had hung her arms over the upper crossbar and roped her wrists there, and stretched her legs out sideways along the lower bar and roped her ankles to its two ends with freight rope, so that she could not lean back against the timber and could not turn her face away from the street.

She had been up there since before eleven.

Her shoulders were cramped and burning, the sun had reddened her face and forearms, and she was so tired that the street swam a little when she looked at it.

She wore the cream-colored dress she wore every morning in the boarding house kitchen, with flour still on the skirt and a plain leather belt at the waist, and her brown hair had come half down out of its pins.

She was not crying.

She had done some of that earlier, in the alley, when they first came for her.

She had decided she would not do any more of it where Stockade Street could see.

Four men stood at the foot of the post.

They wore red kerchiefs knotted at the throat and strips of red cloth tied around the upper arm, the mark every man in the southern Hills had learned to read that summer.

Folks called them the Redbands.

They drove bull teams for the Sidney Road Freight and Forwarding Company, hauling flour and whiskey and blasting powder two hundred and fifty miles north from the railroad at Sidney, Nebraska, and they carried the tools of that trade.

The first held a coiled bullwhip raised over his head, as if he were about to throw it.

The second had a coil of rope over his arm.

The third held a short whip down at his side.

The fourth let a long whip trail out behind him in the dust, twelve feet of braided rawhide, the kind that is made for moving a twelve-yoke ox team up a mountain grade.

A whip like that can split a plank.

None of them was touching her.

They did not need to.

They only stood below the post in a loose line and let the town look.

The town looked from a long way off.

A handful of people stood on the boardwalk to the right, in the shade of the porches, as far back as they could get and still see.

A woman in a long dress stood at the edge of the boardwalk with both hands over her mouth.

Old Ludwig Oberholtzer stood in front of his grocery in his long apron with spilled flour on his shoes.

The telegraph operator stood in his doorway pretending to clean his spectacles.

Sheriff Lazarus Greaves watched from the porch of his office with one hand near his gun and shame sitting in his face like a stone at the bottom of a creek.

And in the street at the left of all of it, with a saddled chestnut horse standing behind him at the hitching rail, a stranger in a green poncho stood with his back half turned to the town, looking at the post.

—

## The Witness

The tallest of the Redbands stepped out in front of the post and lifted his whip hand to the street.

His name was Brodie Scarrow.

He was the foreman of Leopold Stroebel’s bull trains and the loudest dog Stroebel owned, a lean man with a narrow face and a smile that never reached the rest of him.

He liked crowds, because small men borrow their weight from other people’s silence.

“Custer City,” he called, “we have ourselves a witness.”

Nobody answered.

Scarrow grinned up at the woman on the post.

“Miss Penhallow here thinks she saw something up the north road. Something she didn’t understand. Go on, Lucinda. Tell the sheriff what you told your uncle.”

Lucinda looked across the street at the sheriff’s porch.

Lazarus Greaves looked back at her, and his face had gone the color of the dust.

Every soul on Stockade Street knew why.

Three months before, the sheriff’s son had ridden out on the north road with a sack of mail for the Hill City camps and had not come back.

Jamie Greaves was nineteen, freckled and long in the leg, the kind of young man who stood up straighter whenever his father pinned on the badge.

The morning after he disappeared, the sheriff had found Jamie’s hat sitting on his desk, with a folded note under it sealed with a blob of red wax.

The note said, *Do your job carefully, Sheriff.*

That was all it said.

It did not need to say more.

After that, Lazarus Greaves had still walked the street.

He had still locked up drunks and signed warrants.

But whenever the Redbands came to town, he measured every move against the life of a son he could not see, and the whole town had watched him do it.

Lucinda swallowed.

The heat pressed her damp hair against her cheek.

“I saw Jamie Greaves,” she said.

The street changed.

You could feel it change.

A horse stamped somewhere near the livery.

The sheriff took one step down from his porch, and then he stopped.

That stop told on him.

It told on the whole town.

Scarrow’s grin widened.

“Where’d you see him, Lucinda?”

“At the Eleventh Hour mine,” she said.

“Two nights ago. Alive.”

A sound went along the boardwalks, not a cry, not a gasp, something lower: a whole town remembering what it had decided not to ask.

The Eleventh Hour had been shut since the winter of ’76, after its timbers gave way and buried three men in the lower drift.

Nobody went up there anymore.

Nobody except Stroebel’s wagons, at night, with canvas tied down over their loads.

“Now here’s what’s going to happen,” Scarrow said pleasantly.

“You’re going to tell this street you were mistaken. You were tired, and it was dark, and you saw some drifter’s boy. And you’re going to tell me where you put the paper you picked up off the road. Then we’ll cut you down, and everybody goes home to dinner.”

Lucinda looked down at him from the post.

Her voice shook.

It did not break.

There is a difference.

“I saw him. I’m not taking it back.”

Scarrow’s face went hard and flat.

He shook out the long whip behind him in the dust, and drew his arm back over his shoulder, slow, so the town could watch him do it, so that every man on every porch could see exactly what was coming and know that none of them was going to stop it.

The whip lifted.

And the stranger in the green poncho left his chestnut at the rail and walked out into the middle of Stockade Street.

He was a lean, weathered man in his late fifties, with a short brown beard going gray and pale eyes squinted nearly shut against the glare.

He wore a black flat-brimmed hat stained dark around the band with old sweat.

The poncho hung to his hips, heavy wool woven in green and black and white, zigzags and diamonds, with a long white fringe that swung as he walked, much too warm for July.

At his right hip, under the edge of it, showed a worn gun belt and one holstered revolver with a plain walnut grip worn smooth.

His spurs gave a soft ring with every step.

The dust shifted around his boots.

The people on the boardwalks did not move, but somehow the whole street seemed to make room for him.

He stopped twenty feet from the post.

He looked up at the woman once.

Then he looked at the rope on her wrists, and at the whips and the coiled rope below her, and at Brodie Scarrow’s raised arm.

“Untie her.”

—

## The Whip Handle

He did not raise his voice.

He did not need to.

Two plain words, and the whole street heard them.

Scarrow blinked.

Then he laughed, and two of his men laughed with him, the way fools laugh when they cannot read weather.

“Old man,” Scarrow said, “you’re standing in a place that’ll get you hurt.”

Up on the post, Lucinda twisted her head to see the stranger.

There were three whips and a rope between them, and she could not bear to watch another person bleed on her account.

“Mister, walk away. They’ll whip you too.”

The stranger looked up at her.

For a moment something moved behind his squinting pale eyes, something old and heavy.

“I waited once. I’m done waiting.”

From his porch, Sheriff Greaves called out, hoarse.

“Stranger, step back. You don’t know what this is.”

The stranger did not turn his head.

“I’ve seen it before.”

The sheriff closed his mouth.

A man who has seen shame in his own mirror knows it when he sees it in another man’s face.

Lucinda Penhallow looked down at the old man in the street, and something in her chin came up.

“Then you’d better be quick, old man.”

Cruel men depend on timing, and once a crowd starts wondering, the spell gets thin.

He swung around to face the stranger with the whip still raised over his shoulder.

“You got a name?”

“Not one you need.”

“Men with no names generally end up in shallow ground.”

“Then save yourself the shoveling,” the stranger said.

“Cut the rope.”

“In this town,” Scarrow said, “Leopold Stroebel decides who gets cut down and who doesn’t.”

The stranger glanced once toward the sheriff’s porch.

Then he looked back at Scarrow.

“No. He just taught you all to believe it.”

Scarrow’s arm came forward.

He was not aiming at the woman now.

He was aiming at the old man’s face, and the twelve feet of braided rawhide came whistling out over his head like a snake uncoiling.

The stranger’s revolver came out of the holster in one smooth, unhurried motion and fired once.

The bullet struck the whip six inches below Scarrow’s fist, where the braided lash met the hickory handle, and cut it through.

The long lash went sailing off over the street and fell dead in the dust a dozen yards away.

Scarrow stood holding a stub of wood with nothing on the end of it.

In the same heartbeat, the youngest of the Redbands went for his pistol.

His name was Pip Lassiter, he was twenty years old, and he had a thin mustache and worse judgment, and he drew first.

Not well.

Not fast.

Just first.

The stranger’s second shot went into the dirt an inch in front of the boy’s boots and threw a spray of hot dust across his knees.

Pip Lassiter yelped and jumped back, and the pistol jumped out of his hand and skidded under the post.

Scarrow dropped the whip stub and grabbed for his own gun.

A third shot cracked, and it did not come from the stranger.

It came from the sheriff’s porch.

Lazarus Greaves had drawn at last, and his bullet struck the signpost a foot from Scarrow’s head and threw a shower of pine splinters across his face.

Scarrow flinched and turned his head, and that half turn was all the stranger needed.

He stepped in and rapped the barrel of his revolver across the back of Scarrow’s gun hand, and the pistol fell, and Scarrow went down on one knee in the dust, stunned and furious and not a scratch on him.

Now the whole street knew the truth.

The sheriff had moved.

Not far.

But enough.

The other two Redbands stood very still with their whips hanging from their hands and looked at one another.

The stranger kept his revolver low, pointed at nothing in particular.

Then he looked down at the two whip men.

“Lower those whips. Nobody touches her today.”

The whips went down into the dust.

He looked at Pip Lassiter, who was standing with his hands up and his mouth open.

“You carry a knife, son?”

The boy nodded.

“Use it on that rope. Gently.”

Pip Lassiter climbed onto the lower arm of the post beside her and sawed through the rope on her right wrist, then her left, then climbed down and cut her boots free.

When the last rope parted, Lucinda’s knees gave out, and the stranger holstered his gun and caught her under the elbow before she could fall.

He held her firm, but not close.

There is a difference.

“Can you walk?”

“I can be stubborn,” she said, breathing hard.

“If that helps.”

“It usually does.”

—

## Two Years of Paper

Odile Spurlock came out through the batwing doors of the Lamplighter Saloon with a shotgun under one arm.

She was a broad, gray-haired widow from New Orleans who had buried a husband and two brothers and every soft opinion she had ever held about men on the frontier.

People said Leopold Stroebel left the Lamplighter alone out of respect.

He left it alone because Odile had told him once, in front of half the town, that he could collect her saloon one board at a time after she was finished putting holes in him.

“Bring her inside,” she said, “before every fool in town decides to get brave in the wrong direction.”

Behind them, Brodie Scarrow was getting up off his knee with his pride hurting worse than anything else.

He spat in the dust.

“This isn’t done.”

The stranger did not turn around.

Odile did.

“Then bring better manners when you come back.”

Inside, the Lamplighter smelled of coffee and lamp oil and old sawdust.

Odile swept a table clear with one arm, and the stranger set Lucinda down in a chair.

Her hands began to shake the moment she sat.

Courage holds a person upright in public.

It collects its bill later, in private.

Lazarus Greaves came in a minute after.

He took his hat off before he stepped all the way inside, and it made the room hate him a little less.

Lucinda looked at him for a long moment.

“You knew Stroebel used the Eleventh Hour. You suspected your own son was up there.”

The sheriff’s face went hard, not with anger, but with the effort it took not to break in front of them.

“I suspected a great many things.”

From the window, without turning, the stranger said, “And wrote them down.”

Greaves looked at him sharply.

It was the first time the two men truly measured each other.

“Yes. I’ve got a notebook. Two years of it.”

That landed in the room.

You could feel it land.

Lucinda set down her cup very carefully.

“Then why did I have to be tied up in the street?”

The sheriff took that one standing up.

“Because they have my boy.”

Lucinda’s face changed.

It did not soften exactly.

It became more human.

“Then listen to me. He’s alive. He’s thin, and he was coughing, but he was standing. I carried a message up the north road two nights ago because Uncle Ishmael was too sick to ride, and I saw lanterns at the Eleventh Hour. Six or seven of Stroebel’s men loading crates under canvas. They had Jamie reading names off a paper by the lantern light. And one of them dropped this.”

She drew a folded page out of the torn seam of her sleeve, damp with sweat, and spread it on the table.

It was a freight list.

Rifles.

Cartridges.

Blasting powder.

Every case of it was government freight, signed out of Sidney for the new Army post going up on Bear Butte Creek, and turned around at the Eleventh Hour and sold to whoever paid best.

At the bottom were three marks: a rail buyer out of Cheyenne, a claim company in Deadwood, and a deputy sheriff from Lawrence County named Elmo Rasch.

“There was another page,” Lucinda said.

“Jamie still has it. That’s the one with the names.”

Then a horse pounded past outside, and something struck the saloon door with a sharp wooden thud.

A knife was stuck in the door, pinning a folded note to the wood.

The stranger pulled it free, and Odile read it aloud.

“Five o’clock. Stockade Street. Bring the woman and the paper. Come alone, Sheriff, unless you’re done wanting a son.”

The clock behind the bar said a quarter past two.

—

## The Badge and the Warrant

“I have to go alone,” Greaves said.

“That’s what Stroebel wants,” said the stranger.

“And he’ll keep your boy after he has her and the paper both. Men like that don’t let go of leverage because a frightened father asks nicely.”

The sheriff looked at Lucinda.

“I won’t trade you.”

Her eyes went to the window, where the empty signpost still stood in the street with the cut ropes hanging from it.

“You already did,” she said.

“A little.”

The sheriff took that one too.

“What I need is a warrant from Deadwood,” he said.

“What you need is a plan.”

“I’m the sheriff.”

The stranger looked at him.

“Then start acting like one.”

The words were hard, maybe too hard, and the stranger’s face changed a little after he said them.

In the sheriff’s office, Greaves took a brown leather notebook out of his bottom drawer and set it on the desk.

The stranger turned the pages slowly.

Names.

Dates.

Freight bills.

A claim transfer signed by a widow who could not write.

Wagons seen on the north road after midnight.

“You built a case,” the stranger said.

“I built an excuse. Every time I wrote another name, I told myself I was getting closer. I was just still wearing the badge.”

The stranger tucked the notebook under his arm.

“That’s evidence,” Greaves said.

“It doesn’t leave my office.”

“It’s a coffin,” said the stranger, “unless somebody outside Custer City knows it exists.”

Then, more quietly, looking at the empty cell: “I wore a badge once. Deputy United States marshal. Kansas and Nebraska, fourteen years. I had a daughter. Libby. She was nineteen. Some men took her off a train platform in ’71, and I knew where they had her by sundown. I sat in a hotel waiting on a federal warrant, because the law said I had to.”

He touched the notebook.

“The warrant came clean. The funeral came cleaner.”

That was all he said.

Some pasts do not need a full confession.

Sometimes one sentence carries the bones.

—

## Short Words

Ishmael Penhallow, the telegraph operator, was a thin, nervous man who drank when he was frightened, and Custer City had kept him frightened for a year.

When he saw his niece come through the door, his eyes filled up.

“Uncle Ishmael. Can you raise Deadwood?”

“Not all of that,” he said, looking at the notebook.

“Send names,” the stranger said.

“Stroebel’s wax mark. The Eleventh Hour. The government powder. Jamie Greaves alive. Ask for Deputy Marshal Wakefield.”

Ishmael sat down at the key.

His hands shook.

Lucinda put her hand over his.

“Short words,” she said.

The key began to click, slow at first, then steadier.

After a long minute the wire answered.

*Wakefield on Rapid Creek. Hold evidence. Avoid open fight. North road watched.*

At four o’clock, Stroebel sent another message.

A boy on a mule galloped down Stockade Street, threw something onto the sheriff’s step, and was gone.

It was Jamie’s folding knife, the little one with the bone handle that had been his grandfather’s.

Under a loosened strip of bone was a scrap of paper, folded small.

The writing was crooked, done in bad light.

*Pa, don’t trade her.*

Four words.

They were enough to knock the breath out of a grown man.

Lazarus Greaves folded the scrap into his vest pocket.

When he looked up, something in him had changed.

It was not healed.

It was decided.

He buckled on his gun belt, checked his revolver, and came out to stand in front of Lucinda Penhallow.

“I’m sorry,” he said.

She nodded.

It was not forgiveness.

Not yet.

But it was something.

—

## Five O’Clock

The plan they made was not clever enough for a dime novel, and that was why it had a chance.

The sheriff would meet Stroebel in the street.

Lucinda would stand by the telegraph office, because she was the witness and because she flatly refused to hide.

Odile would keep the saloon doors open and the shotgun handy.

Lars Hovde, the blacksmith, rolled two freight wagons across the side street.

A laundress set two full buckets of water on the boardwalk by the alley and left them there.

Every one of those little things said the same thing.

*Not again.*

At ten minutes to five, Lucinda walked out alone to the signpost.

One cut rope still hung from the upper arm.

She reached up and untied the knot with her own hands and let it fall in the dirt.

“Was that necessary?” the stranger asked, when she came back.

“For me,” she said.

He nodded.

“Then it was necessary.”

At five, Leopold Stroebel rode in from the north on a tall black horse that looked better fed than half the town.

He was a heavy, clean-shaven man with a red silk sash across his vest and a pearl-handled revolver he probably loved more than any living thing.

Eight men rode behind him: Brodie Scarrow with a new whip on his saddle, and Deputy Elmo Rasch with a tin star pinned crooked on his vest.

Stroebel stopped thirty yards from the sheriff.

“You’re getting a warrant,” said Lazarus Greaves, “when Marshal Wakefield gets here.”

Stroebel laughed softly.

“Wakefield is riding into a canyon full of my men.”

His eyes moved to Lucinda.

“You should have stayed grateful, Miss Penhallow.”

Lucinda lifted her chin.

“I was never grateful for being afraid.”

“My boy asked me not to trade her,” said the sheriff.

For just a moment, Stroebel’s face changed.

Then he gave a small nod toward the old assay office balcony.

A rifle cracked from up there.

The bullet struck the doorframe of the telegraph office a foot from Lucinda’s shoulder and threw pine chips across her sleeve, and Odile dragged her down behind the steps.

The street broke open.

Horses reared.

Men shouted.

The stranger fired once at the balcony.

Not at the rifleman.

At the fat rain barrel beside him.

Water burst out across the boards, the rifleman’s feet went out from under him on the wet planks, and his rifle clattered down into the street.

A rider spurred toward the telegraph office with his pistol up, and Ludwig Oberholtzer swung a broom handle into his knee as he passed.

The man fired one shot into the sky and fell headlong into the laundress’s buckets.

He came up soaked and blinking, and he was out of the fight.

Not every victory is elegant.

Some of them are wet.

Elmo Rasch spurred for the telegraph office.

The stranger stepped into the open street and fired at the deputy’s saddle, and the bullet cut the latigo strap through.

The saddle turned, and Rasch went down into the dust in a heap, and Ishmael Penhallow ran out and kicked the deputy’s pistol away under the boardwalk, and then stared down at his own boot as if he could not believe what it had done.

Then Leopold Stroebel stopped performing and started trying to survive.

He slid off the black horse with his pearl-handled revolver and moved through the dust toward the only cover in the street, the old signpost.

Lazarus Greaves stepped out to see whether Lucinda had been hit, and Stroebel came around the far side of the post with his revolver coming up.

Lucinda saw him first.

She came up from behind the steps, snatched the cut rope out of the dust, and flung it hard and low across the ground.

It tangled around his boots.

It made him look down for half a second.

Half a second was enough.

The stranger fired.

The bullet struck the pearl-handled revolver just in front of the trigger guard and tore it out of Stroebel’s hand and sent it spinning away into the street.

Stroebel stumbled back against the signpost, staring at his empty hand.

There was not a mark on it.

The street went still in pieces.

First the shooting stopped, then the shouting, then the horses, then the town.

Lazarus Greaves walked toward Stroebel with his revolver in his hand.

Everyone on Stockade Street knew he had imagined this moment for three months.

Stroebel knew it too, and he smiled.

“Go on, Sheriff. Your boy’s dead either way the minute you put me in irons.”

The sheriff’s gun hand trembled.

Nobody spoke.

It was not their choice to make.

A man cannot be carried across his own line.

He has to step over it himself.

Lazarus Greaves lowered his revolver and took the irons off his belt.

“Leopold Stroebel, you’re under arrest. Kidnapping. Extortion. Theft of government property.”

Stroebel spat in the dust.

“You think that badge makes this clean?”

The sheriff snapped the irons shut.

“No. It just makes it mine to answer for.”

Nobody cheered.

Custer City had not won a horse race.

It had survived a sickness long enough to say its name out loud.

—

## The Man in the Green Poncho

Deputy United States Marshal Everard Wakefield came down the north road at dusk with six riders on blown horses.

They had gone around the canyon by the old pack trail, the long way, because a telegraph operator had sent a warning in short words.

Wakefield read three pages of the sheriff’s notebook, and his mouth tightened.

“This’ll do.”

“There’s a second page,” said Lazarus Greaves.

“My son has it. Up at the Eleventh Hour.”

Wakefield took off his hat, and the whole street went cold.

“We went to the mine first, Sheriff. We found your boy.”

The sheriff’s voice came out very small, too small for a lawman, just right for a father.

“Alive?”

“Alive. Thin as a rail and mad as a hornet. He had two other prisoners up there, and when the timbers started groaning in the lower drift last week, he got them both up the ladder and kept them there. And he had this inside his shirt.”

He held out a folded page stained with mine dust.

Names.

Payments.

Routes.

Elmo Rasch’s signature.

Enough to bury Leopold Stroebel in any court that still had a pulse.

But Lazarus Greaves was already walking past him toward the back of the column, and then he was running, and nobody in Custer City ever said a word to him afterward about a sheriff running in public.

Wakefield’s eyes went past him and found the old man in the green poncho by the livery, with a tin cup of coffee in his hand, already looking as if he meant to be gone before anyone asked him to explain himself.

“I’ll be damned,” the marshal said softly.

“Ozias Treadwell.”

Stroebel, sitting on the jail step in irons, looked up.

“Who?”

“You never read the dime books, Stroebel? They had a fellow in them who rode for the federal courts in Kansas and Nebraska for fourteen years and never once let a newspaperman print his name. Wore a green wool poncho and never shot a man he could bring in alive. They called him the nameless gunslinger. I always figured he was made up. Then I joined the service at Leavenworth, and the man who taught me to serve a warrant was standing in front of me in that same poncho.”

Leopold Stroebel looked at the old man by the livery for a long time.

And for the first time since he had come to the Black Hills, something in his face looked afraid.

—

## A Signpost Pointing Nowhere

By midnight, the signpost was gone.

Lars Hovde and two miners took it down one bolt at a time.

They did not burn it.

Odile said burning was too quick.

But before they started, Lucinda walked out into the lantern light, took the blacksmith’s bar, and pulled the first spike out of the upper arm herself, with the whole street watching.

Ozias Treadwell sat outside the livery with a cup of Odile’s coffee.

Lucinda came and stood beside him.

“You’re leaving,” she said.

It was not a question.

“Morning. Horse needs rest.”

“And you?”

He almost smiled.

“I’m less sensible than the horse.”

“You didn’t have to stop today.”

He looked into his coffee a long time.

“Once, I didn’t. My daughter was caught in a town that loved procedure more than people.”

“And saving me fixes that?”

“No,” he said, quick and honest.

“It just keeps that from being the last true thing about me.”

She nodded slowly.

There are some wounds no stranger should try to mend with pretty words.

—

## In Her Own Name

The federal court sat in Deadwood that October, in a long room over a hardware store, with every bench full and men standing down the stairs into the street.

Lucinda Penhallow wore a plain dark dress, her hair pinned up properly.

Leopold Stroebel sat twenty feet away in a new suit and watched her the whole time, the way he had watched the town for two years, waiting for her to be afraid.

His lawyer, a smooth man from Cheyenne, walked up and down in front of her for most of an hour.

It was dark that night on the north road, wasn’t it, Miss Penhallow?

And you were tired.

And frightened.

Isn’t it possible you were mistaken?

Lucinda looked past him at Leopold Stroebel until Stroebel was the one who looked away.

Then she leaned forward in the chair, and her voice carried down the stairs.

“I saw him. I’m not taking it back. I said it tied to a post in the middle of Stockade Street, and I’ll say it here in my own name. I was frightened. I still saw him.”

The lawyer sat down.

Jamie Greaves testified the next morning and laid the page from the Eleventh Hour on the clerk’s table.

Lazarus Greaves read his notebook into the record, every page, and did not spare himself on a single one.

Leopold Stroebel was sentenced to fifteen years in the house of correction at Detroit, where Dakota Territory sent its federal prisoners in those years.

Brodie Scarrow got five.

Elmo Rasch got four and lost his star.

Pip Lassiter, who had cut the rope and told the truth about it, got ninety days and a lecture from the bench he said was worse than the ninety days.

Ozias Treadwell was not there.

He had ridden north on the morning after the shooting, past the bare place in the middle of Stockade Street where the post had stood, the green poncho bright for a while in the early sun, then smaller, then only another shape in the dust.

But every July after that, on the anniversary of the day the Redbands tied a woman to a signpost pointing nowhere, Lucinda Penhallow walked out into the middle of Stockade Street at noon and stood on the bare spot where it had been, with her hands free at her sides.

And nobody in Custer City ever asked her why.

You Might Also Enjoy