Undefeated Singing Champion Picked a Man — Didn’t Know It Was Elvis Presley, Everyone Booed Elvis
The air inside the lounge was thick with cigarette smoke and the smell of spilled bourbon. August 1974, 2:30 in the morning, downtown Las Vegas, Fremont Street. Not the glittering strip with its fountains and its headliners, but the old part of town where the casinos were older and the carpets were thinner and the people at the tables had usually lost more than they could afford. And in a small dark lounge at the back of one of those old casinos, under a single hot spotlight, stood Lorraine Dupreee, the voice of Fremont Street. 70 weeks in a row, she had won the Thursday night song battle in that room.
70 straight. Nobody had come close. And on that particular night, as she always did, she stepped down off the little stage with the microphone in her hand and walked out among the tables to pick her next challenger from the crowd. She stopped in front of a man in the corner, a heavy-set man in a rumpled jacket with a thick dark beard, a hat pulled low, and big tinted glasses, sitting with two friends, not drinking, just watching. She pointed straight at him. “You, come on up.” And the room started to laugh. When he got to the stage and she asked his name, he said, quietly, “Aaron.” Nobody reacted.
The name meant nothing to anybody. And when he told the piano player what he wanted to sing, the crowd started booing him. What happened over the next 10 minutes, nobody in that room ever forgot. Because the man in the beard was Elvis Presley, and not one person in that lounge, not even the woman who picked him, knew it. To understand how the most famous man in the world ended up sitting in the corner of a downtown Las Vegas lounge at 2:30 in the morning in a fake beard, you have to understand what his life in Las Vegas had become by the summer of 1974.
Elvis had been coming back to Vegas twice a year since the summer of 1969. Every time, it was the same. 4 weeks, sometimes more, at the Las Vegas Hilton, the biggest hotel in the city. Two shows a night, seven nights a week. A dinner show at 8:00 and a midnight show that often didn’t end until well after 1:00 in the morning. He lived on the 30th floor of the Hilton in a penthouse suite. And when he wasn’t on stage, he almost never left it. He couldn’t. If he walked through the casino, it would take 40 security guards to get him back to the elevator.
If he tried to go to a restaurant, the restaurant would fill up within minutes. He hadn’t walked down a city street like an ordinary person in almost 20 years. He was 39 years old that summer. He was tired. And he was bored in the specific, crushing way that only very famous people get bored. Every night, the same suite, the same people, the same walls. He said once to one of his friends that the penthouse at the Hilton was the most expensive jail cell in America. So, every once in a while, he played a game. It started as a joke years earlier in Hollywood.
The costume department at one of the studios had made him a disguise as a gag. A fake beard, a fake mustache, a pair of thick glasses. He wore it once to see if he could get through a hardware store without being recognized, and he made it all the way to the register before the girl behind the counter screamed. After that, he kept the beard in a little case. And every now and then, when the walls started closing in, he’d take it out. Most of the time it didn’t work. Somebody always recognized the eyes, or the voice, or the walk. But every once in a while, it did.
And those few hours being nobody, walking around like any other man, were some of the happiest hours of his life. On Thursday night, August 22nd, 1974, he finished the midnight show at the Hilton around 20 past 1. He came off stage soaked in sweat, the way he always did. And while he was sitting in the dressing room with a towel over his head, his old friend Red West made the mistake of saying something. Red had known Elvis since high school in Memphis. He was one of the very few people alive who would say no to him, and who would tease him without asking permission first.
And that night, half joking, Red said, “You know what, E? I bet you couldn’t last 1 hour anywhere in this town without somebody knowing who you are. Not 1 hour. Not even with that beard on. I’ll put a $100 on it.” Elvis took the towel off his head. He looked at Red for a long moment, and then he grinned the grin that everybody around him knew meant trouble. “Get the car,” he said. Red said later that he regretted it before the words were even all the way out of his mouth. But a bet was a bet, and 20 minutes later, a plain brown sedan with Red West at the wheel, Charlie Hodge in the passenger seat, and a heavy-set bearded man in a rumpled tweed jacket and a battered fedora in the back, slipped out of the Hilton service garage and headed downtown.
They didn’t go to the Strip. That was the point. The Strip was where people went to see stars. Downtown was where people went to forget about them. Fremont Street in 1974 was the old Las Vegas, the original one. Neon arches and cowboy signs and casinos that had been there since before the war. The tourists from Ohio stayed on the strip. Downtown belonged to the locals, the old gamblers, the off-duty dealers and cocktail waitresses and cab drivers, the people who actually lived in that city and made it run. Red parked a block off Fremont. They walked the last part.
Elvis kept his head down, his hat low, his hands in his pockets. They walked right past a couple of drunks and a young couple arguing on a corner and an old man selling newspapers and nobody looked twice. Charlie said later that he watched Elvis’s shoulders loosen up with every step, like a man taking off a heavy coat. They ducked into one of the smaller casinos, old carpet, low ceilings, the rattle of slot machines and the clink of chips. And at the back of the casino floor, past the craps tables, there was a doorway with a little hand-lettered sign over it.
The Starlight Lounge, Thursday night song battle, 2:00 a.m. Elvis stopped and read it and then he looked at Red and said, “What’s that?” Red shrugged, “I don’t know, some kind of singing contest.” And Elvis Presley said, with a look on his face that Charlie Hodge would remember for the rest of his life, “Well now, let’s go in.” The Starlight Lounge held maybe 120 people if you didn’t care about fire codes and on Thursday nights, nobody did. It was a long low room with red vinyl booths along the walls, little round tables crowded together in the middle and a bar running down one side under a mirror so old the silver was coming off the back of it.
At the far end was a stage about the size of a pickup truck bed with an upright piano, a drum kit, and a stand-up bass leaning in the corner. And on the wall beside the stage, painted bright red and white, hung the thing that made Thursday nights at the Starlight famous all over downtown, the applause meter. It was a big homemade dial, the kind they used on old television talent shows, a wooden half circle with a needle in the middle that swung from zero all the way up to a red zone at the top marked with the word “Wow.” A microphone hidden over the stage picked up the noise from the crowd, and the louder they cheered, the higher the needle went.
Every Thursday, two singers went head to head. Each one sang one song, and whoever pushed the needle higher won the night and a hundred dollars cash and the right to come back the next Thursday and do it all again. For 70 straight weeks, the same person had won. Her name was Lorraine Dupreee. She was 40 years old. She’d grown up in a little town outside Lake Charles, Louisiana, the daughter of a Baptist preacher, singing in her father’s church from the time she was four. She’d come to Las Vegas in 1959 with a cardboard suitcase and a voice that could rattle a stained glass window.
And for 15 years, she’d sung in every lounge on Fremont Street that would hire her. She’d opened for comedians nobody remembered. She’d sung behind strippers. She’d sung for drunks who talked through every song. She’d been told by three different record men over the years that she was going to be a star, and every one of them had stopped returning her calls. But on Thursday nights at the Starlight, she was a queen. People came from all over downtown to hear her. Dealers came in on their breaks. Cocktail waitresses from the Golden Nugget brought their boyfriends.
Old men who’d been coming to that room since the ’50s sat at the same table every week. And when she walked out under that spotlight, they stood up. They called her the voice of Fremont Street. And every Thursday for 70 weeks, she’d sent that needle into the red. Now, here’s the part that matters. For the first few months of her streak, the Starlight’s manager had picked her challengers, local singers, lounge acts, hopeful kids, and she’d beaten every one of them. But then, people started talking. They said the contest was fixed. They said the manager was picking easy marks to keep his star happy.
They said Lorraine Dupreee only ever beat nobodies. That talk hurt her more than anything else ever had in that town, because she knew what she could do, and she’d waited 15 years for somebody to notice. So, she changed the rules. “From now on,” she said, “she’d pick her own challengers, out of the crowd, at random, any man or woman in the room, anybody at all. That way, nobody could say it was fixed.” And it had worked. Every week, she’d walk out among the tables with the microphone, look around the room, and point at somebody. A tourist, a cab driver, a college kid, a retired school teacher.
Sometimes they were good. Once in a while, they were really good. And every single time, Lorraine Dupreee had beaten them. 70 weeks, 70 wins. People said there wasn’t a singer in Las Vegas who could beat her in that room. And she’d started, in her quieter moments, to believe it. That was the room Elvis Presley walked into at a quarter to 2:00 on that Friday morning with a fake beard on his face and a hundred-dollar bet riding on whether anyone would notice. Nobody did. The three of them found a little table in the back corner, as far from the stage as they could get.
A cocktail waitress came by chewing gum and asked what they were drinking. Red and Charlie ordered beers. Elvis ordered a glass of water. The waitress looked at him like he was out of his mind sitting in a bar at 2:00 in the morning ordering water. And Charlie said she looked right into his face from about 3 ft away, rolled her eyes, and walked off. And Elvis turned to Red with the biggest, most delighted grin under that beard and whispered, “She didn’t know me, Red. She looked right at me and she didn’t know me.” “Hours not up yet,” Red said. At 2:00 sharp, the house lights went down and a little man in a shiny blue suit climbed onto the stage.
This was the manager, a fast-talking New Yorker named Sal Benedetto, who’d been running the Starlight since the Kennedy administration. He tapped the microphone. “Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Thursday night song battle at the Starlight Lounge. Some of you are new. Some of you have been coming here so long you’ve got your names carved on the tables. Either way, you know why you’re here. 70 weeks in a row, ladies and gentlemen, 70 weeks undefeated. Please welcome back your champion, the voice of Fremont Street, Miss Lorraine Dupreee.” The room exploded.
People were on their feet before she even came out. The old men at the front table were stomping on the floor. The cocktail waitresses were whistling, and Lorraine Dupreee walked out into that spotlight in a long gold sequined gown that caught every bit of light in the room, with her hair piled high and her chin up. And she looked out over that crowd like she owned every inch of it, which on Thursday nights she did. Elvis sat up in his chair. Charlie said he watched Elvis’s whole face change. Not the way it changed when he saw a pretty woman, the way it changed when he heard a voice he knew was going to be good before it had sung a note.
He leaned forward with his elbows on the little table and he didn’t move again for a long time. Lorraine took the microphone off the stand. She thanked everybody for coming. She made a joke about Sal’s suit that got a big laugh. And then she said the words that the regulars in that room knew by heart. The words she said every single week. “All right now, you know how this works. I don’t pick the easy ones. I don’t let Sal pick. I walk out there and I choose. Anybody in this room. And whoever I choose gets one song to take my crown.” She smiled. “Nobody has yet.” The crowd roared and Lorraine Dupreee stepped down off that little stage, microphone in her hand, and started walking slowly between the tables, looking at faces.
It was the same thing that happened every Thursday. People leaned back in their chairs. They looked down at their drinks. They studied the ceiling. A big construction worker at one of the middle tables actually pulled his baseball cap down over his eyes and pretended to be asleep and the people around him laughed. Nobody wanted to be picked. Being picked by Lorraine Dupreee meant standing up in front of a hundred people and getting beaten in front of all of them. She walked slowly. She took her time. She stopped at a table of young sailors on leave, looked them over, shook her head, and kept going.
And the sailors cheered with relief. She passed a woman in a nurse’s uniform. She passed a pair of old card dealers. She walked all the way to the back of the room, toward the corner where three men were sitting at a little table, two with beers and one with a glass of water, and she stopped. Lorraine said years later that she couldn’t explain it. There was nothing special about him. Heavy set, a scraggly dark beard, a hat that looked like it had been sat on, big tinted glasses, a tweed jacket that didn’t fit right. He looked like a traveling salesman who’d lost his commission at the craps table, but he was the only person in that whole room who wasn’t looking away from her.
He was looking right at her, calm, interested, not afraid, and not drunk, either, which on Fremont Street at 2:00 in the morning made him close to a miracle. She raised her hand and pointed straight at him. “You,” she said, “Mr. Water, come on up.” The whole room turned around to look, and when they saw who she’d picked, they started to laugh. It wasn’t mean at first. It was the laugh a crowd gives when they think they’re about to see somebody get embarrassed. Somebody called out, “Lorraine, he’s going to faint.” Somebody else yelled, “Get that man a real drink first.” A cocktail waitress laughed so hard she had to set down her tray.
The bearded man didn’t move. Red West leaned over and whispered urgently, “E, you don’t have to do this. Let’s just go. The bet’s off. You win. I’ll pay you.” And under the beard, Elvis whispered back, “It’s fine, Red.” “It is not fine. If you open your mouth up there, every person in this room is going to know.” “Then I won’t sing like me,” Elvis said, and he stood up. The laughter got louder when he stood because standing up, he looked even more out of place. The jacket was too tight across the shoulders. The hat was too small. He walked through those tables slowly with his head down, and people actually leaned out of his way like he might be contagious.
Somebody said, “Look at him. He’s shaking.” He wasn’t shaking, but he was walking the way he walked when he didn’t want anybody looking at his face. And from the back, it looked a lot like a nervous man. He climbed up onto the little stage. Lorraine handed him the microphone with a big, warm, slightly pitying smile. Not unkind. She’d done this 70 times. She knew what it felt like to be the one standing there. “What’s your name, honey?” He leaned into the microphone. His voice came out low and soft, and he pushed it down a little further than it naturally went, into his chest.
A little rougher, a little older. “Aaron,” he said. Nobody reacted. Of course they didn’t. It was his middle name. It was printed on his birth certificate in Tupelo, Mississippi. But nobody in that room had ever heard Elvis Presley called anything but Elvis. To 100 people at 2:00 in the morning, Aaron was just a name, a nobody’s name. “Well, Aaron,” Lorraine said, “where you from?” “Mississippi, ma’am.” “Mississippi!” She turned to the crowd. “We got a country boy, y’all!” A few people whooped. “And what do you sing, Aaron from Mississippi?” “Gospel, mostly,” he said. “Church music.” That got the biggest laugh of the night.
Gospel? In the Starlight Lounge? At 2:00 in the morning? Sal Benedetto, standing by the bar, actually put his hand over his face. Somebody yelled, “Hallelujah, brother!” Somebody else shouted, “Pass the collection plate!” And the old men at the front table, Lorraine’s most loyal fans, shook their heads like this was the saddest thing they’d ever seen. Lorraine didn’t laugh. She was a preacher’s daughter. She looked at him a little more carefully. Then she said, “Well, all right. I’ll go first.” She handed the band a nod, and Lorraine Dupreee sang “St.
Louis Blues.” It was W.C. Handy’s old song, 60 years old by then, a song that every great blues singer from Bessie Smith on had taken a crack at. And she tore that room apart with it. She started it low and slow, almost lazy, leaning on the piano, and then built it and built it until the whole room was clapping along. And by the last verse, she was walking out among the tables again, singing right into people’s faces. And the old men at the front were on their feet. And when she hit the final note and held it, the sound of that crowd sent the needle on the applause meter swinging straight up into the red, past the top line, into wow. “It was,” the regulars said afterward, “one of the best she’d ever done.” She came back to the stage breathing hard, glowing, and handed the microphone to the bearded man.
She leaned close and said, so only he could hear, “Your turn, sugar. Don’t be scared. They’ll be nice to you. Probably.” He took the microphone. He walked over to the old upright piano, leaned down, and said something quietly to the piano player, an old man named Leon who’d been playing that room for 20 years. Leon looked up at him with a puzzled frown and said, “You sure?” And the bearded man nodded. Leon shrugged and played a few slow, quiet chords. And a few people in the front recognized it. It was an old spiritual, older than anyone in the room, “Sometimes I feel like a motherless child.” That’s when the booing started.
Not everybody, but enough. The young sailors started it. Then a few people at the bar picked it up. “Boo! This ain’t church! Come on, man, sing something fun. Sit down, preacher. Somebody threw a crumpled napkin at the stage. The old men at the front table just sat there with their arms folded, shaking their heads. A spiritual, a slow, sad, old church song sung by a nervous fat man with a fake-looking beard in a casino lounge against the voice of Fremont Street after she just sung St. Louis Blues into the red. It was the worst choice anybody had ever made in that room.
Red West said he put his head down on the table. The bearded man didn’t react to the booing at all. He didn’t look at the crowd. He didn’t look at Lorraine. He reached up and set the microphone back on its stand, then stepped back from it. One step, two steps, until he was standing several feet away from it at the very edge of the little stage, too far for it to pick up much of anything, and he closed his eyes, and he started to sing. He didn’t sing like Elvis Presley. That’s the thing everyone who was there agreed on years later after they found out.
If he’d sung like Elvis, they’d have known in two notes, the sound, the phrasing, the little catch in the voice. The whole world knew it by heart. Instead, he sang the way he used to sing when he was a boy standing in the back of the little Assembly of God church in East Tupelo before anybody had ever told him he was special. Low, plain, no tricks, no growl, no vibrato. He kept his voice down in his chest, deeper and quieter than any record he’d ever made, the way old men sing in country churches when they’re singing for God and not for anybody sitting in the pews.
Sometimes I feel like a motherless child. The first line was so soft that the people in the back couldn’t hear it over the booing, but the people in the front could. And one by one, they stopped. By the second line, the sailors had stopped. By the third, the people at the bar had turned around on their stools. By the end of the first verse, the Starlight Lounge, which had been roaring with booze and laughter 30 seconds before, had gone so quiet that you could hear the slot machines out on the casino floor through the doorway. He wasn’t using the microphone.
He didn’t need it. That room was small, and the voice coming out of him filled it the way water fills a glass. It wasn’t loud. It was just everywhere. And it was so sad. That’s what Lorraine said later. Not performed sad, real sad. Like a man who knew exactly what it felt like to be a long way from home, and who had lost the one person who would have known how to bring him back. A long way from home. A long way from home. Lorraine Dupreee was standing at the side of the stage where she’d stepped to give him room. She was a preacher’s daughter from Louisiana.
She’d been singing that spiritual since before she could read. And she said that somewhere in the middle of that first verse, she realized she was crying, and she didn’t know when she’d started. At the front table, one of the old men, a retired railroad worker named Clarence Hobbs, who had come to every one of Lorraine’s 70 Thursdays, took his hat off and held it against his chest. And then, the bearded man did something that nobody in that room expected. At the end of the verse, he opened his eyes, turned his head, and looked straight at Lorraine.
And he held out his hand. Not for the microphone, for her, inviting her in. She didn’t hesitate. She didn’t even think. She stepped across the stage, took his hand, and when he started the second verse, she came in under him. Harmony. The high part, soft and sweet. The part she’d sung a thousand times in her daddy’s church behind the deacons. And the two of them stood there in the middle of that little stage, holding hands, no microphone. A 40-year-old lounge singer in a gold sequined gown and a heavy-set stranger in a bad beard singing an old slave spiritual together in a casino at 2:30 in the morning.
And there wasn’t a single person in that room who could take their eyes off them. Leon, the old piano player, said he had to stop playing for a few bars because he couldn’t see the keys anymore. They sang it through to the end. On the very last line, the bearded man let his voice drop away entirely and let Lorraine finish it alone. One long pure note floating up over that room and then fading into nothing. For about 5 seconds, the Starlight Lounge was absolutely silent. And then the needle on the applause meter went off the scale. People weren’t just clapping, they were standing on their chairs.
The sailors who’d started the booing were whistling through their fingers. The cocktail waitress who’d rolled her eyes at the glass of water was crying into her serving tray. Clarence Hobbs, the old railroad man, was standing at the front table, still holding his hat against his chest, tears running into his collar. The noise was so loud that the needle swung past wow and slammed against the pin at the top of the dial and stayed there, buzzing. Sal Benedetto climbed up on the stage with his hands in the air, trying to quiet everybody down. It took him almost a full minute.
And then he said what he said every single week. All right. All right, folks. Now we got to pick A WINNER. WHEN I POINT, you make some noise. First, our challenger. Let’s hear it for Aaron from Mississippi. And the room exploded all over again. It was louder than it had been for Lorraine. Everybody in that room could hear it. The old men at the front table could hear it. Lorraine could hear it. For the first time in 70 weeks, there was no question. The needle was climbing and climbing. And the voice of Fremont Street was about to lose her crown to a nobody in a fake beard who’d sung a spiritual.
Lorraine said later that she stood there and felt it go. 70 weeks. 15 years in that town. The only thing she had that was all hers. She said she remembered thinking, well, at least it was a real one. At least it wasn’t a nobody. And she started to smile the way you smile when you lose something and decide to be gracious about it. And then the bearded man stepped forward. He took the microphone out of Sal Benedetto’s hand. He didn’t say a word into it. He just turned to Lorraine, took her hand again, and raised it straight up over her head the way a referee raises a fighter’s hand at the end of a championship bout.
And he held it there. And he pointed at her with his other hand. And he kept pointing and shaking his head and pointing at her until the crowd understood what he was telling them. Her. Not me. Her. The room got it all at once. And when Sal, stunned, said into the microphone, “And our champion, Miss Lorraine Dupreee,” the whole place came apart a third time, louder than both of the others put together. People were chanting her name. The needle slammed back up to the top of the dial, and stayed there. 71. The bearded man let go of her hand, gave a small, quick bow to the room, handed the microphone back to Sal, and stepped down off the stage.
He walked straight back through the tables to the corner, sat down next to Red West and Charlie Hodge, and picked up his glass of water like nothing had happened. Red stared at him. He said, very quietly, “What did you just do?” And Elvis said, “I lost, Red. Pay up.” Red started to laugh. He couldn’t help it. “You lost the contest,” he said. “I lost the contest,” Elvis agreed. “But it’s been an hour and 10 minutes, and not one person in this room knows who I am.” He held out his hand, palm up. “That’s a hundred dollars.” Red West dug into his pocket and paid him.
He said later it was the best hundred dollars he ever lost. They should have left right then. Charlie Hodge kept saying so. The longer they stayed, the bigger the chance somebody would figure it out. But Lorraine Dupreee had finished thanking the crowd, and she’d stepped down off the stage, and she was walking through the tables again, straight toward the corner. People were reaching out to touch her arm as she passed, congratulating her. She barely noticed. She was looking at the man in the beard. She stopped at their table. She looked down at him, and she said, “You let me win.” “No, ma’am,” he said, in that low, rough, disguised voice. “You won.” “Don’t you lie to me,” Lorraine said. “My daddy was a preacher.
I can smell a lie from across a church. That room was yours. You heard it. I heard it. Why’d you give it back?” He was quiet for a moment. Then he said, “Could we talk outside a minute?” They went out through the kitchen, past the dish washers, into the alley behind the casino. It was still close to 90° even at 3:00 in the morning. The neon from Fremont Street was spilling over the rooftops, pink and green and gold. Red and Charlie stood at the kitchen door, keeping watch. And in the alley, Lorraine Dupree folded her arms and waited. “I gave it back,” he said, “because it’s yours.
You earned every one of those 70 nights. I watched you. You walked into that room tonight and those people stood up for you before you sang a note, and you’d earned that, every bit of it. I didn’t earn anything tonight. I just got lucky with an old song.” “That wasn’t luck.” “Maybe not,” he said, “but you’ve been fighting for that crown in this town for 15 years. I could hear it in every note of that blues, and I’m not about to walk in off the street and take it from you for a hundred-dollar bet.” Lorraine stared at him. “A bet?” He laughed, a little embarrassed. “It’s a long story.” And it was the laugh that did it, not the voice he’d been using all night, his real laugh.
Lorraine said later that her heart almost stopped because she’d heard that laugh before, on records, on television, on a hundred late nights in a hundred lounges when somebody put a quarter in the jukebox. And she looked at him, really looked at him, at the shape of the jaw under that beard, at the eyes behind those tinted glasses, and she took one step back and put her hand over her mouth. He saw her see it. He didn’t try to deny it. He just held up one finger, gently, the way you’d ask a child to be quiet in church. “Please,” he said, in his own voice now, “don’t.” She couldn’t speak for a moment, and then, because she was Lorraine Dupree, and she had never in 15 years let anybody see her rattled.
She put her hands on her hips and said, “Mr. Presley, you came down to my room in a fake beard and sang a spiritual at me.” “Yes, ma’am.” “In a tweed jacket.” “It’s a borrowed jacket.” “It’s a terrible jacket.” And Elvis Presley threw his head back and laughed so loud that Charlie Hodge at the kitchen door hissed at both of them to keep it down. They talked in that alley for nearly an hour. She told him about Lake Charles and about her daddy’s church and about the cardboard suitcase in 1959 and the three record men who’d promised her the world.
She told him why she picked her challengers out of the crowd. “Because they said I only beat nobodies,” she said, “and I needed to know every week that I could still beat somebody who might be somebody.” “Well,” Elvis said, “tonight you did.” “Tonight I didn’t,” she said. “Tonight somebody let me and I’m going to know that every Thursday for the rest of my life.” He thought about that for a long moment and then he said something she never forgot. He said, “Miss Dupree, 2,000 people stand up for me every night up on that hill before I even open my mouth.
They’re standing up for a name, for a picture on a record, for somebody they remember from 1956. I don’t know anymore if they’d stand up for me if I walked out there without it. Tonight, for about 4 minutes, I got to find out. A room full of strangers booed me and then they stood up anyway. You don’t know what that’s worth to me.” He paused. “You gave me that when you picked me. So, I figured the least I could do was give you back your crown.” She asked him, before they went back in, why he’d chosen that song out of every song in the world. And he looked up at the strip of sky over the alley, pink with neon, and said, “My mama used to sing it to me when I was little and we didn’t have anything.
After she passed, I couldn’t sing it for a long time. I don’t know why it came out tonight. It just did.” He looked back at her. “It’s been 16 years. Some nights I still feel exactly like that song.” Lorraine reached out and took his hand the way she had on the stage, and they stood there for a moment without saying anything else. Before he left, he made her promise not one word to anybody as long as he was alive. Not to Sal, not to Clarence, not to the papers. She promised. And then he did one more thing. He took the $100 Red had just paid him out of his pocket, folded it, and pressed it into her hand. “Your prize money,” he said, “for week 71.” “Sal already paid me.” “Then this is for the next one,” he said.
They walked out of the alley onto Fremont Street just before 4:00 in the morning. Three men nobody looked at twice and drove back up to the Hilton, and Elvis did two shows that night. Red said he was the happiest he’d seen him all year. Two weeks later, a man Lorraine had never met walked into the Starlight on a Thursday night, sat in the back, and asked to see her after the show. He was a record producer from Nashville. He said a mutual friend, who preferred not to be named, had asked him to come and listen. And in the spring of 1975, Lorraine Dupreee, 41 years old, walked into a recording studio for the first time in her life and made a gospel album.
It was a small record on a small label. It never got near the charts, but it was played on gospel radio stations across the South for years, and it took her to churches in Louisiana and Mississippi and Alabama, where people stood up for her before she sang a note, and none of them had ever heard of Fremont Street. The first song on that album was Sometimes I Feel Like a Motherless Child. She kept her Thursday nights at the Starlight, too. She won ’71 and ’72, and she kept winning for more than two more years, until the night she decided she didn’t need to prove anything anymore and retired the crown herself.
But behind the bar at the Starlight, for as long as that lounge existed, there hung a little wooden plaque that Lorraine had paid a sign painter to make, with the dates of every one of her wins burned into it. All of them looked the same, a week number and a date, except one, week 71. Next to it, instead of a date, there was just one word, Aaron. People asked her about it for years. Who was Aaron? She’d only smile and say he was a country boy from Mississippi who sang a spiritual once and gave her back her crown. Elvis Presley died on August 16th, 1977, 3 years, almost to the week, after that night on Fremont Street.
Lorraine Dupreee heard the news on the radio in her kitchen. That Thursday, she walked out onto the stage at the Starlight, told the crowd there would be no song battle that night, sat down at the edge of the stage with no microphone, and sang Sometimes I Feel Like a Motherless Child, All Alone, for a room that didn’t understand why she was crying. Only after that night did she finally start telling the story. To Clarence Hobbs first, then to a handful of others, and every one of them had been in that room in 1974 and remembered the bearded man with the glass of water and the booing and the silence and the needle slamming into the pin and every one of them said the same thing.
Of course. Of course it was. Here’s what that night really teaches if you strip away the famous names. Real greatness doesn’t need the crown. The most famous man in the world walked into a room where nobody knew his name and the crowd booed him and he won them over anyway and then he gave the win away because he understood that a crown means more to the person who had to fight for it every single week than to the person who’s handed one every night. The strongest thing you can do with power sometimes is set it down.