News

What Happened To Prince Philip’s 4 Sisters After He Died

The photograph should have been an ordinary record of a royal funeral. Instead, it captured something that would follow one family for generations.

On November 23, 1937, a sixteen-year-old boy walked through the streets of Darmstadt, Germany, surrounded by men wearing Nazi uniforms. His dark overcoat hung loosely from his shoulders. His hands rested at his sides, and his expression revealed almost nothing.

Behind him came the coffins.

One contained his older sister, Cecilia, who had been eight months pregnant. Others held her husband, their two young sons, and their children’s grandmother. All had died together in an aircraft crash just seven days earlier.

The boy was Prince Philip of Greece and Denmark.

Ten years later, he would marry Princess Elizabeth, the future Queen of Britain, in Westminster Abbey. By then, Germany had been defeated, the full horror of the Nazi regime was emerging, and Philip was preparing to become part of the British royal family.

But not one of his surviving sisters would attend his wedding.

To understand why, you have to look beyond that photograph, beyond the uniforms, and beyond the comfortable idea that a family must share the same political beliefs simply because its members share the same blood.

Philip’s four sisters had married four German princes. Two had joined the Nazi Party. Another was married to a man who operated one of Hermann Göring’s secret surveillance agencies. One of the husbands would eventually fall under suspicion because of his connections to officers involved in the attempt to assassinate Hitler.

Their mother, meanwhile, would risk her life hiding a Jewish family in Nazi-occupied Athens.

And Philip himself would serve in the Royal Navy, fighting against the military forces of the country in which his sisters lived.

This was not simply a story about a British prince with uncomfortable German relatives.

It was the story of a family broken apart long before the war began, pulled into some of Europe’s darkest political machinery, and left to live with decisions that none of them could entirely undo.

And it began with a journey that was supposed to end at a wedding.

Cecilia was thirty years old when she boarded the aircraft in Frankfurt on November 16, 1937.

She had married Georg Donatus, Hereditary Grand Duke of Hesse and by Rhine, six years earlier. They had built a family, settled into the routines expected of their position, and were now preparing to celebrate another marriage.

Georg’s younger brother, Prince Louis of Hesse, was marrying Margaret Geddes, a young Englishwoman, in London.

For the Hesse family, the occasion promised a welcome gathering after years of political upheaval. Although Germany had changed dramatically since Hitler’s rise to power, private family occasions still offered moments when old aristocratic connections could appear reassuringly familiar.

Cecilia and Georg planned to travel with their sons, Ludwig, aged six, and Alexander, aged four. Georg’s mother, the Dowager Grand Duchess Eleanor, would accompany them.

Their youngest daughter, Johanna, remained at home in Darmstadt.

She was only two years old.

It was an ordinary decision, made for practical reasons. A small child would be more comfortable staying behind than making a demanding international journey.

Nobody imagined that decision would determine who survived.

Cecilia was eight months pregnant, making the trip particularly demanding. Nevertheless, she boarded the Belgian Sabena airliner with her family, expecting to arrive in England in time for the celebration.

The aircraft was a three-engine Junkers scheduled to fly from Frankfurt to Croydon, with a stop at Ostend on the Belgian coast.

The weather was dreadful.

Heavy fog had settled over the region, and visibility near the airfield was poor. As the aircraft approached Ostend, the pilot struggled to locate a safe landing position.

He circled the area, searching for a recognizable landmark through the thick cloud.

The plane descended.

Then it descended again.

At approximately 11:30 that morning, near the Belgian village of Steene, one of its wings struck the chimney of a brick factory.

The aircraft crashed into a field and caught fire.

Nobody on board survived.

The first reports were devastating enough. The deaths of Cecilia, her husband, their two sons, and the Dowager Grand Duchess had wiped out much of one branch of the Hesse family in a single morning.

But investigators and rescuers discovered something else among the wreckage.

The body of a newborn baby.

Contemporary reports suggested that Cecilia had gone into labor during the flight’s final minutes or around the moment of the crash. The exact circumstances could never be established with certainty.

The discovery made the tragedy even harder to comprehend.

Cecilia had boarded the plane carrying a child she expected to welcome into the world. By the time rescuers reached the wreckage, both mother and baby were dead.

Hundreds of miles away, Philip was attending Gordonstoun, his boarding school on the northeastern coast of Scotland.

He was called away from his ordinary school routine and informed that his sister and almost her entire household had been killed.

There was little time to absorb the news.

A funeral was being arranged in Germany, and he was expected to attend.

At sixteen, Philip had already experienced more family separation than many people endure in a lifetime. Yet this was something different. Cecilia was not merely a distant royal relative or a name in a family tree.

She was one of the older sisters who had helped fill the gaps left by his absent parents.

Now she was gone.

The boy traveled to Germany for the funeral.

And there, standing among the mourners, he found the two people who had once been the center of his childhood.

His mother and father.

They had not been together for six years.

Princess Alice had traveled from Greece. Prince Andrew had come from Monte Carlo. Their son stood between two parents whose lives had separated so completely that a family catastrophe was required to bring them into the same place.

The funeral was conducted with the ceremony expected for a German princely family.

The streets were lined with people. Uniformed men took their places in the procession. Nazi banners and swastika armbands appeared throughout the ceremony.

Hermann Göring attended.

Some of Philip’s own brothers-in-law appeared in Nazi uniforms.

For a British observer looking at the surviving photographs today, the scene can seem almost impossible to reconcile with the man who later became Queen Elizabeth II’s husband.

Yet the photograph does not tell the whole story.

Cecilia and Georg Donatus had joined the Nazi Party on May 1, 1937, just six months before their deaths.

Their membership was not a rumor invented decades later. The records exist.

Georg Donatus appears to have embraced the movement with some enthusiasm. Cecilia’s personal convictions are more difficult to establish because she left behind comparatively little testimony explaining what she believed.

That distinction matters.

Joining the party was a real decision, and it cannot be dismissed simply because the people involved were royal or because their lives ended tragically. But neither can Cecilia’s individual beliefs be reconstructed with certainty from her husband’s political commitments.

The same caution becomes even more important when examining Philip’s three surviving sisters.

They had not all made identical choices, and their husbands occupied very different positions within Hitler’s Germany.

At the time of Cecilia’s funeral, however, those distinctions offered little comfort.

The Hesse family still had one small child to care for.

Johanna.

The little girl who had remained in Darmstadt was suddenly without parents or brothers.

Her uncle Louis and his bride, Margaret Geddes, married quietly in London the day after the crash. What should have been a joyful occasion had become a ceremony overshadowed by death.

They returned to Germany and adopted Johanna.

For a brief period, it seemed that the family might preserve something of Cecilia’s household through the little girl.

Then, in June 1939, Johanna contracted meningitis.

She died at the age of three.

Within less than two years, Cecilia, her husband, and all four of their children had died.

For Philip, the loss was another rupture in a childhood in which permanence had always seemed painfully uncertain.

To understand why he had already spent so much of his young life moving between relatives and schools, the story must go back to 1922.

Philip was barely eighteen months old when his family was forced to leave Greece.

The Greek military campaign in Asia Minor had ended disastrously. The political consequences were severe, and Prince Andrew, Philip’s father, was arrested, brought before a revolutionary court, and eventually sentenced to lifelong banishment.

Six other defendants were executed.

Andrew survived, but his family could no longer remain safely in Greece.

A British warship, HMS Calypso, helped carry them into exile.

According to the familiar family account, the infant Philip slept in an improvised cot made from a fruit box.

It is an image that captures the strange contradiction of his early life.

He was born a prince, descended from several European royal dynasties, yet his family was leaving its country with few possessions and no secure future.

They eventually settled in Saint-Cloud, outside Paris, in a house lent by a wealthy relative.

For much of the 1920s, the household depended on the financial assistance of others.

Prince Andrew had neither a stable occupation nor a reliable income. Princess Alice devoted increasing amounts of her time to charitable work, particularly helping Greek refugees whose lives had also been disrupted by war and displacement.

As the years passed, Alice became more intensely involved in religious matters.

Her behavior worried people close to her.

By 1930, her mental health had deteriorated sufficiently for her relatives and doctors to intervene. She was diagnosed at the time with schizophrenia and taken, against her wishes, to a psychiatric sanatorium in Kreuzlingen, Switzerland.

The institution was run by psychiatrist Ludwig Binswanger.

Sigmund Freud was consulted about her case, and the treatment ideas associated with that consultation are deeply disturbing by modern standards.

Philip was nine years old.

He would go approximately five years without seeing his mother.

His father did not become the parent who filled the gap.

Andrew closed the house at Saint-Cloud, sold household possessions, and moved toward the south of France. He spent much of his time in hotels and on a yacht, supported in part by a companion.

He and Philip were not permanently estranged, and they would occasionally meet.

But they no longer shared a home.

Philip’s four sisters, meanwhile, were reaching marriageable age, and their lives were changing rapidly.

Between December 1930 and August 1931, all four married into German princely families.

Sophie, the youngest daughter, married Prince Christoph of Hesse in December 1930.

She was sixteen years old.

Christoph was twenty-nine.

Cecilia married Georg Donatus of Hesse in February 1931.

Margarita, the eldest sister, married Prince Gottfried of Hohenlohe-Langenburg in April.

Theodora married Berthold, Margrave of Baden, in August.

Four weddings in less than a year.

Four new households.

Four sisters establishing their lives in Germany.

And one boy, only ten years old by the end of that summer, left without either parent or any of his sisters living with him.

He began moving between schools and relatives.

There was schooling in France, time at a preparatory school in Surrey, visits with relatives in Britain, and holidays spent with members of his mother’s extended family.

His uncle George, Marquess of Milford Haven, became an important figure in his upbringing. His grandmother at Kensington Palace also provided a connection to the family life he had lost.

But Philip never developed the simple sense of belonging that comes from growing up in one household.

Years later, when someone reportedly asked him what language had been spoken at home, he responded with a question of his own.

What did they mean by home?

It was not merely a clever remark.

For much of his childhood, there had been no single place that answered the description.

And one of his sisters’ marriages would soon put him directly inside the Germany that was becoming increasingly dangerous.

In 1933, Philip was sent to Schule Schloss Salem, a boarding school near Lake Constance.

The school was closely associated with the family of his sister Theodora’s husband, Berthold of Baden.

It seemed a practical arrangement. The boy needed an education, and his brother-in-law’s family could provide one at an institution with an established reputation.

Its headmaster was Kurt Hahn, a German educator of Jewish descent who believed that young people should learn discipline, resilience, responsibility, and independence through demanding work rather than comfort.

Hahn had also become an outspoken critic of the Nazis.

When Hitler came to power in 1933, the school quickly found itself under political pressure.

Hahn was arrested.

His influential connections in Britain helped secure his release, and he eventually left Germany for Scotland.

There, on the coast of Moray, he founded Gordonstoun.

Philip followed him.

His time at Salem had lasted only two terms.

One anecdote from those months reveals something about the difference between the young prince and the political atmosphere surrounding him.

As the Nazi salute became compulsory in German schools, Philip reportedly found the gesture amusing. According to accounts repeated by his biographers, the raised arm reminded him of the signal boys at his English preparatory school used when asking permission to leave for the lavatory.

He laughed at it.

How much of that story was polished in later retellings is uncertain.

What is clear is that Philip left Nazi Germany and continued his education under the guidance of a man the Nazis had driven out.

The connection would influence him for the rest of his life.

Yet the sister whose marriage had helped him reach Salem was not the one whose household was most deeply entangled with the regime.

That was Sophie.

And by the time Philip returned to Germany for Cecilia’s funeral in 1937, Sophie’s husband had become one of the men entrusted with listening to the private communications of Hitler’s enemies.

Sophie had entered her marriage at an age when most girls were still deciding what kind of adult they wanted to become.

Her husband, Christoph of Hesse, belonged to an old German aristocratic family whose titles had once carried substantial political importance.

But Germany had changed after the First World War.

The monarchy was gone. The old ruling houses had lost their positions, and many aristocrats possessed grand names and impressive family histories without the financial security or political influence their parents had enjoyed.

Christoph was ambitious, intelligent, and determined to find a place for himself in the new Germany.

He found it in the Nazi movement.

In 1931, before Hitler became chancellor, Christoph joined the Nazi Party. The following year, he entered the SS.

These were not decisions made under the pressure of a regime already controlling every part of German life.

He chose the movement while its future remained uncertain.

And when Hitler came to power, Christoph’s early loyalty helped open doors.

By 1935, he was running an organization called the Forschungsamt, or Research Office.

The name sounded harmless, almost academic.

Its actual purpose was anything but.

The Forschungsamt operated as Hermann Göring’s secret communications intelligence service. Its employees intercepted telephone conversations, examined correspondence, monitored foreign diplomatic communications, and collected information on people the government wanted to watch.

The results went to senior officials within the Nazi leadership.

Christoph was no longer simply an aristocrat who supported Hitler.

He had become an important administrator within the surveillance machinery of the dictatorship.

Information collected by his organization could influence investigations, arrests, and decisions at the highest levels of government.

Its work also contributed to the atmosphere of suspicion and political violence surrounding events such as the Night of the Long Knives in 1934.

Back at home, Sophie was raising children.

Within eighteen months of her wedding, she had become a mother. More children followed, filling the household with the ordinary demands of family life even as her husband’s official responsibilities grew increasingly secretive.

That contrast matters.

There would have been meals, children’s illnesses, household arrangements, birthdays, and family gatherings.

Outside those routines, Christoph was helping operate a government organization that listened to people’s private communications without their knowledge.

What Sophie understood about every aspect of his work is impossible to establish.

But she was not entirely detached from the political world in which he operated.

In 1937, Sophie and Christoph named their third child Karl Adolf.

Family accounts also describe Hitler sending a gift following the child’s birth.

In private recollections written later in her life, Sophie acknowledged that she had initially found Hitler impressive. She remembered the impression he had made on her as a seemingly charming and modest man.

Those recollections are uncomfortable precisely because they show how political judgment can be shaped by proximity, social surroundings, and personal impressions.

Sophie was young when she first encountered Hitler’s circle. Her husband was advancing within the regime, and members of the German aristocracy were seeking new positions in a country whose old social order had collapsed.

She did not hold the kind of official role her husband occupied, and no comparable Nazi Party membership record has been established for her.

But her lack of formal membership does not mean that she was untouched by the ideology or insulated from the advantages her household received.

She participated in a privileged world that had chosen to accommodate the dictatorship.

And Christoph was not the only member of the Hesse family deeply involved.

His older brother, Prince Philip of Hesse, had married Princess Mafalda of Savoy, daughter of King Victor Emmanuel III of Italy.

That marriage created a valuable connection between Hitler and Benito Mussolini.

Prince Philip became an intermediary between the two dictators, carrying sensitive messages between Germany and Italy.

In March 1938, following Germany’s annexation of Austria, he communicated Mussolini’s acceptance of the development to Hitler.

His responsibilities went considerably beyond diplomacy.

He became governor of Hesse-Nassau and assisted with the acquisition of Italian artworks for Hitler’s planned museum at Linz.

His administrative position also placed him near some of the regime’s gravest crimes.

In 1940, a building at Hadamar was transferred into the Nazi program that systematically murdered disabled patients under the guise of medical euthanasia.

Historians have documented Prince Philip’s administrative involvement in that transfer.

That cannot be dismissed as merely an unfortunate family association.

The Hesse brothers had become useful to the dictatorship in different ways.

One helped supply intelligence. The other served as a political intermediary and regional administrator.

Their family enjoyed access to extraordinary power.

Yet the very system they had helped support would eventually turn against them.

The change began in Italy.

In July 1943, Mussolini was removed from power and arrested by his own government.

The event alarmed Hitler, who already harbored deep suspicions about sections of Europe’s traditional aristocracy.

German families with close ties to the Italian royal household suddenly became politically vulnerable.

Prince Philip of Hesse had spent years serving as a trusted link between Hitler and Mussolini.

Now, because of his marriage to Mafalda, that same connection made him suspect.

In September 1943, he was detained and eventually imprisoned at Flossenbürg concentration camp under a false identity.

For the family, his arrest was a frightening reversal.

A man who had once communicated directly with Hitler could no longer rely on the protection of that relationship.

And within weeks, another disaster struck.

On October 7, 1943, Christoph of Hesse was traveling by aircraft over the Apennine Mountains in northern Italy.

He had been serving as an officer in the Luftwaffe.

The weather was poor, and the plane crashed into a mountainside near Forlì.

Christoph was killed.

He was forty-two years old.

The official explanation was an aviation accident.

But inside the family, questions persisted.

Christoph had overseen a secret intelligence organization. He possessed knowledge of sensitive communications, political relationships, and private conversations involving some of the most powerful men in Germany.

His brother had just been arrested.

Had Christoph become a liability?

Could his death have been arranged?

These suspicions appeared in later family accounts, but no convincing evidence has emerged to establish that the aircraft was deliberately brought down.

The more cautious historical interpretation remains that he died in an ordinary wartime crash.

Still, the family’s doubts reveal how completely the political atmosphere had changed.

They had once believed that their closeness to the regime provided security.

Now they were afraid of the very authorities who had promoted them.

Sophie received the news as a twenty-nine-year-old mother of four.

She was also pregnant.

The child she was carrying would never meet its father.

In July 1944, she gave birth to a daughter, Clarissa.

By then, the political and military situation had grown even more dangerous.

Her brother-in-law was still imprisoned, and his wife Mafalda had suffered a fate even more terrible.

Following Italy’s break with Germany, Mafalda had been drawn to the German embassy in Rome, arrested, and deported to Buchenwald concentration camp.

The fact that she was the daughter of an Italian king provided no protection.

She was imprisoned in conditions entirely removed from the life she had once known.

In August 1944, Allied aircraft bombed a nearby munitions facility.

Mafalda was severely injured.

She died three days later, on August 27.

Her husband was still being held in captivity and would not learn of her death for months.

For Sophie, the losses accumulated almost faster than she could respond to them.

Her husband was dead.

Her brother-in-law was imprisoned.

Mafalda had died in a concentration camp.

Children within the extended family were left without one or both parents.

Sophie helped care for Mafalda’s children while struggling to manage her own growing household.

The war had not yet ended, and Germany was already collapsing around them.

What makes her situation difficult to judge is that personal suffering did not erase the family’s earlier political responsibilities.

Christoph had helped build the surveillance system of the dictatorship.

Prince Philip of Hesse had held important positions within the regime.

Their later suffering was real, but it did not undo the consequences of their earlier decisions.

Sophie was forced to live with both truths.

The end of the war brought another humiliation to the Hesse household.

American forces requisitioned Kronberg Castle, which had belonged to the family for generations, and converted it for military use.

Hidden inside the castle was a valuable collection of family jewelry belonging to Princess Margaret of Prussia, Christoph’s mother.

In 1945, three American officers, including Women’s Army Corps Captain Kathleen Nash, discovered the jewels.

Instead of protecting the property, they stole it.

Precious stones were removed from their settings. Gold was melted down. Items were sent back to the United States.

The theft eventually became the subject of an extraordinary military investigation and court-martial.

Some of the collection was recovered.

Much of it disappeared permanently.

For the Hesse family, already struggling with deaths, imprisonment, political disgrace, and the destruction of the war, the loss represented another severed connection to its past.

Sophie had entered her marriage as a teenage princess, surrounded by the remnants of an old European aristocratic world.

Before she reached thirty-one, her husband was dead, her country had been defeated, and much of the security she had known had disappeared.

But her story was only one part of the family.

Theodora, the sister whose marriage had helped send Philip to Salem, experienced the war very differently.

She had married Berthold, Margrave of Baden, in August 1931.

Their home was connected with the school at Salem, near Lake Constance, where the family had invested considerable energy in education.

Berthold came from a household with a complex political history.

His father, Prince Max of Baden, had briefly served as the last imperial chancellor of Germany in 1918 and announced the abdication of Kaiser Wilhelm II.

After the monarchy collapsed, Max had turned his attention toward education.

He helped establish the school at Salem and brought Kurt Hahn into its leadership.

Berthold himself had been educated under Hahn and developed a lasting respect for his methods.

This connection had shaped Philip’s life long before anyone understood how important it would become.

When the Nazis arrested Hahn in 1933, his expulsion from Germany could have ended the relationship between teacher and pupil.

Instead, Philip followed him to Scotland.

At Gordonstoun, Hahn encouraged the boys to confront difficult conditions, take responsibility for themselves, and develop confidence through practical experience.

Sailing, outdoor activity, discipline, and physical endurance became central parts of school life.

Philip responded strongly to this environment.

For a boy who had spent years moving between relatives and temporary homes, Gordonstoun offered something unusually stable.

It gave him a routine.

It placed him among people who cared less about his complicated royal ancestry than about what he could accomplish.

And it encouraged the independence that would later become one of his defining characteristics.

Years afterward, Philip sent his own son, Prince Charles, to Gordonstoun.

Charles did not share his father’s enthusiasm for the school, but that difference only demonstrates how personally important Philip considered the experience.

The chain of events was remarkable.

Theodora married Berthold.

Berthold’s family supported Salem.

Salem employed Kurt Hahn.

The Nazis forced Hahn to leave Germany.

Philip followed Hahn to Scotland.

A marriage that had briefly placed the young prince inside Nazi Germany had also helped provide his route out.

During the war, Berthold served in the German army.

He was severely wounded in France in 1940, suffering a head injury that ended his active military service.

He returned home and spent the remainder of the war away from the fighting.

Unlike Christoph of Hesse, he did not become an important Nazi Party official.

Theodora remained at Salem, caring for their three children and managing family life amid increasing uncertainty.

It was hardly an easy existence.

The school was taken over and reshaped under Nazi authority. Germany’s military fortunes worsened, and ordinary life became increasingly difficult.

But compared with the catastrophes facing Sophie, the household at Salem remained relatively stable.

When the war ended, the Baden family recovered control of the school.

Berthold devoted much of his later life to its administration.

Theodora’s experience revealed an important distinction that was often lost when Philip’s German relatives were discussed as a single group.

Marrying a German prince in 1931 did not automatically place someone at the center of the Nazi state.

Some aristocratic families cooperated enthusiastically with Hitler.

Others adapted, withdrew, resisted particular demands, or tried to preserve their institutions while avoiding deeper political involvement.

Their choices were not identical.

Neither were their consequences.

And the life of Philip’s eldest sister, Margarita, showed just how complicated those choices could become.

Margarita married Prince Gottfried of Hohenlohe-Langenburg in April 1931.

Their family home stood at Langenburg, a castle overlooking the surrounding countryside in southwestern Germany.

The family had occupied the estate for centuries, and the marriage appeared to offer Margarita a secure and relatively peaceful future.

Gottfried had spent part of his childhood in England.

He was comfortable speaking English and maintained connections with relatives across Europe.

He was also a professional soldier, more closely associated with military service than with the secretive political world occupied by Christoph of Hesse.

For a time, the marriage seemed to give Margarita the kind of settled family life her younger brother had never experienced.

Then tragedy entered their household.

In 1933, Margarita gave birth to her first son.

The baby did not survive.

She was twenty-eight years old.

The loss came at a time when the rest of the family was already dealing with profound instability, but Margarita had to carry her own grief while continuing to meet the expectations placed upon her.

In later years, she and Gottfried would have four more children.

Their family grew, and Langenburg remained their principal home.

Yet politically, the couple made a decision that would later complicate attempts to describe them as entirely separate from the Nazi regime.

In 1937, Margarita and Gottfried joined the Nazi Party.

It was the same year that Cecilia and Georg Donatus became members.

This detail is important because Gottfried would later be viewed as one of the less compromised husbands in Philip’s family.

His subsequent difficulties with the regime were genuine.

But his earlier membership was genuine as well.

Political loyalties and personal decisions were rarely as tidy as later family histories sometimes suggested.

When the Second World War began, Gottfried served in the Wehrmacht.

His military career eventually took him to the Eastern Front, where the German invasion of the Soviet Union brought him into a brutal and increasingly destructive conflict.

Accounts of his later life describe his growing disillusionment with the regime.

Precisely how and when his views changed is difficult to establish.

What is clear is that he knew members of the German officer corps who eventually became associated with opposition to Hitler.

That connection became dangerous in July 1944.

On July 20, a group of German officers attempted to assassinate Hitler by placing a bomb inside his military headquarters.

The explosion killed and injured several people.

Hitler survived.

The retaliation was immediate and ruthless.

The Gestapo began arresting suspected conspirators, but the investigation spread far beyond the people directly responsible.

Old friendships, family connections, military relationships, and private correspondence became sources of suspicion.

Anyone connected to the conspirators could become a target.

Gottfried knew some of the officers implicated in the attempt.

Within weeks, he was removed from his military command.

Family accounts have linked his dismissal to those associations and to his increasingly critical attitude toward the regime.

There is no established evidence that Gottfried personally participated in planning the assassination attempt.

He was not arrested as a conspirator.

But his removal from command was a serious warning.

At a time when men were being imprisoned and executed for far less, the family could not know how much further the authorities might go.

Margarita was at Langenburg with young children, including a baby born that year.

She had already lost one child.

Now she faced the possibility that her husband could be taken from her as well.

The situation was made more frightening by the uncertainty.

There was no reliable way to know whether an investigation had ended, whether a suspicious acquaintance had named someone, or whether another arrest would follow.

Gottfried survived the remaining months of the war.

But for Margarita, 1944 revealed that the political order her family had once accepted could turn against people who had previously belonged to it.

By the autumn of that year, the four sisters’ lives could hardly have been more different.

Cecilia had been dead for seven years, along with her husband and children.

Sophie was a widow raising five children while helping care for other children left vulnerable by the war. Her husband’s brother remained imprisoned, and his wife had died at Buchenwald.

Theodora was at Salem, living with a husband whose military service had ended after a serious injury.

Margarita was at Langenburg, married to an officer who had fallen under suspicion following the attempt on Hitler’s life.

Every household was affected by the same war.

But each had reached that moment by a different path.

And while all of this unfolded in Germany, their mother was living a life that none of them could have predicted when she was taken to a Swiss sanatorium in 1930.

Princess Alice had eventually returned to Greece in 1938.

She became increasingly committed to religious work and practical charity.

Her life was modest compared with the aristocratic world in which she had grown up.

She wore a gray religious habit of her own design and devoted herself to helping people whose circumstances were far worse than hers.

When German forces occupied Greece, Alice refused to leave Athens.

The city endured terrible suffering.

During the winter of 1941 and 1942, famine swept through Athens, killing tens of thousands of people.

Food became desperately scarce.

Families who had once managed ordinary lives struggled to find enough to eat, and the streets filled with people weakened by hunger.

Alice worked with relief organizations, including the Red Cross.

She helped organize soup kitchens, assisted orphaned children, and participated in efforts to obtain medical supplies.

At one point, she traveled to Sweden as part of her efforts to bring necessary supplies back to Greece.

Her title did little to lessen the daily realities of occupation.

She was also profoundly deaf, a condition that had shaped her experiences since childhood.

Yet she continued working among people who needed assistance.

Then, in 1943, she faced a decision that placed her own life in danger.

German authorities were intensifying the persecution and deportation of Jewish communities in Greece.

Among those threatened was the family of Haimaki Cohen, a Jewish former member of the Greek Parliament.

Decades earlier, the Cohen family had helped Alice’s father-in-law, King George I of Greece.

Alice remembered that connection.

When Rachel Cohen and two of her children needed somewhere to hide, she offered them shelter.

They moved into her apartment in Athens.

For more than a year, Alice concealed them from the occupying authorities.

Every visit to the building carried a potential risk.

German security officials could ask questions, search rooms, or investigate suspicious behavior.

Alice understood what could happen if the people she was sheltering were discovered.

Yet she continued protecting them.

According to accounts of the episode, when German officials questioned her, she sometimes used her deafness to avoid providing useful answers.

Her apparent vagueness made her more difficult to interrogate.

It was a dangerous strategy.

She was not merely expressing disagreement with the regime or offering sympathy to persecuted people.

She was hiding individuals whom the occupation authorities were actively seeking.

Discovery could have meant imprisonment or death.

The family remained concealed until they could emerge safely.

Alice did not turn the episode into a public story about her own courage.

For decades, her actions remained largely unknown outside those directly involved.

It was not until 1994, twenty-five years after her death, that Yad Vashem formally recognized her as Righteous Among the Nations.

Prince Philip traveled to Jerusalem for the ceremony.

When asked about his mother’s actions, he explained that she had not spoken about them and suggested that she would simply have regarded helping another human being in danger as the natural thing to do.

That response revealed something important about Alice.

Her religious convictions had not remained a private source of comfort.

They had become the basis for practical decisions that placed other people’s safety above her own.

The contrast within the family was extraordinary.

Some of her sons-in-law had served the Nazi state.

One had directed an intelligence organization used by the regime.

Her daughters were trying to survive the destruction of Germany.

Yet Alice had chosen to protect Jewish people from the government that controlled the country in which her daughters lived.

And her only son was serving in the armed forces fighting against that government.

Philip joined the Royal Navy in 1939.

War gave him responsibilities that were both dangerous and, in one sense, simpler than the complications of his childhood.

At sea, he had a defined role.

He belonged to a crew.

His duties mattered because other sailors depended on him, not because of his ancestry.

In March 1941, at the age of nineteen, Philip served aboard HMS Valiant during the Battle of Cape Matapan.

The battle took place in the Mediterranean, where British warships confronted Italian naval forces.

Philip was responsible for operating a searchlight control system.

In the darkness, the searchlights helped illuminate enemy ships so that the British guns could engage them.

It was demanding work carried out under battle conditions.

Philip performed well enough to receive a mention in dispatches.

He later participated in operations connected with the Allied landings in Sicily and continued serving as the war moved toward its conclusion.

In September 1945, he was present in Tokyo Bay when Japan formally surrendered.

Throughout the war, Philip had little or no contact with his sisters in Germany.

Their separation lasted roughly six years.

There have been different explanations for the silence.

Wartime censorship made communication difficult. Political sensitivities surrounding his German relatives may also have influenced decisions about contact.

His uncle Lord Mountbatten’s advice has sometimes been mentioned as another possible factor.

Philip rarely discussed the matter publicly.

Whatever the precise explanation, the practical result was the same.

His sisters were living through the destruction of Germany.

He was serving with the British fleet.

And the ordinary bonds of family life had been interrupted by a conflict larger than anything the five siblings could control.

When the war ended, the surviving members of the family faced very different futures.

In Germany, Allied authorities began examining people’s involvement with the Nazi regime.

Denazification proceedings attempted to distinguish major offenders from lesser participants and those who had not been responsible for the dictatorship’s activities.

For members of the former German aristocracy, these investigations could be deeply unsettling.

Family titles and old social connections no longer guaranteed protection.

Prince Philip of Hesse, Christoph’s older brother, had been released from Flossenbürg but was detained again by American authorities.

He remained involved in investigations and proceedings for years before eventually being classified as a lesser offender.

Gottfried of Hohenlohe-Langenburg also underwent scrutiny.

Berthold of Baden, who had not been a Nazi Party member and whose military career had ended after his injury, emerged without comparable political difficulties.

The families that had once lived in castles and moved within the highest levels of European society now had to explain their wartime conduct to Allied officials.

For some, the process exposed serious responsibilities.

For others, it created an opportunity to reestablish their standing in postwar society.

Meanwhile, Philip was building a new life in Britain.

He had developed a close relationship with Princess Elizabeth, the eldest daughter of King George VI.

They had known each other for years, and their relationship had grown through correspondence and meetings during the war.

By 1947, marriage was approaching.

But Philip’s background presented a problem for the royal household.

He had been born a Greek and Danish prince.

His father belonged to a royal family that had been expelled from its country.

His mother came from a family with both British and German connections.

And his surviving sisters were married to German princes, some of whom had been involved with the Nazi regime.

Britain was still recovering from the war.

Cities bore the scars of bombing.

Food rationing remained part of everyday life.

Memories of German occupation across Europe, concentration camps, and the deaths of British service personnel were painfully recent.

A royal wedding could not escape that political atmosphere.

Philip gave up his Greek and Danish royal titles.

He became a naturalized British subject and adopted the surname Mountbatten, the English form of his mother’s family name.

He was now Lieutenant Philip Mountbatten of the Royal Navy.

These changes were practical steps toward his marriage and his future position in the British royal family.

But they also marked another transformation in a life already defined by changes of nationality, residence, and family circumstances.

The boy who had once slept in a fruit box aboard a ship carrying his family out of Greece was preparing to become the husband of Britain’s future queen.

The ceremony was scheduled for November 20, 1947, at Westminster Abbey.

And as arrangements proceeded, one decision became clear.

None of Philip’s three surviving sisters would attend.

Sophie, Theodora, and Margarita were absent from the guest list.

The palace did not publish a detailed official explanation, leaving later historians and biographers to interpret the decision.

But the political context was unmistakable.

Only two years had passed since the defeat of Nazi Germany.

Two of Philip’s surviving sisters had husbands whose family histories were politically complicated. Sophie had been married to a senior SS officer who had directed Göring’s surveillance service.

Margarita and her husband had joined the Nazi Party in 1937.

Theodora’s household had a less compromised history, but her marriage still placed her within the German aristocratic world that British public opinion regarded with suspicion.

The potential consequences of inviting them were obvious.

A wedding intended to symbolize hope, stability, and national renewal could easily have become a controversy over the groom’s German relatives.

So the sisters stayed away.

For Philip, the decision brought another painful division between his private family life and the position he was entering.

His sisters were among the people who had known him longest.

They remembered the childhood in France, the absence of their parents, and the uncertainty that had followed their exile from Greece.

They had watched him grow up while moving between schools and relatives.

Now he was getting married, and none of them would be present.

There was one member of his immediate family who did attend.

His mother.

Princess Alice traveled from Athens and took her place in Westminster Abbey wearing her gray religious habit.

Around her were some of the most important figures in British society, dressed for a royal celebration.

Alice, who had spent the war assisting people in occupied Greece, looked strikingly different from the women wearing elaborate hats, jewels, and ceremonial clothing.

Yet she had contributed something deeply personal to the wedding.

She possessed a tiara whose diamonds could be used to create jewelry for Philip’s bride.

The stones were removed and incorporated into the engagement ring he gave Elizabeth.

It was an intimate connection between the young couple and the mother whose absence had shaped so much of Philip’s childhood.

A diamond ring, made from Alice’s jewelry, became part of the story of Britain’s future queen.

Behind it was the life of a woman who had endured exile, psychiatric confinement, years of separation from her children, and the dangers of wartime Athens.

When Elizabeth and Philip married, the public saw a young couple beginning a new chapter for the monarchy.

Few people watching the ceremony understood how much family history had been left outside the Abbey.

The separation did not last forever.

By the time of Elizabeth’s coronation in June 1953, Britain’s political atmosphere had changed.

The war was further in the past.

Relations with West Germany were being rebuilt, and former enemies were increasingly becoming partners in a new European order.

This time, Philip’s surviving sisters were invited.

They attended the coronation and appeared in photographs documenting the occasion.

For the first time in years, the German branch of his immediate family could participate openly in one of the major events of his royal life.

The reunion did not erase what had happened.

Cecilia was still dead.

Sophie’s first husband had been an SS officer.

Margarita and Gottfried’s Nazi Party membership remained part of their history.

Theodora and Berthold had lived through the destruction and rebuilding of their school.

And the family had lost people to wartime violence, disease, imprisonment, and accident.

But the siblings were no longer separated by an active war.

Philip resumed visiting his sisters privately.

He traveled to Salem and Langenburg and maintained relationships with his nieces, nephews, and other German relatives.

Members of the extended family later remembered him as an attentive brother who took an interest in their lives.

These connections rarely attracted the public attention given to his official duties in Britain.

For Philip, however, they represented continuity.

The sisters were among the last people who could remember the world before his childhood family disintegrated.

Their shared history could not be recreated, but their relationships could continue.

Sophie eventually rebuilt her life after Christoph’s death.

In April 1946, she married Prince George William of Hanover, whose sister was the Queen of Greece.

The couple later settled at Salem, where George William became involved in the leadership of the school associated with Kurt Hahn and the Baden family.

Sophie had three more children with her second husband.

Altogether, she raised eight children.

Her life stretched across extraordinary changes.

She had married for the first time at sixteen, become a widow before thirty, lived through the destruction of Nazi Germany, and later watched her brother take on an increasingly prominent role within the British monarchy.

In old age, she reflected on her earlier impressions of Hitler.

Her recollections did not simply deny that she had once found him appealing.

She acknowledged the impression he had made on her when she was young and described how completely her understanding had changed.

Those admissions are an important part of the historical record.

They reveal a woman confronting the distance between what she had once believed and what the regime had actually become.

Such a change of judgment could not reverse history.

But it helps explain why her life cannot be understood through a single photograph or political label.

Theodora remained closely associated with Salem and the Baden family.

Berthold died in 1963.

She survived him by six years, dying in 1969 at the age of sixty-three.

That same year, their mother Alice died at Buckingham Palace.

The woman who had spent so much of her life moving between countries, religious communities, and charitable work had spent her final period close to her son and his family.

Her death removed another living connection to Philip’s complicated childhood.

Margarita lived until 1981.

She died at Bad Wiessee in Bavaria at the age of seventy-six.

Sophie outlived all her sisters.

She died in Munich on November 24, 2001, aged eighty-seven.

By then, almost everything about the world into which she had been born had disappeared.

The royal houses of her childhood had lost their former authority.

The Nazi regime had been defeated decades earlier.

Germany had been divided and reunited.

Her brother had become one of the most recognizable members of the British royal family and was approaching an extraordinary milestone in his long public life.

Of the four girls who had left Greece with their parents and baby brother in 1922, Sophie was the last to die.

Their family history had come to span much of the twentieth century.

And yet one of its most significant episodes had remained largely unknown until long after the war.

Alice’s rescue of the Cohen family was formally recognized by Yad Vashem in 1994.

Her remains had already been transferred to Jerusalem in 1988, fulfilling her wish to be buried on the Mount of Olives.

When Philip visited Jerusalem for the recognition ceremony, he also visited his mother’s grave and planted a tree in her honor.

There was something deeply fitting about the location.

Alice had been born into European royalty, lived through exile and illness, and spent the final decades of her life seeking a religious purpose beyond the privileges of her birth.

Her most enduring act had not been a royal ceremony or a diplomatic accomplishment.

It had been opening her home to people who faced persecution and possible death.

And the son who had once gone years without seeing her was now helping preserve that part of her memory.

Still, the public story of Philip’s German relatives remained difficult.

Some accounts reduced it to a simple accusation: all four sisters had been Nazis.

Others tried to minimize the connections, treating the marriages as unfortunate coincidences and the political choices as irrelevant family history.

Neither version was adequate.

Cecilia and her husband had joined the Nazi Party shortly before their deaths.

Sophie had not held comparable party membership, but her husband occupied a powerful position in the SS and Göring’s intelligence apparatus.

Theodora was married to a man whose family had supported an educational institution that came into conflict with the Nazis and whose own wartime military service ended after a serious injury.

Margarita and Gottfried joined the Nazi Party, yet Gottfried later lost his military command following the assassination attempt against Hitler because of his associations with suspected opponents.

These were not identical circumstances.

Nor did the suffering some of the families later experienced automatically absolve them of earlier decisions.

Christoph’s death did not change what his surveillance agency had done.

Prince Philip of Hesse’s imprisonment did not erase his political activities.

Gottfried’s difficulties in 1944 did not remove the fact that he had joined the Nazi Party seven years earlier.

History becomes less useful when every contradiction is smoothed away.

The difficult details are often the ones that explain the most.

And perhaps no single image captured those contradictions better than the photograph taken in Darmstadt in 1937.

A sixteen-year-old boy walked between men wearing the uniforms of a dictatorship.

The boy himself would soon serve against that dictatorship.

His mother would protect Jewish refugees from it.

His sisters would live under it, and their husbands would experience its power in dramatically different ways.

Behind the boy came the coffins of people he loved.

He could not have known what the following years would bring.

He could not have anticipated the war that would divide his surviving family, the naval battles in which he would serve, or the royal marriage that would transform his place in British history.

He could not have known that the politics surrounding his sisters would prevent them from attending his wedding.

And he could not have imagined that, decades later, the same family relationships would still matter so much to him.

On April 9, 2021, Prince Philip died at Windsor Castle at the age of ninety-nine.

His funeral took place under COVID-19 restrictions, which limited attendance to thirty mourners.

Places were extraordinarily scarce.

The list was largely determined by close family relationships, and many people who would ordinarily have attended a major royal funeral could not be present.

Yet Philip had made a particular request.

Three relatives from his German family connections were included among the mourners.

They represented descendants of the families of Theodora, Margarita, and Hesse.

To many observers, their presence was a minor detail in a ceremony dominated by the grief of Queen Elizabeth and the British royal family.

But to anyone who knew Philip’s childhood, it carried a meaning that went far beyond protocol.

In 1947, his sisters had been absent from his wedding.

In 1953, they had returned to Britain for the coronation.

Over the decades that followed, he had quietly maintained the relationships that war and politics had once made so difficult.

And when the time came for his own funeral, he ensured that members of those families would be represented.

There was no need for a public speech explaining the decision.

The guest list said enough.

It connected the elderly Duke of Edinburgh, who had spent more than seventy years beside Britain’s queen, with the teenage boy who had once traveled alone to Germany to bury his sister.

Eighty-four years separated those two funerals.

In the first, Philip had walked through Darmstadt surrounded by uniforms, grief, and a family already fractured by exile and political upheaval.

In the second, members of that same extended family traveled to Britain to say goodbye to him.

The intervening years had brought war, separation, political disgrace, reconciliation, and the gradual disappearance of nearly everyone who had known him as a child.

Yet something had survived.

Not the political beliefs of every relative.

Not the old aristocratic world into which the family had been born.

And certainly not the illusion that their history could be made simple.

What survived was Philip’s determination to maintain a connection with the people who shared that history, even when the world around them made those connections uncomfortable.

Look again at the photograph from November 1937.

There is the sixteen-year-old prince in his dark overcoat.

There are the SS uniforms and swastika armbands.

There are the coffins.

A picture that might initially appear to reveal a troubling political allegiance instead opens the door to a far more complicated family story.

It tells of a boy who lost his home before he understood what exile meant, who grew up without his parents beside him, and who watched his four sisters disappear into marriages that carried them toward very different destinies.

It tells of choices that brought power to some members of the family and danger to others.

It tells of a mother who risked her life to protect strangers while her own children were divided by war.

And it tells of a man who, despite everything, never entirely abandoned the bonds formed during a childhood marked by loss.

The photograph captures Philip surrounded by the symbols of a regime he would soon fight against.

But the full story is not contained in those uniforms.

It lies in what came before them, what happened afterward, and the family relationships that endured long after the regime itself had disappeared.

At sixteen, Philip had no way of knowing how history would judge the people walking beside him.

He knew only that his sister was dead.

And he had come to say goodbye.

You Might Also Enjoy