News

What Happened to Mary Queen of Scots’ Body After Her Execution?

The executioner raised the severed head of Mary, Queen of Scots, before the witnesses and cried, “God save the Queen!”

Then something went terribly wrong.

The auburn hair slipped from his grasp. What he had been holding was a wig, and Mary’s head fell to the floor, revealing the short, gray hair beneath it.

For a moment, the room must have been stunned into silence.

Mary was only 44 years old. She had once been celebrated as one of the most beautiful royal women in Europe, a queen who had grown up surrounded by the elegance of the French court. Now, after nearly two decades of imprisonment, even her appearance had become a reminder of everything she had lost.

But the shocking scene at Fotheringhay Castle on February 8, 1587, was only the beginning of a far stranger story.

The English authorities had spent years trying to prevent Mary from becoming a political threat. By executing her, they believed they had finally removed that danger.

What they had not fully anticipated was the problem of her body.

Mary was not an ordinary prisoner whose remains could be quietly carried away and forgotten. She was an anointed monarch, a woman with a powerful claim to the English throne, and someone whom Catholics across Europe already regarded as a symbol of their faith.

Her death threatened to transform her into something even more troublesome than a living rival.

A martyr.

The officials responsible for her execution understood the danger. A piece of bloodstained clothing, a lock of hair, or even a fragment of wood from the scaffold might become a treasured relic. Such objects could inspire the very people the English government wanted to silence.

So they made a decision that would determine what happened to Mary in the hours, months, and years that followed.

They would control every trace of her death.

Yet despite their efforts, Mary’s body would remain a political problem for more than 25 years, passing through secrecy, an extraordinary burial, and a final royal intervention that would place her in the heart of the country that had condemned her.

To understand how that happened, it is necessary to return to the beginning of her life, when almost nobody could have imagined such an ending.

Mary Stuart was born on December 8, 1542, at Linlithgow Palace in Scotland.

Six days later, her father, King James V, died.

Before she was even old enough to understand what a crown meant, Mary had inherited one.

Her childhood was shaped by the political ambitions of adults. Scotland was a kingdom caught between powerful neighbors, and marriage was one of the most important weapons available to its rulers.

When Mary was still a child, she was sent to France, where she grew up at the royal court. There she received the education and upbringing expected of a European princess, surrounded by ceremony, music, elaborate clothing, and people who understood the importance of royal blood.

She eventually married the French dauphin, Francis, who became King Francis II in 1559.

For a brief period, Mary was both Queen of Scots and Queen Consort of France.

Then Francis died in 1560, leaving her a widow while she was still a teenager.

The life she had known in France was effectively over.

When Mary returned to Scotland in 1561, she found a country very different from the one she had left. The Protestant Reformation had transformed its religious and political landscape, and Mary, a Catholic monarch, faced nobles who were deeply suspicious of her faith and her authority.

She attempted to govern amid those divisions, but her personal life soon became entangled with the struggles surrounding her throne.

In 1565, she married her cousin Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley.

The marriage brought together two people with significant royal claims, but it quickly deteriorated. Darnley wanted power and recognition, while Mary had increasing reasons to distrust his judgment and behavior.

Their relationship became part of a wider conflict among the Scottish nobility.

Then, in February 1567, Darnley was murdered.

His death shocked Scotland, and suspicion fell upon several people, including James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell.

Mary herself became the subject of accusations and rumors. Whether she had any involvement in her husband’s murder would remain a matter of historical controversy.

What made her situation far worse was her subsequent marriage to Bothwell.

To many Scottish nobles, the marriage appeared intolerable. The man widely suspected of involvement in Darnley’s death had become the queen’s husband.

Rebellion followed.

By the summer of 1567, Mary had been forced to abdicate in favor of her infant son, James VI. She was imprisoned, escaped, and attempted to regain her position, but her supporters were defeated.

In May 1568, she crossed the border into England.

She believed her cousin, Queen Elizabeth I, might help her recover her Scottish throne.

Instead, Elizabeth made the decision that would shape the rest of Mary’s life.

She kept her in captivity.

At first, the arrangement might have appeared temporary. Mary was a fellow monarch, a relative, and a woman whose imprisonment created difficult questions about royal authority.

But Elizabeth had good reason to fear what Mary’s freedom might mean.

Mary possessed a hereditary claim to the English crown. To many Catholics, who rejected the legitimacy of Henry VIII’s marriage to Anne Boleyn, Elizabeth’s own claim was doubtful.

Some regarded Mary as the rightful sovereign of England.

That made her dangerous even when she was hundreds of miles from London, confined behind guarded doors.

Over the next 19 years, Mary lived in a succession of English residences and castles. Her surroundings varied, but the essential fact remained the same: she could not leave.

She maintained a household, wrote letters, practiced her religion, and continued to hope that the political circumstances around her might change.

She also grew older.

The young queen who had once moved freely through the French court became a prisoner whose future depended upon another woman’s decisions.

And Elizabeth’s government became increasingly concerned about plots to remove the English queen and replace her with Mary.

The crisis finally came in 1586.

A group of Catholic conspirators, associated with a young Englishman named Anthony Babington, became involved in a plan to assassinate Elizabeth and place Mary on the throne.

Elizabeth’s spymaster, Sir Francis Walsingham, had developed a sophisticated network of informants and agents. He was determined to discover whether Mary was connected to the conspiracies being organized in her name.

Secret correspondence was intercepted, including messages smuggled through the stopper of a beer barrel.

One letter appeared to show Mary approving a plan that included Elizabeth’s assassination.

How much Mary knew about the conspiracy, and how the intercepted correspondence should be interpreted, has remained a subject of historical discussion. But for Elizabeth’s government, the evidence was sufficient.

Mary was brought to trial at Fotheringhay Castle in October 1586.

She did not accept the court’s authority over her.

Her position was that she was an anointed queen, not an English subject, and therefore could not legitimately be tried by an English tribunal.

But her arguments did not save her.

The commissioners found her guilty.

For Elizabeth, the verdict created an agonizing political dilemma. Allowing Mary to live meant leaving a possible figurehead for future conspiracies. Executing her meant ordering the death of a fellow monarch and close relative.

It was a decision with consequences far beyond England.

In early February 1587, Elizabeth finally signed Mary’s death warrant.

Even then, the circumstances surrounding its execution became controversial. Elizabeth’s ministers proceeded with the arrangements, while Elizabeth later insisted that she had not intended the warrant to be carried out so quickly.

On the evening of February 7, Mary received the news.

She would be executed the following morning.

There would be no further appeal, no rescue from Scotland, and no last-minute intervention from the courts of Europe.

After nearly 19 years in English captivity, the waiting was over.

Mary spent her final hours preparing.

She wrote letters, attended to her will, made arrangements for those who had served her, and prayed.

Her servants understood that the next morning would separate them from the woman they had followed through years of uncertainty and confinement.

Some had been with her long enough to remember a very different Mary, one who had still believed she might regain her freedom.

Now they could do little but help her face what was coming.

On the morning of February 8, a scaffold stood in the great hall of Fotheringhay Castle.

Black cloth covered the platform. A wooden block waited at its center.

Among those present were the Earls of Shrewsbury and Kent, along with officials and other witnesses gathered to observe the execution.

Mary entered with remarkable composure.

Accounts describe her maintaining the dignity expected of a queen, even as she approached the instrument of her death.

She was accompanied by loyal attendants, including Jane Kennedy and Elizabeth Curle, who helped remove her outer garments.

Beneath them, according to several descriptions, she wore red.

The color carried particular religious significance because of its association with Catholic martyrdom. Later writers would make much of this detail, although the precise appearance and intended symbolism of her clothing remain subjects of interpretation.

What is certain is that Mary understood the importance of how she would be remembered.

She had lost her throne, her freedom, and nearly every political opportunity to reclaim her position.

But she had not surrendered her conviction that she was a queen.

When the moment came, she prayed.

Among the words attributed to her was the Latin prayer, In manus tuas, Domine, commendo spiritum meum — “Into thy hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.”

Jane Kennedy helped cover her eyes.

Mary knelt before the block.

The executioner lifted his ax.

The first blow did not complete the execution.

A second blow followed, and the executioner finally completed his task.

For the witnesses, what happened next would become one of the most frequently repeated details of Mary’s death.

And before the day ended, the authorities would already be attempting to erase the physical evidence of what had taken place.

The story of the wig quickly became part of the accounts circulating after the execution.

Mary’s familiar auburn hair had concealed what years of confinement had done to her. Beneath it, her natural hair was reportedly short and gray.

There was something especially cruel about that discovery. The same woman whose beauty had once been discussed across European courts was now exposed to the gaze of strangers in the most humiliating circumstances imaginable.

Other stories emerged from the hall, some considerably harder to verify.

One account claimed that a small dog, belonging to Mary, had hidden beneath her clothing and remained there throughout the execution. When her body was moved, the frightened animal supposedly emerged and refused to leave her.

The image was so affecting that it became one of the best-known details of her final moments.

But not every contemporary witness mentioned the dog, and historians have questioned how reliably the episode was recorded.

Another report claimed that Mary’s lips continued moving for some time after her execution. This almost certainly reflected exaggeration rather than a trustworthy observation.

These stories reveal how rapidly Mary’s death acquired a life of its own.

Even before her remains had been removed from the hall, people were beginning to transform what had happened into a narrative of suffering, courage, and martyrdom.

That was precisely what the government feared.

If Mary became a Catholic martyr, anything associated with her death might acquire extraordinary significance.

The authorities therefore moved quickly.

Her clothing was collected. The wooden block, the materials used during the execution, and other objects that had come into contact with her blood were gathered together.

According to contemporary descriptions, these items were burned in the great hall.

Nothing was to be preserved as a relic.

The officials watched as the objects were consumed by fire. The scaffold was dismantled, and the floor was cleaned to remove the visible traces of the execution.

It was an unusually thorough attempt to prevent Mary’s death from creating physical objects that might later become symbols of resistance.

Yet there was one thing they could not burn.

Her body.

It was removed from the hall and taken to another room within the castle.

There, according to accounts of the preparations, a postmortem examination was performed. The opening of royal bodies was not unusual during this period, particularly when embalming was required.

In Mary’s case, the examination may also have helped prevent later allegations about the condition of her remains or the circumstances of her death.

Her internal organs were removed and buried discreetly somewhere within the castle grounds.

The precise location was not publicly recorded, and it would not become a recognized royal burial site.

The rest of her body was embalmed and enclosed in a lead coffin, protected by an outer wooden case.

Lead was commonly used in royal and aristocratic burials because it could help contain the effects of decomposition and preserve a sealed burial.

For Mary, however, the coffin would present a problem of its own.

Before that happened, there was another indignity.

The servants who had remained loyal to her during her imprisonment were not given the opportunity to mourn over her body in the manner they wished.

They were prevented from entering the room where she lay.

According to one account, some managed to look through a gap in a partition.

What they saw was not the ceremonial repose of a monarch surrounded by the symbols of her rank.

Mary was lying beneath a covering taken from a billiard table.

For women who had spent years attending to her, arranging her clothes, bringing her letters, listening to her worries, and caring for her during captivity, the sight must have been painful.

The distinction between queen and prisoner had followed Mary even beyond death.

Outside the castle, however, England was reacting very differently.

When news of the execution reached London, bells rang and celebratory bonfires appeared in the streets.

To many Protestants, Mary’s death meant the removal of a serious danger to Elizabeth’s rule.

For years, stories of Catholic conspiracies had created an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty. Now the woman whose name had appeared at the center of so many plots was gone.

But Elizabeth herself did not publicly welcome the news.

Instead, she reacted with anger.

According to those around her, she insisted that she had not intended the death warrant to be carried out so quickly.

Her secretary, William Davison, had been involved in passing the signed warrant to the officials responsible for acting upon it.

Elizabeth blamed him for proceeding without further authorization.

Davison was imprisoned in the Tower of London and prosecuted. His punishment damaged his career and left him in a deeply difficult position.

Whether Elizabeth’s anger was entirely genuine has remained one of the enduring questions surrounding Mary’s execution.

Perhaps she had signed the warrant but hoped never to bear the responsibility of seeing it enforced.

Perhaps she had genuinely expected a delay.

Or perhaps her response was an attempt to protect herself from the diplomatic consequences of executing a fellow sovereign.

All three possibilities reveal how uncomfortable Mary’s death had become for the English crown.

In life, Mary had been a prisoner whose existence caused political difficulties.

In death, she was still creating them.

And now the government had to decide where to bury her.

The obvious possibilities were all troublesome.

Westminster Abbey was the traditional resting place of English royalty, but giving Mary a place there could appear to acknowledge the royal status and dynastic claim that had made her such a threat.

Sending her remains to Scotland was no simpler.

Mary had been forced from the Scottish throne almost 20 years earlier, and her son, James VI, had been raised as a Protestant under the influence of people who had opposed her.

Although James protested publicly against his mother’s execution, he was also determined to protect his political relationship with England.

His future prospects depended heavily upon that relationship.

Elizabeth had no children, and James was a leading candidate to succeed her.

For him, turning his mother’s death into an open confrontation with the English queen could have jeopardized everything he hoped to inherit.

When the possibility of returning Mary’s body to Scotland was raised, there was little appetite for an immediate decision.

The dead queen was left waiting.

Her coffin remained at Fotheringhay Castle as the weeks passed.

In France, the contrast was striking.

Henry III, Mary’s former brother-in-law, arranged a solemn memorial service for her at Notre-Dame Cathedral in Paris in March 1587.

There, she could be remembered as a Catholic queen whose execution had shocked royal Europe.

But in England, the body at the center of those ceremonies had still not been given a permanent grave.

Spring passed.

Then the summer heat arrived.

And something happened to the coffin.

According to a report from the period, the lead enclosure split open.

The probable explanation was the pressure created by decomposition inside the sealed coffin, worsened by the warmer weather and the conditions of its temporary storage.

A plumber had to be brought in to repair the damaged lead.

The image was a grim contrast to Mary’s former life.

Here was a woman who had once worn the crowns of two kingdoms, whose marriages had shaped international alliances, and whose claim to the English throne had frightened one of Europe’s most powerful governments.

Now her remains lay in a coffin that required repair before it could even be buried.

It had been nearly six months since her execution.

At last, Elizabeth authorized a funeral.

The chosen location was Peterborough Cathedral, approximately twelve miles from Fotheringhay.

Peterborough was a place of considerable religious importance and already contained the grave of Catherine of Aragon, the first wife of Henry VIII.

Catherine, too, had been a royal woman whose relationship with the English crown had ended in humiliation and political conflict.

The decision to bury Mary there therefore carried a certain dignity, even if it fell short of the royal burial she might once have expected.

The arrangements were placed in the hands of William Dethick, Garter King of Arms, an official experienced in the elaborate ceremonies surrounding royal and noble deaths.

Late on July 30, 1587, Mary’s coffin was placed upon a funeral carriage drawn by four horses.

It was carried from Fotheringhay to Peterborough, leaving behind the castle where she had spent the last months of her life.

The journey was short, but its significance was immense.

For the first time since her death, Mary was being removed from the place of her execution.

At Peterborough, the coffin was quietly placed in the grave before the principal funeral ceremony.

The official concern was that the summer heat might compromise the repaired lead coffin if the burial were delayed.

The public rites would follow.

On August 1, the cathedral became the setting for a carefully organized display of mourning.

Bridget Russell, Countess of Bedford, served as the chief mourner, representing Queen Elizabeth.

Banners were carried, heraldic symbols were displayed, and an elaborate black ceremonial structure was erected in connection with the funeral.

Accounts describe an arrangement representing the deceased queen, although scholars have debated the precise form of the objects displayed and whether a full effigy was present.

Everything was designed to give the occasion the dignity of an important royal funeral.

But the ceremony also exposed the deep division that had shaped Mary’s life.

The service was Protestant.

Mary had remained a committed Catholic.

And some of the people who had loved and served her were unwilling to participate in a religious ceremony that contradicted her beliefs.

Several members of her Scottish household refused to attend the service and withdrew from the cathedral.

Others remained.

For the mourners, the disagreement was painfully personal.

They had already lost the woman they served. Now they were being asked to watch her burial conducted according to the religious practices of the government that had executed her.

William Wickham, Bishop of Lincoln, delivered the funeral sermon.

He acknowledged that he had never personally known Mary.

There was something revealing about that admission. The man appointed to address the congregation was speaking about a woman whose life had been discussed and judged across Europe, yet whom he himself had never met.

The ceremony continued with the formal rituals of mourning.

The staffs carried by members of Mary’s household were broken and placed in the grave.

It was a traditional sign that their official service had ended.

The symbolism was difficult to miss.

Those who had devoted years to a queen in captivity were now releasing the last visible signs of their responsibilities to her.

Mary’s coffin lay beneath the floor of Peterborough Cathedral, near the resting place of Catherine of Aragon.

The funeral was sufficiently elaborate to be described in a published account a few years later.

Yet for all its ceremony, there was an uncomfortable truth.

Mary had not been buried in Scotland, the kingdom she had inherited as a baby.

She had not been laid to rest among the English monarchs to whom she was related.

Her son had not come to witness the ceremony.

She had been buried in England, under the authority of the queen who had approved her execution.

And for the next quarter of a century, she remained there.

Nothing suggested that her grave would ever be disturbed again.

But the political future Mary had spent so many years hoping for was not entirely extinguished by her death.

It was waiting in the person of her son.

In March 1603, Queen Elizabeth I died.

She had ruled England for more than 44 years, survived repeated threats against her throne, and remained unmarried and childless.

With her death, the question that had haunted English politics for decades finally required an answer.

Who would inherit the crown?

The man chosen was James VI of Scotland.

Mary’s son.

He was now James I of England as well, bringing the crowns of the two kingdoms under a single monarch for the first time.

The irony was extraordinary.

Elizabeth had spent years fearing that Mary’s claim to the English throne might undermine her rule. Yet the person who ultimately succeeded her was Mary’s own child.

James had been barely a year old when his mother was forced to abdicate the Scottish throne.

He had grown up largely separated from her, raised as a Protestant king while she remained an imprisoned Catholic queen.

He was 20 years old when she was executed.

By the time he inherited the English crown, he was an experienced monarch in his thirties, accustomed to navigating political difficulties and making compromises that would preserve his authority.

He could not bring his mother back.

But he now possessed something she had been denied throughout her captivity.

The power to determine how she would be remembered in England.

At first, James did very little.

In the summer of 1603, he sent a velvet pall to cover his mother’s grave at Peterborough Cathedral.

It was a respectful gesture, but it did not change the circumstances of her burial.

Mary remained beneath the cathedral floor, far from the traditional resting places of English sovereigns.

Perhaps James was occupied with the enormous responsibilities of his new position. Perhaps he understood that publicly honoring his Catholic mother required political care in a kingdom whose established church was Protestant.

Whatever his reasons, several more years passed before he took a decisive step.

In 1606, James commissioned a grand monument for Mary at Westminster Abbey.

The sculptor Cornelius Cure was entrusted with the work. After his death, his son William continued the project.

The monument was expensive, costing approximately £825, an enormous amount of money at the time.

It was not simply a decorative tomb.

It was a public statement.

For years, Mary’s enemies had treated her claim to the English throne as something dangerous. They had resisted allowing her a burial that might acknowledge her position among the royal families of England.

Now her son was using the resources of the English crown to create precisely the kind of memorial she had been denied.

There was something deeply personal in the decision, even if James did not express it in the language of grief.

He had not known his mother as an ordinary child knows a parent.

There had been no shared childhood, no long years of family life, and no opportunity for him to comfort her during her final imprisonment.

Their relationship had been shaped by separation, religion, and politics almost from the beginning.

But he could still honor the woman from whom he had inherited his blood and his first crown.

And he could do so in a place where England would never be able to overlook her.

Westminster Abbey.

The choice of location mattered.

The abbey was one of the most prestigious religious buildings in the kingdom and the burial place of generations of English rulers.

To place Mary there was to acknowledge that her story belonged within the history of the English monarchy, regardless of how Elizabeth’s government had once viewed her.

But commissioning the monument was only the beginning.

Mary’s body was still in Peterborough.

In September 1612, James finally ordered that to change.

On September 28, he signed a royal warrant authorizing the removal of his mother’s remains.

Twenty-five years after her execution, Mary’s coffin was to be brought out of its grave.

The order required arrangements to be made with the same attention to ceremony and dignity expected for a member of the royal family.

At Peterborough, the grave was opened.

The coffin that had once been sealed in haste, damaged by decomposition, repaired by a plumber, and lowered into the earth during a summer night was lifted out again.

For a second time, Mary was leaving a place where others had decided she must remain.

But this journey was different.

She was no longer being moved by officials attempting to solve the problem of an executed prisoner.

She was being brought to London by the command of her son, the king of England and Scotland.

The funeral procession traveled south.

In October 1612, after nightfall, Mary’s remains were received at Clerkenwell by distinguished churchmen and nobles, including the Archbishop of Canterbury.

From there, the coffin was conveyed to Westminster Abbey.

The old ceremonial hearse associated with her funeral in 1587 remained at Peterborough.

It was the end of one chapter of Mary’s burial history and the beginning of another.

Inside Westminster Abbey, a new resting place awaited her.

She was buried in the south aisle of the Lady Chapel, commonly called Henry VII’s Chapel, one of the most magnificent parts of the abbey.

The completed monument was designed to communicate rank, dignity, and royal ancestry.

Upon the marble tomb lies a sculpted figure of Mary.

She wears a close-fitting cap, a ruff around her neck, and a long mantle that falls along her body.

Her hands are folded in prayer.

At her feet rests a crowned lion, representing Scotland.

The figure is peaceful, almost serene.

Nothing about the carving resembles the confusion of her final moments at Fotheringhay.

There is no sign of the executioner’s ax, the fallen wig, or the decades she spent as a prisoner.

Instead, visitors see a queen presented in a posture of prayer, surrounded by the symbols of her royal identity.

Latin inscriptions celebrate her ancestry and dynastic importance.

One describes her distinguished position through marriage and the even greater distinction of her lineage.

The inscriptions were composed with considerable care, including contributions associated with Henry Howard, Earl of Northampton.

But something important was missing.

They did not plainly describe the violent circumstances of Mary’s death.

There was no detailed accusation against Elizabeth and no explicit account of the execution at Fotheringhay.

The omission was politically understandable.

James wished to honor his mother, but he also ruled the kingdom that had condemned her. He had inherited Elizabeth’s throne and could hardly build his new dynasty upon an open denunciation of his predecessor.

The memorial therefore achieved something more subtle.

It restored Mary’s royal dignity without reopening every conflict surrounding her death.

And the message became even more striking when viewed in relation to another tomb in the chapel.

Across from Mary, in the north aisle, lies Elizabeth I.

Elizabeth shares her monument and burial place with her half-sister, Mary I of England.

James had also commissioned the monument honoring Elizabeth.

The two rival cousins, whose competing claims had troubled England for so many years, were now commemorated within the same chapel.

During their lifetimes, Mary and Elizabeth had never met face-to-face.

They had exchanged letters, negotiated through advisers, and spent years attempting to understand each other’s intentions.

At different moments, Mary had hoped Elizabeth would protect her, while Elizabeth feared that Mary’s very existence might endanger her throne.

Their relationship had been one of the most consequential rivalries of the sixteenth century.

Now their monuments stood across from one another.

And there was an unexpected difference.

Mary’s tomb was taller and more elaborate than Elizabeth’s.

Historians have suggested that this may have been intentional.

James was the son of Mary Stuart, and his right to inherit both crowns depended upon the dynastic connections represented by his mother’s ancestry.

By constructing such an impressive monument, he may have been doing more than honoring a parent.

He may also have been reminding the kingdom of the royal blood through which his own authority had descended.

That interpretation cannot be established beyond doubt.

But the physical contrast between the monuments remains.

The woman whom Elizabeth’s government had refused to bury at Westminster now occupied one of the abbey’s most impressive royal tombs.

And it was Elizabeth’s successor who had made it possible.

The surrounding monuments add another layer to the story.

Nearby stands the memorial of Margaret Douglas, Countess of Lennox.

Margaret was the mother of Lord Darnley, Mary’s murdered second husband.

She was therefore Mary’s mother-in-law and the grandmother of James VI and I.

Her monument includes figures representing members of her family, among them Darnley kneeling in prayer.

The relationships represented in this part of Westminster Abbey are remarkable.

Mary had married Margaret’s son.

Darnley’s murder had contributed to the collapse of Mary’s reign.

Their child, James, had survived the turmoil and inherited the English crown.

And now the monuments of the family stood near one another, their complicated history preserved in stone.

It was a kind of reunion that none of them could have imagined during their lives.

For Mary, the journey seemed finally complete.

Her remains had traveled from Fotheringhay to Peterborough and then from Peterborough to London.

Her son had fulfilled the task of giving her a permanent resting place worthy of her rank.

For more than two centuries, the tomb stood undisturbed.

Visitors came to admire the sculpture, read the inscriptions, and remember the queen whose extraordinary life had ended on an executioner’s scaffold.

Most saw only the monument.

Few gave much thought to what remained beneath it.

Then, in 1867, another discovery brought the physical story of Mary’s burial back into view.

Arthur Penrhyn Stanley, the Dean of Westminster, was deeply interested in the history of the abbey and the people buried within it.

He wanted to investigate some of the burial vaults beneath the Lady Chapel, particularly to clarify the resting place of King James I.

James had died in 1625 and had been buried in the abbey, but the precise arrangement of royal coffins in the vaults had become uncertain over time.

Stanley organized an examination.

When the vault was opened, investigators found a collection of coffins belonging to members of the Stuart royal family.

The scene was very different from the polished marble monuments above.

There were no sculpted figures in prayer and no elaborate inscriptions greeting visitors.

Instead, the remains of kings, queens, princes, and other royal relatives rested together in the confined darkness beneath the chapel.

Among them was Mary’s coffin.

It lay along the north wall.

Stanley later described what he had seen in his writings about Westminster Abbey.

The coffin was covered with pitch, and its lead covering followed the general shape of the body it enclosed.

This was the actual resting place of the woman represented by the magnificent monument overhead.

The contrast was striking.

Above the vault, Mary appeared as a crowned queen commemorated in marble.

Below it, she rested inside a lead coffin whose history reached back to the anxious days following her execution.

It was a reminder that the grandeur of a royal tomb does not necessarily reflect the simplicity of the burial beneath it.

There was another remarkable detail.

Resting above Mary’s coffin was the coffin of Lady Arbella Stuart.

Arbella was a relative of James I whose own royal ancestry had drawn her into the dangerous politics of the Stuart dynasty.

She had become the center of a controversy surrounding her marriage to William Seymour, a match that alarmed James because of the couple’s combined claims to the succession.

Arbella was imprisoned and died in the Tower of London in 1615.

Her presence in the vault added another tragic story to the family history surrounding Mary.

The same royal blood that could raise one person to a throne could make another person a political prisoner.

Other members of the family were buried nearby.

Among them were Henry, Prince of Wales, the eldest son of James I, whose early death in 1612 had disappointed hopes for the future of the dynasty.

There was also Elizabeth Stuart, Queen of Bohemia, remembered as the Winter Queen.

Their lives had followed very different courses, but their remains had eventually come together beneath the chapel.

Mary was no longer isolated in the way she had been at Fotheringhay.

She lay among descendants and relatives whose fortunes had been shaped by the same royal inheritance.

Stanley’s investigation did not transform Mary’s burial into a new public spectacle.

Her remains were not placed on display.

The examination helped document the arrangement of the royal coffins, and the vault was left as a resting place for the dead.

The story that began with the urgent concealment of an executed queen’s body had ended in a family burial chamber beneath one of England’s greatest churches.

Yet the journey to that chamber tells us something that the marble monument alone cannot.

After Mary’s execution, the English government had been determined to prevent her death from becoming a source of political or religious inspiration.

Her bloodstained clothing was destroyed.

The materials associated with the execution were burned.

The hall was cleaned, her body was removed, and her servants were denied the opportunity to mourn her as they wished.

Even her first coffin became a problem when it split open during the summer heat.

For months, the authorities had possessed the remains of a woman who had once worn two crowns, but they had no politically comfortable place to put her.

Finally, she was buried at Peterborough.

The funeral was elaborate, but the religious divisions surrounding her life followed her into death. Some of the people closest to her could not bring themselves to participate in the Protestant service.

For 25 years, that appeared to be the end.

Then the political circumstances changed.

Mary’s son inherited the English throne.

The same dynastic claim that had once made his mother a threat became part of the foundation of his own monarchy.

James did not need to wage a war or overturn a government to restore her place within the royal family.

He already possessed the authority to do so.

He commissioned her monument, ordered her remains removed from Peterborough, and brought her to Westminster Abbey.

The woman whose body had once been treated as a dangerous political object was now buried among the monarchs of the country that had executed her.

And the irony did not end there.

Elizabeth had feared what Mary’s claim to the crown might mean for England.

But when Elizabeth died without an heir of her own, it was Mary’s son who became king.

The royal blood that had caused Elizabeth so much anxiety ultimately continued the English monarchy.

Mary herself never lived to see that outcome.

She never knew that James would inherit Elizabeth’s throne, commission a magnificent monument in her honor, or order her body moved to Westminster.

She died believing that her earthly prospects had come to an end.

But her story continued through the people and institutions that survived her.

Today, Peterborough Cathedral still remembers her former burial place near the grave of Catherine of Aragon.

A Scottish flag marks the area associated with Mary’s original grave, drawing attention to the queen who rested there for a quarter of a century.

At Westminster Abbey, her imposing monument remains in the Lady Chapel.

Visitors can see the marble figure with its folded hands, the long robes, and the crowned lion at her feet.

Across the chapel stands the memorial of Elizabeth I.

The two women who spent so much of their lives separated by fear, politics, religion, and competing claims to the throne now remain close to one another in death.

Their tombs do not explain everything that passed between them.

They do not settle the arguments over Mary’s involvement in conspiracies or Elizabeth’s responsibility for the execution.

They cannot tell us exactly what either woman thought during the years when their decisions shaped one another’s lives.

But they preserve the outcome of a remarkable historical reversal.

Mary began life as a queen before she was a week old.

She became Queen Consort of France, returned to Scotland as a young widow, lost her Scottish throne, fled to England seeking protection, and spent the last 19 years of her life in captivity.

She died on a scaffold, and the officials who oversaw her execution tried to ensure that nothing connected with it could be turned into a relic.

Yet the efforts to control her memory did not succeed.

Her story was repeated in letters, histories, memorials, and accounts of her final moments.

Her first grave did not remain her last.

Her son became the ruler of the kingdom whose queen had condemned her.

And the woman who had once been denied a place among the English monarchs eventually received a monument more imposing than that of her greatest rival.

Beneath the magnificent marble, in the darkness of a royal vault, Mary’s remains still lie within the abbey.

The coffin itself is hidden from the visitors who stand above it.

But the journey it made has never been forgotten.

For all the efforts made to erase the traces of Mary’s execution, the authorities could not erase what her life and death meant to the generations that followed.

The prisoner of Fotheringhay became a queen remembered at Westminster.

And more than four centuries after her death, the woman whose body England once struggled to bury remains one of the most unforgettable figures in its royal history.

You Might Also Enjoy