“Touch Her Again” — The Stranger On The Roan Mare Made The Whole Town Freeze
The first thing that stopped was the blacksmith’s hammer.
Knut Lindqvist had been drawing out a wagon tire at the north end of Front Street, and the ring of his anvil was so much a part of Paintbrush that nobody heard it anymore.
They heard it when it stopped.
It stopped on the upstroke, a little after two o’clock on Thursday, the fourteenth of July, 1881.
After that, the only sounds in town were the wind, a horse blowing through its nose, and a young woman trying very hard not to cry.
Garrick Dorrance had her by the hair in the middle of the street.
He stood behind her, a big man with a full black beard and dark hair that hung to his shoulders.
His shirtsleeves were shoved up past the elbow, a brown leather vest hung open over his chest, and a cartridge belt rode low on his hips with a row of brass shells winking in the sun.
His fist was closed in her hair at the crown of her head, and he held her there the way a man holds a sack he has not yet decided to drop.
Behind them, his black gelding with the white blaze stood at the hitch rail of the Ashcroft Mercantile, shifting its weight and watching.
The young woman was Della Ashcroft, and the store behind her was hers.
She was twenty-five years old.
Her dress was a gray-green calico with a small dark print, the plain kind a storekeeper wears to haul crates in, and the sleeve on her left shoulder had torn half off when Garrick dragged her across her own counter.
Her long brown hair had come down out of its pins.
She had both feet planted in the dust, and her teeth were clenched so hard that the whole street could see it.
The whole street could see everything.
That was the point.
Paintbrush sat where Sweetroot Creek came down out of the Bighorn Mountains, two hard days north of Fort Fetterman.
It had one street, a church with no steeple, the Antler saloon, a barbershop, a hotel, a forge, and the Ashcroft Mercantile, which sold everything from coffee to coffin nails.
Upstream lay the Keyhole ranch, and the Keyhole belonged to the three Dorrance brothers.
Garrick was the oldest and the biggest and the one who did the talking.
Corbin, the middle one, was thin and careful and kept the books.
Linus, the youngest, laughed at whatever Garrick said a half second before anybody else did.
Between them they held the creek, the grass, the credit at the bank in Fetterman, and the tin star on Deputy Elmer Truax’s vest, which the Keyhole had paid for.
Right now Corbin stood on the top step of the mercantile with a folded paper and a pen in his hand.
Linus leaned on the porch post beside him and grinned.
Deputy Truax was nowhere at all.
Garrick bent his head close to hers, but he pitched his voice for the street.
“Say it so they can hear you, Della. Hal got thrown. Say it, sign Corbin’s paper, and you’re on the Fetterman buckboard in the morning with four hundred dollars in your pocket.”
Della Ashcroft lifted her chin as far as his fist allowed.
“Hal didn’t fall. You know he didn’t fall.”
Hal Ashcroft had come up from Colorado four years earlier with six hundred dollars, a wagon of stock, and a strawberry roan mare named Tansy.
He had built the store with his own hands on the only lot in Paintbrush that fronted the freight crossing.
Garrick Dorrance had offered to buy that lot three times.
Hal had said no three times, politely, and gone on selling flour at a fair price, which in a Keyhole town was a kind of insult.
On the ninth of February, Hal rode up the Sweetroot breaks with two sacks of flour for a homesteader’s family who were snowed in.
He did not come back.
Corbin and Linus Dorrance found him the next morning at the bottom of a cutbank, with his neck broken and his saddle beside him, the cinch strap parted.
His mare had thrown him, they said.
The mare had run off with the wild bunch, they said, and good riddance to a killer horse.
They brought back the body and the saddle.
They did not bring back the mare.
Della buried her husband in the frozen ground behind the church, and then she did the one thing nobody in Paintbrush had ever done to a Dorrance.
She said it out loud.
She said it at her counter, in the church, and on the porch of the Antler, and she wrote it in a letter to the United States marshal at Cheyenne.
The marshal answered in June that a deputy would come up the Fetterman road in the fall to take statements.
Garrick Dorrance had decided that by the fall there would be no statements to take.
So at two o’clock he had walked into her store, and when she told him for the fourth time that it was not for sale, he took her by the wrist and pulled her over the counter.
Then he wound his hand into her hair and walked her out into the middle of Front Street to say it in front of everyone.
Everyone did what Paintbrush always did.
Barlow Venn, who kept the Antler, stood very still inside his own doorway.
Obed Stokes, who was mayor and justice of the peace and also cut hair, drew the shade on the barbershop window, though everyone could see his shape behind it.
At the forge, Knut Lindqvist stood with the hammer lifted and did not bring it down.
Della looked at every door on that street.
Not one of them opened.
The only stranger in town that day had ridden in at noon.
He came down off the Fetterman road at a walk, on a strawberry roan mare with a flaxen mane and tail, a deep-chested animal that moved as if the street had been swept for her.
He tied her at the rail in front of the Antler, across the street from the mercantile.
He was a lean, weathered man in his late fifties, with graying stubble on a lined face and pale eyes that seemed to squint even in the shade.
He wore a sweat-stained brown hat with a flat brim, brown leather work gloves, and a heavy wool poncho in dark wine red and brown, woven with pale geometric bands and fringed at the hem.
Under it was a faded shirt, and when he sat down, the poncho fell back far enough for Barlow Venn to see one revolver in a worn holster.
He took the table by the front window, asked for coffee instead of whiskey, and watched the mercantile across the street for two hours, the way a man watches a pot he expects to boil.
When Garrick Dorrance walked Della Ashcroft out of her store, the stranger set the cup down on its saucer without a sound and stood up.
Barlow Venn moved before he knew he was going to.
“Mister. That’s Garrick Dorrance. He’s got twenty men on the Keyhole and the deputy in his pocket. It ain’t your affair.”
The stranger settled his hat.
“It got to be my affair about the time I bought my horse.”
The stranger walked out through the batwing doors and down into the sun.
As he passed the hitch rail, the roan mare swung her head after him and let out a long, high whinny that went the length of Front Street.
In the middle of the street, Della Ashcroft’s eyes went wide.
She knew that horse’s voice the way she knew the creak of her own front step.
She could not turn her head to look, but she knew it.
The stranger crossed the street and stopped a dozen feet from them, beside the hitch rail where the black gelding stood.
He did not hurry, and he did not put his hand anywhere near his gun.
Garrick looked him up and down, from the dusty boots to the faded hat.
“You’re lost, grandpa. The saloon’s behind you.”
The stranger did not answer him.
He looked past Garrick’s shoulder at Della.
“Are you hurt, ma’am?”
Her voice shook, but it came out.
“Not so bad I can’t stand.”
Garrick laughed, loud enough to carry.
“This is between me and the widow. She’s fixing to tell the town something. Go finish your coffee.”
On the porch, Linus laughed too, right on time.
The stranger did not look at Linus.
He kept his eyes on Garrick’s face, and only his face, the way a man reads a brand.
Garrick did not care for it.
He opened his fist and let go of Della’s hair, with a little shove that sent her stumbling a step toward the hitch rail, and he squared himself to the stranger with his right hand loose beside the cartridge belt.
“I’ll tell you once. Turn around.”
The stranger stayed exactly where he was.
Something in Garrick’s face changed then.
He could feel the town behind every curtain, and he knew what the town was seeing: Garrick Dorrance told a man to turn around, and the man did not.
A man who runs a town on fear cannot let it see that.
So he grinned for the windows, and he reached back with his left hand for Della’s hair again, slowly, so everyone could watch him do it.
“Watch this, Paintbrush.”
The stranger spoke, and he did not raise his voice at all.
“Touch her again.”
Garrick’s hand stopped a few inches from her hair.
He had not meant it to stop.
It simply did.
And for the length of three heartbeats, the whole town of Paintbrush froze.
Barlow Venn froze in his doorway with his hand on the batwing.
The barber’s shadow froze behind the shade.
Knut Lindqvist froze with the hammer still raised, and the wagon tire went from orange to gray under it.
On the porch, Linus Dorrance’s laugh stopped in his throat, and Corbin’s pen stopped over the paper.
Garrick brought his hand slowly back to his side, and his face went dark red above the beard.
“Or what, old man?”
The stranger did not blink.
“Or everybody you ever scared finds out what you look like in a fair fight.”
Garrick’s right hand went for his gun.
He was quick for a big man, and he had done it a great many times when the other man was unarmed.
Nobody in Paintbrush saw the stranger draw.
What they saw was the poncho swing, and what they heard was one flat, hard crack that slapped off the false fronts and came back from the hills.
Then they heard the heavy brass buckle of Garrick Dorrance’s gun belt hit the street.
—
## The Mare At The Rail
The bullet had gone through the tongue of the buckle, a finger’s width from Garrick’s belly, and cut it clean in two.
The whole weight of the belt, forty brass cartridges and a revolver in its holster, slid down over his hips and dropped around his boots like a sack of nails.
Garrick’s gun had come two inches out of the holster before the holster left him.
He stood in the middle of Front Street with his empty hand open and his belt around his ankles, like a man who had stepped into a trap.
But every soul behind every curtain in Paintbrush saw it, and Garrick knew they did.
The stranger’s revolver was in his gloved hand now, held low, the muzzle pointed at the dirt a yard in front of Garrick’s boots.
The stranger tipped his head at the belt.
“Step out of it, son. Or stand in it all day. Your choice.”
Garrick stepped out of it, one boot and then the other, and his face above the black beard was the color of raw meat.
The stranger hooked the belt with the toe of his boot, slid it across the dust under the black gelding’s nose, and holstered his gun.
Only then did he look at Della.
She was holding the rail to keep herself up, and she was not looking at him at all.
She was looking across the street at the roan mare tied in front of the Antler.
The mare was looking back at her, ears pricked hard, and as Della watched, she called again, lower this time, the soft rumble in the chest that a horse saves for someone it knows.
Della’s hand came off the rail.
“That’s Tansy. That’s my husband’s mare. They said she ran off with the wild bunch.”
The stranger answered the way another man might have said it looked like rain.
“She didn’t.”
Then he turned back to Garrick Dorrance.
“Take your brothers and go home.”
Garrick found his voice, though it came out thick.
“I’ll be back here at eight o’clock in the morning with every man on the Keyhole.”
“Then I’ll be here at eight o’clock in the morning. Bring the bill of sale for this mare, too. I’d like a look at the signature.”
Linus Dorrance made a small sound on the porch, like a man who has stepped on a nail.
Corbin turned and looked at his youngest brother.
Garrick climbed onto the black gelding without his belt, without his gun, and without a word, and the three of them rode north at a walk, because Garrick would not let the town see him gallop.
When the dust had settled, doors opened a crack.
Down at the forge, Knut Lindqvist finally brought his hammer down, once, on cold iron, and the clang of it seemed to wake everyone up.
Della Ashcroft walked straight across Front Street to the rail of the Antler.
The roan mare put her nose into Della’s chest and pushed, the way she had pushed Hal every morning for the sugar in his pocket.
Della put both arms around the mare’s neck and held on.
She had not cried in front of Garrick Dorrance.
She cried now, quietly, into the flaxen mane, and nobody on that street was fool enough to watch.
When she lifted her head, the stranger was standing a few feet away with his hat in his hand.
“How do you have her?”
“Bought her off a horse trader at Fort Fetterman, three weeks ago. He bought her off a Keyhole man two days after your husband died.”
She was looking at the mare’s left shoulder now, where the summer coat lay thin over a small old brand.
It was a plain circle, nothing inside it, nothing under it.
Hal had tooled the same mark into the skirt of his saddle, and when she had asked him once what it meant, he only laughed and said it meant he had been raised right.
“You know that brand.”
“I put it on her.”
He said nothing else, and she found that she could not ask.
—
## Hal’s Saddle
At seven that evening, Della came across to the livery barn behind the Antler, where the stranger had put Tansy in a stall and spread his bedroll in the empty one beside her.
She had pinned up her hair and put on a dark blue dress with both its sleeves, and she was carrying her husband’s saddle in her arms.
“You wanted to see a signature. I want you to see this first.”
She turned up the near side of the saddle and took hold of the latigo, the long strap of oiled leather that holds the whole saddle on the horse.
It was in two pieces.
She laid the two ends together in the lantern light.
For about three parts of its width, the leather had been cut straight and clean on the underside, where a man saddling a horse would never see it.
The last quarter was torn, ragged and stretched, the way leather tears when the full weight of a rider and a hard turn come onto it at once.
“Corbin said the leather was rotten. That latigo was eight months old. I sold it to Hal myself, off my own shelf.”
The stranger took off one glove and ran his thumb along the cut edge, slowly, twice.
Halfway along the cut there was a tiny step in the leather, a ridge no wider than a pencil line, where the edge jumped and then ran straight again.
“Knife’s got a nick in the blade. About a third of the way up from the handle.”
“Is that enough? For a judge?”
“Not by itself.”
He reached inside the poncho, brought out a flat leather wallet, and took two papers out of it.
The first was a bill of sale on a page torn from a tally book.
*Fort Fetterman, Feb. 11, 1881. Sold to J. Hatch, one strawberry roan mare, flaxen mane and tail, circle brand on left shoulder, for forty dollars. L. Dorrance.*
Della read it twice.
“Two days. Hal was not even buried yet. The ground was too hard.”
“Forty dollars for that mare. A man who sells a horse like that for forty dollars doesn’t own her and knows it.”
He held out the second paper.
It was a letter, creased soft from riding in a pocket, and it was in Hal Ashcroft’s hand.
*Paintbrush, W.T., January 20th, 1881. Boss, Garrick Dorrance has made his offer for the lot three times now and this last time he did not smile. Della says we are not selling and she is right. I am writing you because if anything should happen to me this winter, I want one man in the world to know the truth. If you hear I was thrown, don’t believe it. Tansy never threw anybody in her life. You raised her. You know. Look in on Della if you are ever up this way. Your friend, Hal.*
“It followed me. Huerfano River, Walsenburg, Trinidad, then down into New Mexico. I didn’t have it in my hand till the end of May. He’d been in the ground three months.”
“I came up the Fetterman road to see the grave. I found the mare instead, in Hatch’s corral, with her ribs showing. Then I knew which part of the letter to believe.”
Della folded the letter and held it against her chest.
“He called you Boss.”
“He came to work for me when he was fourteen. Ran off from a mule outfit in Pueblo. I put him on a horse and he stayed six years. Best hand with a young horse I ever saw.”
“He never told me about you. Not your name. Not anything.”
“I asked him not to.”
She waited, and he did not explain.
“Garrick will come at eight. Twenty men.”
“More like eight. Half the Keyhole pushes cows for thirty dollars a month. Thirty dollars don’t buy a man for this.”
“And if it’s twenty?”
He looked at the mare, who was pulling at her hay as if nothing had ever happened in the world.
“Then it’ll be a long morning.”
She put the halves of the latigo into his hands.
“You keep these. He’ll burn the store before he lets anybody from Cheyenne see them.”
At the barn door she stopped and turned.
“Are you going to tell me your name?”
“In the morning.”
“Why not now?”
“Because in the morning you’ll need it more.”
—
## A Knife In The Dark
The town went to bed early that night, and nobody slept.
Knut Lindqvist sat in his forge with a shotgun across his knees that he had not fired in eleven years.
In the livery barn, the stranger lay in the empty stall with his hat over his face and his hand on the butt of his revolver.
At a little after one in the morning, the back door of the barn opened.
The moonlight came through the gaps in the plank walls in long gray stripes, and one of the stripes slid across a tin star.
At dark he had ridden out to the Keyhole, and at midnight he had ridden back, and he had come straight to the barn with something in his free hand that caught the moon.
He crept along the stalls until he came to the roan mare.
The stranger’s saddle hung on the partition between the two stalls, the latigo hanging down.
Truax took hold of the strap, laid a blade against the underside of the leather, and began to cut.
He had cut about a third of the way through when he heard, very close to his left ear, the small, oiled double click of a revolver being cocked.
“That’s far enough, Deputy.”
Truax dropped the latigo.
He did not drop the knife, because his hand would not open.
The stranger stepped out of the dark stall into a stripe of moonlight.
“You were cutting my cinch strap three parts through, on the underside. So that tomorrow, when I go to get on my horse in a hurry, the saddle turns under me and I land on my head. I’ve seen it done once already. Put the knife on the partition. Handle first.”
Truax laid it down.
It was a bone-handled hunting knife, and the stranger held it up to the light.
About a third of the way up from the handle, there was a small nick in the edge.
“Whose knife is this?”
Truax’s mouth worked, but nothing came out of it.
The stranger let the hammer down to half cock.
“Elmer. You’re not a bad man. You’re a scared one. A scared man can still be useful. Whose knife?”
Whatever Truax saw in the stranger’s face made the words fall out of him all at once.
“Garrick’s. He took it off his own belt at the Keyhole and give it to me and he said, use this one, it’s done the job before.”
The barn was very quiet.
“Did you know what he meant?”
The deputy’s face crumpled.
“Everybody on the Keyhole knows. They don’t say it, but they know. I never touched Hal Ashcroft, mister, I swear to God I never. I just never said.”
The stranger took a strip of spare latigo from his saddlebag, laid it over the partition, and drew Garrick’s knife once along its underside.
Then he held the cut edge to the moon.
A third of the way along, there was a tiny step in the leather, a ridge no wider than a pencil line.
He put the strip in his wallet beside the two halves of Hal Ashcroft’s latigo, and took down a coil of rope from the peg by the door.
“Here’s how this goes, Elmer. You spend the rest of the night tied to that post, because I don’t trust you as far as the door. In the morning you stand on the boardwalk and tell the town what you just told me. Then you take off that star and give it to the mayor.”
“Garrick will kill me.”
“Garrick is going to be very busy tomorrow.”
He tied the deputy to the barn post, firmly and not cruelly, and put a horse blanket around his shoulders against the cold.
Then he lay back down in his bedroll and slept for four hours as if nothing at all had happened.
The deputy stood against the post and listened to the mare eat her hay, and for the first time in two years, he thought about what kind of man he had become.
—
## The Whole Town Is Watching
They came at eight o’clock exactly.
Garrick Dorrance rode in front on the black gelding, wearing a new gun belt with a second revolver tucked into it, as if two guns could make up for the one he had lost in the street.
Corbin rode on his left and Linus on his right.
Behind them came eight Keyhole riders with rifles across their saddles.
Not twenty.
Eight.
Della Ashcroft counted them from the step of her own store, where she was standing because she had refused to stand anywhere else.
The stranger sat on the top step beside her with the poncho loose around him and three pieces of leather across his knees.
Tansy stood at the mercantile rail, in the place where Garrick’s gelding had stood the day before.
Front Street was empty, but not the way it had been the day before.
Every door stood an inch open.
Obed Stokes stood in the barbershop window with the shade all the way up, wearing his good black coat, as if he were going to church.
The riders pulled up in a loose line about forty feet from the store.
“Della. You’ve got till I count ten to bring that paper down here and sign it.”
The stranger answered for her.
“She’s not signing anything this morning, Garrick. She’s going to swear to something instead.”
Then he looked along the line of riders, one face at a time.
“You men push cows for thirty dollars a month and found. I know that wage. I paid it myself, years back. It’s an honest wage for honest work. It’s not enough to hang for.”
At the far end of the line, a gray-headed old cowhand on a mouse-colored horse had been staring at the mare at the rail since they rode up.
Now he nudged his horse out a few steps for a better look at her shoulder.
“Garrick. That’s an empty circle. On a roan.”
“So?”
The old cowhand’s name was Shad Danner, and he had come up the trail from Texas when Garrick Dorrance was still in short pants.
He took off his hat and looked at the man on the step for a long, careful moment.
“I seen that brand on a roan horse in Trinidad, back in seventy-four. I seen the man that rode it walk into a corral after the Haskins brothers by himself, and all three of them came out alive and in irons. The newspapers back East called him the Man on the Roan. Wouldn’t nobody tell the papers his name, so the ten-cent books just called him the nameless gunslinger.”
The line of riders shifted.
The stranger did not confirm it and did not deny it.
Della Ashcroft stared at him.
The circle on Hal’s saddle.
*It means I was raised right.*
Garrick’s face had gone stiff.
“I don’t care if he’s Wild Bill come up out of the grave. Ten.”
The stranger stood up, slowly, so every man in the street could see both his hands, and came down the steps with the leather.
“Before you count, Garrick, let these men see what they’re riding for.”
He held up the two halves of Hal Ashcroft’s latigo, and then the third piece beside them.
“Hal Ashcroft’s cinch strap, cut three parts through on the underside. And this one, cut last night in the livery barn with the knife Garrick Dorrance gave his deputy to cut mine. Same nick in the blade. Same step in the leather, a third of the way along. Any man who has worked leather can see it from his saddle.”
Garrick’s voice went up for the first time.
“That’s a lie and a piece of cowhide.”
The stranger did not turn his head.
“Knut.”
The blacksmith came down the middle of Front Street with the shotgun in one hand and Elmer Truax by the collar in the other, the horse blanket still around the deputy’s shoulders and straw in his hair.
Knut stood him in front of the riders and in front of the town.
Truax looked at Garrick, then at the ground, and then, with an effort the whole town could see, at Della Ashcroft.
“Garrick give me his own knife last night and he said, use this one, Elmer, it’s done the job before. Linus laughed. I’m sorry, Mrs. Ashcroft. I’m sorry I never said.”
He unpinned the tin star with fingers that would not work properly, walked it to the barbershop, and held it up until Obed Stokes opened the door and took it.
Then the stranger held up the bill of sale.
“February the eleventh. Two days after Hal Ashcroft died. One strawberry roan mare, forty dollars. Signed L. Dorrance.”
Every head in the street turned toward Linus, and Linus Dorrance went white.
“Garrick told me to. He said get rid of the mare, she’s the only one who knows. I didn’t cut nothing. I just sold the horse.”
Shad Danner put his hat back on.
“Boys, I’ve drawn my last Keyhole wage.”
He turned his horse out of the line and rode toward the livery barn, and he did not hurry and he did not look back.
Two more went after him, and then the rest.
Garrick looked around at the open doors and the faces in every window.
For the first time in his life, Paintbrush was watching him, and it was not afraid.
He swung down off the black gelding.
He did not go for either gun.
He walked straight at Della Ashcroft instead, the way he had walked into her store the day before, and his hand came up toward her hair.
She did not step back.
She stood on the bottom step of her own store with her shoulders square, and she said it before the stranger could.
“Touch me again, Garrick. Go on. The whole town is watching your hand.”
The doors opened then, all of them at once, as if somebody had pulled a single string.
Barlow Venn came out through his batwings.
Obed Stokes came out in his black coat with the deputy’s star in his fist.
The women came out of the hotel, and the freighters came out of the wagon yard, and the homesteader Hal had been carrying the flour to in February came out of the church with his hat in his hands.
Thirty or forty of them stood on the boardwalks on both sides of the street, and they did not say anything.
They did not need to.
Garrick Dorrance’s hand stopped a foot from Della’s face.
It shook.
Then it went down, not to her hair and not to his gun, but to his side.
Behind him, Corbin had climbed down from his horse.
He walked up and put a hand on his brother’s shoulder, the first time anybody in Paintbrush had ever seen him touch Garrick.
“It’s done, Garrick. It’s been done since February. You just didn’t know it.”
Garrick Dorrance stood there with his brother’s hand on his shoulder and the whole town looking at him.
Then he unbuckled his new gun belt himself and let it fall.
—
## The Empty Circle
Obed Stokes swore Della Ashcroft’s complaint on the counter of her own store at nine o’clock that morning, with the church Bible and twelve witnesses standing among the flour barrels.
She signed it with the same pen Corbin Dorrance had brought for the bill of sale, in her own hand, in the place where they had wanted her to sign her store away.
Then she read it out loud, every word, so that nobody in Paintbrush could ever say they had not heard.
*That on the ninth day of February, 1881, at the breaks of Sweetroot Creek, Garrick Dorrance did willfully cut the cinch strap of the saddle of Hal Ashcroft, causing his death.*
Her voice did not shake once.
Knut Lindqvist put irons on Garrick and Linus in his forge, carefully and without any pleasure in it.
The Friday mail buckboard left for Fort Fetterman at noon with two Dorrance brothers chained to the seat, Elmer Truax beside them as a witness, and Knut on the tailboard with the shotgun.
The stranger rode beside it on a livery bay.
He did not ride Tansy, and Della did not understand why until she went out to her hitch rail and found the roan mare still standing there with a note tucked into the bridle.
*She was Hal’s. That makes her yours. She likes the sugar in your left pocket, not your right. R.F.*
The trial was held at the September term of the district court in Cheyenne.
Elmer Truax testified for two days.
Linus Dorrance testified against his brother for one, in exchange for a charge of horse theft instead of a worse one.
Corbin, who had cut nothing and sold nothing and only kept the books, testified that Garrick had come home on the night of the ninth of February and asked him to wipe a knife.
Della Ashcroft testified last.
She told the court about the latigo and the letter and the empty circle, and the hand in her hair, and the town that had stood behind its curtains.
And she told it about the morning the town came out.
Garrick Dorrance was found guilty of murder in the second degree and sent to the territorial penitentiary for the rest of his natural life.
Linus got two years for the mare.
The stranger stayed exactly long enough to sit in the witness chair one afternoon, take his oath, and give his name to the clerk in a voice the back row could not hear.
Della heard it from the front row.
*Ransom Fairley.*
He found her waiting at the hitch rail outside the courthouse.
“Now you have it.”
“You said I’d need it in the morning. I didn’t need it at all, in the end.”
“No. You didn’t. That was the best part.”
“Why did Hal never tell me your name?”
“Because my name brings men up the road to find out if the books were true. I didn’t want that coming to his door. I’d have done better to let it come.”
“Will you come back to Paintbrush?”
“I’ll come back to see the mare. Keep the sugar in your left pocket.”
He tipped the brim of the flat brown hat, pulled the wine-red poncho around his shoulders against the first cold wind off the plains, and rode south toward Colorado on a horse that was not a roan.
She did not ask him to stay.
He did not look back.
On the first cool morning of October, Della Ashcroft walked out into the middle of Front Street in Paintbrush, to the place where Garrick Dorrance had stood with his hand in her hair.
She stood there by herself in the sun for a minute, in her own two shoes, with nobody holding her.
Down at the forge, Knut Lindqvist’s hammer was ringing on the anvil, and the town did not even hear it.
Then she climbed a ladder against the front of her store with a pot of white paint, and over the door, where the old sign had said only ASHCROFT, she lettered in her own hand:
*D. ASHCROFT. GENERAL MERCHANDISE. FAIR PRICES. NOT FOR SALE.*
Under it, small, she painted a plain circle with nothing inside it.
When she came down the ladder, the strawberry roan mare at the rail put her nose against Della’s left pocket and pushed.
Della Ashcroft laughed out loud in the middle of the street, and the whole town heard her.