They Didn’t Just K*ll the Villagers – The H*RRIFYING Truth About the Comanche Raids in Mexico
The children are playing close to the houses, the horses are out on the grass, and the workers are in the fields. It is 1835 on a ranch estate in northern Mexico. The estate is called the Hacienda de las Ánimas, the hacienda of the souls, near Parral in Chihuahua. In about four years, one of the boys playing here will be riding with the men who are about to raid it. They come out of the north, about 300 Comanche riders. They kill the men who try to fight, and they drive off the horses and the mules, but they do not just kill the villagers when they ride away; they take the children with them.
You have been told that the Comanche raids into Mexico were about horses, about stolen herds and quick money. That is not the whole story, and this was not one raid. For about 15 years, war parties of hundreds of men rode the road south into Mexico, some of them more than 600 miles from home—that is about as far as Boston is from Detroit. By one historian’s count, they killed more than 2,600 Mexicans, and they took the children, the boys and the girls, by the hundreds, and many of them never came home.
So why take the children? Why ride all that way for them? The answer is worse than anything that happened on the hacienda that day. Bernardino Saenz was one of the boys taken that day. Four years later, an American trader met him on the open plains, dressed like a Comanche, and asked him one simple question. Nobody expected his answer, not even the trader. And here is the second thing: years later, a man from Durango traveled more than 500 miles—about as far as New York is from Dallas—to find the wife the Comanches had carried off. He found her. What happened next is one of the saddest scenes of the frontier, and behind both stories there is a bigger question historians still argue about: how much these raids helped the United States win its war with Mexico.
Before we are done, you will know why the Comanches turned on Mexico, what happened to the children, and the solemn promise the United States made and then bought its way out of. Now, back to the years before that raid, to a peace that had held for almost 50 years between Spain and the Comanches. The war that emptied northern Mexico did not start with hatred; it started with the broken peace. In 1786, the Spanish Empire made peace with the Comanches, and for decades that peace mostly held. In 1821, Mexico won its independence from Spain. In 1827, the new Mexican government signed its own treaty with the Comanches at San Antonio, and it failed almost at once. By 1834, the great raids had begun.
In the early 1830s, two of the great Comanche peace chiefs died, and the men who had kept the old agreements were gone. In 1845, a Comanche war chief who strangely went by the name Santa Anna explained the war to an Indian agent in one sentence.
“The war began because the Spaniards had broken a treaty that was made some years since.”
The danger had been growing for years. As early as 1826, the state of Nuevo León ordered its people to travel only in groups of at least 30 armed men on horseback; to go from one town to the next, you needed a small army. And up on the plains, there was always a buyer. American traders at posts like Bent’s Fort on the Arkansas River and the trading houses on the Red River bought horses and mules from the raiders and sold them guns, powder, and cloth. Every stolen mule from Chihuahua had a market, and many of those buyers were Americans. Delaware and Shawnee middlemen moved the herds north and east into American hands. Mexican officials accused the Texans and the Americans of paying the raiders to bleed Mexico; historians think most of that was rumor, but the money was real, and the Comanches knew exactly where to spend it.
And when the North begged Mexico City for help, the answer rarely came. Mexico was a young country, broke and divided, and in the years before the war with the United States, governments rose and fell one after another. One minister of war is said to have answered a plea from the north in four words:
“Indians don’t unmake presidents.”
You could see what that meant. After the raid on the Hacienda de las Ánimas in 1835, the governor of Chihuahua raised a thousand volunteers and led them after the Comanches himself. They came home empty-handed, and their report was short:
“We could not overtake them.”
Understand who the Comanches were. They were the greatest horse people of the southern plains, families who moved with the buffalo with children, grandparents, and herds of thousands of horses. For a young Comanche man, a raid into Mexico meant horses, honor, a name, and a wife. As the historian Brian DeLay put it, at bottom they were fighting to win honor, avenge fallen comrades, and grow rich. And the revenge part mattered more than most people think. Every Comanche killed in Mexico was a reason for the next raid.
And there was one exception. While they raided Chihuahua and Durango, the Comanches kept the peace with New Mexico, Mexico’s own northern province. An American trader of the time noticed it. Though at continual war with the south of the republic, he wrote:
“For many years the Comanches have cultivated peace with the New Mexicans.”
New Mexico was where they traded, not where they raided. So by the middle of the 1830s, Mexico had lost the peace, lost the trade, and lost the attention of its own capital. All that was missing was a reason for the Comanches to turn their full strength south. In 1840, they found it.
In the summer of 1840, near Bent’s Fort on the Arkansas River, about 10,000 Cheyenne, Arapaho, Comanche, Kiowa, and Plains Apache camped together and made a peace that ended years of war among them. Historians call it the Great Peace. For the Comanches, it meant one thing above all: their northern border was safe. Now they could turn south, and they did not have far to look for leaders. One of them was a Penetika Comanche war chief named Buffalo Hump—Potsanaquahip in his own language—a man the Texans had already learned to fear.
That same summer, in August 1840, Buffalo Hump led the great raid on the town of Linville on the Texas coast. His warriors burned the town and left with some 3,000 horses. Hold on to that number. Mexico was about to learn what a raid that size looked like.
Again and again, every year, the road south was called the Comanche Trail. It ran from the plains of the Texas Panhandle past Horsehead Crossing on the Pecos River, down through a gap in the mountains, and across the Rio Grande in the Big Bend country. In places it was a mile wide; one explorer wrote that it was so well beaten it looked as if engineers had built it. Along its whole length lay the bones of horses and mules that had died on the march, bleaching white in the sun. You could follow it without a map; you only had to follow the bones.
From the Big Bend, the war parties crossed into Mexico and gathered in a vast desert basin called the Bolsón de Mapimí. From there they could strike in every direction—into Chihuahua, Durango, Coahuila, and Nuevo León—and farther south than anyone in Mexico City had thought possible. They rode at the same time every year. A young British officer named George Ruxton, who crossed northern Mexico in 1846, wrote it down:
“So regular are these expeditions,”
he wrote,
“that in the Comanche calendar the month of September is known as the Mexico moon.”
And these were not small bands. On more than 30 occasions between 1834 and 1846, parties of a 100 men or more crossed the Rio Grande. More than a third of them had at least 500, and on four occasions Mexican officials reported war parties of 800 to 1,000 men. A thousand men in one war party. Between those war parties and the haciendas of the north, there was almost nothing: a few poorly paid soldiers, ranchers with old muskets, and a government more than 700 miles away in Mexico City. The villages of the north were alone.
One American saw this war from the other side. Josiah Gregg was a trader on the Santa Fe Trail, a sickly young man from Missouri who had gone west on his doctor’s advice and who ended up writing one of the best books ever written about the prairies. Remember his name; he is the man who will meet the boy from the hacienda of the souls. Gregg saw what the raids looked like from the plains. He wrote that the Comanches made continual inroads upon the whole eastern frontier of Mexico, driving off immense numbers of horses and mules and killing the citizens they met or making them prisoners,
“particularly the females and boys.”
Particularly the females and boys. Read that line again, because the whole story is hiding inside it. The men were killed; the women and the boys were taken. And by 1840, the raiders had a plan for every one of them.
Now to the winter. The raids came south in full force, and the first great campaign that showed Mexico what was coming for the raiders. The season had a name of its own: this is the Mexico moon. The warning came first in January 1840. About 600 raiders struck the town of Lampazos in Nuevo León, all of them armed, a Mexican report said, with carbines and lances. A captain, 17 soldiers, and five townsfolk died. And that was before the Great Peace freed the Comanches to turn south.
It is December 1840. Several hundred Comanche riders splash across the Rio Grande with spare horses running beside them. The air is cold, the river is low, and nobody on the other side knows they are coming. The great raid of that winter has begun. They ride south for weeks through Coahuila, past the city of Saltillo, and on into Zacatecas and San Luis Potosí. They hit the mule trains on the roads; they sweep through the haciendas of San Salvador and El Salado and the mining towns of Bonanza and Concepción del Oro. Then they turn back north, driving everything they have taken in front of them.
Picture it from a hillside: first the dust, a brown wall rising over the valley; then the sound, thousands of hooves on dry ground; then the herd itself, horses and mules by the thousand. And inside it, riding in the middle of the herd, the captives. Years later, a Mexican woman who had been carried north as a captive told George Ruxton what the road north was like. Crossing the desert, she said, the raiders went four days and nights without water for their animals, and hundreds of them died on the way. The captives rode through the same desert and the same thirst.
On the 10th of January 1841, the men of Saltillo ride out to fight them. They lose. Among the dead is a lawyer and militia colonel named José María Goríbar. By one count, more than 100 Mexicans were killed in that campaign alone. When a militia force finally caught one of the returning war parties near Saltillo, it took back more than 1,500 horses. That was only part of one herd, and half of what Buffalo Hump had taken from Linville. And the raid had lasted most of the winter, from December into March.
You have been told that raiders like these struck and ran and were gone in a night. This was not that. This was a campaign months long, hundreds of miles deep, led by men who knew the roads, the water holes, and the haciendas better than the soldiers sent to stop them.
Here is the number that should stop you: between 1831 and 1848, by the count of the historian Brian DeLay, raiders from the Plains killed 2,649 Mexicans. That is more than all the American soldiers killed in battle in the entire Mexican War. And that is only the dead somebody wrote down.
Some raids were about revenge and nothing else. In October 1844, a Kiowa leader named Satank led a war party into Tamaulipas to avenge his brother. At a place called Los Moros, more than 20 men, women, and children died in the fire. 46 more men were killed when they rode in to help. Then the raiders moved on to the Rancho de la Palmita, where more than 100 people died.
To the people of northern Mexico, the whole region seemed to be burning. And on some of the raiders who died that autumn, Mexican soldiers found something that made their blood run cold: silver peace medals stamped with the face of an American president, Martin Van Buren. Medals the United States gave to Indian chiefs as a sign of friendship to Mexico. It looked like proof—proof that the United States was behind the raids, arming the raiders and waiting for northern Mexico to bleed. And in less than two years, the United States and Mexico would be at war.
But the medals were not the worst thing the raiders carried home. The worst thing was riding in the middle of the herd: boys and girls from the haciendas, a long way from home. Because the Comanches did not take children by accident; they took them on purpose, and they had a reason that almost nobody in Mexico wanted to hear.
And now we come to the strangest scene in this whole story. It is the summer of 1839, out on the open plains, and Josiah Gregg’s wagon train has met a large band of Comanches. Among them, Gregg notices a boy of 10 or 12, dressed like all the others. Gregg writes that the boy’s nationality could scarcely be detected under his Indian guise. Then the boy speaks Spanish.
“Are you not a Mexican?”
Greg asks.
“Yes, sir. I once was.”
“What is your name?”
“Bernardino, sir, at your service.”
“When and where were you taken?”
“About four years ago,”
the boy says.
“At the Hacienda de las Ánimas, near Parral.”
He is the boy from the hacienda of the souls. And then Gregg makes him the offer that any captive child should want to hear:
“Shan’t we buy you,”
Greg asks,
“and take you to your people? We are going thither.”
The boy hesitates, then he answers, and Gregg writes down every word, first in Spanish and then in English:
“Oh, no, sir. I am now too much of a brute to live among Christians.”
This is the moment the first mystery gets its answer: why take the children? Because the children became Comanches. A boy taken at six or seven could in four years forget his own country; in ten, he could be riding back into it as a raider. And Bernardino was not the only one who made that choice. Gregg saw it again and again. He wrote that the captives frequently become attached to their masters, and that these prisoners in time often turn out to be the most formidable savages. Some of them, he wrote, guided the raids back into the very country they came from. They herded the horses, they married the warriors, they became the warriors. A captive boy grew up to replace a son the band had lost; a captive girl was often made a wife. Gregg wrote:
“Every one of them made the raiders stronger and made Mexico weaker.”
In Durango, the authorities once found four Christian men guiding a Comanche war party through their own homeland. The war was not only taking Mexico’s children; it was turning them against the place they were born and the families they were born into. Nobody wrote down what a Comanche mother would have said about a captive boy in her lodge, but if she had spoken for herself, it might have sounded like this:
“The Mexicans killed my son. This boy is my son now, and when he grows up he will ride with his brothers.”
Sit with that for a moment. To the family on the hacienda, the boy was stolen. To the family in the lodge, he was replaced and loved. And to the boy himself, after four years, the hacienda was a place he no longer belonged to.
On the same day, Gregg met a woman from near Matamoros who had married a Comanche and who refused to go home. One captive, a boy of about 15, was bought for about the price of a mule and sent back to Mexico. But Bernardino Saenz stayed where he was; his keeper would not sell him, and the boy did not want to be sold. After that summer of 1839, he wrote out of the written record. Nobody knows if he ever saw Parral again.
Gregg even heard of a governor’s daughter. Some 20 years earlier, the Comanches had taken the daughter of the governor of Chihuahua. Her father sent $1,000 to ransom her. The ransom was arranged, and the girl refused to come home. If even a governor’s daughter could not be brought back, what chance did the children of the ranch hands have?
And the North was about to get worse, because a new army was marching toward Mexico, and this one wore American uniforms. Mexico was about to fight two invasions at once, one from the Plains and one from Washington, and the second would change what the first meant. It began with a war between two countries, and it ended with a promise.
In 1846, the United States went to war with Mexico. On one side, President James K. Polk, who wanted California and the Southwest; on the other, General Antonio López de Santa Ana, who kept coming back to rule Mexico. That autumn, George Ruxton, 25 years old, was riding through Durango and Chihuahua. In September 1846, he wrote that the Comanches were overrunning the whole department of Durango and Chihuahua, had cut off all communication, and had defeated the regular troops sent against them in two pitched battles.
“Upwards of 10,000 head of horses and mules have already been carried off,”
he wrote,
“and everywhere the people have been killed or captured. The roads are impassable, all traffic is stopped, the ranchos barricaded, and the inhabitants afraid to venture out of their doors.”
A rancher Ruxton met put it more simply: the Comanches were everywhere, he said, and two days before they had killed two of his men. Not a soul ventured out of his house in that part of the country. So when Mexico City asked the northern states of Chihuahua Durango and Zacatecas to send soldiers against the American invasion, none of the three sent men. Chihuahua’s deputies said their state had been afflicted and desolated for 15 years by the savages, drowned in the blood of the men.
Some historians argue that this is how the raids helped decide the war. The state legislature of Chihuahua described what daily life had become:
“We travel the roads at their whim,”
the legislators wrote,
“we cultivate the land where they wish and in the amount they wish.”
In their own country, the people of the North were living by permission.
The Americans noticed. A proclamation issued in the name of General Zachary Taylor promised the people of northern Mexico to drive back the savage Comanches and to compel them to restore to you from captivity your long-lost wives and children. The invaders were offering to rescue Mexico’s captives.
But then, and this is the reversal, the promise came true at least once. In May 1847, near the town of Parras in Coahuila, a captain named John Reid and about 30 Missouri volunteers caught a war party coming back from a raid. By most accounts, the raiders were Comanches. The Missourians killed scores of the raiders, took back hundreds of horses, and freed 18 Mexican women and children. The mayor of Parras wrote them a letter of thanks. Back in the United States, Senator Thomas Hart Benton held that letter up and called it a trophy of a new kind in war. It was a strange sight: American soldiers who had come to conquer Mexico fighting Comanches to save the women and children of the very country they were at war with. Nobody in this story was only one thing.
And Mexico had its own dark answer to the raids. In 1839, the state of Chihuahua hired an Irish-born adventurer named James Kirker to hunt Apaches for pay, and later the state paid bounties for scalps. In 1846, Kirker’s men and townsfolk killed about 130 peaceful Apaches at the town of Galeana. Most of the scalps that were paid for were Apache, not Comanche, and some of the scalp hunters killed Mexicans too and sold their hair. Neither side in this war had clean hands, and on the frontier everybody knew it.
Think about the arithmetic. By DeLay’s count, between 1831 and 1848, 2,649 Mexicans were killed in the raids, and 72 Comanches and Kiowas died fighting in Mexico. And neither number counts the captives—the ones who were not killed and who were never seen at home again.
And the Comanches had not forgotten Parras. In August 1847, Buffalo Hump, the war chief of the Linville raid, crossed the Rio Grande near the mouth of the Pecos with several hundred warriors. By September, an American Indian agent reported him deep in Mexico with 600 to 800 men out, it was said, to avenge Parras.
Somewhere in the middle of all this, far to the north at Bent’s Fort on the Arkansas River, a Mexican woman from the state of Durango was living among the American traders. Years earlier, the Comanches had carried her off in a raid on Durango. Later, a party of Kiowas brought her to the fort, and William Bent bought her. At the fort she lived with an American mountain man named Hawkins, and by 1846 she had given him a daughter. She had a new life, a new name—Mrs. Hawkins—and a child she loved. And far to the south, in Durango, her husband was still looking for her.
I promised you at the start that I would tell you what happened when he found her. It is 1846, and the man from Durango arrives at Bent’s Fort. How he learned where she was, nobody knows. George Ruxton wrote that he had come upwards of 1,500 miles to recover his lost wife. The American army is passing through on its way to Santa Fe, and its commander, Colonel Stephen Kearny, is asked to decide. Kearny rules that she should be given up to her husband, provided she is willing to go. She is willing, on one condition: she will not leave without her daughter. But Hawkins will not let her take the child.
Now she has two choices: her husband or her daughter. And so she stays at the fort with the mountain man and the little girl, and she lets her husband go. Ruxton wrote that she preferred to share the buffalo rib and venison with her mountaineer, and he finished the story in one line: eventually, the poor Durango returned to his home alone, 1,500 miles there, 1,500 miles back, and nobody riding beside him on the way home. That is what the raids did to the families who were left behind; some of them found their people, and their people were no longer theirs.
By the end of the war, even Washington knew. In December 1847, President Polk told Congress that bands of fierce and warlike savages were raiding northern Mexico, and that at this model, many Mexicans, principally females and children, are in captivity among them. Mexico, he said, has been and must continue to be too feeble to restrain them, principally females and children. Almost the same words Gregg had written years earlier about the open plains. Now they were in the mouth of the President of the United States, James K. Polk. And Polk had a plan for them.
But first, a question nobody likes to answer: how many of the captives ever came home? By DeLay’s count, 852 Mexican captives were recorded between 1831 and 1848. Of those, 580 were ransomed or rescued; the rest, almost 300, simply disappear from the paper. And those are only the ones somebody wrote down. A Mexican minister of war told Congress in 1848 that the Indians still held more than 600 captives, women and children. Where they ended up and what they became will stay unfinished forever. And the United States had just promised to bring them home. An American official sent to the new border would later sum up what happened to that promise in a single sentence. We will come to it.
Then came the promise that was supposed to pay for all of it. After almost two years of fighting, the United States and Mexico signed the treaty that ended the war. Inside it was one line northern Mexico had been waiting 15 years to hear. Call it the solemn promise. It was signed at Guadalupe Hidalgo, outside Mexico City, on February 2nd, 1848. Mexico gave up nearly half of its territory, and in Article 11 of that treaty, the United States made a promise about the raiders who lived on the land it had just taken.
“All such incursions,”
said Article 11 of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo,
“shall be forcibly restrained by the government of the United States.”
No American could buy a Mexican captive or a stolen Mexican horse, and the United States bound itself in the most solemn manner to rescue the captives and return them to their country. For the people of northern Mexico, that was the only good thing in the whole treaty. The American negotiator reported that the North had accepted the peace because of that one article; they had lost the war, but at least they thought the raids would stop.
They did not stop. Remember Chief Santa Anna, the Comanche who blamed the Spaniards for breaking the old treaty? In December 1846, he had visited Washington; in 1848 and 1849, he led raids into Mexico anyway, against the new treaty. He did not live long enough to be punished. In late 1849, cholera swept through his people and killed more than 300 Penateka Comanches in a few weeks. Santa Anna was one of them. The disease did what no army had done.
And the raids went on. In 1854, John Russell Bartlett, the American commissioner sent to draw the new border, wrote that the Comanches still crossed the Rio Grande in bands of 300 or 400 and penetrated the very heart of Chihuahua. Then he wrote the sentence that should have shamed his own government:
“Yet the system flourishes in full vigor, notwithstanding the efforts made to suppress it on the part of the United States in compliance with the solemn stipulations of the treaty with Mexico.”
Read that line twice. In July 1853, at Fort Atkinson on the Arkansas River, the Comanches and Kiowas themselves signed a treaty with the United States. They promised to stop raiding Mexico and to restore all captives that may hereafter be taken—hereafter, not the captives they already had.
In Durango alone, the state’s officials later counted nearly 6,000 people killed over 20 years of raids, 748 carried off, and 358 settlements abandoned. Whole villages were simply left to the wind. In 1849, the governor of Durango set aside at least 2,000 pesos to buy back the state’s captives.
“For this sacred purpose,”
he wrote in the official papers.
All of this had a polite name: depredations. Mexico’s claims against the United States were filed as claims for Indian depredations, and by one count they added up to more than $31 million. Depredations. That is the word for a burned village, a dead father, and a child who never came home.
And there are people in this story that almost nobody remembers: the boy of 15 who was sold for the price of a mule; the woman from Matamoros who would not go home; the almost 300 captives on DeLay’s list who simply stop appearing; and Bernardino Saenz, who rode off the edge of the page in 1839. The witnesses did not outlive the war by long. George Ruxton died in St. Louis in 1848 at 27. Josiah Gregg died in the mountains of northern California in 1850 after a fall from his horse, weak from hunger. Buffalo Hump lived on into the reservation years, though the accounts differ on when he died.
Now look at the chain from start to finish: in 1786 Spain made peace with the Comanches, Mexico lost it, and by 1834 the great raids had begun. The raids emptied the North, and in 1846 the United States invaded a country already bleeding, and in 1848 the treaty that ended the war made the solemn promise. Every link was somebody’s answer to the link before it.
The raids into Mexico faded in the 1850s and 1860s with cholera, drought, the vanishing buffalo, and the new American forts. The end came in Texas on June 2nd, 1875. Quanah Parker, the leader of the last free Comanche band on the plains, brought his people in to surrender at Fort Sill. But by then the United States had already settled its own debt to Mexico in a way that is rarely told.
So why take the children? Because a captive child could become a Comanche, a herder, a wife, a warrior, and sometimes a raider riding back into the country that lost him. The raiders did not just kill the villagers; they took the next generation.
Here is the detail that changes how you see this whole story: on December 30th, 1853, in Mexico City, the United States signed a new treaty with Mexico, the one most people remember as the Gadsden Purchase. The United States paid $10 million for a strip of desert and for something else. In Article 2 of that treaty, Mexico released the United States from all liability under Article 11—the promise to stop the raids and bring the captives home, made in the most solemn manner, was bought back in the same deal as a strip of land for a railroad.
And the raids did not stop when the promise was sold. Both things were true at the same time: the United States had made the promise, and the United States had paid to be free of it. The captives stayed where they were, and the frontier was full of promises like that.
In 1879, on the White River in Colorado, a government agent made promises of his own to the Ute people, and it ended with the women of his family carried off into the mountains. We will follow that trail next.
But first, there is one more road to travel today. If you drive south into Big Bend National Park on Highway 385 through Persimmon Gap, you are driving the old Comanche Trail. On one side of the Rio Grande, a national park; on the other, the towns that the Mexico moon emptied. Two memories of the same road.
Go back to that boy on the open plains in 1839, dressed like a Comanche, answering an American trader in Spanish. He had been taken from the hacienda of the souls, and he decided he could not go home. Some captives were never rescued; some no longer wanted to be.