News

They Didn’t Just K*ll the Settlers – The H*RRIFYING Truth About Catherine & Sophia German (1874)

It is dawn on the Kansas prairie and a family of nine is breaking camp. The frost is still on the grass, the cattle are restless, and the wagon is almost packed. The date is September 11th, 1874. They are camped beside the Smoky Hill River in western Kansas in the cold before sunrise. One day’s walk west there is an army post called Fort Wallace with soldiers, a doctor, and safety. Tonight, if nothing goes wrong, they will be there. They never reach it. Riders come out of the grass and within minutes five members of the family are dead: the father, the mother, the only son, and two of the daughters.

You have been told this is a story about a family that was killed on the prairie. That is not the whole story. It is not even the worst part of it. This family had come more than a thousand miles from Georgia—farther than New York to Chicago—and five of them died one day short. Four girls were left alive; the oldest was 17, the youngest was five. And the riders put them on horses and carried them south, away from everything they had ever known.

So why spare four girls? Why kill a farmer, his wife, and three of their older children, and keep the four who could not fight back? The answer is darker than the killing. The oldest captive was Katherine German, 17 years old. Her sister Sophia was 12. For almost 6 months they would be dragged from camp to camp while the army hunted for them through rain, snow, and war.

And here is the second thing: 2 months after the attack, soldiers riding through an abandoned Cheyenne camp in Texas saw a pile of buffalo hides move. What they found underneath it is one of the most heartbreaking scenes of the whole frontier, and what was done to the older girls on that ride the old books would not print.

Before we are done, you will know why that war party came into Kansas, what happened on the long ride south into Texas, who found the little ones under the hides, and how a few words spoken in a chief’s lodge set the older sisters free.

This story is one they cleaned up more than most, and it starts long before Kansas.

Now go back four years before that frosty morning on the Smoky Hill. Go back to the beginning of the road west, to a small, worn-out farm high in the mountains of North Georgia in the spring of 1870. John German farmed a hillside in Fannin County, near the little town of Morganton in the Blue Ridge country of North Georgia. He married a girl named Lydia Cox, and together they raised a house full of children on land that was never quite big enough to feed them all. It was steep country with thin soil and long winters—the kind of place people left.

When the Civil War came, John German went to fight for the Confederacy, and he was taken prisoner. When he finally came home in 1865, the farm was in ruins, the fields were overgrown, and he had a family to feed with nothing but his own two hands. Like thousands of other men in the ruined South, he started to look west.

By 1869, there were seven children in the German house, all of them growing up on the same small hillside farm: Rebecca Jane, the oldest, then Steven, the only boy, then Catherine, Joanna, Sophia, Julia, and finally little Addie, the baby of the family. Catherine, the third child, was born in 1857, so she was old enough to remember the hungry years of the war.

Then a letter came from a friend urging them west to Colorado. Colorado was booming; there was land and there was work. On April 10th, 1870, the Germans loaded everything they owned into a wagon and left Georgia for good. They had no idea that the trip would take them 4 years—longer than the whole Civil War had lasted.

They did not get far before the money ran out. In Howell County, Missouri, they stopped among relatives and stayed for more than 2 years, working, saving, and waiting for the chance to move on. That was the pattern of the whole journey: stop, work, save, and move a little farther west. In Kansas, near the town of Elgin, John and his son Steven hired themselves out to plow fields on the Osage reservation, and they plowed for 10 months. Steven was 18 by then, strong enough to do a man’s work, and the family needed every dollar he could earn.

Every stop cost them another season. Four years on the road, and they were still not there.

August 1874: the family rolls into Ellis, Kansas, at the edge of the danger zone where the settled country ends and the open plains begin. Ellis sits on the Kansas Pacific Railway, one of the last towns before the empty country. And here someone gives John German a piece of advice that will decide everything that comes after:

“Take the old stage road up the Smoky Hill River,” they tell him, “straight to Fort Wallace. That way there will be water for the cattle every night.”

The advice is about water. Nobody warns them about the war.

From Ellis to Fort Wallace is about 140 miles of open grass—a little over 2 hours by car today. For a family walking beside one wagon and a few cattle, it is well over a week. A week of river bottoms, empty hills, and wide sky. And between that wagon and the war, there is nothing at all.

Because in the summer of 1874, the southern plains were burning, and the people who had set them on fire had their own list of reasons, older and deeper than anything the German family had ever heard of. For years, the Southern Cheyenne, the Comanche, and the Kiowa had watched the buffalo herds vanish. White hunters shot the animals by the thousands, took the hides, and left the meat to rot on the grass. Trainloads of hides were shipped east while the carcasses piled up on the prairie. For the people of the plains, the buffalo was food, shelter, clothing—everything—and it was disappearing in front of their eyes.

In June of 1874, hundreds of warriors attacked a trading post of buffalo hunters at a place called Adobe Walls in the Texas Panhandle. They expected an easy victory. Instead, the hunters’ long-range rifles cut them down from inside the walls, and the warriors rode away carrying their dead. Among the warriors that day was a young Comanche war leader named Quanah. Among the hunters behind the walls was a young man named Billy Dixon. Keep both of those names in mind.

The attack had been sold to the warriors by a young Comanche medicine man named Isa-tai, who promised them that the hunters’ bullets could not hurt them. When the bullets did, the anger did not go away; it needed somewhere else to land. That defeat set off a summer of revenge raids across Kansas, Colorado, and Texas. Wagon trains, survey crews, and lonely ranches all along the frontier were about to pay for Adobe Walls.

One of the bands that rode north out of that defeat was led by a Southern Cheyenne war leader named Medicine Water. Understand who these people were: they were not a faceless horde out of an old movie. They were families with children and grandparents and women who had already buried more relatives than most settlers would lose in a whole lifetime. Many of them had survived Sand Creek in 1864, where Colorado soldiers attacked a sleeping camp at dawn. Some had survived the Washita in 1868, where Custer’s cavalry struck another winter camp the same way. And now, in 1874, they had lost again at Adobe Walls.

Sand Creek matters more than any other name on that list. A Cheyenne chief named Black Kettle had camped where army officers had told him he would be safe, and he flew an American flag over his lodge to show that he was at peace. The soldiers came anyway. Most of the dead were women, children, and old people; they died under an American flag.

Riding with Medicine Water that summer was his wife. Her name was Mochi, Buffalo Calf Woman, and 10 years earlier she had been inside the camp at Sand Creek. By her own account, she watched a soldier shoot her mother in the head. In the story that her people still tell, that same soldier then tried to attack her, and she killed him with her grandfather’s rifle. It was November 29th, 1864, at Sand Creek, Colorado, and Mochi was 24 years old. After that day, she became a warrior.

On August 24th, 1874, Medicine Water’s band struck a party of government surveyors in what is now Meade County, Kansas. Captain Oliver Short, his 14-year-old son Truman, and four other men were killed. News of the killings spread across the Kansas frontier, and settlers began to pull back toward the towns. But the band was not finished. From Meade County in August of 1874, the band turned north toward the Smoky Hill. Whether they rode there hunting for wagons on the old stage road or simply crossed the trail and found one, the sources do not say. What every account agrees on is where they were on the morning of September 11th.

Think about the arithmetic of that morning: on one side, 19 riders, two of them women who had been at war all summer; on the other, a family of nine—a tired farmer, his wife, and seven children—with one wagon and a few cattle. The German family’s fate had already been decided in a war they had never even heard of.

Now back to dawn on the Smoky Hill and the last few minutes the German family would ever spend together.

It is the 11th of September, 1874. The family is breaking camp, the children are doing their morning chores, and John German is getting the wagon ready to roll. Fort Wallace is one day away. Fort Wallace had been built for exactly this kind of danger; the army set up the post in 1865 to guard the stage line and the travelers on the Smoky Hill Road. For a family on that road, the fort meant guns, a surgeon, and a night’s sleep without fear.

It starts as a sound: hoofbeats out in the grass, coming fast. The cattle lift their heads, and then they scatter. The smoke from the morning fire is still hanging in the cold air when the riders reach the camp, and there is no time to run and nowhere to run to. John is shot, and he goes down beside the wagon. Lydia runs to him, and according to later accounts, it is Mochi herself who strikes her down with a tomahawk. In the family’s memory, Rebecca Jane, 20 years old, grabs an axe and tries to fight; she does not last long. John, Lydia, Steven (19), Rebecca Jane (20), Joanna (15)—in a few minutes on a cold morning one day from safety, five people who had walked together for 4 years are gone.

The riders take what they want from the wagon and then they set it on fire. All five of the dead are scalped, and four girls—Catherine, Sophia, Julia, and Addie—stand beside the Smoky Hill River in the smoke of that September morning and watch it happen.

You have been told that frontier raids were about horses and plunder, quick and impersonal, over in an hour. This one was not. The four girls who were taken were going to learn that the killing took minutes, and what came after would take months.

Here is the number that should stop you: what happened to the girls on the ride south, we know mostly from Catherine. And she carried it for 53 years before she told it to her niece for a small book that was published in 1927. She was 17 when it happened, and 70 when the book came out. Even then, there were things she would only hint at.

The band rode south out of Kansas, across Indian Territory, and down into the Texas Panhandle in the autumn of 1874. The girls were kept cold, hungry, and exposed to the weather on horseback for days at a time, with almost nothing to eat. That autumn the rains came hard; the creeks flooded, and the girls rode on through mud and cold. Sophia was 12. Sixty years later, she still remembered that ride in plain words:

“When I got so tired I could hardly stay on, they tied my feet by a thong under the horse’s belly.”

The strap cut into her legs so deeply that she said she still carried the scars—a 12-year-old girl tied to a moving horse day after day.

The old histories used polite words for what happened next, words like “hardship” and “indignity.” What Catherine remembered was worse. She said that young warriors from the war party assaulted her. And not only once; she said that some of the worst humiliation came not from the men, but from the women of the camp, and above all from Mochi, the woman who had watched her own mother die at Sand Creek.

Then, somewhere on that ride, the band made a decision that split the sisters in two. Julia (seven) and Addie (five) were traded away to another Cheyenne band, the people of a chief named Greybeard. Catherine and Sophia stayed with Medicine Water. Greybeard led his people down the eastern side of the Llano Estacado, the great flat tableland that runs from Texas into New Mexico; Medicine Water went down the western side, probably crossing into New Mexico. For the first time in their lives, the four sisters were apart, and none of them knew if the others were still alive.

In Greybeard’s camp, the two little girls were mostly neglected. Nobody wanted them, and nobody fed them much; some family accounts even say they were left to fend for themselves for weeks. And that trade, which looked like a death sentence for the two smallest German girls, would turn out to be the thing that saved them.

This is the moment the first mystery gets its answer: why did the riders kill five and spare four? On the southern plains in 1874, a dead girl was worth nothing at all; a living captive was worth something. And that value is exactly what would bring the army after them.

Look at what a captive was worth: adoption, horses, ransom, protection. A captive could be adopted to replace a son or a daughter lost to the soldiers. A captive could be traded to another band for horses. A captive could be ransomed back to the whites for guns, blankets, and food. And when the army came, a captive could be protection—the only thing standing between a camp and a cavalry charge. The girls were the currency.

That is the cold truth under this whole story. It is why Julia and Addie were handed from one band to another like a pair of horses, and it is why the four of them were kept alive, and why they were never safe. They were starved, they were beaten, they were traded. And for the people in that war party who had lost mothers and children of their own at Sand Creek, keeping the daughters of the enemy alive and making them suffer was also a kind of revenge.

Nobody wrote down what the women of that camp would have said about it, but if they had spoken for themselves, it might have sounded like this:

“Soldiers came into our camp at dawn and killed our mothers. Now the daughters of the whites will learn what that feels like.”

Sit with that for a moment. Every one of those uses—adoption, horses, ransom, protection—needed the girls alive. And not one of them needed the girls to be well, or fed, or warm, or unafraid. That is the whole difference between being spared and being saved.

And the German sisters were not the first. In 1836, a 9-year-old girl named Cynthia Ann Parker was carried off from her family’s fort in Texas by Comanche raiders; she grew up Comanche, married a war chief, and had a son. That son was Quanah, the same young war leader who rode against the hunters at Adobe Walls in the summer of 1874. A living captive was worth hunting for.

Back in Kansas in September 1874, soon after the attack, the burned wagon was found on the Smoky Hill, with the five bodies lying in the cold grass beside it. The dead were buried. Word of the killings spread east, and the army that was already at war on the southern plains now had a new reason to finish it.

This is the turn in our story: the charge of the wagon train. The man in charge of the hunt was Colonel Nelson A. Miles of the Fifth Infantry. He was 35 years old, a former store clerk from Massachusetts who had never been to West Point and who had climbed to command through the bloodiest battles of the Civil War. He was ambitious, hungry for a general’s star, and the fate of the German girls was about to become his cause.

That autumn, five army columns were closing in on the Texas Panhandle from every direction: from Kansas, from New Mexico, from Indian Territory, and from Texas itself. The idea was simple: give the free bands of the southern plains no place left to run.

And understand what that looked like from the other side. In Palo Duro Canyon in September 1874, troops captured the horse herds of Comanche, Kiowa, and Cheyenne camps and shot more than a thousand of the horses so their owners could never ride them again. Lodges were burned; winter food was burned. For the Cheyenne families running from those columns with their children and their old people, it must have felt like Sand Creek all over again, only slower. Neither side in this war had clean hands, and both sides knew it.

Two names matter from this point on: Nelson A. Miles, who wanted the German sisters back, and a Cheyenne chief named Stone Calf, who would end up holding the lives of the two oldest in his hands.

From his scouts and from Cheyenne prisoners, Miles learned something that changed everything: the four German girls were still alive, and two of them were somewhere in the camp of Greybeard. The other two were somewhere else, farther west, with the band that had killed their family.

On the night of November 4th, Miles sent out a young officer named Frank D. Baldwin, his chief of scouts, with a small detachment of cavalry, infantry, and scouts, and one little mountain howitzer. Baldwin was 32 years old and he already wore a Medal of Honor from the Civil War. But Baldwin’s real job was not to fight; it was to take a train of supply wagons back to be refilled—23 six-mule wagons, and every single one of them empty. The infantrymen marched beside them on foot, and nobody expected those wagons to see a fight.

After three days and nights of marching through rough country, the column camps in a grove of cottonwoods on McClellan Creek in the Texas Panhandle. It is bitterly cold. They light only the fires they need to make coffee.

On the morning of the 8th of November, 1874, a scout comes galloping back to the column. Ahead of them, he says, is a big Cheyenne camp, with lodges and pony herds everywhere. The scout is W.F. Schmalsley, and his report, as it was retold years later, is short:

“We are sure it is Greybeard’s band. His tepee is there.”

Somewhere inside that camp—though nobody in the column can see them yet—are Julia and Addie German.

Baldwin is outnumbered, and he knows it. Waiting for reinforcements is the safe choice. But if he waits, the camp will see him and run, and the captives will go with it, or worse. What he does next is one of the strangest charges in the history of the American army. He puts his infantrymen into the empty wagons. He lines up the 23 wagons in a double column beside the cavalry, with the howitzer in the middle. Then the trumpeter sounds the charge, and the whole thing—horses, mules, wagons, and men—goes rolling down the slope and straight through the Cheyenne camp.

The people in the camp run, leaving almost everything behind. The fighting goes on for about 4 hours across about 12 miles of open plain—roughly the length of Manhattan—until the men and the animals are too exhausted to go on. Behind them, Greybeard’s camp stands empty.

This is the scene that every telling of this story lingers on longest. Riding through that empty camp are Baldwin’s scouts, and one of them is Billy Dixon, the same young buffalo hunter who had fought at Adobe Walls that summer. Two months earlier, he had earned a Medal of Honor of his own in a fight at a place called Buffalo Wallow. As the scouts pass a pile of buffalo hides, somebody sees it move. Under the hides are Julia and Addie German—seven and five years old, starving, scarred, bruised, and so burned by the sun that the men can barely recognize them.

Accounts differ on exactly who reached them first, a scout or an infantryman from the Fifth, but they agree on what happened next: the two little girls start talking and they cannot stop, and they tell the soldiers everything. Billy Dixon later remembered that hard men—scouts and soldiers who had seen everything the plains could do—turned away so nobody would see their faces.

Frank D. Baldwin received his second Medal of Honor for that morning in 1874. His citation says that he could have waited for reinforcements, but that the delay would have permitted the Indians to escape and kill their captives.

Stop and picture what that sentence means. If Baldwin had done the sensible thing and waited, the camp would have scattered across the Llano Estacado, and the army believed the two little girls would have been killed. Instead, a lieutenant gambled with a train of empty wagons, and he won.

Julia and Addie were put in the care of an army surgeon and sent north to Fort Leavenworth in Kansas. They were safe. But two of the German sisters were still out there somewhere on the high plains with winter coming on. Catherine was 17 and Sophia was 12, and they were still with Medicine Water’s people somewhere along the western edge of the Llano Estacado.

And that winter, almost everyone in that camp was starving, captives and captors alike. In September at Palo Duro, the free bands had lost their horses, their lodges, and their winter food. In November, Greybeard’s camp was broken at McClellan Creek. By December, the snow had come. The winter of 1874 became a slow disaster for every free Cheyenne band on the southern plains.

So in January 1875, Miles and another officer, Lieutenant Colonel Thomas H. Neil, tried something different. Instead of sending more soldiers, they sent messengers—friendly Kiowa riders out onto the plains to find the Cheyenne camps and tell them it was time to come in. On January 20th, Neil even wrote a letter to the two captive sisters themselves and told them to read it out to the chiefs who held them.

The Kiowa riders found Stone Calf’s camp on a branch of the Pecos River, near the line between Texas and New Mexico. By then, Medicine Water’s band was camped with Stone Calf’s people. Stone Calf was bringing his band back from far to the south, and they were hungry, cold, and tired of running.

The messengers told Stone Calf, a Southern Cheyenne chief, that peace now depended on one thing: the safety of Catherine and Sophia German. Those were the few words spoken in a chief’s lodge that would set the older sisters free.

Stone Calf did not argue. He had the two sisters moved into a lodge right next to his own, where he could see who came and went. From that day on, anyone who wanted to hurt them would have to go through a chief first.

I promised you at the start that I would tell you how the older sisters got out. It was not a cavalry charge. In the first days of March 1875, by most accounts, Stone Calf, Greybeard, Red Moon, and other chiefs brought their bands in to surrender at the Darlington Agency in Indian Territory. That is when Catherine and Sophia were finally released. The sources disagree on the exact day. By one count, Stone Calf alone brought in 820 Cheyenne people when he surrendered: starving families, worn-out horses, and two girls from Georgia who had been gone for almost 6 months.

And then came the moment the army had been waiting for. The surrendered Cheyenne were gathered, and the two sisters were asked to point out the people who had killed their family and the ones who had abused them. We do not know exactly what that moment looked like—a 17-year-old girl standing in front of the people who had done this to her. But we know how it ended: Catherine and Sophia pointed.

Among the people they picked out were Medicine Water and his wife, Mochi. Both of them, along with the others the sisters named, were put in irons and held for punishment. The girl who had been carried off from the Smoky Hill had just decided the fate of her captors.

And yet, many years later, when someone asked Catherine how she felt about those people, her answer was not what you would expect. We will come back to it.

But the story did not end in Stone Calf’s Lodge. The people who did this, the people who saved the sisters, and the $10,000 that would pay for their future were all about to collide in a way that almost nobody telling this story expects.

From the Darlington Agency, the prisoners were sent east. And the story of the German sisters became a story about what the country would do next. What followed was the price and who paid it.

The army picked out 74 prisoners from the southern plains for punishment: 35 Cheyenne, 27 Kiowa, 11 Comanche, and one Caddo. All of them prisoners sent east, far from everything they knew. Greybeard, the chief whose camp had held the two little sisters, never made it; on the way east, by army accounts, he tried to take his own life, was stopped, and was later shot and killed while trying to escape.

The rest were taken in prison wagons to Fort Leavenworth and then by train all the way to Florida, to an old Spanish stone fortress in St. Augustine called Fort Marion. They would stay there for 3 years. Their jailer, an officer named Richard Henry Pratt, handed them ledger books and colored pencils, and some of the prisoners filled them with drawings of the life they had lost. Pratt later used what he learned there to found the Carlisle Indian School.

Mochi was among them, the only woman in the group. She is often described as the only Native American woman the United States Army ever held as a prisoner of war. She stayed at Fort Marion until 1878, went home to Indian Territory, and died there 3 years later. Medicine Water came home from Fort Marion, too; the accounts of how long he lived after that do not agree.

Catherine and Sophia were taken north to Fort Leavenworth in 1875. And there, for the first time since the morning on the Smoky Hill, all four German sisters were together again.

Colonel Nelson A. Miles, the man who had hunted for them, was named their legal guardian. And the man who hunted for them went on to become one of the most famous soldiers in America: Nelson A. Miles, who sent Baldwin to McClellan Creek in 1874, accepted the surrender of Geronimo in 1886, and in 1895 became commanding general of the whole United States Army.

Congress set aside $10,000 for the four sisters for their support and their schooling; when each girl turned 21, she would receive $2,500. Remember that money; we will come back to where it came from.

They were raised by a Kansas couple, Patrick Corny and his wife. All four of the German sisters grew up, married, and built families of their own in Kansas, Colorado, and California. They became Catherine Swerdfagger, Sophia Feldman, Julia Brooks, and Adelaide Andrews.

In 1927, Catherine’s niece, Grace E. Meredith, published a small book built on Catherine’s own memories. It was called Girl Captives of the Cheyennes. It is the story Catherine finally told, and it is the closest thing we have to the voice of the girl who was 17 on the Smoky Hill.

And this is the answer Catherine gave years later when she was asked if she hated the people who had done this to her:

“Oh no. I saw how they suffered while I lived with them that winter. So many died from the cold and lack of food. Besides, I am a Christian and cannot live with hate.”

Read that line twice.

And there are people in this story that almost nobody remembers: Joanna German, 15 years old, who appears in the histories only as a name on a list of the dead; Steven, 19, who plowed Osage fields to pay for a trip he never finished; and the Cheyenne children who did not live through the winter of 1874, whose names are in no army report at all.

Now look at the chain from start to finish: Sand Creek in 1864 made Mochi a warrior; the Smoky Hill in 1874 made Catherine a captive; and Fort Marion in 1875 made Mochi a prisoner. Every link was somebody’s answer to the link before it.

The places are still marked. In 1928, Adelaide came back to the creek where she had been found under the hides at 5 years old, with Sophia beside her. In 1936, Texas put up a granite marker near McClellan Creek with the story of the rescue carved into its face. And in 1952, the town of Pampa, Texas, welcomed Julia back as its guest of honor.

But the $10,000 still had one more secret.

So why did the riders on the Smoky Hill let four girls live? Because a living captive was worth something: in horses, in ransom, in revenge, and in the end, in peace. The same value that kept them alive is what kept them suffering.

Here is the detail that changes how you see this whole story: the $10,000 that Congress gave the German sisters did not come out of the national treasury. It was taken out of the annuities owed to the Cheyenne people—the payments they had been promised by treaty. Those annuities came from a treaty signed in October 1867 at Medicine Lodge Creek in Kansas, where the Cheyenne were promised food, clothing, and supplies every year in exchange for their land and for peace. Less than 10 years later, part of that promise was taken back to pay for the German sisters.

That means the sisters’ future was paid for by the whole tribe, including families who had never been anywhere near the Smoky Hill and who were hungry themselves that winter. Justice for one family and a bill for another: both things were true at the same time.

And the Cheyenne were not the only riders who took captives on the southern plains. Across the Rio Grande in northern Mexico, the Comanche had been raiding whole villages for generations on a scale that makes this story look small. We will follow that trail next.

But first, there is one more grave in this story. On the 4th of July, 1957, an old woman named Julia German Brooks came all the way from California to the old Army Cemetery at Fort Wallace in Kansas. She was there for the dedication of a marker over a common grave: the grave of her mother, her father, her brother, and two of her sisters. Less than a hundred miles west of that grave in Colorado is Sand Creek, where Mochi watched her own mother die. Today it is a National Historic Site.

Two graves, two memories from the same war. Think back to that frosty morning on the Smoky Hill, one day’s walk from Fort Wallace. The German family never made it there together. It took Julia 83 years to finish the last day of the trip.

You Might Also Enjoy