News

The Torture of the Queen’s Nurse: How Spain Blamed a French Princess for an Inbred Dynasty’s Empty Cradle

Madrid, July 1685. In a tower room of the court jail at about half past two in the morning, a French woman in her 40s was tied to the rack. She was the Queen of Spain’s own wet nurse. A harpsichordist had sworn that she secretly fed the Queen pills to stop a royal pregnancy. Outside, gangs were stoning anyone who looked French. The Queen was Marie Louise d’Orléans, married at 17 to Charles II, a king whose jaw jutted so far that an English envoy said he swallowed food whole. Six years and no heir. Madrid blamed her. To understand how a queen’s nurse ended up on a rack in a Spanish prison, you have to go back 23 years to Paris and to a birth that disappointed almost everyone in the room.

Marie Louise was born at the Palais Royal on the 26th of March, 1662. Her father was Philippe, Duke of Orléans, the only brother of King Louis XIV. Her mother was Henrietta, the youngest daughter of King Charles I of England. That made the baby a granddaughter of two kings, which sounds like the best possible start in life. The problem was that she was a girl. Royal families wanted sons, and her parents were no exception. According to one 19th century biographer, when Henrietta learned she had given birth to a daughter, she exclaimed, “Then throw her into the river!” It’s a brutal line, and we only have it secondhand, but it fits the pressure every royal mother lived under.

The same account says the baby’s grandmother, the formidable Anne of Austria, consoled Henrietta with a different thought. A girl born so close in age to the little dauphin, the heir to France, might one day become a queen herself. Someone had to feed this unwanted princess, and her father chose a woman named Nicole Quentin, the wife of his own household surgeon. In royal houses, the wet nurse was more than a servant. She was often the closest thing a child had to a constant physical daily mother.

Remember that name. 23 years later, Nicole Quentin would be the woman tied to the rack in Madrid. And whatever her mother first said about her, Marie Louise did not grow up unloved. She became her father’s favorite child. She lived mostly at the Palais Royal in Paris and at the Chateau of Saint-Cloud, just west of the city, with every privilege France could offer. Her grandmother, Anne of Austria, doted on her.

And when Anne died in 1666, she left the little girl the bulk of her fortune. Her other grandmother, the widowed queen of England, Henrietta Maria, kept her company at her house in Colombes. She was given the education of a princess who would one day sit on a throne. She learned to ride, to play the harpsichord, to sing, to dance, and to hold polished conversation. She was also, apparently, a child with a temper. One of the women charged with shaping her character worked hard to curb what were described as her frequent fits of anger. The spoiled, impulsive girl and the frightened, isolated woman she later became are the same person.

Keep both of them in mind. Then, in the summer after she turned eight, her world cracked open. Her mother, Henrietta, was no ordinary duchess. She was the beloved sister of King Charles II of England. And in the spring of 1670, she crossed the channel to help negotiate a secret treaty between her brother and Louis XIV. It was signed on the 1st of June. She returned to France in the middle of June. A few days later, on the 29th of June, at Saint Cloud, she drank a glass of iced chicory water, something she drank almost every day. She had been unwell for months with recurring pains in her side. This time, almost at once, she clutched her side in agony.

She was convinced she had been poisoned and begged for an antidote. Over the next few hours, her condition collapsed. In the early morning of the 30th of June, 1670, Henrietta died. She was 26 years old. Louis XIV ordered an autopsy carried out by French doctors with English observers present. The autopsy found no evidence of poison at all. That did not stop the talk. At court, people whispered that friends of her husband’s jealous male favorite had slipped something into her cup. Modern writers have suggested a burst ulcer, an infection of the lining of the abdomen, or other causes. The true cause of her death has never been settled.

What we do know is that a little girl of eight lost her mother suddenly, painfully, and amid cries of poison. She left behind two daughters, Marie Louise and a baby sister, Anne Marie, not yet a year old. A little brother had already died in 1666. In those years, the bond between Marie Louise and her nurse grew even closer. Of all the people around her, Nicole Quentin was the one who stayed. Her father, Philippe, did not stay a widower for very long. The French crown needed him to produce sons, and in 1671, he married a German princess, Elizabeth Charlotte of the Palatinate, known to history as Liselotte.

Stepmothers rarely come off well in royal stories, but this one did. Liselotte was blunt, funny, and a compulsive letter writer, and she grew genuinely close to Marie Louise. Later, when the girl was living far away, Liselotte would send two letters every single week for a while. Then, life settled again, and at the French court, people began to say something very flattering about the teenage princess. Her cousin, the Dauphin, the only surviving son of Louis XIV, was almost exactly her age. They often danced together at court balls. The old prediction from her cradle seemed to be coming true. “Marie Louise,” people murmured, “might one day be queen of France.” It was a lovely idea.

It was also never really on the table. Louis XIV did not marry off members of his family because they enjoyed dancing together. He married them to win treaties, borders, and futures. And by the late 1670s, the future he cared about most lay south of the Pyrenees, in Spain. Louis’s own little daughter, Marie Thérèse, had once seemed destined for that throne. The court already treated her as a future queen of Spain.

Then, in 1672, she died at the age of five. Louis had no other legitimate daughter to offer. What he did have was a niece of exactly the right age, rank, and reputation for beauty. The moment came in 1678 and 1679 when France and Spain made peace at Nijmegen after years of war. A royal marriage was the traditional way to seal a peace. Historians have pointed out that the arrangement suited Louis either way. If his niece gave Spain an heir, that child would be half French. If she gave Spain no heir at all, Louis’s own descendants, through his Spanish wife, had a claim to the whole Spanish Empire.

That brings us to the groom. Charles II of Spain was born in Madrid on the 6th of November, 1661. He was the only surviving son of King Philip IV and his second wife, Mariana of Austria. Mariana was not just Philip’s wife, she was also his niece. The Spanish and Austrian branches of the Habsburg family had married each other for generations, uncles to nieces and cousins to cousins to keep crowns, lands, and claims inside the family. Charles became king at the age of three when his father died in 1665. As a small child, he survived measles, chickenpox, rubella, and smallpox, any of which could kill. He also had rickets and he could not walk unaided until he was four.

He wore leg braces until he was five. His modern biographer, Elisabetta Lurgo, describes the young king in the year of the marriage. He was not yet 18, but his unsteady walk was obvious to everyone. He often seemed drowsy. Epileptic seizures left him exhausted and he suffered from repeated intestinal trouble. And then, there was his face. The Habsburgs were famous for a long, jutting lower jaw. Doctors today call it mandibular prognathism, which simply means the lower jaw grows too far forward. In Charles, Lurgo writes, “It was so pronounced that swallowing was very difficult and excess saliva made his speech hard to follow.” Years later, in the 1690s, the English envoy Alexander Stanhope wrote home that the king “swallows all he eats whole for his nether jaw stands so much out that his two rows of teeth cannot meet.” So yes, a king who really couldn’t chew.

That description comes from his 30s, but the jaw itself had been with him since birth. It would be easy to stop there and call him a monster, and plenty of writers have. The evidence is more complicated. From the age of six, Charles was taught by a legal scholar from the University of Salamanca, and later he took lessons in music and mathematics. He loved hunting and spent long days at it. Foreign diplomats who met him later found him shy and unsure of himself, but courteous, generous, and perfectly able to follow a discussion. Whatever else he was, he was not the helpless simpleton of legend.

But none of that nuance reached a 17-year-old girl in Paris. In July 1679, her father and her uncle told Marie Louise that she would marry the king of Spain. She did not take it well. According to the accounts that survive, she spent much of the following weeks in tears. One story, repeated in many later retellings, has Louis trying to comfort her by asking whether he could have done any better if she had been his own daughter. Her reported answer was quick and cutting. “No, but you could have done better for your niece.” The point was obvious. He could have married her to his son. It’s a perfect line, which is exactly why it should be treated with caution.

It comes to us as a court story, not a document. And her stepmother, Liselotte, who knew her as well as anyone, later dismissed the gossip that Marie Louise was in love with the Dauphin. So, her tears may not have been for a lost romance at all. They may have been for Spain itself, its rigid court, its strict etiquette, its sickly king, and the fact that she would almost certainly never come home. Spain had doubts of its own. Some of its ministers disliked the choice because Marie Louise’s mother had been an English princess. If she had a son, the future king of Spain would be related to a Protestant royal family.

On the Spanish side, the match was pushed through by Charles’s illegitimate half-brother, Don Juan, then the most powerful man at court. In the end, peace with France mattered more, and the ministers accepted her. The marriage contract was signed on the 30th of August, 1679. The next day, the 31st, she was married by proxy in the chapel at Fontainebleau. The groom himself was not even there. A distant cousin, the Prince of Conti, stood in his place. Two 17-year-olds were now husband and wife, and they had never met. Before she left, Marie Louise went to the convent of Val-de-Grâce in Paris, where her mother’s heart was kept.

Then came the farewells at court. Louis, the story goes, told her, “Goodbye, Madame, and forever.” He reportedly added that the greatest misfortune would be to see her back in France. He was thinking of another princess of the family who had walked out on her Italian husband and returned home. Louis wanted no repeat. On the 20th of September, 1679, her carriages turned south towards Spain. She did not travel alone. A large French household rode with her, and two members of it matter enormously to this story. The first was Nicole Quentin, her old wet nurse, now a widow, who came along as a duenna of the queen’s private rooms.

She had been at Marie Louise’s side since the day she was born. It sounds like a modest job. It wasn’t. The women in that post held the keys to the queen’s bedchamber and antechamber, which meant they controlled who could reach her in private. The second was a young harpsichordist from Provence named Marguerite Lautier, one of the musicians who joined the new queen’s entourage at Fontainebleau. Hold on to both names. While the bride crawled south over bad roads, her husband could hardly sit still. Charles had fallen in love with Marie Louise before he ever saw her, from a portrait his half-brother, Don Juan, had shown him.

Don Juan himself died that September before the wedding he had arranged could take place in person. Charles did not wait for anyone. He set out north to meet her. The wife of the French ambassador, the Marquise de Villars, watched this happen and wrote about it to a friend in Paris. “The king,” she said, “was rushing off in search of the queen so quickly that nobody could keep up.” If Marie Louise had not reached Burgos when he arrived, he meant to take the archbishop with him and keep riding all the way to the French frontier if necessary so he could marry her on the spot. “He was,” she wrote, “transported with love and impatience.” Even Charles’ mother, Mariana, who had just returned to court after a period of political exile, seemed eager for the girl to be happy.

Marie Louise, for her part, was trying. She had learned some Spanish as a child so she could talk with her aunt, the queen of France, who was Charles’ half-sister. Now she used it to write to her husband. In one letter she told him that people had tried to make her believe he disapproved of her riding on horseback. She had since been assured that the opposite was true and that on such bad roads, horses were the best way to travel.

Then she promised that she would do whatever pleased him because “I shall only like that which you like.” Notice the horse in that letter. It will come back. On the 19th of November, 1679, the two finally met at Quintana Palla, a small village near Burgos in northern Spain. Marie Louise moved to kneel and kiss the king’s hands. Charles stepped forward and raised her up before she could. She was wearing, according to one account, a beautiful French costume covered with a surprising quantity of gems. They exchanged a few words in Spanish and then the conversation simply broke down. His speech was slurred and mumbled.

Her Spanish was not good enough to follow it. The French ambassador had to step in as interpreter between husband and wife. They were married in person that same day with very little ceremony. After that, Marie Louise dressed in the Spanish fashion because that was what Charles preferred. Her first meeting with her mother-in-law, Mariana, went well. So, here is the first surprise of her Spanish life. The husband she had dreaded was not cruel, cold, or indifferent. He was besotted. Later historians would describe the years of their marriage as the happiest of Charles’s life. Whatever Marie Louise felt at Quintana Palla, she had not been handed to a brute.

The couple reached Madrid in early December. The new queen’s formal entry into the capital was put off until the 13th of January, 1680, and until then she was kept largely out of sight. When the day came, it was staged as an elaborate public ceremony, a grand welcome for the woman who was supposed to secure Spain’s future. And Spain was very clear about what that future meant. Even before she arrived, while she was still on the road, a Jesuit preacher named Francisco Garcia told the ladies of the Madrid court what the new queen was coming for. With her, he said, Spain could promise itself firm peace, constant victory, and a glorious succession.

At the royal betrothal celebrations, another court preacher prayed aloud that the young couple’s lives would be continued in others. Everyone understood the code. The queen’s real job was her womb. Charles felt that pressure, too. In a letter to his mother around the time of the match, he wrote that his ministers and subjects resented any delay on his part in securing the succession so desperately wanted by all.

Then, in December 1679, barely a month after she reached Madrid, Marie Louise missed her period. The news did not stay private. It did not even stay in Spain. Every foreign ambassador at court wrote home to report it. Day by day the court waited because the longer the delay lasted, the more likely a pregnancy became. For a few weeks, Marie Louise was one of the most watched women in Europe and the attention was entirely on her body.

Then, it was over. Before long though, it became clear there was simply no baby. The papal nuncio reported that the queen’s pregnancy had simply vanished after 2 months and some days of continual hope. Charles was the first to comfort his wife and he seemed confident it would happen soon. Others were far less patient. The Venetian ambassador passed on a darker reading to his government. “There were suspicions at court,” he wrote, “that nature had unjustly denied her the ability to pass from wife to mother.” She was 17. She had been in Madrid about 2 months and the first whispers that the problem was her had already reached Venice.

Now she had to live inside the most rigid court in Europe where almost everything she did was governed by rules. The Spanish court ran on etiquette the way a ship runs on its rigging. Pull one rope the wrong way and everything shook. For a French princess raised at Saint-Cloud, the rules were a shock. Marie Louise was not supposed to eat in private as she liked. She was not supposed to lean out of the palace windows. She was not free to dress in the latest fashions or to throw parties, balls, and casual gatherings the way the French court did and no one was allowed to touch the queen. Her person was effectively sacred.

All of this was enforced by one woman, the camarera mayor, the chief lady of the queen’s household. She ran a female world of somewhere between 200 and 300 servants and attendants, each with a fixed rank and fixed duties. For Marie Louise, that woman was the Duchess of Terranova, an aristocrat with a fearsome reputation. And yet, in those first months, the young queen did not look miserable.

In February, 1680, the French ambassador’s wife, the Marquis de Villars, sent Paris a strikingly frank report. The queen, she wrote, had grown so plump that if it went on, her face would become round. She usually slept 10 or 12 hours and ate meat four times a day. Her favorite meals were breakfast and lunch, when she always had both a boiled capon and a roast one. She laughed a great deal. She was sweet and accommodating with the king. The same letter contains one quietly devastating line. Marie Louise had seen Charles’s portrait before she married him, Madame de Villars noted, but no one had painted his strange moods or his love of solitude.

Spanish customs had not been turned upside down to please the new queen, she added, though her mother-in-law, Mariana, did whatever she could to soften them. That detail about Mariana matters, because she is often cast as the villain of this story. The truth is messier. Their relationship had ups and downs, and Mariana was jealous of her daughter-in-law’s hold on Charles. But one Spanish historian has argued that relations between the two queens turned out better than anyone expected. Mariana, he says, often interceded with her son so that he would grant the French girl’s whims. The Duchess of Terranova was a different matter.

She reproached the queen constantly over her French habits and her disregard for protocol. Then, according to court sources studied by modern historians, she went too far. She killed one of the queen’s beloved canaries. Marie Louise slapped her. Striking the head of your own household was a serious breach, and Charles might well have scolded his wife. He didn’t. Marie Louise explained that she had been overcome by an antojo, a pregnancy craving, the sort of sudden irrational urge that pregnant women were believed to be unable to resist. Whether she believed she was pregnant or simply knew what would work, it worked.

Better still, she managed to get the Duchess removed. In August 1680, Terranova was dismissed, and a far more accommodating Duchess of Albuquerque took her place. The new chief lady, having seen what happened to her predecessor, did as little as possible. So, the helpless child bride had just beaten the most feared woman in her household. Remember that. Marie Louise was isolated, but she was not powerless. She was, however, losing her French world. At one court festival, the French ambassador recorded, “She let her chamber women wear veils, like the noble ladies of honor, who came from Spain’s grandest families, and felt insulted.” The quarrels between her Spanish attendants and her French servants grew so bitter that on the 14th of March, 1680, most of the French household was sent back to France.

Only a handful stayed. One was her old nurse, Nicole Quentin, whom the Spaniards now called Nicolasa Cantine, and soon simply La Cantina. Another was the nurse’s niece, Susana, who served at the Queen’s table. The third was the harpsichordist, Marguerite Lauche. Marie Louise clung to this tiny circle. It was the last piece of home she had left. That summer, her new country showed her another face.

On the 30th of June, 1680, the Spanish Inquisition held a general auto da fe in the Plaza Mayor of Madrid. An auto da fe was a public ceremony in which people convicted by the Inquisition were paraded, their sentences read aloud, and those condemned to death handed over to the civil authorities for execution outside the city. This one was staged as part of the festivities surrounding the royal wedding. It lasted the entire day. Charles, Mariana, and Marie Louise watched from the royal box above the square. We know what it looked like because the court painter Francisco Rizi recorded it in an enormous canvas a few years later.

It hangs today in the Prado. Look closely at the royal balcony and you can find her there, an 18-year-old French girl a few months into her marriage, presiding over a festival of the Inquisition held partly in her honor. No reliable record tells us what she felt. The painting only tells us she was there. Meanwhile, politics was closing in. In February 1680, Charles appointed the Duke of Medinaceli as his chief minister, and Medinaceli soon clashed with the queen. He believed the French ambassador, the Marquis de Villars, was steering her through his wife, her most constant companion.

In February 1681, Charles asked Louis XIV to recall Villars, accusing him of meddling in the private affairs of the palace. The irony is that Marie Louise was not much of a political agent. Madame de Villars herself admitted that the queen did not amuse herself much by reasoning about politics. Paris wanted a spy in Madrid. What it actually had was a young woman who preferred riding, music, theater, and her small French circle.

But Madrid had no interest in her hobbies. Month after month, the court watched for only one thing. Soon the whole city was watching, too, and Madrid had a song ready for the occasion. A little rhyme began circulating through the gossip spots of the capital, where people gathered to trade news and insults. It was addressed directly to the queen. In Spanish, it plays on the royal emblem of France, the fleur-de-lis, the golden lily, and on a cruel pun. Roughly translated, it goes like this: Give birth, lovely fleur-de-lis, in a fortune so strange, if you give birth, you give birth for Spain.

And if you don’t, it’s back to Paris. In Spanish, the punchline is si no pares a Paris. The word for you give birth and the name of the city sound almost exactly the same. It was witty, and it was vicious, and it was not entirely spontaneous. Historians who have studied the political satire of this period trace rhymes like this one to the circles at court that favored Austria over France. In Charles’s Spain, satire was a weapon. Rival factions, one writer of the time said, made war with their pens. The pen war had a target, and it was her body. Hostile courtiers began suggesting to the king that Louis XIV had chosen his niece precisely because she was barren.

If Charles died without children, the reasoning went, the Spanish crown would slide toward France. Another rumor claimed that Louis had somehow made her unable to have children. A third whispered that she was secretly taking treatments to make herself sterile, so that when her sickly husband died, she could go home to France as a widow. Look at what those stories have in common. They contradict each other completely, and every single one makes her the problem. Behind the gossip was a system of surveillance. A queen’s menstrual cycle was not her own business. It was watched constantly in the hope of a delay.

Doctors set her diet in detail, recommending foods believed to help conception. Some activities were considered dangerous for a queen who needed to conceive, and riding was one of them. For a young woman who loved horses, that alone said a great deal about what her life had become. In June 1681, while the court was at the Palace of Aranjuez, Marie Louise announced another delay. This time, even the doctors were skeptical, and the hope faded once more. One diplomatic report concluded that the missed period was simply her usual irregularity.

The next year brought fresh suspicions, fresh reports to every court in Europe, and fresh disappointment. And the people of Madrid, one historian notes, blamed each failure directly on her. When medicine failed, the royal couple turned to heaven. They went on processions and pilgrimages to holy places, and spent long hours venerating relics. Her chambermaids offered advice and questionable home remedies. Doctors argued over the causes of what everyone called the queen’s sterility. According to her biographer, the church even offered her exorcisms to free her from a supposed spell.

Meanwhile, everyone else seemed to be having babies. In 1682, her cousin the Dauphin, the man gossip had once paired her with, had his first son. In 1684, her younger sister Anne Marie, now Duchess of Savoy, announced that she too was expecting. And inside the queen’s own rooms, a far more dangerous story had already been told. Early in 1681, Marguerite Lothier, the harpsichordist who had stayed behind when the French household was sent home, went to the queen’s chief lady with an accusation. We know her version because she repeated it to a judge 4 years later. She said she had often seen the old nurse, Nicolasa Cantin, give the queen a drink in secret at moments when the king was away or busy in his study.

Suspicious, Lautier tasted it herself and suffered violent pains in her stomach. She also claimed that whenever the queen’s period was late, the nurse gave her certain pills. Pretending to have a headache, Lautier asked the queen for one and tried it. She said it made her insides burn and that 2 days later she bled more heavily than she ever had before or since. Her conclusion was explosive. The nurse, she said, was feeding the queen drugs to bring on her periods and prevent a pregnancy. In other words, to stop the king of Spain from ever having an heir. The chief lady, the Duchess of Albuquerque, did not believe a word of it.

Neither did the wife of the chief minister, who heard the same story. The accusation went nowhere. At least, not yet. It’s worth pausing on what we actually have here. The word of one servant with no other witness about tastes and stomach pains that nobody else could check. It’s an allegation. Nothing in it was proven then or later. But it had been spoken aloud and it would come back. And here is the other side of Marie Louise in these years. She was not simply a victim of the fertility obsession. She learned to use it. One historian who studied her household found that whenever a pregnancy seemed possible, Charles’ attention and generosity multiplied and she took advantage.

In her first month she secured privileges for her favorite attendants, including a double ration for her beloved nurse, granted, as the record put it, because of the affection the queen had for this servant. She used her influence in larger ways, too. She helped block an early move to have Charles recognize a son of the Austrian emperor as his heir. And her open hostility to the chief minister, Medinaceli, helped bring him down. When he resigned in April 1685, his notorious incompatibility with the queen was counted among the main reasons. By the mid-1680s, the frivolous French queen had real power at court.

Her closest ally was still the woman who had nursed her as a baby, and that woman was about to give Madrid a full-blown scandal. To understand why a palace romance could set Madrid on fire, you need to know the mood of the city in the mid-1680s. Louis XIV had spent the previous years swallowing border territories piece by piece, using legal pretexts to claim lands that had once been tied to places he already held. Spain suffered most.

In December 1683, Charles declared war on France. It was brief and humiliating. French guns bombarded Luxembourg, and in August 1684, Spain signed a truce that let Louis keep what he had taken, Luxembourg included. In Madrid, hatred of the French was running very high, and the queen was French. In June 1685, after Medinaceli’s resignation, a new man took effective control of the government, the young Count of Oropesa. He was still settling into power, and he had enemies to impress. Inside the queen’s rooms, the old nurse had become a force. Marie Louise loved her, as the harpsichordist Lauthier later put it to a judge, more than her life.

A hostile courtier, the Duke of Montalto, complained that when Charles fell ill, the queen barely visited him, yet whenever the nurse was bled by her doctors, the queen went to see her at all hours. Montalto disliked the queen, so treat that with caution. But the attachment itself is beyond doubt. The nurse also had a powerful Spanish ally, a well-connected lady named Mariana de Aguirre. Together, according to the French ambassador and other observers, the two women traded on the Queen’s favor, obtaining positions and royal grants for their friends and relatives. The new French ambassador, arriving in March 1685, found that the Queen would hardly listen to anyone else.

The previous ambassador had called the nurse false, ambitious, and utterly without scruple. Then came the love affair. Living in the palace was a Frenchman from Normandy named Jean de Vermond. He had been a captain of grenadiers until he killed a French gentleman in a duel in 1675 and was banished from France. He drifted to Spain, worked in the French embassy’s stables, and after the ambassador’s expulsion, the Queen took him into her own stables at the nurse’s request. He and the nurse became lovers.

In April 1685, Montalto sent a gleeful report to a colleague in London. The nurse, he wrote, still wore the habit of a palace duenna and was neither very young nor at all beautiful. People in town laughed at the idea of the two of them marrying. But she had been moved out of the palace to Mariana de Aguirre’s house, and there, he added, “They say she had just given birth to a boy.” That is a rumor passed on by a hostile man, but think about how it landed in Madrid. The Queen of Spain mocked in songs for 6 years because she could not produce a child and her 40-something nurse rumored to have produced one.

The couple married on the 8th of April, 1685. A satire claimed the Queen’s own household had paid a dowry of 7,000 doubloons. Under palace rules, a married woman could not stay in the Queen’s private service, and the nurse lost her post the very next day. Marie Louise simply put her back. Within days, her wages were restored against all etiquette. Soon, the newlyweds were seen heading to Aranjuez with a train worthy of a grandee riding in a royal carriage. In the queen’s stables, Viarmont had a bitter rival, Pierre Le Villain, who had married the harpsichordist Marguerite Lautier. Viarmont had helped Levelain get his job years earlier, but now the two men competed for every promotion, and Viarmont, backed by his wife’s influence, was winning.

Montalto wrote that in the stables, there was no authority but Viarmont’s. Levelain and Lautier fought back with whispers. Viarmont, they said, was a French spy. How else could a banished duelist travel back into France to buy horses and return unharmed? In June, Viarmont and the nurse struck first. They accused Levelain of theft, and he lost his position. Levelain was desperate. He tried to challenge Viarmont to a duel, saying that since the man had left him without bread for his wife and children, it hardly mattered if he lost his life. Viarmont refused. According to later testimony, Levelain also talked about stabbing his rival or even poisoning him with a broth laced with ground diamond.

The nurse made sure the queen heard about the threats. Then, things turned frightening. On the 20th of June, an armed servant of Mariana de Aguirre turned up at the house where Levelain and Lautier rented a room, asking the landlady for a written account of herself and her tenants. Levelain feared a plan to seize them and bundle them out of Madrid without the king’s knowledge. The next night, the same servant came back, claimed he was acting for the queen herself, and walked into their room. Lautier, alone, ran screaming down the stairs in her nightshift.

On the 23rd of June, the couple fled Madrid. They stopped in the town of Cuenca, and there Levelain took his revenge. The old accusation about pills had gone nowhere, so he wrote a far bigger one. The nurse and her husband, he claimed, were plotting to poison the King of Spain while French troops massed on the border waiting for his death. Charles’ mother ignored it as spite. Oropesa scoffed that such things were usually carried out before anyone announced them.

But the Austrian emperor’s ambassador seized on the story and spread it everywhere. Soon, Madrid was buzzing with talk of a French plot against the king, and the rumors pointed straight at the queen herself. Charles refused to believe that his wife was involved. A French memoir says he trusted her virtue too much to suspect her, but he ordered Oropesa to act. In early July, Levelain and Lautier were arrested in Cuenca and brought back to Madrid for questioning. The case went to Francisco Bravo de Sobremonte, a royal magistrate whose job was to judge criminal matters involving French subjects in Madrid.

Above him sat a special committee chaired by Oropesa. Everything was handled in unusual secrecy. The Venetian ambassador called it the only business in a long time that Spain had managed to keep truly secret. On the 10th of July, 1685, the judge questioned Marguerite Lautier. She repeated her old story and made it bigger. The nurse, she said, had secretly given the queen a yellow drink, pills of very bad quality, and doses of theriac after supper and at other hours, while claiming it was to protect her in case someone in Spain tried to poison her.

Then Lautier went further. Veramond, she said, was Louis XIV’s agent. His pardon for the duel had been the price for making sure the queen never had an heir. Late on the night of the 14th of July, around 11, officers knocked at the door of the nurse and her husband. Vairemont was waiting with a primed pistol and a small sword. He wasn’t expecting the law, he was expecting the mob. He gave up without a fight and the couple were taken by coach to a house on the Calle Valverde and locked in separate rooms below ground.

The next day, the judge questioned the nurse. Asked why she thought she had been arrested, she said she supposed it was because people claimed she wanted to poison the king and she was innocent of any such wickedness. Had she given the queen drinks or pills? Only twice, she said, a little theriac in a drop of wine, once in front of the king himself, for a stomach ache. Theriac was an ancient cure-all, a thick compound of dozens of ingredients prescribed for everything from poisoning to indigestion, and here her answers began to wobble. Where was the theriac now? At home, in a little pot. No, in a chest in the queen’s private room.

She couldn’t remember where in the palace it was. Finally, she wasn’t sure it had been theriac at all. It might have been another remedy. The judge began to suspect her. On the 18th of July, the king’s physicians and his chief apothecary opened a small chest seized from her belongings. Inside, they found scented powders, sugar pastilles, Hungary water, viper powder, theriac, and other preparations.

There was no suspicious pill. But the experts added that some of these substances, theriac in particular, could make a woman miscarry if given carelessly. It was not proof, but it was enough to keep the case alive. Outside, Madrid was boiling. One night that month, three men went to the palace to find out which sedan chair belonged to the nurse. Warned, she stayed in the palace and sent the chair home empty.

On the way, the men tore open its curtains, found nobody inside, smashed it to pieces in rage, and injured a servant. Then, from the 19th of July, the anger exploded into a riot. Gangs looted French shops and threw stones at anyone who looked French. The Venetian ambassador feared a general uprising. On the night of the 22nd of July, the nurse was moved to the court jail. She denied everything again. Oropesa needed a confession to win his victory over the French faction completely, and the committee ordered her put to the torture. At 1:00 in the morning, the judge told her the decision and asked her to confess.

She said everything she had told him was true. He asked again, same answer. She was taken up to a tower room where the rack stood and asked a third time. She swore she was innocent. The jail surgeon examined her and declared her fit. The executioner tied her to the rack. The torture began at about half past 2:00 in the morning. The record lists cords bound and tightened in turns, a garrote twisted on her right arm, and pressure on her left foot. Through all of it, screaming, she kept proclaiming her innocence. It ended at a quarter to 4:00. The judge ordered her carried to a bed in a nearby cell and treated.

She never confessed, not once. And her endurance did something the court may not have intended. It convinced the judge, and through him Oropesa, that she was innocent. On the 24th of July, a proclamation banned attacks on foreigners, and the riots began to die down. The committee reviewed the case, and rumor said its members wanted the nurse executed. Charles refused. He feared his wife’s fury if an apparently innocent woman was killed, and he was worried about French troops on the border. Instead, he chose exile for the nurse, her circle, and all the newer French servants. In the Venetian ambassador’s words, political council had prevailed over judicial decree.

Charles knew his wife would resist. Late on the night of the 28th of July, officers took away the last French confidant still serving her, the nurse’s niece, Susanna. The next morning, Marie Louise called for Susanna to help her dress. Susanna was gone. What followed comes to us from a single anonymous letter written days later. It claims the queen tried to throw herself from a window and was held back by one of her ladies. She called for scissors to cut off her hair. She demanded post horses to ride to France. She refused to hear mass and locked herself in her room until 9:00 that night. In the end, Charles gave in.

He summoned Oropesa and ordered Susanna brought back. Oropesa threatened to resign. On the 30th of July, the decree was published. The nurse, her husband, and the French servants of the palace were expelled from Spain, each paid 1,000 gold pistoles. The nurse, injured, left days later and reached Bayonne on the 18th of August. Her accusers were rewarded with a pension and shipped off to the Canary Islands.

For Marie Louise, the summer of 1685 left her more alone than she had ever been. At the end of August, the Duke of Montalto reported that the queen had not gone out to any public function or even for a drive in many days, perhaps months. He thought that was wise. During the arrests, he wrote, “The common people, who knew no respect, might have shouted insults at her in the street. Think about that for a moment. The Queen of Spain was afraid to leave her own palace because of a rumor about her womb. Even now, the cycle continued. Montalto added that some people suspected she was pregnant again. “Nobody took it seriously,” he said, “because she had been late by 2 months or more before, only to discover each time that it was nothing.” Still, the rumor briefly won back some of her lost popularity.

In Paris, the reaction was very different. Louis XIV had his ambassador warned that if anyone attempted anything against the Queen’s life in Madrid, he would send 100,000 men to avenge it. And the nurse, tortured in Spain, was welcomed in France almost as a heroine. In December, Marie Louise’s father gave her lodgings in the Palais Royal and the best doctors he could find to treat her injuries.

So, let’s ask the question Madrid would not ask aloud. If the nurse was not secretly sabotaging the Queen’s pregnancies, and no one ever proved she was, then why was there still no child? Marie Louise may have had her own answer. According to one account repeated by later historians, she confided to the French ambassador that she was no longer a virgin, but that as far as she could tell, she believed she would never have children. We don’t have the original wording, so it has to be treated with care, but it suggests a woman who understood more about her marriage than the people chanting at her. Her biographer Elisabetta Lurgo puts it bluntly.

By tradition, the blame fell on the Queen, even though the King’s own problems were so obvious that people began to raise questions about his impotence. And modern science has added something those courtiers could not have known. In 2009, a team of Spanish geneticists reconstructed Charles’s family tree across 16 generations and more than 3,000 people. They calculated what’s called an inbreeding coefficient, a measure of how likely a person is to inherit two identical copies of a gene through shared ancestors. For the founder of the Spanish Habsburg line, it was 0.025. For Charles, it was 0.254, roughly what you would expect in the child of a brother and sister.

The researchers went further, and here we have to be careful. They speculated that Charles may have inherited two rare genetic disorders, one affecting the hormones produced by the pituitary gland, the other affecting the kidneys. Together, they suggested, these could explain much of his medical history, including his impotence and infertility. It is a hypothesis, not a diagnosis. There is no DNA to test, and other researchers have proposed other conditions, such as fluid on the brain.

But nearly every serious modern account points in the same direction. The empty cradle was very likely his. That is the real sense in which she was blamed for his inbreeding. Generations of uncles marrying nieces had shaped the body of the man she married. Madrid blamed the bride. She did not stop fighting. In April 1686, she set out to bring her banished ally, Mariana de Aguirre, back to court. She summoned Oropesa and told him to advise the king to allow it. He firmly refused. According to Montalto, she dismissed him with a thunderous frown, went straight to her husband, shouted at him, and dug in her heels.

Her pleas grew so forceful and so pitiful that Charles gave way. Aguirre came back. Montalto was appalled. She would be, he wrote, worse than all the devils together and worse than the nurse. That same year, another woman arrived in Madrid, and she brought a reputation with her. Olympe Mancini, Countess of Soissons, was a niece of the late Cardinal Mazarin and once close to Louis XIV himself. In 1679, she had been named in the Affair of the Poisons, the huge Paris scandal over poisoners and black magic at the French court. She was accused of plotting with a notorious sorceress and one modern account says the accusations even included the death of Henrietta, Marie Louise’s own mother.

None of it was ever tried. Olympe fled France in January 1680 to avoid arrest. Now she settled in Madrid where Spanish high society celebrated her. Soon she had won the confidence of the queen. Marie Louise’s health meanwhile was quietly deteriorating. For years she had been taking all kinds of remedies to promote fertility, many of them of unknown composition. She suffered from long-standing stomach pains, nausea, and a recurring colic and she had asked her father to send her medicine for it from France. Her biographer describes her as prone for years to disordered eating. She had become heavy. One food historian notes that she was fond of sweetened drinks of lemon and cinnamon whose preparation required 32 pounds of sugar.

In the autumn of 1688, she caught smallpox. According to an early 20th century history, Charles, frightened, kept his distance. She survived. Her two countries, however, were heading for disaster. That autumn, French armies invaded the Palatinate, the German homeland of her stepmother Liselotte, and would soon lay much of it waste. A new European war was beginning and Spain was moving toward the enemies of France. Once again, Marie Louise was the most French person in a country that was turning against France. At the beginning of February 1689, still recovering, still coughing, she decided she wanted to go riding.

The most detailed account of what happened next comes from her modern biographer, Elisabetta Lurgo, who pieced it together from the reports of the time. Despite a tormenting cough, Marie Louise got out of bed and went hunting. During the ride, her horse reared. As she fought to bring it under control, she was thrown forward against the pommel of the saddle, the raised front of it, and took a violent blow to the stomach. Several people around her feared the worst.

Remember that letter she wrote to Charles on her way into Spain in 1679, promising to give up riding if he wished, and so relieved to hear he didn’t mind. 10 years later, the pastime she loved had just hurt her badly. At first, it seemed she had escaped. She went back to bed to nurse her cough. The next day, she felt better, well enough to eat heartily. According to the accounts, she ate a great many raw oysters, some olives, and drank large glasses of iced milk. At 5:00 the following morning, the pain began. Severe stomach cramps, vomiting, violent diarrhea. One account adds convulsions. Her condition worsened fast, and her doctors soon realized there was nothing they could do.

On the 11th of February 1689, she made her confession and received the last rites. The papal nuncio came to give her the Pope’s blessing. He found her dying. Only her eyes, he wrote, still showed that she knew what was happening. Two more moments from that bedside come to us secondhand. A witness quoted by a 20th century Spanish historian says she told Charles that he might have many wives, but none who would love him more than she did. Another early account, translated by an English historian, has her telling her confessor that she was at peace and very glad to die. Neither line can be fully checked.

But the first fits what we know about the strange, real affection between these two people, a besotted husband and a homesick wife who had, over 10 years, grown genuinely fond of him. On the morning of the 12th of February, 1689, Marie Louise d’Orléans died in the Alcázar of Madrid. She went, her confessor wrote, “So quietly that we hardly noticed her passing away.” She was 26 years old. She had been queen for less than 10 years.

That number should stop you because we have heard it before. 19 years earlier, at Saint-Cloud, her mother Henrietta had also died at 26, suddenly, in agony, with pain in her abdomen after drinking something ordinary. And what happened next followed almost exactly the same script. The news reached Versailles on the 20th of February, and the French court immediately began to whisper about poison. Who would want the queen of Spain dead? The rumor mill supplied several answers. Some pointed at Charles’s mother, Mariana. The theory went that she wanted a younger, fertile bride for her son, preferably one friendly to Austria.

There is no evidence for it at all. Others looked at the Countess of Soissons, the exiled Frenchwoman who had won the queen’s trust and whose name had already been linked to poison in Paris. Suspicion hung over her long enough that in January 1690, she was ordered to leave the Spanish court. She protested her innocence and moved back to Brussels. Nothing was ever proven against her.

And there was a broader political logic, which is exactly what makes these rumors so tempting. The pro-Austrian party at court certainly did not mourn her. Within weeks, Spain was moving firmly into the alliance against France, and in April 1689, war with France was declared in Madrid. Her death removed the last French voice beside the king, just as Spain changed sides. That is a fact about timing. It is not evidence of murder. The Spanish court, aware of the gossip, ordered an autopsy, partly to put an end to the rumors. It found no sign of poison. Spain’s royal collections today describe the French poisoning stories as completely without basis.

So, what did kill her? Here, historians genuinely disagree, and the honest answer is that we don’t know. Lurgo points out that the poison theory, so beloved of older historians, conveniently ignored how ill the queen already was. Many modern accounts settle on appendicitis, an infection that was usually fatal before modern surgery. Others point to the blow from the saddle. Lurgo herself favors the most ordinary explanation of all, food poisoning, most likely from the raw oysters, in a young woman whose body had just been through smallpox and years of stomach trouble. But, Lurgo raises one more possibility, and it may be the saddest.

For years, Marie Louise had been taking remedies meant to make her fertile. Just before this final illness, Lurgo writes, she had undergone a new treatment based on drugs whose composition is unknown. She cannot rule out that the queen was accidentally poisoned by the very cures she took to give Spain an heir. Look at how strangely the two deaths mirror each other. Mother and daughter, both 26. Both struck down suddenly by abdominal pain after eating or drinking something they consumed without a second thought. Both surrounded by cries of poison. Both examined by doctors who found none.

And in both cases, centuries later, the true cause is still argued over. There was even a thread connecting the two. The Countess of Soissons, suspected in Madrid, had reportedly once been accused in Paris in the middle of the poison scandal of a hand in Henrietta’s death, as well. Two royal women, nearly two decades apart, and one woman’s name whispered over both. Nothing in either case was ever proven against her. For the man who loved her, none of these theories changed the central fact. Charles had lost the wife he had chosen from a portrait and adored for 10 years.

And the court did not give him long to grieve. Spain still needed an heir, and the ministers began searching for a new queen almost at once. Two candidates were considered, a Medici princess from Tuscany and a German princess, Maria Anna of Neuburg. They chose Maria Anna. Her family was famous for one thing above all, fertility. Her sister was already married to the Austrian emperor. The proxy wedding took place in August 1689, barely 6 months after Marie Louise’s death.

Meanwhile, the first wife had to be buried. Her body lay in state in the Alcazar, and her funeral was celebrated with all the ceremony due to a queen. Then she was carried to the great monastery of El Escorial, the resting place of Spanish royalty. But even there, her failure followed her. Today, she lies in the Pantheon of the Infantes, among princes and princesses, not in the royal vault reserved for kings and for the queens who gave birth to kings. The sermons followed her, too. At one of her funeral services in Madrid, the royal preacher, Manuel de Guerra y Ribera, spoke. Years earlier, at her grand entry into Madrid, he had urged her to fulfill the people’s longing for an heir.

Now, standing over her memory, he lamented that the gentle queen had been forced to sacrifice her natural ambition to live on through her descendants. Even in death, she was still being measured by her womb. Her will tells us who she cared about at the end. She left 4,000 gold pistoles to her old nurse, Nicolasa Cantin, the woman tortured in her name. The money was never paid. Whether because Spain’s treasury was empty or because the nurse was still hated at court, she received nothing. In 1703, living in France, she petitioned the Spanish Council for her legacy. She was refused. The nurse’s niece, Susana, did better.

The queen had arranged for her to receive 3,000 pistoles and a valuable jewel and to marry a Spanish gentleman who was given a government post. The wedding took place in the Alcazar on the 27th of April, 1689. Even after death, Marie Louise was looking after the last French girl in her rooms. And her old accusers? Pierre Levian lived out his years in the Canary Islands on his royal pension. He died there in 1698, aged about 38. His widow, the harpsichordist Marguerite Lautier, asked the crown for support. She too was turned down.

Then there was Charles. His second marriage produced exactly what the first had produced, no child. Over the following decade, the king became convinced that a curse lay on him. Her biographer describes him as obsessed with the idea of a spell that kept him from becoming a father. In March 1698, the English envoy Alexander Stanhope, wrote that the king thought everything said or done around him was a temptation of the devil and never felt safe unless his confessor and two friars slept in his room every night. This is the period that gave him the nickname history remembers, Charles the Bewitched.

And in those last years, he did something that still unsettles people who read about it. Near the end of his life, he had the coffins at the Escorial opened, and he insisted on seeing the body of his first wife. French chroniclers reported that Marie Louise was found whole, still in her clothes, her face faintly colored. An older account says the sight brought him to a passion of tears and despair. Lurgo writes that he gazed at her with a morbid fascination, and then fled in fright. We have no reliable record of anything he said there. Charles died on the 1st of November, 1700. He was 38 years old. The doctors who later opened his body recorded damage almost everywhere they looked.

Among the findings, as reported by medical historians, was that he had only a single testicle, and it was atrophied. Think back to the songs in Madrid streets, and to the nurse screaming her innocence on the rack. For nearly 10 years, a city had demanded to know what was wrong with the French queen. The final medical evidence pointed at the king. It doesn’t prove beyond doubt what made him infertile. It does make the blame poured on Marie Louise look exactly like what it was, the habit of a world that always looked first at the woman. There is one last twist, and it is pure irony. Charles’s death set off the question every European court had been dreading, who would inherit the Spanish empire?

In his final will, under heavy pressure, Charles left everything to Philip of Anjou, the grandson of Louis XIV. A French prince took the Spanish throne. The result was the War of the Spanish Succession, which tore across Europe from 1701 to 1714. Remember what Marie Louise’s enemies had whispered 20 years earlier, that Louis had sent his niece to Spain precisely because she would bear no children so that the crown would eventually fall to France. She had nothing to do with how it happened. She had been dead for more than 11 years.

But the French succession, her enemies had accused her of plotting, arrived anyway without her. So what is left of the queen they blamed? A spoiled, quick-tempered girl from Saint-Cloud who was sent away at 17, a wife who slapped her chief lady over a dead canary and won, a queen who hid in her palace while the city chanted about her body, a woman who tried to throw herself from a window by one account when they took away the last of her French friends, and a 26-year-old who died in agony just as her mother had with the word poison echoing behind her. Madrid’s little song had given her two choices: give Spain a child or go back to Paris.

She gave Spain no child. And Marie Louise never saw Paris again.

You Might Also Enjoy