The Duke Who Defied Society When He Stepped Forward to Dance with the Widowed Bride in Her Vintage Blue Dress
He’s home, Mrs. The Duke’s come home to Fartarn. The carrier shouted it from the lane before his cart had even stopped, standing up on the board, with the rains slack in his fist. His old horse put its head down to the grass at the verge as though it had heard the news at every gate since dawn, and was tired of it.
when a Farburn was in the paddock below the house with a hazel switch in her hand, turning the Michael Moss towards the pen. The mist was still lying in the bottom of the dale, white as milk in a bowl. Above it the fell stood out brown and gold. The bracken turned, and the waterfall at the head of the gill made its low, steady noise that she no longer heard unless she listened for it.
Which duke? She said, though there was only one he could mean. She shut the hurdle behind the last goose and came to the wall. The carrier leaned down to her, pleased to have somebody who had not heard it yet. Burkholm, the son, not seen in the dale since they buried the old duke. And that’s going on for 10 years. Came up the north road 3 days since with no more fuss than a curate.
They’ve seen him walking by the falls on his own and the long room at the inns to be opened for the Miklmus assembly and they say he’s promised to show himself. The young gentlemen are laying wages already on which young lady he’ll lead out first. He laughed and gathered up the res. There’ll be some new gowns sewn in this dale before Friday. I’ll tell you that.
Behind her, the dairy door opened. Vashi Farburn stood in it with her sleeves pushed up and her hands white with salt from the butter. She had heard every word. Wa saw it, and the way she held herself, very still, with her chin up like a woman listening for her name in a crowd.
The carrier touched his hat to her and drove on down the lane towards the ford, and the mist took the cart into itself, horse first, until nothing was left of it but the sound of the wheels. Vashi did not move from the doorway. We shall go, she said, both of us. I shall want a companion, and a widow is the proper thing. Then she went back inside, and Rena heard the butter pats begin again, quick and hard, as if they had done something to offend her.
So that was settled, the way most things in that house were settled, with no question asked, and no answer wanted. Wa stood a while longer by the wall with the switch in her hand. The geese muttered in their pen. A curu went over late for the coast, calling as it went. She thought about the long room at the inn, which she had danced in only [clears throat] once, and about the gowns in the press upstairs, which she did not need to think about at all, because she knew them by heart.
There were two black ones and a gray. There was a brown stuff gown for the farm, and there was the blue. She had been married in the blue three autumns before in the little stone church at the Dalefoot. It had been her mother’s gown first, a ball gown from the days when her mother was a young woman who taught music in the town and was asked to the good houses to play.
Her mother had kept it wrapped in linen for 20 years. When Davyy Farburn asked for Wena, the two of them had unpicked it together at the kitchen table by candle light and made it over for a bride. The silk was the blue of the sky above the fell on a hard, clear morning. Her mother had been ill already by then, though they did not speak of it.
She had sat with the gown across her knees and her needle going, and every so often she had stopped and simply looked at her daughter, as if she were learning her. Davyy had seen her come up the church path in it, and had stopped dead the porch, a big fair-haired man, with his collar too tight and his ears scarlet. You look like the weather’s going to hold,” he had said, which was the finest thing a hill farmer could say about anything.
She had laughed out loud in the church porch. Her mother had died before Christmas that year. Davey had died the winter after of a fever he caught bringing the you down off the fell in a snowstorm, and the blue gown had gone back into the press, wrapped in the same old linen. She had not taken it out since.
She had not needed to. Nobody asked a widow anywhere that she would need a blue silk gown. She was 23 years old, and she had stopped expecting to be asked anywhere at all. On the Wednesday night, Bashi came into the bedroom with a candle while Vena was brushing out her hair. She stood looking at the press.
“Not the blue,” she said. Anything but the blue. When I put the brush down. Then what? You told me the gray made me look like a crow at a wedding. Vashi’s mouth went tight. She had a new gown of her own hanging in her room. Rosecoled silk made in the town by a dress maker who had been paid for it in egg money and butter money saved through the whole of the summer.
Wena had helped her save it. Wear the gray then,” Bashi said. But she said it without conviction, and after a moment she went out again. In the end, it was the blue because there was nothing else, and because Wena had found sitting alone on the bed afterwards that she did not want to go to her first assembly in 3 years, looking like a crow.
The truth about Vashi was not simple and WA had stopped expecting it to be. She was Davey’s elder sister by more than 10 years. She had kept house for their father at the farm since she was a girl, and when the father died, she had gone on keeping it for Davey, and when Davyy married, she had stayed. She had never been courted that anybody knew of.
She was handsome in a sharp highcolored way and proud and quick with her tongue. She worked harder than any woman in the Dale and never once let anybody see her tired, and she had not wanted her brother to marry a music mistress’s daughter with soft hands and a piano forte, and she had not troubled to hide it.
When Davey was dying in the front bedroom with the snow piled against the window, he had held WA’s wrist so hard that it marked. “Don’t leave our Vashi on her own,” he had said. “She’ll never ask. She’d sooner starve than ask. But she’s not so hard as she makes out.” Wa had promised. She had promised because he was frightened and because she loved him, and because it had seemed then like a small thing to give.
She had not understood that a promise made to a dying man does not get smaller afterwards. It grows. It fills the house. Every morning for 2 years, she had got up in the dark and done the work of the farm beside Vashi. and Vashi had never once said thank you and Wena had never once thought of leaving. Now Vashi was leaving instead.
The farm was the Farburn’s own, the only land in the upper Dale that had never belonged to Fartan. But it could not be worked by two women with no man to hire and no money to hire him with. And Vashi had said so at last in the spring. Vashi had written to a cousin of her mother’s in a wool town far down the valley, a widowed draper’s wife with a tall narrow house above the shop.
The cousin had written back that she could find room. So at old Miklmas, when the hiring fairs were over and the farm gear was sold, Vashi would go down to the cousins and Wena would go with her. That was what the promise meant now. In a fortnight, Venner would leave the Dale for good, to be a poor relation in a stranger’s back bedroom, because she had given her word to a dying man that his sister would not be alone.
There was one thing she would leave that she could not bear to think about, and so she did not think about it. In the parlor under a shawl stood her mother’s little square piano for the only thing Wena had brought to the farm besides her clothes. Vashi called it the dust catcher. It was to be sold with the rest.
Wa played it only when Vashi was out at market or down at the chapel with the parlor door shut and the window open onto the gill. She played the old heirs her mother had taught her and she played the one piece that her mother had made herself. The winter winner was born and never written down. It had no name.
Her mother had only ever called it yours. Nobody in the world knew it now but Wena and her fingers. The long room at the inn smelled of candle grease and wet wool, and the Miklmus goose that was being carved in the parlor below. It was full to the walls. Every farming family of any standing in the dale had come down for it with the town families and the clergy and the doctor’s wife.
A crowd of young men in tight coats stood in a knot by the door and looked at everybody as if they had paid to. Vashi went in first in her rose silk with her head high. Wena came after with Vashi’s shawl over her arm. The talk did not stop when they came in, but it changed. Wena felt it change. the way you feel the air change before rain, and she did not need to look round to know where the eyes had gone.
They found two chairs on the bench along the wall, under a window that would not quite shut. For a while, nothing happened. The fiddlers tuned. The master of ceremonies went up and down with his list. Wena sat with her hands folded in her lap and looked at the floor, and she thought that if she kept very still, it would pass, as such things generally did.
Then, quite close behind her, from the group of town ladies by the punch, a woman’s voice said, “My dear, is that a gown or a family relic?” Somebody laughed. another voice said. She was married in it, I’m told. And that brought a louder laugh, a delighted one, the laugh of people who have been given something to share.
Winner did not turn round. She had learned in 2 years at the farm how to sit through a thing without letting it reach her face. She was managing it quite well until she heard the next laugh. It was small and quick and a little breathless and it came from beside her. It was Vashis. She will wear it, Vashi said to the ladies by the punch, half turning on the bench with her chin up and her color high sentiment, you know.
We are only country people. And the ladies laughed again warmly now because Vashi had come over to their side and that was always welcome. It was then that Wena felt it finally all the way down. Not the strangers. She did not know the strangers and would never see them again. It was the small quick laugh beside her from the woman she had got up in the dark for every morning for 2 years because of a promise.
She sat very straight. She looked at the fiddlers. She noticed that the left-hand fiddler had a patch on his elbow in a different brown. She noticed that the candles in the near sconce were guttering in the draft from the window. She noticed that her own hands in her mother’s old kid gloves were holding each other so tightly that the darned fingertips had begun to split again.
By the door, the young man in the yellow waste coat had heard the laughter and wanted his share of it. He was the son of a mill owner from lower down the river, with more money than his father had ever had at his age, and a voice made for being heard across a room. A guinea, he said, says no man in this room stands up with the widow in her grandmother’s gown. His friends roared.
Two of them took him up at once. Somebody slapped the wall, and at the other end of the room, beside a pillar, a tall man with a burn hair, turned his head. He still had his hat under his arm. He looked at the bench under the window. He had half noticed it a moment before, when a woman in rose silk turned on it to laugh with the ladies by the punch.
Evan, Duke of Burkholm, had been at the assembly for less than a quarter of an hour, and he had already decided it was the last he would ever attend. He disliked crowds. He disliked being looked at, and he had been looked at since he came through the door, measured and priced like a horse at a fair. He had come only because his great aunt had asked it.
Lady Una was 80 and nearly blind and too proud to say how much she missed company. She sat now in the chair beside his pillar with both hands on the head of her stick. What is it? She said. What are they laughing at, Evan? I can’t see past the end of my [clears throat] own nose in this light. He did not answer at once because the laughter had done something to him that he had not expected.
It was the last laugh that did it. The young man’s, the big pleased laugh of somebody who has made a room look at him. Evan had known a laugh exactly like it. He had laughed at himself. At 19, in his first London season, he had stood in a ballroom with his friends and made a clever remark about a girl in a turned silk gown.
It was a very good remark. The whole group had laughed, and then the people near them, and the girl had heard it. She was a clergyman’s daughter, up from the country, in the only good gown she owned. He had watched her face go perfectly still. Then she had walked out of the ballroom, and he had never learned her name.
“A widow,” he said to his aunt, “in an old blue gown. The town ladies are laughing at it, and the woman beside her laughed with them. Now the young men are laying a wager that nobody will dance with her. Lady Una’s mouth tightened. She knew everybody in the Dale by name, though she had not seen most of their faces clearly for years.
Blue gown under the window. That’ll be the Farburn widow. Davy Farburn’s girl from the farm below the falls. Her mother taught music in the town before she married. She turned her blind eyes up towards him. “Well,” she said, “Are you going to stand there with your hat under your arm all night?” The young man in the yellow waist coat had seen the Duke’s head turn.
He had the sense to be a little alarmed, and not quite enough sense to stop. your grace,” he called down the room with a bow that was half a joke. “Will you take the wager?” Every face in the long room turned towards the pillar. Evan looked at the young man for a moment, quite without expression. “No,” he said.
He put his hat into his aunt’s lap. Then he walked down the whole length of the room through a silence so complete that the fiddler’s boughs hung in the air and stopped in front of the bench under the window. Wa saw him coming and did not believe it. She saw a tall man in a dark coat with orbin hair a little too long at the collar as if he had forgotten to have it cut.
He had a narrow serious face and eyes of a dark moss green like the moss on the north side of the field walls after rain. She saw Vashi beside her half rise with her hand going to her hair. She saw the master of ceremonies hurrying up with his list where the name of the squire’s eldest daughter was written at the top in his best hand. Then the Duke bowed, not to Vashi, and the room went so quiet that Wena could hear the waterfall in her head, though it was far up the dale. “Mrs.
Farburn,” he said, “will you give me the first dance.” His voice was low and level, not meant to carry, and it carried to every corner of the room anyway. Wena looked up at him. For a moment she could not think at all. Then she thought very clearly that if she said no, the laugh would win.
It would follow her down the valley and up the draper’s narrow stairs and into the back bedroom, and it would be there every night for the rest of her life. She took off the shaw that was over her arm and laid it in Vashi’s lap. “Yes, your grace,” she said. “Thank you, I will.” Then she stood up in her mother’s blue gown and put her split glove into his hand.
The fiddlers did not know what to play. The master of ceremonies stood with his mouth open and his list in his hand. The Duke said without turning his head, “Something the lady knows.” The leading fiddler was an old man from the head of the Dale who had played at Wena’s wedding. He looked at her once and struck up the old country tune that every girl in the dale had danced to since she could walk.
A sound went through the room that was half a sigh. Then a farmer’s son near the door took his sweetheart’s hand and came out onto the floor and after him another couple and another. Within a minute, the set had filled and the long room was dancing because the Duke had started it. He danced as if he had learned it long ago and not done it for years.
He was careful and exact, and he did not smile. Wena danced as she had danced at her own wedding because her feet remembered the tune before she did. They went down the set and back. at the top waiting their turn. He said quietly. You need not have accepted. She said, “I know.” Down the set again under the candles, past the faces.
“They will say you did it to win their guinea,” she said when they met at the bottom. He looked at her directly then. “Then they will be wrong.” That was all. He did not say anything else for the rest of the dance, and neither did she, and it was the most she had been spoken to by anybody in a very long time. When it was over, he took her back to the bench under the window and bowed and went away to dance with the squire’s daughter, as he was supposed to.
Wa sat down. Her heart was going so hard that she could feel it in her throat. She looked at her gloves and saw that the right one had split all along the seam of the first finger from holding his hand or from holding her own so hard before it. She took them both off and put them down on the bench to look at them.
And then Vashi stood up white to the lips and said, “We are going home.” And took her by the arm. 10 minutes later, they were in the carrier’s cart going up the dark dale, and the gloves were still lying on the bench in the long room under the window that would not shut. Vashi did not speak the whole way home. Neither did Wena. There was a moon over the fell, and the mist had come down into the bottom again, and the cart went up through it like a boat.
Once near the ford, Vashi made a sound that might have been the beginning of something. Then she turned her face away towards the dark, and Wena saw only the line of her cheek, and the rose silk shining under the edge of her cloak. At the farm gate, Vashy got down without help, and went into the house ahead of her, and up the stairs, and shut her door.
Wena stood a long time in the kitchen with the fire banked low in her blue gown with her bare hands held out to the embers. Evan found the gloves himself an hour later when the room was emptying and the candles were going out. He had looked for her after his dance with the squire’s daughter and she had gone. He stood by the bench under the window and picked them up.
They were small and old, a soft gray kid that had once been good, and they had been darned many times at the tips of the fingers, all 10 of them, with tiny, careful stitches. The darning had worn through again at the right forefinger. He held them on his palm. He had seen gloves worn through like that before, long ago, in his mother’s dressing room.
[clears throat] They were the gloves of somebody who played. He put them into the breast of his coat and took his aunt home. In the carriage, Lady Una said nothing for a long time. And then she said, “You made a great many enemies tonight, all of them under 25. It was very well done.” He looked out at the dark.
“I did not do it for them.” She sniffed. “I know you didn’t. You did it for some girl you laughed at once, I expect when you were young and stupid. He did not answer, and she did not press him, which was the closest Lady Una ever came to tenderness. Outside the window the falls showed white under the moon as they climbed the hill, and the gloves lay against his chest as light as two leaves.
He meant to take them back the next morning, and he did ride down to the farm below the falls. He left his horse at the ford and walked up the lane, rehearsing a sentence he did not much like, but as he came near the house, he heard a piano forte through an open window, and he stopped in the lane by the wall.
Somebody was playing a slow air he had never heard before. It was plain and grave and very tender. It went up like a question and came down again without an answer and then went up again a little higher as if it would not stop asking. He stood by the wall with his hat in his hand and listened to it all the way to the end.
Then he walked back to the ford without knocking and rode home with the gloves still in his coat. We’ll take a very short break. If you don’t want to miss new stories, please subscribe to the channel. And while we rest here for a moment, there is something I have wanted to tell you about. For years, you have asked me for a longer story. So, I wrote one.

Three complete novels. One family, 26 years. You saw one promise. The Duke’s Promise Trilogy by Gary Peton. And because so many of you listen instead of reading, the complete audio books come included. More than 24 hours in this same voice you are listening to right now. You can get it exclusively at timeless lovebooks.com.
And if you’re watching on your TV, just point your phone camera at the code. You will also find the link at the top of the description and in the pinned comment. Now settle back in. Our story is waiting. That evening after dinner he told his aunt. She sat for a long while with a stick across her knees. Her companion of many years had married a curate in the spring and gone to live in Lincolnshire.
And since then the evenings at Fartan had been very long. She could no longer read. She could no longer sew. Music was the last pleasure she had that did not need her eyes, and there had been none in that house since her companion went away. “Write to her,” Lady Una said at last. “No, I’ll write to her. You’ll make a muddle of it.
” And the next morning a footman in the Burke home livery rode down to the farm below the falls with a letter in a hand so large and shaky that had covered the whole sheet. It asked whether Mrs. Farburn would come up to Fartan every afternoon until old Miklmus to read to an old woman who could not see and to play to her in the evenings if she was willing. It named a wage.
It was a fair wage, and more than fair, and Vena read the sum twice to be sure of it. Vashi read the letter over her shoulder at the kitchen table. “You’ll not go,” she said. “Not after last night. Every eye in the dale will be on you, walking up that hill.” Wena folded the letter. She looked at her sister-in-law at the high color and the tight mouth and the eyes that would not quite meet hers.
And she thought of the small quick laugh by the punch. I shall go, she said. It’s only till old Miklmas. You’ll have the wages for the cousin’s house, Vashi. Every penny we’ll need them. [clears throat] She said it quietly and she did not raise her voice and she did not ask. It was the first time in 2 years she had told Vashi what she was going to do instead of waiting to be told.
Vashi looked at her as though she had never seen her before. Then she went out to the dairy and slammed the door. Wena sat down at the table and wrote her answer in her mother’s careful hand. She gave it to the footman who had been waiting in the yard with his hat on and his ears pricricked like a dog’s. The road to Fartan went up the side of the gill past the falls.
Wa walked it the next afternoon in her brown stuff gown and her old cloak with her hands bare because she had no other gloves. It had rained in the night, and the beck was running high and brown, and the waterfall came down over its lip of black rock in a great white rope that she could hear long before she saw it. The rowans along the path were heavy with berries.
The bracken on the fell side was the color of a fox. Above the falls, the road came out onto the shoulder of the hill, and there was the house. It was long and [clears throat] low and gray, built of the same stone as the walls and the barns, so that it looked less like a duke’s house than a farm that had kept on growing.
A grave old butler let her in by a side door and took her through a hall hung with antlers and old dark pictures. Lady Una’s sitting room was at the end of a passage, small and very warm, with a fire built up as if it were January. The old lady sat in a highbacked chair beside it with a shawl over her knees and her stick against her hand.
She was tiny and very upright with a fierce hooked nose and white hair under [clears throat] a lace cap and her eyes with a cloudy blue of a winter sky that might snow. They moved towards the door when Wena came in and fixed a little to the left of her. Farburn’s widow, she said. Come where I can hear you. Sit down. Can you read? Yes, my lady.
Everybody says yes. Most of them can’t. Read me the newspaper. She pointed her stick at a table. Wa sat and read the front of the newspaper aloud, a long dull column about corn and the weather in the south. And after a minute, Lady Una struck the floor with her stick. You read like a curate who wants his dinner. I don’t care about corn.
Read me the deaths and the marriages, and read them as if you’d known the people. So Benner read the deaths and the marriages. And somewhere in the middle of a long notice about a baronet’s widow in Bath, she heard her own voice change. she read as if she were telling it across a kitchen table. When she looked up, the old lady was smiling with her eyes shut.
“Better,” Lady Una said. “You have a good voice when you forget to be frightened. I’m told you have a good touch on the piano forte, too.” Wena went still. “Who told you that, my lady?” The blind eyes opened and moved a little in her direction. Nobody you need concern yourself with. There’s an instrument in the drawing room that nobody has touched since my last companion married and left me.
It was tuned on Monday by a man from the town at very great expense and with a great deal of complaint about the damp. You’ll play to me on it this evening after I’ve dined. Not now. I’m going to sleep now. Read me something dull and I shall be off in 5 minutes. It took her rather less than five.
Winner sat with the book open on her knee and listened to the old lady breathe and to the fire and to the house around them which was very quiet. Somewhere a clock struck. Somewhere a door closed. She thought she heard a man’s step go along the passage outside, slow and even, and pause at the door and go on.
She did not get up to look. She sat with her bare hands folded on the book and looked at the fire. She had not sat still in a warm room in the middle of an afternoon with nothing to do and nobody wanting anything of her since before her mother died. The drawing room at Fartan was long and high and smelled of beeswax and cold ashes, though the fire had been lit for her.
The pianoforte stood at the far end by the window, a grand instrument of dark wood with its lid propped open, and when Vena sat down at it and touched the first cord, she nearly took her hands away again. She had only ever played her mother’s little square piano, which was sweet and thin, and a little out of tune in the top notes, however often it was tuned. This was something else.
The sound came up out of it, and filled the room to the ceiling. Lady Una, settled in a chair by the fire with her eyes shut, said without opening them, “Well, go on. It [clears throat] won’t bite.” She played the old heirs her mother had taught her. She played a slow march and a set of variations on a scotch tune and two country dances and then the sad air that the Dale people sang at burials.
She did not play her mother’s piece. That was not for a drawing room. She played for an hour and the old lady never spoke once except to say again at the end of the scotch tune. When the candles had burned down a finger’s width, Lady Una said, “That will do. You’ll come tomorrow at the same time.” Then, as arose, she said in a different voice, much lower, “It’s been a long while since I heard that instrument. A very long while.
Thank you, child.” And she put out her thin hand, and when I took it, and found it was trembling. Across the hall behind the closed door of the library, Evan sat at his desk with a pen in his hand and a letter halfwritten in front of him and did not write any more of it. He was 31, and he had not been in that house in an evening for nearly 10 years.
He had told himself he came back this autumn to see to the estate which needed it, and to see his great aunt, who would not live forever. Both of those were true, but he had come back mostly because he was tired of London and of being looked at and of the faces around dinner tables that smiled at him and wanted something.
And now somebody was playing the old pianoforte across the hall, and he could not move. He sat and listened, and he thought about the girl in the London ballroom, as he did more often than he would have admitted to anybody. He had been 19 and very pleased with himself, and the remark had been about her sleeves. He could not now remember the words.
He remembered only the laugh going round and her face going smooth and pleasant, the way a pond goes smooth after a stone sinks. She had not cried. She had simply turned and walked the length of the room to the door with everybody watching and gone out. He had asked about her afterwards, and nobody knew.
Some Parson’s girl, they said, from some county or other. She had gone home the next week, and his friends had forgotten her by the Thursday. He had not. A laugh did not have to strike anybody. He had learned. It only had to go round, and something was taken out of the room that never came back. Evan had spent most of his life since then, being very careful never to laugh at anybody at all.
People called him cold. He had decided long ago that he would rather be cold. He did not go into the drawing room. He sat in the library and listened through two closed doors until the playing stopped. Then he heard the side door open and close and her light step go away across the yard towards the road.
After that, he took the old gray gloves out of the drawer of his desk where he had put them that morning and laid them on the blott in front of him. He had meant to give them back to her tonight. He could not bring himself to do it with all 10 fingers worn through, as if he were handing her back her own poverty in a little parcel. In the morning he rode down into the town and left them at the glovers in the marketplace with instructions to mend them in kid of the same gray and not to hurry.
Down at the farm, Vashi was waiting up with the candle. She had the tin box on the kitchen table, the one they kept the money for the cousin’s house in, and she watched while Vena put her first day’s wage into it. Then she shut the lid. Did he speak to you? Wena hung up her cloak. I didn’t see him. I read to Lady Una and played for her.
That’s all. Vashy looked at her a moment longer. They’re saying in the town that he did it to shame me, she said. That he picked you out under my nose to show the whole Dale what he thought of a woman who laughed. Her voice was quite steady. only her hand on the tin was not. Do you know what they called me after the sister who laughed? Wa stood by the dresser and looked at her.
She thought of a dozen things she might say, and some of them were true, and all of them would have been easy. She said none of them. “You did laugh, Vashi,” she said instead. Vash’s chin went up. For a moment, WA thought she would say something cutting, as she always did, but she only looked down at the tin under her hand. “I know I did,” she said.
“I don’t know why they were all looking, and I wanted them to stop looking at us. I wanted to be on the side that was laughing for once.” Then she took the candle and went up to bed and left Wena in the dark kitchen with the fire and the sound of the beck below the house. That night Wena lay awake under the slope of the roof and thought about her mother, which she did not often let herself do.
She remembered a winter evening in the little house in the town, the winter before the wedding, with snow falling past the window and the square piano fort in the corner. Her mother had sat beside her on the bench with her shawl round both their shoulders. Again, her mother had said slower. It isn’t a jig. It’s a question, love.
You’re asking somebody something. You have to leave them room to answer. Then she had put her own hands over winners on the keys, light and dry and warm, to show her the place where the tune went up and waited. Why don’t you write it down? Wa had asked her once. Then it would be safe. Her mother had only laughed.
She could write music well enough. She said she had copied out parts for her pupils for years, but she had learned the best things she knew by ear from her own mother, who could not read at all. “This one isn’t for paper,” she said. “It’s for you. Don’t play it for people who talk through it.
Play it for the ones who listen.” And Wena never had. She had played it to her mother and to Davey once on their wedding night. He had sat on the arm of the old parlor chair with his big hands between his knees and cried without seeming to know he was doing it. Since then she had played it to nobody but the gill outside the parlor window.
So the days took on a shape the way days do. In the mornings she worked at the farm beside Vashy, for there was a great deal to do before old Miklmas. The use had to be gathered off the fell and the best of them sold. The geese went to market. The farm gear was cleaned and set out in the yard for the sale.
In [snorts] the afternoons she walked up past the falls to Fartan and read to Lady Una. The old lady fell asleep and woke and asked for the deaths and marriages again. Then she made sharp remarks about everybody in them. In the evenings she played, and on the way home in the dark she walked down the gill road alone, with her hands bare and the mist coming up from the beck to meet her and the lights of the farm below.
She saw the Duke only at a distance in those first days. He was out on the fell with his steward or riding along the walls or standing in the yard talking to the shepherds about the gather. Once she passed him on the road above the falls. He was on foot leading his horse with his coat dark from the rain.
He stopped and bowed and she curtsied and neither of them said a word. She went on down the hill with her face hot. She did not know why it should be hot. He had not said anything. That was precisely the trouble, she thought. He was a man who said so little that every word he did say stayed with you, and you turned it over afterwards like a stone in your pocket.
Then they will be wrong.” [clears throat] She said it under her breath, walking down through the ruins in the dark. five words in the middle of a country dance, and she had heard them in her head every day since. It was a wet evening at the end of the first week when it happened. The rain had come over the fell at dusk and settled in, and it ran down the long windows of the drawing room in sheets, so that the candles showed double in the glass.
Lady Una had dined early and fallen asleep in her chair by the fire before Wena had finished the first country dance. Her breathing was slow and even, and her cap had slipped a little over one ear. Wa went on playing softly for a while. Then she stopped and sat with her hands in her lap, listening to the rain. The room was warm. The house was silent.
And without quite deciding to, she put her hands back on the keys and began to play her mother’s piece. She had never played it on an instrument like that. It came up out of the dark wood as if it had been waiting there. It went up like a question and came down without an answer and went up again a little higher and waited the way her mother had taught her.
She played it slowly. She played it as if her mother were on the bench beside her with the shawl around them both. When the last note had gone into the corners of the room, she sat with her eyes shut and her hands on the keys. Then a man’s voice said quietly from the doorway, “What is that called?” She turned so fast that the bench scraped.
The Duke was standing just inside the door in his shirt sleeves and waste coat with a book closed on his finger. As if he had come out of the library, meaning to go somewhere else, and had forgotten where. She felt the blood go into her face. She felt something worse than that, too. A kind of shame, as if he had walked in on her undressed.
“It hasn’t a name,” she said. “It isn’t for anybody.” I thought her lady was asleep. He did not come any further into the room. “She is? I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to listen.” He paused. “That isn’t true. I did mean to. I heard it once before from the lane below your house the morning after the assembly. Wena stared at him.
You stood in the lane and listened. He met her eyes. I came to bring your gloves back. I heard the pianoforte through the window and I could not knock. I stood by the wall until it was finished. And then I went home. She did not know whether she was angry. She thought she ought to be. And my gloves, she said. You have them still? He hesitated.
It was the first time she had ever seen him look uncomfortable. They are being seen too, he said. You will have them back. I give you my word. It was such a strange answer that she could not think what to say to it, and so for a while neither of them said anything at all. Lady Una slept on. The rain ran down the windows.
After a time, the Duke came and stood by the end of the pianoforte with his hand resting on the dark wood and looked down at the keys rather than at her. “You asked me at the assembly why I had done it,” he said. “You didn’t ask in words, but you wanted to know.” Wa said nothing. He was quiet a moment.
Then in the same lowle voice looking at the keys he told her about the girl in the London ballroom. He told her about the remark and the laugh going round and the long walk to the door. He told it very plainly. The way a man tells a thing he has never told before and has rehearsed in his head for yours.
I never learned her name. He said I never could tell her I was sorry. I have thought of her a great many times since, and I expect she has never once thought of me. When I heard that young fool laugh in the long room, it was my own laugh I heard. I knew exactly how pleased with himself he was, and the woman beside you laughed with them the way my friends did.
He took his hand off the pianoforte. So I crossed the room. It was not chivalry, Mrs. Farbin, I would like you to know that. I simply could not bear to hear it again and do nothing. Wa looked at him for a long time. She saw that his hand resting now at his side was not quite steady. She understood that no one else had ever been told this.
Not his great aunt, not his friends in London, not anybody. She understood too that he had told her because of the piece, because she had played it and he had heard it, and he thought it only fair to give her something of his own in return. You did something that night I could never have done for myself, she said. I could have sat there till the candles went out.
I could have walked out with my head up, but I couldn’t have made them stop laughing. Only you could do that. And you did. He looked up at her then. His face eased very slightly, the way the fell eases when the cloud lifts off it. She had never seen it do that before. What is it? He said, and nodded at the keys. If it hasn’t a name.
So she told him. She told him about her mother and the winter she was born and the little house in the town with snow going past the window. She told him that her mother had made the piece up out of her own head and had never written it down because she said it was not for paper. She had never given it a name either.
She had only ever called it yours. Nobody knows it now but me, she said. When I’m gone, it goes, too. I used to think that didn’t matter. Lately, I’ve begun to think it does. The Duke was quiet. Then he said, “I could write it down.” She looked at him. “My mother taught me to read and write music before I could read a book.
” He said, “She kept me at it on wet afternoons, copying out her parts. She plays still in bath and writes to complain that I never do. I play badly, but I can hear a thing and put it on paper near enough. If you would play it to me a little at a time, I could write it down, and then it would be safe. He stopped. Only if you wish it.
She told you it wasn’t for paper. Wa sat with her hands in her lap. She heard her mother’s voice very clearly in the warm room with the rain on the windows. Don’t play it for people who talk through it. Play it for the ones who listen. She looked at the man standing at the end of the piano forte. He had stood in a wet lane by a wall and listened to it to the end and gone away without knocking.
She told me to play it for the ones who listen. She said, “You listened?” “Yes, I wish it.” And from the chair by the fire, without opening her eyes, Lady Una said, “Then do it in here where I can hear you, and don’t either of you imagine I’ve been asleep.” So that was how they did it. Every evening after Lady Una had dined, the Duke brought a sheath of ruled music paper from the drawer of the pianoforte stool, where it had lain since he was a boy.
He set it on a little table at Rena’s elbow with a pen and ink. Wena played a phrase. He listened with his head bent and wrote and then read it back to her in a low hum under his breath. He was quick. He heard things in it that she had never known were there. “It waits there,” he would say, and she would say, “Yes, it’s asking.
” And he would nod and write it down. Lady Una sat by the fire with her stick across her knees and pretended to doze and every so often she said again. And they played it again. It went slowly, for the piece was longer than Wena had ever realized and fuller. She had never had to think about it before. She had only ever played it. Now she found she had to take it apart bar by bar and hand each piece across to him to be written down.
It was a strange and tender business, like handing somebody the contents of a drawer you had never let anybody open. On the fourth evening she came to a run in the left hand that she could not slow down. Her fingers knew it, but she could not make them tell her what they did. She tried it three times. Then he said quietly again as fast as you like and wrote it down at the speed and she played it without a pause.
When he held the page out to her, she reached for it and without either of them meaning it. Her hand closed over his on the paper. She did not let go at once. She felt his hand go still under hers. It was warm and he did not move it, and he hardly seemed to breathe. Neither of them said a word. He wrote the bar down. She played the next.
Lady Una said again from the fireside a little louder than she needed to. And on the walk home that night down the gill road with the falls loud after the rain, Wena held her right hand closed in the fold of her cloak. She held it so all the way down to the farm, as if there was something in it she might drop.
Evan sat up in the library long after she had gone those nights with the pages spread out on the desk in front of him under the lamp. He copied out each evening’s work fair in his best hand on clean paper. He found he could hear the piece in his head now, the whole of what they had so far.
He found he could hear her voice saying it’s asking. He was not a man who had ever had much use for his own feelings. He had learned young that they were safer kept out of sight. But he sat in that room night after night with her mother’s music under his hands, and he knew perfectly well what had happened to him. He had known it, if he was honest, since a wet lane and a wall and an open window.
He did not know what to do about it. That was the trouble. She was two years a widow in his aunt’s pay with a whole dale ready to talk. Anything he said would be a wait on her. He was the Duke of Burkholm and she could not easily say no to him, and he would never be sure that she had not said yes for the same reason.
So he said nothing. He copied the music out. He rode the fell walls in the mornings with his steward. And every evening he went into the drawing room at the hour she began to play and sat at the little table with his pen and listened. Down at the farm the days were running out. The use had gone down to the autumn sales at the market town.
The geese had gone at Miklmas. On the Saturday before old Mikkelmas, the auctioneer came up from the town, and the farm gear was sold in the yard in the rain, piece by piece, to neighbors who did not quite meet Vashie’s eye. The plow went, and the harrows, and the churns, and the old oak settled from the kitchen. Last of all, two men carried the little square pianoforte out of the parlor and stood it in the wet yard under a sack.
Wena stood by the dairy door with her arms folded tight and watched the landlord of the inn in the market town buy it for the long room cheaply because nobody else had bid. She did not cry. She watched them lift it onto the cart and rope it down. She watched the cart go down the lane towards the ford with the sack flapping.
Vashi beside her said nothing for a long time. Then she said quite gently for her, “I never once heard you play that thing. Not in 3 years.” Wena did not look at her. “You were always out when I did.” Bashi was quiet. “I know,” she said. “I went out so I’d not have to.” Wena looked at the empty lane. “It doesn’t matter,” she said.

“It’s only wood and wire. Mother never wrote the piece down, but it isn’t in the wood either.” She did not say that it was written now, or very nearly in a man’s careful hand on a desk at the top of the gill. She did not say anything else at all. She went inside to the bare parlor and stood in the square of clean floor where the pianoforte had been on the Tuesday before old Miklmas.
Vashi went down to the market town on the carrier’s cart to see about the boxes for the coach and she came back white. Wena saw it from the yard as the cart drew up. Vashi got down without a word and walked straight past her into the kitchen. When WA followed, she was standing at the table with her bonnet still on and both hands flat on the bare boards as if the floor had moved.
“They’re laying wages on you,” she said without turning around. “In the long room at the inn, that young pup in the yellow waist coat and his friends. They have a book open on the parlor table where anybody can see it.” Wena stood in the doorway. On me. Vashley turned then. Her face was quite steady, but there were two red marks high on her cheekbones, like the marks of fingers.
On whether the Duke was ever in earnest, she said, or only making game of the whole Dale. They say he picked the shabiest gown in the room to show us what he thought of us. They say he has you up there playing every night, so he’ll have a tale to laugh at in London once he’s tired of the tune. Those were the words. Tired of the tune.
She took her bonnet off and put it down on the table very carefully, as if it might break. The doctor’s wife crossed the marketplace so as not to bow to me. She bowed to me at the assembly. Wena? She asked after my butter. Wa came into the kitchen and sat down on the bench because her knees would not hold her.
She thought of the warm drawing room and Lady Una by the fire saying again and the Duke’s bent head over the music paper. She thought of how it would sound, told in the long room over the punch by a young man who needed to be laughed with. It did not matter that none of it was true.
She had lived in the Dale long enough to know that a thing did not have to be true to be believed. It only had to be told with enough people listening. It isn’t so, she said. You know it isn’t. Lady Una is in the room every minute. I know it isn’t, Bashi said. That’s nothing to do with it. She sat down on the other end of the bench, which she had never done before in two years, and looked at her own hands.
They were red and rough from the butter and the cold water, and she turned them over as if they belonged to somebody else. I was 17 the first time I went to that long room. She said, “Mother made me a gown out of an old one of hers with the sleeves cut down. I thought it was the finest thing I had ever seen.
And a girl from the town looked at it and laughed.” Her friends laughed, too, and nobody asked me to dance all night. I sat on that bench under the window till the candles were out. I never went back. Not till this Mikkelmus. Wena turned and looked at her. Vashi did not look back. So when they started on your gown, she said very low.
I laughed with them. Because I knew what it was like on the other side, and I couldn’t bear to be on it again. [clears throat] That’s the truth of it. I’m not proud of it. She drew a long breath. And now they’re laughing at you again. And [clears throat] it’ll get worse, not better. It always does. So, I’m asking you, come with me on Thursday, WA.
Don’t stay up there to be talked about. Davey said I’d never ask you for anything. I was outside the door, Wena. I heard him. Her voice cracked very slightly, and she mended it at once. He was wrong. I’m asking. There was nothing in the world Wena could have said to that. But yes, she had promised a dying man in a snowbound room that his sister would not be alone.
And now his sister had asked, which was the thing he had said she would never do. Wa put out her hand and laid it over Vashi’s red one on the bench between them. Vashi’s hand went stiff under it. Then slowly it turned over and held on. “I’ll come,” Wena [clears throat] said. “Of course I’ll come.
” And they sat like that in the bare kitchen for a long while, the two of them, with the light going and the beck loud below the house, saying nothing at all. The next evening was her last at Fartan. She walked up past the falls for the last time in the brown stuff gown, and she did not let herself look at anything too long, because she knew if she did, she would not be able to stop.
Lady Una was in the drawing room already by the fire. The Duke was at the little table with the pages laid out, more than a dozen of them now, in his clear, small hand. Only the end was left to write. when I sat down at the piano forte and played it for him slowly. The question went up and came down and went up again higher and waited.
And then at the very end, as her mother had always played it, it came home. It found the note it had been asking for quietly, as if it had known all along. He wrote it down. He played it back with one finger very carefully, and this time he had it right. Then he sat back and looked at the pages, and she looked at them too, and neither of them said anything for a moment. “There,” he said at last.
“It’s safe,” Wena sat with her hands on the keys. “Thank you,” she said. Her voice did not come out properly. She tried again. “I’m going with my sister-in-law tomorrow, down to the market town for the fair, and onto her cousins by the morning coach. I shan be coming back up the gill. She made herself look at him.
Lady Una knows. I told her this afternoon. The Duke did not move. She saw his hand go flat on the pages the way Vashis had gone flat on the table as if something had shifted underfoot. Is it what you wish? He said. She could have told him then about the long room and the book on the parlor table. and tired of the tune. She did not.
She could not bear to have him hear it from her mouth. It’s what I promised. She said, “My husband asked me not to leave his sister alone. She’s asked me herself now. I can’t refuse her.” She waited. She did not know what she was waiting for. A word. Any word at all. He looked at her across the little table and his face was very still and there was something working in it that she could not read.
Then I wish you a safe journey, he said. You will have your gloves before you go. I gave you my word. That was all. He stood and bowed. Wa stood and curtsied and went to Lady Una’s chair to say goodbye. The old lady took her face between both thin hands and held it as if she were trying to see it with her fingers. “You’re a fool, child,” Lady Una said.
“So is he.” “And I’m too old to wait for either of you to stop being one.” Then she kissed Wena’s forehead and let her go. Wena went out by the side door into the dark yard and down past the falls, and she did not cry until she reached the ford. In the drawing room, Lady Una sat very upright in her chair and listened to the side door close.
“Well,” she said. Evan was standing by the window with his back to her. “She has made her choice. It’s hers to make.” Lady Una struck the floor with her stick so hard that the fire jumped. Don’t you dare talk to me like a parson. I’m 80 years old and I am not deaf, whatever else I am. My maid’s sister is married to the osler at the inn.
They have a book open in the long room, Evan, on whether you were ever in earnest with the girl or only laughing at her. That’s what she’s running from. and she’d sooner die than tell you so.” He turned round. His face had gone very white. Lady Una did not soften. “You laughed at somebody once,” she said. “Don’t look at me like that.
I know you did. You’ve spent your whole life since making sure you never would again. And that’s to your credit. But you’ve made a religion out of keeping still, my boy. You stood there just now and let her walk out of the door because you didn’t want to be await on her. Do you know what that looks like from where she stood? It looks like a man with nothing to say.
She was quiet a moment. When a woman’s waiting for a word, being too careful to speak, and having nothing to say, come to exactly the same thing in the end. Evan stood a long while by the dark window. He could see nothing in it but the reflection of the room. There was the fire and the old lady in her chair and his own face and the pianoforte with its lid still open.
He thought about a girl walking the length of a London ballroom to the door. He had sat in this room every evening for a fortnight and listened to a woman hand him the whole of her heart a bar at a time. He had written it down very neatly. He had never once said what it did to him.
He thought that if he let her get into that coach in the morning, he would have learned only half of what that girl had taught him. He had stopped laughing. He had never learned to speak. He went to the library. He took the pages from the desk and sat down with a fresh sheet. Then he began to copy the whole piece out fair from the first note to the last, so that she would have it entire without a blot.
It took him most of the night. When it was done near dawn, he sat for a while with the pen in his hand. Then he wrote a word at the top of the first page, above the first bar, where a piece of music has its name. He looked at it a long time. He did not cross it out, and at first light he rode down the gill road to the market town in the halflight, with the falls loud beside him, to fetch a pair of gray gloves from a glover’s shop.
The market town was full to the rooftops for old Miklmus. The carrier brought them down at midday with their boxes roped behind through a street so thick with people that the cart could hardly move. It was hiring day. The farm lads stood along the market cross in their clean smoks, waiting for a farmer to come and look them over.
Carter wore a twist of whip cord in his hat and a shepherd a tuft of wool. The girls stood in a row by the churchyard wall in their best bonnets. There were gingerbread stalls and a man selling ballads that nobody bought and a fiddler on every corner. The mist had burned off. The sky over the fells was the hard clear blue of a morning when the weather means to hold.
They had a room for the night at the top of the inn under the roof with a window that looked down on the yard where the coach would stand at first light. Vashi saw the boxes carried up and paid the boy. Then the two of them went down the narrow stairs to ask the landlady about supper.
And at the turn of the passage they came face to face with the young man in the yellow waist coat. He was standing in the parlor doorway with three of his friends and a glass in his hand. Behind him on the parlor table, open where anybody could see it, lay a long, thin book [clears throat] with a pencil on a string.
He saw Wena and grinned and began very softly to hum a tune. His friends laughed. Wena felt her face go cold. But before she could move or speak, Vashi stepped past her and planted herself in front of the young man, so close that he had to take a step back into the parlor. She was a head shorter than he was.
It made no difference at all. You’ll take your hat off to my sister, young man, she said in the clear, carrying voice she used for calling the cows in off the fell. or I’ll go down the street this minute and tell your father what you lost at cards behind this inn at last year’s hiring. I know because the osler told me and the osler’s never been wrong yet.
The young man went scarlet to the roots of his hair. He took his hat off. Vashi looked at him a moment longer and then she took Wena’s arm and walked her back up the stairs without another word. in the little room under the roof. She sat down on the end of the bed and put her hands over her face and Wena saw that they were shaking.
“I’ve wanted to do that,” Bashley said through her fingers. “Since I was 17.” Then she laughed, and it was not the small quick laugh from the bench in the long room. “It was something else altogether.” Wena sat down beside her. After a while, Vashi took her hands away from her face and looked at the boxes stacked against the wall.
“I lay awake all last night,” she said. “Thinking about what our Davyy said to you. Don’t leave her on her own. That’s what he said, isn’t it?” Wena nodded. “Well, he never asked you to come and be lonely with me. He’d not have wanted that. Not for you, Vashi.” Wena said, “I’m not going to break my word.” Ashley shook her head. “You’ve kept it.
You’ve kept it two years through every cold morning, and I never once said thank you, and I’m saying it now.” She stood up and went to the window and looked down into the yard. I’ll go to the cousin. I’ll do well enough. I’m good at work, and she’ll be glad of it, and it’s what I’m fit for. You’re fit for something else. Her back was very straight.
I’m not telling you what to do. I’ve done enough of that. I’m only telling you that you’re free of me if you want to be. That’s all. It’s yours to choose now. There was a knock at the door. It was the land lady, a stout, red-faced woman with her sleeves rolled, and she had a flat parcel in brown paper under her arm.
For Mrs. Farbin, she said. His grace brought it himself not half an hour since, and he’s in the long room now, if you please, standing by a pillar like a man waiting to be hanged. She put the parcel in WA’s hands and went away down the stairs, and they heard her laughing all the way to the bottom.
Wena sat on the bed and opened it with fingers that would not work properly. Her gloves lay on top. They were the same soft gray kid, her mother’s gloves, but every fingertip had been mended with new gray leather, so fine that she could hardly see the joints. They were whole again. They were better than whole. Under them lay a thick fold of music paper, written out fair from the first note to the last, in a clear, small hand, without a single blot.
And at the top of the first page, above the first bar, where a piece of music has its name, he had written a word, yours. Below it, smaller, he had written a single line. For the ones who listen, I should like to go on listening for as long as you will play. Wa sat with the pages in her lap and did not move. Vashi came and stood beside her and looked down at the word on the page and did not ask what it meant.
After a long moment, she said quite gruffly, “Your blues in the top of the box. I packed it myself. I’ll lace you.” And Rena looked up at her sister-in-law and understood that this was the nearest thing to a blessing Vashi knew how to give. She stood up. Vashi took the blue gown out of the box and shook out the creases and helped her into it.
She laced it with quick hard fingers and turned her round by the shoulders to look at her. There, she said, “You look like the weather’s going to hold.” The long room was hot and crowded and roaring. It was not the Miklmis assembly of a fortnight before. It was the hiring fair dance and anybody might come who had a coat on his back.
Farm lads who had been hired that morning were spending their first wages on punch. Dairy maids danced in their patterns. The town families stood along the walls and the doctor’s wife was there by the window and the young man in the yellow waist coat was in the corner with his friends and his book. and against the far wall with a candle on its lid and a jug of ale beside the candle stood a little square pianoforte.
There was a scratch along its side that Vena had made herself with a thimble when she was 6 years old. She walked in in her mother’s blue gown with her mended gloves on her hands. The noise did not stop, but it changed the way it had changed before, and she felt the eyes go to her. Somebody by the punch said something, and somebody laughed.
Wena did not look round. She did not look for the pillar either, though she knew exactly where it was. She walked the whole length of the room to the little piano forte. She moved the ale jug onto the floor. Then she sat down on the stool and took off her gloves finger by finger and laid them on the lid beside the candle and put her bare hands on her mother’s keys.
She played it for them. She played her mother’s piece, the one that was never for anybody to a room full of farm lads and dairy maids and town ladies and a young man with a betting book. She played it on the thin sweet instrument it had been made on a little out of tune in the top notes. It went up like a question and came down and went up again and waited and the room went quiet.
It went quiet by degrees the way the mist goes off the dale in the morning till nobody was talking at all. Nobody laughed. A dairy made by the door put her hand to her mouth. The old fiddler from the head of the dale, who had played at her wedding, lifted his fiddle, and found the tune by ear, and came in under it softly at the place where it waited.
And at the very end it came home. She sat a moment with her hands on the keys. Then she stood and put her gloves on again and turned round. The Duke was standing by the pillar exactly where he had stood on Miklmus night with his hat under his arm. His face was very pale. Wena walked back down the whole length of the long room towards him through a silence so complete that she could hear the candles.
She stopped in front of him. She curtsied. Your grace, she said, and her voice carried to every corner of the room, though she had not meant it to. Will you give me the first dance? Yes, he said. Thank you, I will. And he took her hand. The old fiddler struck up the country tune that every girl in the Dale had danced to since she could walk.
Nobody else came onto the floor at first. Then a Carter’s lad with whip cord in his hat took a dairy maid by the hand and came out and then another couple and then the whole room. They went down the set and back. At the top waiting their turn, Wena said quietly. You need not have accepted. He said, “I know.
” They went down the set again under the candles, past the faces. When they met at the bottom, she said, “They have a book open in the corner.” And whether you mean it. He looked at her directly then, as he had looked at her a fortnight before. “Then they had better write it down,” he said. “I mean it. I love you.
I have loved you since a lane and a wall and an open window. Will you marry me?” Wena stopped dancing there in the middle of the set, and the couple behind them nearly walked into them. She looked up into his face. She thought of a promise in a snowbound room kept now and of a sister-in-law at an upstairs window. She thought of her mother’s hands over hers on the keys.
“You have to leave them room to answer.” “Yes,” she said. “Yes, Evan.” It was the first time she had ever said his name. She heard him hear it. He lifted her gloved hand and kissed it there on the floor of the long room in front of the whole Dale. And in the corner, very slowly, the young man in the yellow waist coat closed his book.
Afterwards in the inyard, with the noise of the dancing coming through the windows and the stars out over the fells, he drew her close to him under the arch. He held her there for a long time without saying anything. Then he kissed her very gently as if he were asking her something, and she kissed him back, which was the answer.
“You stood in the lane,” she said against his coat. You stood in the lane and listened to the end and went away without knocking. He laughed then quietly the first time she had ever heard him laugh, and it was nothing like the laugh he had been ashamed of half his life. I’ve been trying to knock ever since, he said.
Vashi left by the coach at first light, as she had always meant to. Wena stood in the yard in the cold with her shawl around her and the duke beside her and watched the boxes roped onto the roof. Vashi would not be persuaded to stay. She had made up her mind, she said, and for once in her life it was her own mind and nobody else’s.
She kissed Wena once hard on the cheek and got up into the coach without help. As the horses pulled out under the arch, a hand came up at the window and stayed there, red and rough from the butter, until the coach turned the corner and was gone. They were married before the month was out in the little stone church at the Dale Foot on an ordinary gray morning with the rooks loud in the churchyard elms.
The bride wore an old blue gown made over once and a pair of gray kid gloves mended at every finger. Lady Una sat in the front pew with her stick and said again very loudly when the vicar stumbled over the vows and the whole church laughed and this time nobody minded. The old fiddler played them out of the church porch.
The tune he played had no name that anybody in the Dale knew. It went up like a question and came home. The next Miklmass, the carrier’s cart, came up the lane with news as it always did, and the carrier stood up on the board to shout it, but there was nobody in the paddock to hear him. The farm below the falls had a new family in it now, a young shepherd and his wife.
The news went on up the gill road to the long gray house on the shoulder of the fell, where the drawing room windows stood open to the sound of the falls. A cradle stood by the pianoforte, and in it slept a small red-haired daughter of five weeks, with her fists closed. Her mother sat at the keys, playing very softly.
Her father sat at the little table beside them with a pen, writing down a new piece, a bar at a time. Lady Una was by the fire, older and fiercer than ever, saying again. On the mantelpiece stood a letter from a wool town far down the valley. Bashti did not write often and never at length. But she had a little ribbon shop now, she said, in the front room of the cousin’s house, and it did very well.
She had been to the Miklmiss assembly in the town. She did not say whether anybody had asked her to dance. She only said that she had worn a new gown, and that nobody had laughed, and that she had stayed until the candles were out. There were things that could not be mended. Wena’s mother had never heard the piece played in a room full of people who listened.
Davy lay in the churchyard at the Dale foot and Wena still took him the first primroes every spring. Evan never learned the name of the girl in the London ballroom, and never could tell her he was sorry. But Evan had bought the little square instrument back from the landlord of the inn the week of the wedding.
It stood now in the room where Venner had first played to an old blind woman, and its lid was never shut, and down in the bottom of the dale that Mikkelmass morning, the mist lay white as milk in a bowl, and above it, as far as anybody could see, the weather held. Thank you for listening to the story all the way to the end.
If you would like to support the channel and keep these stories free for everyone, my new trilogy, The Duke’s Promise, is out now. Over 600 pages and more than 24 hours of narration in this same voice that you will not find anywhere else. It is waiting for you at timelesslobooks.com. And if you’re watching on your TV, just point your phone camera at the code.
Please tell us which city you’re watching from and what the story made [clears throat] you feel. Don’t forget to subscribe so you won’t miss new stories. As always, thank you for being