News

The Chair On Avenue Berthelot: How Klaus Barbie, The Butcher Of Lyon, Interrogated The Women Of The French Resistance

Signature: 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

The chair was made of plain wood, the kind you would find in any school or town hall in France.

It stood in the middle of an office on the second floor of a large building on Avenue Berthelot in Lyon, facing a desk, a lamp and a window that had been painted over so that nobody outside could see in.

In the spring of 1944, the young woman sitting on that chair had been told to keep her back straight and her hands on her knees.

She did both.

She was twenty-three years old.

She had been arrested that morning on a tram with a bundle of underground newspapers hidden under her coat, and she had already decided, somewhere between the tram stop and the front door, that whatever the men in this building asked her, she would give them nothing.

We will call her Claire Vernet.

She is not a single real person.

She is a composite, built from the documented experiences of the women of the Lyon Resistance who passed through the offices of the German security police between 1942 and 1944, so that this story can follow one woman from beginning to end without putting invented words into the mouths of real survivors.

The places, the dates, the men in charge and the other women named in this article are real.

The building had once been the French army’s medical school, the École du Service de Santé Militaire.

By 1944 it belonged to the Sipo-SD, the German security police and intelligence service, and one of its sections, Section IV, was what the people of Lyon simply called the Gestapo.

The head of that section was a thirty-year-old SS officer from the Rhineland with a soft voice, a polite smile and a habit of conducting the most important interrogations himself.

His name was Klaus Barbie.

The city would give him another name, one that followed him for forty years.

The Butcher of Lyon.

—

## A City Between Two Rivers

Lyon sits where two rivers meet, the Rhône and the Saône, and during the Second World War it sat at another meeting point as well.

After the defeat of 1940, France was cut in two.

The north was occupied by the German army.

The south, including Lyon, was left to the collaborationist government of Marshal Pétain in Vichy.

For two years, that line made Lyon a refuge.

People who were hunted in the north came south.

The largest Resistance movements in the southern zone, among them Combat, Libération-Sud and Franc-Tireur, were run in large part from Lyon.

By the end of 1942, the city had earned a nickname that it still carries with pride: the capital of the Resistance.

In November 1942, after the Allied landings in North Africa, the German army crossed the demarcation line and occupied the south as well.

The refuge was gone overnight.

That same month, the German security police sent a new officer to Lyon to take charge of the fight against the Resistance and the persecution of the city’s Jews.

He was twenty-nine years old.

—

## The Man From Bad Godesberg

Klaus Barbie was born on 25 October 1913 in Godesberg, a spa town on the Rhine that is now part of Bonn.

His father was a schoolteacher who had come home from the First World War bitter and wounded, and the family’s life was not a happy one.

Barbie joined the SS in September 1935 and the Nazi Party in 1937.

He trained in the SD, the intelligence service of the SS, and after Germany invaded the Netherlands in 1940 he served in Amsterdam, where he took part in hunting down Jews and Freemasons.

In Lyon, his formal rank was modest.

He was an SS-Obersturmführer, roughly a lieutenant, and according to the German Historical Museum he was only promoted to captain, SS-Hauptsturmführer, in November 1944, after he had already left the city.

But rank was never the measure of his power.

As head of Section IV of the Sipo-SD in Lyon, he directed arrests, interrogations and deportations across the whole region.

Historians estimate that he was directly responsible for the deportation of up to 14,000 people, Jews and members of the Resistance, during his time in France.

On 9 February 1943, his men raided the offices of the Union Générale des Israélites de France on Rue Sainte-Catherine, a Jewish welfare organization.

They waited inside and arrested everyone who came through the door.

Eighty-four people were taken in a single day.

Almost none of them came back from the camps.

It was the first time many people in Lyon heard his name.

It would not be the last.

—

## The Hotel By The Station And The School On Avenue Berthelot

When the security police first arrived in Lyon, they set up their offices in the Hôtel Terminus, a large railway hotel next to the Perrache station.

Barbie’s section worked there in the winter of 1942 and into 1943.

In the spring of 1943, most of the sections of the Sipo-SD moved into the former military medical school on Avenue Berthelot, on the other side of the Rhône.

According to the French Ministry of the Armed Forces’ memorial service, the building became an interrogation center, where prisoners brought over from Montluc prison were questioned and, in some cases, executed without trial.

Montluc was the other half of the system.

It was an old military prison close to the center of the city, requisitioned by the German army in February 1943 and quickly taken over by the Gestapo.

Between February 1943 and August 1944, more than 10,000 men, women and children were held there, according to the Montluc national memorial.

For many of them, the pattern was the same: a cell at Montluc, a truck across the river in the morning, a day on Avenue Berthelot, a truck back at night.

And then, for most of them, a train.

On 26 May 1944, Allied bombers struck the area around Avenue Berthelot, and the building was badly damaged.

Barbie’s men moved again, this time to offices on Place Bellecour, in the heart of the city.

They stayed there until the Germans left Lyon in late August 1944.

—

## Claire

Claire Vernet grew up in the Croix-Rousse, the old silk-weavers’ hill above the city, where the streets are steep and the buildings are linked by covered passageways called traboules.

During the war, the Resistance used them to vanish.

Her father had been a weaver.

Her mother sewed for a dress shop on the Presqu’île.

Claire had wanted to be a teacher, and she had been studying for her exams when the war came and the money ran out.

She took a job as a typist in a lawyer’s office instead.

The lawyer was a member of the Resistance.

So, within a few months, was she.

At first, she only typed.

Leaflets.

Lists of safe addresses.

Copies of articles for the underground newspapers.

Then she began to carry things: envelopes, false identity papers, bundles of newspapers tied with string.

She was young and slight and ordinary looking, and nobody looked twice at a girl on a tram with a shopping bag.

That is exactly why the Resistance used so many women as couriers.

And it is exactly why, by 1943, the Gestapo in Lyon had begun to look very carefully at girls on trams.

On a cold morning in the spring of 1944, two men in civilian coats boarded Claire’s tram at a stop near the Rhône.

One of them stood at the front.

The other walked slowly down the aisle, looking at faces.

He stopped at hers.

He did not shout.

He asked her, politely, to come with him.

—

## The Office

No transcript survives of the interrogations that took place on Avenue Berthelot.

What follows is a reconstruction, based on the way survivors described the first hours of their questioning: the courtesy, the patience, the quiet threats, and the men waiting by the door.

The office was on the second floor.

A desk.

A lamp hanging low from the ceiling.

A single wooden chair in the middle of the floor.

Claire was told to sit.

Two men in grey-green uniforms took their places by the door, and a third man came in carrying a thin cardboard file.

He wore a dark civilian suit.

His hair was combed back flat and shining.

He sat down across the desk from her, opened the file, and smiled as if they were about to discuss the terms of a lease.

He glanced at her once and spoke in careful French.

“Sit up straight, mademoiselle. This is only a conversation.”

Claire kept her hands on her knees and her eyes on his face.

“Then let me go home, if it is only a conversation.”

He turned a page in the file, without hurrying.

“You will go home. As soon as you give me one name.”

She had practiced this answer, alone, in the dark, many times.

“I don’t know any names. I type letters for a lawyer.”

He closed the file, stood up and walked slowly around the desk until he was behind her chair.

He rested one hand on the back of it.

He did not touch her.

He did not need to.

“Everyone in this chair says that. By tonight, they all remember.”

By the door, one of the uniformed men grinned at the other.

Claire felt her heart beating in her throat.

She kept her back straight anyway.

“Then you will wait a very long time.”

For a moment, nobody in the room moved.

Then the door behind her opened, and the two men by it straightened up as if an officer had walked onto a parade ground.

The man who came in did not say anything at first.

He was not tall.

He did not wear a uniform.

He walked to the window, looked at the painted glass, and then turned to look at the girl on the chair, the way a man looks at a piece of work that has been left unfinished on his desk.

The man with the slicked hair stepped back from the chair.

Claire did not know the newcomer’s name that day.

Many prisoners did not.

Some only put a name to the face decades later, when it appeared in newspapers from the other side of the world.

—

## What Happened In Those Offices

It is important to say plainly what the courtesy in those offices was for.

The Gestapo in Lyon wanted names, addresses, meeting places, radio sets, arms caches, the identity of a leader known only by a code name.

When politeness did not produce them, the questioning turned to brutality.

Survivors described beatings, prisoners held under ice-cold water in a bathtub until they lost consciousness, people hung by their wrists, and days of questioning that went on long after the prisoner had stopped being able to speak.

Many testified that Barbie took part in this himself.

Women were not spared because they were women.

If anything, the interrogators understood that a woman’s family could be used against her.

Husbands, children and parents were arrested and brought into the same buildings, sometimes into the same room.

For Claire, the questioning went on for days.

She was taken back and forth between Montluc and Avenue Berthelot.

She was asked the same questions again and again, by the man with the slicked hair, by others, and at least once more by the quiet man who had stood by the window.

She gave them nothing.

She survived those days by doing one small thing over and over.

Each time she was brought into the room, she sat down and straightened her back before anyone told her to.

It was the only decision in that building that was still hers.

—

## Montluc

At Montluc, the women were kept apart from the men, crowded into cells built for far fewer people.

There was little light, little water and almost no privacy.

Former prisoners later described the particular humiliations of women held there: no way to wash, no sanitary supplies, guards who could look in at any time.

And yet the cells were also places of solidarity.

Women shared the little food they had.

They passed on news in whispers and through the walls.

A new arrival who came back from Avenue Berthelot unable to stand would find hands to hold her up and someone to give her the place nearest the door, where the air was best.

In the morning, the guards would read out names from a list.

Some of those names were for another day of questioning.

Some were for a train to a transit camp in the north, and from there to Germany.

Some were for a firing squad.

Nobody in the cell knew which list a name was on until the woman who owned it was gone.

—

## Caluire, June 1943

The most famous prisoner Barbie ever questioned was not a woman, but his capture shaped everything that happened afterward in Lyon.

Jean Moulin had been sent to France by General de Gaulle to unite the scattered movements of the Resistance into a single organization.

By the spring of 1943 he had done it.

On 21 June 1943, he met several Resistance leaders in the house of a doctor, Frédéric Dugoujon, in Caluire, on the northern edge of Lyon.

Barbie’s men arrived during the meeting and arrested everyone in the house.

How the Gestapo learned of the meeting has been argued over by historians and in French courtrooms for eighty years.

What is not in doubt is what happened next.

Moulin was held under a false name and questioned at length, and he did not reveal what he knew.

He was transferred to Paris and then put on a train toward Germany.

He died in early July 1943, near Metz, from the treatment he had received.

He gave Barbie nothing.

—

## A Visit To The Gestapo

Among the men arrested at Caluire was a Resistance leader called Raymond Aubrac, held under a false name.

His wife, Lucie Aubrac, was a history teacher and a founder of the Libération-Sud movement.

According to her own account, published after the war, Lucie went into Gestapo headquarters in person, posing as a young woman of good family who was engaged to the prisoner and expecting his child.

She asked to see the officer in charge.

In her telling, she spoke with Barbie himself, who informed her that her “fiancé” had been condemned to death.

She did not leave it there.

On 21 October 1943, a Resistance group ambushed a German truck carrying prisoners between Montluc and Avenue Berthelot.

Raymond Aubrac and more than a dozen other prisoners were freed.

Lucie had helped to plan the attack.

In early 1944, the couple escaped to London.

Some details of Lucie Aubrac’s story were later disputed, and Barbie himself tried to cast suspicion on the couple, claims that historians have not accepted.

But the central facts are not in question: a woman walked into Barbie’s headquarters by choice, looked at the men who held her husband, and then went back out and took him from them.

—

## Lise Lesèvre: Nineteen Days

Lise Lesèvre was not young when the Gestapo found her.

She was forty-three, a wife and the mother of two sons, born in Isère and living in Lyon.

She had joined the Resistance in 1941 together with her husband Georges and their son, under the code name “Severane.”

She printed leaflets, carried messages and trained new recruits.

On 13 March 1944, she was arrested at the Perrache station carrying a message intended for a Resistance leader known as “Didier.”

The next day, the Gestapo arrested her husband and their sixteen-year-old son, Jean-Pierre.

What the Gestapo wanted from her was simple.

They wanted Didier.

For nineteen days, according to her later testimony, Barbie questioned her himself.

She was beaten, hung by her wrists and held under freezing water.

One beating broke a vertebra.

She was shown her husband and her son, held in the same prison, as a way of making her talk.

She did not talk.

A German military court sentenced her to death for “terrorism.”

By an administrative mistake, she was put in the wrong cell and the sentence was never carried out.

Instead, she was deported to Ravensbrück, the women’s concentration camp north of Berlin, and then to a forced-labor commando at Leipzig, where prisoners made anti-aircraft shells for the German air force.

She survived.

Her husband did not.

Georges Lesèvre died of typhus at Dachau in April 1945, just before the camp was liberated.

Her son did not either.

Jean-Pierre was among the prisoners put aboard the ship Cap Arcona in the Bay of Lübeck, which was sunk by British aircraft on 3 May 1945, days before the end of the war in Europe.

The British pilots did not know that the ships were full of prisoners.

Forty-three years later, Lise Lesèvre would stand in a courtroom in Lyon and look for the face of the man who had questioned her.

—

## Simone, Thirteen

On 6 June 1944, the day the Allies landed in Normandy, the Gestapo arrested a Jewish family in Lyon, the Kadosches.

They had been betrayed by someone they were sheltering.

Their daughter Simone was thirteen years old.

The family was taken to Gestapo headquarters.

Simone would later describe, many times, the man who came toward her and her parents there, gently stroking a large grey cat.

He asked her, politely, where her two little brothers were.

When she said she did not know, he put the cat down on a table and struck her across the face.

The man was Klaus Barbie.

Simone and her parents were sent to Montluc, then to the transit camp at Drancy outside Paris, and then to Auschwitz.

Her mother was killed there in August 1944.

Simone survived.

She married after the war and became Simone Lagrange.

She spent decades trying to bear witness to what had happened.

In 1972, when a photograph of a German businessman living in Bolivia appeared in the French press, she looked at it and recognized the man with the cat.

—

## Izieu

Nothing Barbie did in Lyon is remembered with more grief than what happened on 6 April 1944 in the village of Izieu, in the hills about fifty miles east of the city.

Since 1943, a large house in Izieu had sheltered Jewish children whose families had been arrested, deported or scattered.

It was run by Sabine and Miron Zlatin, and for months it had been a place of lessons, games and letters home.

On the morning of 6 April 1944, acting on a tip-off, men of the Lyon Gestapo drove up to the house.

They arrested forty-four children, aged four to seventeen, and seven of the adults who looked after them.

That evening, Barbie sent a telex to Paris reporting the operation.

The children were taken to Lyon and then to Drancy.

Almost all of them were deported to Auschwitz and murdered.

Miron Zlatin and two of the oldest boys were shot in Estonia.

Of the adults, only one, Léa Feldblum, survived.

Sabine Zlatin had been away from the house that day.

Among the children were two sisters, Mina and Claudine Halaunbrenner.

Their mother, Ita, had placed them in the care of a children’s aid organization because she could no longer protect or feed them.

She never saw them again.

That telex, signed in Barbie’s name, would lie in an archive for decades.

In the end, it became one of the most important pieces of evidence against him.

—

## Claire’s Road

In June 1944, Claire Vernet was put on a train with several dozen other women from Montluc.

She did not know where it was going.

She arrived, weeks later, at Ravensbrück.

It was a camp of tens of thousands of women from every country in occupied Europe.

Like Lise Lesèvre, Claire was sent on to a factory commando, where women prisoners worked twelve-hour shifts for the German war industry.

She survived because others helped her survive, and because she helped them.

When she was liberated in the spring of 1945, she weighed less than she had at fourteen.

She went home to the Croix-Rousse.

Her mother was still alive.

Her father was not.

She went back to typing, and later to teaching, the career she had always wanted.

She married.

She had children.

She did not talk about Avenue Berthelot.

Like many women who came back from the camps, she found that people did not really want to hear.

France wanted to remember the Liberation, not the years before it, and women of the Resistance were often treated as helpers, not fighters.

So she said nothing, and she watched the newspapers.

—

## A Useful Man

Barbie left Lyon in late August 1944, days before the city was liberated on 3 September.

When the war ended, he was on the lists of wanted war criminals.

He was not arrested.

He was hired.

From 1947, the Counter Intelligence Corps of the United States Army used Barbie as an informant.

The Americans were already preparing for the Cold War, and a man who knew how to run informers and how to hunt communists was, to some of them, more valuable than a man who should stand trial.

That same year, a French court sentenced him to death in his absence.

A second French court did the same in 1954.

When France asked for him, the Americans did not hand him over.

Instead, in 1951, with help from a smuggling route through Italy run by a Croatian priest, Krunoslav Draganović, the Americans helped Barbie and his family leave Europe.

These escape routes for wanted Nazis were known as ratlines.

He arrived in Bolivia under a new name: Klaus Altmann.

For the next thirty years, Klaus Altmann lived in Bolivia as a businessman and a Bolivian citizen, working with the country’s military governments and security services.

In the mid-1960s, the West German intelligence service, the BND, recruited him as an agent.

The man who had sat behind the desk on Avenue Berthelot was living in the sun, protected, and useful.

—

## Beate, Serge And A Mother From Lyon

He was found by two people who refused to let the past stay buried.

Beate Klarsfeld was a German woman who had become famous for confronting former Nazis in public.

Her husband, Serge Klarsfeld, was a French lawyer whose father had been murdered at Auschwitz.

Together, they tracked down the men responsible for the deportation of Jews from France.

In 1971, working from German court files and photographs, the Klarsfelds identified “Klaus Altmann” as Klaus Barbie.

In January 1972, the information was published.

Simone Lagrange looked at his photograph and knew him at once.

The Bolivian government refused to send him back.

So the Klarsfelds took the case to the street.

In 1972, Beate Klarsfeld traveled to La Paz with Ita Halaunbrenner, the mother of Mina and Claudine, the two little girls taken from Izieu.

The two women chained themselves to a bench in the center of the city in protest.

The photographs went around the world.

It still took eleven more years.

—

## Back To Montluc

In 1982, a civilian government returned to power in Bolivia.

In February 1983, Barbie was arrested in La Paz on a pretext involving an unpaid debt to the state and, within days, put on a plane to French Guiana and then to France.

When he arrived in Lyon, he was briefly held in Montluc, the same prison where so many of the people he had questioned had waited for their names to be called.

That August, the United States government published the results of an inquiry led by Allan Ryan of the Justice Department.

It concluded that American intelligence officers had protected Barbie after the war and had helped him escape to South America.

The United States formally apologized to France.

In a flat in the Croix-Rousse, a woman in her sixties sat at her kitchen table and read every word in the newspaper about the man who had stood by the painted window.

—

## Lyon, 1987

The trial of Klaus Barbie opened on 11 May 1987, before the criminal court of the Rhône department in Lyon.

He was charged with crimes against humanity, the only crime that French law allowed to be tried so many years later, because crimes against humanity have no statute of limitations.

The charges included the Rue Sainte-Catherine raid, the deportation of the children of Izieu, and the last convoy that left Lyon for the camps in August 1944.

His lawyer was Jacques Vergès, a provocative defense attorney who tried to turn the trial into an attack on France’s own colonial record.

After the first days, Barbie refused to attend the hearings, which French law allowed.

Many of the witnesses would never get to look him in the eye in the courtroom.

They testified anyway.

Simone Lagrange told the court about the man with the cat.

Ita Halaunbrenner spoke about her daughters and about the journey she had made to La Paz in search of justice.

She was so overcome that she could barely continue.

Lise Lesèvre, eighty-six years old, refused the chair she was offered and gave her testimony standing up.

She described the nineteen days.

She called Barbie a “pure sadist” and said she had recognized him “without effort.”

Claire Vernet was not a witness.

But women like her filled the public seats day after day.

They had waited forty years to hear these things said out loud, in the city where they had happened.

On 4 July 1987, Klaus Barbie was found guilty of crimes against humanity and sentenced to life imprisonment.

He died in prison in Lyon on 25 September 1991, of cancer.

He was seventy-seven years old.

Lise Lesèvre died one year later, in 1992, at the age of ninety-one.

—

## What Really Happened

Claire Vernet is a composite character.

Her arrest, her interrogation, her time at Montluc and Ravensbrück and her silence after the war are built from the documented experiences of many women who passed through the hands of the Lyon Gestapo.

The scene in the office on Avenue Berthelot is a reconstruction, written in the way survivors described the first hours of questioning.

The men in that scene, including the quiet man by the window, are not portraits of specific individuals, and none of the words spoken there were recorded.

Everything else in this article is real.

Lise Lesèvre, Simone Lagrange, Lucie Aubrac and Ita Halaunbrenner were real women, and what is said of them here comes from their own accounts, from their testimony at the 1987 trial and from the records of historians and memorial institutions.

—

## The Chair

The building on Avenue Berthelot still stands.

Today it houses the Centre d’Histoire de la Résistance et de la Déportation, a museum where schoolchildren from Lyon come to learn what happened in the city during the war.

But the women who sat on chairs like it are not gone from the story.

They gave nothing to the men across the desk.

They carried what happened to them through the camps and through forty years of silence.

And when the man who had stood by the window was finally brought back to their city, they walked into a courtroom, some of them refusing even to sit down, and told the world exactly who he was.

You Might Also Enjoy