News

Sophie Scholl Was 21 When She Stood Before Hitler’s People’s Court On February 22, 1943. The Judge In The Red Robe Shouted. She Answered Him With One Sentence Germany Still Remembers

A wood-paneled courtroom, lit from one side by pale winter light, and a young woman standing at the front of it as if nobody else were in the room.

There is a picture that is meant to show a morning in Munich, in February of 1943, and this is what it shows.

She stands in the foreground.

Her dark hair is short and falls in soft curls around her ears.

She wears a gray tweed jacket over a cream-colored blouse buttoned all the way up to the collar.

Her lips are closed.

She is not crying, and she is not pleading.

She is looking straight at you, with an expression that is very hard to read.

It might be fear held down.

It might be something closer to patience.

Behind her, the room is full of men.

On the left, men in olive-brown uniforms with brass buttons and white belts stand in a row.

On the right, an older man in a dark suit and a striped tie stands with his arms at his sides, watching her.

Behind him stand more men, one of them in a blue uniform.

Sunlight from a tall window lays bright stripes across the dark wood of the wall.

Nobody in the picture is touching her.

Nobody is raising a voice.

There is only a young woman standing very straight, and a room full of men who have already made up their minds.

It is not a photograph.

It is a modern AI reconstruction, made to look like a still from a film, and parts of it are wrong.

The uniforms on the left look more like American Army uniforms than German ones.

There is no judge in the picture, and the real judge that day was impossible to miss: he wore a red robe, and he did most of the talking.

The real trial took place in the Palace of Justice in Munich, in a room filled with invited officials of the ruling party, and the young woman was not standing alone.

Her brother sat beside her, and so did a friend.

But the picture gets some things right: her youth, her short dark hair, her plain clothes, and above all the stillness in her face, which those who saw her in her last days remembered.

Her name was Sophie Scholl.

She was twenty-one years old, a student of biology and philosophy at the University of Munich.

On Monday, February 22, 1943, she stood with her brother Hans and their friend Christoph Probst before the People’s Court, Hitler’s special tribunal for what it called treason.

Four days earlier, she had been caught inside the university after scattering leaflets that called on Germans to stand up against the regime.

The judge shouted.

She answered him calmly, in a sentence that is still quoted in Germany today.

And the verdict that was read out to her a little after one o’clock that afternoon was carried out so quickly that by the time the sun went down over Munich, she was gone.

This is the story of how a girl who once marched in a Hitler Youth uniform came to stand in that room, what she said there, and why her country now counts her among the greatest Germans who ever lived.

—

## A girl from Forchtenberg

Sophia Magdalena Scholl was born on May 9, 1921, in Forchtenberg, a small town on the Kocher River in Württemberg, in the southwest of Germany.

She was the fourth of six children.

Her older siblings were Inge, Hans and Elisabeth.

After her came Werner, and then a little sister, Thilde, who lived only a few months.

Her father, Robert Scholl, was the mayor of Forchtenberg when she was born.

He was a liberal, a man with a sharp tongue and strong opinions, and he did not trust nationalists or men who shouted.

Her mother, Magdalena, had been a deaconess, a Protestant nursing sister, before she married.

She was a woman of quiet, practical faith.

In 1932, when Sophie was eleven, the family moved to the city of Ulm, on the Danube.

Robert Scholl opened an office there as a tax and business adviser.

The children were encouraged to read, to hike, to draw, to play music and to think for themselves.

In January 1933, Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Germany.

Sophie was eleven.

Like most of the girls in her class, she joined the League of German Girls, the female branch of the Hitler Youth, when she was twelve.

Her brother Hans joined the Hitler Youth and rose to become a leader in it.

For a while, the movement gave them what it gave millions of young Germans: camping trips, songs around the fire, uniforms, a sense of belonging to something large and new.

In November 1937, the Gestapo arrested several of the Scholl siblings because Hans and his friends had been part of an independent youth group that the regime had banned.

According to the family’s later accounts, Sophie was taken in too and released the same day, perhaps because she looked so young.

She was sixteen.

It was the first time she saw what the state did to people who did not fit.

Over the next few years, her doubts hardened into something else.

She saw a Jewish friend from school left out of the League of German Girls.

When the war began in 1939, she saw the young men of her town go to the front, among them the man she loved, a young army officer named Fritz Hartnagel.

Her letters to him are full of questions about how a decent person could serve such a war.

—

## Her father’s words

In the summer of 1942, the regime came for her father.

Robert Scholl had said, in front of an employee in his office, that Hitler was a scourge of God, and the remark was reported.

He was tried and sentenced to four months in prison.

Sophie was twenty-one by then.

The family later told how she went to the prison wall in Ulm at night and played an old folk song on her flute, so that he might hear it from his cell.

The song was “Die Gedanken sind frei.”

Thoughts are free.

Within a year, she would take a far greater one.

—

## Munich, May 1942

Before she could study, the state required her to serve.

Sophie trained as a kindergarten teacher and was then sent to the national labor service and to wartime auxiliary work, months of drudgery that she endured and hated.

In May 1942, she was finally allowed to enroll at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich.

She studied biology and philosophy.

Hans was already there, studying medicine, and he brought her into his circle of friends.

They were young men who had all served as army medics and who now went to lectures in between their duties.

There was Alexander Schmorell, born in Russia to a German father and a Russian mother, a lover of Russian literature and sculpture.

There was Christoph Probst, quiet, thoughtful, married young, already a father.

There was Willi Graf, a serious Catholic who had seen the war in the east.

And there was a professor of philosophy and musicology, Kurt Huber, a man in his late forties whose lectures were full of veiled remarks that his students understood perfectly.

What Sophie did not know at first was that some of them had already begun to act.

—

## The White Rose

In late June and July of 1942, four leaflets appeared in Munich.

They were typed on a borrowed typewriter and copied by hand-cranked machine, and they were mailed to professors, doctors, booksellers and tavern owners, people whose names were picked out of telephone books.

They were signed “The White Rose.”

Their message was blunt.

They called the regime a dictatorship of evil.

They told readers that the German people were becoming complicit by their silence.

One of them told readers plainly that hundreds of thousands of Jews had been put to death in occupied Poland, and asked why the German people did nothing.

They urged passive resistance: sabotage in factories, refusal to give to party collections, refusal to cooperate.

Hans Scholl and Alexander Schmorell wrote the first four.

Then, in late July 1942, the young men were sent to the Russian front for several months as medics, and the leaflets stopped.

—

## How she came in

How exactly Sophie found out about the leaflets is told in different ways.

Some accounts say she recognized the words.

Some say she found the evidence in Hans’s room.

Some say he tried for a while to keep her out of it, to protect her.

What the record does show is what she did once she was in.

When the young men came back from Russia in the autumn of 1942, the group grew more organized and more daring.

In January 1943, they produced a fifth leaflet, headed “An Appeal to All Germans!”

This time there were not a few hundred copies but somewhere between six and nine thousand.

Sophie helped buy paper, envelopes and stamps in small amounts, in different shops, so as not to draw attention.

She carried copies by train to other cities and posted them there, so that the postmarks would not point back to Munich.

Leaflets turned up in Augsburg, Stuttgart, Frankfurt, Salzburg, Linz and Vienna.

In early February 1943, members of the group went out at night and painted slogans on walls in Munich.

“Down with Hitler” was one.

“Freedom” was another.

She was no longer the quiet girl from Ulm who played the flute outside a prison.

She was part of the only group of German students who were openly calling, in writing, for the end of Hitler’s rule.

At the beginning of February 1943, the news came from the east.

The German Sixth Army, surrounded for months in the ruins of Stalingrad, had surrendered.

Fritz Hartnagel, the young officer Sophie loved, had been there.

He was flown out in January.

For the first time, many ordinary Germans began to doubt the official story.

Kurt Huber, the professor, sat down and wrote the sixth leaflet.

It was addressed to the students of Germany.

It began “Fellow students!” and it spoke of the dead of Stalingrad.

It called on the young people of Germany to rise against the party that had led them there, in the name of freedom and honor.

Hans and Alexander Schmorell edited it.

Then the group printed it, by the thousand.

Some copies were mailed.

And Hans and Sophie decided to do something they had never done before: take the leaflets into the university itself, in daylight.

—

## Thursday morning, February 18

On the morning of Thursday, February 18, 1943, Hans and Sophie Scholl walked into the main building of the University of Munich carrying a suitcase and a small bag.

Inside were copies of the sixth leaflet.

It was late in the morning.

Lectures were still going on behind closed doors.

The two of them moved quickly along the empty corridors, laying stacks of leaflets outside the doors of lecture halls, on window ledges, on stairs, where students would find them the moment classes ended.

The main hall of the university is built around a great open atrium, a tall courtyard under a glass roof, with galleries running around it on every floor.

When they were nearly done, there were still leaflets left.

On the top floor, beside the railing, Sophie pushed the last of them over the edge.

They floated down through the light into the hall below.

A university maintenance man named Jakob Schmid saw the paper falling.

Schmid was a party member and a man who believed in the regime.

He ran up, seized Hans and Sophie, and held them.

The doors of the building were locked.

They were taken to the office of the rector, and the Gestapo was called.

Hans had in his pocket a handwritten draft for a seventh leaflet.

He tried to tear it up and to swallow the pieces, but the Gestapo recovered enough of it.

The handwriting belonged to Christoph Probst.

—

## The man across the table

That afternoon, Hans and Sophie were taken to the Gestapo headquarters in Munich, a former royal palace called the Wittelsbacher Palais, and put in separate rooms.

Sophie’s interrogator was a Gestapo officer named Robert Mohr.

He was forty-five years old, a career policeman who had been a police chief in the Palatinate before he moved to the Gestapo in Munich.

At first he did not believe she had done anything.

She sat in front of him calmly and explained that she and Hans had simply been at the university, that the suitcase was for laundry she meant to fetch from home, that they had nothing to do with any leaflets.

She was so composed that Mohr, by his own later account, thought she might be telling the truth.

Then the reports came in from the searches of their rooms.

There were stamps, a great many of them, more than any student would need.

There was evidence that tied the leaflets to them.

And Hans, in his own room down the corridor, faced with the proof, confessed.

When Sophie learned that, she stopped denying.

But she did not do what interrogators expect people to do when they break.

She did not begin naming names.

She told Mohr that she and Hans had done it, that they had bought the paper and the stamps, that they had distributed the leaflets.

She tried to take as much as possible onto herself and onto Hans, and to give the Gestapo nothing that would lead to anyone else.

—

## The way out she refused

Mohr interrogated her for hours over three days, from February 18 to 20.

At some point in those days, he tried to offer her a way out.

Years later, in 1951, he described it in a report he wrote for her father.

He said he had tried to save her life by having her state that she had been under her brother’s influence, that she had simply followed Hans, that she did not share his political views.

She did not walk through it.

According to the surviving record of her interrogation, she told him instead that she was still of the opinion that she had done the best she could do for her people, and that she did not regret what she had done.

She said she would take the consequences on herself.

Those words were written down by the Gestapo’s own clerk.

For decades, the record of her interrogation lay in an archive in East Germany.

It became available to researchers only after the Berlin Wall fell.

—

## The paper with one word

On Sunday, February 21, the indictment arrived.

It was a typed document from the chief prosecutor of the People’s Court, charging Hans Scholl, Sophie Scholl and Christoph Probst with treason, aiding the enemy and undermining the military strength of the nation.

The trial was set for the next morning.

Sophie was allowed to read it in her cell.

On the back of her copy, she wrote one word.

“Freiheit.”

Freedom.

In the cell with her during those days was another prisoner, a woman named Else Gebel.

Gebel was a political prisoner herself, a member of a communist resistance group, and she had been assigned work in the Gestapo prison.

She spent those days and nights with Sophie, and after the war she wrote down what she remembered for Sophie’s parents.

And she remembered what Sophie said on the morning of February 22, before she was taken away to the court.

As the morning began, she said that it was such a fine, sunny day, and she had to go.

Then, according to Gebel, she added that so many young men were losing their lives on the battlefields every day, and that what she and Hans had done might wake thousands of people up.

—

## Monday, February 22: the courtroom

The trial began at about ten o’clock that Monday morning, in a courtroom in the Palace of Justice in Munich, the great domed courthouse near the city’s old center.

The People’s Court normally sat in Berlin.

This time its president had come to Munich himself, flown in for the sole purpose of presiding over this one case.

The public was not invited.

The seats were filled with officials of the party, members of the security services and officers in uniform, an audience chosen to watch and to approve.

Hans, Sophie and Christoph Probst sat in the dock, each between two policemen.

They had defense lawyers, assigned to them by the court.

The lawyers did almost nothing.

Christoph Probst was twenty-three.

He had been arrested on Saturday, February 20, when he went to collect his pay.

He was married to a young woman named Herta, and they had three children: two little boys and a baby daughter only four weeks old.

Herta was in the hospital with a dangerous fever after the birth.

She had not been told that her husband was under arrest.

Hans was twenty-four.

Sophie was twenty-one.

—

## The judge in the red robe

The president of the People’s Court was Roland Freisler.

He was forty-nine years old, a lawyer who had once been a prisoner of war in Russia and had come home to join the party early.

He had risen to become one of the senior officials of the Ministry of Justice, and in January 1942 he had been one of the men who sat at the table at the Wannsee conference in Berlin.

In August 1942, he became president of the People’s Court.

He wore a scarlet robe.

He was famous, even among the regime’s own officials, for the way he ran a trial.

He did not let defendants finish a sentence.

He mocked them.

He shouted at them from the bench, and his voice rose until it filled the room.

The prosecutor and the defense often had little to do, because Freisler did the questioning, the accusing and the deciding himself.

Under his presidency, the court handed down thousands of death sentences.

That morning, he questioned Probst first, then Hans, then Sophie.

He raged at them for treason, for stabbing the soldiers at the front in the back, for dishonoring the university and the nation.

Hans tried to speak about why they had done it.

Freisler cut him off.

Then it was Sophie’s turn.

—

## One sentence

Nobody made a word-for-word transcript of what was said in that courtroom.

But one sentence from Sophie Scholl has come down to us, and it is quoted in almost every account of that morning.

In the middle of Freisler’s accusations, she spoke.

She did not raise her voice.

“Somebody, after all, had to make a start.”

According to the accounts that preserve that sentence, she went on.

What they had written and said, she told the court, was also believed by many others.

They just did not dare to say it as openly as she and her brother had.

Some later accounts also record that she told the court that everyone in the room knew as well as she did that the war was lost, and asked why they were too cowardly to admit it.

It is not certain exactly when in the hearing she said each of these things, and some sources place the words about the many others in her interrogation rather than in the courtroom.

But the core of it was recorded and remembered: in a room full of uniforms, in front of a man who shouted for a living, a twenty-one-year-old student said calmly that she was not alone, that she was only the first.

Toward the end of the hearing, there was a disturbance at the door.

Robert and Magdalena Scholl had come to Munich that morning, with their son Werner, a soldier home on leave, as soon as they heard what was happening.

According to the family’s accounts, they tried to get into the courtroom.

A guard is said to have told Magdalena that she should have raised her children better.

Robert forced his way in and tried to speak in their defense, and he was taken out again.

At the end, each of the three defendants was allowed a last word.

Hans used his to plead not for himself but for Christoph Probst, for the sake of his wife and children.

Freisler cut him off.

Then the verdict was read.

Treason.

Aiding the enemy.

Undermining the strength of the armed forces.

All three were sentenced to the highest penalty the law allowed.

It was a little after one o’clock in the afternoon.

Under the rules of the People’s Court, there was no appeal.

The three of them were driven straight to Stadelheim prison, on the southeastern edge of Munich.

—

## The words in the video

The short video that goes with this story uses three lines, spoken by her.

The first is her documented sentence from the trial: “Somebody, after all, had to make a start.”

The second and third are not a word-for-word quotation.

They condense what she is recorded as saying next, that what they had written and said was also believed by many others, who just did not dare to express it as they had.

In the video, that becomes two short lines: “What we wrote, many others believe too.”

And: “They just don’t dare to say it out loud.”

The meaning is hers.

The exact wording is shortened to fit a few seconds of film.

The men around her in the video stay silent.

In the real courtroom, the man doing the shouting was the judge.

—

## The afternoon at Stadelheim

That afternoon, the prison allowed something it did not usually allow.

The parents were let in to see their children one last time.

Hans came first.

He saw his father and mother and his brother Werner across a barrier.

He thanked them, and he told them that he had no hatred, that he had put everything behind him.

Then Sophie was brought in.

The family later described how she smiled.

Her mother offered her some sweets that Hans had turned down.

Sophie took them gladly and said that she had not even had lunch yet.

Her mother is said to have told her that she would never come through that door again.

Her father is said to have told his children that they would go down in history, that there was still such a thing as justice.

After her parents had gone, Robert Mohr, the Gestapo officer who had questioned her, came to the prison one more time.

He found Sophie in a guard’s room, and she had been crying.

She apologized to him for her tears.

She explained that she had just said goodbye to her parents.

A Protestant prison chaplain gave Hans and Sophie communion together.

Christoph Probst, who had grown up without any church, asked to be received into the Catholic faith, and a priest baptized him that afternoon.

And then, against the usual rules, the guards let the three of them sit together for a few minutes and share a cigarette.

According to the guards’ later accounts, they were calm.

Probst is said to have told the other two that in a few minutes they would see each other again in eternity.

At five o’clock in the afternoon, Sophie Scholl was led out first.

She was put to the guillotine, the method the regime used for civilians it condemned.

Hans followed two minutes later, and Christoph Probst three minutes after him.

The guards later reported that in his last moment, Hans called out in a loud voice, so that it rang through the prison.

“Long live freedom!”

Accounts of Sophie’s own last words differ, and nobody can be sure of them.

The words her cellmate remembered from that morning, about the fine, sunny day, are the ones most people know.

Hans, Sophie and Christoph were buried in the cemetery at Perlacher Forst, next to the prison.

—

## The others

The Gestapo did not stop with three.

Alexander Schmorell tried to escape to Switzerland and was arrested in Munich on February 24, after he took shelter in an air-raid shelter and was recognized.

Kurt Huber, the professor who had written the sixth leaflet, was arrested on February 26.

Willi Graf had been arrested on the same day as the Scholls.

On April 19, 1943, Freisler came back to Munich for a second trial against fourteen defendants from the circle.

Huber, Schmorell and Graf were all sentenced to the highest penalty.

Most of the others were sent to prison.

One was acquitted.

Huber and Schmorell were put to death at Stadelheim on July 13, 1943.

Willi Graf was held for months longer, questioned again and again in the hope that he would give up more names.

He gave none.

He was put to death on October 12, 1943.

Many decades later, in 2012, the Orthodox Church declared Alexander Schmorell a saint.

The families paid too.

Five days after he lost his children, Robert Scholl was sentenced to eighteen months in prison for listening to foreign radio broadcasts.

His wife and his daughters Inge and Elisabeth were also taken into custody for months, as relatives of the condemned.

Werner Scholl, the brother who had stood in the prison that last afternoon in his army uniform, was sent back to the Russian front.

He went missing there in 1944 and was never found.

Fritz Hartnagel, who had been flown out of Stalingrad, did not reach Munich in time to see Sophie.

After the war, he married her sister Elisabeth.

—

## The leaflet that fell from the sky

The Gestapo had taken the people who made the sixth leaflet.

It had not taken the leaflet.

A copy of the text reached Helmuth James von Moltke, a German lawyer who worked for the military intelligence office and who led a secret resistance circle of his own.

On a trip to Scandinavia in the spring of 1943, he passed it on, and it reached Britain.

The British printed it again, with a new heading: “The Manifesto of the Students of Munich.”

In the summer and autumn of 1943, aircraft of the Royal Air Force dropped millions of copies of it over German cities.

The words that Sophie had pushed over a railing into a university hall in February came down out of the sky all over Germany.

It did not end the war.

But it meant that Germans who picked up those pages in their gardens and streets learned that some young Germans had said no, and what had happened to them because of it.

—

## What became of the men in the room

Roland Freisler went on presiding over the People’s Court in Berlin.

In the summer and autumn of 1944, he conducted the trials of the officers and officials who had plotted against Hitler on July 20, shouting at them as he had shouted at the students in Munich.

On February 3, 1945, during an American air raid on Berlin, a bomb hit the court building.

Freisler was crushed by falling masonry.

It was not quite two years after the morning in Munich.

Robert Mohr, the interrogator, went on to lead a Gestapo office in occupied Alsace.

After the war he was interned for a time by the French but was never tried for his work.

He later worked at a spa town in the Palatinate and lived until 1977.

Jakob Schmid, the maintenance man who caught them, was rewarded by the regime.

After the war, he was tried and sentenced in a postwar court for what he had done, and he spent time in a labor camp.

—

## How Germany remembers her

After the war, Robert Scholl became mayor of Ulm, the city where his children had grown up, from 1945 until 1948.

He spent the rest of his life in public work, and he lived until 1973.

Sophie’s sister Inge wrote a book about the group, simply called “The White Rose,” which became one of the most widely read books about the German resistance.

In front of the main building of the University of Munich, the square is now called Geschwister-Scholl-Platz, the Scholl Siblings Square.

The square across the street is named after Professor Huber.

Set into the cobblestones in front of the university entrance are copies of the leaflets, scattered on the ground as if someone had just let them fall.

All over Germany and Austria, schools and streets carry the names of Hans and Sophie Scholl.

In 2003, a bust of Sophie Scholl was placed in the Walhalla, the hall of fame above the Danube near Regensburg, among the great figures of German history.

That same year, a German television network asked viewers to choose the greatest Germans of all time.

Hans and Sophie Scholl, voted for together, came in fourth, ahead of Bach, Goethe, Bismarck and Albert Einstein.

Among younger voters, they came first.

In 1982, the actress Lena Stolze played her in two German films.

In 2005, the film “Sophie Scholl: The Final Days,” built in part on the interrogation records that had come out of the East German archives, starred Julia Jentsch as Sophie and Alexander Held as Robert Mohr.

Jentsch won the Silver Bear for best actress at the Berlin Film Festival, and the film was nominated for the Academy Award for best foreign language film.

In 2021, on the hundredth anniversary of her birth, Germany issued a stamp and a coin in her honor.

The last surviving member of the circle around the White Rose, Traute Lafrenz, lived until March 2023.

—

## What the record does not say

Some retellings make Sophie the leader of a vast national network.

She was not.

The White Rose was a small circle of friends, with helpers in a few other cities, and the leaflets they produced, all six together, numbered around fifteen thousand copies.

Some give her long, perfect speeches to her brother and to her interrogator.

Those speeches were written later, for books and films.

Some say her father was arrested when she was a teenager and that she visited him behind glass.

In fact, he was imprisoned in 1942, when she was already a university student.

Some say her last words were spoken in the corridor on her final walk.

The words about the sunny day come from her cellmate, and they were spoken that morning, before the trial.

What is left, when the inventions are cleared away, is smaller and harder.

A student who could have said she was only following her brother, and did not.

A word written on the back of a charge sheet.

And one calm sentence spoken in a courtroom where nobody was supposed to answer back.

—

## The picture, once more

Now it is possible to say what is true in it.

The young woman is true.

She was twenty-one, small and dark-haired, dressed plainly, and she stood in front of a room full of men in uniform who had come to see her condemned.

The stillness is true.

The Gestapo officer who questioned her, the cellmate who slept beside her and the guards who led her out all remembered how calm she was.

The light is true, in its way.

It was a clear, cold, sunny day in Munich, and she noticed.

What the picture gets wrong is almost everything around her.

The uniforms are the wrong uniforms.

Her brother and her friend are missing from beside her.

The judge is missing, and so is his red robe, and so is his voice.

And what the picture cannot show is everything around that moment.

The flute played at night outside a prison wall in Ulm.

The leaflets floating down through the atrium.

The officer across the table who offered her a way out.

The one word on the back of the indictment.

The sweets she took from her mother because she had not had lunch.

In the picture, she is still standing in the courtroom, and the men behind her have not yet spoken.

In the story, they did.

And she had already given her answer: somebody, after all, had to make a start.

You Might Also Enjoy