News

“Sign It Or Stand In The Sun.” They Tied The Widow To A Cottonwood For $300… The Drifter Downstream Had Buried Better Men

By twenty minutes past ten the heat had a sound to it.

It ticked in the dry grass.

It hummed in the cottonwood leaves over her head, the only leaves for a mile in any direction.

It sat on the flat like a lid on a pot.

Her name was Isobel Treadway.

She was twenty-six years old, and she was standing with her back against the trunk of the lone cottonwood that grew beside her spring, with her hands behind her and a length of rawhide wrapped twice around her wrists and twice around the tree.

She wore a faded blue work dress, the one she wore for washing, and her hair had come loose from its pins hours ago and hung over her shoulders in the wind, and there was dust on everything, on her dress, on her shoes, on the backs of her hands where she could not see them.

At the roots of the tree, on a flat gray stone where she could not miss it, lay a folded deed, a steel pen, and a squat glass inkwell, the paper held down against the wind by an old horseshoe.

The deed was for her land.

The price written into it was three hundred dollars.

Four riders sat their horses out on the flat, one to the west and three to the east, far enough off that a traveler on the county road would have taken them for cowhands resting their horses, close enough that they could see her face.

A fifth man had come in on foot a few minutes ago, the one in charge, a long-jawed man with a gray mustache, and he squatted on his heels beside the stone and tapped the deed with one finger.

“Sign it or stand in the sun,” he said.

“Noon’s coming either way, Mrs. Treadway. Only one of us minds.”

She did not answer him.

She had stopped answering him at about eight o’clock.

She was looking past him, at something on the creek bank.

A man was walking up from the water.

He came slowly, on foot, leading a tired bay horse by the reins, a man in a broad brown hat and a dusty brown coat too heavy for the weather, and he stopped about ten paces from the tree and stood there with his back to the riders and his face to her.

Isobel lifted her chin.

“Keep riding, mister. This is Thistle Company business.”

The stranger did not keep riding.

He looked at the rawhide.

He looked at the inkwell on the stone.

He looked, for a long time, at the four men on their horses.

“Ma’am,” he said quietly, “I’ve buried better men than those four.”

The deed on that stone was never signed.

Everybody on the flat that morning knew that by the end of it.

What none of them knew yet, not the four riders and not the man with the gray mustache and not even Isobel Treadway, was that before the sun stood straight up, a different piece of paper would come out of the inside pocket of the drifter’s coat.

And that the man who had ordered the rope would read it twice, in front of his own riders, and then sit down in the dirt beside the cottonwood because his legs would no longer hold him.

—

## Why would a cattle company pay three hundred dollars for a spring it said it already owned?

Halfmoon Creek ran nine miles northwest of the Chugwater stage station, in Laramie County, Wyoming Territory, and for most of its length in the summer of 1884 it was not a creek at all.

It was a crooked line of white sand and cracked mud with a few green rushes along it, and cattle stood in it in the afternoons and bawled.

All but the last half mile.

At the head of that half mile, out of a crease in the ground below a low sandstone rim, a spring came up cold and clear and never stopped.

It had not stopped in the wet years and it had not stopped in the dry ones.

It ran past a single cottonwood that somebody had planted there, or that had planted itself, long before anybody now living came into the country, and it filled the creek bed below it for half a mile with living water before the sand took it back.

Coleman Treadway had found that spring in the spring of 1879.

He was a carpenter from Ohio with a bad cough and a good eye, and he walked the whole country between the Chugwater and the Laramie River that first summer, digging his heel into the ground, watching where the antelope came down to drink in the evenings.

When he found the spring under the cottonwood, he sat down beside it and did not get up for an hour.

He filed on the quarter section that held it, paid the government a dollar and a quarter an acre, built a two-room cabin, and in 1880 married Isobel Haig, a schoolteacher’s daughter from Cheyenne who could rope a calf and keep accounts.

They ran forty cows, raised the only garden for twenty miles, and sold water to passing trail herds at two cents a head.

And in the autumn of 1882, a man named Desmond Varick rode up the creek in a new buggy with yellow wheels and asked to buy all of it.

Varick was the American manager of the Thistle Land and Cattle Company, Limited, which had been organized that year in Edinburgh with a great deal of Scottish money and a very handsome prospectus.

Isobel saw a copy of that prospectus years later, in a lawyer’s office in Cheyenne, and she could still recite one sentence on its third page when she was an old woman.

It said that the company held, by purchase and possession, all the permanent living water on Halfmoon Creek and its tributaries.

Varick had written that sentence before he ever came up the creek in his buggy.

The shareholders in Edinburgh had bought the range on the strength of it, and the herd on the strength of something called a book count.

A book count was how cattle were sold in those years, when nobody could round up thirty thousand head scattered across a thousand square miles.

You took the seller’s books, added the calves branded each year, subtracted a polite figure for losses, and paid for the total.

If the books said fourteen thousand six hundred cattle, Edinburgh paid for fourteen thousand six hundred cattle.

Nobody in Edinburgh had ever seen them.

Coleman Treadway turned Varick down at his own kitchen table.

He told him the spring was the only thing on the place that could not be replaced, and that a man did not sell the only thing he could not replace.

Varick smiled and said he quite understood.

He came back five more times.

The price went up each time, and the smile got thinner.

Then, in February of 1884, Coleman Treadway caught pneumonia hauling hay in a blizzard and died in nine days, in the front room of the cabin he had built, with his wife holding his hand.

There was no mystery about that.

Isobel never pretended there was.

He had been sick before and he was sick again and that winter killed a good many people on the Chugwater.

What happened after that was a different matter.

The sixth offer came three weeks after the funeral, and it was lower than the fifth.

The seventh came in May, and it was lower again.

By July it was three hundred dollars, and Varick had stopped coming up the creek himself.

He sent his range foreman instead.

Isobel understood very well what a falling price meant.

It meant that Varick did not believe he would have to pay it.

What she did not understand, not until the middle of that Thursday morning, was why it suddenly had to be paid by noon.

—

## The four men who came up the creek at sunrise

She was at the spring with two buckets when she heard them.

It was a little after six, and she had gone down early to fill the buckets for the garden before the heat came up.

She heard the horses before she saw them, five riders coming up the creek road at a walk.

Neighbors came fast and waved.

These men came slow and spread out.

She set the buckets down and walked toward the cabin, not running.

Her husband’s shotgun stood loaded inside the door.

She was twenty yards from it when the biggest of the riders swung his horse across the path in front of her and sat there grinning.

The man in charge rode up beside her and touched his hat.

His name was Burr Kincheloe, the Thistle Company’s range foreman, a long-jawed man of fifty with a gray mustache and pale, patient eyes.

He had always been perfectly polite.

He was perfectly polite now.

“Morning, Mrs. Treadway,” he said.

“Mr. Varick’s compliments. He’s sorry he couldn’t come himself. He’s got company coming to dinner.”

“Then he’ll be busy,” Isobel said.

“And so will I.”

Kincheloe took a folded paper out of his coat.

“It’s the same paper. Three hundred dollars, cash, on signing. I’ve got the cash on me.”

“It’s the same answer,” she said.

“I’ve said no six times. You can make it seven.”

The big rider laughed.

His name was Fen Arbuckle, and he laughed at most things, especially things that were not funny.

Behind him sat Dobie Mulroney, a lean, gray, careful man who had ridden for cattle companies in three territories and had stopped being troubled by anything along the way.

And behind Mulroney, holding his reins too tight, sat a boy of about twenty-one with a sunburned neck who would not look at her.

His name was Ottie Lusby.

He had been on the Thistle payroll six weeks.

“I was afraid you’d say that,” Kincheloe said, without seeming afraid of anything.

“So here’s the other way of doing it. Mr. Varick says it’s a hot morning and you’re a reasonable woman. He says you might find it easier to be reasonable standing out in the open air for a while, where there’s nothing to do but think.”

He turned in his saddle and looked at the cottonwood.

“That’ll do,” he said.

It took them less than a minute.

Arbuckle had her by the arms before she had finished understanding what Kincheloe meant, and he walked her the forty yards to the cottonwood with her heels dragging in the dust, and Mulroney took a coil of rawhide off his saddle horn and tied her with the unhurried skill of a man who had done it before, in some other county, to somebody else.

Twice around her wrists behind her back.

Twice around the trunk.

A knot she could not reach.

“Not too tight,” Kincheloe said.

“Mr. Varick doesn’t want any marks.”

Mulroney did not answer.

He did not tie it too tight.

He did not tie it loose, either.

Kincheloe took the deed out of his coat and unfolded it and laid it on the flat stone at the roots of the tree.

He laid a steel pen beside it.

He took a small glass inkwell out of his saddlebag, uncorked it, and set it down in the dust beside the paper, and he weighted the deed with an old horseshoe he found lying by the spring.

Then he stood up and looked at her, and for the first time that morning he let her see what was under the politeness.

“You’ve got till noon,” he said.

“You can sign any time you like before then, and you’ll walk straight to the spring and have a drink, and I’ll count the money into your hand. That’s your choice. Nobody’s stopping you. Every minute you stand there is your own decision.”

“And at noon?” Isobel asked.

Kincheloe took his time.

“At noon I’ll have to go and tell Mr. Varick,” he said.

“And Mr. Varick isn’t as patient as me.”

—

## What the boy whispered at nine o’clock

They did not stay close.

Kincheloe sent the riders out onto the flat in a wide ring, three to the east, one to the west where he could see the road, and they sat their horses in the shimmer and watched her like men minding a fence.

From the county road it would have looked like a woman standing in the shade of a tree.

Except that by eight o’clock the shade had moved.

That was the other thing Kincheloe had known.

As the sun climbed, the shadow of the cottonwood swung and shrank and slid away around the trunk, and by half past eight she was standing in the full sun with the shade of her own tree lying a few feet behind her, where she could not reach it.

She did arithmetic to keep her mind steady.

Coleman had paid two hundred dollars for the land and four years of his life for the rest of it.

At about nine o’clock, one of the riders came in from the east ring at a walk.

It was the boy, Ottie Lusby.

He got down beside the spring with his canteen as if to fill it, and he filled it, and then he came over to the tree and held it up to her mouth without a word, and she drank.

“You shouldn’t,” she said, when she could.

“I know it.”

He was looking over his shoulder at Kincheloe, who was sitting on the creek bank with his back to them, rolling a cigarette.

“Ma’am, I got to tell you something. You ought to sign it.”

“No.”

“Ma’am.”

His voice dropped.

“It isn’t about the money. Mr. Varick’s got a man coming. Some Scotsman from the company, from over the ocean, coming in on the noon stage at Chugwater. Mr. Varick’s driving down to meet him. He means to bring him up this creek this afternoon and show him the water, and he means for the paper to be signed before he does.”

Isobel looked down at him.

“And if it isn’t?”

Ottie Lusby swallowed.

“Burr said if it isn’t signed by noon, there’s going to be a grass fire on this flat this afternoon,” he said.

“A real bad one. The kind that starts by accident, and takes a cabin with it. And then there won’t be any widow living on the place for the Scotsman to ask about. Just a burnt-out claim that the company bought off the estate.”

He capped the canteen.

His hands were shaking.

“I didn’t sign on for that,” he said.

“I swear I didn’t.”

Then he walked back to his horse and rode out to the ring again, and Isobel stood in the sun and looked at the inkwell on the stone, and for the first time that morning she was afraid.

It was not the sun.

It was the arithmetic.

Varick had sold the Scots a creek he did not own, and somebody from Edinburgh was coming on the noon coach to look at it, and Varick needed her name on a paper dated a year ago, so that the sentence on the third page of the prospectus would be true.

Three hundred dollars.

It was not a price at all.

It was a way of making a lie look like a sale.

What she did not know, standing there, was that the man Varick was driving to Chugwater to meet had not come in on the noon coach at all.

He had come in two days early.

And he was watering his horse a quarter of a mile downstream.

—

## The man in the willows who had been watching since dawn

He had come up the creek road in the dark and turned off into the willows at the bend where the living water ran out into the sand, and let his horse drink, and sat down with his back against a willow trunk and watched the cottonwood come up out of the dark.

He had seen the riders come.

He had seen them walk her to the tree.

He had not moved.

He was somewhere past forty, broad through the shoulders, with a short dark beard going gray at the edges.

He wore a broad brown hat and a heavy brown coat of waxed canvas, too warm for July, because the nights on the high plains were cold.

A gray-and-red striped poncho was rolled behind his saddle.

He carried one revolver, on his right hip, in a holster worn smooth.

The stage agent at Chugwater, where he had eaten supper on Tuesday night, had asked his name, and he had said Smith.

His name was Selby Hoyt.

For years he had ridden the treasure coaches on the Cheyenne and Black Hills road as a shotgun messenger, beside the driver with the strongbox under his boots, from Deadwood south past Hat Creek and Chugwater to the railroad.

He had come through without a scratch.

Some of the men who rode beside him had not.

On the coach road, people said the strange thing about Hoyt was that nobody could remember him giving his name to anybody who did not already know it.

The newspapers in Deadwood had a name for him anyway.

He did not care for it.

In 1883 he had quit the road and gone to work for a different kind of master.

He did not tell that to the agent at Chugwater either.

He watched the boy carry water to the woman at nine.

He watched the shade slide off her and onto the ground behind her.

And at a few minutes past ten, he stood up, tightened his cinch, and took his horse’s reins in his hand.

He did not get on the horse.

He walked.

A man on a horse coming up a creek bank is a man who means to do something.

A man on foot, leading a tired horse, is a man who wants a drink of water.

He wanted every one of them to see him coming for a long way, and he wanted every one of them to decide he was nothing.

—

## Why the four of them laughed

Arbuckle saw him first and called out, and the riders turned their horses, but none of them hurried.

Kincheloe stood up on the creek bank and threw his cigarette into the sand.

The stranger came up out of the willows at a walk, leading the bay, and stopped about ten paces from the cottonwood.

He did not look at the riders.

He looked at the woman.

Isobel lifted her chin.

“Keep riding, mister. This is Thistle Company business.”

He did not answer her right away.

He looked at the rawhide around the trunk, the double turn, the knot behind her where she could not reach it.

He looked at the stone with the deed and the pen and the inkwell.

He looked at the place on the ground behind her where the shade had gone.

Then he turned and looked at the riders, one at a time, the way a man reads brands in a corral.

Arbuckle.

Mulroney.

The boy.

The fifth man out to the west.

Kincheloe walked up from the creek, not fast.

“You’re on Thistle range, friend,” he said pleasantly.

“You’ve had your water. Now you can ride on.”

“This isn’t Thistle range,” the stranger said.

“It’s hers.”

“That’s a matter of paperwork.”

“I can see the paperwork.”

The stranger nodded at the stone.

“It isn’t signed.”

“It will be.”

Kincheloe smiled under the gray mustache.

“The lady is thinking it over. She’s got till noon. There’s no law against a woman standing under her own tree.”

The stranger looked back at Isobel.

She was looking straight at him, and her face was red from the sun and her mouth was dry, but her eyes were perfectly steady.

“How long have you been standing here, ma’am?” he asked.

“Since a quarter past seven.”

The stranger nodded slowly, as if she had told him something he had already worked out for himself.

“Well, that’s long enough,” he said.

Then he asked the other thing.

“How much are they offering you, ma’am?”

“Three hundred dollars,” Isobel said.

“For the only water on this flat.”

Out on the flat, Fen Arbuckle laughed.

It was a big laugh, the laugh of a man who had never once in his life had reason to think his size might not be enough, and after a moment Mulroney smiled thinly, and even the boy made a sound that might have been a laugh if he had not looked so sick.

They were laughing at the stranger, at the coat and the tired horse and the gray in his beard.

Four men on horseback with rifles on their saddles, and one man on foot, and he had come up out of the willows to ask a widow what they were paying her.

“Mister,” Arbuckle called, “you want her loose, you come and loose her. We’ll wait.”

The stranger did not look at him.

“Ma’am,” he said, to Isobel, and his voice was so quiet that the riders had to lean in their saddles to hear it, “I’ve buried better men than those four.”

Nobody laughed at that.

It was not the words.

It was the way he said them, as a plain fact, the way a man might say he had been to St. Louis.

Mulroney’s smile went away.

Kincheloe’s eyes narrowed and went over the stranger again, slowly, the coat, the holster worn smooth on the right hip, the hands.

“You look like a man who’s done this before,” Kincheloe said.

“Care to say where?”

“No,” the stranger said.

“Then I’ll tell you how this goes. You’ve got one revolver. My men have got four rifles and four revolvers. Mr. Varick’s got the sheriff of this county to dinner twice a month. Ride on, and you’ll be in Cheyenne by tomorrow night with a good story. Stay, and Fen there is going to pull you off your feet and sit on you until noon.”

The stranger considered this.

“No,” he said again.

“I don’t believe that’s how it goes.”

He let go of the bay’s reins.

Isobel said afterward that she had been looking straight at him and she never saw his hand move.

One moment it was hanging empty at his side, and the next there was a single flat crack that went out across the flat and came back off the sandstone rim, and the glass inkwell on the stone at her feet jumped and burst.

Ink went everywhere.

It went over the deed in a long black splash, across the printed words and the blank line at the bottom and the place where Varick’s clerk had already written the date.

It went over the horseshoe and the steel pen and the gray stone.

A little of it went on the hem of Isobel’s dress, and stayed there for the rest of her life.

The horses on the flat jumped and wheeled.

Arbuckle’s gelding went straight up and came down sideways and he lost a stirrup and grabbed for the horn.

Mulroney had his hand on his rifle and did not take it out of the boot.

The stranger’s revolver was already back in its holster.

“Now,” he said, in the same quiet voice, “there’s nothing to sign.”

—

## The quarter of an hour on the Halfmoon nobody forgot

It was the longest quarter of an hour that anybody on the Halfmoon could remember.

Isobel told it many times afterward, and she always told it slowly, because that was how it had happened.

Nobody moved for a while.

The bay horse, which had not even flinched at the shot, put its head down and began to crop the dry grass by the spring.

A cottonwood leaf came down and landed on the ruined deed.

Far off on the flat a meadowlark started up again where it had stopped.

Kincheloe looked down at the deed.

Then he looked at the stranger.

“That was company paper,” he said.

“It was a lie with a line on it for her name,” the stranger said.

“I’ve read the original.”

Kincheloe did not understand that.

Isobel saw that he did not understand it, and she saw that it frightened him more than the shot had.

Fen Arbuckle got his gelding settled and his foot back in the stirrup, and his face had gone dark red under the hat.

He was not a man who could stand to have been frightened in front of other men.

He swung down off his horse, slow and deliberate, and dropped the reins, and started walking in toward the cottonwood with his big hands open at his sides.

“I’ll sit on him, Burr,” he said.

“You just say.”

“Fen,” Mulroney said.

Arbuckle kept coming.

The stranger turned to face him.

He did not draw.

He did not take a step.

He only stood there between Arbuckle and the woman at the tree with his hands at his sides, and when Arbuckle was perhaps fifteen feet away, he spoke to him for the first time.

“I’d stop there,” he said.

“You’d be the first man I ever had to bury that I didn’t like.”

Arbuckle stopped.

He told people afterward, in the saloon at Chugwater, that he did not rightly know why.

The man was half his size and had not even drawn again.

He said it was the eyes.

They had not been afraid of anything.

Then Ottie Lusby, out on the flat, did a thing that nobody expected, least of all himself.

He turned his horse around, and he rode it in at a walk, and he got down at the spring, and he walked over to the cottonwood and took out his pocketknife.

“Ottie,” Kincheloe said.

“Get away from that tree.”

The boy did not look at him.

His hands were shaking so badly that it took him three tries to get the blade under the rawhide.

“I’m sorry, ma’am,” he said, very low.

“I’m so sorry.”

The rawhide parted.

Isobel’s hands came free.

She did not fall.

Her legs wanted to, but she put one hand back against the trunk of Coleman’s cottonwood and held herself up, and she stood there swaying a little in the full sun with her wrists red and her face burned and her hair full of dust, and she looked at Burr Kincheloe.

“You’ve had your answer seven times now,” she said.

“Get off my land.”

Kincheloe looked at the boy with the open knife and tears running down his sunburned face, at Arbuckle frozen in the open, at Mulroney, who had very slowly laid his hand on his saddle horn where everybody could see it.

He did the arithmetic.

Isobel watched him do it.

“Mr. Varick’s going to want your name,” he said to the stranger.

“Mr. Varick will have it,” the stranger said.

“In about two hours.”

“You’ll be gone in two hours.”

“No,” the stranger said.

“I’ll be right here. Under this tree. You go and tell him that.”

Kincheloe rode away north at a trot just short of a hurry.

Arbuckle and Mulroney followed.

The fifth rider, out on the road, had already gone.

Ottie Lusby did not go.

He stood by the tree with his pocketknife, looking at the ground.

“They’ll fire me,” he said.

“Yes,” the stranger said.

“I expect they will.”

He took the canteen off his saddle and gave it to Isobel, and waited while she drank, the whole time looking out at the flat, where the dust of the riders was going away north toward the Thistle headquarters and the long road that ran down from there to Chugwater.

“Ma’am,” he said, “I’m sorry I didn’t come up sooner. I needed to see what they’d do. I needed to see all of it.”

Isobel lowered the canteen.

“Who are you?” she asked.

He looked at her for a while.

“Nobody they were expecting,” he said.

“Not yet.”

—

## What happened at the Chugwater station at noon

At five minutes to twelve, Desmond Varick was standing on the porch of the Chugwater stage station in a gray suit and a new hat, with his yellow-wheeled buggy at the rail and a hamper of cold chicken and claret under the seat, watching the Cheyenne road for dust.

He was a handsome man of forty-five with a trimmed brown beard and an easy voice, and he had made a great deal of money in three years, most of it for himself.

In June he had received a letter from Mr. Ewan Dalgleish, secretary to the board in Edinburgh.

Certain shareholders wished the range and herd examined by an independent party.

The board had engaged a gentleman well acquainted with the country, who would present himself at the Chugwater station by the noon coach on Thursday, the twenty-fourth of July.

The letter did not give the gentleman’s name.

Varick had spent a month preparing.

He had had the books copied fair.

He had pushed every steer on the south range down along the Chugwater road, where a man in a buggy would see them.

He had planned a drive up Halfmoon Creek for the afternoon, to show the gentleman the living water.

All he had needed was the widow’s name on a deed.

He had had a clerk date it the eleventh of August, 1883.

The noon coach came in at twelve minutes past twelve, in a cloud of dust, six horses lathered.

The driver was a big red-faced Irishman named Pat Scully who had driven the Cheyenne road for eight years.

He set the brake and climbed down and spat in the road.

Three passengers got out.

A drummer in a checked suit with a sample case.

A soldier’s wife bound for Fort Laramie.

An old man who lived at Chugwater.

Varick looked into the empty coach.

Then he looked at Scully.

“There should be a gentleman,” he said.

“From the Thistle Company. A Scotsman, perhaps. An inspector.”

Scully looked at him for a long moment with an expression that the men on the porch remembered afterward.

“Mr. Varick,” he said, “there was a gentleman. He came up on Tuesday’s coach. Sat on the box beside me the whole way from Cheyenne, wouldn’t ride inside. He got down here Tuesday evening and ate his supper and hired a saddle horse off the agent, and asked me which way it was to the Halfmoon.”

Varick did not say anything.

“I’d have told you,” Scully said, “but he asked me not to. And I’d not have said no to that man about anything. I rode the treasure coach with him four years.”

He spat again.

“He’s no Scotsman, Mr. Varick. You’ll find he’s from Missouri.”

And that was the moment, the agent said afterward, when Desmond Varick’s face went from brown to gray.

He got into the buggy and drove north up the Halfmoon road with the hamper of chicken bouncing on the floor.

On the road he met Kincheloe coming south.

Nobody heard what they said to each other.

But they went north together, as fast as the horses could go.

—

## The paper that came out of the drifter’s coat

They came up the creek road at twenty minutes to one, Varick’s buggy in front and Kincheloe and three riders behind, and the dust they raised could be seen from the cottonwood for two miles.

Isobel was sitting in the shade by then, on the bench Coleman had built beside the spring, with a wet cloth on her wrists.

The boy, Ottie Lusby, was sitting on the ground with his back to the cabin wall.

The stranger was standing exactly where he had said he would be, under the cottonwood, with his hat pushed back and his coat open, and the bay horse dozing beside him.

On the flat stone at his feet lay the ruined deed, black with ink, the horseshoe still on it.

Varick got down out of the buggy.

He walked up to the tree with his hands in his coat pockets, and he took the hands out when he was halfway there, because he did not know what to do with them.

He tried the easy voice anyway.

He was good at it.

“I understand,” he said, “that you have been interfering with company business on this creek, sir. I understand you have discharged a firearm at my foreman. I’m going to have to ask you who you are.”

The stranger reached into the inside pocket of his canvas coat, and every man on horseback behind Varick put his hand on something.

But what came out was a long envelope of heavy paper, much creased, with a broken red seal.

He held it out.

Varick took it.

It was a letter of appointment from the board of the Thistle Land and Cattle Company, Limited, dated at Edinburgh the second of May, 1884, signed by Ewan Dalgleish as secretary, with the company’s seal.

It appointed Mr. Selby Hoyt, of Cheyenne, as the board’s independent examiner of the company’s range, herd and water rights in the Territory of Wyoming, with full authority to inspect the books and ride the range, and it required the company’s manager and all its employees to give him every assistance.

Varick read it once.

Then he read it again, more slowly, and his lips moved.

The stranger took a second thing out of the same pocket.

It was a small tally book with a pencil tied to it by a string, and he opened it and held it so Varick could see the pages.

“I’ve been on your range since Tuesday night,” he said.

“Two days on the south range, a day on the creeks. I counted what I could see and I read what I couldn’t by the water and the grass and the bones. Your books say fourteen thousand six hundred head. I’ll be generous and call it six thousand.”

He turned a page.

“And this morning I came up the Halfmoon to look at all the permanent living water the company holds by purchase and possession,” he said, “and I found it was a widow’s spring with a widow tied to the tree beside it. With a deed on a stone at her feet dated last August. And a man of yours telling her that if she didn’t sign by noon there’d be a grass fire this afternoon.”

Behind Varick, Burr Kincheloe sat his horse without moving.

“The board asked me to find out if the books were honest,” the stranger said.

“I’ll be able to tell them.”

Desmond Varick looked down at the ruined deed on the stone, black with ink.

He looked at the letter in his hand.

He opened his mouth and nothing came out of it.

Then his knees bent, and he sat down in the dust at the roots of the cottonwood, beside the stone, as if somebody had cut a string.

None of his riders got down to help him.

It was Burr Kincheloe who spoke first, and he was not speaking to Varick.

He was looking at the stranger, really looking, for the first time, the brown coat and the beard going gray and the holster worn smooth, and something had come into his pale eyes that had not been there all morning.

“Hoyt,” he said slowly.

“Hat Creek road. You were the messenger on the treasure coach. The one at Robbers’ Roost who never would tell the road agents his name.”

The stranger did not answer.

“The Deadwood papers called you the nameless gunslinger,” Kincheloe said.

“I read it. Everybody on the road read it. I didn’t think you were real.”

“I’m real enough,” Selby Hoyt said.

“And I’m tired, Mr. Kincheloe. I’d like you to take Mr. Varick home, and I’d like you to tell your riders that anybody who sets a match to grass on this flat between now and the first snow is going to meet me again. Then I’d like you to ride to Cheyenne and find yourself a lawyer, because I’m going to be telling a judge about the rope.”

Kincheloe looked at him for a long moment.

Then he got down off his horse, the first of them to do it, and went and took Varick under the arm and lifted him up out of the dust and walked him back to the yellow-wheeled buggy.

At the edge of the yard, he stopped, and turned, and looked at Isobel Treadway on her bench by the spring.

He took off his hat.

He did not say anything.

Then he put it back on and drove the buggy away down the creek.

—

## What the Scots did with their manager

The rest of it took a year, and most of it happened in rooms with carpets on the floor.

Selby Hoyt’s report reached Edinburgh in September of 1884.

It ran to forty pages and a map.

A second examiner, sent out by the board to check the first one, rode the range in October and put the herd at five thousand nine hundred and eighty head, which was eighty fewer than Hoyt had generously allowed.

Desmond Varick was dismissed in October.

A deputy marshal found him in Denver in December, living in a good hotel under another name, and brought him back to Cheyenne, where he was convicted of obtaining money under false pretenses and spent two years in the territorial penitentiary at Laramie City.

Burr Kincheloe testified against him.

It was the price of his own sentence, eleven months, for the rope.

When the judge asked him why he had tied a woman to a tree in July for a cattle company, he said he did not know, sir, that he had done things for cattle companies that he could not account for now.

Dobie Mulroney left the territory before a warrant could be written.

Fen Arbuckle got thirty days, and never again, as far as anybody knew, offered to sit on a man.

Ottie Lusby was the board’s witness, and then the first man the new manager hired.

The Thistle Company never recovered.

Then the terrible winter of 1886 and 1887 came down on the whole northern range, and the company was wound up in 1889 with its shareholders receiving a few shillings in the pound.

The new manager made Isobel a fair offer for the spring in 1885, eleven times what Varick’s man had laid on the stone.

She turned it down at her own kitchen table, and sold the company the right to water its cattle on the lower half mile of the Halfmoon at a cent a head instead, by written contract, for as long as the company lasted.

She kept the company’s copy framed over her stove.

—

## The drifter who did not ride on

Selby Hoyt rode on.

That was what everybody expected and that was what he did, the third week of August, with his report finished and the poncho tied behind his saddle and the bay horse rested.

He came back in October, with business that turned out not to exist, and again at Christmas.

In the spring of 1885, Isobel asked him at her kitchen table whether he meant to keep inventing business on the Halfmoon, or whether he meant to stay.

“I’ve never been anywhere I didn’t think about leaving,” he said finally.

“I haven’t thought about leaving here once.”

They were married in Cheyenne in June.

He planted two more cottonwoods by the spring and lived on the Halfmoon for thirty-one years, and when people asked him about the morning at the spring, he said he had only come up from the creek to water his horse.

Isobel told it differently.

She told it to a newspaper reporter from Cheyenne who came out in 1926, when she was sixty-eight and a widow for the second time.

She told him that the thing she remembered was not the shot, or the ink, or Desmond Varick sitting down in the dirt.

It was the moment just before all of it, when she had been standing in the sun for three hours with her hands tied behind her back, and a tired man in a heavy coat had walked up out of the willows leading a horse and looked at her, and she had told him to keep riding.

And he had not kept riding.

“Every one of them told me what I had to do,” she said.

“Sign it. Be reasonable. Think it over. Stand in the sun. He was the only one all morning who asked me how long I’d been standing there.”

The reporter asked her what she had said to him.

“I told him the truth,” she said.

“Since a quarter past seven. And he said, well, that’s long enough.”

The cottonwood is gone now.

It came down in a windstorm in the 1940s.

But the spring still runs, and the flat gray stone is still there beside it, and if you turn it over to the light you can still see the black ghost of a splash of ink across it, where a glass inkwell burst in the sun one July morning and a deed that was never signed went black from end to end.

Nobody ever signed anything on that stone.

She stood in the sun instead.

And then she did not have to anymore.

—

## What is real in this story, and what is told

The people in this story are invented.

There was no Isobel or Coleman Treadway, no Selby Hoyt, no Desmond Varick, no Burr Kincheloe, and no Thistle Land and Cattle Company, and the Halfmoon spring, the morning at the cottonwood, the noon coach, and the inkwell belong to the story.

The setting is real.

In the early 1880s, British and especially Scottish investors poured money into cattle companies on the northern plains, and several of the largest were organized in Edinburgh and Dundee.

One of them, the Swan Land and Cattle Company, organized in Edinburgh in 1883, had its headquarters at Chugwater, Wyoming.

The Thistle Company in this story is not the Swan company and is not meant to be.

Herds in those years really were sold by “book count,” a figure taken from the seller’s records rather than a roundup, and the practice became notorious when later counts showed many herds badly overstated.

The winter of 1886 to 1887 killed enormous numbers of cattle across the northern range and helped bring down many investor-owned companies.

The Cheyenne and Black Hills stage road ran north through Chugwater, Fort Laramie, and Hat Creek, and treasure coaches carrying gold south from Deadwood were guarded by shotgun messengers.

Selby Hoyt is not based on any particular one of them.

Fights over a single reliable spring were common across the West; this one is told, not recorded.

You Might Also Enjoy