Rush and “2112”: The Tour They Called “Down the Tubes,” the Label That Wanted Shorter Songs and the 20-Minute Answer That Bought Their Freedom
In January 1976, three musicians from Toronto walked into a small recording studio in their home city to make their fourth album.
Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson were 22 years old.
Neil Peart was 23.
Their last record had sold worse than the one before it.
The tour behind it had gone so badly that the band had given it a nickname of its own: “Down the Tubes.”
They were in debt, their American label had made its disappointment plain, and their manager had flown to Chicago to talk that label into paying for one more album.
Nearly everyone around them wanted the same thing: shorter songs, simpler songs, something a radio station could play.
What the three of them recorded that winter opened with a single piece of music more than twenty minutes long.
It was called “2112.”
This is the documented story of how Rush reached that studio, what happened when Mercury Records heard the result, and what the album bought them.
—
## Three Teenagers From Willowdale
Rush began in the summer of 1968 in Willowdale, a suburban neighborhood in the north of Toronto.
Guitarist Alex Lifeson, born Aleksandar Živojinović to Serbian immigrant parents, started the group with drummer John Rutsey.
Within weeks the first bassist was replaced by a school friend of Alex Lifeson’s, Gary Lee Weinrib, known to everyone as Geddy Lee.
Both of them were 15.
For the next five years the trio played high school dances and then, after Ontario lowered its drinking age to 18 in 1971, the bars of Toronto.
Their manager was Ray Danniels, a Toronto booking agent hardly older than they were, who had worked with them since their school days.
No Canadian record company would sign the band.
So Rush and its management paid for an album themselves and released it in Canada in March 1974 on a label of their own, Moon Records.
It was loud, direct hard rock, and reviewers compared it at once to Led Zeppelin.
A copy of the record reached Donna Halper, the music director of radio station WMMS in Cleveland, Ohio.
She put the seven-minute closing track, “Working Man,” on the air, and the station’s phones lit up.
By the usual telling, many callers wanted to know whether it was a new Led Zeppelin song.
The news traveled to Chicago, where Mercury Records had its headquarters.
Cliff Burnstein, a 25-year-old who ran national album promotion for the label, was handed the record with one business day to make up his mind.
According to accounts of his career, he phoned WMMS, confirmed that the reaction in Cleveland was real, and persuaded Mercury’s president, Irwin Steinberg, to sign the band that same day.
That was June 1974.
Rush had an American record deal and, within weeks, a first tour of the United States on the calendar.
—
## The Drummer Who Read Books
John Rutsey did not make that tour.
He had diabetes, and there were real worries about what months on the road would do to his health.
He also did not share his bandmates’ growing taste for longer and more complicated music.
In July 1974 he left, without any public quarrel.
The man who took his place was Neil Peart, a 21-year-old from St. Catharines, Ontario.
He had spent about a year and a half in London trying to make a living as a drummer, had come home without one, and was working at the parts counter of his father’s farm equipment dealership.
He joined Rush on July 29, 1974, which was Geddy Lee’s 21st birthday.
About two weeks later, on August 14, he played his first concert with the band, at the Civic Arena in Pittsburgh.
Rush were opening for Uriah Heep and Manfred Mann’s Earth Band, in front of more than 11,000 people.
Neil Peart turned out to be more than a drummer.
He read constantly, science fiction and fantasy and philosophy, and neither of the other two much enjoyed writing words.
Within months he was the band’s lyricist.
The first album with him, “Fly by Night,” came out in February 1975.
It was made at Toronto Sound Studios with Terry Brown, an English-born engineer and producer who had already remixed the debut and would work on every Rush studio album for the next seven years.
The record reached the Top 10 in Canada, and in 1975 Rush won the Juno Award for Most Promising Group.
In the United States it stalled outside the Top 100.
Two songs on it pointed to what was coming.
One, more than eight minutes long, told a fantasy battle in several parts.
The other was called “Anthem,” a title borrowed from a short novel by the Russian-born American writer Ayn Rand.
—
## “Caress of Steel”
Five months later the band was back in the same studio.
“Caress of Steel” was recorded in July 1975 and released on September 24.
Neil Peart later wrote that the three of them went into it feeling calm and sure of themselves, and that they regarded it as a major step.
Side one held three shorter songs and a twelve-and-a-half-minute fantasy piece called “The Necromancer.”
Side two was a single composition, “The Fountain of Lamneth,” nearly twenty minutes long and divided into six parts.
Even the sleeve went wrong.
It was the first Rush cover by a Toronto artist named Hugh Syme, and it was meant to be printed in silver, to look like steel.
A printing error turned it gold, and the mistake was never corrected.
The album peaked at number 148 on the Billboard chart.
In Canada it had sold about 40,000 copies by March 1976, fewer than “Fly by Night.”
In the United States it would not be certified gold until December 1993, eighteen years after it came out.
Geddy Lee described the effect on the band in the essay that accompanies later reissues of “2112.”
“That really shakes your confidence. We were so confused and disheartened.”
—
## Down the Tubes
The tour for “Caress of Steel” ran through the fall of 1975 and into the first days of 1976.
It is remembered today by a name that began as the band’s private joke.
Geddy Lee told the story again in an interview with the British magazine Mojo.
“Caress Of Steel had bombed. The gigs were half-empty.”
In the same interview he was clear about who came up with the name: the band did.
Alex Lifeson confirmed it to Guitar World in 2013, saying that “Down the Tubes” was simply how the three of them referred to that tour.
The money was as thin as the crowds.
According to the history of the album, there were weeks when the organization struggled to cover the musicians’ wages, which were $125 a week.
Alex Lifeson summed up the finances in that 2013 interview.
“We were already extremely in debt, and it was just getting worse and worse.”
He has said more than once that he started to think about what he would do if it ended.
His father was a plumber, he had worked alongside him before, and he supposed he could go back to that.
In 1980 he told Guitar Player that it was the only time in the band’s life when he came close to giving up.
One detail of the legend needs correcting.
The slump is sometimes described as lasting a year and a half.
From the release of “Caress of Steel” to the release of the album that ended the crisis, it was six months.
—
## One More Record
Mercury Records, part of the Polygram group, did not hide what it thought.
Geddy Lee recalled the message in the Mojo interview.
“Our record company Mercury had told us in no uncertain terms that we were a huge disappointment to them.”
Neil Peart told Classic Rock magazine in 2004 that he had seen the parent company’s forecast of the acts it expected to be selling the following year.
Rush, he said, were not on it.
What the label wanted was not a mystery.
The first album had been straight-ahead hard rock, it had found an audience, and Mercury wanted more of that: compact songs with a chance on the radio.
Alex Lifeson remembered executives regretting that the band no longer seemed interested in what had interested it at the start.
It fell to Ray Danniels to keep the contract alive.
He flew to Mercury’s offices in Chicago and came back with an agreement for one more album.
How he got it is told in slightly different ways.
The reissue essay says he talked up the new record without having heard a note of it, because the band was keeping him away from the sessions.
In the 2013 Guitar World interview it was put to Alex Lifeson that the manager and Terry Brown had both met with the label and reassured it, and he did not disagree.
Speaking to Rolling Stone in 2016, he put it more bluntly: by his account, the manager simply told the label what it wanted to hear.
There was also a practical reason the label could not force the issue.
Alex Lifeson explained in 2013 that the band’s contract was a production deal.
Rush were responsible for delivering a finished record, and what went on it, he said, was up to them.
So the choice belonged to the three of them.
Geddy Lee has described the decision in much the same way in many interviews: if the band was going to go under, it would go under playing its own music and not failing at someone else’s idea of it.
Neil Peart put it more formally in an interview given in the summer of 1976.
“We simply decided that 2112 would have to be the realization of all our hopes.”
—
## Written in Dressing Rooms
The new music was not written in comfort.
Alex Lifeson told Rolling Stone in 2016 where most of it came from.
“We wrote it mostly in arena dressing rooms, and in the car and the van.”
In other words, the answer to the failed tour was written during the failed tour.
By most accounts the album was recorded in January 1976, again at Toronto Sound Studios and again with Terry Brown, who engineered and mixed it as well as co-producing.
Hugh Syme, the cover artist, was also a keyboard player.
The swirl of synthesizer that opens the record is his, played on an ARP Odyssey, and he added a Mellotron to one of the quieter songs.
The instrumental overture that follows borrows a short flourish from Tchaikovsky’s “1812 Overture.”
Side two is the part of the album people tend to forget.
It consists of five separate songs, and not one of them reaches four minutes.
In that narrow sense, Mercury did get its shorter songs.
It simply got them after a side of vinyl that no radio programmer could use.
Alex Lifeson gave Rolling Stone his own description of the record in 2016.
“It was our protest album.”
—
## The Story on Side One
The title piece runs a little over twenty minutes and is divided into seven sections.
It is set in the year 2112, in a society ruled by the priests of the Temples of Syrinx.
Their computers decide what people read, what they see and what they hear.
A young man, who is never named, finds an old guitar in a cave behind a waterfall.
He has never seen such a thing, and he teaches himself to make music on it.
Believing he has found something wonderful, he takes it to the priests.
They dismiss it as a relic of the foolishness that brought down an earlier civilization, and they destroy it.
He dreams of a world where people once made such things freely, and wakes to find that nothing has changed.
The story ends in despair for him, and then with a voice announcing that someone has taken control.
Whether that voice means rescue or a new tyranny, the band left open.
It is not hard to see why listeners connected the priests with record executives.
Nothing in the piece says so, and the band never claimed it was a portrait of anyone at Mercury.
But a story about a man told that his music has no use, written by three men who had just been told much the same, did not need footnotes.
The gatefold cover carried the idea in a single picture.
Hugh Syme drew a naked man standing in front of a red star, and the figure, soon nicknamed the Starman, became the band’s emblem for the rest of its career.
Neil Peart explained that the star stood for any collectivist mentality and the man for the individual against the mass.
—
## The Credit to Ayn Rand
In the liner notes, alongside the words to the title piece, was one extra line of credit.
“With acknowledgement to the genius of Ayn Rand.”
Her short novel “Anthem,” first published in 1938, describes a future society so collective that the word “I” has disappeared.
Its hero rediscovers a forbidden invention and is condemned for it.
According to the history of the album, Neil Peart recognized the resemblance once his own story was written, and added the credit partly to head off any legal complaint.
The line was to cost the band more trouble than the music did.
In 1978, the British weekly New Musical Express ran an article by the writer Barry Miles, based on an interview with the group, that tied their admiration for Ayn Rand to the politics of the far right.
The band has always remembered it as an accusation of fascism.
For Geddy Lee it was personal.
His parents were Jewish survivors of the Nazi camps who had come to Canada from Poland after the war.
He answered the charge again in the Mojo interview.
“2112 was speaking out against totalitarianism, but the NME called us fascists.”
Alex Lifeson told Rolling Stone in 2016 that he had never been much of an Ayn Rand reader himself, and that what appealed to the band was what she wrote about the individual.
Neil Peart, for his part, said in later interviews that he had moved a long way from her ideas as he grew older.
—
## The Day Mercury Heard It
When the album was finished, Ray Danniels took it to Chicago.
This is the scene that later retellings like to dramatize, and it is the one with the least documentation.
One version has the room in open dismay, with a line to that effect put in the mouth of Cliff Burnstein, the man who had signed the band.
No interview could be found for this article in which he says it.
What is on record is Geddy Lee’s account, which points the other way.
He told Mojo that the band’s own manager had not understood the record, and that when it was played at Mercury, everyone in the room was puzzled by it, with one exception.
“Cliff thought the album was awesome, and for us that was so heartening.”
Alex Lifeson’s memory, given to Rolling Stone, is simply that the record company was concerned.
Neither man has described anyone at the label trying to stop the release.
Mercury put “2112” out in the United States in March 1976.
The date usually given today is March 24, though for many years it was listed as April 1, and the trade papers of that spring say only March.
Either way, the band was already on the road by then.
—
## Number 61
The album did not explode.
It climbed.
“2112” reached number 61 on the Billboard album chart in the last week of May 1976, which was its peak and not, as is sometimes said, the position at which it entered.
It stayed on the chart for 37 weeks.
In Canada it went to number 5.
On June 12, 1976, the Toronto Star reported that it had sold more than 200,000 copies in the United States and close to 35,000 in Canada.
Less than three months after release, it had outsold everything the band had made before.
It did this without a hit single.
What it had was a band that would not stop touring.
The tour for “2112” began in February 1976 and, with breaks, ran until June 1977, taking in more than 140 concerts.
It ended with the first shows Rush ever played in Europe.
Over three nights in June 1976 the band recorded its concerts at Massey Hall in Toronto.
The double live album made from those tapes, “All the World’s a Stage,” came out that September and became the first Rush record to reach the American Top 40.
Its sleeve notes described it as the close of the band’s first chapter.
The Recording Industry Association of America certified “2112” gold, for half a million copies, on November 16, 1977.
It was certified platinum in February 1981 and triple platinum in November 1995.
In August 2026, in the album’s fiftieth year, the music press reported that the certification had been raised to four times platinum.
—
## What “2112” Bought
The real prize was not on a chart.
Alex Lifeson named it in the Rolling Stone interview.
“That really bought our independence from the record company.”
Geddy Lee said the same thing to Mojo in his own way.
“The album was a vindication. From that point, we were free to make our own mistakes.”
The proof came with the next record.
In June 1977 Rush went to Rockfield Studios in Wales, with Terry Brown, to make “A Farewell to Kings.”
It contained an eleven-minute piece based on a poem by Samuel Taylor Coleridge.
Nobody from the label asked for anything shorter.
Released that September, it was certified gold in the United States in about two and a half months.
That same year, the band’s management founded a Canadian label for its records and named it Anthem.
“Hemispheres,” in 1978, gave another whole side of vinyl to one composition.
Then, by their own choice, Rush began writing more compact songs.
“Permanent Waves” reached number 4 in the United States in 1980.
“Moving Pictures,” released in February 1981, went to number 3 there and number 1 in Canada, and has sold more than four million copies in the United States alone.
The band stayed with Mercury until 1989.
Cliff Burnstein left the label sooner than that.
He departed in early 1980, and in 1982 he and Peter Mensch founded the management company Q Prime, whose first client was Def Leppard and whose roster soon included Metallica.
Rush made fifteen more studio albums after “2112.”
The last of them, in 2012, was a concept album from start to finish.
Worldwide sales of the band’s records are estimated at more than 40 million.
—
## Epilogue: Forty Years On
On April 18, 2013, Rush were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Los Angeles.
The induction speech was given by Dave Grohl and Taylor Hawkins of Foo Fighters, and the overture of “2112” was part of the music played that night.
Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson and Neil Peart played their last concert together on August 1, 2015, at the Forum in Los Angeles, at the end of a tour marking the drummer’s forty years in the band.
Neil Peart’s final years, and his death in January 2020 at the age of 67, are a separate story that has been told elsewhere on this site.
The line-up that walked into Toronto Sound Studios in 1976 had lasted 41 years, from the summer of 1974 to the summer of 2015.
In October 2025, Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson announced that they would tour again under the name Rush.
The tour, called Fifty Something, opened on June 7, 2026, at the same Los Angeles arena where the band had stopped almost eleven years earlier, with the German drummer Anika Nilles.
By then “2112” was fifty years old, and a new anniversary edition of the album had been announced for the fall.
—
## What Is Documented and What Is Not
The outline of this story is not in dispute.
“Caress of Steel” sold poorly, the tour lost money, and the band itself called that tour “Down the Tubes.”
Mercury wanted more accessible music and considered ending the relationship.
Ray Danniels went to Chicago and secured one more album.
The band opened that album with a twenty-minute suite, and within three months it had outsold every earlier Rush record.
The details at the edges are less firm.
The exact release date is given differently in different places.
Exactly what the manager promised the label, and in whose company, depends on who is remembering.
And the famous scene in the Chicago office rests mainly on Geddy Lee’s later account, which is that almost everyone was baffled and that the executive who had signed the band loved what he heard.
No contract from those years has been published, and no one at Mercury ever said on the record how close the label came to letting Rush go.
What can be measured is what came afterward.
A band that was told in 1975 to write shorter songs spent the next four decades deciding for itself how long its songs should be.
It began with three musicians in their early twenties, a manager who had bought them a few months, and a decision to spend their last chance on the record they wanted to make.