“Release Her!” The Nameless Gunslinger Said To The Most Notorious Thugs In Deadwood
In Deadwood, in the summer of 1879, a thing was lawful if Thaddeus Varnum’s men did it at noon in the middle of Main Street.
That was all the law the gulch had, and everybody on the boardwalk knew it.
So nobody on the boardwalk said a word about the woman in the shoeing frame.
The frame stood in the street in front of Varnum’s freight yard, where his blacksmith shod the bulls for the Fort Pierre wagons.
An ox will not stand on three legs for a smith the way a horse will.
He has to be roped against a brace of poles, and each foot in its turn lashed up to a post.
That morning they had put Rachel Red Willow in it instead.
She was roped at the waist against the slanted poles, bent over sideways, with one ankle lashed to the top of the foot post and her other moccasin flat in the dust.
Then every man of them had stepped back, on Varnum’s order.
A lesson, he liked to say, is a thing a town watches, and no man was to lay a hand on it.
Seven of his men stood about the street with their thumbs in their gun belts, three in a row on one side and four on the other.
It was Thursday, the fourteenth of August, and the sun stood high over the false fronts.
Up the gulch a stamp mill blew its noon whistle.
Rachel was twenty-seven years old, and a horse trader by trade.
She was Oglala Lakota, of the Wagluhe band, who had camped beside Fort Laramie since before she was born, and she had her English from the sutler’s counter there.
She broke ponies to harness and sold them, and the stage company’s barn in Deadwood had bought nine of hers since spring.
She wore what she had ridden all night in: a fringed dress of tan buckskin, a red woven sash, and a beaded band across her forehead.
She had been in the frame since ten o’clock.
She was not looking at the men.
She was looking at the shadow of the foot post, which had been drawing in all morning and was now as short as it would go.
It was the only clock in Deadwood she trusted, and it had just told her the same thing as the whistle.
Across the street, sixty feet away, Sheriff Walter Baird stood on the porch of his office with one hand on the rail.
He had been standing there since ten o’clock too.
She had ridden twenty miles in the dark to say eleven words to that man.
She could not say them across a street.
The one who did the talking was Rufe Gaines, who captained Varnum’s riders.
He was a bearded man in a black hat and a brown leather vest, and he spoke to her the way a man speaks to a crowd.
“Tell the town where they’ve got him.”
She kept her eyes on the shadow.
“I will tell the sheriff. Nobody else.”
The man standing behind her laughed.
His name was Judd Sloane, he wore a gray vest, and he was the best pistol shot on Varnum’s payroll and the only man on it who read books.
“Sheriff’s right there on his porch. Sing out.”
She turned her head as far as the ropes allowed, looked at the porch, and looked back at the dust.
“Not across a street.”
Eight days before, the Fort Pierre coach had been stopped at a creek crossing twenty miles out, a little beyond Bear Butte.
The express company’s gold was gone: four sacks of dust, fourteen thousand dollars of it.
The shotgun messenger was gone too, and the messenger was Dave Baird, the sheriff’s younger brother.
Three arrows were standing in the door of the coach.
Varnum’s men had brought that coach in and stood it in front of their office with the arrows still in the door, and it had been drawing a crowd ever since.
They called themselves the Gulch Protective Association, and they guarded the roads for a fee.
Every merchant on Main Street paid it by the week, and paid double in any week after a coach was stopped.
Now there was a paper on the Association’s counter with two hundred and fourteen names on it, asking the commanding officer at Fort Meade to drive the Sioux lodgepole camps out of the Hills.
And there was a Lakota woman who had ridden up to Varnum’s toll gate at first light and asked, in good English, for Sheriff Baird.
They had not let her get as far as the sheriff.
Gaines raised his voice for the boardwalk.
“She knows where the Sioux hid that gold. She knows what they did with Dave Baird. She can stand there till she says so.”
On the porch the sheriff’s hand closed on the rail, and stayed where it was.
Deadwood had learned to get along by looking at its own boots.
Nobody had paid any mind to the old man who rode in from the upper end of the gulch on a tired sorrel.
He had tied up at the rail of the Long Glass saloon and stood a while on the boardwalk with the rest, about as long as it takes a man to roll a cigarette and decide against it.
Then he stepped down into the street.
He walked out to the middle of it and stopped a dozen paces short of the frame, with three of Varnum’s men on his left hand and four on his right.
He was lean and weathered, in his late fifties, with a graying stubble of beard, pale eyes squinted nearly shut against the glare, and an old white scar through his left eyebrow.
He wore a black flat-brimmed hat and a heavy wool poncho in olive and tan, with a great spread eagle woven across the back of it.
His hands hung open at his sides.
On his right hip, under the edge of the poncho, rode one revolver in a tan holster.
He looked at the frame, and the ropes, and the woman.
When he spoke it was not loud, and it was not to her.
“Release her.”
It took the street a moment to believe it had heard him.
Then Sloane laughed, and the rest took it up.
Sloane studied the old man over the top of the frame with real interest.
“He dresses like the man in the dime book. Hat, blanket and all.”
He shook his head, as if he were a little sorry about it.
“Book says he’s left-handed, though. It calls him the nameless gunslinger, and it’s very particular about the hand.”
Gaines walked two steps out from his row and hooked his thumbs behind his buckle.
“Old man, you’re standing in the wrong street.”
The old man might not have heard, so Gaines tried it louder, for the boardwalk.
“Nobody gives orders in this gulch but Mr. Varnum.”
The old man turned his head then, and looked at him for the first time.
“Then one of you had better fetch him. I’d as soon not say it twice.”
Rachel looked at the shadow of the post, and then at the stranger’s boots, and thought that here was a man who had no idea what time it was.
Gaines grinned through his beard at the men around him.
“Hear that? Grandpa wants an appointment.”
His right hand was already going down.
Nobody on Main Street saw the old man draw.
What the boardwalk saw was the corner of the poncho lift, as if a wind had got under it.
There was one flat crack, and Rufe Gaines’s pistol left his hand and went spinning away across the dust toward the sheriff’s porch.
—
## The appointment
Gaines stood looking at his own right hand.
It had all five of its fingers, and not one of them would close.
The old man held his revolver pointed at the ground between them.
“That was the gun. I aimed at the gun. My eyes are not what they were, and I’d hate to be asked to do it twice.”
Nobody else’s hand moved.
Sloane was watching the old man’s gun hand with close attention.
“Right-handed. I told you.”
Somebody on the gallery of the freight office was clapping, slowly.
Thaddeus Varnum came down his own steps in a clean linen coat, a man of fifty with a gold watch chain and the voice of someone who chairs meetings.
“That was pretty. You’ll be the gentleman the express company wired about. They might have saved the fare. The Association has the matter in hand.”
The old man put the revolver back where it lived.
“It’s the lady you have in hand. I’d like her let go.”
Varnum took out his watch and looked at it.
“Six minutes past twelve. I don’t care for shooting in the street at noon; there are ladies on the walk. Take her. Feed her. She may tell a stranger what she won’t tell the town. At five o’clock you bring her back to this frame, with what she knows. Then you may ride out with the express company’s thanks and mine.”
The old man seemed to consider the frame.
“And if I have a different notion at five?”
Varnum smiled at him quite pleasantly.
“Come anyway. I like the whole town at a lesson, and at five the day shift is down from the mills. The frame will hold two.”
The old man thought about five o’clock for a moment, the way a man looks over a horse he is being offered cheap.
“Five o’clock.”
Varnum inclined his head and went back up his steps.
His men went after him, Gaines last, carrying his right hand in his left.
The old man took a knife from under the poncho and walked to the foot post.
“I’m going to cut the foot loose first, miss. Then the waist.”
She had been thinking about that order for two hours.
“Yes. That way.”
He cut the lashing.
Her foot came down, and the leg would not take her, and she held on to the brace until it would.
Then he cut the waist rope at the knot, hung it over the foot post, and stood back a pace.
He did not offer his arm.
She spoke without looking at him.
“Do not carry me.”
He put the knife away.
“I hadn’t thought to. I’ve a bad back.”
The Long Glass was forty yards up the street.
She went from hitching rail to hitching rail, hand over hand along each one, and where there was no rail she walked.
He walked on the street side of her, a pace off, between her and the windows of the freight office.
On the porch across the street, Sheriff Baird had taken his hand off the rail.
It was on the butt of his pistol now, and he did not seem to know what to do with it there.
—
## The Long Glass
The saloon was named for the mirror behind its bar: eleven feet of French plate, freighted in from Fort Pierre in a wagonload of sawdust without a crack.
It showed a person the whole room at once, the wrong way around.
Maude Brennan owned it.
She was fifty, broad, and plain-spoken, and hers was the only house on Main Street that paid the Association nothing, because half the Association owed her money.
She took one look at the two of them in her doorway.
“By the window. Get her off that leg.”
She brought water, and clean cloths for the rope marks, and coffee, in that order.
Then she looked the old man over, from the black hat down to the fringe of the poncho.
She reached behind the bar and laid a paper-covered book on it, thumbed as soft as flannel.
On its yellow cover a man in a flat hat and a blanket stood with a pistol in his left hand and a scar over his right eye.
“Judd Sloane reads this at my bar every night with his lips moving. I know it better than my prayers. Is it you?”
The old man looked at the book without any great affection.
“The fellow in that one is left-handed, they tell me.”
Rachel had turned her head at the window.
She looked at the yellow cover.
Then she looked past Maude Brennan into the long mirror, where an old man in an olive blanket stood with a revolver on his left hip and a scar through his right eyebrow.
She said nothing about it.
It was not her business yet.
Her business was the man himself, and she went at it like a trader.
“Who pays you?”
He answered her straight.
“The express company. Forty dollars and found, to bring back four sacks of dust and one shotgun messenger. That’s the order they wrote it in. I’d have put it the other way around.”
She watched his face.
“The sacks have lead seals on them. With numbers.”
He did not need his paper for it.
“Forty-four fourteen through forty-four seventeen.”
She was silent for a moment.
“The one I turned over said forty-four sixteen.”
Maude Brennan set the coffee pot down rather hard.
Rachel told it then, plainly, the way she would have told the points of a horse.
Her brother Joseph had found him on the evening of the robbery, when he took the pony herd down to water.
A white man lay in the willows under the cut bank, with his leg broken under him, on top of four sacks.
He had seen riders waiting at the crossing and kicked the pouch off the coach before it stopped.
They had put him off the box with a rifle butt, and hunted the creek bank for him until dark.
Then they had driven three arrows into the coach door with the butt of a pistol, and gone home.
Varnum had robbed a coach and come away with nothing but a story.
Her mother had set the leg.
For six days the man was out of his head with fever, and on the seventh he knew where he was, and who had stopped the coach.
He begged them not to carry him to the fort.
Varnum sold the fort its hay and its beef, and whatever the post knew at noon the freight office knew by supper.
He wanted his brother told first, and nobody else.
Rachel moved her leg on the chair.
“So I came for his brother.”
The old man asked the question he was paid to ask.
“And the gold?”
She almost smiled.
“Under my mother’s bed. It is not our gold. A camp that is found with it is a dead camp.”
He nodded slowly.
“And you couldn’t call that across a street.”
She shook her head.
“Eleven riders and twenty miles. They would be at Bear Butte before the sheriff had found his hat.”
He had one question more.
“What were you looking at, in that frame? You never looked at Gaines once.”
She looked out the window, at the street.
“The shadow of the post. I told my brother: if I am not back when the sun is straight overhead, put the white man on a drag and take him to the soldiers’ doctor, whatever he says.”
She counted it on her fingers for him.
“Two hours to the fort, with a drag. Three from the fort to here, for soldiers with a wagon.”
The old man did the sum.
“Five o’clock.”
She would not give him more than she had.
“If the soldiers believe a Lakota who carries in a white man with a broken leg. If they do not, then not at five, and not at all.”
Rachel said the next thing to the window.
“I did not plan the frame. I planned the noon.”
He considered that for some time.
“Then nobody has to be fast today. All anybody has to do is be slow until five.”
She turned from the window and looked at him fully.
“There are eleven words I came here to say. You will have to carry them across the street.”
He waited.
She said them carefully, one at a time.
“Your brother is alive at Bear Butte. Varnum never had him.”
She added the rest as if it puzzled her.
“If he does not believe you, say that the mule’s name was Deuteronomy. I was told to say it. I do not know what it means.”
—
## Sixty feet
Sheriff Baird was behind his desk when the old man came in, and he did not get up.
He was forty-four years old, and in eight days he had got to look sixty.
“I wondered how long before you’d walk over here.”
The old man shut the door behind him.
“You stood on that porch two hours.”
Baird’s jaw worked.
“You have been in this town since noon, mister.”
He pulled open the bottom drawer of the desk and laid a notebook on the blotter.
“Two years. Every man who paid, and what he paid. Every man who wouldn’t, and what happened to his roof afterward. Days, names, which of Varnum’s men. I have not missed a week.”
The old man turned the pages.
“It’s a careful book. Who has read it?”
Baird looked at the wall.
“Nobody. I was waiting until there was enough in it that no man of them could walk away.”
The old man closed the cover.
“And eight days ago?”
Baird’s voice did not shake, but his eyes would not hold still.
“They have my brother. Varnum came in here the night of the robbery with Dave’s hat in his hand. He said his men had found him alive, and were nursing him where no Sioux would ever find him. He said Dave would mend nicely, so long as the sheriff’s office kept to its porch.”
The old man laid one finger on the notebook.
“You saw the hat. Did you see your brother?”
Baird said it very low.
“No.”
The old man gave him the eleven words exactly as he had been given them.
“Your brother is alive at Bear Butte. Varnum never had him.”
Baird did not move.
“That’s what a man would say to get me off the porch.”
The old man agreed with him.
“It is. She thought you might take it so. She says the mule’s name was Deuteronomy.”
The sheriff sat back as if he had been struck.
“We had a mule on the farm in Ohio. Pa let Dave name him. He was six years old, and it was the longest word he knew.”
The old man let him have a moment, and then took it back.
“He has a splint on his leg and fourteen thousand dollars under an old woman’s bed. As of noon he’s on a pony drag bound for Fort Meade. If the Army listens, there will be soldiers in this street about five.”
Baird turned his head toward the window, and the frame beyond it.
“She stood in that thing two hours. For Dave. With me sixty feet off, on account of a hat.”
The old man did not soften it.
“She did. I wouldn’t spend the afternoon on it. There’s four hours left.”
Baird wiped his face with his hand.
“What do you want of me?”
The old man shook his head.
“Nothing until five. I can’t arrest a dog in this county. I’m a hired man with a list of seal numbers. All I can do is stand in the street and be slow. The arresting is yours, and that book is what you’ll do it with. I’d read it out, loud, from the top. It’ll take a while, and a while is what we want.”
Baird put his hand flat on the notebook.
“And if the soldiers don’t come?”
The old man was already at the door.
“Then you’ll have read it out once. That’s once more than in two years.”
Baird asked it of his back.
“Who are you?”
He stopped with his hand on the latch.
“A man who used to wear one of those, and kept getting to places late. I’ve been trying to be on time since.”
—
## Four hours
The old man spent the afternoon walking the length of Main Street, slowly, looking at where the sun was going rather than where it was.
In the Long Glass, Rachel would not stay in the chair.
At one o’clock she got up and walked the length of the bar and back with a hand on the rail.
At two she did it again without the rail.
Maude Brennan watched her from behind the bar.
“You mean to go back out there.”
Rachel turned at the end of the bar and started back.
“I mean to be standing when they come. My brother will be with them, and he is not going to find me in a chair.”
At four Maude took the yellow book off the back bar and held it up, cover outward, to the long mirror.
She looked into the glass for some time.
In it a man in a flat hat held a pistol in his right hand, and the scar ran through his left eyebrow.
She set the book down very gently, as if it had grown hot.
“Well, I will be switched.”
Rachel did not look around.
“Yes. I saw it at noon.”
Maude stared at her.
“And never said a word?”
Rachel tried her weight on the leg once more, and it held.
“It was not my business at noon. At five it may be.”
—
## Five o’clock
At a quarter to five Main Street shut up like a book.
Doors closed, shutters came across, and the boardwalk emptied down to one dog.
The old man walked out and stood where he had stood at noon.
He had taken some trouble over which way he faced.
The sun had come down toward the rim of the gulch behind his left shoulder, and his shadow went out a long way ahead of him.
At ten minutes to five Rachel came out of the Long Glass and walked down the middle of the street, favoring the leg, as far as the frame.
She did not get into it.
She lifted the long waist rope off the foot post, shook it out, and began to coil it over her arm.
The old man spoke without turning his head.
“You’d do better behind a wall, miss.”
She went on coiling.
“He said to bring me back to the frame. I am back. I made this appointment before he did.”
Varnum came at five by his own watch.
He came on a tall bay horse, because a man of property does not walk to a lesson, and ten men came on foot behind him, strung across the street from walk to walk.
Gaines was among them, with his right hand wrapped in a rag and his pistol on the wrong hip.
They stopped at twenty paces, and every one of them had his hat brim pulled down.
The sun was square in their eyes.
Not a man of them had thought about that until now.
Varnum sat easy in the saddle.
“I see the woman. I don’t hear what she knows.”
The old man answered him mildly.
“She knows what time it is. That’s more than you do.”
Varnum did not trouble to understand it.
“This is not a fight, sir. It is a lesson, and Deadwood is at its windows. Mr. Sloane.”
Judd Sloane stepped out of the line, loose and cheerful.
“No hard feelings, old-timer. There’s only one man I ever worried about, and he’s left-handed and in a book.”
Rachel spoke from the frame, and she did not stop coiling the rope.
“Mr. Sloane. Have you got your book?”
He blinked at her, and patted his coat.
“Always.”
She told it as plainly as she had told the rest.
“When I was sixteen a man with a picture wagon came to Laramie. He made pictures on tin for fifty cents, and my father bought one. My father had a knife scar on his left hand. In the tin picture it is on his right.”
She drew the coil tight.
“I said the man had cheated us, and my father laughed at me. A tin picture is a looking glass. Everything in it is the wrong way around. The man who drew your book never saw the man. He saw a tin picture of him. Look at the eye.”
Sloane took the book out.
On the yellow cover the scar ran over the right eye, and the pistol was in the left hand.
Twenty paces off, with the sun behind him, stood an old man with a scar through his left eyebrow and a holster on his right hip.
Sloane looked from the book to the man for a long time.
“It says he walked seven men into Fort Smith on one rope.”
The old man spoke as though it embarrassed him.
“They walked because I’d lost the horses.”
Sloane put the book back in his coat.
He unbuckled his gun belt, hung it over the nearest hitching rail, and sat down on the edge of the boardwalk like a man who has come to the end of a chapter.
“Mr. Varnum, I’ll draw my time.”
It went down the line like a yawn.
Two more belts were hung on the rail.
Varnum’s color had come up.
“There are seven of you left, and one of him.”
The answer came from the sheriff’s porch, in a voice nobody in Deadwood had heard raised in two years.
“March the eleventh, 1878. Holm’s bakery declined the weekly dues. March the thirteenth, the bakery burned. R. Gaines and one other seen in the alley.”
Walter Baird came down his steps with the notebook open in both hands, one step to an entry.
A door opened behind the old man, and Holm the baker stood in it with flour to his elbows.
They came out by ones and twos and stood along the walks, and then in the street itself, behind the old man and beside the frame.
Not one of them had a gun.
They only stood and listened to their own names.
Baird had reached the dust, and he was still reading.
“August the sixth, 1879. Fort Pierre coach stopped twenty miles out. T. Varnum in this office that night, with a hat.”
Varnum leaned down from the saddle.
“Mr. Gaines. Stop his mouth.”
Gaines looked at his wrapped hand, and at the old man, and at two hundred people who were no longer looking at their boots.
He stayed where he was.
It was then that they heard it, from the lower end of the gulch: trace chains, and iron tires on rock.
An Army ambulance came up Main Street behind six mules, with ten troopers riding in twos, and beside its off wheel a Lakota man on a spotted pony.
Rachel looked at the shadow of the foot post.
It lay long across the dust now, pointing at the far boardwalk.
She said it to nobody.
“Five.”
Varnum understood it sooner than any of his men.
He wheeled the bay toward the head of the gulch and the Cheyenne road, and drove in his spurs.
The old man never lifted his hand.
He had been hired to bring back gold and a messenger, and he did not shoot horses.
Rachel had been catching ponies out of a running herd since she was nine years old.
She let the bay come level with her.
The loop went out flat, dropped over Varnum’s hat and shoulders, and drew down around his arms, and by then she had two turns of the tail around the foot post.
That post had been set to hold a bull.
It held.
The bay went on up the gulch by itself.
Thaddeus Varnum sat down in the dust of Main Street at the foot of his own frame, with the wind knocked out of him and nothing broken.
When he had his breath, he spent it on the old man.
“Tell her to release me.”
The old man looked down at him without interest.
“Ask her yourself. Her English is better than mine.”
Varnum did not ask.
Rachel put the tail of the rope into the sheriff’s hand.
“He is yours. I only held him.”
Then, with nobody left in the street to stop her, she said what she had come to say.
“Your brother is alive. He is in that wagon.”
Dave Baird was sitting up in the ambulance, a good deal thinner, with his leg bound between two peeled lodgepoles.
He looked his brother over.
“Walt. You look worse than I do.”
Then he pointed, and his hand was steady.
“Gaines put me off the box. Those two beside him held the leaders. And Varnum sat his horse on the bank and gave the orders. I had six hours in those willows to learn his voice.”
The officer was a young lieutenant named Phelps, gray with dust to the eyebrows.
He lifted a canvas pouch over the tailboard, and the old man took a paper from under his poncho and read four numbers off it.
Every seal was whole, and the lieutenant said the rest of it for the whole street to hear.
“A camp does not rob a coach and then haul the gold to the United States Army with the seals unbroken.”
He walked over to the coach in front of the freight office and drew an arrow out of the door with two fingers.
Its nock was mashed flat.
“No bow ever did that.”
Sheriff Baird stood over the man at the foot of the frame and found the page he wanted.
“Thaddeus Varnum, I arrest you for stopping the Fort Pierre coach with intent to rob it, and for assault on David Baird with intent to kill. There’s two years more in this book whenever the judge wants it.”
From the edge of the boardwalk, Judd Sloane asked the old man the only thing he still cared to know.
“What do they call you, when it ain’t in a book?”
The old man told him, since he had earned it.
“Norcross. Elam Norcross.”
—
## The wrong way around
At sundown he was tightening his cinch in front of the Long Glass.
Rachel came out and stood at the rail, on both feet, with one hand on it.
“You never asked me to trust you.”
He pulled the latigo through.
“You’d have been a fool to. You had had a morning.”
She thought it over.
“You held the street five hours.”
He shook his head at the saddle.
“You held it two before I rode in. You had sent for the Army before you ever laid eyes on me. All I did was keep an appointment.”
She gave him that much.
“It was a good appointment.”
He swung up, and touched the brim of the black hat.
“Rachel Red Willow. I’ll know the name.”
He rode out by the upper road, toward Sidney, where the company wanted its paper signed.
Her brother was waiting at the lower gate with her mare, and she had six ponies to bring in before the month was out.
The paper with two hundred and fourteen names lay on the Association’s counter that night.
By morning sixty were left on it.
The rest had come in the dark and scratched themselves off.
Thaddeus Varnum was tried at the December term of the territorial district court, in a room that smelled of new pine, for most of Main Street had burned in September.
Rachel Red Willow gave her evidence in English, on her feet, and declined the chair.
The sheriff’s notebook took a day and a half to read into the record.
Varnum was given twelve years at hard labor, and Rufe Gaines seven.
They took him east in irons to the House of Correction at Detroit, where Dakota Territory boarded its convicts, having no penitentiary of its own.
The express company paid its standing reward, one tenth of the treasure recovered.
Fourteen hundred dollars went across the counter to Rachel Red Willow, who counted it.
Maude Brennan kept the yellow book behind her bar.
Any man who doubted the story was invited to hold it up to her glass.
But the last that Deadwood saw of the matter came sooner than the trial, on a Thursday three weeks after.
Rachel Red Willow drove six ponies up through the lower gate at noon.
There was no gate man, and no toll.
The stage barn paid her forty dollars a head, and she counted that too.
The frame was back at its trade, with a red-and-white bull roped in it and a blacksmith swearing at the off hind foot.
She stopped beside it in the middle of Main Street, with her own two feet in the dust.
Up the gulch the stamp mill blew noon.
She watched the shadow of the foot post draw in as short as it would go.
It had kept good time for her once, and she saw no reason to quarrel with it.
Then she went on about her business.