Miles Davis DARED Prince To Play Trumpet LIVE To Mock Him-Nobody Was Ready For THIS…
Thursday, November 14th, 1985, Burbank, California. It was a little after 4:00 in the afternoon when a black car rolled up to the artist’s entrance of NBC Studio 1 and just sat there with the engine running. Nobody got out. The security guard on the door, a heavy-set man named Walt, who had worked that gate for 11 years and had seen every kind of star climb out of every kind of car, knew exactly who was inside.
He’d been warned that morning. He’d been told not to rush him, not to open the door for him, not to say anything clever, and above all not to ask for an autograph. The back window came down about 3 in, a cloud of cigarette smoke drifted out into the cool air. Then a voice came out of the gap so low and rough it sounded like gravel being poured slowly out of a paper bag.
“This the place where Johnny does his thing?” Walt said, “Yes, sir, it was.” “Then why does it look like a post office?” and the window went back up. Miles Davis sat in that car for another 6 minutes before he finally opened the door himself. When he stepped out, Walt said later, “It was like watching a painting walk.” He was 59 years old that fall, thin as a coat hanger, wearing a loose black jacket covered in some kind of stitched pattern that looked like it came from Tokyo, which it did, and a pair of sunglasses so big they covered half his face. His
hair hung down past his collar in long loose curls. He had a cane in one hand, which he didn’t lean on so much as carry, like it was a prop he’d been told to bring. In the other hand, he had a small black case battered at the corners with a strip of tape across one latch, his trumpet.
He didn’t let anyone carry it. A young production assistant came jogging out to meet him with a clipboard and reached for the case out of pure habit, and Miles didn’t say a word. He just turned his head and looked at the kid over the top of those sunglasses, and the kid’s hand dropped back to his side like it had been slapped.
“I got it,” Miles whispered. “I’ve been carrying it 40 years. I think I can make it down one hallway.” People who knew Miles Davis in those years will tell you that the whisper was the first thing you noticed and the last thing you forgot. Back in 1956, he’d had surgery to remove growths from his larynx and the doctor told him not to speak at all for 10 days while it healed.
Two days later, he got into a shouting match with a record executive and his voice never came back right. For the rest of his life, it came out of him as a horse, scratchy rasp, barely louder than breath and it meant that whenever Miles talked, a whole room had to lean in and go quiet to hear him. Some people thought he used it on purpose.
Some people thought he’d been using the whole world’s attention on purpose since he was 19 years old. He was not supposed to be on television that night. That’s the first thing you have to understand. For 5 years, from 1975 to 1980, Miles Davis had basically disappeared. He locked himself inside his brownstone on West 77th Street in New York, stopped playing, stopped recording and let his body fall apart.
His hip was so bad he could barely walk. He had diabetes. He had pneumonia more than once. He had problems that he didn’t talk about with anybody. Friends would knock on the door and he wouldn’t answer. His trumpet sat in its case in a closet and there were whole years when he didn’t take it out once.
The man who had made Kind of Blue, the best-selling jazz record in history, the man who played with Charlie Parker when he was still a teenager and then gone on to change the direction of music four or five separate times, was sitting in the dark in a house full of dust and old newspapers and a lot of people honestly believed they would read his obituary before they ever heard him play again.
Then in 1981, he came back thinner, older, stranger, playing a new kind of music with young electric bands, funk basslines, synthesizers, rock guitar and the jazz world, the same critics and purists who had once called him a genius started saying terrible things about him in print. Sellout has been a ghost chasing the charts.
In the spring of 1985, he did something that made it much worse. He left Columbia Records, the label he’d been with for 30 years, the label that had put out almost every important record of his life, and he signed with Warner Brothers. And on his last album for Columbia, he had recorded instrumental versions of two pop songs that were all over the radio at the time.
One was a Cyndi Lauper ballad, the other was a song from a Michael Jackson record. He played them the only way he knew how, soft and aching, with a mute in his horn, and he started playing them live every night. The purists nearly had a collective heart attack. A reviewer in one of the big jazz magazines wrote that watching Miles Davis Lauper song was like watching Picasso paint a cereal box.
Miles cut that review out and kept it in his wallet. He never said why. Some people figured he kept it to stay angry. Others figured it was because he secretly agreed with the part about Picasso. So, that was the man who walked down the hallway of NBC Studio 1 that November afternoon, a legend who a lot of people had decided was finished. A man with a bad hip and a sick body and a new record label that nobody was sure had any idea what to do with him.
He was booked on The Tonight Show starring Johnny Carson to talk about his new record deal and maybe play a little, and everybody at the network was quietly terrified of him. Johnny Carson wasn’t though. Johnny loved him. That’s the part people forget. Carson was a huge jazz fan. He played drums himself, not badly either, and he’d been listening to Miles since the Birth of the Cool records came out when Johnny was still a young radio announcer in Nebraska.
His band leader, Doc Severinsen, was one of the finest trumpet players in America. Having Miles Davis on the show wasn’t some rating stunt for Johnny. It was a personal thing. He’d been asking the bookers to get Miles for years. What Johnny didn’t know, and what almost nobody in that building knew until about 2 hours before the taping, was who else was going to be walking through that same door that night.
At 20 minutes to 5, a second car pulled up to the artist’s entrance. Smaller, no limousine, no entourage, just a dark sedan with tinted windows and one large bodyguard in the front passenger seat. The bodyguard got out first, looked up and down the loading dock the way a man checks a street before crossing it, and then opened the back door.
The person who stepped out was about 5 ft 2 in, maybe 5 ft 3 in in the heels, and he was wearing heels, a pair of ankle boots with a lift you could see from across the parking lot. He had on a long dark coat with a high collar that came up nearly to his ears, and his hair was pushed back from his face in shiny black curls.
He had a thin mustache and very large, very dark eyes, and he moved the way a cat moves when it walks into a room it doesn’t trust yet, taking in every corner before committing to any of them. Walt, the security guard, didn’t recognize him at first. He said later that his first thought was that some teenager had gotten lost on the lot. Then the man looked up at him just for half a second and nodded, and Walt said it hit him like a bucket of cold water.
It was Prince. In November of 1985, Prince Rogers Nelson was maybe the biggest musician in the world. Purple Rain had come out the summer before and sold something like 13 million copies. The movie had been a hit. He’d won an Academy Award. He’d filled arenas all across the country. And then, instead of doing the obvious thing and making Purple Rain part two, he’d turned around and put out a strange psychedelic record that confused half his fans and delighted the other half.
He’d just come back from the south of France where he’d spent the summer and early fall shooting a black and white movie that he was directing himself, and he almost never did television interviews, almost never. He didn’t trust talk shows. He didn’t like being asked about himself. He’d turned down Johnny Carson by one count four separate times.
So, what was he doing at NBC Studio 1 on a Thursday afternoon in November? The official story, the one that went around the building that afternoon, was that he was there to play one song, no interview, no couch. He’d walk out, perform, and leave. His management had arranged it through Warner Brothers, which was his record label, too, and the whole thing had been kept so quiet that even the show’s own staff hadn’t been told until that morning.
Prince didn’t want his name in the TV Guide listing. He didn’t want a crowd waiting outside. He wanted to walk in, do his work, and disappear the same way he did everything. But, there was another story, a quieter one, that people who worked at Warner Brothers in those days tell. And the other story goes like this. When Prince found out that Miles Davis had signed with his label, he’d called the head of the company himself personally, which he almost never did.
And the only thing he asked was whether Miles was going to be on the Carson show and when. And when he was told the date, he said, “Then that’s the night I’ll do it.” Nobody asked him why. At Warner Brothers in 1985, you didn’t ask Prince why. This story is about to take a turn nobody expected. If you love stories about the legends of music and the moments nobody saw coming, take a second right now to hit that subscribe button and turn on notifications, because what happened on that stage a few hours later is something people who were in that room
still talk about 40 years on. Now, here’s where it starts to get interesting. Miles Davis’s dressing room was at the far end of the hallway, the biggest one they had, and he’d asked for three things to be in it. A bowl of fruit, which he didn’t eat, a bottle of Perrier, which he did drink, and no mirror.
That last one confused the staff for most of the afternoon until somebody finally just draped a towel over the one bolted to the wall. He sat in there with the door half open, smoking and running his fingers along the valves of his trumpet without actually playing it. And every so often, someone would walk past and he’d watch them go by without moving his head.
At about 5:15, a young talent coordinator named Lisa, who’d been at the show for less than a year, came hurrying down the hall with an armful of papers, talking to one of the associate producers, and she was excited, and she wasn’t keeping her voice down. “I still can’t believe he actually showed up. Four times he said no, four times.
And now he’s just sitting in there, cool as anything, like it’s nothing.” The producer laughed and said something about the man being the most talented musician alive, and that he’d heard he could play every instrument ever invented, and that the band guys were already nervous. Miles’ head turned. “Who?” he whispered. They didn’t hear him, so he said it again, louder, which for Miles wasn’t very loud at all, but there was something in it that stopped both of them dead in the middle of the hallway.
“Who’s the most talented musician alive?” Lisa went pale. She’d been told very clearly not to bother Mr. Davis. She stepped into the doorway and said carefully, “Prince, Mr. Davis. He’s doing a song tonight. It’s a surprise. It wasn’t on the schedule.” Miles took a long drag on his cigarette and let the smoke out through his nose.
He was quiet for so long that Lisa thought maybe that was the end of the conversation. Then he said, “The little cat with the high heels.” It wasn’t a question. “Yes, sir. The one that plays everything.” “That’s what they say, sir.” Miles nodded slowly. He looked down at the trumpet in his lap, turning it a little so the light from the makeup bulbs slid along the bell, and he said something that Lisa wrote down in her notebook that night because she had a feeling she’d want to remember it.
“Everybody plays everything now,” he said. “Guitar, drums, piano, all of it, all by themselves on a tape machine. That ain’t the same as playing. You can play a hundred instruments and never say one true thing on any of them.” He looked up at her. “Where’s he at?” “Two doors down, Mr. Davis.” “Mhm,” said Miles, and that was all he said. Now, it’s important to say this plainly.
Miles Davis had heard Prince’s music. Of course he had. It was 1985, and you couldn’t turn on a radio in America without hearing Prince. And the truth, which came out years later, is that Miles had already been listening a lot more closely than he let anybody know. But that afternoon in that hallway, what Miles was feeling wasn’t curiosity.
It was something closer to a wound, because here’s what Miles had been hearing for five years. That he was old, that he was over, that he’d lost it, sold out, chased the young kids and their pop charts and their electric toys because he didn’t have anything left of his own. And now here was the young kid himself, the biggest pop star on the planet, two doors down in the same building, on the same night, on the same record label, being called the most talented musician alive by a producer who probably couldn’t name three songs off Kind of
Blue. He sat with that for a while, and the longer he sat with it, the more the cigarette burned down between his fingers without him noticing. About 20 minutes later, there was a knock on the half-open door. Miles looked up and standing there in the hallway, all 5 ft 2 in of him, hands in the pockets of that long dark coat, was Prince.
He didn’t come in. He didn’t say anything clever. He just stood in the doorway, and when he spoke, his voice was quiet, too. Not a rasp like Miles’s, but soft, almost shy, with that flat Minnesota edge to it. “Mr. Davis.” Miles looked at him for a good long while. He looked at the coat, at the hair, at the thin mustache, and then slowly and deliberately, he looked all the way down at the boots.
“Nice shoes,” he whispered. It could have been a compliment. It wasn’t. Prince didn’t blink. “Thank you.” “Your people tell you to come say hello.” “No, sir. Nobody told me anything.” “Then what you want?” Prince was quiet for a second, and then he said, “I just wanted to see your face, that’s all. I’ve seen it on record covers my whole life.
I wanted to see if it was real.” Miles took his sunglasses off. It was the first time he’d taken them off since he got out of the car. His eyes were red around the edges and tired and older than the rest of him somehow. “It’s real,” he said. “Real old, real tired. You’ve seen it now.” And he put the glasses back on and turned back to his trumpet.
And Prince understood that was the end of it. He nodded once, said, “Thank you, sir,” and walked back down the hallway, and his boots clicked on the linoleum all the way to his own door. Lisa, who had watched the whole thing from the other end of the hall, said later that it was the strangest 30 seconds she had ever seen in show business.
Two of the most famous musicians alive standing 6 ft apart, and neither of them raised his voice above a whisper, and it felt like watching two men circle each other in a boxing ring. What nobody in that hallway knew, and what Prince had never told a single journalist in his life, was why he really wanted to see Miles Davis’s face.
To understand that, you have to go back to a small house in North Minneapolis in the early 1960s, and to a man named John the 50th Nelson. John Nelson was a jazz piano player, a good one by every account. Though he never got anywhere near famous, he worked a day job at a Honeywell plant, and at night, under the name Prince Rogers, he led a jazz trio that played the clubs on the north side of town.
And that’s where he met a singer named Mattie Shaw, who became his wife and Prince’s mother. They named their son after the band, Prince Rogers Nelson. His father’s stage name handed down like a watch. His father was a hard man in a lot of ways, quiet, proud, stubborn. He didn’t talk much, and when he did, it was usually about music.
He kept the family piano in the front room, and nobody was allowed to touch it. And nobody did, except for one person. When his father was out of the house, the little boy would sneak into that front room and sit on the piano bench with his feet hanging a foot off the floor, and pick out the melodies of the television theme songs he’d heard that week.
Batman, The Man from U.N.C.L.E., anything with a tune in it. And his father had a record collection, not a big one, but a serious one. Duke Ellington, Thelonious Monk, and Miles Davis, especially Miles Davis. There was one record in particular with a picture on the cover of a man with his eyes closed and a trumpet at his lips that his father played so often, the grooves went gray, kind of blue.
Prince told a friend once, years later, that the first time he remembered seeing his father’s face do something soft, something almost like crying, was listening to that record. His father was sitting in his chair with his eyes closed, and the first two tracks went by, and then the slow ballad after them came on, a thing called Blue and Green, and his father’s whole face just loosened up like somebody had cut a string holding it tight.
And the little boy sitting on the floor watching him thought, “Whatever that is, whatever that man on the record is doing, I want to be able to do that to somebody.” When Prince was seven, his parents split up. When he was 10, he went to live with his father for a while, and then things fell apart there, too.
And at some point, his father put him out of the house. He bounced around after that, an aunt’s place, a friend’s basement. He was a skinny, quiet, very small kid who didn’t fit in anywhere and didn’t try to. And the only thing he had that nobody could take away from him was music. He taught himself guitar. He taught himself drums.
He taught himself bass. By the time he was in high school, he could play just about anything you put in front of him, and people started using that phrase about him that would follow him for the rest of his life. He plays everything. But there was one instrument he never played in public, not once, not in his high school bands, not in the studio, not on any of his records. And the reason was simple.
It was the instrument the man on his father’s record played. In the eighth grade at Bryant Junior High, there was a beat-up old school trumpet in the band room that nobody used with a dent in the bell and a sticky third valve. And the band teacher, a patient man who noticed that the Nelson kid hung around the music room after school when he had nowhere else to go, let him take it home over a summer.
He never officially signed it out. Prince kept it for the better part of two years. He’d practice in the basement where he was staying with a sock stuffed in the bell so nobody upstairs would hear. And he’d put that gray, worn-out copy of Kind of Blue, which he’d taken from his father’s house when he left and never given back, on a cheap record player, and he’d try to play along. Try to find the notes.
Try to find the space between the notes, which was harder. He never got good enough to be happy with it. That’s what he told himself. He could make it sound like a trumpet, but he couldn’t make it sound like that, like the man on the record. And so, he never let anybody hear it. Every other instrument he played, he played for the world.
That one he played only for himself and for a father who didn’t come around much anymore. When he left the school, he gave the trumpet back to the band room, but he never stopped. Over the years, when he finally had money, he bought a horn of his own, a good one, and he kept it in its case in his studio in Minneapolis.
And late at night, after the engineers had gone home and everybody else was asleep, he’d take it out and play for an hour or two with no tape running. Not one person outside a very small handful of people ever knew. Not his band, not his label, certainly not Johnny Carson, and certainly not Miles Davis. Now, back to Burbank. The taping started at 5:30 like it always did.
The audience filed into studio one, about 500 people, most of them tourists who’d gotten tickets that morning, and none of them had any idea what they were about to see. They’d been told Miles Davis was on the show, and a lot of them were older folks who were excited about that. There was a comedian booked and an actress from a popular primetime drama.
Nobody said a word about Prince. The band played the theme. Ed McMahon did the introduction, drawing out the words the way he always did. Here’s Johnny. And Johnny Carson walked out through the curtain, tugged his cuffs, grinned at the crowd, and did about eight minutes of monologue about the weather, the president, and a story in the paper about a man in Florida who tried to marry his own boat.
The actress went first, then the comedian, and then at the break before the third segment, Johnny leaned over to Doc Severinsen, who was standing up at the bandstand in a jacket with more sequins than a Las Vegas stage curtain, and said something that the cameras didn’t catch, but that Doc remembered for years.
Doc, I’ve been waiting for this one since I was 25 years old. If he walks off this set in the first five minutes, I’m blaming you. Doc laughed. Why me? Because you’re the other trumpet player in the building. He’ll smell the competition. They came back from the break, and Johnny did the introduction himself.
He didn’t read it off a card. He’d written it himself that afternoon, which he almost never did. My next guest, he said, is a man who has changed the sound of American music more times than most of us have changed our minds. He played with Charlie Parker when he was 19. He made records in the 1950s that people are still trying to figure out.
He’s recording for a new label now, and he’s got a new album on the way. And I am telling you it is an honor to have him on this program. Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Miles Davis. The band struck up a few bars of something bluesy and cool, and the curtain moved, and Miles walked out. He walked very slowly. The hip he had the cane in one hand and the trumpet case in the other, and he didn’t hurry for anybody, not even for Johnny Carson and 500 people clapping.
When he got to the desk, Johnny stood up and reached out to shake his hand, and Miles set the case down on the floor, shifted the cane, and gave Johnny’s hand one short dry shake. Then he sat down on the couch, laid the cane across his knees, and looked out at the audience through those enormous sunglasses without a flicker of expression.
The applause died down, and it got very quiet. Johnny, who had talked to presidents and astronauts and zoo animals, and who was maybe the best in the world at putting a nervous guest at ease, took one look at him and seemed to decide the best thing to do was just be honest. Miles, he said, I have to tell you I’m a little nervous.
Miles tilted his head. Why? Because I’ve been listening to you since I was in my 20s, and you have a reputation. What reputation? For not suffering fools. There was a long pause, and then Miles leaned in toward the microphone on the desk, and in that sandpaper whisper he said, then you better not be one. The audience laughed.
Johnny laughed hardest of all, slapping the desk, and just like that, the ice cracked a little. They talked. They talked for longer than anyone had planned because the segment was going well, and the producers didn’t want to interrupt it. Johnny asked about East St. Louis, where Miles grew up. And Miles told him his father was a dentist, a well-off man who owned a farm, and that he got his first trumpet on his 13th birthday, and that his mother had wanted him to play the violin.
Why didn’t you? Johnny asked. Violin don’t sound like anything, Miles said. Sounds like somebody crying in a closet. Trumpet sounds like somebody crying on a street corner. Everybody can hear it. Johnny asked about the boxing because Miles was famous for training at a gym every day.
And Miles said boxing was the same thing as music. It was about rhythm and about knowing when not to throw a punch and that the best boxers and the best musicians were the ones who could stand in front of you perfectly still and scare you to death with what they weren’t doing. Johnny asked him about his paintings because in those years Miles had started painting bright, wild, twisting figures.
And Miles said he painted in the mornings because it kept his hands busy and kept him from doing other things with them he didn’t want to do anymore. He said it very plainly and everybody in the room understood what he meant and nobody laughed. And Johnny just nodded and let it be. And then Johnny asked him about the new music.
You’ve taken some heat, Johnny said carefully, from the jazz people for playing some of these pop songs, the Cyndi Lauper tune, the Michael Jackson tune. Some of the critics weren’t too happy. Miles shrugged, a small, slow shrug. Critics ain’t never been happy. They wasn’t happy in 1949. They wasn’t happy in 59. They wasn’t happy in 69.
If they ever get happy, I’m doing something wrong. The audience clapped. But why those songs? Johnny pressed. What is it about them? Miles thought about it. A good melody is a good melody, he said. Don’t matter who wrote it. Don’t matter if the kids like it. People act like I owe them something.
Like I got to keep playing the same thing I played 30 years ago so they can feel young. I ain’t a museum. I ain’t nobody’s jukebox. And here Johnny made a decision. It was a small one and he probably didn’t think twice about it at the time. He’d been told that Prince was in the building and that he’d be playing one song at the end of the show and that it was a surprise.
And since the audience didn’t know, he figured it would be a fun little tease. Well, speaking of the kids, Johnny said smiling, I don’t know if you know this, Miles, but we have a surprise guest tonight. Someone else who’s on your new record label. Someone who I’m told plays just about every instrument there is.
The audience started buzzing. A few people shouted out guesses. Miles didn’t move. He didn’t even turn his head. He just sat very still for a moment. And the people sitting in the front rows said afterward they could see his jaw tighten under the curls. I know who you’re talking about, he said. Little cats here. I seen him.
You’ve met? We met in the hallway. Miles paused. He was wearing heels. The audience roared. Johnny laughed and put his hand over his face. And if the whole thing had stopped right there, it would have been a funny little moment. One of a thousand on that show, forgotten by next week. But it didn’t stop there, because Miles wasn’t finished.
Before we go any further, if you’re enjoying this story so far, let us know in the comments where you’re watching from and whether you’ve ever heard Miles Davis play live. We read every single one, and it helps these stories reach more people who love this music as much as we do. Miles picked the cane up off his knees and set it on the floor very slowly.
Then he leaned forward, both elbows on his knees, and he looked at Johnny, and then he looked out at the audience. And when he spoke, the whole room leaned in to hear. Everybody says he plays everything, Miles said. That’s what I keep hearing. Plays everything. Guitar, piano, drums, bass, whole record by himself. Most talented musician alive.
One of your people told me today. He let that hang in the air for a moment. Well, I got a question for him. Can he play this? And he reached down to the floor, flipped the two latches on that battered black case with the tape across one of them, and lifted out his trumpet. It caught the studio lights, and a little murmur went through the audience because it was a beautiful thing, gleaming and custom, with his name engraved along the side of the bell. He didn’t hand it to anyone.
He just held it up. Everybody plays everything, he whispered. Let’s see him play the one thing that matters. It was a silence you only get once or twice in a lifetime in a television studio. Johnny Carson, who could fill any dead air in the world with a single look, didn’t say a word. Ed McMahon was frozen with his coffee mug halfway to his mouth.
Up on the bandstand, Doc Severinsen had gone completely still, and every musician in the NBC orchestra was looking at each other because they knew exactly what was happening. It was a dare, and it was more than a dare. Everybody who knew anything about music understood it at once. Miles Davis was saying in front of 500 people and millions more watching at home that this pop kid who played everything couldn’t play the hardest instrument in the room, that all those instruments he played were toys, that when it came to the trumpet, the instrument that you can’t
fake, the instrument that shows every flaw in your breath and your lips and your heart, the little cat in the heels would fall flat on his face, and he was saying it to mock him, plain and simple. Everyone in that room could hear it. Johnny finally found his voice. He laughed a little nervously and said, “Well, Miles, I don’t know if he’s even I don’t know if that’s” And from somewhere off to the left of the stage, behind the curtain where the next guest would normally wait, a soft, flat Minnesota voice said, “It’s okay,
Johnny.” Every head in the studio turned. Prince walked out. He hadn’t been announced. The band didn’t play him on. He just came out from behind the curtain alone in that long dark coat with the high collar and the heeled boots and walked across that stage at his own pace with every camera in the building swinging around to find him.
The audience lost its mind. People jumped out of their seats. A woman in the third row screamed so loud that one of the sound men yanked his headphones off. Nobody had known he was there, and now here he was, Prince in person on The Tonight Show, walking toward Miles Davis like a gunfighter walking down the middle of a dirt street.
He stopped about 4 feet from the couch. Miles didn’t get up. He just sat there holding the trumpet, looking at him through the sunglasses. The screaming went on for almost a full minute before it started to settle down, and all that time neither of them said a word or moved. They just looked at each other, and the people in the front row said later that there wasn’t any anger in Prince’s face at all, no embarrassment, no fear.
If anything, he looked calm, almost peaceful, like a man who’d been waiting for a phone call for 20 years, and it had finally rung. When the room was quiet enough, Prince spoke. “I heard you, Mr. Davis.” “I figured you did. You want me to play?” “I want you to try.” A few people in the audience laughed nervously. Prince didn’t.
“Okay,” he said, and then very gently, very respectfully, he said something that surprised everyone. “But not on yours.” Miles’ eyebrows went up above the rim of the sunglasses. “That’s your horn,” Prince said. “That’s your voice. I wouldn’t put my mouth on that. Nobody should.” He turned and looked up at the band. “Mr.
Severson, could I borrow yours?” Doc Severson told this story for the rest of his life. He said he’d been playing the trumpet professionally since he was a teenager, and he’d played in front of kings and presidents, and he’d never in his life felt his hands shake the way they shook when he climbed down off that bandstand holding his horn.
He walked across the stage and held it out. It was a big, bright, beautiful instrument, and Doc said the strangest thing happened when Prince took it from him. He didn’t grab it like a guitar player grabs a trumpet, awkwardly, like it’s a lamp. He took it the right way, left hand wrapped around the valve casing, right hand fingers settling onto the valves as easy as if they’d been there a thousand times.
He waited in his hands for a second. He pressed each valve down once, feeling them, listening to them, and then he looked up at Doc. “Do you have a Harmon mute?” Doc said that was the moment he knew right there. That was when the hair on his arms stood up. A Harmon mute is a small metal cup that fits into the bell of a trumpet and changes its voice completely.
It takes the bright brassy blast out of it and turns it into something closer, thinner, more private, like someone talking to you from the next room. And it was the sound of one man above all others, the sound on Kind of Blue, the sound on Round Midnight, the sound that half the world thought of when they heard the word jazz. It was Miles Davis’s sound.
Doc went back to the band and found one in his case. And when he handed it to Prince Miles, who hadn’t moved a muscle this whole time, slowly took off his sunglasses and set them down on Johnny’s desk. Johnny Carson noticed. He told a writer years later that watching Miles take those glasses off was the moment he realized something real was about to happen on his show, something that had nothing to do with television.
“You sure about this, son?” Johnny said quietly to Prince off mic, though one of the boom microphones caught it anyway. Prince fitted the mute into the bell of Doc’s trumpet, gave it a small twist to seat it, and nodded. “I’ve been sure since I was 12,” he said. Nobody knew what that meant, not yet.
Now, what happened next? The people who were in Studio One that night still describe the same way, and it’s worth telling slowly because this is where everything turns. And if you want to hear exactly how it turns, stay right here with us because the next few minutes are the reason this story has been passed around for decades.
Prince walked to the center of the stage. He didn’t ask for the band. He didn’t ask for a spotlight. He stood on the spot where the comedians usually stood to do their bits, about 15 ft from Miles facing him, not the audience. He turned his back almost completely on 500 people and all three cameras, so that the only person he was playing for was the old man on the couch.
Then he closed his eyes, and for a long moment, he didn’t play anything at all. 5 seconds, 10, 15. The audience started to shift in their seats. Somebody coughed. Up on the bandstand, a young saxophone player named Pete leaned over to the drummer and whispered, “He’s choking. He’s frozen.” And the drummer, an older man who’d been playing jazz since before Pete was born, shook his head without taking his eyes off Prince.
“No, he ain’t,” the drummer whispered back. “Listen.” Because the silence wasn’t empty. That was the thing. Anybody who knew what they were hearing understood that the silence was the first note. It was the oldest trick Miles Davis ever taught the world, the famous line that’s been hung on him for decades, that it isn’t about the notes you play, it’s about the notes you don’t.
Prince was standing there in front of the man who built a whole career on that idea, and before he played one single sound, he was playing it back to him. Then he lifted the horn, took a breath that you could see move his whole small body, and played one note, just one. It was long and low and soft with that mute making it sound far away, like something drifting across a river at night.
He held it until it almost ran out, and right at the end he let it bend down just a little, not much, just a sigh at the end of it, the way someone’s voice cracks when they’re trying not to cry, and almost make it. Then he stopped and waited again. In the front row, a woman in her 60s put her hand over her mouth.
Then he played three notes, then two more, then a long silence, then a short climbing phrase that seemed to ask a question and never quite answer it. It wasn’t fast, it wasn’t flashy. There wasn’t one single piece of showing off in it. He didn’t run up to any screaming high notes the way a lot of young trumpet players would have, trying to prove something.
He didn’t do a single trick. He just played slowly and sadly and sweetly and with enormous space all around every phrase, the way you talk to someone in a hospital room when there isn’t much left to say. Doc Severinsen, who knew the trumpet better than almost anyone alive, said afterward that it wasn’t a technical performance.
Prince’s tone wasn’t perfect, it wobbled once or twice. There was a spot about a minute in where a note came out a little thin, and a lesser player would have panicked and started rushing to cover it. Prince didn’t. He just let it be thin, and then he let the next note be full. And somehow the thin one ended up sounding like it had been on purpose all along.
He wasn’t playing the trumpet, Doc said, he was playing Miles. He’d studied that man so long he’d learned how to think like him, and he was standing there showing him. Johnny Carson sat behind his desk with his chin on his hand, completely still. He didn’t look at the camera once. The director up in the control room said later that he had a whole plan for cutting between shots during the performance, and he threw it out the window about 20 seconds in and just left the camera on Prince’s back and Miles’ face because nothing else in
the world mattered. In Miles’ face, everybody who was there talks about Miles’ face. At first, he just watched, arms crossed, head tilted, that same stony, unreadable expression he’d worn since he walked out. The face of a man waiting for the other shoe to drop. About 30 seconds in, his arms came uncrossed.
About a minute in, he leaned forward a little, and then Prince did something that made Miles Davis, for the only time anybody could remember, visibly flinch. He started playing a melody very quietly, hiding it in the middle of his own phrases at first, so you almost couldn’t tell. Then, more clearly, it was a slow tune, a ballad, one of the most famous ballads in all of jazz from that same old record with the man with his eyes closed on the cover, and Prince wasn’t playing it the way everybody plays it.
He was playing it exactly note for note, breath for breath, the way Miles had played it in a New York studio in the spring of 1959. Every pause in the same place, every little bend in the same place, as if he’d listened to that record 10,000 times with a sock in the bell of a dented school trumpet in a basement in Minneapolis trying to learn how to make a hard man’s face go soft, which of course he had.
Miles sat back hard against the couch like someone had pushed him. People in the audience were crying openly now, not just one or two, dozens. The old jazz fans who’d come to see Miles and knew that melody the way they knew their own children’s names, and the young Prince fans who’d never heard it in their lives and didn’t need to know what it was to feel what it was doing to them.
Ed McMahon had put down his coffee mug and was just staring at the floor, and Prince, with his eyes still closed and his back to the whole world, played the last phrase of that melody. And then, instead of ending it the way the record ends, he let it trail off unfinished, hanging there like a sentence somebody started and couldn’t finish. He lowered the trumpet.
For about 3 seconds, nobody in that studio made a single sound, and then the place came apart. We’ll get to what Miles said in just a moment, but first, if this story has moved you even a little bit, hit that like button because it helps more than you’d think, and share it with someone who grew up with this music.
Somebody in your life needs to hear this one. The audience was on its feet, every single person screaming, clapping, crying. The band was on its feet up on the bandstand, and the older drummer was pounding a rim shot over and over with one stick, and shouting something nobody could hear.
Johnny Carson was standing behind his desk, clapping with his hands up over his head, which almost no one had ever seen him do for a musical guest. And through all of it, Prince just stood there in the middle of the stage, holding Doc’s trumpet down at his side, and looked at Miles. Miles hadn’t moved.
He was sitting on the couch with his hands flat on his knees, and his mouth slightly open, and he was looking back at Prince. And for a long time, his face was absolutely blank, like the face of a man who has just walked outside and found the house he grew up in still standing on a street where it shouldn’t be. Slowly, the noise died down.
It took a long time, and when it was finally quiet enough, everyone looked at Miles because everyone understood that whatever happened next was up to him. Miles picked up his cane from the floor. He planted it, and he stood up slowly, painfully, with that bad hip, while the whole room held its breath. He picked up his own trumpet from the couch cushion, and he walked across that stage, one careful step at a time, until he was standing right in front of Prince.
The height difference wasn’t much, and both of them were thin as rails, and for a moment the two of them just stood there looking at each other up close under the lights. Then Miles leaned in and said something to him, quietly off the microphones, and the boom couldn’t catch it.
And for years, nobody but the two of them knew what it was. Prince gave one small nod. Then he did something nobody expected. He handed Doc’s trumpet back up to Doc, who’d come down to the edge of the stage, and he walked over to the upright piano that the band kept at the side of the set for the occasional musical guest, and he sat down on the bench, and he started to play soft chords, slow, dark jazz chords.
His hands moving over the keys so easily, it looked like the piano was playing itself. They were his father’s kind of chords. Those old minor voicings that Johnny Nelson used to play in the clubs on the north side of Minneapolis, the ones his son used to hear through the floor when he was supposed to be asleep.
It was the same ballad he just played on the horn, only now he wasn’t playing the melody. He was playing the ground underneath the melody, and he was leaving a big wide empty space right on top of it. He looked up at Miles. He was offering it to him. And Miles Davis, 59 years old, the man with the bad hip and the ruined voice, the man everyone said was finished, lifted his own trumpet to his lips with the Harmon mute already in it, and stepped into that space.
What happened over the next 4 minutes has never been released. The master tape of that night’s show, like a lot of Tonight Show tapes from that era, was either lost or recorded over. And the only proof that it happened is the memories of the people who were there. But every single one of them tells the same story.
They say Miles played like he hadn’t played in 10 years. They say it was like watching a man get his body back. The same slow ballad, but Miles playing it his own way now, starting where Prince had left the melody hanging unfinished, and carrying it the rest of the way home. Prince sat beneath him at the piano, following every movement, making space for every breath, never once getting in his way.
The two exchanged quiet glances. At one moment, Miles suddenly stopped playing halfway through a phrase, and left the empty space entirely to Prince on the keys. When he returned, he was smiling, genuinely smiling, his eyes closed. No one at the Tonight Show could remember the last time they had witnessed Miles Davis smile like that in public.
Near the end, Doc Severinsen, standing near the edge of the stage with his own horn, quietly removed the mute from Prince’s old place on the piano lid, placed it inside his own bell, and added one soft harmony note beneath them. Just one, held low and gentle, almost like a third friend quietly joining the table.
Miles looked toward him and gave the smallest nod, and when the music ended, it ended exactly as Miles preferred. There was no dramatic finale, no crashing chords, only one final trumpet note stretching longer and longer, fading into the mute until nobody could tell whether the sound was still there or merely being imagined.
Prince held one quiet chord beneath it until the final second, then silence. Miles lowered his horn. For the first time that evening, he turned completely toward the audience and actually faced them. In the silence, speaking into the closest microphone with that rough whisper that could make hundreds of people freeze, he said, “I asked him to play the one thing that matters.” He motioned toward the piano.
He did. Then, after waiting a moment, he added so softly that the sound man had to raise the levels completely to hear him, “I was wrong about the shoes, too.” That brought the loudest laugh of the entire night. It was the kind of laugh people make after crying, when they need somewhere to release it.
Prince, still sitting at the piano, lowered his face into his hands and laughed with them. It was the only moment anyone on the NBC staff that year remembered seeing him laugh that openly. Johnny Carson stepped out from behind his desk, something he almost never did during the program, and shook both of their hands.
Then, while the cameras were still recording, he did another thing he rarely did. He turned toward the audience and said, “Folks, I’ve been doing this show for 23 years. I’ve never witnessed anything like that, and I don’t believe I ever will again.” They went to commercial. They had no choice.
Nobody was ready for the next segment. The actress scheduled to return for one final conversation was standing backstage with mascara running down her face, while a stage manager rushed around trying to find tissues. And for most people, that would be where the story finished. But something almost nobody knows happened roughly half an hour later, after the taping ended and the audience had left, inside a small dressing room at the far end of that long hallway, if you’re still here, you’re the kind of viewer who wants the entire story and we truly appreciate
that. Subscribe if you haven’t already because this final part is the one that matters most. After the show ended, the halls of Studio One remained crowded with people who weren’t ready to leave. Stagehands, musicians, producers, and crew members stood around in small groups speaking quietly about what they had just witnessed the same way people behave after a wedding or something shocking.
Miles returned to his dressing room, placed a towel over the mirror, and shut the door. Prince went back to his own room. His bodyguard remained outside. People passed by wanting to knock and say something, but the bodyguard gently shook his head each time. Around 20 minutes later, Miles opened his door and stepped into the hallway, cane in one hand and trumpet case in the other.
Slowly, he walked the two doors down toward where Prince’s bodyguard was standing. The bodyguard looked at him. Miles looked back. “Tell him Miles is here,” Miles whispered. The bodyguard never got the chance to tell him. The door opened from the inside before he could turn. Prince stood there wearing a simple white shirt with his long coat tossed over a chair behind him. He had removed the boots.
Standing only in his socks, he looked even smaller, younger, and completely exhausted. “Come in,” he said. Miles entered, the door closed, and for the next hour and a half, nobody knew exactly what happened inside. Most of what became known came from Prince many years afterward during a rare lengthy conversation with a musician friend late one night at his Minnesota studio.
Other pieces came from Miles, who mentioned the night briefly to his co-writer while preparing his autobiography. The two versions fit together like matching pieces of a torn photograph. Miles sat in the only armchair. Prince sat on the floor with his back against the wall and his knees drawn up the same way he had once sat in the front room in Minneapolis while his father played records.
For several minutes, neither man spoke. Miles lit a cigarette. Prince didn’t smoke and disliked the smoke, but he said nothing. Then Miles asked, “Where’d you learn that?” Prince told him everything. He talked about the battered school trumpet at Bryant Junior High, the sticky third valve, the sock placed inside the bell, the basement, and the worn gray copy of Kind of Blue with the man whose eyes were closed on the cover, the record he had taken from his father’s house when he left and never returned.
He told him how his father’s expression would soften whenever that record played, how it was the only time he could remember seeing that softness, and how he had spent years trying to learn how to create that feeling in someone else. “Did you ever,” Miles asked, “do it to him?” Prince remained silent for a long time. “I don’t know,” he finally said.
“He still plays piano. He’s still up there in Minneapolis. We don’t talk much. He came to one of my shows, and afterward he told me I played too many notes.” Prince gave a small laugh. “That was the entire review. Too many notes.” Miles let smoke escape through his nose. It might have been a laugh. “Your daddy’s right.
I know he is. Played too many notes tonight, too. Couple places.” “I know, but not many,” Miles said. “Not many.” Then Miles told Prince his own story. He spoke about his father, Dr. Miles Dewey Davis, the dentist from East St. Louis, a proud and educated man who owned land and horses and wanted his son to become somebody.
His father, not his mother, had given him his first trumpet on his 13th birthday. His father was also the one who told him, when Miles was still a teenager and had gone to New York to study at Juilliard before leaving to follow Charlie Parker through the jazz clubs of 52nd Street, “Don’t you ever let anybody tell you what you’re worth.
” He talked about how his father died in 1962 and how Miles wasn’t there. He had been traveling and performing, received the phone call in a hotel room, then hung up and went to the club and played that night’s gig anyway because that was what he told himself his father would have wanted.
“I played for him that night,” Miles said. “Didn’t tell nobody. Just played for him. Played a ballad. Nobody in that club knew.” Prince, sitting on the floor, spoke quietly. “That’s what I did tonight.” Miles looked at him. “I played for my father tonight,” Prince said. “That part at the end where I didn’t finish the melody, that was intentional.
That’s where he’d always lift the needle from the record every time. He never let it play all the way through. I never understood why. I always wanted to hear how it ended.” He shrugged. “Tonight, you finished it.” Miles remained silent for a long moment. Then he slowly rose from the armchair, leaning on his cane as his bad hip complained with every movement, and opened his trumpet case on the floor beside Prince.
From a small pocket inside the lid, he removed a Harmon mute. It was old, slightly dented, smooth along the edges, and darkened by years of use. He held it toward Prince. “I played Kind of Blue with this one,” he said. “Spring of ’59, 30th Street Studio. Every note on that record passed through this.” Prince stared at it but didn’t take it. “I can’t take that.
” “You ain’t taking it. I’m giving it.” “Mr. Davis, that’s Miles.” Prince swallowed. “Miles, that belongs in a museum.” “I told Johnny tonight I ain’t a museum.” Miles placed the mute into Prince’s hands and closed Prince’s fingers around it with his own long, thin fingers. “And neither are you. Don’t you ever let them turn you into one.
Everybody’s going to want you to play Purple Rain for the rest of your life. Same as they want me to play the same old things. So what? Same notes every night until you die. Don’t you let them. You hear me? Soon as you know how to play something, stop playing it and go find something you don’t know how to play yet.
” Prince later said it was the greatest advice he had ever received and that he spent the rest of his life trying to live by it. Then Miles said one final thing, the sentence Prince would later repeat word for word to that same friend during their late-night studio conversation. The friend said Prince’s voice cracked slightly when he remembered it.
Miles stood over him, leaning on the cane, and said, “You know the difference between a man who plays everything and a man who can play. The man who plays everything is trying to fill every bit of silence in the room because he’s afraid of it. The man who can play, he isn’t afraid of silence anymore. He knows it’s his.
He tapped the mute in Prince’s hand with one long finger. You weren’t afraid tonight. First time I saw you, you were scared in that hallway. I could smell it. Tonight, you weren’t. That’s how I knew. Then he picked up his case, walked toward the door, and stopped with his hand on the knob.
And what I said to you out there on the stage before you went to the piano. Prince nodded. I meant it, Miles said, and walked away. For years, nobody knew what those words had been. Miles never repeated them. Prince never repeated them either. Not until that late night in his studio when his friend finally found the courage to ask. Prince thought about it for a long time before smiling slightly.
Then he said, your daddy would have let it play all the way through tonight. Now, if you’re wondering whether that friendship continued beyond that strange night in Burbank, the answer is one part of this story that can actually be traced. It lasted for the rest of Miles Davis’s life. In the months that followed, the two began calling each other, usually late at night, because that was when both of them were awake.
Miles would call Prince at his Minnesota studio around 3:00 in the morning and sometimes say absolutely nothing. He would simply hold the phone near a tape player so Prince could hear something Miles was working on, then hang up. Prince did the same in return. Sometimes those calls lasted an hour with almost no conversation at all.
At Warner Brothers, they began discussing the possibility of making music together. Prince wrote songs for Miles. He sent him tapes. During the work on the album Miles was preparing in 1986, the project that became Tutu, Prince wrote and recorded a funky playful track. Miles came in and recorded trumpet over it, and for a while the track was expected to appear on the album.
In the end, Prince withdrew it himself because he didn’t believe it was finished enough. That was simply how he worked, but the tape survived, and there were more sessions afterward. By some accounts, dozens of recordings, most of which the public has never heard even today. In his autobiography, published in 1989, Miles wrote about Prince in a way he rarely wrote about any other living musician.
He said Prince could become the Duke Ellington of their generation. He said Prince carried something that reminded him of the church, James Brown, Marvin Gaye, and Jimi Hendrix all at once. But underneath all of that, Miles heard something more important, a musician who understood silence.
Coming from Miles Davis, a man who spent his career refusing to praise almost anyone, those words landed with enormous force. Then, on New Year’s Eve in 1987, at Prince’s own studio complex outside Minneapolis, Paisley Park, Prince hosted a benefit concert. Shortly after midnight, with the new year only moments old, a thin figure wearing enormous sunglasses slowly walked onto the stage with a cane in one hand and a trumpet in the other.
The crowd erupted. Miles Davis and Prince performed together live in front of a paying audience for the first and only time that was ever filmed. Prince played guitar, then keyboards, smiling like a child on Christmas morning. Miles played with force and brightness, his head tilted back.
People who were there later said that during the middle of the jam, Miles walked toward Prince, pointed his horn directly at him, and played one slow, soft, bending note. Prince stopped playing guitar, closed his eyes, and simply stood there while the sound moved over him. Nobody else in the audience understood the reason, but now you do.
Miles Davis died on September 28th, 1991 in Santa Monica, California. He was 65 years old. During the final years of his life, he performed more concerts, painted more artwork, and created more new music than he had during the previous decade, and he never returned to repeating the same old material simply to make people comfortable.
Prince was recording when the news reached him. The engineer working that night said Prince stopped the tape, sat completely still for a long time, and then asked everyone else to leave the room. They waited outside. After some time, they heard something none of them had ever heard inside that studio before.
A trumpet with a mute playing a slow ballad. He played it from beginning to end. Years later, someone asked Prince during an interview who the greatest musician he had ever met was. By then, he had met nearly everyone. He had performed alongside countless musicians, but he didn’t hesitate even for a second. Miles, he said, and not because of what he played, but because of what he didn’t.
He taught me that the most important note is the one you’re brave enough to leave out. I think about that every time I pick something up, every single time. When the interviewer asked if he would ever play trumpet publicly again, Prince simply smiled. I did it once, he said, for the only person who needed to hear it. That was enough.
Prince died in April of 2016 at Paisley Park, the same place where he and Miles had shared that New Year’s Eve performance nearly three decades earlier. During the long months afterward, as people searched through his vault, his studio, and the thousands of things left behind, someone discovered an old trumpet case tucked away inside a closet in one of the rehearsal rooms.