News

Married to Her Uncle at 15, Dead at 21 – The Tragic Life of the Habsburg Girl in the Famous Painting

 

In Vienna in March of 1673, the Holy Roman Empress was 21 years old and pregnant for the seventh time in barely 6 years of marriage. She fell ill with a chest infection on top of an old swelling in her neck and on the 12th of March, she died. A Swedish envoy reported that people at court commonly called it a piece of luck for the dynasty.

Within four months, her widowerower, who was also her uncle, had named his next bride. And the dead empress was the little girl at the center of the famous painting Las Maninas. Her name was Margarita. And to understand how she ended up dead in Vienna at 21, you have to go back to Madrid to a king who had run out of sons. The king was Philip IVth of Spain.

In 1646, his only legitimate son and heir, a teenage prince named Baltasar Carlos, died. Philip still had a daughter from his first marriage, the Infanta Maria Teresa. But a daughter was not what a Spanish king wanted on the throne, and Philillip was a widowerower. He needed a new wife, and he needed sons.

So, he married his niece. Her name was Mariana of Austria. She was the daughter of Philip’s own sister and of the Austrian emperor which made the new queen of Spain her husband’s blood relative before she was ever his wife. She was nearly 30 years younger than Philillip when the marriage took place in 1649. Mariana was 14.

Keep that number in mind. A girl of 14 married to her uncle for the good of the family. It will come back. This kind of match was not a scandal at the Spanish court. It was policy. The Habsburgs ruled two great blocks of Europe through two branches of the same family, one in Madrid and one in Vienna.

For generations, those two branches had married each other again and again so that crowns, lands, and claims stayed inside the house. Uncles married nieces. Cousins married cousins. Nobody in the royal correspondence of the time treated it as a problem worth discussing. Mariana did what she had been brought to Madrid to do and quickly.

On the 12th of July 1651 in the royal Alcazar, the old fortress palace that served as the court in Madrid, she gave birth to her first child. It was a girl. Over the next 10 years, Mariana would give birth to four more children, and only one of them would live to grow up. They named her Margarita Maria Teresa.

She was not the son the kingdom was waiting for and in a court obsessed with succession that mattered. And yet everything we know about her early years suggests that she was adored. Her father, a king in his mid-40s who had already buried an heir, wrote about her in his private letters. Historians who have worked with that correspondence report that he called her my joy.

According to the same accounts, her parents and those close to the family called her their little angel. Her maternal grandfather, the emperor Ferdinand III in Vienna, is also said to have doted on her from a distance. She grew up in the queen’s apartments of the Alcazar, surrounded by ladies, maids, and servants.

She was brought up under the rigid etiquette of the Spanish court, which governed how a royal child stood, ate, walked, and greeted people. and she was given a good education. At least once as a small child, she fell seriously ill and survived. Contemporaries described her as pretty and lively. Despite her parents’ close blood relationship, she did not show the serious health problems that her younger brother would have from birth.

So, this is a loved child, but it’s worth noticing what kind of love it was. In Spain, a woman could inherit the crown. That meant every royal daughter was a reserve heir. If the sons failed, the throne could pass through her to her husband and her children. And in 1651, the sons had failed. Margarita’s father had no legitimate son at all.

The only children who could inherit were two girls. Maria Theresa from his first marriage, who was 13 years older, and the new baby. In practical terms, that made little Margarita far more than a beloved daughter. She was a piece in the inheritance of the Spanish crown itself. Whoever married her might one day have a claim to Spain.

Her parents understood that from the start. As modern historians reconstruct it, Philip and Mariana decided while she was still a small child that Margarita would marry a relative from the Austrian branch of the family. That way, if her rights to the Spanish crown ever became real, they would pass to another Habsburg and not to a French or English rival.

The joy of the family was also its insurance policy, and the decision about her husband was made while she was still in the nursery. In fact, Philillip would wait until 1657 for another son for 6 years. That little girl was one of only two children who could carry his crown. There was one more complication, and it sat right inside that family.

The obvious Austrian husband was a young man in Vienna named Leopold. He was Mariana’s younger brother, which made him Margarita’s uncle. His mother had been Philip’s sister, which also made him her first cousin. The same man filled both slots in her family tree, and he was 11 years older than she was. None of that seemed to bother anyone involved at the time.

What happened next was not a wedding. It was something slower and stranger. For years, the court in Madrid would keep commissioning pictures of this little girl, and some of those pictures would be sent across Europe to Vienna so that the man she was meant to marry could watch her grow up. Stories like margaritas rarely make it into the textbooks, and this channel exists to tell them.

Subscribing means the hidden lives behind royal portraits will not pass you by. Now back to Madrid where the first of those portraits was being painted. The man painting those pictures was Diego Velasquez, the king’s court painter, and he had come back to Madrid shortly before Margarita was born.

His first known portrait of her dates from around 1653. She is about 2 years old, already posed in fullcourt dress like a miniature adult, and it was not made only for her parents. That portrait ended up in Vienna and it still hangs there today in the Kunistoishes Museum. Then in 1656 when Margarita was five, Velasquez painted the picture that would make her face one of the most recognizable in the history of art.

It is a huge canvas more than 3 m tall. The scene is a real room in the Alcaza, the Cuatau del Principe. In the middle stands Margarita, small, pale, and blonde, in a wide court dress. Two young ladies of the queen’s household bend toward her. One is Maria Augugustina Samento. The other is Isabel Develasco. These were the queen’s maids of honor.

And in the Spanish of the court, a maid of honor was called a manina. Around them is a whole little world of palace life. On the right stand two court dwarfs, Mari Barbala and Nicolasito Pertisato, and the boy is teasing a big mastiff that lies there patiently. Behind them, the lady in waiting, Marcela de Oyoa, stands beside an attendant.

At the back, in an open doorway, the chamberlain, Joseé Nietto, is caught on the threshold. And on the left, holding his brush in front of an enormous canvas whose front we never see, is Velasquez himself. Then there’s the mirror. On the back wall hangs a small mirror and in it are two faces, King Phillip and Queen Mariana. Her parents are not really in the picture at all.

They are a reflection as if standing exactly where you, the viewer, stand. We know who almost all these people are because an early biographer of Spanish painters, Antonio Palamino, named them in 1724. The Praau Museum, where the painting hangs today, describes the moment as one in which the infant and her servants pause as the king and queen arrive.

Art historians have spent centuries arguing about what the picture means. Is it about the act of painting, about seeing, about the painters’s own status at court? One line of study has focused on something much simpler. The royal status of the little girl in the center. The whole room is organized around her.

That’s worth holding on to because of what this child was for. The same year Velasquez painted Las Maninus, he produced another portrait of Margarita, this time in a dress of white and silver. It did not stay in Madrid. It went to Vienna, too. And 3 years later, in 1659, he painted her again. Now she was 8 years old, posed in a deep blue dress.

Historians who have studied these portraits see a change between them. The later images show a more mature and formal child, a little girl being presented as a future empress. That portrait was made for Leopold together with a portrait of her baby brother and it too went to Vienna. The Habsburg Heritage Project in Vienna describes the purpose of this series plainly.

The portraits were intended to document the development of the imperial bride. Liupold, in other words, was receiving progress reports in oil paint on his niece. It sounds bizarre to us, and it should, but for royal families who might not meet their future spouses for years, portraits did real diplomatic work.

They showed health, growth, rank, and suitability. A child who looked well was a child who might survive long enough to marry and have children of her own. In this family, there was never something anyone could take for granted. Here’s why. After Margarita, Mariana kept having children. Between 1655 and 1661, she gave birth to four more, a daughter and three sons.

Only one of them would survive to adulthood. In November 1657, she finally gave Philillip the son he had been waiting for, a boy named Felipe Prospero. But the little prince was sickly for much of his short life, and in his portrait by Velasquez, he looks small and delicate. Geneticists have since tried to measure what generations of close marriages did to this family.

In 2009, a team of Spanish researchers calculated what’s called an inbreeding coefficient, a number estimating how much of a person’s genetic makeup comes from shared ancestors. For Margarita’s younger brother, the future king Charles II, they arrived at a figure of 0.254. That is close to the level expected in the child of a parent and child or of a brother and sister.

The same researchers estimated that Mariana herself, Margarita’s mother, had the highest figure of any Spanish Habsburg queen they studied. Because Margarita had exactly the same parents, that calculation applies to her family background as well. but careful. The same study did not examine Margarita herself, and nothing in it proves that her later health problems came from inbreeding.

What the researchers did find was a pattern across the dynasty. Using earlier historical work, they noted that of 34 children born to Spanish royal families between 1527 and 1661, half died before the age of 10. So every portrait sent to Vienna carried a quiet message. She is still alive. She is still growing. The bargain still holds.

There is one more detail about Las Maniness to remember. For much of its life, the painting was not called by the name we use now, and the way it was labeled in the royal inventories would change in a way that says a great deal about how quickly Margarita could be forgotten. We’ll come back to that. Velasquez himself died in 1660.

It was the same year that the question of whom Margarita would marry was finally settled. Here’s the twist. Margarita was not Vienna’s first choice. The original plan had been to marry Leopold to her older halfsister Maria Teresa that would have tied the two branches of the family together through Philip’s eldest daughter.

But Spain was also trying to end a long war with France. The peace settlement known as the Treaty of the Pyrenees came with a marriage attached. In 1660, Maria Teresa was married to the young King Lewis the 14th of France instead. As part of that deal, Maria Teresa renounced her claims to the Spanish throne. In exchange, Spain promised France a dowy.

It was never paid. Hold on to that detail, too, because it will matter enormously decades after everyone in this chapter is dead. With the older sister gone to Paris, Vienna turned to the younger one. In February 1660, Leopold formally asked Philip and Mariana for Margarita’s hand. In April, they accepted.

Margarita was 8 years old. Liupold was already 19. So, who was the man waiting on the other end of all those portraits? Leopold had never been meant to rule. He was a youngest son, and he had been raised and educated for a career in the church. Then in 1654, his older brother, the heir to the imperial throne, died. Liupold was pulled out of his religious training and pushed into the line of succession.

In 1658, at 18, he was elected Holy Roman Emperor. He was pious and passionately musical, a ruler who would later compose music for his own court festivities. and he was, let’s say it slowly one more time, the brother of Margarita’s mother and the son of her father’s sister, her uncle, and her first cousin. If you’re expecting someone at the time to have objected, you’ll be disappointed.

Historians who have worked through the family letters and diplomatic reports note that the Hapsburgs, the foreign ambassadors, and the Spanish ministers all discussed this match without any sign of unease. To them, it was simply the best match available. The Holy Roman Emperor held one of the most prestigious titles in Europe.

Philip and Mariana wanted it badly, and their private correspondence with a nun named Sor Maria de Agrada, a longtime confident of the king, shows how strongly they wished for it. There was still some uncertainty. Even after the engagement, rumors circulated, recorded in the diaries of a cardinal at the imperial court, that Margarita might instead marry Leopold’s younger brother, Archduke Charles Joseph.

Under that scenario, if Spain’s own heir died, the couple might end up ruling Spain together. The rumors came to nothing. But the fact that they existed tells you how people thought about her. Margarita was a route to the Spanish crown and the only question was which Habsburg would travel down it. Then in November 1661, the family suffered a double shock.

On the 1st of November, the frail little prince Felipe Prospero died. He was 3 years old. 5 days later, on the 6th, Mariana gave birth to another son, the future Charles II. In less than a week, the queen buried one heir and delivered another. The new baby was weak from the start. From his birth, he showed the serious health problems that would follow him for the rest of his life.

And that made Margarita’s position even more delicate. If this sickly boy did not survive, she could be the next ruler of Spain. In 1662, Liupold sent a new ambassador to Madrid, Count Ping, whose main task was to bring this marriage home. On the 6th of April 1663, the engagement was officially announced to the public.

A month later, Philip wrote again to Saw Maria describing his happiness at the news. Margarita was 11. The marriage contract was signed in Madrid on the 18th of December 1663. According to her modern biographer, it was concluded for the preservation and growth of the Catholic cause. It promised a dowy.

Like her sisters, that dowy was never paid. But there was one difference between the two sisters contracts, and it was huge. Unlike Maria Theresa, Margarita was not asked to give up her rights to the Spanish throne. The same biographer calls this a political sensation across Europe. The Spanish branch of the family now hung on one sickly little boy.

Behind him stood his sister, and behind her, through marriage, stood Vienna. One historian has pointed to a portrait of Margarita painted around 1665 by Francisco Ruiz delegia in which she holds a small clock. The suggestion is that it marks the day and hour the marriage contract was signed. It’s an interpretation, not a proven fact, but it fits the way her childhood was measured in signatures and dates. And then Spain stalled.

Leopold kept pressing for his bride to be sent. Madrid kept finding reasons to wait. Part of it was her age, but part of it, as historians have argued, was the obvious problem. If Charles died and Margarita was already in Vienna, Spain’s heir would be living in a foreign court. On the 17th of September 1665, Philip IV died.

His will confirmed the marriage to Liupold, and it said something remarkable. If young Charles died, Margarita would inherit the Spanish crown. If she and her husband were abroad, Mariana would govern for them. Charles was now king at 3 years old, and Mariana became regent. Her German confessor, a Jesuit named Johan Ebahard Nidhard, pushed hard for the wedding to finally go ahead and the government confirmed it.

Before Margarita left, the court painter Juan Bautista Martinez del Mazo painted her one more time. She is dressed in black in mourning for her father with small figures in similar sober clothing in the background. Scholars think it was painted so that Madrid would keep an image of her as she looked just before she left forever. She was 14.

On the 25th of April 1666, Margarita was married in the Alcazar in Madrid. The groom was not even there. This was a marriage by proxy, a common arrangement for royal brides who lived far from their husbands. Someone stood in for the absent groom. The vows were exchanged and the marriage became legally binding.

Liupold’s standin was a Spanish nobleman, the Duke of Medineli. The ceremony was attended by the widowed queen Mariana, by the little king Charles, by the imperial ambassador, and by the nobility of the court. That date matters for the title of this story. Margarita’s birthday was in July. So when she was legally married to her uncle, she was actually still 14.

She would turn 15 on the road and she would be 15 when she finally stood beside him. 3 days after the ceremony on the 28th of April, she left Madrid with her personal household. As far as the record shows, she would never see the city again. She would never again see her mother or her little brother, the king.

The journey to Vienna took seven months. The first stage took her east to the port of Denia on the Mediterranean coast. She stayed there for weeks while the fleet was prepared. On the 12th of July, still waiting at Denya, she turned 15. Four days later on the 16th she boarded the Spanish royal fleet escorted by ships from the Knights of Malta and from the Grand Duchy of Tuskanyany.

It was not a smooth start. The fleet made a short stop at Barcelona because Margarita was unwell. Even so, the city put on celebrations for her and an account of the festivities was printed and sold that same year. Everywhere she went, she was not only a passenger, she was an event. On the 20th of August, the fleet reached Finalei, a Spanishc controlled port on the coast of northern Italy.

There she was received by the governor of Milan. On the 1st of September, the procession set out overland, reaching Milan 10 days later. Her official entry into the city was staged on the 15th of September, and she spent most of that month there. Then the procession moved on through Venetian territory and in early October it reached Trento in the mountains.

At every stop there were ceremonies, receptions and festivities in her honor. She had grown up almost entirely inside the Alcazar. Now whole cities were turning out for her. But from here on Spain started falling away. On the 8th of October at the town of Roaretto, the Duke of Albuquerque, who had led her Spanish escort, formerly handed Margarita over to Liupole’s representatives.

A senior Austrian courtier, Prince Dietrichstein, and Cardinal Harak, the Prince Bishop of Trento. Spain gave her up and the emperor’s people received her. She was now officially in imperial hands. On the 20th of October, the new Austrian procession left Roarretto and began the long crossing of the Alps through the Tiroll through Corinthia and through Styria.

And then over the summering pass toward Vienna, autumn was turning into winter. In late November, the procession reached the small town of Shotin, not far from Vienna. And there, the emperor himself rode out to meet his bride. Think about what that meeting actually was. For six years, Liupold had known Margarita as a series of paintings.

He had watched her grow from a toddler into a girl in a blue dress. The traffic in pictures had gone the other way, too. Liupold had sent his own court painter, the Brussels born Gerard Duchhateau, to Madrid, telling his ambassador the man had painted the emperor in large and small formats. Duchhateau painted Margarita there too, and one portrait of her shows her holding a small medallion bearing her future husband’s image.

That was likely the closest she had come to him. Now she was 15, and standing in front of him, he was 26. We don’t have a reliable description of what was said or how either of them reacted at Shopvian, and it would be dishonest to invent one. What we do have is what happened next. On the 5th of December 1666, Margarita made her formal entry into Vienna.

Sources disagree on whether the church ceremony confirming the marriage took place that same day or a week later. So, the safest thing to say is this. In early December in the Imperial capital, the girl from Las Maninas was married in person to her uncle. Accounts of her entry were printed for audiences far beyond Austria.

One of them was published that same year in Granada in the south of Spain. The procession into the city was engraved in enormous detail, numbered figure by figure, so that people could study who rode where. And then came the fireworks. According to Vienna’s Habsburg Heritage Project, the wedding festivities opened with a fireworks display accompanied by cannon fire.

Glittering hearts surrounded the initials L and M for Liupold and Margarita. Then 300 rockets lit up the sky to spell out the letters A, E, I, O, U. That was an old Habsburg motto. Five vowels whose exact meaning people still debate, but whose message that night was obvious enough. This family and this marriage were meant to last.

It is very easy from where we sit to find all of this deeply disturbing. A teenage girl legally married at 14, handed across a border like a treaty delivered to her mother’s younger brother. Every part of that is real. But here’s the complication. When you look at what survives from the years right after the wedding, the picture that emerges is not one of misery.

The letters, the court records, and even the private jokes suggest something that surprises most people who hear this story for the first time. By most accounts, the marriage worked. And Vienna was about to throw a party that would last for almost 2 years. Let’s start with what they called each other. Throughout their marriage, Margarita called Leopold uncle.

She used the German word uncle. He called her Gretle, a homely German nickname for Margaret. Both of those details come down to us through later historians rather than a single famous letter, but they are widely repeated and fit everything else we know. They also shared a language and it wasn’t German.

According to a study published in 2022, Leopold had learned Castellian Spanish out of consideration for his future wife, and the two of them communicated in it privately. They shared a passion for music and theater, too. Liupold was a composer as well as an emperor and the court he was building around his bride was meant to be a stage.

In January 1667, it literally became one. On the 24th of January, the great courtyard of the Hofberg, the imperial palace in Vienna was turned into an arena for a horse ballet called the contest of air and water. This was a huge choreographed performance on horseback with music, costumes, and elaborate stage machinery.

According to Vienna’s Hapsburg Heritage Project, it was intended to outshine the great festivities at Versailles. Leopold himself took part riding his horse Sparanza. Ingenious machinery made it look as if horses and carriages were floating into the air. So that’s the public picture. a young emperor, a teenage empress and spectacle on a scale meant to impress all of Europe.

But the most important news of that spring was much quieter. At the end of March 1667, Margarita appeared in public to go to mass. She was carried in a sedan chair and she was not wearing her garden fonte, the enormous hooped frame that gave Spanish court dresses their famous width. The message was unmistakable. She was pregnant.

We know about this because a Spanish noble woman, the Countess of Castellar, described the outing in a letter written on the 28th of March. 2 days later, Leopold himself wrote to his ambassador in Madrid describing the same appearance again. He wanted the news in Madrid. A pregnancy, especially in the first year, mattered enormously for a royal consort.

As the historian who studied these letters points out, an empress’s position at court was secured once she proved she could conceive legitimate heirs. For Margarita at 15, this was the first real proof of her value in Vienna. In early July, another letter to Madrid reported her delight at having felt the baby move.

And then around her 16th birthday, on the 12th of July 1667, Margarita wrote Leopold a note. It survives today in the Hapsburg family archives in Vienna and it is the most intimate document we have from her. She didn’t write it in her own voice. She wrote it in the voice of the unborn baby. The note opens with the words, “Lord and my father.

” The writer explains that although his father doesn’t know him yet, he has heard the news of what’s happening in Vienna. That the emperor is about to celebrate his mother’s birthday. The baby says he is envious that he can’t attend the party himself. So he asks the emperor to let Margarita take part in the choir in his name. Then comes a small, very human line.

The baby assures his father that the color of a sash his mother wore was not a sign of jealousy, but simply chosen to match the emperor’s own clothes. The scholar who published the note explains that in Spanish court theater, blue was the color of jealousy. So even this playful little letter was smoothing over some tiny marital misunderstanding about a ribbon.

The baby admits he doesn’t yet have a courtier’s polished speech, but promises he will be born speaking like a good son. He prays that God will keep the emperor safe as his mother and he both need. And he signs off in English roughly from my lodging and your majesty’s son who kisses your feet. It’s a funny, clever, flirtatious note from a 16-year-old wife who was clearly enjoying her pregnancy and enjoying teasing her husband.

Whatever we think of how this marriage was made, this does not read like a frightened girl writing to a stranger. The historian who published it sees in these few lines a warm and intimate bond between uncle and niece. That same year, both Margarita and Liupold posed for portraits dressed in theatrical costumes.

These were two people who like dressing up, putting on performances, and making a show of their life together. On the 28th of September 1667, Margarita gave birth to a son. They named him Ferdinand Wel. After all the portraits, contracts, treaties, and journeys, the marriage had produced exactly what it was supposed to produce, an heir.

He lived for less than four months. In January 1668, the little archduke died. Sources differ by one day on the exact date, but not on the outcome. The boy who had written to his father from inside his mother, at least in her imagination, was gone. And here’s what makes that little letter so affecting. The historian who published it notes that the note was kept.

It survived the death of the son who supposedly wrote it. It survived the death of the mother who actually wrote it. Someone in that family held on to it. Only weeks later, on the 23rd of February 1668, a fire broke out in the new wing of the Hofberg, the part of the palace Leupold had been building. The fire was serious enough that the emperor himself had to be rescued.

The wing would have to be rebuilt. For Margarita, her first 14 months in Vienna had brought a wedding, a party, a son, a grave, and a fire. She was 16. The court’s answer to grief was more spectacle, and the biggest spectacle of all was being prepared for her next birthday. The opera was called Il Pomo Doro, the Golden Apple.

It had originally been planned for the wedding itself, but a production this ambitious took time. It finally premiered in July 1668, staged across two days in the middle of the month to celebrate Margarita’s 17th birthday. The music was by the Italian composer Antonio Cesti with additional music written by Leopold himself.

The sets were designed by the court’s theatrical architect, Lovico Bernacini. And to stage it, Leopold had a brand new opera house built on the Cortina, a stretch of the city walls near the Imperial Palace. It could hold up to 5,000 people. The story was built around a golden apple, and the entire production was designed as a tribute to the bride.

According to Vienna’s Habsburg Heritage Project, no expense or material was spared. There were crowd scenes and even live elephants. Contemporaries called it the staging of the century. One modern German account puts the cost at a 100,000 golden and the running time at around 9 hours. Whatever the exact figures, her modern biographer calls it the most important musical theater event of its time.

All of that for a 17-year-old girl who 6 months earlier had buried her first child. It would be easy to read the opera only as a distraction from grief and it may partly have been. But it was also politics. Spectacle like this told Europe that the Hapsburgs in Vienna were rich, cultured, and permanent.

And it told everyone at court where the emperor stood at the center. 6 months later, she gave that court something it valued even more than opera. On the 18th of January 1669, Margarita gave birth to a daughter. They named her Maria Antonia. And this baby lived. For the first time, Margarita had a child who survived infancy.

A little later, a court painter named Jan Thomas painted Margarita with her small daughter beside her. In the end, that girl would be the only one of her children to grow up. So, by now, Margarita was a wife, an empress, a mother, and a patron of the most lavish court theater in Europe. She was also, according to her modern biographer, a spirited and intelligent young woman.

Diplomatic reports suggest she surprised people in Vienna with her poise. One Spanish historian even took an Italian phrase as the title for her study of these years. Young in years, but old in judgment. But underneath all that, a problem had been building since the day she arrived. Margarita had come to Vienna, but she had never really left Spain.

She was surrounded almost entirely by Spaniards. Her secretaries were Spanish. Her confessors were Spanish. Her doctors were Spanish. She loved Spanish music and Spanish ballet. And according to her biographers, she barely learned German. With Liupold, she spoke Spanish. At court, the common language was Italian. Hers was a household within the imperial household, a little piece of Madrid sitting inside the Hofberg.

That is not hard to understand. She had been taken from home at 14, and the people around her were the last link to everything familiar. But Vienna did not see it that way. According to later Austrian historians, the Spanish entourage was seen at court as aloof and arrogant. Resentment against them grew into a broader anti- Spanish mood, and that mood spread to the empress herself.

To many in Vienna, the empress and her people looked like foreigners with no intention of becoming anything else. There was also the question of her health. Her modern biographer records that Margarita had suffered since her youth from a stru. That’s an old medical word for a goiter, a swelling of the thyroid gland in the neck.

One Austrian reference work goes further and says that by the end of her life, she was visibly disfigured by it. We don’t have a doctor’s notes, so we can’t say how large the swelling was, what caused it, or how much it affected her dayto-day, but it was recorded and it was noticed. And to be clear, no source links that go to her parents’ close relationship.

A thyroid swelling can have many causes, and nobody ever recorded which one applied to her. This is the swelling in her neck that was mentioned at the very beginning of this story. Keep it in mind because it will matter at the end. And then there’s one more detail which changes how all those years of fireworks and operas look.

According to the same modern biographer, even while Margarita was alive, Liupold kept open the option of marrying another relative, Arch Duchess Claudia Felicitus from the Tyian branch of the Hapsburg family. The reason given is blunt. Apart from one daughter, Margarita had not given him children who could survive. And an emperor without a son was a dynasty in danger.

Now, we should be careful about what that does and doesn’t mean. It doesn’t mean Liupole didn’t love his wife. Everything else we have suggests he did. It doesn’t prove there was a formal agreement or that anyone told Margarita. What it means is that the dynasty had a backup plan. And the backup plan was a second bride waiting in the wings in case the first one failed.

For a young woman whose whole life had been organized around being someone’s backup plan, there’s a bitter symmetry in that. She had been Spain’s insurance policy as a child. Now Vienna had taken out insurance against her. In the summer of 1669, Margarita was 18. She had one living daughter, a dead son, a husband who by all accounts loved her, and a court that increasingly resented her, and soon she was pregnant again.

That pregnancy would end in February 1670. And what Margarita did in the days around it is the part of her story that is almost never told alongside the pretty little girl in Lasmanus. Most retellings of Lasmanus stop at the little girl in the wide dress. This channel follows the royal lives that museum labels and textbooks leave out.

So subscribing keeps those stories coming to you. Now back to Vienna in February 1670. On the 20th of February 1670, Margarita went into labor far too early. The baby was a boy. They named him Yan Leopold. He was born and he died on the same day. That was her second son lost in 2 years. and the birth itself was dangerous for her too.

According to her modern biographer in Germany’s National Biographical Dictionary, it was during this premature delivery that Margarita made a vow. If she survived, she would have the Jews expelled from the city and from the land. That is a single scholarly account, and it should be presented as one. But another major reference work, the Encyclopedia Judeica, tells a closely related story.

According to its entry on Leopold, Margarita saw the toleration of Jews in Vienna as the reason her firstborn son had died in 1668. The two accounts differ on the exact moment that turned her grief into a demand. They agree on the demand. To understand it, you need context. Vienna had a Jewish community and it had lived for decades in a separate quarter across an arm of the Danube in an area called the Entra word.

Back in 1624, Jews had been ordered to move their homes there. By 1670, it held hundreds of families with their own houses and synagogues. They lived there because the emperors permitted it, and that permission could be withdrawn. Liupold had actually confirmed Jewish protections earlier in his reign, ordering in 1660, 1665, and even 1669 that Jewish lives and property be protected.

One Austrian reference work notes that a first wave of expulsions had already begun in 1669. In 1670, under pressure, he withdrew the protection completely. It would be too simple to say that Margarita alone caused what happened next. The sources point to several forces pushing in the same direction. The city of Vienna asked for the Jews to be expelled.

Students had been rioting against the Jewish community. A powerful churchman, Bishop Leopold Carl von Cololinich, agitated against them. Various misfortunes in the city were unjustly blamed on Jews. And Leopold himself, raised for a career in the church, held deeply ultra-atholic views of his own. According to the encyclopedia Judeaica, he was also weighing complaints from Protestants in Hungary who argued that they were treated worse than the Jews.

The same encyclopedia says the pope even intervened against the expulsion. It went ahead anyway. In 2020, the arch dascese of Vienna marks the 350th anniversary of these events. In its statement, it listed the causes behind the emperor’s decision. student riots, the agitation of clergy and of bishop colony, misfortunes unjustly blamed on Jews, and the anti-Jewish attitude of Leopold’s wife, Margarita Theresa.

So, she was not the only reason, but she is named again and again by historians and by the church itself as one of the reasons. The decree was harsh and simple. Every Jew in Vienna had to leave. The deadline was set for the 26th of July 1670. Families who had lived in the quarter for generations had to sell or abandon whatever they could not take with them.

Leopold, according to that encyclopedia, swore an oath never to let them back. What happened to their quarter afterward was meant as a statement. The great synagogue was torn down. Her biographer connects this to the feast of Corpus Christi that summer, one of the great Catholic processions of the year.

On its site, a Catholic church was built and dedicated to St. Leopold, the emperor’s own patron saint, and the district itself was renamed. The Unter word became the Leopoldstat, Leopold’s town. It still carries that name today. It is Vienna’s second district. Now, think about who we are talking about. The girl at the center of Las Meninas, the one her father called his joy, the empress who wrote a playful birthday note to her husband in the voice of their unborn baby, was 18 years old in 1670.

She had lost two sons. She was a devout Catholic raised in Spain, the kingdom whose rulers had expelled its own Jews in 1492. And by the account of her own biographer, she turned her grief and her fear into a vow that cost hundreds of families their homes. Both of those things are true at the same time.

She was a teenager who had been married off as a child, who kept losing babies and who lived in a court that resented her. And she was also, by the weight of the evidence, one of the people who pushed for a mass expulsion of innocent people from their city. Her own suffering does not cancel out theirs. The expulsion does not erase what happened to her.

There’s a coder to this and it shows how quickly the oath bent when money was involved. Within a few years, wealthy Jewish financiers were allowed back to serve the court. One of them, Samuel Oppenheimer, was readmitted in 1676 and went on to help finance Leopold’s wars. As for the emperor’s sworn oath never to readmit Jews, the Encyclopedia Judeica notes that theologians were found to solve that problem for him.

The ordinary families of the old quarter did not get the same treatment. They had to rebuild their lives somewhere else and their names almost never appear in the story of the girl from the painting. And in that anniversary year of 2020, the Archbishop of Vienna, Cardinal Kristoph Shernborn, asked every parish in the city to pray especially for Vienna’s Jews at Sunday mass as the city marked what had been done to them.

for Margarita herself. The vow brought nothing that she had prayed for. There was no healthy son. The expulsion did not change her luck in childbirth, her health, or her standing at court. If anything, the next two years would make all three worse. To see why Margarita’s pregnancies mattered so much, you have to look back to Madrid.

Her little brother, King Charles II, was now 9 years old, and their mother, Mariana, was ruling Spain as regent in his name. He had been weak since birth, and his health was a constant worry. If he died without children, the Spanish crown would not simply vanish. According to her father’s will, and to the marriage contract that had never asked her to give up her rights, it would pass to Margarita, and through her to her children.

So, every pregnancy in Vienna was being watched far beyond Vienna. As one historian of these years points out, news and rumors about the imperial pregnancies crossed back and forth between the courts of Spain, France, and Austria. Lewis I 14th in Paris was married to Margarita’s older sister and had his own interest in the Spanish inheritance.

Every baby Margarita carried was potentially a future king or queen of Spain. That is an enormous amount of pressure to place on a young woman’s body, and Margarita’s body was not cooperating. In fact, she was now repeating a pattern she had seen before she could understand it. A scholarly journal that studies this court has described her mother, Mariana’s first 12 years of marriage in Madrid as an unbroken chain of conceptions, miscarriages, and care for sickly children.

Now the daughter was living through the same thing in a foreign city at the same age her mother had been. Meanwhile the court around her was changing in a way that would shape how she was remembered. In 1671 a new diplomat arrived in Vienna Pufundorf sent by the king of Sweden. He would stay until 1674 and he wrote detailed reports home about Liupold his court and his politics.

Those reports were published in the 19th century and historians still use them. He was the older brother of the famous legal philosopher Samuel Pufandorf and in Vienna he was an outsider, a Protestant diplomat at a fiercely Catholic court writing for a foreign king who wanted to know how things really stood. Remember his name.

He is the one who will write the sentence quoted at the very start of this story. What did Margarita do in those years? She did what devout Habsburg women were expected to do and she did it in a very Spanish way. In 1672, she introduced into Vienna the veneration of a Spanish saint Peter of Alcantara, a Franciscan reformer who had been declared a saint only 3 years earlier.

At the Franciscan church in Vienna, she founded a chapel in his honor with an alterpiece by the painter Matus Managetta. In that painting, she appears herself together with Leopold and their daughter, Maria Antonia. Her 1990 biography still lists it in the choir chapel of that church. It is a family portrait placed inside a religious one, and the saint at its heart was imported from home in a city where her Spanish household was already resented.

That was not exactly a gesture of blending in. In February 1672, Margarita gave birth again. On the 9th of February, she had another daughter named Maria Anna. For 2 weeks, the Imperial family had two little girls. On the 23rd of February, the baby died. It’s worth stopping here to count because the numbers are the story.

Margarita had arrived in Vienna in December 1666. By early 1672, a little over 5 years later, she had given birth to four children. Ferdinand Wel, Maria Antonia, Johan Leopold, and Maria Anna. According to historians, she had also suffered two miscarriages, though their dates are not recorded in the sources we have. Counting those miscarriages, she had been pregnant six times since her wedding.

Of the four children born alive, only one survived. The children she lost had lived less than four months, a single day, and two weeks. Margarita was still only 20 years old and this was happening while her health was getting worse. The old goiter in her neck according to the Austrian reference work we heard about earlier was making her visibly weaker and was disfiguring her.

Now we come to the ugliest part of court life in these years. According to later Austrian historians, the hostility toward Margarita’s Spanish household had spread so far that courtiers no longer hid their feelings. They openly expressed the hope that the sickly empress would die soon so that Leopold could marry again.

One reference work names the bride they had in mind. Claudia Felicitas of the Tiroll, the same Arch Duchess Leupold had quietly kept in reserve. We should be precise about what that claim rests on. It comes from modern historians summarizing the atmosphere at court, not from a single quoted conversation that we can check.

But it fits what Pufandorf would later write and it fits what Liupold would later do. Think about Margarita’s position by the end of 1672. To Madrid, she was the next heir in line after a sickly little king. To Paris, she was a rival claimant to an empire. To Vienna’s dynasty, she was the woman who had to produce a son.

To many of Vienna’s courtiers, she was a foreigner who stood in the way of a better match to her husband. As far as the evidence shows, she was his beloved Gretle. All of those things were true at once, and all of them depended entirely on what happened in her body. Late in 1672, Margarita was pregnant again.

It was her seventh known pregnancy in 6 years of marriage. If it produced a healthy son, everything might change. Vienna would have its heir, the whispers might fade, and the claim to Spain would pass to a living, healthy boy. If it didn’t, many at court already had a replacement in mind. She was 21 years old when the new year began.

Early in 1673, Margarita was pregnant again, and by March, she was about 4 months along. Then she fell ill. According to her modern biographer, she caught bronchitis, an infection of the airways in the chest. On its own, that might have been something a young woman could survive. But Margarita was already weakened by six pregnancies in 6 years, and she had that old swelling in her neck, the goiter that had followed her since her youth.

Her biographer’s account of the end is brief and blunt. With the infection on top of everything else, he writes, she suffocated. He doesn’t spell out exactly how and we have no surviving doctor’s report to fill in the gaps. Doctors today know that a large goiter can narrow the windpipe, but whether that happened to Margarita, nobody can say from what survives.

So, the honest version is this. A pregnant woman with a long-standing thyroid swelling caught a serious chest infection and she could not breathe her way through it. On the 12th of March 1673 in the Hofberg in Vienna, Margarita died. She was 21 years old, 4 months short of her 22nd birthday. The child she was carrying died with her.

You will find other versions of her death if you go looking. Some popular accounts say she died in childbirth. Others say she died after a miscarriage. One scholar writing in passing in 2022 describes complications after her fourth delivery. But her biographer in Germany’s National Biographical Dictionary and the Imperial Crypt where she is buried both describe the same basic sequence.

An illness during her seventh pregnancy. That’s the version with the strongest support and it’s the one we followed. Some uncertainty remains and it’s only fair to say so plainly. Now remember the sentence from the very beginning of this story. Essias Pufendorf the Swedish envoy who had arrived in Vienna 2 years earlier reported on what people were saying after her death.

In translation his words were these. It was commonly held to be a piece of luck for the German Austrian line that God had taken this lady in the 21st year of her age. The German Austrian line meant the Austrian branch of the Habsburgs. And the logic behind that cold sentence is not hard to follow. Margarita had not given the dynasty a living son.

She had surrounded herself with Spaniards. She was the reason a Spanish claim hung over Vienna. And now the emperor was free to marry again. Consider who wrote this. Pufundorf was a foreign diplomat reporting the mood at court, not the emperor’s private feelings. He tells us what was being said in Vienna. He does not tell us what was said in Leopold’s rooms.

And on that we have a very different picture. According to her biographer, Liupold suffered deeply over her death. He mourned her as his unica margarita, his only margarita. The emperor who had watched her grow up in paintings, who had learned Spanish for her, who had staged the greatest opera of the age for her 17th birthday, was now a widowerower at 32 with a 4-year-old daughter.

Both of those things can be true. A husband can grieve sincerely, and the dynasty around him can see the same death as an opportunity. Margarita was laid to rest in the imperial crypt, the burial vault of the Hapsburgs beneath the Capachin church in Vienna. According to German reference sources, she was also one of the family members whose heart and inner organs were buried separately from the body in keeping with an old Habsburg custom that divided a royal corpse between three different sacred places in the city. Then the dynasty moved on, and

it moved quickly. About four months after her death, Leopold announced his decision to remarry. The bride was Claudia Felicitas of the Tier, the same Habsburg relative who had been kept in reserve while Margarita was still alive. That October, Leopold married her. Margarita had been dead for barely 7 months.

It’s worth repeating what that does and doesn’t prove. It does not prove Leopold didn’t love Margarita. Royal widowers in this period often remarried quickly as a matter of duty because without a son, the dynasty itself was in danger. But it does show how little space there was in this world for her death to be anything other than a problem to be solved.

There’s one more question here that needs a careful answer. Did inbreeding actually kill her? That claim gets made a lot. Here’s what the evidence actually supports. Geneticists have calculated very high inbreeding levels in her family and they have linked inbreeding in the Spanish Habsburg dynasty to unusually high child mortality across generations.

It is reasonable to wonder whether that background affected her children. But no study has examined Margarita herself and nothing in the sources proves that inbreeding caused her goer, her miscarriages or her death. What the sources do show is enough. Six pregnancies in six years beginning at 15.

Four children born, three dead in infancy, a thyroid swelling, a chest infection while pregnant again. That is a documented path to an early grave without inventing anything. Her death did not just end a marriage. It moved a claim. Under her father’s will and her marriage contract, Margarita had kept her rights to the Spanish throne. When she died, those rights did not die with her.

According to her biographer, they passed to Leupold. And through her, they passed to the one child she left behind, her four-year-old daughter, Maria Antonia. And think back to that playful little note from 1667 written in the voice of an unborn son to his father. Somebody kept it, even now that the son and the mother were both gone.

The story should end there with a young empress dead at 21. It doesn’t because she left a daughter and that daughter inherited far more than her mother’s claim. Maria Antonia grew up in Vienna as the only surviving child of Liupold’s first marriage. Through her mother, she carried a claim to the Spanish throne, and that made her one of the most valuable brides in Europe.

In 1685, at 16, she was married to Max Emanuel, the elector of Bavaria, one of the most powerful princes in the empire. On paper, it was a brilliant political match. It was not a fortunate one for her. Her first son was born in May 1689 and died 2 days later. Another child, born in November 1690, died immediately after birth.

Then in 1692, her husband was made governor of the Spanish Netherlands and went to Brussels. According to her modern biographer, the pregnant Maria Antonia did not follow him. She went home to her father in Vienna instead. There in the Hofberg on the 28th of October 1692, she gave birth to a son. They named him Joseph Ferdinand. He survived.

His mother did not. On the 24th of December 1692, about 2 months after the birth, Maria Antonia died in the Hofberg. It was Christmas Eve. She was 23. She was buried in the imperial crypt like her mother. Pause on that for a moment because the pattern is hard to miss. Mariana was married to her uncle at 14.

Her daughter Margarita was married to her uncle at 14 by proxy and 15 in person and died in the Hofberg at 21 while pregnant. Margarita’s daughter Maria Antonia died in the same palace at 23 weeks after giving birth. Three generations of women, each one a link in a chain of inheritance, and the chain kept wearing them out. But the inheritance itself was still alive in the baby.

Little Joseph Ferdinand of Bavaria now carried Margarita’s claim to Spain. And in Madrid, her brother, King Charles II, still had no children from either of his two marriages. As Charles’s health failed, the boy from Bavaria became one of the leading candidates for his throne, and he was named the designated heir to the Spanish monarchy.

On the 6th of February 1699 in Brussels, Joseph Ferdinand died. He was 6 years old. With him went the last chance that Margarita’s line would ever wear the Spanish crown. Charles II died on the 1st of November 1700. In his will, he named as his successor Philillip of Bourbon, a French prince. And who was Philillip? He was the grandson of Louis the 14th and of Maria Theresa, Margarita’s older halfsister, the sister who had renounced her rights to Spain. Leopold refused to accept it.

He claimed Spain for his own family, pointing to his marriage with Margarita and the rights she had never given up. According to her biographer, he pressed that claim for himself and for his sons from his third marriage. Margarita’s rights were now being used on behalf of another woman’s children.

The result was the War of the Spanish Succession, which tore across Europe from 1701 to 1714. When it was over, the Borbin prince kept the throne as Philip V. His family still reigns in Spain today. So, here is the final irony of the two sisters. The one who signed her rights away founded the next dynasty of Spain.

The one who kept her rights, the girl at the center of Las Maninas, left no line to carry them. And that brings us back to the painting. Remember how this painting was labeled? When Charles II died, the royal officials made a careful inventory of everything in the palace. The record of that inventory compiled between 1701 and 1703 describes Lasmaninus as a portrait of the lady empress infanta of Spain with her ladies and servants and a dwarf painted by Diego Velasquez who portrayed himself painting.

They valued it at 10,000 dubloons. That entry knew exactly who she was. The empress, the infant, who had left Madrid at 14 and died in Vienna at 21. Then the Bourbons took over. In 1747, after Philip V’s death, his collection in the new royal palace was inventoried again. This time the same painting was recorded as a portrait of Maria Teresa in Fanta of Spain, Queen of France, shown by Velasquez with the ladies who accompanied her.

They had given the little girl in the center of the painting her sister’s name. And not just any sister. The inventory identified the girl as the grandmother of the late king, the woman whose renunciation had not stopped her grandson from taking Spain. Whether it was a simple mistake or something more convenient, the record does not say.

But a quarter of a century later in 1772 under King Charles III, the inventory repeated the same error, Maria Teresa, Queen of France. By the early 19th century, palace records simply called it the family of Philip IV. Eventually, the painting moved into the new Praau Museum. In the museum’s inventory of 1857, the description correctly named the girl in the center as the infanta margarita, but the title had changed.

It was now described as the picture called Las Maninas, named not for her, but for the maids of honor bending toward her. Today, the Praau identifies her properly, and crowds stand in front of that canvas every day. Most of them know her face. Far fewer know her name. Fewer still know that she married her uncle, that she buried three of her children, that she is tied to the expulsion of Vienna’s Jews, or that the court she lived in called her death a piece of luck.

Her childhood portraits are still in Vienna in the Kestoish’s museum. They arrived in that city long before she did, sent so that a young emperor could watch his niece grow up. They are still there. She stayed only 6 years.

You Might Also Enjoy