Mahalia Jackson Refused to Sit Next to Elvis Presley — What Elvis Said Left Johnny Carson Frozen
The Night Mahalia Jackson Met Elvis Presley
On a Thursday evening in November 1969, Studio 6B on the sixth floor of Rockefeller Center was doing what it always did at a quarter past five, which was pretending that nothing unusual was about to happen. The band was running through a chart in the corner. A page was straightening the cue cards for the third time. And Johnny Carson was in his office with the door half open, going through the guest notes with a pencil, the way he had done every night for seven years.
The people who worked for him knew that this was the calmest the building would be all night. By half past seven, that calm would be gone. Because before the show was over, the most respected gospel singer in the world would rise from her seat in front of millions of people, walk to the far side of Johnny Carson’s desk, and refuse, politely and in front of everyone, to sit next to Elvis Presley.
And what Elvis said next would leave Johnny Carson, a man who had a line for everything, with nothing to say at all. Mahalia Jackson had arrived at four. She came in through the 49th Street entrance on the arm of Mildred Falls, the small, quiet woman who had been her piano player for more than 20 years and who did most of the worrying for both of them.
She was 58 years old. She was wearing a long, dark blue dress with a white collar, a small gold cross at her throat, and the kind of hat a woman wears to church when she intends to be noticed by God and not by men. Her heart had been giving her trouble for five years, and the doctors in Chicago had told her to rest, and she had told the doctors in Chicago that she would rest when the Lord told her to, and not a minute before.
She almost never did talk shows. When she did, she did them her way. By 1969, Mahalia Jackson was not just a singer, she was something closer to an institution. She had sung at the inauguration gala for President Kennedy. She had sung at Carnegie Hall when nobody believed a black woman from New Orleans singing church music could fill it, and she had filled it.
Six years earlier, on a hot August afternoon in Washington, she had stood on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial in front of a quarter of a million people and sung for them just before Martin Luther King walked to the microphone. And people who were close enough to hear said that it was Mahalia, standing behind him, who called out to him to tell them about the dream. Five years after that, she had sung at his funeral.
She had sold millions of records. She could have sold millions more. Because there was one thing about Mahalia Jackson that everyone in the music business knew, and that most of the public did not. She would not sing the blues, not once, not ever, not for any amount of money. Record companies had offered her fortunes to do it. She had turned every one of them down.
She had been raised in the Baptist church by an aunt in New Orleans who believed, with every bone in her body, that there was the Lord’s music and there was the other kind. And Mahalia had grown up believing that the blues were songs of despair and that gospel was the song of hope and that a woman had to choose which one she was going to give her life to. She had chosen.
She had never once looked back. And yet there was something else about Mahalia Jackson, something she almost never spoke about. A wound so old that even Mildred, who knew everything, rarely heard her mention it. It had happened in Chicago more than 30 years before, and it would come back to her that night on Johnny Carson’s couch in a way she would never have imagined.
In the dressing room, while Mildred pressed the creases out of the blue dress with her hands, one of the show’s producers knocked and came in with a clipboard and the careful smile of a man who had been sent to deliver news. He went over the shape of the evening with them, the new album, her trip to Europe, a little about her cooking because Johnny had heard she made the best red beans and rice north of the Mason-Dixon line. Nothing about politics, nothing about her health.
Keep it warm, the producer said. People just want to hear you laugh. Mahalia nodded and said nothing, which Mildred had learned over the years was not the same thing as agreement. What nobody told her was that there would be a second guest. The crew had seen something else. 90 minutes earlier, a tall man in a black overcoat with the collar turned up had come in through the freight elevator at the back of the building with two large men from Memphis walking in front of him and one walking behind.
The producers who met him spoke in the low voices they used for surprise walk-ons. The man asked for a glass of water and a quiet room, and he was given both at the end of the hall. He did not ask who the other guest was. He already knew. It was Elvis Presley. Elvis did not do talk shows. Everyone in the business knew that. For more than a decade, Colonel Tom Parker had kept him away from the couches and the chat and the easy laughter of late-night television because the Colonel believed and said often that people should never get Elvis for free.
If they wanted Elvis, they bought a ticket. They bought a record. They bought a seat in a movie theater. They did not get him sitting around talking like any other fellow. So, when the call had come a week earlier, a surprise walk-on, second segment, Johnny would introduce him without warning, and the other guest would be Mahalia Jackson.
The Colonel had laughed out loud and said, “Absolutely not.” Elvis had said, “Yes.” before the Colonel finished laughing. Priscilla had told him not to do it. “They’re putting you on to get a reaction.” she’d said, standing in the kitchen at Graceland with Lisa Marie on her hip. “You know what those people think of you. You’ll walk out, she’ll be polite, and somebody will make a joke about your hips, and you’ll look like a cheap thrill sitting next to a saint.” Elvis had thought about it for a long time.
“Mama loved her.” he said at last. That was all. Priscilla had looked at him and known there was no point arguing. So, now he was sitting in a small, bare room on the sixth floor of Rockefeller Center with a glass of water going warm in his hand, still wearing the overcoat because he had forgotten to take it off, with one knee bouncing the way it always did before he went in front of people, a thing he had never been able to stop, not even after 15 years.
Joe Esposito, his oldest friend in the group, sat across from him watching the clock. “You don’t have to go out there, E.” Joe said. “I know.” “You can still say no. I’ll tell them you got sick.” “I’m not sick.” “Nobody will check.” Elvis almost smiled. “I’m going out.” he said. “I just want to say hello to her. That’s all. Lisa’s going to grow up, and somebody’s going to tell her that her daddy sat next to Mahalia Jackson.
I want that to be true.” Neither of them had any idea what was about to happen. He was 34 years old, and 1969 had been the strangest year of his life. For most of the ’60s, he had been gone. Not gone from the charts, not entirely, but gone from the stage. He had spent eight years making movies, three a year, sometimes more. Then, a year earlier, almost by accident, he had gone back on television in a black leather suit and sat in a small square with his old friends and played guitar for an hour, like a man who had just remembered who he was.
Then, that summer, he had walked out on a stage in Las Vegas for the first time in nearly nine years, and the room had stood up before he sang a note. He was back. But, being back meant being looked at again, and being looked at again meant remembering exactly how he had been looked at the first time. Because there was something about 1956 that the young people who had just discovered him in Las Vegas did not know or had forgotten.
For a year and a half, much of America had believed that Elvis Presley was dangerous, not just a little wild, dangerous. Preachers stood in pulpits across the South and told their congregations that he was leading their children straight to hell. One minister in Florida called him a menace to Christian America. Newspapers ran editorials saying his music would destroy the morals of a generation.
Church groups held record burnings in parking lots, and teenagers who loved him were made to throw his records into the fire while their parents watched. A judge in Jacksonville threatened to arrest him if he moved his hips on stage. When he went on the Ed Sullivan Show, the cameras were ordered to show him only from the waist up.
Somebody, early on, had given him a nickname. He had hated it from the first day he heard it, and he hated it still. Elvis the Pelvis. He had told a reporter once that it was the most childish thing he’d ever heard a grown man say. The reporter had printed the nickname in the headline anyway. People had written to him by the sackful, and not all of it was kind.
Some letters were from people who said they were praying for him to be struck down. Some were from mothers who said he had ruined their daughters. His mother had been the person he loved most in the world. She had died in August 1958 while he was in the army, and he had never really gotten over it. And most of the people who wrote those letters, who stood in those pulpits, who burned those records in those parking lots, had never heard Elvis Presley sing a single song all the way through.
Mahalia went out first. The studio came up out of its seats for her. It was a sound the Tonight Show audience made for only a handful of people, not the screaming kind, the respectful kind, the sound of 400 people standing up because something in them told them they ought to. She did a small nod, almost shy, and lowered herself onto the couch with one hand on the armrest, and smoothed her dress over her knees, and smiled at Johnny the way a woman smiles at a nephew she suspects of being clever.
For 15 minutes, it was lovely. Johnny asked about the covered dish she’d brought, and Mahalia told him it was gumbo, real gumbo, New Orleans gumbo, and that she had been up since 6:00 that morning in her hotel kitchen making it because she did not trust anybody in New York to feed a band properly. You cooked in a hotel? Johnny asked.
Honey, I cook everywhere, Mahalia said. I cooked in a hotel in Paris. The manager came up to the room to complain about the smell and I gave him a bowl and he came back the next day with his wife. The audience fell about. She talked about her aunt Duke a great deal. Johnny noticed it. Every story seemed to end up with that stern old woman in New Orleans in it, quietly keeping order.
A switch in one hand and a Bible in the other. Then Johnny asked carefully about the offers. The famous offers. The money people had put in front of her over the years to sing the blues. Mahalia’s smile stayed exactly where it was, but something behind it went firm. People offer what they want to offer, she said quietly. I can’t stop them.
I just keep singing for the Lord. Was there ever one that tempted you? She considered the question honestly, which was one of the things people loved about her. There was one, she said. A man in Chicago a long time ago, when I was poor as a church mouse and sleeping on a cot in my cousin’s kitchen. He put $5,000 on the table, cash money.
All I had to do was sing one night in his club. What did you do? I went home and I prayed on it, Mahalia said. And in the morning, the Lord told me that man needed his $5,000 more than I did. The room roared. Johnny, who knew when to leave something alone, left it alone and moved on. And if there was something underneath it all, a readiness, a hand resting on the door, nobody in the audience would have seen it.
At the top of the second segment, Johnny put down his cards and gave the camera the small private smile the crew had learned to recognize. “Mahalia,” he said, “we’ve got a little surprise for you tonight.” Mahalia’s eyebrows went up beneath the brim of her hat. “Johnny, I’m too old for surprises,” she said. “My heart’s not built for it.” “Ladies and gentlemen,” Johnny said, “Elvis Presley.” The room did something very strange.
For a second, it went completely silent, as if 400 people had forgotten how to breathe. And then, it exploded. Girls in the back rows screamed the way girls had screamed in 1956. But under the roar, there was something else, a gasp. A woman in the third row with a church pin on her coat said, “Oh Lord, no,” out loud. Somebody laughed nervously.
Because in November 1969, everyone in that room over the age of 30 remembered the newspapers. They remembered the parking lots, and every single one of them knew exactly who Mahalia Jackson was, and exactly what kind of music she had spent her whole life refusing to sing. He walked out from behind the curtain the way he walked everywhere, loose, a little shy, a little careful, as if the floor might move.
He had taken off the overcoat. Underneath, he wore a dark, high-collared jacket, black trousers, and on a thin gold chain around his neck, a small gold cross, almost exactly like hers. He shook Johnny’s hand. He said something that made Johnny laugh. Then, he turned to the couch where Mahalia Jackson was sitting, and dipped his head to her the way a boy from Tupelo had been taught to greet a lady, and moved to sit down beside her.
Mahalia stood up. She did it slowly, with dignity, with one hand on the armrest, the way a well-raised woman might stand to greet a young man, and for half a second, that is exactly what it looked like. Then, she stepped past him, past the empty seat, and walked slowly around to the far side of Johnny’s desk, to the single armchair at the very end of the set, the one usually kept for the third guest, and sat down in it.
She folded her hands in her lap. She looked at Johnny with a small, apologetic smile. “You go on and sit there, Mr. Presley,” she said softly. “I’m just fine right here.” It took perhaps 4 seconds. Later, people who had been in the room would describe those 4 seconds as if they had lasted much longer, the way people describe a car sliding on ice.
Doc Severinsen said afterwards that he lowered his trumpet without knowing he had done it. Ed McMahon, sitting at the end of the couch, said he had never in his life wanted so badly to be somewhere else. Elvis stood beside the couch with one hand still resting on its back. He didn’t look surprised. He didn’t look anything. After a moment, he sat down where Mahalia had been sitting, in the warm place she had left, and put his hands together between his knees, and looked at the floor.
In the control booth, the director had his hand on the switcher and didn’t move it. He said later that he had thought about cutting to a wide shot, something to break the tension, and decided against it because whatever this was, it wasn’t finished, and he was not going to be the man who cut away from it. The audience made a sound, not a laugh, not quite.
The uncertain rustle of 400 people who had just seen something and couldn’t decide what it was. Johnny’s grin held, but the people who knew him could see it lock in place for a beat before it loosened again. “Well,” he said, “musical chairs. Nobody told me we were doing that tonight.” The room laughed gratefully. Mahalia smiled politely.
Elvis said nothing. And Johnny, who had been reading rooms for a living since before either of his guests had made a record, did not pretend nothing had happened. He walked toward it with a light step. “Mahalia,” he said, “I’ve got to ask, is there something wrong with that side of the couch?” “Oh, no, baby,” Mahalia said, “the couch is very nice.” “Something about the company, then?” Mahalia looked down at her hands for a long moment.
When she looked up, her voice was very soft and very clear. “I’m sorry,” she said, “I don’t mean any disrespect. I truly don’t. But it’s my faith. I was raised a certain way. My Aunt Duke told me there are some things you don’t sit down beside.” She hesitated. “And everybody in this country knows what that young man’s music does to people.” The audience let out a breath that was half a gasp and half a laugh.
Elvis let it wash over him. When it died down, he was still looking at Mahalia with an expression that was neither hurt nor angry, just attentive. “Yes, ma’am,” he said, “that’s fair.” Johnny turned to him. “You want to respond to that?” People who knew him would later say that this was the strangest part. Elvis Presley in front of a crowd was usually all motion, all jokes, all nerves turned into charm.
He’d say the first funny thing that came into his head, and the room would laugh, and the moment would pass. But he didn’t do that now. He took his time, and the room waited for him. “I’d rather ask her something,” he said, “if that’s all right, ma’am. Go ahead, son, Mahalia said. Which songs? Mahalia blinked. I beg your pardon? Which of my songs have you heard, ma’am?
Elvis said, very gently. When you say everybody knows what my music does, which ones have you actually listened to? There was a pause. Short, but everybody in the room felt it. I’ve heard about the hips, Mahalia said. That’s not a song, ma’am, Elvis said. That’s nerves. First time I ever sang in front of real people, my left leg started shaking so bad I couldn’t stop it.
The girls screamed. I didn’t know what they were screaming at. I went off stage and asked my manager what I’d done wrong. He shrugged. “Been shaking ever since.” What else? The burnings, Mahalia said quietly. Down south, the churches burning those records. I read about that. So did I, ma’am, Elvis said. Every morning for a year. He let that sit.
What else? Mahalia didn’t answer. I don’t need to hear them all to know, Mr. Presley, she said at last. The whole country knows what you are. The whole country knows what they wrote about me, Elvis said, and his voice stayed exactly where it had been, low and soft and southern. That’s a little different, isn’t it, ma’am? Mahalia’s chin came up a fraction.
You’re saying I have you wrong. I’m saying I don’t know if you do or you don’t, Elvis said. That’s why I asked. The room was very quiet now. Johnny’s eyes went to the booth. Nobody signaled anything. Johnny tried to help. Mahalia, in fairness, he said, I’m told this young man went on the Ed Sullivan Show back in ’57, the same show where they wouldn’t let the cameras below his belt, and sang a real hymn, in front of 50 million people, which, I have to say, doesn’t sound very much like the devil to me.
Sounds like something my mother would have liked.” The audience laughed gratefully. Mahalia allowed herself a very small smile, but she wasn’t finished, and everybody could see it. Out in the wings, Mildred Falls had both hands pressed flat against her mouth and was standing completely still, like a woman watching a car roll slowly toward the edge of a cliff.
“Can I tell you something about them songs, ma’am?” Elvis said. Mahalia nodded very slightly. “I was born in a two-room house in Tupelo, Mississippi,” Elvis said. “My daddy built it with his own hands, borrowed $180 to do it. And about a block from that house, there was a little Assembly of God church, and that’s where my mama took me every Sunday and every Wednesday night from before I could walk.” He turned his hands over and looked at them.
“Mama used to say that when I was 2 years old, I’d slide down off her lap in the middle of the service and run up the aisle and stand in front of the choir. Couldn’t sing, couldn’t even talk right. I’d just stand there looking up at them, trying to do what they were doing. She said she couldn’t keep me in the pew.” The audience had gone completely silent.
“When we moved up to Memphis, we were poor, real poor. We lived in public housing, the four of us, my grandma, too, in one room. And on Sunday nights, after our own church let out, I used to walk over to a black church on East Trigg Avenue, Reverend Brewster’s church. I’d stand in back where nobody’d make a fuss, and I’d listen to that choir until they turned the lights off.
He looked up at her. “Ma’am, I learned to sing from your people. I learned to sing from your songs. The first thing in this world I ever wanted to be was a gospel singer in a quartet. I tried out for one when I was 18, a group called the Song Fellows. They told me I couldn’t hold a harmony. A year after that, a man at the Grand Ole Opry told me I ought to go back to driving a truck.” A small rueful laugh moved through the room.
“First record I ever made, before anybody knew my name, I paid $4 of my own money at a little studio on Union Avenue to make it. One copy. It was a present for my mama’s birthday. A sweet little song. Not a hip in it.” The audience laughed again, softly. “And last year, ma’am,” Elvis said, “I finally won a Grammy. You know what for?” Mahalia shook her head.
“A gospel record,” Elvis said. “How Great Thou Art. That’s the only Grammy I’ve got. Not for any of the ones they burned. For a hymn.” The silence that followed was so complete that the people in the booth could hear the hum of the studio lights. “That’s the devil’s singer,” Elvis said quietly. “That’s the one that’s supposed to be ruining the children.
A truck driver from Tupelo who just wanted to sing in church. And nobody who wrote about it ever asked me what I was listening to on Sunday nights. Not one.” He touched the small gold cross at his throat. “And this,” he said, “some fellow in a magazine wrote that I wear it for show. I don’t. My mama gave me my first one. I’ve worn one since I was a boy.
I’m not saying I’m a saint, Ms. Jackson. I’m not. I’ve done things I’m ashamed of. I’ve let down people I love. But I’m not what those preachers said I was. I’ve just been sold as it for so long that I quit arguing about it. He paused, and then he said something that made Joe Esposito, listening on a speaker in the little room down the hall, get up out of his chair.
“And I’ll tell you the part that’s my fault,” Elvis said, “because some of it is.” He looked at his hands again. “I let them sell it. When the newspapers started calling me dangerous, the tickets went through the roof. Everybody wanted to see the wild boy. So, I gave them the wild boy. They wanted the hips, I gave them the hips. They wanted the sneer, I did the sneer.
And when the Colonel said, ‘Son, you’re going to make movies now,’ I made movies, 31 of them. Some of them I’m proud of. Most of them I couldn’t sit through.” He shook his head. “And every time some preacher stood up and said I was trash, part of me thought, ‘Well, at least they’re saying my name,’ because I came from nothing, ma’am.
I mean nothing. My daddy went to prison when I was 3 years old over a forged check for a few dollars, because we were hungry. And I was so scared of going back to that, of Mama having to work in a cotton field again, that I let them say anything they wanted about me, as long as the money kept coming.” He looked at Mahalia. “So, you’re not all wrong about me,” he said.
“You’re just wrong about the part you think you’re right about.” Johnny, sensing that the room needed a moment, said very quietly, “I don’t think I’ve ever heard you say any of that before.” “Nobody ever asked,” Elvis said. The silence that followed was a different kind of silence, not tense, thoughtful. Mahalia was looking at Elvis the way she looked at a hymn she had sung wrong the first time she learned it.
“I didn’t know that,” she said finally, “about the church on Trigg Avenue. Most people don’t, ma’am, Elvis said. It’s not your fault. It’s not the part they put on the poster. Why not? Because a poster of a boy shaking his hips sells more tickets than a poster of a boy standing in the back of a church, Elvis said. You know that better than me, ma’am.
You’ve been turning down that money your whole life. A small surprised laugh escaped Mahalia. My whole life, she agreed. Johnny, who had been sitting very still through all of this with the fascination of a man watching a card game he hadn’t dealt, leaned forward. Mahalia, he said gently, 10 minutes ago you changed chairs. Do you still feel the same way about that chair?
Mahalia thought about it for a long time. She was not a woman who said things quickly on television or anywhere else. Can I tell you something, Johnny? She said, something I don’t hardly ever talk about. Please, Johnny said. Mahalia looked at her hands. When I first came up to Chicago, she said, I was 16 years old. I didn’t have nothing but a cardboard suitcase and the songs I learned in New Orleans.
And down there in the church I grew up next to, folks sang with their whole bodies. They clapped. They moved. They stomped their feet on the floorboards till the whole building shook. That’s how I learned to praise the Lord. So, I took that up north with me. And the first big church I sang in, the minister stopped the service in the middle of my song.
He stood up in that pulpit and he looked right at me in front of the whole congregation and he said that I was bringing jazz into the house of God. He said it was blasphemous. He said what I was doing with my body was sinful and he would not have it in his church. The audience was absolutely still. Almost nobody outside her own circle had ever heard her say this.
“I was 16.” Mahalia said. “I went home and I cried all night long. I thought maybe he was right. Maybe there was something wicked in me and I didn’t even know it. I almost quit singing altogether.” “What stopped you?” Johnny asked softly. “My Bible.” Mahalia said. “I opened it up and I found the Psalms. Make a joyful noise unto the Lord.
Praise him with the timbrel and dance. And I went back to that man the next week and I told him so. I said, ‘I’ve read the book. That’s how I praise. And if he didn’t like it, he could take it up with David.'” The room laughed, but it was a warm laugh, a careful one. “They called my singing the devil’s music.” she said slowly. “For years, grown men in collars, and I knew it wasn’t.
I knew it was just me loving the Lord the only way I knew how. And it hurts so much, Johnny, because they never asked me where it came from. They never once came and sat in the back and listened. They just heard about it.” She stopped. She turned in the armchair and looked across Johnny’s desk at the young man sitting alone on the couch with his hands between his knees.
“And tonight I did the very same thing to you.” she said. “Didn’t I, son?” Elvis didn’t say anything for a moment. “A little bit, ma’am.” he said. “Yes, ma’am.” She stood up. The studio went dead still. For a second, it looked as though she might be about to walk off altogether. Johnny’s hand actually moved a fraction of an inch toward her, the way you reach for a glass you think is about to fall, but she wasn’t leaving.
She walked slowly around the end of Johnny’s desk, past Johnny, across the little stretch of carpet, and sat down on the couch, right beside Elvis Presley, in the seat she had refused 15 minutes earlier. She folded her hands in her lap and turned to look at him. “There,” she said, “now tell me about Reverend Brewster’s choir.” The room came apart.
It wasn’t the applause you get after a joke, it was the sound an audience makes when it has just watched something real close in a circle. It went on so long that Johnny had to wait for it, and while he waited, he looked into camera one and for a moment dropped the polish completely. “I have been doing this show for seven years,” he said, “and I have never once seen anybody change seats twice.” When it settled, Elvis did tell her about the choir.
He told her about the women in white gloves who sang altos so low it rattled the windows, about the night he heard Queen C Anderson sing a hymn so slowly that he forgot to breathe and walked home 4 miles in the rain without noticing it was raining. “What did your mama say?” Mahalia asked. “She said, ‘Where in the world have you been?'” Elvis said, “and I said, ‘Church, mama,’ and she looked at me like she didn’t believe a word of it, and then she smelled the rain on me and saw my face, and she just hugged me.” Mahalia laughed, a real laugh, low and helpless, the laugh the crew had heard in the dressing room that afternoon over the gumbo and hadn’t heard since the curtain opened.
“Can I ask you something different, Mr. Presley?” she said after a moment. “Elvis, ma’am, please.” Elvis. She tried the name like a new hymn. The first time they called you the devil in the papers, were you scared? Elvis didn’t answer straight away. Terrified, he said. Of what? Of finding out they were right, Elvis said, that there really was something bad in me, something wrong inside and everybody could see it except me.
And I used to think if Mama ever believes them, I’ll die. Mahalia looked at him for a long time. Did she, she asked, believe them? No, ma’am, Elvis said, not for one second. She used to cut out the bad articles and put them in a drawer so I wouldn’t see them. I found the drawer after she passed. The studio was absolutely silent. Millions of people at home were watching Elvis Presley say something he had almost certainly never said out loud before.
Mahalia reached over and put her hand very lightly on top of his. There’s nothing wicked in you, baby, she said. You just got loved by too many people too fast. From the outside, that looks just like sin. I should know. There were 4 minutes left in the segment. The producer in the booth was already holding up a card that said, wrap. Johnny ignored it.
I don’t suppose, he said, that the two of you would ever consider He didn’t finish the sentence. He didn’t need to. Elvis looked at Mahalia. Mahalia looked at Doc Severinsen’s band and then at Mildred Falls standing frozen in the wings and crooked one finger at her. Mildred came out onto the stage of The Tonight Show in her plain gray dress, sat down at the band’s piano without a word, and played four soft chords.
Everybody in America knew the hymn by the second chord, “Amazing Grace.” Elvis sang the first verse alone. He sang it low, the way he sang late at night at Graceland, when the guests had gone home, and it was just the boys around the piano. Not the Las Vegas voice, the other one, the one he’d learned standing in the back of a church on East Trigg Avenue.
On the second verse, Mahalia came in under him. People who were in Studio 6B that night tried for the rest of their lives to describe what it sounded like, and mostly gave up. A stagehand said it was like hearing a building breathe. Ed McMahon said simply that he had worked in television for 20 years and had never once wept on the air, and he did that night, and he did not care who saw it.
When it was over, nobody applauded at first. Then, the whole studio stood up at once. Johnny Carson, a man who had a line for everything, sat behind his desk with his hands flat on the blotter and said nothing at all. He tried twice. He opened his mouth and closed it again. In the end, he simply looked at camera one and shook his head slowly, and the director, who understood, went to black.
There was a corridor at the back of Studio 6B, a narrow one with a linoleum floor and a single light that led from the stage door to the dressing rooms. Mildred Falls was the only other person in it when it happened, and she didn’t tell the story for many years. Mahalia had stopped halfway down the corridor to catch her breath, one hand on the wall.
Elvis had come up behind her and offered his arm without a word, and she had taken it. At her dressing room door, she opened her handbag and took something out. It was a white handkerchief, a plain cotton one folded into a square, the kind she held in her hand every time she sang, the kind she pressed to her forehead when the spirit came over her.
For when you sweat, baby, she said, you sweat something terrible. I saw you. Elvis laughed. Then he looked at the handkerchief in his hand, and he didn’t laugh anymore. Miss Jackson, he said, I can’t take this. You can, and you will, Mahalia said. And when you’re up on that stage in Las Vegas, and somebody in the front row’s looking at you like you’re something other than a child of God, you give them something.
You hear me? Don’t give them the hips. Give them something they can take home. Then she went into her dressing room and closed the door. Here’s what happened next. Three weeks later, a small envelope arrived at Graceland addressed in careful handwriting. Inside was a single sheet of hotel note paper from Chicago. It said, I bought your gospel record.
I listened all the way through. M. Elvis kept it in his bedside drawer for the rest of his life. The following summer in Las Vegas, he began to do something new at the end of his shows. He would take a white scarf from around his neck, wipe his forehead, and lean down to the front of the stage and place it into somebody’s hands. A girl, an old man, a woman in a wheelchair.
Every show, thousands of them over the years. Nobody could ever quite explain where the habit came from, and Elvis, when anyone asked, would only smile and say a lady told him to. And every single night of every tour for the rest of his career, somewhere in the middle of the rock and roll, the lights would come down, and Elvis Presley would sing a hymn.
Mahalia Jackson died in January 1972 in a hospital outside Chicago. She was 60 years old. Tens of thousands of people filed past her casket. A week after the funeral, a padded envelope arrived at Graceland. Mildred Falls had sent it. Inside was a reel of tape and a short note. The tape was a recording Mahalia had made in her own living room just before she went into the hospital for the last time.
It was only one song, a hymn, and just before the first note, you could hear her voice, tired and smiling, say five words. “This one’s for Elvis, baby.” The next year, Elvis Presley won his second Grammy. It was for a gospel record. In June 1977, on what turned out to be his last tour, he was tired and heavy and sick in ways most people didn’t understand.
But every night, the lights still came down, and every night, he still sang the hymn. And people who were there said that before he began, he would take a plain white handkerchief from his pocket, an old cotton one folded into a square, and hold it in his hand while he sang. He never gave that one away. He never told anyone where it came from.
He just kept it the way you keep a promise. And he sang.