News

“Let Them Go.” — The Nameless Gunslinger Said Before Facing The Most Powerful Family In Dodge City

The Rutledge hands had set the two poles at sunup.

They were peeled cottonwood, ten feet tall, sunk in fresh-dug holes in the bare yard behind the Rutledge holding pens, six miles south of Dodge City, and the dirt was still heaped in raw brown mounds around their feet.

By nine o’clock on that Thursday morning, the tenth of July, 1879, everybody on the place understood what they were for.

Maren Landry was tied to the left one.

Her cousin Beth was tied to the right.

They hung there in the white cotton shirtwaists and pale striped skirts they had sewn together over the winter, the good clothes they had put on two nights before so they would look respectable in front of a judge.

They had never reached the judge.

Their boots had been taken from them in the dark, and each woman had one wrist and one bare ankle lashed high against her pole, so that she stood on a single foot in the dust and could do nothing but hold on.

Cash Larrabee, the foreman, had explained it to the hands while he pulled the knots tight.

“A body standing on one foot don’t run anywhere.”

Maren was twenty-six, the elder, with long honey-brown hair that had come loose across her face and shoulders.

She had kept her head up since dawn, out of nothing but stubbornness.

Beth was twenty-four, darker and quieter, and her head had fallen back against her own arm an hour ago, her eyes half shut against the glare.

Around the poles stood the people who had been told to come and watch.

There were half a dozen Rutledge hands in hats and vests: Rance Yarbro in his striped shirt with his thumbs in his belt, and young Kip Gaither, who could not make himself look at anything but his own boots.

There was Cash Larrabee, tall and bearded, a long pale scarf wound around his neck in spite of the heat, his gun on his hip.

There was Hanne Sorensen, the Rutledge housekeeper, in her dark skirt, standing just behind Beth’s pole because she had been ordered to stand somewhere and that was as close as she dared.

There was Miss Lavinia Rutledge, thirty-four, upright in an olive-green dress and a brown hat set perfectly level, who kept the family’s books and never raised her voice because she never needed to.

And in front of them all, crouched on his heels in the dirt the way he squatted at a horse sale to study a colt’s legs, was her brother.

Eldon Rutledge was thirty-eight.

He had a neat brown mustache, a day of stubble, a gray shirt, a black vest, a faded neckerchief, and a cattleman’s hat pushed back so the whole yard could see his face.

The Rutledges were the most powerful family in Dodge City.

The old Colonel, Bramwell Rutledge, had come out with the railroad in 1872, bought the river bottom south of town for a song, and fenced the best holding grounds on the Arkansas, where the Texas herds waited for buyers.

Since he died, his son and daughter had run all of it: the Rutledge Land and Cattle Company, half the Drovers’ Bank, and two of the three votes on the county board.

There was only one thing south of the river they did not own.

It was a spring.

Sand Plum Spring rose out of a limestone ledge eight miles southwest of town, on the line between two quarter sections, and it had never gone dry, not even in the drought of ’74.

Two brothers, Orville and Rufus Landry, had filed on those quarters in 1872 and built one stone house straddling the line, so that neither could say he had the better half.

Orville painted their one rule on a board and nailed it to the gatepost.

*WATER FREE TO ANY HERD THAT SHUTS THE GATE.*

For seven summers the trail outfits had watered there for nothing, and for seven summers the Rutledges had watched good money run out of a rock and down a creek.

Orville died of pneumonia in 1877.

Rufus was kicked by a mule in January of 1879 and lived two days.

That left the spring to their daughters, half to Maren and half to Beth, and the Rutledges came calling with an offer before the ground on Rufus’s grave had settled.

The cousins said no.

They said no to a better offer, and then to a better one.

In June, Deputy Sheriff Carl Petrie rode out to the spring with a paper from the probate court of Ford County, and his face was gray when he read it to them.

A physician of Dodge City, Dr. Septimus Quayle, had certified under oath that on Tuesday, the third of June, he had examined both women at their home and found them of unsound mind and unable to manage their property.

On the twentieth of June, on the strength of it and a petition from Eldon’s mother, Mrs. Honoria Rutledge, the court had appointed Eldon guardian of their persons and their estates.

Neither woman had ever seen Dr. Septimus Quayle in her life.

Nobody had asked them.

Rutledge riders took them from the stone house with the deputy’s paper and brought them to the home place “for their care.”

The next day a chain went across the trail to the spring, and a new board went up beside Orville’s.

*RUTLEDGE WATER. TEN CENTS A HEAD.*

Two nights ago, Maren and Beth had climbed out of a back window in their good white clothes and walked north toward the probate judge in Dodge City, carrying their shoes so they would make no noise.

They got a mile and three quarters.

Cash Larrabee caught them at first light on the river road, and when they were brought back, Eldon Rutledge had the poles set.

Now Eldon took a folded paper from inside his vest and held it up so that it caught the sun.

He did not stand to do it.

“This is all I need, Maren. Your names, saying you agree to the sale. Judge Harte signs it without a hearing, and you get your boots back today.”

Maren looked down at him from the pole.

Her voice was hoarse from the dust, but it carried.

“So the judge never has to look at us.”

Eldon’s smile did not move.

“So the judge never has to look at you. That’s a kindness, Maren. I’m offering you a kindness.”

Maren lifted her chin.

“I’d sooner stand here till these poles rot.”

Lavinia spoke for the first time, very quietly, looking at her gloves.

“Then there’s the other paper, Eldon.”

Eldon nodded as if she had reminded him of an errand.

“The other paper goes to the state asylum at Osawatomie. Dr. Quayle’s certificate is good there, too. If you won’t sign as wards, you’ll go east on the Tuesday train as patients, and nobody will ever need your signature again.”

On the other pole, Beth Landry opened her eyes.

She looked at Eldon Rutledge the way a person looks at a rattlesnake on a doorstep, with no fear in it at all, only measurement.

Deputy Carl Petrie stood at the edge of the yard beside his horse.

He was a heavy, tired man of forty-five with a star on his vest and a mortgage at the Drovers’ Bank, and he had served every paper the Rutledges had put in his hand for six years.

The stranger came in from the south, at a walk.

He crossed the open flat where the cattle had grazed the grass down to dirt, a single rider on a tall dun horse, and the dust he raised hung behind him in the still air like smoke.

He stopped at the edge of the yard and stepped down without hurry, and stood with his back to the morning sun, looking at the poles.

He was a lean, weathered man in his late fifties, with gray hair clipped short at the back of his neck and graying stubble on a lined jaw.

His hat was a dark brown cattleman’s hat with a wide brim curled at the sides, sweat-stained at the band, and a black neckerchief was knotted loosely at his throat.

Over his shoulders hung a heavy wool poncho in dark wine red and brown, woven with pale stepped and zigzag bands, long enough to hide the faded shirt beneath it and most of the worn gun belt with its single holstered revolver.

He looked at the ropes first.

Then at the bare feet.

Then at the men with guns, and the men pretending not to have them, and the deputy pretending not to be there.

Eldon Rutledge did not get up.

He tipped his hat back a little farther and looked the stranger over from boots to brim, the way he had looked over a thousand trail cattle.

“You’re on Rutledge ground, old man. Ride on.”

The stranger’s pale eyes came down from the poles and rested on Eldon’s face.

“I watered at Sand Plum Spring nine summers running. Yesterday there was a chain across the trail and a sign that wants ten cents a head. I came to ask the Landrys about it.”

Eldon spread his hands toward the poles.

“Well, there they are. Ask.”

The stranger took one step forward.

Only one.

It put him a little closer to Eldon and a little closer to Cash Larrabee, and every man in the yard felt the gun on his hip grow heavier.

Then he spoke, and he did not raise his voice at all.

“Let them go.”

For a second nobody moved.

Nobody had said a thing like that to a Rutledge in seven years, and the yard did not know what to do with the sound of it.

Then Cash Larrabee laughed, low and ugly.

“Grandpa, you got a poor sense of where you’re standing.”

Eldon held up one hand without looking around, the way a man stops a dog.

“Those women are my wards, by order of the court. The deputy there served it himself. Didn’t you, Carl?”

Carl Petrie swallowed.

“I served it.”

The stranger kept his eyes on Eldon.

“Then the court can look at them. Standing up, in their own boots. Not tied to a pole in your yard.”

Eldon did not blink.

“The court’s looked at all it needs to.”

The stranger waited.

“Has it?”

Eldon’s smile thinned.

“Cash. Put this old man back on his horse.”

Cash Larrabee came in from the stranger’s left with his fist cocked low, fast and practiced, and threw it before the old man had finished turning his head.

It caught him high on the cheekbone with a sound like a dropped saddle.

The stranger’s head snapped around, his hat flew off and rolled in the dirt, and for one ugly second it looked exactly the way everybody had expected it to look.

A big young man with a big fist, and an old man going down.

The old man did not go down.

He let the second punch skid off the crown of his skull and drove the heel of his boot into the side of Cash Larrabee’s knee.

Cash’s leg folded.

He went down on that knee in the dust, swearing, and his right hand went for his gun.

The stranger’s left hand closed on his wrist before the barrel cleared leather, and the revolver came up between them pointing at nothing but the ground.

It went off.

The shot slammed flat across the yard and threw a fist of dirt into the air between their boots.

Then the stranger twisted the wrist one more inch, and the gun was in his hand instead of Cash’s.

Nobody else drew.

Nobody could have said afterward why not.

The stranger opened the loading gate with his thumb and let the cartridges drop one by one into the dust at Cash Larrabee’s knees, and the empty shell after them.

Then he tossed the empty gun underhand, and it landed at Eldon Rutledge’s feet.

Eldon had not moved from his crouch.

But his smile was gone, and a bead of sweat had started down his temple from under his hatband.

The stranger picked up his own hat, slapped the dust from it, and put it back on.

There was a red welt rising across his cheekbone.

He did not touch it.

“Let them go,” he said again.

“Tomorrow you can show the judge your paper, and they can show him their faces, and he can decide which one he believes.”

It was Lavinia who answered.

She lifted her eyes from her gloves and looked at the stranger with something like interest.

“Deputy Petrie. The law allows a ward to ask for a hearing on her guardianship, does it not?”

Petrie blinked at her.

“It does, Miss Rutledge.”

Lavinia nodded once.

“Then they may have one. Tomorrow at nine, before Judge Harte. Dr. Quayle will be there to swear to his certificate.”

She turned her head a fraction toward the stranger.

“And the gentleman may come and watch Dodge City do things properly.”

Eldon looked at his sister for a long moment.

Then he understood her, and the smile came back slowly.

Judge Morris Harte held probate court in a rented room over the Drovers’ Bank.

Dr. Quayle drank on Rutledge credit at the Stockman’s Rest.

“Nine o’clock,” Eldon said, and stood up at last, brushing the dust from his knees.

“Carl, they’re in your custody till then. Lose them, and I’ll have your star and your house both.”

He nodded at the poles without looking at them.

“Cut them down.”

None of the Rutledge hands moved.

It was the stranger who walked to the left pole and drew a knife from his belt.

He touched Maren Landry nowhere but the rope.

He cut the ankle first, high on the pole, and caught her elbow as her foot came down so that she would not fall, and then the wrist.

She stood there swaying, both bare feet in the dirt, and studied his face the way he had studied the yard.

“Who are you?”

He folded the knife.

“A man who’s late for his own herd, ma’am.”

He did the same for Beth, and Beth walked straight to her cousin, and the two of them stood holding each other’s forearms in the middle of the Rutledge yard while everyone watched.

Hanne Sorensen came out of the house at a run with both pairs of boots in her apron.

Nobody had told her to.

She set them in the dust in front of the two women, and when she stood up, her eyes were wet, and she did not look at Lavinia Rutledge at all.

—

## The Road Into Dodge

They rode north in a slow line through the heat, the deputy first because the law said he should, Beth on a horse Kip Gaither had saddled for her without being asked, and Maren behind the stranger on the tall dun, her hands closed on the wool of his poncho.

At the toll bridge over the Arkansas, Maren spoke.

“You said you watered at our spring nine summers. Then you knew my father.”

He kept his eyes on the road.

“I knew both of them. Your father used to stand at the gate and count my cattle through with a stick, out loud, so I’d know he wasn’t cheating me on water he wasn’t charging for.”

On Front Street, men stopped talking when the deputy rode by with the two Landry women behind him.

Carl Petrie took them to Mrs. Delphine Oyler’s boarding house at the quiet west end of town.

She put them in the back room upstairs with water to wash in and coffee, and then she went down and stood in her own doorway with her arms folded, and stayed there.

The stranger sat at the little table by the window with his hat on his knee.

Carl Petrie stood by the door, turning his own hat around and around in his hands, and when he finally spoke, he spoke to the floor.

“I read that certificate the day I served it. It says Quayle went out to the spring on the third of June and sat an hour with each of them. It says Miss Maren wept and couldn’t tell him the year. It says Miss Beth laughed at nothing and pulled at her own hair.”

Beth looked up from the table.

“On the third of June we were mending fence on the north line from sunup to dark. Nobody came to that house.”

Maren’s voice was flat.

“We’ve never seen Dr. Quayle in our lives. I wouldn’t know him if he sat down at this table.”

The stranger turned his hat a quarter turn on his knee.

“Would he know you?”

The cousins looked at each other.

It was Beth who saw it first.

“He’s never seen us. All he knows is what Eldon told him. Two Landry girls in white.”

Maren sat up very slowly.

“And tomorrow two Landry girls in white will be sitting at the front table beside the deputy. Right where Eldon’s lawyer will tell him to look.”

The stranger said nothing.

He watched Maren Landry think it through, and he saw the moment the fear went out of her face and something harder came in to take its place.

“Then we won’t be sitting there,” she said.

Carl Petrie stopped turning his hat.

“You can’t lie to a probate court, Miss Landry.”

Maren did not look away.

“I’m not going to say one word that isn’t true, Deputy. I’m only going to sit where I please. The court can’t make me sit at a table I don’t want, can it?”

“No,” he said at last.

“I don’t suppose it can.”

It was the stranger who asked the next question, so quietly that Petrie had to lean in to hear it.

“This Quayle. Is he Septimus Quayle, who was contract surgeon at Fort Dodge after the war?”

Petrie stared at him.

“Same man. Came back to town five years ago with the shakes. How do you know that?”

The stranger was looking out the window at the street, and for a moment his face was a long way off.

“He was a good surgeon once,” was all he said.

—

## Two Women In White

The plan needed two more women, and Maren chose them herself.

Mrs. Constance Fenn was the wife of the Methodist minister, thirty-one years old and afraid of nothing except her husband’s sermons running long.

Miss Ione Shipley was twenty-seven and kept the school on the north side of the tracks, and she had once sold Orville Landry a primer for Beth and refused to take his money.

They came up Mrs. Oyler’s back stairs at dusk and listened to all of it in the lamplight.

“You want us to sit at the front table in white shirtwaists and deep bonnets,” Mrs. Fenn said, “and say nothing at all.”

“Unless the judge asks you a question,” Maren said.

“Then you tell him the truth.”

Ione Shipley’s mouth twitched.

“And if a doctor stands up and swears he examined me at Sand Plum Spring on the third of June?”

“Then you tell the judge where you were on the third of June.”

“I was teaching long division to eleven children who did not want to learn it. I would very much like to tell a judge that.”

Mrs. Oyler had two white shirtwaists that fit, and two deep cotton sunbonnets with long brims that left nothing of a face showing unless you bent down and looked straight in.

By nine o’clock that night, the two women at her back table looked, from across a room, like the Landry cousins in the clothes they had been tied up in.

Maren and Beth would wear what was left: a gray work dress, a brown one, and two plain straw hats.

Cash Larrabee came at one in the morning with three men and a lantern, limping, and walked up onto Mrs. Oyler’s porch as if he owned it.

“Rutledge business. The guardian wants his wards back at the home place tonight.”

In the dark hallway behind Mrs. Oyler, Carl Petrie stood at the foot of the stairs.

“Those ladies are in my custody till nine o’clock, Cash. Mr. Rutledge agreed to it himself, in front of fifteen people.”

Cash’s eyes went to the star.

“Carl, you got a note at the Drovers’ Bank.”

Petrie’s jaw set.

“I know what I got.”

Cash put one boot on the threshold.

From the stairs above the deputy, a voice said, “Cash.”

The stranger was sitting four steps up in the dark with a tin cup of coffee on his knee, and he did not move to stand.

“Go home. Ice that knee. Come back at nine and get yourself a seat in the front row. You’ll want to see this.”

Behind Cash, his three men had already backed down off the porch into the street.

Nobody had told them to.

After a while, Cash took his boot back, too.

—

## The Room Over The Bank

Judge Morris Harte’s courtroom was a long plank room above the Drovers’ Bank, with three windows on Front Street and a bench at the far end that had once been a bar.

It held perhaps forty people.

By a quarter to nine on Friday morning, the eleventh of July, it had seventy in it: storekeepers, freighters, drovers in from the herds, the barber, the minister, and a dozen women who had never been inside a courtroom in their lives.

At the right-hand table sat Eldon in a black coat, Lavinia in her olive green, and their attorney, Mr. Sedgwick, a narrow man with a gold watch chain and a case full of paper.

At the left-hand table, beside Deputy Petrie, sat two women in white shirtwaists, pale striped skirts, and deep sunbonnets, their heads bowed, their hands folded in their laps.

Eldon glanced at them once as he came in and looked away.

He had seen all he needed of the Landry girls in his own yard.

In the very last row, against the back wall beside Mrs. Oyler, sat two young women in plain work dresses and straw hats.

Nobody looked at them at all.

The stranger stood by the back door with his hat in his hand.

Judge Harte came in at nine sharp, a dry, gray-whiskered man of sixty who looked at the crowd with plain displeasure.

“This is a hearing on a petition for restoration. It is not a circus. Mr. Sedgwick.”

Mr. Sedgwick read the petition and the order, and called Dr. Septimus Quayle.

Quayle came up the aisle from near the windows, a tall, stooped man of about sixty in a black frock coat that had been good a long time ago.

He took the oath in a clear, cultivated voice, and he testified for a quarter of an hour, fluently, as though he had rehearsed it.

On the third of June he had driven out to the stone house at Sand Plum Spring.

He had examined Miss Maren Landry first, in the kitchen, for something over an hour.

“She would not meet my eyes. She wept without cause and could not tell me the year.”

He had examined Miss Beth Landry after, in the yard.

“She laughed at nothing. She pulled at her own hair. She told me the spring spoke to her in her father’s voice.”

In the last row, Beth’s hands closed hard on each other in her lap.

Maren did not move at all.

“In my professional opinion,” Dr. Quayle said, “neither young woman was capable of managing her property. I so certified, and I so swear.”

Judge Harte looked toward the left-hand table.

“The wards have no counsel, I see. Is there anyone here to speak for them?”

The stranger stepped forward from the back door.

“With the court’s permission. As a friend of the family.”

The judge looked him over: the dusty boots, the poncho, the dark bruise on his cheekbone.

“And who are you, sir?”

“A man the Landrys’ fathers gave water to for nine years, Your Honor. I’ll give you my name whenever you want it. I’d like to ask the doctor three questions first.”

“Three,” said Judge Harte.

“Not four.”

The stranger stayed in the aisle, halfway down the room, where Quayle had to look past every face in the crowd to see him.

“Doctor, you sat with each of these ladies most of an hour. By daylight. Face to face.”

“I did.”

“Close enough to see the color of their eyes.”

“Certainly.”

“Would you know them again?”

Quayle smiled faintly, the patient smile of an educated man for a simple question.

“I would know them anywhere, sir.”

The stranger turned his hat once in his hands.

“Then here’s my fourth, Your Honor, if you’ll allow it. Doctor, would you show the judge which lady in this room is Miss Maren Landry?”

Mr. Sedgwick half rose.

“Your Honor, this is theater.”

“It is a reasonable question,” Judge Harte said slowly, “for a man who has just sworn he would know her anywhere. Answer it, Doctor.”

Dr. Quayle did not hesitate.

That was the worst of it, afterward.

He stood up, walked three paces to the left-hand table, and stopped beside the nearer sunbonnet.

“This is Miss Maren Landry. The elder. And this,” with a small courteous bow, “is Miss Beth.”

At the right-hand table, Lavinia Rutledge had gone perfectly white.

She had seen the plain gold wedding band on the nearer woman’s folded hand, half a second too late.

“Doctor,” the stranger said, very quietly, “you’ve just sworn that lady wept in her kitchen and couldn’t tell you the year. Would the lady care to take off her bonnet?”

Mrs. Constance Fenn untied the strings and lifted it off.

Every person in that room who went to the Methodist church on Sunday had shaken her hand at the door.

Beside her, Ione Shipley untied her own bonnet without being asked.

“Your Honor, my name is Ione Shipley, and on the third of June I was in my schoolroom from eight in the morning until four in the afternoon. I have the attendance book. I have never laughed at nothing in my life.”

In the back row, Maren Landry stood up.

She took off the straw hat, and her honey-brown hair fell loose down her back.

Beth stood up beside her, and seventy chairs scraped as the room turned around.

“I’m Maren Landry, Your Honor. I can tell you the year. It is eighteen seventy-nine, and the President is Mr. Hayes. On the third of June my cousin and I were mending fence from sunup to dark, and nobody came to our house.”

She looked at Dr. Quayle down the whole length of the room.

“I have never seen that man in my life until this morning. And he has never seen me.”

Judge Harte’s voice was very cold.

“Dr. Quayle. You are under oath, and perjury in this state is a penitentiary offense.”

Quayle did not answer.

He was not looking at the judge, or at Maren Landry, or at the Rutledges.

He was looking at the stranger in the aisle, the way a man looks at a face he has seen in a dream and cannot place.

And now he placed it.

“Fort Dodge,” he said.

“January of sixty-eight. The Baylor freight outfit, caught on the Sawlog in the blizzard. Eleven men with frozen feet.”

The room went dead quiet.

“I operated for sixteen hours in a sutler’s storeroom with one lamp. My orderly fainted at the fourth hour. A teamster took the lamp from him and held it over the table till morning, and never once let it shake.”

His voice cracked.

“I asked your name at the end. You said you didn’t need one.”

The stranger said nothing.

“Nine of those men walked again. You told me it was the best night’s work you ever saw a man do.”

“It was, Doctor. You were the best man in that room.”

Septimus Quayle put his face in his hands.

When he took them away, he looked older and, somehow, steadier than he had looked all morning, and he turned to the bench.

“Your Honor, I never went to Sand Plum Spring. I wrote that certificate at a table in the Stockman’s Rest on the afternoon of the third of June, from a description Mr. Eldon Rutledge gave me, and Miss Lavinia Rutledge watched me sign it. She paid me one hundred and fifty dollars.”

He drew a slip of paper from the inside pocket of his old coat, folded small and gray at the creases.

“A draft on the Rutledge Land and Cattle account, dated the third of June, signed by Miss Rutledge. I never cashed it. The next morning I was sober, and I found I could not walk into a bank with it. So I have carried it for five weeks instead, like a stone.”

He laid it on the bench in front of Judge Harte.

The judge read it, and turned it around so that Lavinia Rutledge could see her own handwriting.

Eldon Rutledge moved.

It was not a plan.

It was the reflex of a man who had never once watched a piece of paper go against him.

He was over the rail in two strides, reaching for the draft, and the deputy was too far away, and the stranger was halfway down the aisle behind a dozen people.

Maren Landry was closer.

She had come forward step by step while Quayle talked, nobody stopping her, until she stood at the end of the bench in her borrowed gray dress.

She did not grab for the paper, or for him.

She only laid her open hand flat on the draft and looked up into Eldon Rutledge’s face, a foot away.

“Let it go, Eldon.”

He stood there with his hand in the air, and seventy people watched him do it.

And for the first time since his father died, Eldon Rutledge understood that the room did not belong to him.

He lowered his hand.

“Deputy Petrie,” said Judge Harte, “take Mr. Rutledge and Miss Rutledge into custody. Mr. Larrabee as well. And keep the doctor somewhere quiet, with coffee and a guard on the door, for his own protection.”

—

## A Name For The Clerk

Judge Harte vacated the guardianship before ten o’clock, in his own hard, slanting hand.

The certificate of the third of June was struck as a fraud upon the court, and Miss Maren Landry and Miss Beth Landry were declared, in the judge’s words, “as sane as anyone in this room, and a good deal saner than some,” and restored to their persons and their property.

The chain across the trail to Sand Plum Spring was to come down by sundown.

Then the judge looked down the room.

“Now, sir. I believe you owe the clerk a name.”

The stranger took the clerk’s pen and wrote in the register in a square, careful hand, and the clerk read it aloud.

“Asher Holloway.”

A sunburned Texas drover by the window said, before he could stop himself, “Lord, mister, you’re him.”

“Beg pardon, Judge. The Galveston papers been writing him up since I was ten. The trail boss nobody could get a name out of. They called him the nameless gunslinger in the books, on account of he’d never give it to the reporters.”

Asher Holloway set the pen down.

“I gave it to the clerk. That’ll do.”

The district court sat in Dodge City in September.

Dr. Quayle testified for the state for a full day and never once looked away from the jury.

Ione Shipley brought her attendance book, Hanne Sorensen told them where the boots had been locked, and Kip Gaither told them who had ordered the poles.

Carl Petrie testified last, and then laid his star on the clerk’s table and said he would rather be a poor man than a tool.

Eldon Rutledge was sentenced to five years in the state penitentiary for conspiracy to defraud, suborning perjury, and false imprisonment.

Lavinia Rutledge drew two years for conspiracy, and Cash Larrabee three for false imprisonment and assault.

Dr. Quayle was not prosecuted.

He took the train east in October, and a year later he wrote Maren that he had found work as a hospital orderly in Saint Louis, carrying lamps for younger men, and that he slept at night.

—

## Free Water

The Holloway herd came up to Sand Plum Spring on the twelfth of July, two thousand four hundred Texas steers under a cloud of yellow dust.

The chain was already down.

Beth had pried the Rutledge board off the gatepost with a claw hammer at first light, and Orville’s old board was still there underneath.

*WATER FREE TO ANY HERD THAT SHUTS THE GATE.*

Maren stood at the gate in her own boots with her father’s stick and counted the steers through, out loud, the whole two thousand four hundred, while Asher Holloway sat his dun beside her and did not interrupt once.

When the last of them had gone through, she shut the gate herself.

That afternoon Kip Gaither drove a wagon out from the Rutledge place and unloaded two peeled cottonwood poles with dirt still caked on their butts.

“Miss Rutledge’s orders were to burn them,” he said, not looking at either woman.

“I figured you had more right.”

Beth split the first one herself.

Maren split the second.

They cooked supper for the Holloway outfit that night in the stone house with a stove full of cottonwood.

Asher Holloway rode on at daybreak.

Maren walked out to the gate to see him go.

“You could have shot every man in that yard. Why didn’t you?”

He looked down at her from the dun before he answered.

“Because they’d have walked into that courtroom anyway and said you were crazy and I was a killer, and the judge would have believed them. A bullet doesn’t settle a paper, Miss Landry. Only the truth does.”

Maren shook her head.

“I didn’t settle it. You did.”

He shrugged under the poncho.

“You chose where to sit.”

She almost smiled.

“Will you water here next summer?”

“If the gate’s shut when I get here.”

He touched the brim of the dark brown hat and rode south along the creek, the wine-red poncho swinging in the morning wind, until the dust of his herd swallowed him.

He did not look back.

She did not ask him to.

Maren Landry stood at the gate of Sand Plum Spring by herself for a long time after that, in her own boots, on her own two feet, with nobody holding her and nothing tied.

Then she took her father’s stick from the gatepost, walked down to the spring with a bucket, and drew the first water of the day for the house.

Behind her, Beth had already started the fire.

It was cottonwood, and it burned clean.

You Might Also Enjoy