Jane Fonda Refused to Sit Next to John Wayne — What John Said Left Johnny Carson Frozen
On a Tuesday evening in October of 1977, the Tonight Show studio in Burbank was doing what it always did at a quarter 5, which was pretending that nothing unusual was about to happen. The band was running through a chart in the corner. A page was straightening the Q cards for the third time. Johnny Carson was in his office with the door half open, reading the guest notes with a pencil in his hand.
and the people who worked for him had learned over 15 years that this was the calmst the building would be all night. Jane Fonda had arrived at 4. She was 39 that year and she was, depending on who you asked, either the finest actress of her generation or the most hated woman in America. Often it was the same people saying both.
She had an Oscar on her shelf for Clute. She had a new picture in theaters, Julia, in which she played the writer Lillian Helman opposite Vanessa Redgrave, and the critics were already saying the word nomination out loud. The studio had sent her on the circuit to talk about it, and the Tonight Show was the biggest stop on the circuit.
But 5 years earlier, in the summer of 1972, she had flown to Hanoi in the middle of a war and let herself be photographed sitting on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun. She would spend the rest of her life explaining that photograph. And in the fall of 1977, there were still people in this country who couldn’t say her name without spitting.
They had a name for her that stuck harder than any role she’d ever played. Hanoi Jane. Before we get into it, tell us where in the world you’re watching this from, and go ahead and hit subscribe while you’re here. She had been born into Hollywood royalty, which was the first thing anybody ever said about her.
And she had spent her whole career trying to make it the least interesting thing. Her father was Henry Fonda. She had grown up on the edges of his sets and in the shadow of his silences. She’d been a model, then anu, then a sex kitten in a space age costume in Barbarella, and then almost overnight, an actress so serious and so precise that the people who dismissed her had to go back and apologize in print.
[music] She was used to being described. She’d been described her whole life, the daughter, the starlet, the radical, the traitor. And somewhere along the way, she had learned that the only answer to being described was to keep working until the description stopped mattering. It hadn’t stopped yet. That fall, she had been carrying a script around Hollywood for close to 5 years.
It was a story about a woman whose husband goes off to Vietnam and who volunteers at a veterans hospital while he’s gone and falls in love with a young man who came home from the war paralyzed from the waist down. Jane didn’t just want to star in it. She wanted to produce it. She’d sat in the spinal cord wards of veterans hospitals in Southern California week after week listening to young men in wheelchairs talk about what nobody back home wanted to hear.
She had been told no in more rooms than she could count. Not because the script was weak, but because, as one executive had put it to her, “Nobody in America wants to pay $3 to watch a man in a wheelchair from a war we lost. And least of all,” he’d said, “From you.” She’d walked out of that meeting and sat in her car in the parking lot for 20 minutes before she could drive.
Her publicist had gone over the shape of the evening with her that afternoon in the dressing room. Not the answers. She never rehearsed answers, just the terrain, the film, Lilian Helman, a little about Vanessa. Nothing about politics, nothing about the war, and nothing about the other script, the one in the drawer.
Keep it light, the publicist had said. It’s Johnny. People want to laugh. Jane had nodded and said nothing, which the publicist had learned over the years was not the same thing as agreement. What nobody had told her was that there would be a second guest. So when she settled into the guest chair that night and Johnny asked her about the new picture, she was warm and she was quick and she was entirely on guard.
I understand Lillian Helman was on the set. Johnny said that must have been something. She came to visit. Jane said she watched me do a scene where I’m smoking and typing and swearing at the typewriter. And when it was over, she walked up to me and said, “Darling, I never once in my life held a cigarette like that.
” And I said, “Lillian, you’re right. You held it like a man holds a grudge.” The audience laughed and Johnny laughed with them. And for a while, the segment moved the way segments moved when a guest was at ease. She told a story about Vanessa Redgrave being so tall that Jane had spent half the picture looking up at her and the other half standing on an apple box.
She talked about Fred Zineman, the director, who said about four words a day and made every one of them count. She was sharp and generous and very funny. And if there was something underneath it, a readiness, a hand on the door, nobody in the audience would have seen it. Near the end of the first segment, Johnny asked her what she wanted to do next that she hadn’t done yet.
It was a soft question, the kind he asked to let a guest choose their own ending. There’s a picture I want to make, Jane said before she’d decided to say it. [music] About the boys who came home from Vietnam, the ones in the hospitals. That’s a tough one to sell, I’d imagine, [music] Johnny said.
She smiled the smile she used when she wasn’t going to say the rest. I’ve noticed, [music] Johnny. The crew had seen something else. 90 minutes earlier, a second guest had come in through the side entrance. John Wayne was 70 years old that fall. He hadn’t made a picture since the shootist the year before, and there were rumors around town about his heart.
Rumors he made a point of ignoring in public. He’d come in quietly in a tan sport coat and a western shirt open at the collar, moving a little slower than he used to. The producers who met him at the door spoke in the low voices they used for surprise walk-ons. He asked for a cup of coffee and a chair and was given both in a small room down the hall.
He did not ask who the other guest was. He already knew. He’d known her father for 30 years. They’d made a picture together in Monument Valley for John Ford back in 1948, Fort Apache, and they’d ridden the same horses and eaten the same dust. And somewhere along the way, two men who agreed about almost nothing in politics had become friends.
Anyway, Wayne had read every word that had been written about Henry Fonda’s daughter in the last 5 years. He’d said a few things about her himself in interviews that he wasn’t especially proud of. He told the producers he wanted to do the show anyway. He hadn’t told them why. The truth was a few weeks earlier he’d been at a dinner where Henry Fonda was sitting at the next table.
Henry was 72 that year and not well and the two of them had talked for a while about horses and old pictures and John Ford who’d been dead 4 years. And then at the very end when Wayne got up to leave, Henry had said something he hadn’t expected. He’d said, “You know, Duke, I don’t understand my own daughter half the time, but I’d hate for her to go through her whole life with everybody in this country deciding who she is before they’ve met her.
” Then he’d look down at his plate and change the subject. Word traveled through the crew in the whispers always traveled in. The Duke and Hanoi Jane on the same couch. Nobody knew what that would look like. One of the older stage hands, who’d worked the show since the New York days, said later that he’d felt the building change temperature the moment Wayne’s car pulled in, like a cold front coming in over a warm room.
You don’t see it, you just know something’s about to move. At the top of the second segment, Johnny put down his cards and gave the camera the small private smile the crew had learned to recognize. Jane, we’ve got a little surprise for you tonight. I think the folks here are going to like it. Jane’s eyebrows went up.
I don’t love surprises, Johnny. Ladies and gentlemen, John Wayne. The room came up off its seats. It was a sound the studio made for only a handful of people on Earth. A roar with an edge of disbelief in it, and Wayne walked out into it the way he walked into everything. Unhurried, a little stiff in the hip, one big hand half raised. He shook Johnny’s hand.
He said something that made Johnny grin. Then he turned toward the couch where Jane Fonda was sitting and moved to take the seat beside her. Jane stood up. She did it smoothly without any drama, the way a woman might stand to greet somebody. And for half a second, that’s exactly what it looked like. Then she stepped past him, past the empty seat, and settled into the chair on the far side of Johnny’s desk, the one usually kept for the third guest.
She crossed her legs, folded her hands in her lap, and looked at Johnny with a bright, expectant smile. “You go ahead and sit there, Mr. Wayne,” she said. “I’m fine right here.” The move took maybe 4 seconds. Later, people who’d been in the room described those 4 seconds as if they’d lasted much longer, the way people describe a car skidding on a wet road.
Doc Severson said his trumpet actually came down off his lip. Wayne stood beside the couch with one hand still resting on the back of it. He didn’t look surprised. He didn’t look angry. He didn’t look like anything at all. After a moment, he lowered himself down where she’d been sitting slowly, the way a big man with a bad back sits down and folded his hands on his knee.
In the fourth row, a columnist who’d come expecting to write 400 words about a costume picture put down her pen and then picked it up again. The audience made a sound. Not a laugh, not quite. The uncertain rustle of several hundred people who had just seen something and couldn’t decide what it was.
Johnny’s grin held, but the people who knew him could see it lock in place for a beat before it loosened. “Well,” he said. “Musical chairs. I didn’t know we were doing that tonight.” The room laughed gratefully. Jane laughed, too. Wayne smiled a little and didn’t say a word. In the control booth, the director had his hand on the switcher and didn’t move it.
He said later that he’d thought about cutting to a wide shot, something to break the tension, and had decided against it. Because whatever this was, it wasn’t finished, and he had no intention of being the man who cut away from it. Johnny had been reading rooms for a living since before either of his guests was famous, and he didn’t pretend nothing had happened.
He did what he was best at. He walked toward it with a light step. Jane, I’ve got to ask. Is there something wrong with that side of the couch? Oh no, Jane said. The couch is lovely. Something about the company, then. She smiled at him, and it was a real smile, and it didn’t give an inch. Johnny, I’ve seen Mr. Wayne’s pictures.
I don’t think there’s a woman in any of them who gets to finish a sentence. and I don’t think there’s a war in any of them that anybody’s allowed to ask a question about. I just thought I’d give myself a little room to talk. The laugh that followed was big and startled, and there was something uneasy in it.
Somebody in the back booed, and somebody else shushed them. Jane let it all wash over her. Wayne let it wash over him, too. When it died down, he was still looking at her with an expression that was neither offended nor amused. just attentive. “That’s a fair shot,” he said evenly. “It wasn’t a shot,” Jane said.
“It was an observation.” “Observation, then.” Johnny turned to him. “You want to respond to the observation, Duke?” Wayne took a moment. He had a way of taking moments that made whole rooms wait for him, and this one waited. “I’d rather ask her something,” he said. “If that’s all right.” “Ask away,” Jane said. “Which pictures?” She blinked.
Which pictures what? Which of my pictures have you seen? He said that you’re basing that on. There was a pause. It was short, but everybody in the room felt it. Jane Fonda was not a person who got caught, and she didn’t like the feeling. [music] The Green Beretss, she said, which I think makes the point. It might, Wayne said.
That one’s a sermon. I’ll give you that. I made it because I thought the boys over there were getting a raw deal back home. And I still think so. But it’s a sermon and there’s not a lot of room in a sermon for anybody to talk back. Man or woman. What else? I don’t need a filmography to know what you make, Mr. Wayne.
The whole world knows what you make. The whole world knows what they write about what I make, Wayne [music] said. His voice stayed exactly where it had been, low and slow. That’s a little different. Jane’s chin came up. Anyone who’d ever sat across a negotiating table from her would have recognized it. You’re telling me I’ve got you wrong.
I’m telling you I don’t know yet, he said. That’s why I asked. The room was very quiet now. Johnny’s eyes went to the booth. Nobody signaled anything. Johnny tried to help. Jane, in fairness, he said, the man made a picture a couple of years ago with Katherine Hepburn, and as I recall, she talked from the opening credits to the closing credits, and he didn’t get a word in edgewise.
Wayne nodded gravely. That’s the truth. Kate Heepburn could talk the ears off a mule. I’d start a line and she’d finish it for me, and then she’d tell me how I should have started it. The audience laughed and Jane allowed herself a small smile. But she wasn’t finished and everybody could see it.
She sat back in the chair and when she spoke again, there was something new in her voice. An edge that had been folded away under the jokes all evening and had now come out. “Let me tell you what I know,” she said. “I know that when I ask a question about a war, I’m a traitor. When a man asks the same question, he’s a statesman.
[music] I know that I’ve been in this business for nearly 20 years and I still get letters every single week from people who want me dead. Not people who disagree with me, people who want me dead. And I know that when I walk into a studio with a script about young men who came home from that war in wheelchairs, young men I’ve sat with whose names I know, the executives look at me like I’m trying to sell them a bomb.
So, forgive me, Johnny, if I didn’t feel like sitting down next to the man they’d hand a flag to without asking a single question. Nobody laughed. It wasn’t that kind of moment anymore. Several hundred people who’d come to see a movie star and a cowboy had just heard something that was neither. Wayne let it sit for a long beat. Then he nodded slowly.
“I think most of that’s true,” he said. The room stirred. Nobody had expected that. most of it. He said, “The part about the flag is true. I’ve been handed things I never had to ask for. And I’ll tell you something I don’t say very often. When the war came, the big one, I didn’t go. I had a wife and four kids and a studio that didn’t want to lose me, and I let them talk me out of it.
Your father went.” Henry Fonda was 37 years old and a big star, and he walked into a Navy recruiting office and enlisted. and he served all the way through to the end of it. A good part of it out in the Pacific. I’ve played soldiers my whole life, ma’am. I was never one. I know exactly what that’s worth. I’d be a fool to sit here and pretend otherwise.
Jane was staring at him. He paused. The part I’d push back on, he said, is the part where you decided what I was from one picture because that’s the same thing they did to you from one photograph. Jane opened her mouth and then closed it again. They looked at you sitting on that gun, Wayne went on, and they decided that was the whole story.
You looked at me in a green beret and decided that was the whole story. I don’t think either one of us is the whole story. But I can’t prove that from over here if you’ve already made up your mind from over there. Johnny, sensing that the room needed a moment, said quietly, “I don’t think anybody said anything like that on this couch in a while.
I don’t think anybody’s been asked,” Wayne said. The silence that followed was a different kind of silence than the one before it. Not tense, thoughtful. Jane was looking at Wayne the way a person looks at a book they dismissed by its cover and then accidentally opened. “That’s a good line,” she said finally. “Wasn’t a line?” “No,” she said.
“I don’t suppose it was.” She unccrossed her legs and leaned forward a little, her elbows on her knees, and the whole posture of the conversation changed with her. “All right, tell me, what am I [music] missing? You’re asking me seriously? I’m asking you seriously.” Wayne didn’t rush it. I made a picture in 52 called The Quiet Man, he said. With Moren O’Hara.
You ever see it? When I was a girl. Then you know Moren doesn’t just finish her sentences. She finishes mine and half of everybody else’s in County Mayo. The whole picture is about a man who has to learn that he can’t just take what he wants from that woman. He has to earn it her way by her rules.
I made five pictures with Morino O’Hara and I don’t believe she lost an argument in any of them. He thought for a moment. I made one called Rio Bravo. He went on. There’s a girl in it, Angie Dickinson, who talks me in circles for 2 hours and never lets me get the last word. And I made one last year called The Shudest. It’s about an old man dying of cancer.
And the only person in that whole town who stands up to him, who looks him in the eye and tells him the truth about himself, is a widow who runs a boarding house, Lauren Beall. She’s the backbone of that picture. I’m just the fella trying to keep up with her. I haven’t seen those, Jane said. Most people haven’t. Wayne said, “That’s fair.
They’re not the ones they put on the lunchboxes, but they’re mine, and I’m proud of them. And there’s more than two lines in any of them for a woman.” Jane studied him for a long moment. “Then why do they always put the gun on the poster?” “Because a poster with a gun on it sells more tickets than a poster with a conversation on it,” he said.
You know that better than I do. You’ve been fighting it longer. A small surprised laugh escaped her. I have, actually. I know, Wayne said. I’ve read about it. Some of what they write about you might even be true. I’d rather find out from you than from the newspapers. Same as I’d rather you found out about me from the pictures than from the reviews.
If you’re the kind of person who believes two people can disagree about almost everything and still sit down and actually listen to each other, this is a good moment to hit that like button before we find out what happened next. Johnny, who’d been sitting very still through all of this with the fascination of a man watching a card game he hadn’t dealt, leaned in.
Jane, 10 minutes ago, you moved chairs. Do you still feel the same way about the chair? Jane considered it. She wasn’t a woman who gave ground on television or anywhere else without deciding to. I’ll tell you what I feel. She said, “I feel like I walked in here tonight with a fight I’ve been having for 5 years, and I picked the first man who walked through that curtain to have it with.
And that isn’t entirely fair to him. It’s not entirely unfair either, but it’s not fair.” “That’s an honest answer,” Johnny said. I try to give honest answers, Jane said. That’s what gets me in trouble. The room laughed, and this time the laugh was warm, [music] and Wayne laughed along with it.
“You said something a minute ago,” Jane went on, turning back to him. “About the boys in the hospitals getting a raw deal. Did you mean [music] that or is that a thing you say?” Meant it. Then tell me something you know about them that I don’t. Wayne thought about it seriously. I went over there in ‘ 66, he said. To Vietnam.
Shook a lot of hands, ate a lot of bad food. And I’ve been going to the veterans hospitals around here for years, ma’am. Quiet. No cameras. And I’ll tell you the one thing I’ve learned in all that time, in all those wards. Those boys don’t care what you think about the war. And they don’t care what I think about it either. They care whether anybody comes. That’s all.
whether anybody comes and sits down and stays a while and doesn’t look away from the chair. Jane’s eyes had gone bright. [music] She didn’t say anything for a moment. That’s what my picture is about, she said finally. That exactly a man in a chair and whether anybody stays. Then make it, Wayne said. And make it right.
Don’t make it a sermon. I made a sermon. It sold a lot of tickets, and I don’t believe it helped one single boy in one single bed. You make the one that helps. There was a shift in the studio then, the kind an audience feels before the people on stage do. Something brittle had softened.
People who’d been sitting forward with their shoulders up were leaning back. “Can I ask you something?” Jane said. “Go ahead. When they started calling you the Duke and putting you on posters and telling everybody what you stood for, were you ever afraid? Wayne took a long time with that one. Every day, he said, afraid I’d find out they were right about me, that I was just a big fella in a hat that they liked the look of.
She looked at him for a long time. That’s exactly what I’m afraid of, she said, except in reverse. I’m afraid they’ll never let me prove they’re wrong about me and I’ll spend the rest of my life being a photograph. You won’t, Wayne said. You don’t know that. No, he said, “But I know what it looks like when somebody won’t quit.
And you’ve got that look. Your father has it, too. He’d never tell you so, but he has it. They’ll say no to you until they get tired of saying it. Then they’ll say yes and act like it was their idea.” Jane laughed. a real one. The laugh the crew had heard in the hallway that afternoon and hadn’t heard since the curtain opened.
“That’s the most cynical encouragement I’ve ever received.” “It’s not cynical,” Wayne said. “It’s just how it goes in this town.” Johnny, sensing the shape of the moment, asked [music] gently. “Duke, do you think she ought to make that picture about the veterans?” Wayne didn’t hesitate. I think anybody who sat in that ward week after week and can still talk about those boys the way she just did ought to make it.
He said that’s not about whose side she was on. That’s about her being the only person in the room who actually wants it bad enough. And if the studios say nobody wants to see it, then the studios are wrong and she ought to find another studio. He shrugged his big shoulders. I made the Alamo with my own money when nobody else would touch it.
nearly went broke. I’d do it again. Can I tell you what I was actually afraid of? Jane said when you walked out before I moved. Go ahead. I was afraid you’d be charming. That’s what they usually do. They’re charming and the room loves them and I’m the woman who wouldn’t play along, so I moved before you could be charming.
I’m not that charming, Wayne [music] said. No, she agreed. You’re worse. You’re reasonable. The room laughed, and it was the warmest laugh of the night. And then Jane Fonda did the thing the whole room had been waiting for without knowing it. She stood up. The studio went still. For a moment, it looked as if she might be about to walk off, and Johnny’s hand actually moved a fraction of an inch toward her, the way you reach for a glass you think is about to fall.
But she wasn’t leaving. She walked around the end of the desk, passed Johnny, and sat down on the couch in the seat right beside John Wayne, the one she’d refused 15 minutes earlier. She smoothed her skirt and folded her hands and looked at him. “There,” she said. “Now say something to me and let’s see if I get to finish a sentence.
” The room came apart. It wasn’t the applause of a joke. It was the sound an audience makes when it has watched something real close, a circle. It went on long enough that Johnny had to wait it out. And while he waited, he looked into camera one and for a moment dropped the polish entirely. “I have been doing this show for 15 years,” he said.
“And I have never once seen anybody change seats twice.” Wayne turned to Jane. “You’ll finish your sentences, ma’am,” he said. “I’ve been married three times, I learned.” The audience howled. Jane put her face in her hands, laughing. When she came up, she looked at him sideways. “For the record,” she said. “I’d have been fine on the other side of the desk.” “Johnny listens.
Johnny gets paid to listen,” Wayne said. “Apparently, so do I.” Now, the segment went on for a while after that, and the whole temperature of it had changed. Jane asked him with real curiosity what her father had been like on the set of Fort Apache when he was younger than she was now. Quiet, Wayne said. Quieter than me, and that’s saying something.
He’d sit off by himself between takes and not say a word to anybody. Ford used to ri him something terrible. But when the camera rolled, he was the best actor I ever stood next to. I mean that. I’d watch him and think, “How in the world does he make it look like he’s not doing anything at all?” Jane was very still. “He doesn’t talk to me much,” she said quietly about things like that.
“I know,” Wayne said. “He doesn’t talk to anybody much. Men our age, most of us never learned how, but I’ve sat on a porch with your father and I’ve heard him talk about you. He’s proud of you, even when he’s mad as hell at you. maybe especially then. Jane didn’t say anything. She just reached over and put her hand on his arm for one second and took it back.
As the segment wound toward its end, Johnny started the rap and Jane put her hand on the arm of the couch and said, “Wait, let me say one thing. Go ahead. I want to say it to him, actually.” She turned to Wayne. I walked in here tonight loaded. She said, “I’ve been loaded for 5 years. And I pointed it at you because you were standing there.
You could have made me look ridiculous. You had the whole room. Every person out there would have been on your side. You could have made one crack about Hanoi and I’d have been the traitor who wouldn’t sit next to John Wayne and everybody would have gone home laughing at me. Didn’t want the room, Wayne said.
Wanted to know why you moved. That’s the thing, Jane said. Nobody ever asks me why. [music] They just write it down. Johnny looked into the camera one last time before the band came in. I’ll say this, he said. I’ve had a lot of people on that couch who didn’t agree with each other. I have never had two people disagree, switch chairs, disagree some more, and end up on the same side of the desk.
I don’t have a name for what that was. I’m just glad we were rolling. At the last moment, Jane reached over and touched the sleeve of his sport coat just briefly. the gesture of somebody making sure something was real before the lights changed. The show went to commercial. The audience stayed on its feet longer than it usually did.
Doc said afterward that he’d held the closing sting a full bar longer than normal just to let the room finish. Backstage in the corridor behind the set, Jane found Wayne near the stage door before either of them had left. He was leaning on the wall, a little gray in the face, catching his breath. She still had the adrenaline of the whole hour in her.
I meant what I said, she told him. You could have buried me. Wasn’t interested. Why not? Half the men in this town would have taken the shot. Most of them have. Wayne thought about it. Because you weren’t wrong, he said. You were just aiming at the wrong fella. Didn’t seem worth winning an argument you’d already half won. She looked at him for a long moment.
I owe you an apology, she said. A real one, not the one out there. Don’t need one, he said. You said something true in front of a lot of people. That’s a lot rarer than an apology. Still, still, he agreed and let her have it. They stood in the hallway for a minute in the quiet with the stage hands moving around them.
I’m going to make that picture, Jane said. I know. When I do, I’m going to send you the first print, [music] and if there’s a single boy in it who’s made into a cartoon or a speech or a sermon, you can call me up and tell me so. I’ll hold you to it, ma’am.” Johnny came down the corridor on his way out with his coat over his arm and stopped when he saw the two of them.
“I’m not going to ask what that was,” he said. “I’m just going to say thank you for doing it on my show and not on MVs.” You’re welcome, Johnny. Jane said, “You know what the funny thing is?” Johnny [music] said, mostly to Wayne. I’ve had people move chairs before. Nobody ever moved back.
The clip was in the columns by Thursday. The first wave of coverage chased the surface the way it always does. Fonda snubs the Duke. Hanoi Jane plays musical chairs. The headlines wanted a feud because a feud is a headline and a conversation isn’t. And most of the early reporting skipped straight past the 15 minutes that had actually happened after the chair.
But the deeper story came up within a couple of weeks because too many people had been in that room. The columnist from the fourth row wrote a long piece that didn’t use the word snub once. It was about what happens when two people who have been described for their entire careers finally get the chance to describe themselves.
One trade paper ran a short item quoting an unnamed studio executive who said that Fonda had done herself no favors in this town and that the chair business would follow her into every meeting for the rest of her career. The executive was wrong. It took about 4 months to prove it. Coming home opened in February of 1978. It was the picture from the drawer.
Jane Fonda played the wife and John Voit played the young veteran in the wheelchair. The studio had finally said yes and acted just as predicted like it had been their idea all along. A few weeks before it opened, a film can arrived by Courier at a big house on the water in Newport Beach. There was a note taped to the lid in Jane’s handwriting.
It said only, “You said you’d hold me to it.” John Wayne watched it alone in the den late at night with the sound turned up because his hearing wasn’t what it used to be. His secretary said later that she’d come down in the morning and found him still in his chair with the empty reels beside him and that he hadn’t said a word about it at breakfast.
A week later, an envelope arrived at Jane Fonda’s office. There was no letter in it, only a single sheet of paper on which somebody had typed on a manual typewriter that skipped a little on the letter E. Three short lines. No sermon. Every one of those boys got to finish his sentences. Well done. Underneath in pen in a big rough hand were two initials, JW.
Years later, when a reporter asked to see it, she took it down off the wall of her office and held it for a moment before handing it over. “People think this is about the movie,” she said. “It’s not. It’s about a man who disagreed with me about almost everything that ever mattered to either of us and who remembered a thing I said on a talk show and thought it was worth a sheet of paper.
She has kept it in a frame ever since.” In the spring of 1978, John Wayne went into Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston for open heart surgery to replace a failing valve. Among the stacks of cards and telegrams that arrived at his room, his family found one with no return address and a Los Angeles postmark. It said, “Come home.
Somebody has to keep the rest of them honest.” It wasn’t signed. It didn’t need to be. He did come home. But in January of 1979, the doctors found cancer again, this time in his stomach and took most of it out. He came out of that surgery thinner than anybody had ever seen him. Most people assumed they wouldn’t see him in public again.
They were wrong about that, too. On the night of April 9th, 1979, at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion in Los Angeles, John Wayne walked out onto the stage of the Academy Awards to present the award for best picture. He was gaunt, and his suit hung loose on him, and the whole hall rose to its feet and wouldn’t sit down.
He told them that he and Oscar had both been around since 1928 and that they were both a little weatherbeaten, but they were still here and planned to be around a whole lot longer. Earlier that same evening on that same stage, Jane Fonda had won the Academy Award for best actress for coming home.
The picture nobody wanted. The picture about a young man in a wheelchair and whether anybody would stay. The story the crew told afterward, which none of them ever put their name to, was that somewhere backstage that night in a corridor much like the one in Burbank, a woman in a long gown with a gold statue in her hand had stopped in front of an old man in a loose tuxedo who was leaning on the wall, catching his breath.
Nobody heard what she said. Somebody saw him smile and say two words back to her. Which pictures? And they both laughed. John Wayne died nine weeks later on June 11th, 1979 at UCLA Medical Center. He was 72 years old. The clip from that October night in Burbank found its way over the years into a handful of courses on media and communication, where it tends to be shown not as an example of conflict, but as an example of what happens when two people refuse to play the roles the room has already assigned them. She did not become Hanoi Jane. He
did not become the Duke. They became two working people arguing honestly. And somewhere in the middle of it, the argument turned into something much closer to recognition. One instructor said she played it for every incoming class and then asked a single question. At what moment did the argument turn into a conversation? The answers, she said, were always the same.
Which pictures? Johnny Carson used to tell people that of all the nights in 30 years, that one sat in a different place for him. I’ve had guests disagree, he’d say. I’ve had guests walk off. I have never had a guest walk off the couch, sit in the wrong chair, argue with a man for a quarter of an hour, and then walk back and sit down next to him on purpose.
And I’ll tell you what made it work. He never once tried to win. She was ready for a man who tried to win. She’d been fighting that man her whole career. He just asked her a question and waited. Years later, Jane Fonda was asked whether she’d been embarrassed that night. “Oh, terribly,” she said, laughing for about 4 minutes. “Then I was grateful. Embarrassment is cheap.