Hypatia Of Alexandria Was Pulled From Her Carriage By A Mob In March 415. She Was The Most Famous Teacher In The City, And A Church Historian Of Her Own Century Called What Followed A Disgrace
A stone courtyard in hard, golden sunlight, and a crowd packed so tightly that nobody in it can step back.
There is a picture that is meant to show a morning in Alexandria, in the spring of the year 415, and this is what it shows.
In the middle of it stands a woman in a long white dress, tied to a rough wooden post.
Her arms are pulled up above her head, and her wrists are bound to the top of the post with thick, dark rope, wound around and around.
Her dark hair is wild and tangled.
A plain braided belt sits at her waist, and the white cloth of her dress is spotted with dust from the street.
Her head is turned toward the men on her left, and her mouth is wide open, as if she is shouting back at them.
Around her, on every side, are men.
Bearded men in rough brown and cream-colored robes, some of them so close that they could reach out and touch her.
Their mouths are open too.
On the left a man thrusts his open hand toward her face.
Behind him and behind her, fists are raised in the air, and here and there a stick or a short blade is lifted above the heads of the crowd.
On the right, a man in a pale head cloth leans in, shouting.
Behind them all rise the sand-colored columns and walls of an old building, washed in light.
Nobody in the picture is striking her.
Nobody has touched her yet.
There is only a woman tied to a post and a wall of angry men who have not yet decided to stop shouting.
It is not a photograph.
There were no cameras in the fifth century, and no artist painted this scene while it happened.
The picture is a modern reconstruction, made with the look of a film, and parts of it are simply wrong.
The woman it shows looks perhaps thirty-five years old, and the real woman was very likely older, perhaps much older.
She was not tied to a post in a courtyard.
According to the oldest account we have, she was pulled out of her own carriage in a street, on her way home.
But the heart of the picture is true.
In March of the year 415, in the city of Alexandria in Egypt, a crowd of men surrounded a woman named Hypatia.
She was the most famous teacher in the city, a mathematician, an astronomer and a philosopher.
She had no weapon, no guard and no way out.
The men around her were led, the same account says, by a man named Peter, who held the small church office of reader.
They took her to a great building that had once been a temple and was by then a church.
And what they did to her there was so shocking that a Christian historian writing in Constantinople a few years later said it brought shame on the bishop of Alexandria and on the whole church of that city.
Most people who have heard her name know only the ending.
This is the story of how the most respected woman in one of the greatest cities of the ancient world came to be standing alone in front of that crowd, and of what happened to her name in the sixteen centuries since.
To understand why a mob would wait for a teacher in the street, you have to begin with her father.
—
## A father’s daughter
Her father was Theon of Alexandria, a mathematician and astronomer who taught in the city in the second half of the fourth century.
Theon was not a great original thinker, and he did not pretend to be.
His life’s work was something more modest and, in the long run, far more lasting.
He took the great textbooks of Greek science, the books that every educated person was expected to know, and he corrected them, explained them and prepared new editions of them for his students.
One of those books was Euclid’s Elements, the foundation of geometry.
Theon’s edition of Euclid became the standard text.
For more than a thousand years, almost every copy of Euclid that anyone in Europe or the Middle East read came down from his version.
The other great book was the Almagest of Ptolemy, the vast mathematical description of the heavens that astronomers used to predict the movements of the sun, the moon and the planets.
Theon wrote a long commentary on it, book by book.
And on the third book of that commentary, an old heading survives with a remarkable line in it.
It says that the text was an edition revised by the philosopher Hypatia, his daughter.
That is the first time we can see her.
Not in a legend, not in a story about her death, but in a working note at the top of a mathematics book, credited by her father.
We do not know her mother’s name.
We do not know exactly when she was born.
We know that she grew up in a house where the most difficult mathematics of the age was the daily business of the family, and that by the time she was a grown woman, she had gone beyond her father.
—
## The teacher in the philosopher’s cloak
The historian Socrates Scholasticus, who wrote his history of the church in Constantinople in the generation after her death, described her plainly.
He wrote that there was a woman at Alexandria named Hypatia, daughter of the philosopher Theon, and that she had reached such heights in learning and science that she far surpassed all the philosophers of her own time.
He wrote that she had taken up the school of Plato and Plotinus, and that she explained the principles of philosophy to anyone who came to hear her.
Students traveled from far away to learn from her.
He also wrote something that tells us a great deal about the kind of woman she was.
Because of the calm and self-possession she had gained from her studies, she often appeared in public in front of the city’s magistrates.
And she was not embarrassed, he said, to walk into a gathering of men.
That last detail mattered.
In the Roman world, a respectable woman was expected to stay out of public business.
Hypatia did not.
She went where the men of power met, and they listened to her.
A later writer, the philosopher Damascius, whose work survives only in pieces, added a picture of her that has stayed with her ever since.
He said she wrapped herself in the tribon, the plain rough cloak that philosophers wore as a kind of uniform, and walked through the middle of the city, explaining Plato and Aristotle and other philosophers to anyone who wanted to listen.
The Byzantine encyclopedia called the Suda, compiled centuries later from older books, lists the works she was said to have written.
A commentary on Diophantus, the mathematician who studied equations with whole-number answers.
A work called the Astronomical Canon.
A commentary on the Conics of Apollonius, the great book on the curves you get when you slice through a cone.
None of these books survives under her name.
Some scholars believe that parts of her work on Diophantus may lie hidden inside later copies of his text, but nobody can prove it.
What survived was her reputation, and the letters of one of her students.
—
## The letters of Synesius
His name was Synesius, and he came from Cyrene, in what is now Libya.
He was a wealthy young man from a good family, and like many young men of his class, he traveled to Alexandria to study.
He studied with Hypatia, and he never forgot her.
Synesius later became a Christian bishop, the bishop of Ptolemais.
That fact alone tells you something about her circle.
Her students were pagans and Christians alike.
What they shared was not a religion but a love of philosophy and of the kind of mathematics that seemed to them to show the order of the heavens.
More than a hundred and fifty letters by Synesius survive, and several of them are written to Hypatia or speak about her.
In one, he asks her to have an instrument made for him, a hydroscope, a glass tube with weights and markings used to measure the heaviness of liquids.
He describes how it should be built, as if he knew she would understand at once.
In another work, he describes a silver astrolabe, a flat instrument for showing the positions of the stars, which he had made as a gift for a high official, and he makes it clear that it was Hypatia who had taught him how to build it.
And in a letter written when he was ill and grieving, after he had lost his children, he addressed her with words that have been quoted ever since.
He called her his mother, his sister, his teacher and his benefactor.
Synesius died around the year 413.
He did not live to see what happened to her two years later.
His letters are the warmest record we have of who she was while she was alive.
They show a teacher whose students kept writing to her for the rest of their lives.
—
## A city that had already burned once
Alexandria in her time was still one of the largest cities in the Roman world.
It had been founded by Alexander the Great more than seven hundred years earlier.
It had been the capital of the Ptolemies and of Cleopatra.
It was a port, a grain city, a city of scholars, and a city with a long reputation for street violence.
By the late fourth century, the Roman Empire had become officially Christian.
Emperors passed laws closing temples and forbidding sacrifice.
In Alexandria, those laws came down on a city where pagans, Christians and Jews had lived side by side, and quarreled, for centuries.
In the year 391, the bishop of Alexandria, a hard and forceful man named Theophilus, led the destruction of the Serapeum, the great temple of the god Serapis on its hill above the city.
It had been one of the wonders of Alexandria.
There was fighting in the streets.
Some pagans barricaded themselves in the temple.
When it was over, the great statue of the god was broken apart, and the temple was torn down.
Hypatia was already a grown woman and a teacher when that happened.
She lived through it.
As far as we know, she did not join the pagans who fought.
She went on teaching, and for more than twenty years after the fall of the Serapeum, she was left in peace.
Then, in October 412, Theophilus died.
—
## The new bishop
The man who took his place was his nephew, Cyril.
Cyril’s election was itself a riot.
Socrates says there was a contest between Cyril and an archdeacon named Timothy, that the city split into factions, and that Cyril won with the help of the crowd.
He was young, ambitious and very able.
He would later become one of the most important theologians in the history of the church, honored as a saint in both the Eastern and Western churches for his writings about the nature of Christ.
He was also, from the first, a bishop who meant to use the power of his office in the streets.
Socrates says that Cyril took on more authority than the bishop of Alexandria had ever held before, reaching into matters that belonged to the civil government.
That set him on a collision course with the most powerful official in Egypt.
—
## The prefect
His name was Orestes.
He was the Augustal prefect, the governor sent by the imperial court to rule Egypt in the emperor’s name.
He was a Christian.
He had been baptized by the bishop of Constantinople.
But he resented the way the bishop of Alexandria was taking over the work of government, and he did not intend to give way.
The trouble broke out in the theater.
Socrates tells the story in detail.
The Jewish community of Alexandria liked to gather in the theater on the Sabbath to watch dancing performances, and these shows often ended in fights.
One day, while Orestes was publishing new rules about the shows, some of Cyril’s followers came to hear them.
Among them was a schoolteacher named Hierax, a keen supporter of the bishop, who was known for leading the applause at Cyril’s sermons.
Members of the Jewish crowd shouted that Hierax had come only to stir up trouble.
Orestes, who already resented Cyril, had Hierax seized and punished publicly, right there in the theater.
Cyril answered with threats against the leaders of the Jewish community.
Then, according to Socrates, some of the Jewish residents laid a trap at night.
They raised a cry that a church was on fire, and when Christians came running out to save it, they were attacked, and a number of them died.
The next morning, Cyril went at the head of a large crowd to the synagogues, took them over, and drove the Jewish residents out of the city.
Their property was plundered.
The Jewish community had lived in Alexandria since the city was founded.
Now a bishop had expelled it, without any order from the emperor.
Orestes was furious.
He wrote to the emperor.
So did Cyril.
The city held its breath.
Socrates says the people of Alexandria pressed Cyril to make peace with the prefect, and that Cyril went to Orestes holding out the book of the Gospels, as a sign of reconciliation.
Orestes refused it.
—
## Five hundred monks from Nitria
South of Alexandria, out in the desert, lay the mountain of Nitria, where thousands of monks lived in cells and communities.
Some of them were fierce men, ready to fight for their bishop.
When they heard that the prefect had refused to make peace, about five hundred of them came into the city.
They waited for Orestes as he drove out in his chariot.
They surrounded it and shouted at him, calling him a pagan and a worshipper of idols.
Orestes, who suspected what was coming, shouted back that he was a Christian and had been baptized by the bishop of Constantinople.
It did no good.
One of the monks, a man named Ammonius, threw a stone, and it struck Orestes on the head.
Blood ran down his face.
Most of his guards ran away.
It was the ordinary people of the city who came to the rescue, driving the monks off and seizing Ammonius.
Orestes had Ammonius questioned under torture, in public, and Ammonius died of it.
Cyril took the body into a church, gave the dead monk a new name, Thaumasius, which means “the admirable,” and spoke of him as a martyr.
Socrates, who was himself a Christian, did not approve.
He wrote that the more sober-minded Christians did not accept that Ammonius was a martyr at all, because he had been punished for his rashness and had not died for refusing to deny Christ.
Cyril, he says, let the matter fade into silence.
But the city did not forget.
The prefect and the bishop were now open enemies.
And many people began to look for someone to blame for the fact that they would not make peace.
—
## The woman at the prefect’s door
This is where Hypatia enters the story of the quarrel.
Socrates says it plainly.
Because Hypatia often met and talked with Orestes, a slander spread among the Christian population of the city that she was the one preventing Orestes from making peace with the bishop.
It is easy to see how the rumor grew.
She was the most respected philosopher in Alexandria.
The leading men of the city, Orestes among them, came to her for advice.
She was a pagan at a time when the old religion was being driven out of public life.
She was a woman who did not keep to the women’s quarters.
And she was close to the one man who stood in the bishop’s way.
There is no evidence at all that she was doing what the rumor said.
There is no letter, no speech, no word from Orestes or anyone else to suggest that she was urging him to fight.
The rumor needed no evidence.
It only needed a city that was already angry.
A much later source, the bishop John of Nikiu, who wrote in Egypt in the seventh century and who approved of what was done to her, shows what that rumor could become.
He wrote that she was devoted at all times to magic, to astrolabes and to instruments of music, and that she had bewitched the prefect and many others through the arts of Satan.
The astrolabe, the instrument she used to teach the movements of the stars, had become in the mouths of her enemies a tool of sorcery.
—
## The crowd at her house
There is one more story, and it must be told with care.
Damascius, the pagan philosopher who wrote about a hundred years after her death, says that one day Cyril was passing her house and saw a great crowd at the door, people and horses, some arriving, some leaving, some waiting.
He asked what the crowd was, and whose house it was.
He was told that it was the house of the philosopher Hypatia, and that she was receiving visitors.
When he heard that, Damascius says, Cyril was so struck with envy that he began at once to plan her death.
That is a serious charge, and it comes from a man who hated the Christian bishops and wrote long after the event.
No modern historian can take it as proof.
But it captures something true about her place in the city.
Her door was crowded.
People of rank came to her.
In a city where the bishop was trying to make himself the center of everything, a pagan woman whose house drew a crowd every day was a standing reminder that not everyone looked to him.
Whether Cyril ever ordered anything is something no surviving document can tell us.
What the oldest account does tell us is what happened next.
—
## March, in the season of Lent
Socrates gives the date with care.
It happened in the month of March, during Lent, in the fourth year of Cyril’s time as bishop, in the year when Honorius was consul for the tenth time and Theodosius for the sixth.
By our reckoning, that is March of the year 415.
He does not give the exact day.
Some modern retellings say it happened on the fifteenth of March, the old Ides, but no ancient source says so.
Some of the men who believed the rumor, Socrates writes, were carried away by a fierce and fanatical zeal.
Their leader was a man named Peter, a reader, one of the minor officers of the church who read the scriptures aloud during services.
They lay in wait for her as she was returning home.
When her carriage came by, they dragged her out of it.
That is the moment the picture is trying to show.
Not a post and not a rope, but a woman pulled from her carriage into a street full of men who had been waiting for her.
They took her to the church called the Caesareum.
The oldest account says that there they tore off her clothes, and that they took her life with ostraka, a Greek word that means broken pieces of pottery or roof tiles.
Socrates then says that they tore her body apart and carried what was left to a place called Cinaron, and burned it there.
That is all the oldest account says, and it is enough.
It takes Socrates only a few lines to tell it.
There is no need to add anything to them.
—
## The church that had been a temple
The building they dragged her to had a long history of its own.
The Caesareum had been begun, according to ancient writers, by Cleopatra in honor of Mark Antony, and completed by Augustus after he defeated them both.
It became a temple to the worship of the emperors.
In front of it stood two tall granite obelisks, already more than a thousand years old, which the Romans had brought from the ancient city of Heliopolis.
By Hypatia’s time, the old temple of the emperors had become a church.
It was one of the most important churches in Alexandria.
The two obelisks that once stood before its doors still exist.
They are known today as Cleopatra’s Needles.
In the nineteenth century, one was taken to London and set up on the bank of the Thames, and the other was taken to New York and set up in Central Park.
Millions of people walk past those stones every year.
Very few of them know that the last place Hypatia was taken in her life was the building that stood behind them.
—
## What the Christian historian wrote
It would be easy to tell this story as if every Christian in Alexandria cheered.
That is not what the sources say.
The most important account of her death was written by a Christian.
Socrates Scholasticus was a lawyer in Constantinople, and his history of the church is careful, fair-minded and often critical of bishops who used violence.
After telling what was done to her, he wrote that this affair brought no small shame upon Cyril and upon the whole church of Alexandria.
And he added that nothing could be further from the spirit of Christianity than allowing massacres, fights and deeds of that kind.
That judgment, written by a churchman within a generation of her death, is one of the reasons we can trust his account.
He had no reason to invent a crime that disgraced his own church.
On the other side stood writers like John of Nikiu, two centuries later, who praised the crowd and called Cyril “the new Theophilus,” because, he said, Cyril had destroyed the last remnants of idolatry in the city.
So the sources do not line up neatly by religion.
A Christian historian condemned the killing.
A Christian bishop, much later, celebrated it.
A pagan philosopher blamed Cyril’s envy.
The truth that all of them share is the simplest part: a learned woman was seized by a crowd led by a church reader named Peter, and she did not come home.
—
## How old was she?
The picture shows a young woman with dark hair and smooth skin.
The real Hypatia was almost certainly older.
Her birth year is not recorded.
Modern estimates run from about the year 350 to about 370.
An early date would mean she was around sixty-five when she died.
The later date, which many scholars have preferred, would still make her about forty-five.
The sixth-century chronicler John Malalas, writing about her death, called her an old woman.
Her student Synesius, writing to her in the first years of the fifth century, wrote as a grown man to a respected elder teacher.
Whatever her exact age, the woman who was pulled from her carriage that March was not a young beauty, as many later paintings and films would show her.
She was a teacher at the end of a long career, someone who had taught two generations of the leading men of Egypt and Libya, and who still drove home through the streets of her own city as if she had nothing to fear.
—
## The words nobody wrote down
No ancient writer records a single word that Hypatia said on the last day of her life.
Some modern retellings put a speech in her mouth.
Some say she lectured on geometry to the end.
None of that appears in any ancient source.
The short lines used in the video that goes with this story are imagined.
They are not quotations, and they should not be repeated as if they were.
They were written to fit what we do know about her: that she was a teacher whose students came from far away, that she taught the movements of the stars, and that she spoke calmly in front of men in power.
In the video, she says to the men around her: “Ask me a question. I will answer you.”
She says: “I have taught your sons to measure the stars.”
And at the end she says: “You can silence me, but you cannot change what is true.”
She may have said nothing at all.
The only thing the record gives us is the silence after.
—
## The law that came after
The killing of Hypatia did not lead to a trial.
No one is known to have been punished for it.
But something did change.
In the autumn of the following year, in 416, the imperial government issued a law about the parabalani of Alexandria.
The parabalani were a body of men attached to the bishop’s church, officially charged with caring for the sick, who had also become a kind of street force that the bishop could call on.
The new law, preserved in the collection of Roman laws called the Theodosian Code, limited their number to five hundred, placed them under the oversight of the prefect, and forbade them from appearing at public shows, in the law courts or at the city council.
The city council of Alexandria had sent its own embassy to the imperial court in Constantinople.
Many historians believe that the law was the empire’s answer to the violence of the years 414 and 415, including her death, although the law itself does not name her.
It did not last.
Less than two years later, in 418, a new law raised their number to six hundred and gave control of them back to the bishop.
Cyril remained bishop of Alexandria until his death in 444.
Orestes disappears from the record.
We do not know what became of him after the murder of the woman whose friendship had been used against her.
—
## Was the bishop guilty?
For sixteen centuries, people have argued about how much Cyril was to blame.
Those who accuse him point to the facts.
His quarrel with Orestes was the reason the rumor spread.
The men who seized her were led by an officer of his church.
They took her to his church.
Nobody was punished.
And a Christian historian of the next generation wrote that the affair brought shame upon him.
Those who defend him point to other facts.
No source written in his own time says that he ordered the attack.
Socrates, who blamed him for creating the climate of violence, does not say that he gave any command.
The story of his envy at her crowded door comes from a pagan writer a century later who had every reason to make him look as bad as possible.
The most careful historians usually end somewhere in between.
Cyril may not have ordered her death.
But he had spent three years teaching the city that violence in his name could go unpunished, and he had let a crowd of monks turn a stone thrown at the governor into a martyrdom.
When the crowd came for Hypatia, it came out of the world he had made.
—
## The legend grows
For a long time after her death, Hypatia was remembered mainly by scholars who read Socrates and the Suda.
That changed in the eighteenth century.
In 1720, the Irish writer John Toland published a pamphlet about her with a long and furious title, using her death as a weapon in his own fight against the power of the clergy.
Voltaire wrote about her in the same spirit.
Edward Gibbon told her story in his great history of the decline and fall of the Roman Empire, in a passage that made her a symbol of reason destroyed by fanaticism.
In 1853, the English clergyman and novelist Charles Kingsley published a novel called Hypatia, which turned her into a romantic heroine and was read by a huge audience.
In 1885, the painter Charles William Mitchell painted her alone in a church in the moment before the end, in a picture now in Newcastle, in the north of England.
It became one of the most famous images of her, and like so many later images, it showed her young.
In 1980, the astronomer Carl Sagan told her story on television in his series Cosmos and linked her death to the end of the great Library of Alexandria.
Most historians today do not accept that link.
The great Library had declined long before her lifetime, and there is no evidence that any library was destroyed when she died.
In 2009, the Spanish director Alejandro Amenábar made a film about her called Agora, with the actress Rachel Weisz in the role.
Along the way, the story kept growing.
Some retellings say the attack lasted an hour.
Some say the crowd sang hymns.
Some say she spoke of mathematics to the very end.
Some give her a loyal servant who fought for her, or a student whose trial she was going to attend.
None of those details appears in any ancient source.
They were added by people who wanted the story to be even more terrible than it was, as if the plain facts were not terrible enough.
—
## What she left behind
Her own books are lost.
Her name was not.
The edition of the third book of Ptolemy’s astronomy that bears her name, through her father’s commentary, is still read by historians of science.
The letters of Synesius still carry her voice, second-hand, asking and answering questions about instruments and stars.
A crater on the Moon is named after her.
So is an asteroid, discovered in the nineteenth century and named 238 Hypatia.
A leading journal of feminist philosophy, founded in the 1980s, carries her name.
And in the long argument about what happened in Alexandria, she has become something she never chose to be, a symbol.
To some she is a martyr of science.
To others she is a victim of politics, caught between a governor and a bishop.
To others she is the first great woman mathematician whose name we know.
What the sources actually show is smaller and sharper than any of those symbols.
A teacher who was respected by pagans and Christians alike.
A woman who walked into meetings of powerful men without fear.
A rumor that she had no way to answer.
And a crowd that was waiting in the street when she drove home.
—
## The picture, once more
Now it is possible to say what is true in it.
The crowd is true.
A crowd of men, led by a church reader named Peter, did wait for her and seize her.
Her helplessness is true.
She had no weapon and no guard, and the most powerful official in Egypt, the man whose friendship had made her a target, was not there to save her.
The light is true in its way, too.
It happened in the spring, in the season of Lent, in a city of white stone under the Egyptian sun.
What the picture gets wrong is almost everything else.
There was no post and no rope.
She was older than the woman in the picture, probably much older.
The scene took place in a street and then inside a church, not in a courtyard of shouting men.
And what the picture cannot show is everything around that moment.
The schoolroom where students came from across the sea to hear her.
The father’s book with her name written at the top.
The letters of a bishop who called her mother, sister and teacher.
The prefect with blood on his face from a monk’s stone.
The rumor that went from mouth to mouth in a city that was already burning with anger.
In the picture, the men are still shouting, and nobody has touched her yet.
In the story, they did not stop.
And a Christian historian, writing in the next generation, set down the plain facts and called it a shame on the whole church of the city, so that nobody who came after could say they did not know.