Henry I — The King Who Ate The Fish His Doctor Forbade And Died From Diarrhea
The smell spread across the hall before anyone understood where it was coming from.
It was sour and heavy, like a cesspit opened in high summer, and it rolled over the long table, over the bread and the wine cups and the picked-over dishes, until one by one the men and women on the benches lifted their hands to their faces.
Nobody said a word.
Nobody had to.
The king of England was standing in the middle of the floor with his back to them.
He had pushed his chair away from the table a moment earlier, as if he meant to walk to the fire, and then he had stopped halfway across the tiles, as if somebody had called his name.
Now he was bent forward over his own stomach, and the gold cloth of his tunic was trembling.
It was late November 1135, in a hunting lodge in the forest of Lyons, in Normandy, a long day’s ride from Rouen.
Until a moment ago the hall had smelled of woodsmoke, wet wool, tired hounds and roasted meat, the smell of a good day’s hunting.
Behind him, on the table, sat a dish that was almost empty.
It had held lampreys, the dish he loved more than any other in the world, and the one dish his physician had told him, that very evening, not to touch.
He was about sixty-seven years old.
He had ruled England for thirty-five years and Normandy for almost thirty.
He had beaten his own brother in battle and locked him away for the rest of his life.
He had thrown a man from a tower with his own hands.
He turned his head, slowly, and looked over his shoulder at the people on the benches.
His face had gone the color of old tallow.
“My physician told me not to touch them.”
Then the next cramp took him, and he could not say anything at all.
Was it only a bad dish of fish?
Or had the dish simply woken up something that was already waiting inside him?
Within a week he would be dead.
Within days of that, his corpse would kill one more man, the last of the many who had died because of him.
Within three weeks his crown would be sitting on the head of a man who had sworn an oath, in front of the whole court, to give it to someone else.
And that man was alive at all only because of a decision he had made on a dock at Barfleur fifteen years earlier, on the worst night of Henry’s life, for a reason so ordinary, and so undignified, that a monk wrote it down in his chronicle.
You will hear what it was before the end.
—
## Why the youngest son was never supposed to wear a crown
He was born in England in 1068, probably in Yorkshire, the fourth son of William the Conqueror and Matilda of Flanders.
He was the only one of the Conqueror’s sons born after the conquest, which meant he was the only one born the son of a king.
It did him no good at all.
When his father died at Rouen in September 1087, the inheritance was divided the way the great families of Normandy always divided things.
Robert, the eldest, got Normandy.
William, the second surviving son, called Rufus for his red face, got England.
Henry, nineteen years old, got money: five thousand pounds of silver.
The monk Orderic Vitalis, who knew men who had been there, wrote that Henry had the silver weighed out carefully, so that not one penny was missing.
It is the first thing we are told about his character, and it tells us almost everything.
He was the only son present when his father was buried in the abbey church of Saint-Étienne at Caen.
It was not a dignified funeral.
The Conqueror’s body had swollen in the heat, and when the attendants forced it into a stone coffin that was too small, it broke open.
The stench drove the clergy through the rest of the service as fast as they could chant it, while the incense burners swung and swung and did nothing.
Henry stood in that church and breathed it.
He could not have known that his own body would one day be carried back into the same building, in a worse state than his father’s.
For the next thirteen years he was a landless prince with a chest of silver, buying a piece of Normandy from one brother, losing it to both of them, besieged on a rock in the sea until his men ran short of water.
In 1090, during a revolt in Rouen, he did something that men remembered for a century.
A rich citizen named Conan Pilatus had led the city’s rebels.
When the revolt failed, Henry took Conan up to the top of the castle tower, showed him the countryside spread out below, told him to look at it well, and then pushed him out of the window.
The place was called Conan’s Leap afterward.
Contemporaries did not think Henry had done anything wrong.
A traitor was a traitor.
In August 1100 he went hunting in the New Forest with his brother the king.
His brother did not come home.
—
## The arrow in the New Forest, and the three-day race for a crown
On the afternoon of August 2, 1100, an arrow struck William Rufus in the chest under the trees of the New Forest.
The man most often blamed was a French knight named Walter Tirel, who swore for the rest of his life that he had not fired it.
Charcoal burners, the story goes, carried the king’s body to Winchester in a cart, dripping.
Henry did not wait for the cart.
He rode for Winchester at once, where the royal treasury was kept, and demanded the keys.
The keeper, William of Breteuil, tried to stand in his way, saying that the crown belonged by oath to Robert, the eldest brother, who was on his way home from the crusade.
Henry, by one account, drew his sword.
He got the keys.
Three days after the arrow, on August 5, he was crowned in Westminster Abbey.
Did he arrange his brother’s death?
Writers have been asking that question for nine hundred years.
No chronicler of the time accused him of it.
The speed of it all looks suspicious only because Henry was always fast, always ready, always the man with a plan for the moment after.
It is equally possible that he simply understood, better than anyone else in that forest, that a crown lies on the ground for a few hours at most before somebody picks it up.
Remember that idea.
Someone else would learn it from him.
Within months he married Edith of Scotland, a princess of the old English royal line, who took the Norman name Matilda.
He issued a charter of liberties promising to end his brother’s abuses.
And in 1101, when Robert landed in England to take back what he believed was his, Henry talked him out of fighting and paid him to go home.
Five years later he stopped paying.
On September 28, 1106, at Tinchebray in Normandy, Henry’s army destroyed Robert’s in about an hour.
Robert was taken prisoner.
Henry kept him for the rest of his life, moved from castle to castle, at Devizes, at Bristol, finally at Cardiff, in reasonable comfort and under permanent guard.
Robert lived as a prisoner for twenty-eight years.
He died at Cardiff in 1134, at about eighty, one year before the brother who had locked him away.
Henry now held everything his father had held.
There was only one thing he still needed, and it could not be won in battle.
He needed a son who would outlive him.
—
## The king who counted every penny, and forgot nothing
The England Henry built was the most closely governed kingdom in Europe.
Twice a year his officials sat around a great table covered with a cloth marked in squares like a chessboard, moving counters from square to square while sheriffs from every county stood before them and accounted for every penny they owed the king.
The chessboard gave the office its name: the Exchequer.
The oldest surviving record of its accounts, the great roll of 1130, is still kept in the National Archives.
He moved constantly, with his court, his clerks, his bed and his kitchen, from castle to manor to abbey.
His household had written rules for everything, down to how many candles each official could claim and how much bread and wine.
Chroniclers called him the Lion of Justice.
Later writers called him Beauclerc, the good scholar, because he could read Latin.
He was also, by the standards of a hard century, frightening.
In 1119, his own daughter Juliane, married to a rebel lord, tried to kill him.
She stood on the walls of the castle of Breteuil and shot a crossbow bolt at her father during a parley.
She missed.
Trapped, she escaped by leaping from the walls into the icy water of the moat.
The story behind her rage is worse.
Earlier that winter, in a quarrel over hostages, her husband had blinded the young son of one of Henry’s castellans.
Henry, to keep his word to the boy’s father, allowed Juliane’s two little daughters, his own granddaughters, to be blinded and mutilated in return.
That was the man.
He forgot nothing and he forgave very little.
And yet he had a weakness, and the chroniclers wrote it down.
Henry of Huntingdon, an archdeacon who lived through his reign, said there was one food the king loved more than any other.
It always made him ill.
He always ate it anyway.
The man who could govern a kingdom down to the last candle could not govern his own appetite.
In 1130, in Normandy, the king had nightmares so violent that his physician, a man named Grimbald, was said to have watched him leap from his bed and grab for his sword.
In the dreams, peasants came at him with pitchforks, then knights with drawn swords, then bishops with their pointed staffs.
A chronicle written at Worcester drew all three scenes, with the king asleep and the crowds standing over him.
By then he had good reason to dream badly.
Ten years earlier, everything he had built had gone to the bottom of the sea.
—
## The night the White Ship sailed without one of its passengers
On the evening of November 25, 1120, the king’s fleet lay in the harbor of Barfleur, on the Normandy coast, ready to cross to England.
A sailor named Thomas FitzStephen came to the king with an offer.
His father, he said, had captained the ship that carried William the Conqueror to England in 1066.
Now Thomas had the finest ship in the harbor, the White Ship, newly fitted, and he asked for the honor of carrying the king.
Henry had already chosen his ship.
But he told Thomas he could carry his son.
William Adelin was seventeen, the only son of Henry and his late queen, the heir to England and Normandy, the reason for everything.
He went aboard with his half-brother Richard, his half-sister Matilda, Countess of Perche, and a crowd of the richest young nobles in the kingdom.
They asked for wine, and William had barrels of it sent to the crew.
The king’s ship sailed in the early evening.
The White Ship did not.
On board, the young passengers drank and laughed and jeered at the priests who came to bless the voyage.
The rowers drank as much as anyone.
The plan was simple and boastful: leave late, row hard, and overtake the king’s ship before it reached England.
Not everyone liked what they saw.
A few passengers walked back down the gangplank before the ship left the harbor.
Orderic Vitalis says they did not like the crowd of wild, headstrong young men on board.
One of them was the king’s favorite nephew, a handsome twenty-something lord named Stephen of Blois.
Orderic also wrote down the exact reason Stephen gave for leaving.
Hold on to that.
In the dark, with about three hundred people aboard, the White Ship rowed at full speed out of Barfleur harbor and struck a rock just under the water.
The rock tore open the port side.
The ship rolled over.
William Adelin was put into a small boat and was being rowed clear when he heard his half-sister screaming in the water.
He ordered the boat back.
So many people grabbed at it that it went under, and the heir to England went under with it.
By morning there was one survivor: a butcher from Rouen named Berold, who had clung to a spar through the November night in a coat of thick ramskins.
Thomas FitzStephen, Orderic says, came up beside the wreck, asked what had become of the king’s son, heard that he was gone, and let himself sink rather than face the king.
Nobody at court dared to tell Henry.
For a time the lords went about with their faces arranged, until at last a young boy was sent in to throw himself at the king’s feet, weeping, and tell him what had happened.
Henry fell to the floor.
He was fifty-two years old.
His queen was already dead.
He had at least twenty children by other women, sons he loved and made into earls, daughters he married to lords across Normandy and Britain.
None of them could inherit a crown.
He married again, a young bride from Louvain named Adeliza, and waited for a son.
No son came.
He had fifteen years left.
He spent most of them making men swear oaths.
—
## The oath that every great man in England swore, and then forgot
There was one legitimate child left: a daughter.
Her name was Matilda, and she had been sent abroad at eight to marry the Holy Roman Emperor.
She came back in 1126, a widow of twenty-four who still called herself the Empress, who had governed in Italy for her husband, and who had very little patience with men who did not do what she told them.
At Christmas 1126, Henry assembled the great men of the kingdom and made them swear to accept her as his heir.
One of the first to swear was King David of Scotland, her uncle.
Then came Henry’s nephew Stephen of Blois and the king’s eldest illegitimate son, Robert, Earl of Gloucester.
William of Malmesbury, who knew Robert, says the two men argued over which of them had the honor of swearing first.
Stephen swore with his hand on the oath, in front of everyone.
Remember that, too.
Henry then married his daughter, against her wishes, to Geoffrey of Anjou, a boy of fourteen, eleven years younger than she was.
The marriage was miserable.
But in March 1133 it produced a son, named Henry after his grandfather, and the old king was overjoyed.
His bloodline was safe again.
In August 1133 he crossed to Normandy for the last time.
He never saw England again.
Within two years he and his daughter were at war.
Matilda and Geoffrey demanded that the castles of southern Normandy be handed over to her while her father was still alive, and that the Norman barons swear loyalty to her now.
Henry refused.
He did not trust Geoffrey, and he did not hand over power to anyone.
When a border lord, William Talvas, Count of Ponthieu, rose against him in 1135, Matilda and Geoffrey took the rebel’s side.
So in the autumn of 1135 the king was in Normandy, sixty-seven years old, fighting his own daughter’s allies, the oath to her still standing and the relationship in pieces.
He was, by every account, in good health.
In late November he rode into the forest of Lyons to hunt.
—
## A fish with a mouth like a ring of teeth
The forest of Lyons lies east of Rouen, a great expanse of beech trees on rolling ground.
Henry had built himself a castle there, a royal lodge at the edge of the woods, and he hunted the forest every chance he had.
Huntingdon names the place: Saint-Denis, in the wood of Lyons.
The hunt was good.
The king came back in the evening hungry.
On the table that night there were lampreys.
A lamprey is not quite a fish, or not the kind anyone would choose to look at.
It is long and slick and boneless, like an eel, with no jaws at all.
Where its mouth should be there is a round sucking disc, lined with rings of small, hooked teeth.
It fastens that disc to the side of a living fish, rasps through the scales and feeds on the blood.
The great men of medieval Europe adored them.
Lampreys were rich, fatty and expensive.
They could be eaten on fast days, when meat was forbidden, because the Church counted them as fish.
Cooks stewed them in wine and their own blood, or baked them whole in pastry, with spices.
Kings sent for them from rivers hundreds of miles away.
Henry of Huntingdon says plainly that the king was always fond of them, and that they always disagreed with him.
That evening, his physician told him not to eat them.
We do not know the physician’s name.
We do not know how he said it, whether he warned once and quietly, or argued at length while the dish sat steaming.
Huntingdon gives us only what mattered to him: the doctor forbade it, and the king would not take the advice.
Picture the old man at the head of the table, still in his hunting clothes, the hall full of hounds and huntsmen and the smell of wet leaves.
He had ruled for thirty-five years.
He had outlived a brother, a wife, a son.
He had been told what to do by no one since 1100.
“I am the king, and I eat what I please.”
Those may not have been his words.
They were certainly his answer.
He ate them, and by every account he ate a great many.
A later age turned it into a phrase that every English schoolchild once learned: Henry I died of a surfeit of lampreys.
For a few hours, nothing happened.
Then, that night, his body began to argue back.
—
## Seven days in the lodge at Lyons
It began, as these things do, with a chill.
The king was cold when the fire was hot.
His hands shook.
Then the cramps came, low in his belly, rolling up like waves, each one harder than the one before, until he was bent double on whatever bench or bed was nearest.
And then his bowels gave way.
Not once.
Again, and again, through the night, with no warning and no end.
Huntingdon, writing as a churchman, puts it in the language of the medicine of his day.
The food, he says, brought a terrible chill into the old man’s body, and a sudden, violent upheaval of everything inside him.
Everyone in that lodge would have understood exactly what that meant, and so would everyone who read it.
The king’s body was emptying itself, and it would not stop.
Medieval lodges were not built for sickness.
There were no washrooms, no running water, no closed drains.
There were chamber pots, and basins, and a narrow garderobe built into the wall that dropped away to a pit below.
There was straw, and linen, and servants carrying water up from the well by the bucket.
The servants came and went all night with basins, with fresh linen, with hot stones wrapped in cloth for his stomach.
The soiled linen went out in armfuls.
The smell did not.
It soaked into the bed hangings and the wall hangings and the rushes on the floor.
Someone burned herbs, rosemary or juniper or whatever was in the stores, and the smoke hung in the room and mixed with the stench into something worse.
Men who came to the door to ask after the king stood in the doorway and did not come in.
By the second day the fever had come.
By the third, the physicians understood that they were losing him.
They had very little to fight with.
Medicine in 1135 was the medicine of the four humors: blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile, which had to be kept in balance.
A man who was purging himself to death was, in their eyes, a man whose humors had been thrown into chaos by a cold, wet, poisonous food.
The usual remedies were warming drinks, spiced wine, broths, rest, prayer, and sometimes the opening of a vein.
None of it worked, because none of it could.
What dysentery-like sickness or food poisoning does to a man of sixty-seven is very simple and very cruel.
It takes the water out of him.
His mouth goes dry and his lips crack.
His eyes sink.
His heart races and his skin, pinched between two fingers, stays pinched.
He grows confused and then very tired.
The king who had weighed out five thousand pounds of silver at nineteen, so that no penny was missing, could no longer keep a cup of water inside himself.
He knew what it meant.
He had seen men die in camps of the bloody flux.
On one of those nights, with the servants carrying the basins out past the earls in the corridor, he sent for the one man in Normandy who could prepare his soul.
“Send for the Archbishop of Rouen, and send for him now.”
Hugh of Amiens, Archbishop of Rouen, rode into the forest and came to the bedside.
Afterward he wrote a letter to Pope Innocent II describing what he saw, and it is the closest thing we have to an eyewitness account of the king’s last days.
He found Henry, he wrote, in great distress.
The king confessed his sins.
He received absolution.
And then, over three days, he confessed again, and again, as if he did not trust a single absolution to be enough.
He gave orders.
All his debts were to be paid.
All the wages owed to his servants and soldiers were to be paid.
Men whose lands he had seized were to have them back.
Men he had sent into exile could come home.
Alms were to be given to the poor.
The man who forgot nothing was trying to settle every account before the last one came due.
His son Robert, Earl of Gloucester, came, and other great lords with him.
Orderic Vitalis names them: William of Warenne, Earl of Surrey; Waleran, Count of Meulan, and his twin brother Robert, Earl of Leicester; and Rotrou, Count of Perche, whose wife, the king’s daughter Matilda, had drowned on the White Ship fifteen years before.
They stood around the bed in a room that smelled like death, with handkerchiefs at their faces, and listened.
What did the king say about his heir?
William of Malmesbury, who later wrote with Robert of Gloucester as his patron, says that Henry left all his lands, on both sides of the sea, to his daughter Matilda.
He also says the king told Robert to take sixty thousand pounds from the treasure at Falaise and pay his household and his mercenaries, so that nobody would go unpaid.
Others would later swear that he said something else entirely.
By the end of the week he was barely conscious.
The great body that had sat a horse from dawn to dusk, that had carried armor into battle at Tinchebray and Brémule, lay sunken in a bed that the servants could no longer keep clean.
His breathing slowed.
On the night of Sunday, December 1, 1135, Henry I, King of England and Duke of Normandy, died in the lodge at Lyons.
He had eaten his last dish of lampreys about a week before.
The men in the room crossed themselves.
And then they faced the problem that every royal household faced when a king died far from his tomb.
They had to move him.
—
## The man who opened the king’s head
The earls lifted the body themselves.
Orderic says that the greatest lords of Normandy carried their dead king out of the forest and down the road to Rouen, a cortege of armed men and torches moving through the bare November woods.
At Rouen the body was prepared for the long journey to England.
That meant embalming, and embalming in 1135 was butchery with prayers said over it.
The king’s entrails were removed and buried at the priory of Notre-Dame-du-Pré, just outside the city.
Huntingdon adds that his brain and his eyes were buried with them.
Getting the brain out of the skull was the job nobody wanted.
A man was hired for it, and paid a great deal of money.
He wrapped his head in thick linen cloths, against the smell.
He opened the king’s head with an axe and took out the brain.
And then, Huntingdon says, he died.
The stench, the chronicler wrote, killed him, though he had covered his face.
He earned his wages dearly.
And then Huntingdon added a line that is still quoted nine centuries later.
This man, he said, was the last of the many whom King Henry had put to death.
Whether the embalmer really died of the smell, or of some infection from the corpse, or of something that had nothing to do with the king at all, we cannot know.
Huntingdon was a moralist, and he liked a story with a sting in its tail.
But he lived through these years, and he was writing for readers who could have checked.
The rest of the body was slashed all over with knives, packed with salt, and sewn up inside the hides of oxen, layer on layer, to hold in the smell.
It was not enough.
From Rouen the cortege went on to Caen, to the abbey church of Saint-Étienne, where Henry’s father lay.
It was the same church where, forty-eight years before, a nineteen-year-old prince had stood and breathed the stench of his father’s broken coffin.
Now he lay in front of the same altar himself.
The weather turned.
The winter gales in the Channel would not let the ships cross.
For weeks, through Advent and into Christmas, the body lay on its bier in the abbey church at Caen.
And Huntingdon says that through all the salt and all the hides, a black and horrible fluid seeped out of it, without stopping.
The monks set vessels under the bier to catch it.
Attendants, sick with horror, carried them away and emptied them, and came back, and emptied them again.
The candles burned.
The monks chanted.
The green-grey air of a closed church in winter thickened, day after day.
And while the old king dripped into a basin in Caen, somebody in England had already learned the lesson he taught in 1100.
—
## The race Henry would have recognized
When the news from Lyons reached the port of Wissant, on the coast near Boulogne, Stephen of Blois did not wait.
He was Henry’s nephew, the son of his sister Adela.
He was about forty, charming, brave, generous, popular, and enormously rich, because his uncle had made him so: Henry had given him lands across England and Normandy, married him to an heiress, and treated him almost as a son.
He had sworn the oath to Matilda in 1126.
He crossed the Channel in the same winter storms that were keeping his uncle’s body in Caen.
He rode to London, and the Londoners, who had their own reasons to want a king in a hurry, acclaimed him.
He rode to Winchester, where his younger brother Henry was bishop.
The keeper of the royal treasury handed over the keys.
It was exactly what his uncle had done, thirty-five years before, after the arrow in the New Forest.
There was still the oath.
Every great lord and every bishop in England had sworn to accept Matilda.
So a witness came forward.
Hugh Bigod, the royal steward, swore that he had been at the king’s deathbed, and that on his deathbed Henry had changed his mind and released his barons from the oath to his daughter.
There is no good reason to believe him.
Malmesbury flatly contradicts him, and Robert of Gloucester, who was certainly in the room, never said any such thing.
But nobody wanted a war with a woman most of them distrusted, a husband from Anjou whom they hated, and a two-year-old grandson.
On December 22, 1135, three weeks after Henry died, Stephen of Blois was crowned King of England at Westminster by William of Corbeil, Archbishop of Canterbury.
The archbishop had sworn the oath to Matilda too.
Henry’s body was still lying in Caen.
When the weather finally broke, the hides and the salt and what was left inside them were carried across the Channel and brought to Reading, to the great abbey Henry had founded in 1121 to pray for his soul.
In early January 1136 he was buried in front of the high altar.
King Stephen came to the funeral.
So, in the end, the nephew stood beside the uncle’s tomb, wearing the crown the uncle had spent fifteen years trying to give to someone else.
And how was Stephen alive to wear it?
—
## What Stephen of Blois did on the dock at Barfleur
Go back to November 25, 1120.
The White Ship is loading at Barfleur.
The wine is going around.
The young lords are shouting, the rowers are drunk, the priests have been jeered off the deck.
Stephen of Blois, the king’s favorite nephew, is on board.
And then he isn’t.
Orderic Vitalis, the monk who gave us most of what we know about that night, gives the reason Stephen got off the ship.
Some later writers stress the drunken crowd.
But Orderic says it plainly.
Stephen had diarrhea.
A sudden attack of it, as the ship was about to sail.
He could not face a winter crossing of the Channel on a crowded ship in that condition.
He walked back down the gangplank, found somewhere better to be, and watched the White Ship row out into the dark without him.
Three hundred people drowned that night, including the only legitimate son of the king.
Stephen lived.
Fifteen years later, a dish of lampreys and a week of the same miserable sickness killed the king himself, at the worst possible moment, with his daughter at war with him and his barons only half-loyal to her.
And the man who reached the throne first was the one man the White Ship had left behind.
One upset stomach saved the man who would take the crown.
Another one, nine centuries of storytellers have said, killed the king who wore it.
It is hard to think of another dynasty that turned twice on the same undignified thing.
What followed was not funny at all.
Matilda landed in England in 1139 to fight for her inheritance, and for most of the next fourteen years England was at war with itself.
The chroniclers called it the time when Christ and his saints slept.
Barons built castles without permission and filled their dungeons.
The Peterborough chronicle says men were hung up by their feet and smoked, and villages stood empty because there was no one left to work the fields.
In 1141 Stephen was captured in battle at Lincoln, and Matilda came within days of being crowned, until the Londoners rose against her and drove her out of the city.
In 1142 she was besieged in Oxford Castle in the snow, and escaped across the frozen river at night, by tradition wrapped in a white cloak so the sentries would not see her against the ice.
It ended only in 1153, when Stephen, exhausted and grieving his own son, agreed that the throne would pass after his death to Matilda’s son.
The boy born in 1133, the grandson whose birth had overjoyed the old king, was crowned in December 1154 as Henry II.
Henry I had his heir in the end.
He just had to die, and his kingdom had to bleed for nineteen years, before it happened.
—
## Where is Henry I now?
Nobody knows.
Reading Abbey stood for four hundred years over the body that had been sewn into ox hides.
Pilgrims came to it.
Kings stayed in it.
Then, in 1539, Henry VIII dissolved the abbey, and its last abbot, Hugh Faringdon, was hanged outside his own gate.
The abbey was stripped.
The lead came off the roofs, the stone was carted away for other buildings, the tombs were broken up.
Whatever marked the grave of Henry I in front of the high altar disappeared, and nobody wrote down where it had been.
Today the ruins of the abbey stand in the middle of Reading, behind a prison and beside a school, with offices and car parks spread across the ground where the great church once stood.
In 2015, a project to search for the king was announced, inspired by the discovery of Richard III under a parking lot in Leicester.
A radar survey of the ground in 2016 picked up what may be graves near where the east end of the church once stood.
None has been opened.
None has been shown to be his.
His entrails lie somewhere under Rouen.
His brain and eyes were buried with them, if Huntingdon is right.
His body, or what is left of it, is somewhere under the streets of an English town, the man who once accounted for every penny in his kingdom now lost himself.
The lampreys are still in the rivers.
—
## The dish on the table
Go back for a moment to that evening in the forest of Lyons.
The fire.
The hounds asleep under the benches.
The hunt-tired lords.
The old king pushing his chair back from the table and walking out into the middle of the floor, and stopping.
The dish of lampreys behind him, almost empty.
The physician who had said no.
Henry I had spent his whole life refusing to let anyone take anything from him.
Not his father’s silver, not his brother’s crown, not his daughter’s castles.
Not even, in the end, a plate of fish he knew would make him sick.
He loved them.
They always disagreed with him.
And on the night his body finally turned against him, with the court holding their noses on the benches and the cramps bending him double in the middle of the hall, the most powerful man in Western Europe looked back over his shoulder and said the only thing left to say.
“My physician told me not to touch them.”
—
## What the record actually says, and what is legend
**From the chroniclers of the time:** Henry of Huntingdon (*Historia Anglorum*, written within a few years of the events) is the source for the lampreys, for the fact that the king always loved them and they always disagreed with him, for the physician’s warning, for the embalming at Rouen, for the man who opened the skull and died, called “the last of many whom King Henry put to death,” for the salt and the ox hides, and for the black fluid caught in vessels under the bier at Caen.
Orderic Vitalis is the source for the silver weighed out in 1087, Conan’s Leap, the White Ship, the boy who told the king, and the lords at the deathbed.
The letter of Archbishop Hugh of Amiens to Pope Innocent II describes the repeated confessions and the king’s orders about debts and exiles.
William of Malmesbury records the bequest to Matilda and the sixty thousand pounds from Falaise.
**Dates:** Henry died on the night of December 1, 1135, at Saint-Denis-en-Lyons (Lyons-la-Forêt), after about a week of illness.
Stephen was crowned on December 22, 1135.
The burial at Reading is dated to January 4 or 5, 1136, depending on the source.
**What the sickness was:** Huntingdon describes the illness in the language of humoral medicine, as a deadly chill and a sudden, violent disturbance inside the king’s body, followed by fever.
The “diarrhea” in the title is the usual modern reading of that description, not a word from his text.
Modern writers have suggested food poisoning, a bacterial infection such as listeria, or an illness that had nothing to do with the fish.
The Latin word Huntingdon uses can also mean eels.
“Surfeit of lampreys” is a later phrase; Huntingdon does not say how many he ate.
**Stephen and the White Ship:** Orderic Vitalis says Stephen of Blois left the ship before it sailed because he was suffering from diarrhea; other accounts stress the drunkenness on board.
Both may be true.
**Uncertain or legend:** whether Henry arranged his brother’s death in 1100 (no contemporary accused him); Henry drawing his sword at Winchester; whether the embalmer died of the smell itself; Hugh Bigod’s deathbed story (almost certainly false); Matilda’s white cloak at Oxford; the popular saying that after the White Ship Henry “never smiled again,” which comes from later writers and a nineteenth-century poem, not from his own time.
The 2016 radar survey at Reading found possible graves; none has been identified as his.
**What we reconstructed:** the scene in the hall, the moment the first cramp struck at table, the smell, the herbs and the basins are our reconstruction of what the sources describe more briefly.
The physician is not named in any source; Grimbald was Henry’s physician in 1130, but we do not know who was with him at Lyons.
The king’s spoken lines are not quoted by any chronicler: “I am the king, and I eat what I please” and “My physician told me not to touch them” put Huntingdon’s account into words, and “Send for the Archbishop of Rouen, and send for him now” is our wording; Archbishop Hugh’s letter says only that he was called to the king and came to his bedside.
**About the video:** the short clip with this story is a modern AI reconstruction in the style of an old oil painting, not a historical image.