News

George Armstrong Custer Ignored His Crow Scouts And Led 210 Men Into Sitting Bull’s Camp In 1876. His Last Note Said “Be Quick,” And Not One Of Them Came Back

A wooden frame in dry grass, under a pale summer sky.

There is a picture that is meant to show the last hour of George Armstrong Custer, and this is what it shows.

Two rough timber posts stand in a field of yellow prairie grass, leaning toward each other, with a third log lashed across their tops.

A man in a blue cavalry uniform hangs spread between them.

His wrists are tied to the crossbar with heavy coils of rope, high above his head, and his boots are roped to the feet of the two posts, so that his arms and legs make the shape of a letter X.

His jacket is dark blue with two rows of brass buttons and the straps of an officer on its shoulders.

A red neckerchief is knotted at his throat, a leather belt with a brass plate crosses his waist, and his blue trousers carry the yellow stripe of the cavalry.

The cloth is dusty and creased, and one knee of his trousers is worn through.

His fair hair falls in curls over his ears, and his face, with its long mustache, is tipped back toward the sky.

Beside him, on the right, stands a warrior, tall and bare-armed, reaching up with both hands to the rope at the end of the crossbar.

He wears a breastplate of long white bone beads, a red blanket thrown over one shoulder, fringed buckskin leggings striped with beadwork, and eagle feathers in his long black hair.

A little farther off, two more warriors stand and watch.

One holds a tall lance upright, with feathers tied below its iron point.

The other holds a rifle across his body.

Behind them, across the whole width of the picture, rises a village of white lodges, and in front of the lodges sits a long crowd of men on horseback, with lances raised against the sky.

It is a picture built to make you flinch.

It is also an artist’s invention, and the moment in it never happened.

George Armstrong Custer was never taken alive.

Nobody tied him to a frame, and nobody stood over him while a village watched.

A Miniconjou Lakota leader named Red Horse, who fought on the ridge that day, said afterward that not a single soldier was taken prisoner.

Custer died in the fighting, on a bare hill above the Little Bighorn River in Montana, on Sunday, June 25, 1876.

He had a bullet wound in his chest and another in his left temple, and no one who rode beside him lived to say which came first.

That is the strangest thing about the most famous defeat in American history.

The man everybody knows died where nobody on his own side could see him.

About an hour before the end, while he still believed the day could be won, he had sent back a message.

His adjutant scribbled it in pencil on a page torn from a notebook, and a young Italian trumpeter carried it at a gallop to the one officer who might still have saved them, Captain Frederick Benteen.

It said: Come on.

Big village.

Be quick.

Bring packs.

Benteen read it.

He never reached Custer.

And on the hill four miles to the north, by the time anyone from Custer’s own regiment saw him again, he had been dead for two days, and so had every man who rode with him.

About two hundred and ten of them.

For a long time the country told itself a story about how they died, and it was a story told almost entirely by men who had not been there.

The people who had been there were Lakota, Northern Cheyenne and Arapaho, and they had been telling a different story from the beginning.

To understand both stories, we have to go back eight years, to a treaty.

—

## A treaty that said forever

Eight years before the battle, in 1868, the United States signed a treaty with the Lakota and their allies at Fort Laramie, in what is now Wyoming.

The treaty set aside a great reservation west of the Missouri River.

Inside it lay the Black Hills, a dark, pine-covered range rising out of the plains, a place the Lakota held sacred.

The treaty said that the land was set apart for their absolute and undisturbed use, and that no white person would be allowed to settle on it or even pass through it without their consent.

Six years later, in the summer of 1874, the Army sent a column of soldiers, scientists and newspapermen into the Black Hills to look the country over.

Its commander was Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer.

His expedition found gold.

The news ran in papers across the country, and the miners came.

In 1875 the government offered to buy the Black Hills, and the Lakota leaders refused.

So in December of that year the government changed the rules.

Every band living outside the agencies was ordered to come in by January 31, 1876, in the dead of a plains winter.

Those who did not come in would be treated as hostile.

By that one order, a family following the buffalo with their lodge poles dragging behind their horses had become, on paper, an enemy of the United States.

The Army planned a campaign for the spring.

The Seventh Cavalry would ride with the eastern column, and Custer would lead it.

—

## The boy general

Custer was thirty-six years old that summer.

He had graduated from West Point in June of 1861, last in his class of thirty-four, a few weeks after the Civil War began.

Two years later, at twenty-three, he was a brigadier general.

He wore a velvet jacket heavy with gold lace and a bright red tie, and the men of his Michigan cavalry brigade tied red neckerchiefs around their own throats to look like him.

That is where the red cloth in the picture comes from.

It belongs to the war in Virginia, not to Montana.

In 1864 he married Elizabeth Bacon, the daughter of a judge from his home town of Monroe, Michigan, whom everyone called Libby.

When the war ended, the Army shrank, and the boy general became a lieutenant colonel of the new Seventh Cavalry, on the plains.

In November of 1868 he led the Seventh in a dawn attack on a Southern Cheyenne village on the Washita River, in what is now Oklahoma.

It was the camp of Black Kettle, a chief who had spent years trying to keep the peace.

Black Kettle and his wife were shot down as they tried to cross the river.

Many of the dead were women and children, and Custer’s men took more than fifty women and children captive.

The Army called it a victory.

The Cheyenne remembered it as something else, and they remembered the name of the man who led it.

In 1874 Custer published a book about his years in the West.

He called it My Life on the Plains.

It contains a passage that is still quoted, because it is so strange coming from him.

If he were an Indian, he wrote, he thought he would much rather throw in his lot with those who stayed free on the open plains than submit to the narrow limits of a reservation.

He understood perfectly well why the people he was hunting refused to come in.

He hunted them anyway.

In 1876, after a quarrel with President Ulysses S. Grant that nearly cost him his command, he needed a victory that the newspapers would carry.

—

## The Sun Dance on the Rosebud

On the other side of that campaign was a Hunkpapa Lakota named Sitting Bull.

He was about forty-five years old.

He had never signed the treaty, and he had never come in to an agency.

In early June the bands held a Sun Dance in the valley of the Rosebud Creek.

Sitting Bull had made a vow.

His adopted brother, Jumping Bull, cut fifty small pieces of skin from each of his arms as an offering, and Sitting Bull danced, looking toward the sun, through most of a day and a night, until he fell.

When he came to, he told what he had seen.

He had seen soldiers falling into the camp upside down, like grasshoppers dropping from the sky, and he had heard a voice say that they were being given to the people.

Days later, on June 17, the southern column under General George Crook came north up the Rosebud.

The Lakota and Cheyenne rode out to meet it.

Among their leaders was an Oglala in his middle thirties named Crazy Horse, a quiet man who did not make speeches and who had followed no one else’s orders for years.

The fight on the Rosebud lasted most of a day.

When it was over, Crook pulled back to his supply camp to wait for reinforcements, and stayed out of the campaign for weeks.

Nobody told Custer.

The camp moved west, into the valley of a stream the Lakota called the Greasy Grass, which the Army’s maps called the Little Bighorn.

It was not a war party.

It was a town, the largest gathering of the plains peoples that anyone could remember.

There were the Hunkpapa of Sitting Bull, and the Oglala of Crazy Horse, the Miniconjou, the Sans Arc, the Blackfeet Lakota and the Two Kettles.

There were the Northern Cheyenne, under leaders like Two Moon and Lame White Man, and a handful of Arapaho.

Historians still argue over the numbers, but the camp may have held seven or eight thousand people, with perhaps fifteen hundred to two thousand fighting men.

The men who would fight there on June 25 were not a professional army.

They were fathers and husbands and hunters, and when the soldiers came, they would come straight at their families.

—

## The men who rode with him

The Seventh Cavalry rode up the Rosebud in the last week of June with about six hundred soldiers.

With them came Crow and Arikara scouts, a few civilian packers and guides, and a newspaperman from Bismarck, Dakota Territory, named Mark Kellogg, who meant to send home the story of a lifetime.

Custer had brought his family along.

His younger brother Tom commanded a company.

His youngest brother, Boston, rode as a civilian forage master.

His nephew, Henry Armstrong Reed, eighteen years old, whom everyone called Autie, had come out for the summer to see the West.

His sister’s husband, Lieutenant James Calhoun, commanded another company.

The soldiers carried single-shot Springfield carbines, the model of 1873, and Colt revolvers.

The carbine fired a heavy, powerful cartridge in a copper case, and when the chamber grew hot and dirty the case could swell and stick.

Second in command was Major Marcus Reno.

He was forty-one, a West Pointer of the class of 1857 and a veteran of the Civil War, but he had never fought the peoples of the plains.

Third was Captain Frederick Benteen, also forty-one, born in Petersburg, Virginia, into a family that sided with the Confederacy, though he himself had fought for the Union.

He was white-haired already, blunt and capable, and he despised Custer.

He had never forgiven him for the Washita, where Custer had ridden away while Major Joel Elliott and his detachment were still missing, and he had said so in a letter that found its way into the newspapers.

—

## The Crow’s Nest

Before dawn on June 25, Custer’s scouts climbed a high point in the Wolf Mountains that they called the Crow’s Nest.

Among them were four Crow men whose names would become famous, White Man Runs Him, Curly, Hairy Moccasin and Goes Ahead.

They looked west, toward the Little Bighorn, fifteen miles away.

They saw a horse herd so big that it seemed as if the ground itself were moving.

Then they saw the smoke of hundreds of lodge fires.

When Custer rode up later in the morning, he stared through his field glasses and said that he could not see any village.

Several of the men there remembered that his guide, Mitch Bouyer, a man of French and Lakota descent, warned him the camp was bigger than any he had ever seen.

The Crow and Arikara scouts were more blunt.

In the stories they told for the rest of their lives, the scouts said that there were too many of them down there, and that the soldiers who went down into that valley would not come back up.

The men who knew the country best looked into that valley and said do not go.

Custer had planned to rest his men through the day and attack at dawn on the twenty-sixth.

Then word came that some of the camp’s people had seen soldiers on the trail.

He believed that the village knew he was there, and that if he waited, its people would scatter in every direction, as they always did.

So he decided to attack at once.

—

## Four pieces

Around noon, on the high divide between the Rosebud and the Little Bighorn, Custer broke his regiment into pieces.

Benteen took three companies, about a hundred and twenty men, and was sent off to the southwest, across a line of broken hills, to look for other camps and to keep anyone from escaping that way.

Captain Thomas McDougall took one company to guard the pack train, the slow string of mules that carried the regiment’s reserve ammunition.

Reno took three companies, about a hundred and forty troopers, with most of the Arikara scouts.

Custer kept five companies for himself, C, E, F, I and L, about two hundred and ten men.

The regiment that had ridden in together would never be whole again.

Reno was ordered to cross the river and charge the southern end of the village, and he understood that Custer would back him up.

Custer did not follow him.

Reno’s men crossed the Little Bighorn at a shallow ford a little before three in the afternoon, re-formed on the far side, and rode north down the valley at a trot.

In the camp it was a hot, lazy afternoon.

Many of the young men had danced late into the night and were still asleep.

The first thing most of them knew was a cloud of dust down the valley and the sound of shots.

The village was close to three miles long.

Reno was attacking one corner of it.

—

## Four lines on a page

While Reno rode down the valley, Custer and his five companies turned north along the bluffs on the east side of the river.

At some point on that ride he came out on a height and saw the camp for the first time, or at least a long stretch of it.

His trumpeter that day was a young man named Giovanni Martini, born in Italy, who had enlisted under the name John Martin and still spoke little English.

Martin remembered later that the general seemed pleased.

A little farther on, Custer called him over and gave him a message for Benteen.

The adjutant, Lieutenant William Cooke, a tall Canadian with famous side whiskers, was afraid the trumpeter would garble it.

So he took out a notebook and wrote it down, and tore out the page.

Benteen.

Come on.

Big village.

Be quick.

Bring packs.

The note survives.

It is kept today in the library of the Military Academy at West Point, the school Custer had finished last in his class.

Read it today and it is a cry for help, written by a man who had just seen something much bigger than he had planned for.

Just as telling is what it does not say.

It does not say where Custer was going, or where Benteen should look for him.

Martin, who carried it back at a gallop, was one of the last men of the regiment to see Custer alive.

Another was a sergeant named Daniel Kanipe, who had been sent back a little earlier with a message for the pack train.

The Crow scouts were sent back too, and lived.

Every other soldier who rode on with Custer after that was dead within two hours.

—

## The timber

Down in the valley, Reno’s charge had stopped.

The warriors were not running from him, the way Custer had said they would.

Reno halted his men short of the lodges and had them dismount and fight on foot in a skirmish line across the valley.

The line did not last long.

Warriors worked around its left end, toward the open prairie, and Reno pulled his men back into a stand of cottonwood timber along the river.

The first bullets of the attack had gone into the southern end of the camp, where the Hunkpapa lodges stood.

Those were Sitting Bull’s people.

They were also the people of a Hunkpapa war leader named Gall, a big, powerful man of about Custer’s age.

In those first minutes, two of Gall’s wives and three of his children were killed.

Ten years later, on the battlefield, he told a reporter what it did to him.

It made my heart bad, he said, and after that he killed all his enemies with the hatchet.

We have those words through an interpreter and a newspaper, but nobody disputes what happened to his family.

In the timber, Reno was talking with his chief scout, an Arikara named Bloody Knife, an old friend of Custer’s, when a bullet struck Bloody Knife in the head and killed him at Reno’s side.

Something in Reno seemed to break.

Within moments he ordered his men to mount, then to dismount, then to mount again, and then he led them out of the timber at a gallop, back toward the river.

It was not a retreat.

It was a rout.

Warriors rode right among the troopers, shooting them off their horses.

The survivors scrambled up the bluffs on foot and on horseback.

By the time they reached the top of the hill that still carries Reno’s name, around forty of his men were dead and many more were wounded, and several were still hiding in the timber below.

His command was finished as a fighting force.

Four miles to the north, out of sight behind the ridges, Custer’s five companies were still alive.

—

## Reno Hill

The men who reached the top of the bluff were no longer an army.

They were survivors, with fouled carbines, lost hats and empty canteens.

Then, about half an hour later, Benteen rode up from the south with his three companies.

He had found nothing in the hills, and he had been heading back to the main trail when Martin met him with the note.

He had the note in his pocket.

But he looked at what was in front of him and decided that the first thing to do was to stay with Reno.

From somewhere to the north came the sound of firing, heavy volleys rolling over the hills.

Benteen said later, under oath, that he had no idea where Custer was, and that he did not know whether the firing meant Custer was attacking or being attacked.

It has been argued over ever since, and nobody has ever settled it.

What is certain is that the command waited on the hill for the packs to come up, and that the firing to the north went on, and then grew less.

Finally, without orders, Captain Thomas Weir mounted his company and rode north along the bluffs toward the sound.

From a high point a mile or so north, a place now called Weir Point, they looked toward the hills where Custer had gone.

They saw dust and smoke, and the hillsides were covered with riders.

Then the riders began to come toward them.

The command fell back to Reno Hill and dug in, and there it stayed.

—

## Medicine Tail Coulee

While Reno’s men were climbing the bluffs, Gall had done something that decided the rest of the day.

He saw that Reno was beaten, and he turned away from him.

Word had come that more soldiers had been seen on the hills east of the river, near the lower end of the camp, where the Cheyenne lodges stood.

Gall rode north through the camp, gathering men as he went.

Somewhere along the bluffs, Custer’s command had come down a long, wide ravine called Medicine Tail Coulee toward a ford of the river.

Some of the warriors’ accounts say the soldiers tried to cross, and were met at the water by a small group of defenders.

Others say they only came near and turned back.

Whatever happened, the soldiers did not cross.

They were pushed away from the river and up onto the high ground, onto a long ridge with ravines on either side.

They were no longer attacking.

They were being herded.

Then Crazy Horse came.

He had ridden down through the camp, crossed the river farther north and swung around, and now he came at the ridge from the north and the east with a large body of Oglala and Cheyenne.

Gall and his men pressed from the south.

Two leaders saw the same opening at the same time and rode into it.

—

## The last hill

On the southern end of the ridge, Calhoun’s company dismounted and formed a firing line.

For a while it held.

Warriors worked up the gullies toward it on foot, firing from the grass, some with repeating rifles traded from merchants or taken in earlier fights, many with bows that sent arrows in high arcs over the crest.

The line broke, and the men of Captain Myles Keogh’s company, just behind it, were overrun as they tried to rally.

Keogh’s body was found later in the middle of a knot of his own men.

The rest of the command, the headquarters with Custer and the remnants of the other companies, pulled back toward the highest knob at the north end of the ridge.

It would later be called Last Stand Hill.

By the time they reached it, there may have been only fifty men left.

There, by the warriors’ accounts and by the bones found later, the soldiers shot some of their own horses and lay down behind them.

Red Horse, the Miniconjou, described the end five years later.

He said the soldiers became foolish, and that many of them threw away their guns and raised their hands and called out to the Lakota to pity them and take them prisoner.

The Lakota did not take a single soldier prisoner, he said, but killed all of them.

Some Cheyenne accounts add something darker.

They say that in the last minutes, with the warriors closing in, some of the soldiers turned their guns on themselves or on one another.

The witnesses did not agree on what they had seen, whether men were choosing death over capture or firing blindly in the smoke.

The ground itself has its own story.

In 1983 a grass fire burned the battlefield bare, and over the next two years archaeologists walked it with metal detectors and recovered thousands of cartridge cases, bullets and fragments.

They did not find one great circle of fire around one hilltop.

They found clusters and scatters over more than a mile of ridges and ravines, the marks of small groups fighting, moving, breaking and falling.

Where exactly Custer fell, nobody knows.

His body was found near the top of the knob.

He had been hit in the left side of the chest and in the left temple.

Either wound might have killed him, and no one can say which came first.

With his hair cut short and his famous buckskin jacket, by some accounts, tied behind his saddle in the heat, he would have looked like any other officer in the dust.

In those last minutes, he was just another soldier.

—

## Water

The men on Reno Hill knew none of this.

They lay in shallow holes scraped in the hard ground with knives and tin cups, behind dead horses, boxes and saddles, while warriors fired into the position from the surrounding ridges.

The siege went on through the rest of the afternoon, all through the night, and most of the next day.

The wounded lay in the sun of a Montana June and cried for water.

The river was in plain sight, a few hundred yards down a steep ravine, covered by warriors’ rifles.

On the morning of the twenty-sixth, volunteers went down the ravine with canteens and camp kettles.

Four of the best shots in the command lay on the crest above them and fired to cover them while they ran.

At least one of the water carriers was killed and several were wounded, but they kept going, and they brought water up the hill.

The Army later awarded twenty-four Medals of Honor for the battle, and fifteen of them went to men who carried water.

That afternoon the great village began to move.

The grass on the valley floor was set on fire, and behind the smoke the lodges came down and the people packed and went south, up the valley and out of sight, a column of people and horses miles long.

Why they left is still debated.

Whatever had happened on the ridges, the leaders understood that more soldiers would come.

—

## The morning of the twenty-seventh

On the morning of June 27, General Terry’s column, with Colonel John Gibbon’s infantry, came up the valley.

A young lieutenant of infantry named James Bradley rode up to Terry and told him that he had counted one hundred and ninety-seven dead soldiers on the ridges.

When the officers of the Seventh walked over the field, they found the dead of the five companies scattered along the ridges and down into the ravines, in clusters and alone.

Every one of them was dead.

There were the officers, and Tom Custer and Boston Custer, and the boy Autie Reed, and James Calhoun.

There was Mark Kellogg, the newspaperman, who never filed his story.

Most of the bodies had been stripped of their clothing.

Many had been mutilated, as the dead of both sides often were in the wars on the plains.

Custer’s own body had been stripped, but it was mostly left alone.

A Northern Cheyenne woman named Kate Bighead had her own explanation.

She had been in Black Kettle’s camp on the Washita as a young woman, and she had seen Custer the next year, in 1869, when he came to the Cheyenne to make peace and smoked the sacred pipe with their chiefs.

The chiefs told him then that if he ever broke his word and made war on the Cheyenne again, he would be killed.

According to what Kate Bighead was told, two Southern Cheyenne women found his body on the hill and told the men around it to leave it alone.

One of them pushed the point of a sewing awl into each of his ears.

It was, they said, so that he would hear better in the next world, since he had not listened to the chiefs in this one.

That is the whole of the story as she gave it, and nobody else saw it.

—

## The drawings and the woman

The American version of the battle began on the morning of June 27, with officers walking over a field where everything had already happened.

But the field had never been empty of witnesses.

In 1881, at the Cheyenne River Agency in Dakota Territory, Red Horse sat down with an Army surgeon named Charles McChesney and told the story of the battle through an interpreter.

He also drew it.

He made more than forty large drawings in pencil and colored crayon on sheets of paper.

They show the warriors mounting, the charges, the soldiers falling, the horses running loose, and the dead laid out in rows.

They are one of the earliest full accounts of the battle by anyone who fought in it, and they were drawn five years after it ended.

For most of a century, popular histories were written as if the warriors’ side of the battle had never been recorded.

It had been, and it was sitting on a shelf.

In the early 1920s Kate Bighead told her story to a doctor named Thomas Marquis, who lived among the Northern Cheyenne in Montana and spent years taking down the memories of old people.

He published it in 1927, more than fifty years after the battle.

She had watched the fight from horseback, at the edge of it, and her account is one of the very few that tell us what a woman in the camp saw.

She remembered the panic in the lodges when Reno’s men came.

She remembered riding up behind the warriors to sing strong-heart songs for a young nephew, and finding him later in a gully, badly wounded.

And she remembered the warriors coming back from the ridge in the evening with the news that every one of the soldiers over there was dead.

The ground, when the archaeologists finally read it, agreed with the drawings and with her memory more than it agreed with the paintings.

—

## The widow

Libby Custer was thirty-four when her husband died.

She lived for almost fifty-seven years more.

Libby wrote three books of her own about life with Custer on the frontier, Boots and Saddles, Tenting on the Plains and Following the Guidon.

She wrote to generals, to editors, to painters and to historians.

The painters did the rest.

A lithograph of the Last Stand, given away by a brewery, hung in saloons across the country for generations, with Custer standing tall in the middle of his men, yellow hair blowing, saber raised.

She made it her life’s work to see that the hero of the Last Stand stayed a hero, and while she lived, most of the officers who had served with him kept their sharpest opinions to themselves.

Reno could not.

In 1879, at his own request, a court of inquiry met in Chicago to examine his conduct at the Little Bighorn.

In the end it found nothing in his conduct that called for the Army’s action.

In law, he was cleared.

In the public mind, he was not.

He was court-martialed twice more on charges that had nothing to do with the battle, and in 1880 he was dismissed from the Army.

He died in Washington in 1889, at the age of fifty-four, poor and largely forgotten.

In 1967, an Army review board changed his dismissal to an honorable discharge, and his remains were moved to the national cemetery at the battlefield.

Benteen stayed in the Army, defended his conduct for the rest of his life, was never charged with anything, and died in 1898.

In private letters, written late in his life to an old trooper of the regiment, he said exactly what he thought of Custer, in language that was not printed until long after both men, and Libby too, were dead.

Libby died in New York in April of 1933, four days before her ninety-first birthday.

The Last Stand that most Americans still see in their minds, the yellow hair, the saber, the loyal men standing in a ring, is in large part the Last Stand she protected for fifty-seven years.

—

## What the victory cost

For the Lakota and the Northern Cheyenne, the Little Bighorn was the greatest victory they ever won over the United States Army.

It was also the beginning of the end.

The country’s answer came fast.

In 1877 Congress passed a law taking the Black Hills.

In May of that year, Crazy Horse rode into Camp Robinson in Nebraska with about nine hundred of his people and surrendered.

On September 5, during an attempt to lock him in the guardhouse, he was stabbed with a soldier’s bayonet, and he died that night, at about thirty-five.

Sitting Bull led his people north into Canada, and in July of 1881, with too little game to feed them, he rode into Fort Buford and surrendered.

On December 15, 1890, during the unrest over the Ghost Dance, Lakota agency police came to arrest him at his cabin on the Grand River, and in the fight that followed he was shot and killed.

Gall had surrendered early in 1881, a few months before Sitting Bull, and later sat as a judge on the agency court at Standing Rock until his death in 1894.

The leaders of the greatest victory of the plains peoples died, one by one, inside the system they had fought to stay out of.

The Black Hills case went on long after them.

In 1980, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that the Hills had been taken illegally and that the Lakota were owed compensation.

The Lakota refused the money.

They wanted the land.

—

## The name on the gate

Within a few years of the battle, the field became a national cemetery.

In 1881 the soldiers’ bones were gathered from the scattered graves and reburied around a granite monument on the top of the hill, and white marble markers were later set up across the ridges where the men were thought to have fallen.

For more than a century the place carried one man’s name.

It was the National Cemetery of Custer’s Battlefield Reservation, and from 1946 it was the Custer Battlefield National Monument.

The Lakota, the Cheyenne and the Arapaho who had defended their families there came to it as visitors, to a park named for the officer who had attacked them.

In 1991, after years of pressure, Congress changed the name.

It became the Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument.

The same law called for a memorial to the warriors, and in 2003 it was dedicated, a circle of earth and stone not far from the soldiers’ monument.

Since 1999, red granite markers have been set on the ridges where Lakota and Cheyenne fighters are known to have fallen, among the white marble stones of the soldiers.

—

## The picture, once more

Look at the picture one last time.

The frame of rough timber, the man in blue spread between the posts, the warrior at the crossbar, the two men watching, the lodges and the long row of riders.

Now it is possible to say what is in it.

The village is real, in a way: there was a great camp of lodges on the Little Bighorn that afternoon, bigger than anyone in the Seventh Cavalry had imagined.

The rest is invented.

The red neckerchief belongs to the Civil War.

The long curls had been cut before the campaign began.

There were no sabers on that ridge either, because the regiment had boxed them up and left them behind weeks earlier.

Custer was never captured, never tied, and never held up in front of a village.

The witnesses who were there said that no soldier was taken alive.

And the frame itself, the whole idea of the picture, is an old story that the dime novels told about the peoples of the plains, not something that anyone saw on that hill.

Any words we give the man on the frame have to be imagined.

If we imagine them, they can only be built from the few things that are known: the scouts who warned him, his decision to attack that day, and the four lines on a notebook page that are the last order he ever gave.

The words below are imagined, except for the ones that were written on that page.

He lowers his head and looks out at the men in front of him.

“My scouts said turn back.”

He breathes, and his voice drops.

“I told them we attack today.”

He lifts his eyes toward the long row of riders.

“Come on. Big village. Be quick.”

He says the last words of the note almost to himself.

“Bring packs.”

He turns his head toward the empty hills to the south.

“Benteen is coming. Benteen is com—”

Benteen did not come.

He had the note in his pocket, and he stayed on a hill four miles away, with the wounded and the beaten, while the firing to the north rose and fell and stopped.

The picture shows Custer dying slowly, in front of everyone.

The truth is the opposite.

He died fast, in the dust, among men who could not tell him from anyone else, and nobody on his side saw it.

The only people who saw how the Seventh Cavalry ended were the people it had come to attack.

They told what they saw, in drawings and in interviews and in stories told to their grandchildren, for a hundred years.

The country had a painting it liked better.

You Might Also Enjoy