News

“Four Indians Wanted Her For A Wife: Sioux Indians C*pture Helen Carothers, Minnesota, August 1862 “

Today we have some more actual history about the 1862 massacre of Minnesota settlers by the Sioux or Dakota Indians. We will be reading the narrative of a woman named Helen Carrothers, a 19-year-old mother of two children who was captured by Indians during the outbreak on August 18th, 1862. We will be reading from this book, A History of the Great Massacre by the Sioux Indians in Minnesota, Including the Personal Narratives of Many Who Escaped. This book was published by Charles S. Bryant all the way back in 1863, just one year after the massacre took place. In 1862, the Sioux Indians were upset because they had not received their promised rations and annuities due to the outbreak of the Civil War and perhaps corruption among the Indian agents. As a result, they decided to attack and kill all the white settlers living in Minnesota. Here is Mrs. Helen Carrothers’ account of the attack on her family and neighbors.

Narrative of Mrs. Helen Carrothers of Beaver Creek:

Mr. Carrothers and family had resided on a claim intended as a homestead for some four years previous to the 18th of August, A.D. 1862, on Beaver Creek, six miles from the Lower Sioux Agency. The family then consisted of himself, a wife, and two children—a girl and a boy, the girl aged three and the boy two years. We give the personal narrative of Mrs. Carrothers in her own words:

On the morning of the outbreak, Monday, the 18th of August, 1862, I was at Mr. S. R. Henderson’s, taking care of Mrs. Henderson, who was quite ill. Early in the morning, at half past six o’clock, while we were at breakfast, four Indians came to the house and looked in. They had on Indian blankets. After looking about a short time without coming in, they departed, going toward Mr. Earle’s.

While at Mr. Earle’s, they attempted to take his gun, but failing in this, they sat down by his door. About the same time, Mr. Henderson, Mr. Earle, Mr. Wedge, Eugene White, and three of Mr. Earle’s boys, accompanied by David Carrothers, seeing some 150 Indians on the prairie catching horses, went down to prevent them.

When desired to desist from taking the horses, these Indians refused, stating that they were going to kill Chippewas and needed the horses. Seeing all efforts useless, the men returned.

And as they were on their way toward the houses, a Mr. Veightman from the Lower Agency arrived and reported that the Indians were killing all the whites at the latter place.

Mr. Earle had his horses already in the harness for some purpose on the farm. My husband was from home. David Carrothers, my brother-in-law, came after me, and I went with him to Mr. Earle’s. It was soon determined to go to the fort with two horse teams belonging to Mr. Earle and another team with three yoke of oxen attached. We began our journey, the Indians remaining behind.

We had scarcely got under way when I saw several more Indians not hitherto seen rise up, and we were soon surrounded on all sides. Before we had gone fifteen rods from the house, the teams were all stopped, and Mr. S. R. Henderson and David Carrothers went out to the Indians to learn their intention.

On inquiry, they were told that the whites were all to be killed. This was the more shocking to us as these Indians were all well known to us and had hitherto expressed so much friendship for us. A parley for some moments took place, during which the strongest remonstrances possible were urged. The result of the parley was then that our lives should be spared if we would give up all the teams.

Again, David Carrothers pleaded for one team in which Mrs. Henderson, who was sick, and her two small children might be conveyed to Fort Ridgely. They agreed also to this, and shook hands with all of us in token of satisfaction, and seemed well pleased.

Thus deprived of our teams except the one which carried Mrs. Henderson, we supposed at this sacrifice all were safe. But sad to relate, after going about ten rods further, the Indians came up with us and demanded this last team also. Another urgent appeal was made for the sick woman, when it was agreed that if the team then drawing the wagon were given up, the wagon might be retained.

This was yielded, and we again advanced on our intended journey, the men drawing the wagon by hand. We could not think of leaving Mrs. Henderson in this way. We had advanced some twenty rods; I was some ten rods ahead of the wagon, when I heard the Indians singing, and looking round, heard the report of three guns. The dreadful truth flashed upon my mind: the Indians were actually killing us.

When the firing began at the wagon, Mrs. David Carrothers, who was holding an umbrella over Mrs. Henderson, jumped out of the wagon, two balls passing through her dress before she reached the ground. At the request of Mrs. Henderson, a white flag—a pillowcase—was held up by David Carrothers and Mr. Henderson. This flag of truce was not respected, but was soon riddled with bullets, and the fingers of Mr. Henderson holding one corner of it were shot off, and the flag fell. At the first fire, Mr. Wedge fell dead at the wagon.

Mr. Henderson and David Carrothers, after the former had lost his fingers, seeing that they could offer no assistance to Mrs. Henderson, ran from the wagon. Mr. Earle and his sons and Eugene White were still ahead of me.

When the Indians came up to us, they shook hands with each of the women and said we were now going to live with them.

Here we sat down in the open prairie, guarded by two Indians, and in some fifteen minutes, eight more came back from the pursuit of our men, and with these we returned. They would not let us return by Mrs. Henderson’s, but we saw a fire where she had last been seen, and we supposed they had burned her and her little children. This turned out to be so, as I afterward learned.

The party of which I was one now consisted of eight persons, as follows: Mrs. David Carrothers and baby, Mrs. Earle and two daughters, Mrs. White and baby, Julia White, and myself. All these were ordered into one of the wagons taken from us and driven to Mr. Earle’s house, when we were told to get out.

The conversation was in the Sioux language, most of which I understood. We stood by the door while the Indians plundered the house, breaking up all the furniture, throwing cups and saucers and other dishes through the windows. One of their number, an Indian called John, went to the spring and brought us water in a pan procured from the house. When all they wanted was put into the wagon, we were driven off to Little Crow’s house.

In the route, we were taken past our house and the house of Mr. Hunter, one team attended by three Indians stopping at the latter place. As we proceeded, we asked and obtained leave to walk down the hill, at the foot of which was the house of Thomas Robinson, the Indian interpreter. On the door of this house being struck violently by one of the Indians with a hatchet, another one reproved him sharply, saying:

“This is an Indian’s house.”

Here we remained until the other team came up from Mr. Hunter’s. At this place, Julia White, Julia Earle, myself, and two children were placed in one wagon, and all the other women and children into the other.

We next stopped at the house of Mr. Hayden, and remained in the wagons until the Indians had taken from the premises all they wanted, and had wantonly shot down a hog and some chickens in the yard.

Here, Indian John told me he had cut off Mrs. Hayden’s head, and that she was then lying in the house. This was a lie, as I afterward learned. Mrs. Hayden escaped unharmed with her child to Fort Ridgely, and is now alive and well.

We next went to the house of Mr. Young, a German. The door was open, and the house had already been plundered. We went on, and next passed by the house of Mr. Eisenreich. Here again, the same Indian, John, told me that Mrs. Eisenreich had been killed, and that her children were then alive in the house. This was not true, as Mrs. Eisenreich and children were at the time captive with the Indians.

We passed on, and next came to the Minnesota River, and crossed at a ford. The Indians here walked up the river hill, and I drove. After we crossed, we came into a prairie, where John told me I must drive fast, that he heard the cannon at the fort, that the soldiers he feared would come after them and kill them before they reached Little Crow’s.

Again we had a steep hill to go up, and all got out and walked. At the top of the hill, an Indian told me that he was going to take me to John Moore’s house. I inquired if Mrs. Elizabeth Carrothers and myself might not remain together. His answer was emphatic:

“No.”

We were then separated and were not again permitted to stay in the same wagon. The team in which was Mrs. Earle then drove off toward Redwood, and I saw her no more that day.

About a mile from the hill last alluded to, they stopped and loaded the wagon full of different kinds of stores: dried apples, prunes, calico, blankets, and numerous other articles taken from the Lower Agency. On the top of this load, with three Indians, we were permitted to ride. Some of the dried apples were given us to eat.

At the river, they had opened a chest brought from Mr. Earle’s, and which had been packed by him with stores such as sugar, meat, bread, and clothing. Of these stores they gave us to eat, I suppose to be quite sure they did not contain poison.

We soon came in sight of Little Crow’s house, and approaching near, stopped some fifteen rods from the door of the great chief, who was himself at home. I asked if I could not go down to the house. The privilege was refused. Here we were given water to drink from an old tin kettle. In a few moments, Little Crow came along, and seemed very much pleased to see us, and extended a cordial hand to welcome us to his own home.

I then asked the chief himself if I could not go down to his house. He tried to be agreeable and said yes, and soon showed us the way to his Indian mansion—a two-story frame house made of boards set upright in battens, with one room below and two above, all plastered, furnished with a good cooking stove, chairs, tables, and good common furniture. Besides the usual and ordinary furniture, the house was packed with goods of all kinds taken as plunder, such as sugar, coffee, tea, calico, and clothing in general.

I told Little Crow that I was hungry. He pointed to a sack of flour and said:

“Go and make you some bread if you are hungry.”

After he had gone out, an old squaw came and made me a cup of coffee and prepared me some bread fried in grease, and I and the children ate our supper. On the table at this meal were good ordinary dishes, knives, and forks, and the table was quite supplied, butter, sugar, and coffee being among the luxuries. It was, however, an extra occasion, both as to the guest and the supply of provisions.

After supper, I went out and sat by the door of the chief, looking after my boy Tommy. While sitting here, Little Crow came along and gave me a sudden push, saying:

“Go into the house. The Indians will kill you if you do not.”

Thus kindly admonished, I took the boy, went into the house, and sat behind the door, and taking my boy on my lap, tried to keep him still.

While thus situated, I saw Little Crow’s brother come in and sit down by the side of a German girl, and putting his arms around her in a loving manner, said in the Sioux language:

“This is my squaw.”

This Indian told us that John wished all of the women to go up to his tepee. We had now to obey an Indian who chose to command us. This, too, was the brother of the renowned Little Crow.

We all arose and followed him. On arriving at John’s tepee, we found it all fitted up in the nicest Indian fashion, John himself building a fire after we arrived. He seemed to behave as though he expected us to remain with him. Outside of the tepee, supper was being cooked, and we all sat down there, but had scarcely been seated a moment when a squaw came and took Mrs. Earle and her daughter Julia off with her, not permitting them to remain for supper.

Mrs. White and baby, myself, and two children were now all the white persons left at the tepee of the too-much-delighted, lying John. Here we ate supper. While we were eating, the squaw fitted up the tepee, and supper being over, we all went in. A buffalo robe was brought, and we sat down according to the Indian fashion.

The squaw now gave me a comb and told me I must braid my hair after the Indian fashion. After this was done, a comforter was brought for a bed for the children.

About ten o’clock, Little Crow came around and said:

“We must not be in haste to go to bed, as we must make us some clothes to wear.”

The waiting squaw, in obedience to this hint from the chief, soon brought forth a blue-colored cloth to make into skirts and a calico sack for each of us. We had soon sewed up a skirt each for ourselves. I had sewn mine up with a seam in the usual way among white people. The squaw ordered me to take it out and directed me to place the two edges so that one doubled over the other, and then to run the seam down. This, she said, was their fashion.

Owing to this mistake, Mrs. White finished her skirt first, but refused to put it on, it looked so horrible. I very cheerfully put mine on and laughed heartily at the figure I cut, thus half-dressed in Indian costume. The squaws, too, were taken with a fit of laughter, and went and brought in other squaws and Indians, and we all laughed heartily. Mrs. White reluctantly and soberly put hers on, and the laugh turned on her, but she seemed not to see why anyone should laugh. I felt as Mrs. White did, yet I forced a laugh with a desire to make myself as agreeable as possible under the circumstances.

This night, the Indians sat up all night long running bullets and preparing for war against the whites. I also sat up all night. Once during the night, the alarm was given that the soldiers were coming, and all was hurry and bustle getting ready to leave for Yellow Medicine. But after a while, Little Crow came around and told them they had better not go. All were soon quiet again.

In the morning, we had for breakfast boiled beef without salt. I could not eat it and asked for salt. The reply I received was that they had no salt, but would have some that day. After giving the children some, I put the rest back, as I could not eat beef without salt. The squaw told me I had better eat it, for it was all we would get until night, as they were going to Yellow Medicine.

They now watched me very closely. I was not permitted to go out of the tepee alone, but was always attended by a squaw and compelled to wear a blanket over my head.

About eleven o’clock of that day, Tuesday, the 19th of August, a squaw came and took Mrs. White away and left me quite alone. The Indians now came to me, Little Crow and others, and talked a long time about killing someone. I did not understand who, but now a squaw came and told me that they were going to kill me. The reason alleged was that four Indians wanted me for a squaw, and as they could not agree, Little Crow, unable as umpire to decide the quarrel, had concluded to settle the difficulty in the way intimated.

The squaw was ordered to take me into a cornfield nearby and disrobe me, and the Indians were then to come and kill me. She took me out and told me to take off my squaw clothes. I told her I would not unless she would bring me something else to put on. She went back to the tepee and brought me a quilted skirt, an old rag unfit for anyone to wear.

When she left me, I started and went over toward the middle of the cornfield. An Indian soon came where I was and said the Indians were not going to kill me. After he went away, I made off still further, and the idea came to me that I might possibly get away.

Soon another Indian came looking after me and was within six rows of corn of me, when I sat down and he passed by without discovering me. As he disappeared, I took fresh courage, soon passed out of the corn and through a potato patch, and down into the woods.

That night, I stayed in the grass at the head of Tiger Lake.

The next morning, I thought I would try and cross Minnesota River and go over to my house and find something to put on better than that which I had. I made a number of attempts to ford the river at different places, but failed in each attempt. I could get over myself, but could not get over with the children, the water being up to my chin, and I failed to manage them and myself too in water so deep.

Thus baffled in my efforts to cross the river, I stayed around there for three nights after reaching the river. I then went up near to the Lower Agency on the hill. Here were two roads, one near the bank, the other half a mile back on the prairie. I traveled along one near the riverbank, while the Indians at the same time were on the other. I could not at this place get down the bank, some 200 or 250 feet to the river.

I finally found a path down the hill at Joe Campbell’s spring, and hid just below the spring until almost dark, and then went up to the house. And finding there a feather bed, I threw that down a trapdoor into the cellar, and went down with my children and took up my abode there for the present.

Here I tried to find something to eat, but did not succeed. I remained here for three nights and two days. Indians came into the house at different times during the nights and days while I was below in the cellar.

This place became too fearful to endure longer, and I thought I would go down to the ferry and cross the river. All this time, I ate nothing but a few potatoes I found in Campbell’s garden. These potatoes were very small, not larger than the end of my thumb.

When I reached the river, I found the ferryboat gone, and I was again disappointed. But wandering along the shore, I found a board box, pointed at one end and square at the other, nearly filled with water. Opposite this, I saw a soldier, one of Captain Marsh’s men, killed on the Monday previous.

I bailed out the boat with a teacup which I had brought from Campbell’s house to drink from, and got in with my children, and sat down in the middle and pushed off from the shore. Thus improperly balanced, the boat went round and round. I discovered that I must make my station at the end of the boat, and when thus balanced, the boat went down the stream, leaking fearfully. With my teacup, I made a feeble effort to keep the rickety craft afloat, but the water gained on me fast.

I now found I must make for the shore, and in my efforts to do so, succeeded in getting hold of some willows overhanging the edge of the river, and was soon safe on the shore. Had the boat not leaked so badly, I had intended to go down the stream in it opposite the fort. But now, having made a crossing after falling down about seven miles without sinking, thankful for this unlooked-for assistance, I sent the sinking craft adrift, leaving my teacup in it, and hastily set out for Fort Ridgely.

I had seen in different places, in all, six dead soldiers along the river, lodged in the driftwood. I now ascended the hill and reached the road leading from the Agency to Fort Ridgely. It was just sundown as I stepped into the road.

At the first house I came to on the road, I stopped to rest and search for food. The house was deserted and plundered. I went into the garden, and there found some cucumbers. I pared them with an old chisel which I found at the house and ate them, giving each of the children a piece.

I went forward and thought I would travel all night and reach the fort before I stopped. It was now getting dark, and the mosquitoes were exceedingly annoying. I could not protect myself from them, as I had two children to carry, and my face was totally covered with them. It was now entirely dark. I could not travel, and so was compelled to stop for the night.

I heard horses coming and supposed the Indians were returning from the fort, and that I should even yet be killed when I had so nearly escaped. I went off from the road and hid in the grass, and there remained all night.

I was, in fact, afraid to go to the fort, for Little Crow had told me that everyone at the fort would be killed, and that when these men were killed, he was going with his own men to New Ulm.

In the morning, however, hoping against hope, I made toward the fort. Came to a house, but found nothing at all in it; it had, from appearance, not been occupied for some time.

I then went on to Mr. Bush’s house, three miles from the fort. Here I found some sugar in a bowl, tasted it, and gave some to my children. I went into the cellar, there found some butter, but could not eat it. I was so near the fort, I thought I could get something better there if the Indians had not killed off all the white people.

While in the cellar, a man came down and looked into the cellar. I supposed, of course, it was an Indian and was much frightened. But to my joyous surprise, the strange man asked me if I could give him something to eat.

I replied:

“This is what I am looking for.”

This man proved to be a German who had come there three nights before and had not the courage to go to the fort, as he had heard shooting there most of the time. So he had dug a hole in a haystack close by and had remained there ever since.

Seeing I had determined to go to the fort, this companion in distress took my little girl and carried her for me, which helped me very much.

When within half a mile of the fort, Lieutenant Culver and Warren DeCamp came out to meet me, Mr. DeCamp supposing me to be his own wife until he came within twenty feet of me. We stopped where I met the men from the fort until some clothing could be brought for me. A gray blanket was brought, and in this I wrapped myself, head and ears, and in this manner made my joyous entry into Fort Ridgely.

“After all,” I exclaimed, “I am safe!”

I had been out eight days, having had nothing to eat but raw potatoes and a cucumber. I had carried the two children all the way except about one-half mile. The eldest was nearly four years old. I had traveled from Little Crow’s house, and the route I had taken, over thirty miles. I had been in imminent danger of detection by the Indians several times. The reader may imagine my joy at reaching Fort Ridgely.

I remained at the fort three nights. The first night I could not sleep; some fellow sufferers congregated to hear of my escape, which exhausted the night. The eldest child during this night would frequently cry out in its troubled dreams:

“Mama! Mama, I can’t walk!”

While on the route, this little girl would wake from partial sleep and most piteously cry:

“Mama! Mama, give me some bread!”

All I could reply from my full heart, with face averted from the child, was:

“When we get to the fort, you shall have something good to eat.”

I remained at the fort three days and came to St. Peter. I then went to La Crosse, Wisconsin, and remained all winter. In March, 1863, I came to St. Paul, and in June returned again to St. Peter, where, at the request of friends, I have furnished the simple story of my adventures among the Sioux Indians.

So that’s it for this account given by Helen Carrothers of her brief captivity with the Sioux Indians after she was captured on August 18th, 1862. She made an interesting escape by losing herself in the cornfields and then eventually making it to Fort Ridgely. This account was given in 1863, less than a year after she returned from captivity.

To provide some details about her later life, I am now going to read this section from her Find a Grave website page:

Helen was born in Wisconsin to parents Thomas and Laura Paddock, both natives of Vermont. She was named after heroine Lady Helen Mar from the historic novel The Scottish Chiefs by Jane Porter, first published in 1810. Beginning with Helen Mar Paddock, the name carried through four generations of daughters: Helen Mar McInany (1873–1912), Helen Mar Riddle (1898–1950), and Helen Mar Johnston (1929–2010).

In October 1856, when she was only 13 years old, Helen married James Carrothers, aged 26. In 1857, following a move to Winona, Minnesota, the couple moved to the southwest quarter of Section 22 in Beaver Falls Township, Renville County, Minnesota, six miles from the Lower Sioux Indian Agency, where Mr. Carrothers was employed as a carpenter. They were some of the first white residents of the area known as Beaver Creek Settlements, and here their children, Altha and Thomas, were born. Helen was only 15 years old when she gave birth to Altha.

Mr. Carrothers could be away from home for several days at a time, so Helen became acquainted with the Dakota Indians and learned their language. The medicine man was fond of Helen and taught her how to gather herbs and use them to make medicine, and she would go with him to nurse the sick.

By the summer of 1862, the number of white settlers in the area had grown, and many of the Dakota were angry with the results of treaties and with conditions at the reservation. It all boiled over on August 18th, 1862, when Indians attacked the whites at the Lower Sioux Agency and at the settlements in the region, killing hundreds and taking over 100, mostly women and children, as prisoners.

When word of the uprising reached the Beaver Creek settlements, several residents gathered at the Jonathan Earle claim, where they made plans to go to Fort Ridgely for protection. They traveled just a short distance when they were surrounded by Indians who began shooting at them. Some in the group were killed, some escaped, and the rest—women and children, including Helen and her two children; her husband was away at the time—were captured. All were then taken to Chief Little Crow’s village.

Helen and her children managed to escape from this camp, and after a perilous journey lasting eight days, they reached Fort Ridgely. In time, refugees at the fort were taken to St. Peter and then to St. Paul. In early September, Helen traveled to La Crosse, Wisconsin, to visit her parents, who were overjoyed to learn that she was still alive. She remained with them through the winter months to recover from exhaustion and other effects of her captivity and escape.

In April, James rejoined Helen, and they moved to St. Paul, where he worked as a pattern maker in a foundry, and she boarded the men who worked with him. They were there for just two months before moving to St. Peter. By this time, they were having problems with their marriage.

Many years later, Helen would write:

“After my capture by the Indians, there was discord between me and my husband, and at St. Peter we agreed to disagree.”

Following their divorce, he joined the First Wisconsin Battery of Light Artillery and went to the South, and she went to work for Joseph and Valencia Reynolds, keepers of the Northwestern Hotel in St. Peter. She worked there for two years, then returned to the home of her parents, who had moved from Wisconsin to Dodge County, Minnesota. Here she met Dennis McInany, a native of Ireland, and they were married in October 1869. They eventually had three children: Helen Mar, Arthur, and Moses.

So Mrs. Carrothers and her husband divorced shortly after she returned from captivity, and she later remarried. It is unclear why the divorce occurred; all she says is that they “agreed to disagree.” But it’s possible that this was a similar situation to what happened to Mrs. Wright after she returned from her captivity. In Mrs. Wright’s case, her husband divorced her after she gave birth to a half-Indian child.

Most of these videos were about the attack on the Lake Shetek community, which was on August 20th. This attack we read about in this episode occurred two days earlier, on August 18th, 1862, near the Lower Sioux Agency. So this was one of the first attacks after the outbreak began. We will have some more episodes on the Minnesota Sioux massacre in the future on this channel, including one focusing on the causes. Some people seem to think that the massacre was justified, so we will explore the causes of the attack and see if they justified the mass killing of approximately 600 white settlers.

This channel is called Unworthy History because we cover actual history that has now been deemed unworthy to show on history channels on TV. Here on this channel, we try to preserve the worthy history of our ancestors by reading their words directly from old books.

You Might Also Enjoy