News

Fanny Kelly Was Taken From Her Wagon Train By A Lakota War Party In 1864. The Woman Captured Beside Her Escaped The Next Night, And Years Later Published Their Story Under Her Own Name

Tall golden grass, under a hard blue sky full of white clouds.

There is a painting that is meant to show the first days of Fanny Kelly’s captivity, and this is what it shows.

A young woman is walking toward us through a high meadow, the grass up to her knees and bending in the wind.

She wears a long, pale cream dress, ragged at the hem, with a belt of fringed hide at her waist and thin bracelets on her wrists.

Her long red-gold hair is blowing out to one side, and her eyes are cast down at the ground in front of her feet.

Behind her, a few steps back on the left, walks a man with long dark hair, bare to the waist, a bow and arrows over his shoulder.

A second man follows further back on the right, near a lone pine tree, with a bow slung across his back as well.

Neither man is touching her.

Nobody is holding a rope.

She is simply walking in front of them, and there is nowhere else to walk.

Far behind them, beyond the meadow, a line of white-capped mountains runs along the horizon.

It is a painting, made long after the fact, and much of it is invented.

Nothing in her own book says she had red hair; the painter chose it.

The pale dress belongs to the end of her story, not the beginning, and the snowfields belong to a postcard, not to a hot, dry July on the North Platte.

She was never alone with two men in an empty meadow, either.

She was somewhere in the middle of a war party she counted at more than two hundred riders.

But the walking is true.

In July 1864, a nineteen-year-old woman from Kansas walked north across the plains in front of the men who had taken her, carrying a chief’s bow and gun and a long stick she did not yet know was his pipe.

And she was not the only woman taken that evening.

Somewhere in the same column rode Sarah Larimer, twenty-eight years old, with her eight-year-old son.

The two women had shared a road, a campfire and a plan for a new life in the mountains.

The next night, one of them got away.

The other stayed for five months.

Years later, the two of them sat down to write the story together.

Then one of them carried the pages to Philadelphia, and the name on the cover was not Fanny’s.

—

## Two families on the road

Fanny Wiggins was born around 1845 in Orillia, in what was then Canada West.

When she was eleven, her parents moved the family to Geneva, in Allen County, Kansas.

Her father did not live to see the farm; he died of cholera on the way.

In 1863, she married Josiah Kelly, a farmer and a discharged Union soldier at least fifteen years older than she was.

His health had suffered in the war, and the plan the young couple made was the plan of thousands of families that decade.

They would go west, to the new gold country in what is now Idaho and Montana, where the air was said to be good for a weak chest and the land was said to be free for the taking.

They did not go alone.

With them went Mary Hurley, Fanny’s niece, a little girl of seven by most accounts, whom the Kellys had taken in and were raising as their daughter.

There were two Black men working for the Kellys, Franklin and Andy.

There were wagons, oxen and a small herd of milk cows.

On May 17, 1864, they left Geneva.

On the road they met the Larimers.

William Larimer was a businessman with a wagon full of goods.

His wife, Sarah Luse Larimer, born in 1836, was something rare on that road.

She would make her living as a photographer, one of the very few women in that trade in the West.

Their son, Frank, was eight.

The two women were close enough in age and far enough from home to become friends quickly.

Others joined the little train as it went: an elderly Methodist minister named Sharp, a young man named Gardner Wakefield, and a driver named Noah Taylor.

It was a small company, eleven people in all.

The minister and the driver joined them near Fort Laramie, and the travelers believed the road ahead was safe enough.

—

## Whose road it was

The emigrants called it the Oregon Trail.

For the people who lived along it, it was a wound that would not close.

The road ran up the North Platte River through country that the Lakota, with their Cheyenne and Arapaho allies, had hunted for generations.

Every summer, thousands of wagons rolled through it.

The oxen ate the grass along the river.

The travelers cut the timber and shot the game.

Their cattle brought sicknesses with them, and so did they.

Treaties had been signed.

Payments had been promised in return for safe passage, and they had arrived late, or short, or not at all.

By 1864, the northern plains were already at war.

After the Dakota War in Minnesota two years earlier, the Army had sent columns west to punish the Sioux peoples, and the punishment fell on bands that had had nothing to do with Minnesota.

That very summer, General Alfred Sully was in the field against the Lakota, and two weeks after the Kelly train was attacked, he fought them at Killdeer Mountain.

None of that was known in the wagons.

The Kellys and the Larimers were thinking about gold, grass and water.

The men on the bluffs above them were thinking about something else.

—

## The evening at Little Box Elder Creek

On July 12, 1864, late in the afternoon, the little train crossed Little Box Elder Creek, a few miles west of a stage stop called LaPrele Station, in what is now Wyoming.

Then the riders appeared.

Fanny later described them as “painted and equipped for war.”

She guessed there were more than two hundred of them.

Accounts disagree about which Lakota people they were.

Fanny’s own captor would turn out to be an Oglala war leader, while other sources speak of Miniconjou and Hunkpapa men in the party.

What is certain is that the wagons were outnumbered twenty to one.

Josiah Kelly drew the wagons together.

Fanny begged him not to fire a shot.

He listened to her.

An old man rode forward alone.

Fanny would learn his name as Ottawa and would later write that he was “over seventy-five years of age, and partially blind.”

He struck his chest, shook hands and said, in the few English words he had, that his men were friends.

They wanted trade.

They wanted food.

For an hour or more, the emigrants did what the warriors asked.

They handed over flour, sugar and coffee.

Josiah gave up his best horse.

The riders moved in among the wagons, smiling and looking at everything.

When the warriors suggested a meal together, the men of the train went off to gather firewood and fetch provisions, each to his own task, and for a moment nobody was watching anybody else.

Then the shooting started.

Sharp, the old minister, was killed within a few steps of where Fanny stood.

Noah Taylor was shot down beside his team.

Franklin fell almost at her feet.

Gardner Wakefield was badly wounded and, by most accounts, died of it soon after.

William Larimer took an arrow in the arm and ran.

Josiah Kelly and Andy, out of sight in the brush, heard the guns, saw the smoke, and understood that two men could do nothing against two hundred.

They ran too.

When it was over, there were four people left standing among the wagons who had not run and had not fallen.

Fanny Kelly and Mary.

Sarah Larimer and Frank.

—

## Two horses heading north

The warriors emptied the wagons.

They broke open trunks, threw flour on the ground to take the sacks, and carried off the cloth and the tools and everything that could be carried.

Fanny went to the old man, Ottawa, and begged him to protect her.

He told her to be quiet.

Sarah Larimer was weeping, and a man silenced her with a blade held up in front of her face.

Then Ottawa did something Fanny did not understand at the time.

He put a band of feathers on her head.

Later she learned what it meant.

She was his.

At dusk, Fanny and Mary were lifted onto one horse.

Sarah and Frank were put on another.

The whole party turned north, away from the road, and rode on into the dark.

Fanny had a few things in her pockets: some letters, a couple of small books, and a fold of paper money, a little over a hundred dollars.

As they rode, she tore pages from the books and let them fall, one by one, onto the trail behind her, for Josiah to follow.

Then, in the dark, she made a decision that she would carry for the rest of her life.

The trail was black under the trees, and the riders around them were singing.

A grown woman sliding from a horse would be seen.

A small girl might not be.

Fanny whispered to Mary that they were only a few miles from the wagons, that the papers would show her the way back, and that she should lie still in the grass until the riders had passed.

She wrapped her own shawl around the child against the cold.

And when the nearest men had drifted a few lengths away, she let Mary down to the ground.

The column rode on.

Nobody turned.

An hour later, Fanny tried to slip down herself.

This time they saw.

They struck her, and they asked where the child was.

She said Mary had fallen asleep and tumbled off, and that she had only jumped down to find her.

They did not believe her.

They promised that they would look for the girl in the morning.

Mary did not survive.

She was found dead some days later near the trail, and Josiah buried her where she lay.

Fanny would not know that for weeks.

—

## The next night

In the morning the column moved on, and the two women were together again.

They walked now, at least part of the time.

Ottawa had chosen Fanny over Sarah to carry his things, and she carried them: a bow, a gun, and a long, heavy stick wrapped in hide that she could not identify.

She kept looking back at the trees.

The wind in the grass sounded to her like Mary calling.

At some point that day, worn out and distracted, she dropped the long stick and it broke.

Nobody saw.

She kicked the pieces into the grass and kept walking.

That evening the war party halted in a valley not far from Deer Creek Station, a stage and telegraph post on the North Platte.

The warriors tied Fanny down for the night with heavy straps.

She worked at them whenever nobody was looking.

Sarah Larimer lay near her with Frank.

She was terrified.

By Fanny’s account, Sarah begged her not to leave her behind if she got free.

Fanny would not promise.

All she could think of was Mary and Josiah.

Fanny fell asleep at last.

When she woke, Sarah and Frank were gone.

Sometime in the night, mother and son had slipped out of the sleeping camp.

It has been said, and Fanny believed, that a man of the war party helped them, or at least chose to look the other way.

They made their way through the dark to Deer Creek Station.

William Larimer was there.

He had reached the station with the arrow wound in his arm.

His wife and son walked in alive.

At the Lakota camp, Fanny Kelly lay in her straps, nineteen years old, alone among more than two hundred strangers, and understood that nobody had untied her.

—

## Alone

The war party kept moving north, deeper into country that no wagon road touched.

It was July on the high plains, and it was hot.

When the men dug for water in a dry creek bed and found only a little, there was none for her.

She walked behind the horses with Ottawa’s bow and gun on her shoulders and her mouth full of dust.

A few days later, at a night camp, the dancing stopped and Ottawa called out to her.

He wanted his pipe.

It took her a moment to understand, and when she did, she went cold.

The pipe was the long stick she had broken and left in the grass.

For a man like Ottawa, a pipe was not a possession.

It was sacred.

He was furious.

In Fanny’s telling, he declared she should die for it, and men began to prepare a horse and a rope.

She did the only thing she could think of.

She pulled the paper money from her pockets, one hundred and twenty dollars in banknotes, and held it out, then handed the notes around, insisting how much they were worth.

Whether it was the money, or her terror, or something in the old man that softened, the preparations stopped.

She fainted.

When she woke, the horse and the rope were gone.

—

## A lodge on the Powder River

About two weeks after the attack, the war party rode into a large Oglala village, and the warriors went in the way returning warriors did, in their best paint and in the clothes they had taken.

Fanny saw one man in a hat from the wagons, wearing a pair of her own silk gloves.

She went into Ottawa’s lodge as what she later called his “exclusive property.”

She carried wood and water.

His wives received her with suspicion at first.

Over the following weeks, some of the women of the village grew kind to her.

They brought her food.

They dressed the sores on her feet.

One of the older wives made her tea so that she could sleep.

In the lodge she was given a little girl, a child of the village called Yellow Bird.

Ottawa told her, in the few words he had, that this child was hers now, to take the place of the one she had lost.

Fanny did not understand yet what he meant by “lost.”

Then, in late July, the village was on the move.

Sully was coming.

The fighting that followed broke the Lakota summer.

Villages fled across the Badlands and over the Yellowstone, leaving lodges, food and robes behind, and the soldiers burned what they found.

There was hunger in the camps that autumn, real hunger.

Fanny ate grass when there was nothing else.

—

## A circle of chiefs

After the losses, the mood in the camp turned toward the only white person in it.

By her account, the chiefs called a council and brought her into the middle of the circle.

A stake had been set in the ground, with kindling piled around it.

The pipe went around.

Men spoke of vengeance.

The soldiers had killed their relatives and burned their food.

Here was one of the soldiers’ people.

The council was deciding whether to burn her.

Then Ottawa stood up.

Fanny did not yet understand everything that was said, but she understood enough, and she wrote it down later as best she could.

Vengeance was their right, the old man said.

But this woman had done them no harm since the day she was taken.

She had been kind.

The children of the lodge loved her like a sister.

She should not pay for what other people had done.

The council listened to him.

Nobody lit the kindling.

She walked out of that circle alive, and into weeks of hunger that were almost as dangerous.

—

## What she learned about Mary

That autumn, a rider she did not know came up beside her on the trail.

At his side hung a small shawl.

It was her shawl, the one she had wrapped around Mary in the dark on the first night.

Fanny understood then what had happened to Mary.

She fell from her horse, and for a long time afterward, she wrote, she could not feel anything at all.

She understood, too, what Ottawa had meant by the child she had lost.

—

## A rider named Porcupine

Some weeks later, a well-dressed man rode into the village on a fine horse.

His name was Porcupine, and he had come from the soldiers.

After a few days, he came to Fanny and handed her a letter.

It was from a Captain Marshall of the 11th Ohio Cavalry, and it said three things she had not dared to hope.

The Army knew she was alive.

It had tried more than once to reach her.

And the man who carried this letter had been paid, in clothes, a horse and provisions, to bring her back.

For a moment she thought it was over.

Then Porcupine told her he was not taking her anywhere.

He had the soldiers’ goods already.

He would tell them she had died.

He laughed at the idea that the soldiers would punish anyone for it.

She begged him.

It made no difference.

He rode away, and she stayed.

It was the cruelest kind of news, and also the most precious.

Somebody on the other side was looking for her.

—

## Jumping Bear

There was one person in those months who did more for her than anyone else, and he was not an Oglala.

Early in her captivity, a quarrel broke out over a small kindness.

A relative of Ottawa’s gave Fanny a pair of stockings, Ottawa took offense, and the relative, unable to strike back at the chief, turned on her.

He fitted an arrow to his bow and aimed it at her chest from a few steps away.

A young man stepped in and snatched the bow out of his hands.

His name was Jumping Bear.

He was Sihasapa, a member of the Blackfeet band of the Lakota, which is not the same people as the Blackfoot of Montana.

Some historians identify him with John Grass, who had been baptized as a small child by the Jesuit missionary Pierre-Jean De Smet and later became one of the leading men of Standing Rock.

That identification is not certain, but it is often made.

From then on, Jumping Bear watched out for her.

He rode near her on the march.

It became clear to Fanny that he wanted her for a wife.

She did not want that, and she did not dare refuse him outright.

In November, men of his band, the Sihasapa, came to Ottawa’s camp.

General Sully had told the Lakota bands that there would be no peace and no winter supplies while a white woman was held among them.

The Sihasapa wanted the supplies.

After two days of talk, Ottawa let her go with them, for horses.

Here the story becomes a story about a letter.

—

## The gate at Fort Sully

In the Sihasapa camp, Fanny learned that some of the men intended to use her return as a trick.

They would take her to Fort Sully, on the Missouri River, and when the gate opened to receive her, they would rush it.

Jumping Bear came to visit her there.

She asked him, by her own account, to prove his friendship.

She gave him a letter for the soldiers at the fort, telling him it spoke well of him and would bring him a reward.

It did speak well of him.

It also warned the officers of the plan and begged them to save her.

He carried it.

Early in December 1864, on a day the accounts place between the ninth and the twelfth, a party of chiefs rode toward Fort Sully with Fanny Kelly among them.

She wore a white cotton gown, with a buffalo robe across her shoulders against the cold.

Snow lay on the ground.

Behind them, at a distance, came a large body of warriors.

The gate opened a little way.

Officers and an interpreter came out.

The chiefs and Fanny were brought inside.

Then the gate shut, with the main body of warriors still outside.

The letter had arrived.

Fanny Kelly was free, five months after the evening at Little Box Elder Creek.

There is another version of her release.

Some later writers say she had been traded to a Hunkpapa man and was brought in under the protection of Sitting Bull, who was Hunkpapa, not Oglala.

Her own book tells it as the story of the letter and the gate, and that is the version most people know.

About two months later, Josiah Kelly reached the fort.

He had never stopped looking for her.

It was Josiah who told her, in words, what the shawl had already told her about Mary.

—

## Sarah’s road

Sarah Larimer’s story after the second night is shorter, and stranger.

She and William recovered at Deer Creek.

They did not go on to the gold fields.

They stayed in the West, and Sarah did what she had set out to do.

She ran photography studios with her husband, in Colorado and Wyoming in those first years after the attack.

When the Kellys’ life fell apart, the Larimers were there.

Josiah Kelly died of cholera on July 28, 1867, in Kansas.

Fanny was carrying their child, and the baby was born after his father’s death.

She was twenty-two years old, a widow, a mother, and a woman whose name had been in newspapers across the country.

The Larimers invited her to come and live with them in Wyoming.

She went.

—

## Two days and five months

It is worth stopping here, before the courtroom, to look at what each woman actually had to tell.

Sarah Larimer had the evening at the creek.

She had the ride north in the dark, the morning walk, and the night at the camp near Deer Creek.

She had the long hours of not knowing whether her husband was alive, and the escape through the dark with an eight-year-old boy.

That is a real story, and a frightening one, and nobody should belittle it.

Fanny Kelly had all of that, and then she had five more months.

She had the broken pipe and the hundred and twenty dollars.

She had the lodge, the wives, the little girl named Yellow Bird.

She had the flight from Sully across the Badlands, the hunger, the council and the stake, the shawl at a stranger’s side.

She had Porcupine, Jumping Bear, the letter and the gate.

Any book about the summer of 1864 that told the whole of it would have to be mostly Fanny’s book.

That is what made what happened next so bitter.

—

## One story, two books

The two women had something nobody else in the country had.

They had both been there.

They agreed, by Fanny’s account, to write the story of 1864 together.

Fanny had kept notes and memories of five months that Sarah had not lived through.

Sarah had a photographer’s eye and her own two days in the war party.

The book they planned would carry both their names, and both of them would share in whatever it earned.

Then, as Fanny told it, Sarah took the manuscript.

In 1870, a book appeared in Philadelphia under one name only.

It was called The Capture and Escape; or, Life Among the Sioux, and the name on it was Sarah L. Larimer.

Fanny went to law.

In a Kansas district court she sued Sarah and William Larimer for ten thousand dollars, a large fortune at the time.

Her complaint said they had broken their agreement to publish together and had secretly carried off manuscripts that were hers.

How it ended is not clear from the records most easily found today.

One later account says the case went through several trials over about ten years before it was settled.

Another says Fanny won, but not anything like the sum she had asked for.

What is certain is that the two women who had lain side by side in a Lakota camp on the night of July 13, 1864, ended up on opposite sides of a courtroom.

In 1871, Fanny published her own book.

She called it Narrative of My Captivity Among the Sioux Indians.

It came out in Hartford, Connecticut, and it was reprinted for years.

Today the two books are sometimes bound together, the short story and the long one, under the same cover.

Fanny’s book is a book of its time, written for readers who wanted villains, and its language about the Lakota is often harsh.

But it is also full of the women who fed her, the old man who spoke for her in the council, the child who was handed to her, and the young man who carried her letter.

She did not leave them out.

—

## After

Congress later paid Fanny Kelly five thousand dollars, in 1870 by most accounts.

It was for what she had lost, and for the warning that had saved Fort Sully.

She moved to Washington, D.C. She married again, to a man named Gordon.

She spent much of the rest of her life in the capital, and in the end she was comfortably off.

There is one more story from those years, and it comes from a long way off.

In 1921, the widow of John Grass told a family friend that a white woman had once come to see her husband in Washington, had taken his hand and called him “kola mitawa,” my friend, and said she was glad to see him.

If John Grass was Jumping Bear, then that woman was Fanny Kelly.

The story cannot be checked.

It is a good story, and it may be true.

Fanny Kelly died in Washington on November 15, 1904.

She was about fifty-nine.

Sarah Larimer kept making photographs.

She ran a studio in Humboldt, Kansas, from 1874 into the 1880s, and later in Texas, and she was still working in the trade in 1912.

—

## The words nobody wrote down

The video that goes with this story gives Fanny Kelly a few words to say on the walk north.

Nobody recorded what she said on that walk, so the lines below are imagined, rendered in English, and built only from what she wrote about those first two days.

“Mary… please, God, let her find the road.”

That is the prayer of a woman who had just let a child down into the dark and could not know what came next.

“Sarah, stay close to me.”

That is the one person she still had, and the one she would wake up without.

“Josiah will come. He will come.”

That is the hope she held onto through five months, and the reason she tore pages out of her books.

None of those words is in her book in that form.

They are there only to give her a voice for a few seconds, in a picture that was made up long after she was gone.

—

## The picture, once more

Look at it again now.

The golden grass and the blue sky.

The young woman walking toward us with her eyes on the ground.

The two men behind her, bows on their shoulders, neither of them touching her.

The pine tree, the far white mountains.

Now it is possible to say what is true in it.

The walk is true.

She walked north for days in front of the men who took her, and she was carrying a chief’s weapons when she did.

The cast-down eyes are true.

She spent those first days looking at the ground and at the trees, for a child and for a husband who did not come.

What the picture leaves out is everything around her.

It leaves out the other woman, who was walking in the same column that day and who would be gone by morning.

It leaves out the more than two hundred riders, the broken pipe on the ground, and the money in her pocket that would buy her life.

And it gives her a white dress she would not wear until the very last day, at the gate of Fort Sully, five months later.

In the picture, she walks alone in front of two men.

In the story, she walked alone in front of all of them, and the only friend she had on that road got away in the night and took the story with her.

You Might Also Enjoy