News

Elizabeth Báthory Was Never Put On Trial. In The Winter Of 1610 They Shut The Countess Inside Her Own Castle At Čachtice, And She Never Came Out Again

A narrow stone cell, a low wall of red brick, and a woman on the wrong side of it.

There is a picture that is meant to show the last free moments of Elizabeth Báthory, and this is what it shows.

She is leaning forward over the half-built wall, as if she is trying to climb out before it gets any higher.

Her long black hair has come loose and falls around her face.

Her face is wet with tears.

Her mouth is open, caught in the middle of a cry.

She wears a gown of deep red velvet stitched with gold, and a wide collar of white lace stands up around her neck like the collar of a queen in a portrait.

One of her hands grips the rough bricks on the left.

The other reaches toward the bricks on the right, as if she could hold them back.

On the right side of the picture there are two other hands, and they are not hers.

They are a workman’s hands, big and cracked and gray with mortar dust, and they are setting one more brick on top of the wall in front of her.

You do not see the man’s face.

You only see the hands, and the dirty sleeve of his shirt, and the brick.

Behind her, deep in the cell, three candles burn in an iron holder on the stone wall.

They are the only warm light in the room.

Everything else is cold stone and gray mortar and shadow.

Nobody in the picture is striking her.

Nobody is dragging her anywhere.

There is only a woman, a wall that is getting higher, and a pair of hands that do not stop.

It is not a photograph, and nobody painted it while it happened.

It was made long afterward, and some of it is imagined.

The woman in it looks about twenty-five.

The real Elizabeth Báthory was fifty years old in the winter she was locked away.

Nobody knows exactly what her prison looked like, and historians still argue about how much of the famous “walled in alive” story is true.

But the heart of the picture is real.

In the last days of December 1610, Elizabeth Báthory, Countess of one of the richest and most powerful families in the Kingdom of Hungary, was taken into custody inside her own castle at Čachtice.

She was accused of being behind the disappearance of a great number of young women and girls who had served in her households.

She was never charged in any court.

She was never allowed to answer a single accusation in public.

She was shut away in her own castle, and three and a half years later she died there.

Some people say she was the worst female murderer in history.

Some people say she was a rich widow who was destroyed by the men who wanted what she owned.

The strangest thing about her story is that both of those claims have serious historians on their side, and four hundred years later, nobody has been able to settle it.

This is the story of how a countess disappeared behind a wall without ever being judged, and of what the records actually say about her.

—

## The night on the hill

It begins in the cold at the very end of the year 1610.

Čachtice Castle sits on a limestone hill above a small village in what is now western Slovakia.

In 1610 it was part of the Kingdom of Hungary, and it was one of many castles that belonged to Elizabeth Báthory.

In the last days of the year, a party of armed men rode up toward the castle.

At their head was György Thurzó, the Palatine of Hungary, the highest official in the kingdom after the king himself.

He did not come alone.

With him, according to the accounts that survive, were members of Elizabeth’s own family, the husbands of her daughters, and a group of armed retainers.

By every rule of their world, the woman inside that castle could not be touched.

She was a widow of a national war hero.

Her uncle had been king of Poland.

Her relatives ruled Transylvania.

Noblewomen of her rank were not arrested in the night like common criminals.

And yet these men had come to do exactly that.

To understand why they dared, and why what happened afterward was not a trial but something stranger, we have to go back fifty years.

—

## A girl from Ecsed

Elizabeth Báthory was born on August 7, 1560, at Nyírbátor in eastern Hungary.

The Báthory family was one of the oldest and grandest noble houses in Central Europe.

Her father, György Báthory, belonged to the Ecsed branch of the family.

Her mother, Anna Báthory, belonged to the Somlyó branch.

Her parents were cousins, which was common among the great families of the time, who married inside a small circle to keep land and power together.

Her mother’s brother, István Báthory, became Prince of Transylvania and then, in 1576, King of Poland.

Other relatives held Transylvania after him.

To be born a Báthory was to be born close to the top of the kingdom.

There are stories about her childhood.

Later writers said she suffered fits, perhaps seizures, as a girl.

There is also an often-repeated tale that as a child she watched a horrible punishment carried out on a servant on one of the family estates.

Nobody can check those stories today, and some of them may have been invented later to explain the woman she was said to have become.

What is better attested is that she was well educated for her time and her sex.

She could read and write, and letters in her name survive.

Later writers claim she knew Hungarian, Latin and German.

Whatever the exact number, she was not an ignorant woman, and that matters for what came later.

A clever, literate, well-connected woman can write letters, call on relatives, argue her case.

Anyone who wanted her silenced would have to make sure she never got the chance.

—

## Fourteen and married

In 1574, when Elizabeth was about thirteen, she was formally engaged to Ferenc Nádasdy, the son of another powerful Hungarian family.

The wedding took place on May 8, 1575, at Varannó, today Vranov nad Topľou in Slovakia.

She was fourteen.

He was about nineteen.

It was a great political event.

The guest list was full of nobles, and the gifts were lavish.

Ferenc’s wedding gift to his bride was his household at Čachtice, the castle on the hill with the village and lands below it.

Years later, in 1602, he bought the castle outright from the emperor.

The same castle where, thirty-five years after the wedding, she would be locked away.

Because Elizabeth’s family outranked her husband’s, she kept her own surname, which was unusual.

The couple were often called by both names: the Nádasdy-Báthory household.

—

## The wife of the Black Bey

Ferenc Nádasdy became a soldier, and a famous one.

For most of their marriage, Hungary was at war with the Ottoman Empire.

In the long war that began in 1593, Ferenc was one of the most feared commanders on the Hungarian side.

The Ottomans were said to call him the “Black Bey,” and Hungarians remembered him as the Black Knight of Hungary.

He was away on campaign for years at a time.

That meant that, for long stretches, Elizabeth was the one who ran everything.

She managed a network of castles and estates spread across the kingdom.

She commanded hundreds of servants.

She dealt with stewards, tenants and money.

When enemy raiders threatened the lands, it was her letters that organized the response.

The couple had several children who lived to adulthood, including their daughters Anna and Katalin and their son Pál, who was born in 1598 and became the heir.

In the households she ran, there were many young women and girls in service: maids, seamstresses, kitchen girls, and also the daughters of lesser noble families, who were sometimes sent to the household of a great lady to learn manners and make a good marriage.

That was ordinary for the age.

What happened to some of those young women is the question that has never gone away.

—

## A world where a servant did not count

Before going further, it is necessary to say something uncomfortable about the world Elizabeth lived in.

In sixteenth-century Hungary, a great noble household held near-total power over the people who served it.

Beatings were common.

Punishments that would shock anyone today were treated as a normal part of keeping order.

A serf or a servant girl had almost no way to complain, and almost nobody above her would listen if she did.

That does not excuse anything.

It explains why, for many years, no one with power seemed to care what happened behind the walls of the Báthory castles.

It also explains why the line between a harsh mistress, of whom there were many, and a murderer, which is what Elizabeth was later called, was a line that powerful men got to draw.

And they drew it only when it suited them.

—

## A widow with a fortune

Ferenc Nádasdy died on January 4, 1604.

He was in his late forties.

Elizabeth was forty-three, a widow, and one of the richest people in the kingdom.

She held enormous estates in her own right and on behalf of her son, who was still a child.

She was also, according to many historians, owed a great deal of money by the Crown.

Ferenc had lent large sums to finance the war against the Ottomans, and the Habsburg rulers of Hungary were famously short of money.

How much was owed is still argued.

But a king who owes a fortune to a widow has a reason to be interested in what happens to her.

Matthias, it is said, believed that if she were condemned to death, her property would pass to the Crown and his debts would be wiped out.

Remember that, because it comes back at the end.

From 1608 the king of Hungary was Matthias II.

And around the same time, the rumors about the widow of Čachtice grew too loud to ignore.

—

## The whispers

The rumors had started years earlier.

Between 1602 and 1604, a Lutheran minister named István Magyari complained about the countess, both publicly and at the royal court in Vienna, over what he had heard was happening in her household.

The stories were always the same.

Girls went into service in her houses and did not come back.

Some were buried at night.

Some were said to have died of “illness” in numbers no illness could explain.

At first, those girls were the daughters of peasants, and almost nobody with power acted.

Then, according to the later testimony, the dead began to include girls from lesser noble families, who had been sent to the countess to be educated.

That changed everything.

A dead serf could be ignored.

A dead daughter of a noble family had relatives who could write to the Palatine, and to the king.

—

## The Palatine

In 1610, King Matthias ordered an investigation, and he gave it to the Palatine, György Thurzó.

It is worth looking closely at Thurzó, because he is the man who decided what happened to Elizabeth.

He was the highest judge and official in the kingdom under the king.

He was also connected to the Báthory and Nádasdy families.

Ferenc Nádasdy, as he lay dying, is said to have asked Thurzó to look after his widow and children.

So the man appointed to investigate Elizabeth was at the same time a protector of her family.

That double role explains a great deal about what came next.

In a letter of March 5, 1610, Thurzó sent two notaries out to collect testimony.

By October of that year they had fifty-two statements.

By 1611 more than three hundred people had been questioned: servants, villagers, local officials, clergy, and relatives of the missing.

—

## What the witnesses said

Historians read the testimony in two completely different ways, and both readings deserve a fair hearing.

The first reading says the evidence is overwhelming.

Many witnesses, questioned in different places, described the same pattern: young women beaten, starved, burned, or left out in the cold, and girls who died in the countess’s service and were buried in secret.

They named the same small circle of servants who were said to carry out the countess’s orders.

Some of the accounts came from people who had nothing to gain by inventing them.

The second reading says the evidence would never stand up in a modern court.

Most of the witnesses were repeating what they had heard from others.

Almost nobody claimed to have seen the countess kill anyone with their own eyes.

The key confessions came from servants who were interrogated under torture, and people under torture will say whatever they think will make it stop.

The numbers were wildly inconsistent.

The servants themselves gave figures in the dozens.

One witness, a woman named Zsuzsanna, claimed to have heard of a list in the countess’s own hand that counted six hundred and fifty victims.

No such list has ever been found.

And the men running the investigation stood to gain from the countess’s fall.

Both readings are true at the same time.

Something terrible happened in those households.

Girls did die.

Whether Elizabeth was a serial killer, or the cruel mistress of a cruel household whose crimes were then inflated, is the question that has never been answered.

—

## The last days of December 1610

Thurzó did not wait for the investigation to end before he acted.

At the end of December 1610, he went to Čachtice himself.

In a letter to his wife written right afterward, Thurzó claimed that his men had found evidence of the crimes in the house: one girl dead, and another still alive whom he described as the countess’s next victim.

The popular version says the countess was caught in the act, covered in blood.

That version comes from much later.

One account of the arrest says she was sitting at dinner when the men came in.

Some historians accept that account as it stands.

Others point out that it is exactly the kind of discovery a man would need to make if he had already decided how the story should end.

Elizabeth was taken into custody that night.

Her servants were taken too.

—

## Bytča, January 1611

The servants were tried, and quickly.

On January 2, 1611, and again on January 7, at Bytča, the seat of Thurzó’s own family, a court heard the cases of four people who had served in the countess’s household.

Seventeen witnesses testified at the first hearing alone.

Two of them were women who had worked as nurses and servants for many years, Ilona Jó and Dorottya Szentes.

A third was a young man named János Újváry, usually called Ficzkó.

The fourth was a washerwoman named Katarína Beniczky.

All of them were questioned under torture.

The sentences were the harshest the law allowed.

The two women were put to death in public, by burning, after further torments.

Ficzkó was beheaded.

Katarína Beniczky was spared death and sentenced to prison for life, because witnesses said she had been bullied by the others.

Another woman named in the testimony, Erzsi Majorova, was hunted down later and also burned.

The commoners paid in full, and in public.

The countess, whose orders they were said to have followed, was never brought into that courtroom at all.

—

## The countess who was never tried

Why was she never tried?

The king, it seems, wanted a trial, and he wanted her put to death.

Thurzó, and the men of her own family, wanted the opposite.

A public trial of a Báthory would have been a disaster for the whole nobility.

It would have dragged every great house connected to her through the mud.

It would have given her the chance to speak, and she was not a frightened peasant.

She was a literate, well-connected noblewoman who knew exactly how much she was owed and by whom.

And a trial might have ended with the Crown taking her estates, which her family did not want either.

So they found another way.

There would be no trial, no verdict, and no sentence.

The countess would simply be kept locked away in her own castle for the rest of her life, out of sight, unable to speak to anyone, while her property passed quietly to her children.

The king, according to the accounts, was persuaded to accept it.

It was a solution that suited everyone in power.

It was also a solution that made sure the one person at the center of the whole affair never said a word in public.

—

## The masons

This is the part of the story that everyone knows, and the part that is hardest to pin down.

The most famous version says that masons were brought into Čachtice Castle and that they walled up the doors and windows of the countess’s rooms, leaving only small slits for air and a narrow opening through which food could be passed.

That is the scene in the picture: a wall going up, brick by brick, with a woman on the other side of it.

The idea did not come from nowhere.

Thurzó himself wrote that she had been locked into a bricked-up room.

But other documents point the other way.

When priests visited her in July 1614, the record of their visit suggests that she could move about inside the castle, which sounds more like strict house arrest than a sealed cell.

Many modern historians think the walled-in image has been sharpened by later storytellers.

What the records agree on is this.

She was confined at Čachtice from the winter of 1610 to the end of her life.

She was kept apart from the world.

She was never released, never tried, and never allowed to answer.

Whether the door to her room was bricked up or simply locked and guarded, the effect was the same.

She went in alive, and she did not come out.

—

## Three and a half years

She lived like that for about three and a half years.

One of the highest-born women in Europe spent her last years in the rooms of her own castle, while outside the walls her name was already turning into a legend.

There is a detail from those years that cuts both ways, like everything else in this story.

In September 1610, a few months before her arrest, she had written a will leaving her inheritance to her children.

At the end of that year she signed an arrangement dividing her estates among them.

Her fortune passed to her family, not to the Crown.

And the large sum that the king owed her was cancelled after her arrest.

If she was simply a convicted monster, why let her family settle her estate like that of a respectable noble widow?

Those who believe she was framed point to it as proof that the affair was really about property all along.

Those who believe she was guilty point out that her family had every reason to keep the estates out of the Crown’s hands, whether she was guilty or not.

Both explanations fit.

—

## August 21, 1614

Elizabeth Báthory died at Čachtice on August 21, 1614.

She was fifty-four years old.

A story told about her last night says that she complained to a guard that her hands were cold, and that he told her it was nothing and that she should lie down.

In the morning she was found dead.

Nobody can prove that story either.

It has the sound of something a village would tell.

What is certain is that she died where she had been put, without ever having faced her accusers in open court.

—

## A grave nobody can find

Even her burial became a problem.

She was first buried in the church at Čachtice, on November 25, 1614.

According to the accounts, the people of the village did not want the woman they called the beast of Čachtice lying in their church, and her body was later moved, probably to the Báthory family crypt at Ecsed, where she had been born.

Today nobody can say for certain where she lies.

The most infamous woman in the history of Hungary was made to disappear twice: once behind the walls of her own castle, and once from the map.

—

## The blood that was never in the record

You probably came to this story already knowing one thing about Elizabeth Báthory: that she bathed in the blood of young women to keep her skin young.

It is one of the most famous images in all of horror.

It has fed films, novels and games for centuries, and it is the reason her name still sells.

It does not appear in a single document from her lifetime.

There is no mention of it in the hundreds of pages of testimony gathered against her, and the men who gathered that testimony had every reason to include the most shocking detail they could find.

When the witness statements were rediscovered in 1765 and published in 1817, they still said nothing about blood baths.

The story of the blood baths first appears in print more than a hundred years after her death, in a history of Hungary published by a Jesuit scholar, László Turóczi, in 1729.

After that, every generation added something.

A magic mirror.

An iron maiden in the cellar.

Body counts that kept climbing.

And because she had been silenced so completely, there was nobody to answer any of it.

A woman who is never allowed to speak is the perfect canvas.

Anyone can paint anything on her.

—

## Monster or victim

So which was she?

For a long time, almost everyone accepted the legend.

In the twentieth century, some Hungarian historians began to argue the other side.

The historian László Nagy, in a book published in 1984, argued that Elizabeth was the victim of a political plot by the Habsburgs and her own relatives, who wanted her lands and wanted her debts erased.

Others followed with similar arguments.

Other historians, who have gone back to the testimony and the letters, think that is too simple.

They point to the number of witnesses, the consistency of the accounts, and the complaints that began years before the investigation.

In their view, something real and very dark was happening in her households, even if the legend has inflated it beyond recognition.

The honest answer is the one that has kept this story alive for four hundred years.

We do not know.

We know that young women died in her service.

We know that her servants were tortured and executed.

We know that she was locked away without a trial.

And we know that the most famous thing everybody says about her was invented more than a century after she died.

What we will never have is her side of the story, because the people who sealed her away made very sure she would never give it.

—

## The other Báthory

There is one more piece of the background that the legend usually leaves out.

In the same years that the rumors about Elizabeth were growing, another member of her family was making the Habsburg court very nervous.

Gabriel Báthory, a young relative from the Somlyó branch, became Prince of Transylvania in 1608.

He was ambitious, unpredictable and hostile to Habsburg power, and for a few years he looked as though he might make the Báthory name the strongest force in the region.

Some historians argue that this matters.

A rich Báthory widow in the middle of Habsburg Hungary, with estates and castles and money owed to her, and a restless Báthory prince next door in Transylvania, was not a comfortable combination for the king.

Breaking the widow’s power, and keeping her fortune away from any family alliance, would have suited the Crown very well.

That does not prove she was innocent.

It does show why so many people had reasons, other than justice, to want her gone.

Gabriel Báthory himself was murdered by his own men in 1613.

Elizabeth outlived him by less than a year.

—

## What the servants said about the numbers

The numbers in this story have grown with every telling, so it is worth going back to where they started.

The servants who were tried at Bytča in January 1611 were asked how many girls had died.

Their answers, given under torture, did not agree with each other.

The figures they gave ranged from a few dozen to around fifty, depending on who was speaking and how many years they had served.

Then there was the witness who spoke of six hundred and fifty, from a list nobody ever produced.

It is that last number, the one with the least evidence behind it, that became famous.

It appears in countless books, websites and lists of history’s worst killers, usually printed as if it were a fact.

The truth is that nobody knows how many young women died in Elizabeth Báthory’s service.

The honest range in the surviving testimony is wide, and every figure in it was given by someone who was frightened, or in pain, or repeating a rumor.

Even the smallest of those numbers is a horror.

None of them was ever tested in court against the woman they accused.

—

## Čachtice today

The castle where she was confined still stands on its hill above the village, although for centuries it was only a ruin.

It was damaged in the early eighteenth century and slowly fell apart.

In recent years parts of it have been repaired and made safe, and visitors climb the path to the walls, as Thurzó’s men did on that December night in 1610.

Guides point to the part of the castle where the countess is said to have been kept.

Nobody can be sure which room it was.

In the village below, there is a small museum, and the story is told to tourists from all over the world.

Her name has been used for horror films, heavy metal bands and novels.

In 2008 the Slovak director Juraj Jakubisko made a film that told her story as the tragedy of a woman destroyed by her enemies.

In 2009 the actress Julie Delpy made another that leaned the opposite way.

Neither of them could do what nobody has ever done: put Elizabeth Báthory in a courtroom and let her speak.

—

## The words nobody wrote down

No record preserves anything Elizabeth Báthory said on the night she was taken, or in the years she was confined.

The lines below are imagined, written only for the short film made from the picture.

They are not history, and they are not her words.

In the film, she leans over the rising wall and looks at the hands setting the bricks.

“Stop. I am a Báthory.”

She turns her eyes toward the place where a judge should be standing, and there is nobody there.

“Where is my trial? Where are my judges?”

Her voice drops, and for a moment she is not crying.

“Let them hear me in open court.”

Then the next brick goes down, and she says the last thing quietly, almost as a promise.

“If you close this wall, the truth stays in here with me.”

—

## The picture, once more

Now it is possible to say what is true in it.

The wall is true, in the way that matters.

Whether it was made of brick or of locked doors and guards, a wall was put between Elizabeth Báthory and the world in the winter of 1610, and it was never taken down.

The workman’s hands are true.

Someone carried out the order.

Someone always does.

The woman’s face is not true.

She was fifty, not twenty-five, and nobody knows whether she cried, or raged, or said nothing at all.

What the picture leaves out is everything around that moment.

It leaves out the girls who went into service in her households and never came home, and the families who waited years for anyone in power to listen.

It leaves out the servants who were tortured until they confessed, and then burned or beheaded in public at Bytča.

It leaves out the Palatine who was both her judge and her family’s protector, the king who owed her money, and the relatives who made sure the estates stayed in the family.

And it leaves out the one thing nobody was ever allowed to hear: her answer.

In the picture, the wall is still only half built, and her hands are still on the bricks.

In the story, the masons finished.

You Might Also Enjoy