Dr. Joseph Warren Was Shot Dead At Bunker Hill In 1775 And Buried In A Ditch With Another Man. The Next Spring, Paul Revere Knew Him By His Teeth
A hillside above a burning town, in the smoke of a summer afternoon.
There is a picture that is meant to show how Dr. Joseph Warren died, and this is what it shows.
The sky is pale and full of drifting gray smoke.
On the right, behind a broken wall of split timbers, low flames run along the ground.
Beyond the timbers a few men in broad hats aim long muskets out across the field, under a striped flag with a ring of white stars.
On the left a long line of soldiers in red coats and white cross-belts stands with bayonets raised under a British flag.
In the front of the picture two men face each other.
On the left stands a British officer, tall and straight, with powdered white hair tied back at the neck.
He wears a red coat faced with dark blue and laced with gold, fringed gold epaulettes on his shoulders, a crimson sash at his waist, pale breeches and tall black boots.
His sword is drawn, but its point rests on the ground beside his boot.
He is looking down, and his face is hard.
On the right, a few steps away from him, a man is down on both knees in the dirt.
He wears a blue coat with buff facings and gold epaulettes, a buff waistcoat and a white cravat, and a sword hangs at his hip.
One of his hands holds a black three-cornered hat against the ground.
The other is pressed flat against his chest.
His dark hair is loose, and his face is turned up toward the smoke.
It is a picture that makes you wait for the next moment.
It is also an illustration made in our own time, and the moment in it never happened.
Joseph Warren did not kneel in front of a British officer, and nobody stood over him with a sword.
As far as the best accounts tell, a musket ball struck him in the head in the last minutes of the battle, and he died where he fell.
What happened to him after that is the part of the story that the old paintings leave out.
He was thirty-four years old.
He was a doctor with one of the busiest practices in Boston, the father of four children, and the president of the rebel government of Massachusetts.
Three days before the battle that government had made him a major general.
He went up the hill anyway as a volunteer, with a borrowed musket, and he stood in a ditch of fresh earth with farmers.
When the fighting was over, the British soldiers who buried the dead on that hill recognized him.
A captain whose men did the burying wrote afterward that he had put Warren into one hole together with another rebel.
There the body stayed, in British hands, through a long summer, an autumn and a winter.
In the spring of 1776 the British left Boston, and a small party of men walked out onto the hill with shovels to look for him.
Two of them were his brothers.
The third was a silversmith who also, as a side trade, made false teeth.
His name was Paul Revere.
When they opened the ground, the dead were past knowing by their faces.
So Revere bent over the remains and looked for something he had made with his own hands, two small teeth that were not real teeth at all, because he had carved them himself out of ivory and fastened them in place with gold wire.
To understand how a doctor ended up in that hole, and how his friend found him there, we have to go back to the town where both of them grew up.
—
## A doctor from Roxbury
Joseph Warren was born on the eleventh of June, 1741, in Roxbury, a farming town just outside Boston.
His father, who had the same name, was a farmer with an orchard.
In October of 1755 the elder Joseph Warren fell from a ladder while he was picking fruit in that orchard, and he died.
His son was fourteen.
The boy was already at Harvard College, and he finished there in 1759.
He then did what young men who wanted to be doctors did in the colonies at that time.
There was no medical school in North America yet, so he apprenticed himself to a working physician in Boston and learned the trade at the bedside.
He was good at it.
In 1764 smallpox broke out in Boston, and the town allowed inoculation, the dangerous but effective practice of giving healthy people a mild case of the disease on purpose.
Young doctors who were willing to work through an epidemic made their names that year, and Warren was one of them.
On the sixth of September, 1764, he married Elizabeth Hooton, an eighteen-year-old heiress.
They had four children: Elizabeth, Joseph, Mary and Richard.
His practice grew until it was among the largest in the town.
His patients included the poor of the waterfront and the richest merchants on King Street, and also, it is said, some British officers and their families.
In 1773 his wife died.
He was thirty-one, a widower with four small children, and by then he was something more than a doctor.
—
## The man in the toga
Boston in the 1760s and 1770s was a town in an argument with its own government.
Parliament in London kept passing laws to tax the colonies, and Boston kept refusing to accept them.
Warren was drawn into the argument early, and he turned out to have a gift for it.
He wrote for the newspapers.
He sat on the town’s committees.
He joined the secret circle of men that called itself the Sons of Liberty, and he rose to become grand master of one of the two Masonic grand lodges in Massachusetts, whose members included a good part of the patriot leadership.
One of the men he met there was a silversmith from the North End named Paul Revere.
On the fifth of March, 1770, British soldiers fired into a crowd on King Street and killed five men.
Every year after that, Boston held a public oration on the anniversary of what it called the Boston Massacre.
Warren gave the oration in 1772.
He gave it again in 1775, and that second time is the one that people remembered.
By then Boston was an occupied town.
General Thomas Gage was both the military commander and the royal governor of Massachusetts, and thousands of British troops were quartered in the streets.
The anniversary fell on a Sunday that year, so the oration was held on Monday, the sixth of March, in the Old South Meeting House.
The building was packed, and a large number of British officers had come in and taken seats near the front.
The accounts of what came next were written later, and they do not all agree.
The best-known version says that the crowd was so thick that Warren had to climb in through a window behind the pulpit.
It says that he wore a white Roman toga, like an orator of the old republic, and that he spoke while officers in red coats sat a few feet below him.
A diary kept by the former royal governor, Thomas Hutchinson, records a rumor that one officer had brought an egg to throw in Warren’s face as a signal for the others to draw their swords.
The egg was never thrown.
There were hisses from some of the front rows, and there was a scuffle near the end, and nobody was hurt.
Warren had stood up in an occupied town and spoken against the occupation, and he had walked out again.
Six weeks later the argument stopped being an argument.
—
## The night of the riders
On the evening of the eighteenth of April, 1775, Warren learned that British troops were about to march out of Boston into the countryside.
Their orders were to seize the gunpowder and cannon the colonists had stored at Concord.
Two of the most wanted patriot leaders, John Hancock and Samuel Adams, were staying at Lexington, on the road the troops would take.
Warren sent two riders to warn them.
One was a tanner named William Dawes, who went out by the land route over Boston Neck.
The other was Paul Revere, who was rowed across the river to Charlestown and rode from there.
The next day, after the fighting at Lexington and Concord, Warren rode out and joined the militia who were harrying the British column on its long march back to Boston.
At one point a musket ball came close enough to strike part of his hair or his wig.
By nightfall the British were penned inside Boston, and thousands of armed New Englanders were camped in a ring around them.
The siege of Boston had begun, and Warren was one of the men running it.
—
## The silversmith’s other trade
Paul Revere was six years older than Warren.
He was a silversmith by trade and the son of a silversmith, a French Huguenot immigrant whose name had been Apollos Rivoire.
In the hard years of the 1760s, when the silver trade was slow, he looked for other work.
One of the things he took up was dentistry.
He is said to have learned it from an English surgeon-dentist who passed through Boston in the 1760s.
Around 1770 he was advertising in the Boston newspapers that he could replace lost front teeth with artificial ones that looked like real teeth and allowed the wearer to speak properly.
Revere made the replacement teeth out of ivory, shaped them to fit the gap, and tied them to the healthy teeth on each side with fine wire.
One of his customers was Joseph Warren.
According to the National Museum of Health and Medicine, Revere replaced Warren’s upper left canine and the first premolar beside it with ivory, and fastened them in with gold wire.
It was a small piece of work on a friend’s mouth.
Neither man could have guessed what it would one day be used for.
—
## Three days a general
After Lexington and Concord, Massachusetts was governed by a body that the royal government did not recognize, the Provincial Congress.
Its most important arm in wartime was the Committee of Safety, which raised men, bought powder, and gave orders to the army camped around Boston.
Warren sat on the committee and was, in practice, its leading man.
When John Hancock left for Philadelphia to sit in the Continental Congress, Warren became president of the Provincial Congress.
He was the most important political figure left in Massachusetts.
On the fourteenth of June, 1775, the Provincial Congress voted to make him a major general.
Three days later he was dead.
His colleague Elbridge Gerry wrote to the Massachusetts delegates in Philadelphia on the twentieth of June.
“Our good, our beloved Friend Doctor Warren,” he wrote, “is no more.”
He had been chosen a major general two days before, Gerry wrote, had “Accepted on Friday and on Saturday dyed like a Hero.”
There is a story, printed many years later, that Gerry had begged Warren not to go to the hill.
In that story Warren answered with a line from the Roman poet Horace that every schoolboy who had learned Latin knew.
“Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori.”
It is sweet and fitting to die for one’s country.
The line is not in Gerry’s letter of June 20, and nobody has traced it to anything written in 1775.
It may be true.
It is also exactly the kind of sentence that a grieving country puts into the mouth of a dead man.
—
## A hill in the night
Boston sits on what was then almost an island, joined to the mainland only by the narrow strip of Boston Neck.
Across the river to the north lies another peninsula, Charlestown, with a small town at its southern tip and two hills behind it.
The higher hill, farther back, was called Bunker Hill.
The lower one, closer to Boston, was called Breed’s Hill.
Whoever put cannon on those hills could fire down on the British ships in the harbor and into the town itself.
General Gage knew it, and he planned to occupy the heights.
The rebel command heard of the plan and moved first.
On the night of the sixteenth of June, about a thousand men marched out of Cambridge carrying picks and shovels as well as muskets.
They were led by Colonel William Prescott of Pepperell, a farmer of forty-nine who had served in the last war against the French.
Their orders were to fortify Bunker Hill.
For reasons that historians have argued about ever since, they dug instead on Breed’s Hill, closer to the enemy.
They worked through the short summer night in silence.
By first light there was a square earthen fort, a redoubt, about a hundred and thirty feet on each side, standing where there had been a pasture the evening before.
—
## The morning
The first British warship opened fire at dawn.
Others joined in, and so did a battery on Copp’s Hill in the North End of Boston, directly across the water.
The men in the redoubt had been digging all night.
They had little food and not enough water, and now iron was falling on them.
Early in the morning a cannonball killed a young man from Billerica named Asa Pollard, who was working outside the walls.
Many of the men had never seen a man killed in war, and they stopped digging to stare.
Prescott climbed onto the parapet and walked along it in full view of the British gunners to show them that it could be done.
The digging went on.
One of the men in the redoubt was a company clerk named Peter Brown.
A week later he wrote a letter to his mother describing the day, and it is one of the best accounts we have from a man in the ranks.
Late in the morning General Gage held a council of war in Boston and settled on a plain frontal attack.
General William Howe would take something over two thousand men across the river in boats, land them on the shore of the Charlestown peninsula, and drive the rebels off the hill.
Twelve miles to the south, in Braintree, Abigail Adams heard the guns and climbed a hill near her farm with her seven-year-old son, John Quincy, to look toward the smoke.
Early in the afternoon, rebel snipers in the houses of Charlestown began firing on the British as they landed.
Howe asked for the town to be burned.
Heated shot and fire-bombs from the ships and from Copp’s Hill set the wooden town alight, and within a short time it was one great fire.
That is where the flames in any honest picture of the battle belong: below the hill, in the streets of Charlestown, not along the walls of the fort.
—
## The volunteer
Warren had spent the night of June 16 in Watertown, where the Provincial Congress was meeting.
He had a bad headache and had not slept.
When word came that the British were preparing to attack, he got up and went.
He crossed Charlestown Neck on foot while it was under fire from the ships, and he came up the back of the hill.
At the rail fence on the left of the American line he found General Israel Putnam of Connecticut, a famous old fighter of fifty-seven.
Putnam, by the usual account, offered to take orders from him, since Warren now outranked him.
Warren refused.
He had come as a volunteer, he said, and he only wanted to know where he could be of the most use.
Putnam pointed him to the redoubt.
At the redoubt the scene repeated itself.
Prescott offered him the command, and Warren again refused, saying that Prescott and the others knew how to fight and he had come to learn.
These exchanges come to us from men who wrote them down years afterward, and the words have certainly been polished.
What is not in doubt is the plain fact underneath them.
The most important political leader in Massachusetts went into the redoubt as a private soldier, and he stayed there.
One tradition gives him a fierce remark as he looked out at the British lines.
“These fellows say we won’t fight!”
“By Heaven, I hope I shall die up to my knees in blood!”
Like the line from Horace, it comes from later tellings.
—
## Three times up the slope
The British landed, formed up, and waited for reinforcements.
It was after three in the afternoon before Howe was ready.
His men carried heavy packs, and the grass on the slope was long and full of fences and stone walls.
The plan was for the light infantry to go along the beach on the right, under the bank of the Mystic River, and turn the rebel flank at the rail fence, while the main line went up the hill toward the redoubt.
The Americans had very little powder.
The order passed along their line was to hold fire until the enemy was very close, and to aim low, at the officers.
The famous version of it is “Don’t fire until you see the whites of their eyes.”
Nobody can say for certain who said it, and something very like it had been said by European commanders in earlier wars.
The order itself was real, and so was what it did.
On the beach, the light infantry came along the shore in a narrow column and walked into the fire of the men behind a stone wall at the water’s edge.
The front of the column was shot down almost to a man, and the rest fell back.
On the slope, the main line came within a short distance of the redoubt and the fence, and the American volley tore through it.
The British fell back down the hill.
They formed again and came up a second time, and again they were driven back.
Inside the redoubt, the officers were counting powder.
Men took cartridges from the dead and the wounded.
Artillery cartridges were broken open and the powder handed round.
Reinforcements were supposed to be coming across Charlestown Neck, but the Neck was under fire from the ships, and most of the units that were sent turned back or never came.
Howe brought fresh troops across from Boston and prepared a third attack.
This time the men left their packs behind, and this time the main weight went straight at the redoubt, with bayonets fixed.
—
## The redoubt
The third attack came up the slope near five o’clock.
The Americans fired what they had left, and it was not much.
Then the British were at the walls and over them.
A redoubt is not a castle.
It is a ditch and a bank of earth, with an opening at the back.
Once the enemy was inside, the defenders had almost no bayonets and almost no powder, and they fought with musket butts and stones while they tried to get out.
Major John Pitcairn of the Royal Marines, the officer who had commanded the British advance guard at Lexington two months earlier, was shot as he climbed the wall.
His son, a lieutenant in the same corps, carried him away, and he died in Boston that night.
Joseph Warren was among the men falling back from the fort.
He was hit in the head by a musket ball.
The ball struck him just below his left eye.
He fell, and he died almost at once.
The best summaries of the evidence put the place some distance outside the redoubt, as the defenders were pulling back across the hill.
Who fired the shot has never been settled.
A British account of the time said that the man who shot him was an officer’s servant, who had recognized him.
A forensic analysis published in 2011 found that this story fits the evidence, though it cannot prove it.
Other accounts simply say that he was shot in the general retreat by a soldier who had no idea who he was.
The rest of the Americans got off the hill.
The retreat was not a rout.
The men went back over the Neck under fire from the ships, and Major Andrew McClary of New Hampshire was killed by a cannonball there, one of the last American officers to die that day.
Thomas Knowlton, the Connecticut captain whose men had held the rail fence, came off the field alive.
He would be killed fifteen months later, at Harlem Heights in New York.
By sunset the British held both hills and the burning ruins of Charlestown.
—
## The ledger
The British had won the hill.
The price was written down in General Gage’s own return of casualties.
Two hundred and twenty-six officers and men were killed.
Eight hundred and twenty-eight were wounded.
That was more than a thousand men out of the roughly two and a half thousand who were sent across the river, and the officers had suffered worst of all.
In some companies every officer was dead or wounded.
The American losses were heavy too, though lighter.
The usual figures are about a hundred and fifteen killed, about three hundred and five wounded, and about thirty taken prisoner, most of them wounded men left behind in the redoubt.
General Henry Clinton, who had crossed over in the afternoon to help, wrote that it was “a dear bought victory.”
Another such, he added, would have ruined them.
Gage was recalled that autumn, and Howe took his place.
The siege of Boston went on.
—
## One hole for two men
When the fighting ended, the British were left on a hill covered with dead and dying men of both armies.
The wounded were carried down to the boats.
The dead had to be buried quickly, in the June heat.
Burial parties went out across the slope and dug where the bodies lay.
Among the American dead near the redoubt they found a man in good clothes, and someone knew him.
The news that Dr. Warren was among the slain went through the British camp fast.
One officer who was there was Captain Walter Laurie of the 43rd Regiment.
He had commanded the British companies at the North Bridge in Concord on the nineteenth of April, and on Breed’s Hill it was his men who did the burying.
He wrote afterward about what he had done with the president of the rebel congress.
He said that he had found Warren among the slain and “stuffed the scoundrel with another rebel, into one hole.”
The hole was a shallow trench near the redoubt.
Warren was put into it with an unknown American soldier and covered with earth.
Other stories reached the American lines in the weeks that followed, and they are harder to judge.
Some said that Warren’s fine clothes had been stripped from him on the field.
Some said that his body had been stabbed with bayonets after he was dead, or that his face had been beaten.
These stories passed from person to person in a besieged country that badly wanted to hate its enemy, and none of them comes from a witness who signed his name to it.
The worst story of all has a paper trail, and it is worth looking at carefully.
On the twenty-fifth of November, 1775, a young Boston lawyer named Benjamin Hichborn wrote a long letter to John Adams.
Hichborn had been held for some time as a prisoner on a British warship, and he passed on what he said he had heard from two gentlemen belonging to the Preston, the flagship of the British admiral.
According to them, a naval lieutenant named Drew had gone up to the hill a day or two after the battle and had the earth dug away from Warren’s body.
He had spat in the dead man’s face, Hichborn wrote, and jumped on his stomach.
At last, Hichborn wrote, he had cut off the head and done every act of violence to the body.
Hichborn added that the British officers in general despised Drew for it.
So the story has a name, a date and a chain of tellers.
It is still hearsay, written down months later by a man who had not seen it, from men who are not named.
Nothing written by the men who opened the grave in 1776 confirms it.
It may be true in whole, in part, or not at all.
What is certain is that the British left Warren in a shallow hole on the hill, in an enemy’s grave, without a name.
There is also a remark that has followed his memory ever since.
General Gage is supposed to have said that the death of Dr. Warren was worth more to the British than the deaths of five hundred ordinary rebels.
It is a rumor, and it is not found in anything Gage is known to have written.
—
## “Fell gloriously”
The news reached the American camps that night, and it spread outward from there.
On the eighteenth of June, Abigail Adams sat down to write to her husband in Philadelphia.
“The Day; perhaps the decisive Day is come on which the fate of America depends,” she began.
Then she gave him the news that she knew would hurt him most.
“I have just heard that our dear Friend Dr. Warren is no more but fell gloriously fighting for his Country.”
She added what she had been told he used to say: that it was better to die honorably in the field than ignominiously hang upon the gallows.
If the rebellion failed, the men who led it would be tried for treason, and Warren had been one of the men most likely to hang.
In Philadelphia, two days before the battle, the Continental Congress had named George Washington commander of a new Continental Army.
He was already on the road north when the news of Breed’s Hill reached him.
He took command at Cambridge early in July, of an army that had just lost its best-known civilian leader on the first real battlefield of the war.
“Fell gloriously” became the way the country spoke of Warren.
It was a kind phrase.
It said nothing about the trench.
Within a few years there were poems and plays about the death of Warren, and in 1786 the painter John Trumbull, who had watched the battle from a distance as a young officer, finished his famous painting of it.
In Trumbull’s picture Warren lies dying in the arms of another man, and a British officer, Major John Small, reaches out to stop a grenadier from driving a bayonet into him.
It is a noble scene, and it is invented too.
—
## The spring of 1776
The siege of Boston lasted through the winter.
In March of 1776 the Americans fortified Dorchester Heights, south of the town, with cannon that had been hauled all the way from Fort Ticonderoga in New York.
Howe, who was now in command, decided to leave.
On the seventeenth of March the British army sailed out of Boston harbor, taking with it about a thousand Loyalist civilians, and the town was in American hands again.
Charlestown was a field of ashes.
The two hills behind it were still covered with the earthworks of both armies, and with graves.
Within a few weeks a small party went out to look for Warren.
It included his brothers, one of whom, John Warren, was also a doctor.
It included Paul Revere.
How they found the right place is not well recorded.
Some people in the area must have remembered where the burial parties had dug near the redoubt, and they opened the ground there.
They found two bodies together in a shallow grave.
The bodies had been in the earth for about nine months, through a summer and a winter.
Nobody could say from what was left of the faces which of the two men, if either, was Joseph Warren.
—
## The teeth
This is the moment the story is usually told for.
Revere knew the mouth he was looking at.
He had worked in it himself.
He looked for the two ivory teeth on the upper left side of the jaw, the canine and the premolar beside it, and for the twist of gold wire that held them to their neighbors.
They were there.
He knew them as a silversmith knows his own work, by the shape of the carving and the way the wire was turned.
The body was Warren’s.
It is often called the first forensic dental identification in American history: the first time, as far as anyone knows, that a dead person in America was named by someone recognizing the work that had been done on his teeth.
The National Museum of Health and Medicine calls it one of the earliest cases of forensic evidence being used to identify a fallen American soldier, and that careful wording is the safest.
What makes Warren’s case different is that the man who made the teeth was the man who identified them, and that both men are famous.
—
## Two funerals and three graves
The remains were carried back into Boston.
On the eighth of April, 1776, the town gave Joseph Warren the funeral that he had been refused on the hill.
His Masonic brothers walked in procession, and soldiers of the new Continental Army marched with them.
The service was held at King’s Chapel, and a young lawyer named Perez Morton gave the oration.
Warren was laid in a tomb in the Granary Burying Ground, a short walk from the meeting house where he had spoken in his toga the year before.
He did not stay there.
In 1825 his remains were moved to a vault under St. Paul’s Church, also in Boston.
In 1855 they were moved again, to the family vault at Forest Hills Cemetery, in what had once been his home town of Roxbury.
That is where he is now.
—
## Four children
When Warren died, his four children were living away from Boston, in Worcester.
They were looked after by Mercy Scollay, a Boston woman who had been close to Warren after his wife’s death.
Some writers have said that she was engaged to marry him.
Others think she was only the friend who took in his children.
The evidence does not settle it.
What is clear is that she fought for them.
In 1776 she wrote to John Hancock asking that something be done for their education.
Nothing much was done for two years.
Then the cause was taken up by an unexpected man.
In 1778 General Benedict Arnold, who had known Warren in the first weeks of the war, heard that the children of the hero of Breed’s Hill were living in straitened circumstances.
He sent five hundred dollars of his own money for their schooling, and he pressed Congress to support them.
Sources differ on exactly when Congress agreed, but in the end the children were granted the half-pay of a major general from the day of their father’s death until the youngest came of age.
Two years later Arnold went over to the British.
His name became the word Americans use for a traitor, and the money he gave to Joseph Warren’s children is one of the few things he did in those years that nobody has ever held against him.
The children did not have long lives, most of them.
Young Joseph graduated from Harvard in 1786 and died in 1790, at twenty-two.
Richard, the youngest, died at twenty-one.
—
## The hill with the wrong name
The battle in which Joseph Warren died is called the Battle of Bunker Hill.
It was fought almost entirely on Breed’s Hill.
The name came from the original orders and from the British, who called the whole high ground of the peninsula by the name of its tallest hill, and it never came off.
In 1825, the year Warren’s remains were moved to St. Paul’s, the old Marquis de Lafayette laid the cornerstone of a monument on the battlefield, and Daniel Webster gave the address.
The great granite obelisk was finished in 1843.
It stands on Breed’s Hill, on the site of the redoubt.
It is called the Bunker Hill Monument.
Nearby stands a marble statue of Joseph Warren, put up in 1857.
What it changed was a question that nobody in America or in Britain had been able to answer before June 17.
Could farmers with muskets stand against regular soldiers in the open?
After that afternoon, everybody knew.
—
## The picture, once more
Look at it one last time.
The pale smoke, the burning timbers, the line of red coats with their bayonets.
The tall officer with his powdered hair and his sword point on the ground.
The man in blue on his knees, with one hand on his chest and his face turned up.
Now it is possible to say what is true in it.
The red coats are true, and so is the smoke, and so is the fire.
The officer and his soldiers really did take that hill, and the men behind the wall really did fire on them until they had nothing left to fire.
The rest is invented.
The man in blue wears the uniform of a Continental general, with gold epaulettes, and Joseph Warren never wore one.
He had held his commission for three days, the Continental Army had been created by Congress in Philadelphia that same week, and there were no such uniforms on Breed’s Hill.
Tradition says that he went to the hill in his own good clothes, as a gentleman and a doctor.
The fort was not a wall of timbers.
It was a ditch and a bank of earth, dug by farmers in one night.
The fire in the picture is in the wrong place.
It was down the hill, in Charlestown, where the houses were burning.
The striped flag with a ring of stars did not exist yet; Congress did not adopt a flag of stars and stripes until 1777.
The British flag in the picture has a red diagonal cross that was only added to the Union flag in 1801.
And no British officer stood over Joseph Warren while he knelt and looked up at the sky.
By every good account, he was shot in the head and he died where he fell, among the men who were trying to get off the hill.
The British did not need to stand over him.
What they did to him was simpler and colder than that.
They put him in a hole with a stranger and left him there without a name.
And when his friends came back for him, the face that had spoken in the Old South Meeting House could not tell them anything.
It was a small piece of carved ivory and a twist of gold wire that brought him home.