News

Dolly Parton Dared Eddie Van Halen to Play Something Slow on TV — Nobody Expected What He Chose

Eddie Van Halen, Dolly Parton, and the Song He Could Not Play

In March 1987, in the middle of a taping of The Tonight Show, Eddie Van Halen stood up from a seat in the fourth row of the studio audience, took off his baseball cap, and walked down the aisle toward Johnny Carson’s stage. He wasn’t booked. He wasn’t carrying a guitar. In the inside pocket of his jacket was a cassette tape he had found in a closet 3 months earlier and had not been able to listen to all the way through.

He was walking down that aisle because Dolly Parton had just told millions of people that the fastest guitar in the world was hiding. And she had dared him to prove her wrong. What Eddie did when he reached that stage was not what anybody in Burbank expected. Not the audience, who were already on their feet.

Not Johnny Carson, who had a line for everything and was about to run out of them. And not Dolly Parton, who had spent 40 years reading people and was certain she had read this one right. She had. And she hadn’t.

And the difference between those two things is the whole story. It was Thursday, the 12th of March 1987 at NBC Studios in Burbank, California. The Tonight Show was taped in the early evening, the way it always was. Straight through from top to bottom, as if it were going out live.

No retakes, no stopping. Whatever happened on that stage between half past 5:00 and 7:00 was exactly what millions of people would see in their living rooms at half past 11:00 that night. Dolly Parton was the second guest. She was there to talk about a new record.

Valerie Bertinelli was the third. She was there to talk about a television movie. And her husband, who hated sitting in green rooms almost as much as he hated talking on television, had asked if he could just watch from the audience like a normal person. The producers found him a seat on the aisle in the fourth row.

He pulled a baseball cap down low, slid into it, and for the first 40 minutes of the show, nobody around him had any idea who he was. That was exactly how Eddie wanted it. Because in the spring of 1987, Eddie Van Halen did not want to be looked at. He did not want to be asked how he was doing.

And there was one thing in particular that he did not want to talk about with anybody, least of all on national television. Three months earlier, on the 9th of December, 1986, his father had died. To understand what happened on that stage, you have to understand where both of them were that spring. Dolly Parton was 41 years old, and she was already one of the most famous women in the world.

She had written Jolene and I will always love you. She had starred in 9 to 5. She had a theme park in the Smoky Mountains with her name over the gate, getting ready for its second summer. And she had just put out the record she was proudest of in years.

It was called Trio. She had made it with Emmylou Harris and Linda Ronstadt, two singers she loved. And the three of them had been trying to make it together for the better part of a decade. Record labels and managers and schedules had gotten in the way every single time.

Now, finally, it was out. It was the opposite of a big production. Three women, three voices, a few acoustic instruments, and old mountain songs that sounded like they had been sung on a back porch after supper. No drum machines, no smoke, no flash.

Dolly loved it more than almost anything she had ever done. And she was in the mood that spring to tell anybody who would listen why it mattered. Eddie Van Halen was 32, and he was on top of the world, at least from the outside. Nine years earlier, the first Van Halen album had changed the way an entire generation thought about the electric guitar.

Kids everywhere had heard him tapping the strings with both hands and gone out and bought guitars and tried to do the same thing. And most of them had failed. Magazines called him the greatest guitarist alive. The band’s latest record, 5150, made with their new singer, Sammy Hagar, had gone straight to number one in America the summer before.

They were playing arenas full of 15,000 people a night. And there was a word that followed Eddie around in those years. In the reviews, in the guitar magazines, in the mouths of the musicians who resented him. Fast.

The fastest. The flashiest. The man with a thousand notes. And underneath that word, for some people, there was another, quieter judgment.

That it was all fireworks. That if you took away the speed and the volume and the tricks, there might not be anything underneath. That Eddie Van Halen could play anything except something simple. Eddie had heard all of it.

He never answered any of it. He just went home and practiced. But that spring, for the first time in his life, he wasn’t practicing much at all. His father, Jan, had been a professional clarinet and saxophone player in Holland.

He had played in orchestras and on the radio. When the family came to America in 1962 with a piano and about $50, nobody in California wanted a Dutch clarinet player. And Jan spent years washing dishes and cleaning buildings so his two sons could have music lessons. Late at night, after his shifts, he would sit at the kitchen table in Pasadena and play his clarinet very softly.

Old tunes from Holland so he wouldn’t wake anybody up. Eddie grew up falling asleep to it. It was his father who had sat him down at a piano when he was six. It was his father who told him again and again that the hardest thing in music was not to play fast.

It was to play one note and mean it. And after the funeral in December, when Eddie and his brother Alex were clearing out their father’s things, Eddie had found a shoebox at the back of a closet. Inside was a cassette tape labeled in his father’s handwriting with a single Dutch word and a year. He had put it in a tape player once.

He had listened for about 15 seconds. And then he had turned it off, put it in his pocket, and carried it everywhere with him for 3 months without being able to play it again. It was in his pocket that night in the fourth row. Hold on to that.

Before this story is over, it will matter more than anything else that happened on that stage. Dolly came out to the kind of applause she always got, big and warm and a little louder from the men in the back rows. She was wearing a bright blue dress, and her hair was piled up even higher than usual. And the first thing Johnny Carson did was look at her and shake his head slowly and wait for the laugh.

Because that was the game they always played. She played it right back. They talked about Trio. Dolly told the story of the three of them trying for 10 years to get it made, and the record company men telling them nobody wanted to hear three women singing old mountain songs without a single drum on them.

“And now it’s out,” Johnny said. “And now it’s out,” Dolly said. “And Johnny, I’m prouder of that little record than just about anything I’ve done. Because there’s nothing on it to hide behind.

It’s just us and a few old guitars. If it’s no good, everybody’s going to know it’s no good.” The audience laughed. Johnny nodded. And then he did something he did now and again when a guest was relaxed and the segment was going well.

He pushed a little. “Nothing to hide behind,” he said. “That’s interesting because a lot of music these days, it seems to be all about how fast and how loud. The kids are all buying these guitar players who play about a thousand notes a second.” “Oh, I know,” Dolly said.

“My nephews have the posters.” “Who’s on the posters?” “Well, that Van Halen boy mostly,” Dolly said. “The one with the big grin. Eddie.” In the fourth row, on the aisle, a man in a baseball cap went very still. “What do you make of him?” Johnny asked, “coming from where you come from?” Dolly smiled and for a second it looked like she was going to make a joke and move on.

She didn’t. “Well, I’ll tell you the truth,” she said. “That boy can play. I mean it.

My nephew put that record on for me at Christmas. The one where he does it with both his hands and I sat there with my mouth open like everybody else. I’ve been around pickers my whole life, Johnny. Back home in the mountains, every other man on the porch could play something.

I have never heard anybody play like that.” There was a little murmur in the audience. That was not what they expected from Dolly Parton. “But,” Johnny said. “But,” Dolly said and she smiled again.

And this time it was a different kind of smile. Every time I hear him, he’s going so fast. It’s like his hands are running away from something. And I always sit there and think, ‘Honey, slow down.

Just one time. Let me hear what you sound like when you’re not running.'” The audience laughed a little uncertainly. “You think he can’t play slow?” Johnny asked. “Oh, I think he can,” Dolly said.

“I think that boy could play anything he wanted. I just don’t think he wants to, because slow is scary. When you play slow, there’s nowhere to hide. Every note’s out there by itself, naked as a jaybird, and everybody can hear if you mean it or not.” She shrugged.

“I’d love to hear him play one plain thing,” she said. “Something slow. A melody your grandmama could hum. No tricks, no thousand notes, just one little tune, played like he means it.” She laughed, warmly, not cruelly.

“But I don’t think he’d dare.” In the fourth row, Eddie Van Halen had pulled his cap even lower. He was not angry. That was the strange thing, and the thing Valerie, watching on a monitor backstage, understood before anybody else. Most rock stars of 1987, hearing a country singer tell America they were hiding behind their tricks, would have been furious.

Some of them would have stormed out. A few would have stormed the stage. Eddie just sat there, with his hands clasped between his knees, looking at the floor. Because Dolly Parton had just described, in about 30 seconds on national television, something he had not been able to say to anyone for 3 months.

He had not played anything slow since the funeral. Not one thing. He had gone into his studio behind the house almost every night that winter and played fast, loud, for hours until his fingers hurt. Because when it was that loud and that fast, he didn’t have to think.

And every single time he had tried to slow down, to play something quiet, something plain, the kind of thing his father would have played at the kitchen table, his hands had simply stopped. Like his hands were running away from something. He hadn’t known a stranger could see that from a record. The woman in the seat next to him had been glancing at him for a while.

She was in her 50s, from Kansas City, on vacation. And she had a son who had the same posters Dolly’s nephews had. When Dolly said his name, she had looked at the man in the cap a little more closely. When Dolly said, “I don’t think he’d dare,” she grabbed his arm.

“Oh my god!” she said, much louder than she meant to. “You’re him!” Heads turned. A few rows of people twisted around in their seats. A camera operator on the floor, who had been bored for most of the segment, swung his camera around on instinct and found a man in a baseball cap in the fourth row trying very hard to disappear.

In the control booth, a director looked at the monitor and said something that can’t be repeated and reached for the button that talked to the stage. Up on the couch, Dolly had moved on to a story about her theme park. She was halfway through it when she noticed Johnny wasn’t listening anymore. He had a hand to his ear, the way he did when somebody in the booth was talking to him.

And off to the side of the stage, just out of shot, the show’s producer, Fred de Cordova, was making a gesture Johnny had seen maybe three times in 25 years. A flat hand waving low. Wait. Johnny turned back to the camera and smiled the smile he used when he didn’t know what was going on.

“Well,” he said, “it seems we have a little situation.” Dolly looked at him. “I’m being told,” Johnny said, still listening, “that we have a guest in our audience tonight, in the fourth row, who may have heard everything you just said, Dolly.” The audience started to turn around in their seats. A ripple went through the room. Then a name whispered, then said out loud, then shouted.

Dolly’s face changed, just slightly. It was the look of a woman who had said exactly what she meant and was now going to find out what it cost. “Oh, Lord,” she said. “Is he big?” The audience roared.

“Not very,” Johnny said, squinting out past the lights. “Ladies and gentlemen, I believe Eddie Van Halen is in our audience tonight.” The studio came apart. People were standing up all over the room, trying to see past each other. The band was whispering.

Ed McMahon leaned across the couch toward Dolly and said something that made her laugh and put a hand to her chest. And in the fourth row, very slowly, a skinny man in a denim jacket stood up and took off his baseball cap. He had the grin, the famous one, the grin from the posters, too wide for his face. But anybody close enough could see that the grin was a little shaky that night.

“Eddie,” Johnny called out, “you want to come down here and defend yourself?” The audience cheered. Eddie looked at the stage for a long second. He looked at Dolly Parton in her blue dress on the couch, who was looking right back at him without blinking. Then he walked down the aisle.

This was the moment everybody in the room thought they understood. The rock star had been called out by the country singer on national television. Now, he was coming down to settle it. Half the audience was expecting a fight.

The other half was hoping for one. He climbed the steps onto the stage. He shook Johnny’s hand. He shook Ed McMahon’s hand.

And then, he turned to Dolly. She didn’t stand up. She didn’t offer her hand. She just sat there with her legs crossed and her hands folded in her lap and waited, the way she had waited out a lot of angry men in her life.

Eddie sat down on the other end of the couch. He put his cap on his knee. For about 5 seconds, nobody said anything. Johnny tried.

Eddie, I want you to know Dolly said some very nice things about you before she said “I heard.” Eddie said. He was looking at Dolly. “I heard all of it.” “Did you?” Dolly said. “Yeah.” He turned his cap around in his hands.

The audience leaned forward. Everybody was waiting for the punch. “You’re right,” Eddie said. There was a pause.

A long one. The audience made a sound that wasn’t quite a laugh. Johnny’s eyebrows went up, and Dolly Parton, who had been bracing herself for a fight, blinked. “I’m sorry?” she said.

“You’re right.” Eddie said again. He gave a short, embarrassed laugh and looked at the floor. “I’ve been running. You could hear it from a record.

That’s kind of scary, actually.” Nobody in the room knew what to do with that. A rock star was not supposed to walk onto Johnny Carson’s stage and agree with the woman who had just said he was hiding. “Well, now.” Dolly said slowly, and her voice had softened. “I didn’t mean it ugly.

I hope you know that.” “I know,” Eddie said. “That’s why it got me.” Johnny leaned forward on his desk. He knew what he had. So, does that mean, he said, you’ll take the dare?

The audience whooped. And Doc Severinsen, the band leader, who had been watching all this from the bandstand with his trumpet in his lap, did not wait to be asked. He waved to his guitar player, who unstrapped a sunburst electric guitar, plugged a long cable into a small amplifier, and came hurrying across the stage with both of them, grinning like a kid who had just been picked first for a team. He held the guitar out to Eddie.

And this is the part of the story the audience in Burbank had not been expecting at all. Eddie took the guitar. He put the strap over his shoulder. He tuned it in about 10 seconds by ear, without looking.

The audience went quiet. Dolly folded her hands. Something slow, Johnny said. Something your grandmother could hum.

Eddie nodded. He put his left hand on the neck. He closed his eyes. He played one note.

Then, he stopped. He tried again. Two notes. Three.

Slow. A melody beginning. And then, his hands seemed to just stop moving, as if somebody had cut a wire. He stood there with his fingers on the strings and his eyes closed for what felt like a very long time.

And then, out of nowhere, his hands took over, the way they did when he wasn’t thinking. A burst of notes poured out of that little amplifier. A fast, wild tapping run up the neck. The sound from the posters.

The sound everybody in that room knew. A few people started to cheer. He stopped it dead after about 3 seconds. The cheering died.

He opened his eyes and looked down at the guitar like it had done something without his permission. “See?” he said quietly. “That’s what happens.” The studio was completely silent now. “Every time I try to slow down, my hands just go.” He took the strap off his shoulder and handed the guitar back to Doc’s guitar player very carefully.

“Sorry, man. Thank you. It’s a great guitar. It’s not the guitar.” Johnny Carson, who had done more than 4,000 of these shows and had a line for every situation known to man, didn’t say anything at all.

Backstage, in the little room where the third guest waits, Valerie Bertinelli was standing in front of a monitor with both hands pressed flat against her mouth. She was the only person in the building who knew what had happened in December. She was the only one who knew why his hands had stopped. In the control booth, a nervous associate producer leaned over to the director and asked whether they should go to a commercial.

Get the man off the hook. Give everybody a minute. The director had his hand on the switcher. He didn’t move it.

He said afterwards that some things you don’t interrupt, not even for a car commercial, and that he’d known within about 2 seconds this was one of them. It was Dolly who spoke first. “Honey,” she said, “what happened?” Eddie didn’t answer right away. He looked out past the lights for a moment, at the audience he couldn’t really see.

And then he looked at the corner of the bandstand, at something nobody in the room had paid any attention to all night. Doc Severinsen’s band had an upright piano pushed into the corner behind the horn section, half covered by a music stand. “Is that thing in tune?” Eddie asked. “It better be,” Doc said from the bandstand.

“We pay a man to make sure.” Can I? Johnny spread his hands. Eddie, at this point, I don’t think it’s my show anymore. The audience laughed gratefully because it needed to.

Eddie walked across the stage to the bandstand. One of the horn players moved the music stand out of the way. He pulled the bench out, sat down, and put his hands on the keys without playing anything. Most people don’t know this, he said, not really to anybody, but I didn’t start on guitar.

I started on this when I was six. My dad sat me down at a piano in Holland and said, “You’re going to learn this properly.” I had lessons for years. I won competitions. He laughed a little.

I couldn’t even read the music. I’d watch the teacher’s hands and play it back by ear and fool everybody. He ran his thumb along the edge of the keys. “My dad was a musician,” he said.

“Clarinet, saxophone. He played on the radio over there, and when we came over here, nobody wanted him. So, he washed dishes for years so my brother and I could have lessons. He used to come home after work and sit at the kitchen table at midnight and play his clarinet really quiet so he wouldn’t wake us up.

Old Dutch songs, slow ones.” He was quiet for a moment. “He’s the one who always told me the hardest thing in music isn’t playing fast, it’s playing one note and meaning it.” He smiled a little at the keys. “A few years ago, we put him on one of our records,” he said. “Just a little old jazz tune on clarinet.

We did it for him. 20 years in this country washing dishes, and he finally got to make a record. He wore his best suit to the session. He kept apologizing to the engineers for taking up their time.” Dolly had stopped smiling. Not because she was upset, because she had understood before anybody else in the room where this was going, and it would have been wrong to smile at it.

“He passed,” Eddie said, “in December.” The audience didn’t make a sound. “So, that’s what my hands are running from,” he said. “Every time I try to play something slow, it’s him. It’s that kitchen table, and I can’t get through it.” He shrugged, still looking at the keys.

“So, I play fast. Fast is easy. Fast doesn’t leave any room in the song for him to be missing from.” For a long moment, nobody moved. Then, Dolly Parton stood up from the couch.

She walked across the stage in her heels, slowly, past Johnny’s desk, past the startled horn section, and she sat down on the end of the piano bench next to Eddie Van Halen, close enough that their shoulders almost touched, the way you sit down next to somebody at a wake. “Can I tell you about my daddy?” she said. Eddie nodded. “My daddy’s name is Lee,” Dolly said.

“He’s a farmer, tobacco mostly, back home in Sevier County, Tennessee. Raised 12 of us in a little cabin up on the side of a mountain. No electricity, no running water. He worked harder than any man I ever knew.” She folded her hands in her lap.

“And my daddy can’t read,” she said. “Never could. Never had the chance to learn. He had to go to work in the fields when he was a little boy, and that was the end of school for him.” A small murmur went through the audience.

Most of them had never heard this. “So, you know what I figured out when I was a little girl and started writing songs?” Dolly said. “I figured out that if I wanted my daddy to understand what I was saying, I had to say it plain. No big words, no fancy tricks.

If my daddy couldn’t feel it the first time he heard it, it wasn’t any good. She smiled, a little sad. Every plain song I ever wrote, honey, I wrote so a man who couldn’t read could understand it. That’s all a plain song is.

It’s how you talk to your daddy. Eddie was looking at her now. I was wrong a little bit earlier, Dolly said. I said you were running.

You’re not running. You’re just trying to talk to your daddy, and he’s not there to listen. And that’s the hardest thing in the world. I’d play fast, too.

Eddie’s eyes had filled up. He didn’t wipe them. He looked down at the piano keys for a long time. And then, he reached into the inside pocket of his jacket and took out a cassette tape.

The audience didn’t know what it was. Johnny didn’t know what it was. Dolly looked at it, and then at him. I found this in his closet, Eddie said.

After the funeral. It’s him. Playing on the radio in Holland back in the ’50s, before I was born. My brother thinks somebody taped it off the radio for him.

I’ve had it in my pocket for 3 months. He turned it over in his hands. I listened to 15 seconds of it once. I couldn’t do any more.

What’s on it? Dolly asked softly. A song he used to play at the kitchen table, Eddie said. An old Dutch lullaby.

Real slow. The kind of thing your grandmama could hum. The room was so quiet, you could hear a camera on its pedestal rolling half an inch across the floor. Dolly looked over at Johnny.

Johnny looked off to the side of the stage at Fred de Cordova. Fred looked up at the sound engineer in the booth. There was a short, frantic conversation that nobody in the audience could hear. Somebody ran.

Johnny turned back to the stage. Eddie, he said, very gently, if you want us to, we can play that right now. It’s your call. Eddie looked at the tape for a long time.

Okay, he said finally. But I want to play with him. A young man from the sound booth jogged out, took the tape from his hand, and jogged back. Eddie turned to the piano, put his hands on the keys, and waited.

Dolly stayed exactly where she was on the end of the bench. The studio speakers crackled. And then, over the most famous stage in American television, came the sound of a clarinet. It was a little hissy, the way old radio recordings are, with a faint hum underneath it.

But the clarinet was clear and warm and very slow. And it was playing a simple tune in a minor key, the kind of melody that sounds like it has been sung to children for 300 years. It didn’t show off. It didn’t hurry.

Every note was out there by itself, and every one of them sounded like the man playing it meant it. Eddie listened to the first phrase with his eyes closed. On the second phrase, he started to play very softly, under the clarinet, not over it, playing chords, the kind of 6-year-old learns in his first year of lessons, finding the key, following his father’s melody, leaving space for every note. He didn’t add a single extra thing.

No runs, no tricks, nothing fast at all. For the first time in 3 months, his hands didn’t stop. And about halfway through, without anybody asking her to, Dolly Parton started to hum. Just a harmony, low and quiet, sitting under the clarinet and above the piano, the way she had sung harmony with her brothers and sisters on a porch in Tennessee when she was a little girl.

No words. She didn’t know the words. Nobody in the room knew the words. It didn’t matter.

A Dutch clarinet player who had died 3 months earlier, his son at a borrowed piano, and a farmer’s daughter from the Smoky Mountains humming along. It lasted about 2 minutes. When the clarinet finished its last long note, there was a little click on the tape and a few seconds of hiss, and then a man’s voice, very faint, saying something in Dutch that nobody in the room could understand. Eddie took his hands off the keys.

Nobody clapped. Nobody knew whether they were allowed to. Dolly leaned her head over, just slightly, until it touched his shoulder for a second. Then she sat up again.

“What did he say?” she asked, “at the end?” Eddie wiped his eyes with the heel of his hand and laughed, a small, broken laugh. “He said, ‘That’s enough for tonight. Go to bed.’ He said, in Dutch. He used to say that to us.

I guess he said it to the radio, too.” And then the Tonight Show audience came up out of their seats. It wasn’t the polite applause they gave to comedians and movie stars. It was the noise a room makes when it knows it has just seen something it will be telling people about for the rest of its life. People were crying.

The horn section was on its feet. Doc Severinsen had his trumpet tucked under his arm and was clapping above his head. Johnny Carson waited for it to die down. It took a long time.

Then he looked into camera one. “I have been doing this show for 25 years,” he said. “I have had guests disagree. I have had guests walk off.

I have had animals bite me. I have never had a guest walk up out of my audience, lose a dare, and then win it on my piano with his father.” He shook his head. “Dolly,” he said, “you told the whole country he wouldn’t dare.” “I did,” Dolly said. She was crying, too, a little, and laughing at the same time.

“And I have never in my life been so happy to be wrong on television. But the most important part of that night didn’t happen in front of the cameras. It happened about 20 minutes later in a narrow corridor behind the stage after Valerie’s segment had come and gone and the studio lights had finally gone down.” Eddie was standing by the stage door with Valerie, holding his baseball cap and the cassette tape, when he heard the clack of high heels on the linoleum behind him. Dolly had taken her shoes off by then.

She was carrying them in one hand. Without them, she came up to roughly the middle of his chest. “Well,” she said, “look at you. You look like you’ve been crying on national television.” “You did that,” Eddie said.

“I did not,” Dolly said. “Your daddy did that. I just hummed.” They both laughed. Valerie, who had known Dolly a little from years of the same television circles, hugged her and whispered something in her ear.

And Dolly squeezed her hand and said, “You hold on to this one, honey. He’s a good one.” Then she turned back to Eddie, and she was serious again. “I want you to promise me something,” she said. “Okay.” “Tonight, you played your daddy’s song.

That’s a good thing, and I’m glad I was there for it. But that was his playing song.” She tapped the cassette in his hand. “One of these days, I want you to write one of your own. Something slow, something simple, for somebody you love.

No tricks, no thousand notes, just you meaning it. I don’t know if I can, Eddie said. Sure you can, Dolly said. You just did.

And when you’ve done it, you send it to me. Send it where? Tennessee, Dolly said, putting her shoes back on. They’ll find me.

Everybody does. She walked off down the corridor, and Eddie stood there with the tape in his hand for a long time after she had gone. That night, at half past 11, Eddie and Valerie sat on the end of their bed in the house in Studio City and watched the whole thing go out. Neither of them had been sure until the last minute that NBC would air it all.

They did. The dare, the guitar, the piano, the clarinet, all of it. When it got to the part where the clarinet started playing, Eddie got up, walked out of the bedroom, and went out back to his studio. Valerie didn’t follow him.

She turned the television down and let him be. About an hour later, she heard something coming from the studio she hadn’t heard all winter. Not loud, not fast, just a piano. Somebody playing an old Dutch lullaby.

Slowly, by himself, all the way through. By the next morning, the clip was everywhere. The papers had a wonderful time. Dolly dares Eddie.

Guitar hero loses bet, wins everybody. But the people who had actually watched it talked about something else. They talked about the two minutes of an old clarinet recording, and the fastest guitar player in the world playing simple chords under it like a little boy at his first lesson. For a long time after that, nothing seemed to come of Dolly’s promise.

Van Halen made another record. They toured the world again. Eddie went on playing fast and loud in arenas every night because that’s what he did and he loved it. But 4 years later, on the 16th of March, 1991, Eddie and Valerie had a son.

They named him Wolfgang after Mozart because Eddie said there was no greater composer who ever lived. And not long after Wolfgang was born, Eddie wrote a piece of music for him. It was short, a little over a minute, just one acoustic guitar. No tapping, no tricks, no thousand notes.

A slow, gentle, simple melody that a father played for his newborn son in the middle of the night to get him back to sleep. He named it after the day the boy was born, 316. It went on the album Van Halen released that summer, For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge, right in the middle of all the loud songs, a quiet little minute that sounded like it had wandered in from somebody’s nursery. For years afterward, Eddie played it on stage, alone, in the middle of the show, in front of 15,000 people who had come to hear him go fast.

And every night, for that 1 minute, those arenas went completely quiet. According to the version of this story Valerie liked to tell, a cassette went into a padded envelope that summer with a Tennessee address on the front. Inside, there was 316 and a short note in Eddie’s messy, sloping handwriting. Wrote a plain one, For my boy.

Took me 4 years. Sorry it’s late. Ed. The reply came back about 3 weeks later on pink note paper.

Never too late, honey. Told you you could play slow. Your daddy would be proud. So am I.

Dolly. Eddie kept that note for the rest of his life in a drawer in the studio under the cassette with his father’s clarinet on it. Years later in 1995, Dolly Parton started something called the Imagination Library, a program that mails a free book every month to young children so that no child grows up the way her father had, unable to read. She has said many times that she started it for him.

It has since given away more than 200 million books all over the world. The little boy who could never read the music and the woman whose daddy could never read the words both spent their lives finding ways to say things plain. Eddie Van Halen died on the 6th of October 2020 after a long fight with cancer. He was 65 years old.

Wolfgang was 29. A few weeks after his father died, he released a song he had written for him. It was called Distance. It was slow.

It was simple. There was nothing to hide behind. A son playing something plain for the father who had once played something plain for him. The obituaries talked about the speed, the stripes, the tapping, the thousand notes, the man who changed the electric guitar forever.

Almost none of them mentioned a night in Burbank in March 1987 when a country singer told the whole country the fastest guitar player alive was hiding behind his speed and he walked up out of the audience and agreed with her. She was right about the running. She was wrong about why. That’s the thing about being told the truth about yourself in front of everybody.

It’s easy to fight it. It’s much harder to sit down at a borrowed piano, admit what you’re running from, and then play it anyway, slowly, one note at a time, until you mean every single one. Eddie Van Halen could play anything. On that one night, the hardest thing he ever played was a lullaby.

You Might Also Enjoy