News

Anne Boleyn Was Beheaded By The Swordsman Of Calais On May 19, 1536, After Being Made To Wait One More Day: What Really Happened In Her Final Hours

A woman’s face, very close, under a gray sky.

There is a picture that is meant to show the last morning of Anne Boleyn, and this is what it shows.

She fills the left side of it, so close that we can count the freckles across her nose.

She wears a black French hood, curved like a horseshoe around her face and edged with two rows of gold braid and small white pearls.

Her dark hair is parted in the middle beneath it.

Her gown is black velvet, its square neckline trimmed with gold embroidery and a white pleated edge.

Around her neck hangs a thin gold chain with a single gold letter on it, a B, with three pearls hanging below it.

Her eyebrows are drawn up and together, her gray eyes are wide open, and her lips are parted, as if she has just caught her breath.

Behind her, on the right, stands a man on a wooden platform.

He is dressed all in black, a rough black tunic belted at the waist, dark breeches and tall boots, and his head is covered by a black hood with two holes cut for the eyes.

His arms hang at his sides.

Behind him rises a tall wooden frame, two upright posts joined at the top, with a slanted steel blade held high between them and a round opening near the bottom.

A wicker basket stands at its foot.

Below the platform is a crowd.

There are men in tall black top hats and black bow ties, and women in white bonnets with their hands pressed together under their chins, and almost every one of them is staring up at the platform with an open mouth.

Far behind them, the spires of a Gothic city stand against the clouds.

It is a picture that is hard to look away from.

It is also an artist’s invention, and almost every detail in it that can be checked is wrong.

The tall frame with the slanted blade is a guillotine, a machine that France adopted in 1792, two hundred and fifty-six years after Anne Boleyn died.

She was not killed by any machine.

The men in top hats belong to the nineteenth century.

There was no jeering crowd of strangers either, and no basket.

The real morning was smaller, quieter and much stranger than this.

It had begun, in a sense, the day before, when she was told that she would die, and then made to wait.

She had been ready since dawn.

She had taken the sacrament and said her prayers, and when the hour came and went and the morning wore on, word reached her that it would not be today after all.

She would have to do it all again tomorrow.

And when she heard this, she did not thank God for one more day of life.

She sent for the man who guarded her, and she told him that she was sorry, because she had thought to be dead by this time, and past her pain.

Those are her own words, or as close to them as we will ever get, and they come from a letter written that day by the man who guarded her.

To understand why the Queen of England was sorry to be alive, we have to begin with the woman at the window.

—

## The woman at the window

On the morning of the nineteenth of May, 1536, Anne Boleyn was either about twenty-nine years old or about thirty-five.

Nobody wrote down the year she was born, and historians still argue over whether it was 1501 or 1507.

She had grown up between two worlds.

As a girl she had been sent abroad, first to the court of Margaret of Austria in the Netherlands, and then to France, where she served in the household of Queen Claude, the wife of King Francis I.

She came home to England in her early twenties speaking fluent French, dressing in the French style and carrying herself like nobody else at the English court.

The black French hood in the picture is one thing the artist got right about her.

She made it fashionable in England, and it is the hood she wears in nearly every portrait that has come down to us.

The B on its chain comes from those portraits too.

When Henry VIII began to want her, in the middle of the 1520s, he was married to Catherine of Aragon, and he already had a mistress’s place to offer.

Anne refused it.

She would be his wife or nothing.

That refusal, held for six years, changed England.

To marry her, Henry needed his first marriage annulled, and the pope would not do it.

So Henry broke with Rome.

He made himself the supreme head of the Church in England, he had his own archbishop declare the first marriage void, and in 1533 he married Anne and had her crowned.

Thomas More, who would not accept the new order, went to the block in 1535.

The monasteries began to close.

And there was a trap inside all of it that nobody saw at the time.

The king had made himself the highest authority in the English Church partly so that he could marry Anne.

That meant that when he wanted to be free of her, there was no pope she could appeal to, and no court above the king’s own.

The machinery that had raised her was the machinery that would remove her.

—

## The king’s spring

Henry VIII was forty-four in the spring of 1536.

He was no longer the athletic young prince of his twenties.

In January he had been thrown from his horse at a joust and lay without speaking for some time, and an old ulcer on his leg was getting worse.

That same month Catherine of Aragon died, and a few days later Anne lost a child, a boy, according to the reports that went around the court.

In more than ten years of marriage to two queens, Henry had one living legitimate child, and she was a girl.

Her name was Elizabeth, and she was two years and eight months old.

By then the king’s attention had moved to one of Anne’s own ladies, a quiet, fair young woman named Jane Seymour.

The man who turned his wish into a legal case was Thomas Cromwell.

He was a blacksmith’s son from Putney who had made his own way in the world, and tradition says that as a young man he had served as a soldier in Italy.

By 1536 he was the king’s chief minister.

He had helped Henry marry Anne, and now he and Anne had quarreled bitterly over what to do with the wealth of the closed monasteries, and over much else.

In the last days of April and the first days of May, Cromwell moved.

The charges, when they came, were adultery with four men, incest with her own brother, and plotting the king’s death.

Historians have gone through them line by line, and many of the dates do not work, because on the days she was supposed to have met her lovers she was elsewhere, or still recovering from childbirth.

It did not matter.

—

## A fortress, not a field

The Tower of London in 1536 was not only a prison.

It was a royal palace, an armory, a treasury and the place where the king’s coins were struck.

It even kept a menagerie of wild animals, including lions.

Anne was not thrown into a cell.

She was held in the queen’s lodgings, a set of royal rooms near the river, the same rooms where she had stayed in the days before her coronation three years earlier.

She had walked into them then as a queen about to be crowned.

Now she walked the same floors as a prisoner.

When she arrived, she asked the man in charge whether she was going into a dungeon, and he told her no, she would go into the lodging she had lain in at her coronation.

She is said to have answered that it was too good for her.

The place where she would die was also inside the walls.

Most traitors died in public on Tower Hill, an open rise just outside the fortress, where all of London could come to watch.

Anne would not.

Her scaffold was built within the Tower itself, which was a mark of her rank and also a way of keeping the event under control.

Visitors to the Tower today are shown a glass memorial on Tower Green, beside the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula, and are told that the scaffold stood near there.

That spot was marked in the reign of Queen Victoria.

Several historians now think the scaffold more likely stood a short walk away, on the open ground to the north of the great White Tower, where the parade ground is today.

Either way, it was a short walk from her rooms.

—

## The man with the pen

The man in charge of the Tower was Sir William Kingston, its constable.

He was an old soldier and courtier who had spent years in the king’s service, and he had guarded important prisoners before.

He was not Anne’s friend.

His task was to keep her, and also to report on her.

Day after day he wrote to Cromwell, telling him what she had said, what she had done, who she had named and what mood she had been in.

Without those letters we would know almost nothing of what Anne Boleyn said in the Tower.

That is worth holding on to.

Nearly every word we have from her in those days comes to us through the pen of a man writing to her enemy.

When we read that she was calm, or wild, or laughing, we are reading what Kingston chose to put on the page for Cromwell to read.

The letters have also come down to us damaged.

A fire in the eighteenth century scorched the volume that holds them, and parts of the pages are burned away, so that some of her sentences end in gaps.

Kingston was not the only one listening.

The women who were placed with her in the Tower were not her own friends.

They included Kingston’s wife and Anne’s own aunt, Lady Boleyn, who was on poor terms with her, and Kingston reported that the women repeated to him what Anne said, especially when she talked in her sleepless hours.

She was hardly ever alone, and nothing she said was private.

—

## Two days before

On the seventeenth of May, two days before Anne’s own death, five men were taken out of the Tower to Tower Hill.

They were her brother George Boleyn, Lord Rochford, and four men of the king’s circle, Sir Henry Norris, Sir Francis Weston, William Brereton and a young court musician named Mark Smeaton.

All five were beheaded with an axe in front of a large crowd.

Only one of them had ever confessed to anything.

That was Smeaton, and he was the only one of the five who was not a gentleman.

One writer of the time said that he had been put to the rack, and others told stories of a knotted cord tightened around his head.

Neither story can be proved.

What is known is that he confessed after hours alone with Cromwell’s people, and that he was the one man whose confession could be used against the queen.

George Boleyn denied everything to the last.

So did Norris, Weston and Brereton, although on the scaffold they spoke in the careful, general way that condemned men usually did, saying that they deserved to die for their sins, without saying which sins.

Two other men were held in the Tower in those days and later let go.

One of them was the poet Thomas Wyatt, who had known Anne since they were young, and who was rumored to have loved her once.

There is a tradition that from his window in the Bell Tower he could see the scaffold, and that he watched the five men die.

Anne knew that they were dead.

She knew what the same morning would look like for her.

—

## The choice

In the days that were left to her, Anne Boleyn had one thing that nobody could take away before the end.

She would be allowed to speak on the scaffold.

A speech from the scaffold could not be stopped once it had begun.

The crowd would hear it, and people would write it down and send it abroad.

She could have used it.

She could have named Cromwell.

She could have sworn before God that she was innocent and called the whole proceeding a lie, and some condemned prisoners in other reigns did exactly that.

She did not.

At some point in those days, she decided to say almost nothing.

She would not accuse anyone.

She would not confess, either.

She would praise the king and accept the sentence of the law, and leave every question open.

Nobody knows when she made that choice, or exactly why, and she never explained it.

But there is an obvious reason, and it was two years and eight months old.

On the seventeenth of May, the same day that the five men died, Archbishop Thomas Cranmer had declared Anne’s marriage to the king invalid, which made her daughter Elizabeth illegitimate in law.

Her family was still within the king’s reach as well: her father, her mother, her sister Mary.

A queen who defied Henry from the scaffold could not hurt him.

She could only hurt the people she was leaving behind.

—

## The swordsman

The court that tried Anne on the fifteenth of May sentenced her to be burned or beheaded, at the king’s pleasure.

Burning was the old punishment for a woman found guilty of treason.

The king chose beheading.

And he made one further choice that no English king had made before.

Anne would not die by the axe.

She would die by the sword, and the man who would do it had to be brought from abroad.

The chroniclers call him the hangman of Calais.

Calais was then an English town, the last piece of English territory on the French coast, and later tradition says that the swordsman came from the neighboring town of Saint-Omer, in France itself.

His name was never written down, and the names that have been given to him in novels and films are inventions.

The difference between the two weapons was a matter of craft.

An axe was heavy, and an English headsman worked with a low wooden block, and a clumsy stroke could need a second blow or a third.

A trained swordsman needed no block.

The prisoner knelt upright, and a single level stroke was enough.

The fee usually given for the man from Calais is twenty-three pounds, six shillings and eightpence, a very large sum at the time.

And then there is the timing.

A message had to cross the Channel to fetch him, and he had to make the same journey back, and by the eighteenth of May he was in London, ready to work.

The trial ended on the fifteenth.

Nobody could have made that double journey in three days.

Whoever sent for him did not wait for the verdict.

—

## Laughing and weeping

Kingston’s letters from the first days of May describe a woman whose mood would not hold still.

One moment she was weeping, he wrote, and the next she was laughing.

She talked about her mother.

She talked about the men accused with her, and worried aloud about what they might say.

She swore that she was as clear of any man as she was of the king.

She asked for the sacrament to be kept in the closet beside her room, so that she could pray before it.

She said, more than once, that she would have justice.

This is the part of the story that the paintings leave out.

People waiting to be killed do not hold one expression for days on end, the way a face in a picture does.

They laugh.

They make jokes.

They talk about ordinary things, and then they stop in the middle of a sentence.

The mind cannot stay in terror without a break, and so it flickers.

Anne’s laughter in the Tower is one of the most human things in the whole record of her fall.

—

## The morning that did not end

On the morning of the eighteenth of May, Anne Boleyn was ready to die.

She sent for Kingston to be with her when she received the sacrament, and in his presence she swore, on the sacrament and on the salvation of her soul, that she had never been unfaithful to the king.

Then she waited.

The hours went by.

Nothing happened.

The execution had been put off.

Cromwell had sent orders that all strangers were to be cleared out of the Tower first, and the foreign ambassadors were to be kept away, and there was the matter of the swordsman, who may only just have arrived.

Nobody seems to have thought to tell Anne until the morning was nearly over.

When she did hear, she sent for Kingston again.

In the letter that he wrote to Cromwell in those last hours, he set down what she said to him, and in modern spelling it runs like this:

“Master Kingston, I hear I shall not die before noon, and I am very sorry for it, for I thought to be dead by this time, and past my pain.”

Kingston tried to comfort her.

He told her that there would be no pain, because it was so quick.

She answered him.

“I heard say the executioner was very good, and I have a little neck.”

And then, Kingston wrote, she put her hands around her neck and laughed heartily.

The old soldier added a line that historians have argued about ever since.

He had seen many men and also women executed, he wrote, and they had all been in great sorrow, but to his knowledge this lady had much joy and pleasure in death.

It is easy to read that as madness.

It reads more like exhaustion.

She had said her goodbyes, she had sworn her last oath and taken the sacrament as a dying woman, and now she had been handed back a day she did not want.

—

## The second night

She spent the night of the eighteenth in prayer.

Her almoner was with her, and the women around her kept watch.

Nobody left any description of that night that we can trust in detail.

The scaffold was ready, or nearly ready, somewhere outside in the dark.

The swordsman from Calais was somewhere inside the walls.

And in another part of the Tower, if the tradition about his window is true, Thomas Wyatt was awake too, two days after he had watched the five men die, knowing what was coming in the morning.

—

## Dressing for the sword

On the morning of the nineteenth of May, Anne dressed with care.

She did not dress for court.

The accounts that describe her clothes agree on a dark gown, probably gray damask, with a short mantle over it trimmed with ermine.

On her head she wore an English hood, the stiff gabled headdress that English women of rank had worn for a generation.

That is the second thing the picture gets wrong.

The woman famous for bringing the French hood to England went to her death in an English one.

Under it, her hair was dressed so that it could be quickly gathered up.

Everything she put on that morning was chosen with one man in mind, the man who would have to do his work quickly on a platform in the open air.

She took nothing that could get in his way.

It is one of the strangest details of the whole day.

On the last morning of her life, the Queen of England did part of the swordsman’s preparation for him.

—

## The knock at the door

Wriothesley, a herald who kept a chronicle of those years, says that it was about eight o’clock in the morning when she was brought out.

Other accounts make it closer to nine.

Kingston came up to her rooms to fetch her.

She came out with four of her ladies.

She walked with Kingston ahead of her, across the inner ward of the Tower, past the old hall of the palace, through the gate in the wall around the White Tower, and along its western side.

It was a walk of a few minutes.

It was the last time she would cross the Tower, and three years earlier she had crossed it as a queen on her way to be crowned.

One witness said afterward that she had never looked so beautiful.

Another said that she kept looking back over her shoulder, as if she were still expecting a messenger.

No messenger came.

—

## Who was watching

The crowd on that ground was not a London mob.

Wriothesley names the people who were there by their offices.

There was the Lord Chancellor, Sir Thomas Audley.

There were the Duke of Suffolk, the king’s old friend Charles Brandon, and the Duke of Richmond, the king’s own sixteen-year-old illegitimate son, Henry Fitzroy.

There were most of the members of the king’s council, and Thomas Cromwell was among them.

There were the Lord Mayor of London, the aldermen and the sheriffs, and a number of men from the chief guilds of the city.

How many people stood there altogether, nobody counted.

Modern guesses run from a few hundred to about a thousand.

There were no top hats, because top hats had not been invented.

There were no bonneted women shrieking at the platform.

Whatever the people on that ground felt, the accounts do not describe them jeering.

—

## The speech

She climbed the steps of the scaffold.

There was straw on the boards.

There was no block, because there would be no axe.

Several versions of what she said were written down by people who were there or who spoke to people who were there, and they differ in small ways.

The version printed by the chronicler Edward Hall is the best known.

In modern spelling, it begins like this:

“Good Christian people, I am come hither to die, for according to the law, and by the law, I am judged to die, and therefore I will speak nothing against it.”

She went on to say that she had not come there to accuse any man, nor to speak of the things she was accused of.

She asked God to save the king and send him long to reign, because, she said, a gentler and more merciful prince there never was, and to her he had always been a good and gentle lord.

Then she said something that is easy to read past.

“And if any person will meddle of my cause, I require them to judge the best.”

If anyone, in time to come, should look into her case, she asked them to think the best of her.

It is the nearest she came, in public, to saying that she was innocent.

She did not confess.

She did not accuse.

She left the question open, and she asked the future to answer it kindly.

She finished by asking everyone there to pray for her.

—

## No block

Her ladies came forward.

She took off the short mantle trimmed with ermine.

Then, according to one account written by a witness and sent abroad, she took off the English hood herself.

One of her young ladies handed her a linen cap, and she put it on and pushed her hair up inside it.

She knelt down on the straw.

She drew her skirts close around her feet, so that she would fall decently.

One of her ladies tied a cloth over her eyes.

Then the women moved back.

She began to pray aloud.

According to Wriothesley, the words she kept saying were these:

“To Jesus Christ I commend my soul.”

Hall writes that she was saying “Jesu, receive my soul” over and over.

Later writers added a story that is often repeated and cannot be checked.

They say that the swordsman did not want her to know the exact moment, and so he called out to someone across the platform, perhaps asking for his sword, and while she turned her head a little toward the voice, he stepped in from the other side.

Whether or not it happened that way, every account agrees on one thing.

It was a single stroke.

Wriothesley says that her head was struck off at one stroke.

The sword had been kept hidden, by one account under the straw, so that she would not see it while she spoke.

She never saw it at all.

—

## An arrow chest

Nobody had made a coffin for her.

That may have been carelessness, or haste, or the fact that nobody in charge had quite believed until the end that it would really happen.

It may also have been deliberate.

The story that has come down to us is that an old wooden chest was brought out of the Tower’s stores, a long narrow box that had been used for storing arrows, and that her body was laid in it, with her head beside her.

The accounts that tell this differ on the details, and some call it simply a chest of elm.

Her ladies did the work themselves.

They would not let the men of the Tower touch her.

They carried her a few steps to the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula, the small church within the walls, and she was buried that same day under the floor of its chancel.

There was no funeral, and no stone was set up over her.

Her brother George was already buried in the same chapel.

Three years earlier she had ridden through London to her coronation, and the celebrations had gone on for days.

Now she was buried in a box meant for arrows, within the hour, by the women who had dressed her that morning.

—

## The king that day

Henry VIII was not at the Tower.

A story grew up later that he had gone hunting that morning, and that he waited in the forest for the sound of the guns from the Tower that would tell him he was free.

It is a good story, and there is no evidence for it.

What the records show is harder.

The next day, the twentieth of May, Henry was formally betrothed to Jane Seymour.

On the thirtieth of May, eleven days after Anne’s death, he married her.

He did not order masses for Anne, and he did not mark the day.

Her initials were taken down from the palaces, and her badge of a white falcon was replaced with Jane’s.

The news went out quickly.

The imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who had hated her for years, sent his reports to the emperor.

Abroad, Catholic writers told her death as God’s judgment on a heretic queen.

The Protestants were less sure what to say about her yet.

—

## What the women kept

The women who carried her body went back to court.

Some of them would serve Jane Seymour, and some served the queens who came after her.

As far as anyone knows, not one of them ever wrote down what she saw on the nineteenth of May.

There is a family tradition that one of the women on the scaffold was Margaret Lee, the sister of Thomas Wyatt, and that she was the one who stood closest to the queen at the end.

It cannot be proved, but it would explain a great deal about her brother’s poems.

Thomas Wyatt was released from the Tower not long afterward.

He went back to court and to the king’s service, and he kept writing.

One of the poems that is believed to come from those weeks carries a Latin title taken from the Psalms, “Innocentia Veritas Viat Fides Circumdederunt me inimici mei.”

The usual translations of it miss a pun.

“Viat” is not a Latin word.

It is Wyatt’s own name, the way it was often spelled, set in a row between innocence, truth and faith, followed by the line from the Psalm, “my enemies have surrounded me.”

The poem names no names.

It is about the men who died on Tower Hill, and in it Wyatt writes, “These bloody days have broken my heart.”

He writes that the Bell Tower showed him a sight that stuck in his head day and night.

He never wrote Anne’s name in it.

He did not need to.

—

## The daughter

Elizabeth was two years and eight months old on the day her mother died.

She was in a household of her own, away from the court, and she was too young to understand what had happened.

Her title of princess had already been taken from her.

Her governess later wrote to Cromwell complaining that the child had grown out of her clothes and had nothing proper to wear, because nobody was paying for her anymore.

She learned the story later, and in pieces, from people who had to be careful about what they told her.

In 1558, twenty-two years after the morning on the scaffold, she became Queen Elizabeth I.

She reigned for forty-four years.

She never married.

Historians have argued about whether the second fact had anything to do with the first, and nobody will ever know.

She almost never spoke of her mother in public.

But under her reign, the Protestant writers of England turned Anne Boleyn into something new, the queen who had opened the door to the reformed faith, a martyr brought down by her enemies.

—

## The bones under the floor

For three hundred and forty years, Anne Boleyn lay under the floor of the chapel with others who had died on the scaffold.

In 1876, under Queen Victoria, the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula was restored.

The floor of the chancel had sunk, and the workmen had to take it up.

Underneath they found bones, many of them not lying in their original order but heaped together, as if the graves had been disturbed more than once over the centuries.

A doctor, Frederic Mouat, examined them, and a Tower official, Doyne Bell, wrote an account of the work.

In the place where Anne was supposed to lie, they found the bones of a woman.

Mouat described a woman of between twenty-five and thirty years of age, of delicate build.

They decided that she was Anne Boleyn.

The bones were sealed in lead, placed in oak boxes with her name on them, and laid back under the floor, and the chancel was paved with marble, with a memorial tile for each name.

Many historians today doubt that identification.

If Anne was born in 1501, she was about thirty-five when she died, too old for Mouat’s description.

The graves had been dug up and filled in again, and the bones of several people may have been mixed.

The tile in the floor of the chapel that bears her name may not mark her at all.

They took her title, her marriage, her daughter and her life, and in the end they may have taken even the certainty of where she lies.

—

## Five hundred years of Annes

Every generation since 1536 has made its own Anne Boleyn.

To the Catholic writers of her own century she was a witch and an adulteress who got what she deserved.

To the Protestant writers of her daughter’s reign she was a martyr.

The nineteenth century made her a tragic lover.

The twentieth century made her a schemer or a victim, depending on the film.

And somewhere in all of that, the hours themselves went missing.

The waiting.

The day that was taken away and handed back.

The joke about the little neck.

The English hood she took off with her own hands.

The arrow chest.

—

## The picture, once more

Look at it one last time.

The face so close that the freckles show.

The black French hood with its gold braid and pearls, the black velvet, the gold B on its chain.

The man in the black hood on the wooden platform, the tall frame with the slanted blade, the basket, the crowd in top hats and bonnets with their mouths open.

Now it is possible to say what is true in it.

The French hood is true to her life, if not to her death.

She wore it in her portraits, and she brought it into fashion in England.

On the morning she died, she wore an English hood instead, and she took it off herself.

The B is true to the portraits as well.

The fear on her face may be true.

Nobody knows what her face looked like in those last minutes, and the witnesses who wrote about her describe her as calm, and even smiling.

The rest is invented.

There was no guillotine.

The machine in the picture was adopted in France at the time of the French Revolution, more than two and a half centuries later, and Anne Boleyn died kneeling upright on straw, by a single stroke of a sword.

There was no block and no basket.

No account describes the swordsman of Calais wearing a hood over his face.

The people in top hats and bonnets belong to the age of Queen Victoria, the age that dug up the floor of the chapel looking for her bones.

There was no city of spires behind the scaffold, only the walls of the Tower.

And there was no screaming crowd.

There was a quiet gathering of officials and councilors and city men, among them the minister who had built the case against her and the king’s own son.

What the picture cannot show is the thing that made her last hours so hard.

It shows a single moment of terror.

What she lived through was a whole day of waiting, and then another.

She had made herself ready to die on the eighteenth of May, and they told her to wait.

She told the man who guarded her that she was sorry, because she had thought to be dead by then, and past her pain.

The next morning she dressed herself for the sword, walked across the Tower, asked the people of the future to judge her kindly, and knelt down in the straw.

It was a single stroke.

She never saw the sword.

You Might Also Enjoy