News

Alfred The Great — The King Who Collapsed In Agony At His Own Wedding Feast

The stone had been sitting in the middle of the yard since morning, and nobody had moved it yet.

It was round and grey and as wide as a barrel, worn smooth on top by a hundred years of hands, and it sat in the packed dirt where the straw had been swept back to make a ring.

Around the ring, the guests had crowded onto every bench, every step and every gallery rail they could find.

They had been eating and drinking since the day before.

They would go on eating and drinking through the coming night.

It was the year 868, somewhere in the kingdom of Mercia, and a prince of the West Saxons was getting married.

The games had started after noon.

Men had wrestled in the dust.

Men had thrown spears at a post.

Now the warriors were taking turns at the stone, because that was how a hall found out who was strong and who only talked about it.

A big Mercian had rocked it onto his knees and dropped it.

Another had lifted it to his waist and staggered three steps before it fell, and the galleries had roared and the silver had changed hands.

Then the bridegroom stood up.

He was nineteen years old, slight for a warrior, with dark curling hair and a short beard he had not had for long.

He wore a tunic of deep wine red, belted at the waist, with a band of gold stitching at the collar and the hem, and red hose, and soft leather boots laced at the ankle.

He was the youngest son of a dead king and the brother of a living one.

He was not supposed to be lifting stones on his wedding day.

His friends told him so.

Someone near the front shouted that the bride’s people would be watching.

He walked out into the ring anyway, and the noise of the galleries rose to meet him.

A thegn in a brown tunic dropped to one knee at the edge of the ring, the way the old men did when they wanted to judge a lift up close.

A man in a yellow tunic with a short sword at his hip stepped back toward the far wall to give him room.

The bridegroom looked up at the crowd and laughed.

“Stand back. I lift my own stone.”

He bent his knees.

He put his arms around the cold curve of the rock, his cheek almost against it, and he pulled.

The stone came up an inch off the dirt.

And something inside him broke open.

That is the only way anyone could describe it afterward.

The young man who had laughed a moment earlier went rigid.

His eyes flew wide.

His mouth opened and no sound came out of it at first.

The stone dropped back into the dirt and he dropped with it, down onto one knee, both arms still wrapped around the rock as if it were the only thing holding him up.

Behind him a cloud of dry yellow dust rose from the trampled straw and hung in the hot air.

The thegn on his knee lifted his arm and pointed, and his face went white.

The galleries did not understand yet.

Some of them were still cheering.

On the ground, the bridegroom pressed his forehead against the stone and spoke through his teeth.

“Something has torn inside me.”

Twenty-five years later, this young man would be the most famous king in English history.

He would beat the Vikings when everyone else had lost.

He would build towns, write laws, translate books with his own hand, and be the only English king ever to be called “the Great.”

He would do all of it with the thing that started in that yard still inside him.

And near the end of his life, he would sit down with a monk from Wales and tell him the strangest part of the story, the part nobody in those galleries could have guessed.

The pain that dropped him to his knees on his wedding day was not, in his own mind, an accident.

In a sense, he had asked for it.

—

## The youngest son who was never meant to be king

His name was Alfred, and when he was born, nobody would have bet a single silver penny on him wearing a crown.

He came into the world in 849 at Wantage, a royal estate on the edge of the Berkshire downs, the fifth son and the last child of Æthelwulf, King of the West Saxons, and his wife Osburh.

Four brothers stood between Alfred and the throne.

In a family like his, that was usually the end of the conversation.

Younger sons became bishops, or warriors who died young, or quiet landholders who were remembered only in a list.

His father seems to have loved him in a particular way.

When Alfred was four, he was sent across the Alps to Rome, a journey of months over roads where children died of fevers and travelers died of bandits.

The pope, Leo IV, received the little boy and put on him the belt and robes of a Roman consul, an honor for a noble guest.

Two years later Alfred went to Rome again, this time with his father, and stayed for a year.

He saw the ruins, the churches, the marble and the crowds.

He was six years old.

It is the kind of thing that stays with a person.

His mother gave him the other thing he never lost.

There is a story his biographer heard from Alfred himself.

One day Osburh sat with her sons and showed them a book of English poems, with a large painted capital letter on its first page that caught the boys’ eyes.

She told them she would give the book to whichever of them could learn it first.

Alfred, the youngest, could not read yet.

He took the book to a teacher, had the poems read to him over and over until he knew them by heart, and came back and recited them to his mother.

He got the book.

He did not learn to read Latin properly until he was nearly forty.

But the boy who memorized a whole book to win it was already the man he would become.

He was stubborn.

He wanted things very badly.

He would keep at something long after a sensible person would have stopped.

And he was, from the beginning, a little afraid of himself.

By the time he was a teenager, three of his four older brothers were dead, two of them after short reigns as king, and the last, Æthelred, was on the throne.

The family that had looked so crowded had thinned out.

Alfred was becoming, slowly, the spare that might actually be needed.

And at the same time, his biographer tells us, the young prince was fighting a hidden war that nobody at court could see.

—

## The prayer a boy should never have prayed

He was a young man with a young man’s appetites, and he was deeply, painfully devout.

That combination tormented him.

The monk who later wrote his life, a Welshman named Asser, says that in his youth Alfred was afraid that his own desires would pull him away from God, and that he could not master them on his own strength.

He would get up before dawn, in secret, and go to churches to pray, lying face down on the stone floor.

And he began to pray for a very specific thing.

He asked God to send him an illness.

Not just any illness.

He was careful about it, in the way a clever, frightened young man is careful.

He asked for a sickness that would keep him humble and keep his mind on heaven, but that would not be visible on his body, so that men would not look at him with disgust, and that would not make him useless, so that he could still ride and fight and do the work his family needed from him.

He was asking God for a weight to carry.

A small one.

A secret one.

According to Asser, he got it.

Some time in his teens, Alfred was struck with an affliction that Asser, writing in Latin, calls *ficus*.

Translators have argued about the word for a century, and most of them render it as piles, a painful swelling of the veins that made sitting a torment and riding worse.

It was exactly what he had asked for.

Nobody could see it.

It did not stop him from doing his duty.

It simply hurt, all the time, in a way that a young prince who spent his days on horseback could never forget for an hour.

He lived with it for years.

And then, Asser says, he went hunting in Cornwall.

It was a long way west, into country where the people still spoke a British tongue.

During the hunt, Alfred broke away and went to a small church, the church of a holy man called Gueriir, where the body of another saint, Neot, would later be laid.

He went inside alone and lay down on the floor in front of the altar, and he prayed the opposite of the prayer he had prayed before.

He asked God to take the sickness away.

He did not ask to be well.

He was too afraid of himself for that.

He asked for the pain he had to be replaced by some other, lighter illness, one that would still keep him humble but would not grind him down the way this one did.

He got up off the floor of that church, rode back to his companions, and not long afterward, Asser says, the old affliction was gone.

It never came back.

Alfred must have thought his prayer had been answered.

He had asked for something milder.

He had not asked for it to come later.

—

## Two kingdoms and one feast

By 868, the world around Alfred was on fire.

Three years earlier, an army had landed in East Anglia that was unlike anything the English had faced before.

For a century, the men from the north had come in raids: a handful of ships, a burned monastery, a cargo of silver and slaves, and gone before the local lord could gather his men.

This was different.

The English chroniclers called it simply the great army, and later writers would call it the Great Heathen Army.

It did not leave.

It took horses, wintered on English soil, and went where it liked.

In 866 it took York.

By 867 it had killed two Northumbrian kings in a single day.

Mercia, the great kingdom of the Midlands, knew it would be next.

Its king, Burgred, was already married to Alfred’s sister.

Now the West Saxons and the Mercians tied themselves together a second time.

Alfred, nineteen, the heir of his brother King Æthelred, would marry a Mercian noblewoman named Ealhswith.

She was the daughter of a Mercian ealdorman called Æthelred Mucel, lord of a people known as the Gaini, and on her mother’s side she came from the royal blood of Mercia.

No chronicle describes her face.

Asser never even gives her name.

But she would be Alfred’s wife for more than thirty years, and she would bear his children and outlive him, and the marriage that began at that feast would hold.

The wedding was celebrated in Mercia, among her people.

Asser says the feast went on day and night.

That was how weddings of great families were done.

The hall was hung with whatever cloth and color the host could find.

Whole animals turned on spits.

Ale and mead went round in horns and cups until the benches were loud and the floor was slick.

There were songs.

There were games.

There were boasts made at the table and tested in the yard, because a warrior culture never let a boast go untested for long.

And somewhere in the middle of all of it, in front of the whole gathering, the bridegroom was struck down.

—

## The moment the noise stopped

Go back to the yard, and slow it down.

The ring of trampled straw.

The galleries packed with guests in their best colors, the women in long dresses and veils at the rail, the men standing on the benches to see.

The smell of roasting meat drifting from the hall and the sharper smell of spilled ale and sweat and horses.

The light coming down hard and yellow, raising the dust.

The bridegroom crouches.

His hands find their grip on the stone.

For a fraction of a moment, everything is exactly as it should be.

A young prince, a little drunk, a little proud, showing his new family that the West Saxons are not soft.

If the stone comes up, there will be a roar.

If it does not, there will be laughter and another horn of ale.

Either way, it is a good day.

The stone comes up an inch.

The pain, when it comes, comes from the inside.

That is the first thing Alfred would have known about it, and the thing that made it so frightening.

It was not a pulled muscle in the back or a wrenched shoulder, the kind of injury every young warrior knew and could name.

It started somewhere deep in his belly and went through him all at once, sudden and enormous, so sharp that it took his breath before it took his legs.

He drops the stone.

He goes down to one knee, still holding the rock, because there is nothing else to hold.

The thegn at the edge of the ring, who was crouched there to watch the lift, sees his face before anyone else does.

He has seen men hit with spears.

He knows what real pain looks like on a face, and this is it.

He throws out his arm and points, and his shout is the first sound in the yard that is not cheering.

The galleries go quiet in waves.

The front rows first, then the benches behind them, then the people craning over the rail who still do not know what they are looking at.

Someone laughs and stops.

Someone knocks over a cup.

On the ground, the young man tries to get up and cannot.

His arms are still around the stone.

He tightens them, as if he means to try again, and his voice comes out thin and furious.

“I can lift it. Give me one moment, and I can lift it.”

He cannot.

His friends reach him first.

The man in the yellow tunic, the one who stepped back to give him room, is there with an arm under his shoulder.

Alfred’s face is grey under the dust.

Sweat has broken out along his hairline.

His breathing has gone short and shallow, the breathing of a man trying not to move anything inside himself, and when they try to lift him he makes a sound none of them have heard him make before.

He grips the arm of the nearest man hard enough to leave bruises.

“Get me out of here before my bride sees her husband on his knees.”

It was too late for that.

Everyone saw.

This is the part of the story that Asser, writing years afterward with Alfred himself as his source, takes most seriously.

The pain came, he says, suddenly, in the presence of the whole crowd.

It was a pain unknown to every physician present.

Nobody could name it.

Nobody had seen anything like it.

A strong young man in the middle of his own wedding feast had been struck down by something invisible, in front of hundreds of witnesses, and none of the experts in the hall could say what it was.

And so the hall did what people always do when they cannot explain something.

It reached for the explanations it already had.

Some of the guests said it was the eye.

In a world without germs, envy was a physical force.

Hundreds of people had been staring at the bridegroom all day, admiring him, wishing they were him, and that much attention fixed on one young body could do it harm.

They called it fascination, the evil that a crowd’s gaze could do.

Others said it was the devil.

The devil had always envied good men, and here was a prince who prayed on stone floors before dawn, being married in the middle of a holy alliance against the heathens.

Of course something dark had reached for him.

Others said it was a strange new kind of fever, something that had come with the armies, something nobody had a name for yet.

And somewhere in the hall, carried away to a quiet room and laid on a bed while the feast went on uneasily outside, the bridegroom himself must have been thinking of something else entirely.

A church floor in Cornwall.

A prayer for the old pain to be taken away and replaced with another.

He had been given his answer.

The feast went on, because feasts did.

The marriage was made.

But from that day on, Alfred carried the new pain with him.

And it was not lighter.

It was far worse than the one it replaced.

—

## A pain that never left him for an hour

We know what it was like for him because, unusually for a king of the ninth century, he talked about it.

Asser, who became one of his closest companions, was writing his book in the year 893.

Alfred was forty-four, in his forty-fifth year.

And Asser says plainly that the illness that struck at the wedding feast had tormented Alfred without stopping from his twentieth year to that day.

Twenty-five years.

The pain came and went.

But Asser describes something worse than the attacks themselves.

Even when God gave him a day or a night or an hour of relief, the fear of that pain never left him.

He could not enjoy the good hours, because he knew the bad ones were coming back.

He lived every day braced for it, the way a man lives in a house where the roof might come down.

We do not know what it was.

Modern doctors who have read Asser’s account have made their guesses, and the guess they make most often is a disease of the gut called Crohn’s disease, a lifelong inflammation of the bowels that tends to appear in the late teens and early twenties, comes and goes in flares, causes sudden, terrible stomach pain, and can follow a person for decades.

It fits the age.

It fits the suddenness.

It fits the long, grinding years.

Others have suggested a chronic infection, or something that was partly in the body and partly in a deeply anxious mind.

A few historians think Asser shaped the story to make Alfred look like a suffering saint.

What nobody disputes is the picture Asser paints, because he saw it with his own eyes.

A king who would be in the middle of a conversation, or a council, or a meal, and would suddenly stop, go grey, and grip the edge of the table until it passed.

A king who never knew, when he woke up, whether today would be a day he could ride.

A king who had to plan every journey, every battle, every hour of business around a body that might fold up underneath him at any moment.

The young man from the stone ring was about to inherit a kingdom at war.

He would have to fight for it with his insides on fire.

—

## The year of nine battles

The great army came south in 870, and in 871 it fell on Wessex.

The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle lists the fights of that year one after another in a grim little catalogue: Englefield, Reading, Ashdown, Basing, Meretun.

Nine major battles south of the Thames in a single year, it says, not counting the smaller raids.

Most of them the English lost.

At Ashdown, on the bare chalk of the Berkshire downs, Alfred commanded half the army.

His brother the king was still in his tent, hearing Mass, and would not come out until the priest had finished.

The Danes were already forming up on the higher ground.

Alfred could not wait.

Asser, who later walked the battlefield with men who had fought there, says that Alfred led his men uphill against the enemy “like a wild boar,” and that the fight raged around a single small, stunted thorn tree that was still standing in Asser’s day.

The English won.

It was one of the few clear victories of that terrible year.

Picture the man who did that.

Twenty-one years old.

Three years past a feast where a stone had broken him open from the inside.

Leading a charge up a chalk slope against an army that had killed kings, with a body that could betray him at any moment.

A few weeks after Easter, his brother Æthelred died.

We do not know of what.

He may have been wounded.

He may simply have been worn out.

Alfred was king.

He was twenty-one.

He had a wife, a war, a kingdom that was losing, and a sickness that nobody could name.

And he had been king for barely a month when he lost another battle, at Wilton, and had to pay the Danes to go away for a while.

They went.

For a while.

—

## Twelfth Night, and a king with nowhere left to run

The night everything fell apart was the most festive night of the winter.

It was the feast of the Epiphany, the twelfth night after Christmas, in the first days of January 878.

Alfred was at Chippenham, a royal estate in Wiltshire, with his household and his men.

There was a truce.

The Danish king Guthrum had sworn oaths, given hostages, and taken his army away to the north.

It was winter, the season when armies did not move.

Everyone could eat and drink and sleep.

Guthrum moved.

His army came down on Chippenham in the dead of winter, by surprise, at the one time of the year when nobody was watching.

The Chronicle tells it in a few flat, devastating lines.

The Danes occupied the land of the West Saxons and settled there.

They drove many of the people across the sea.

They forced most of the rest to submit.

All except the king.

Alfred got out.

With a small band of followers, he went west into the wet country of Somerset, into the great marshes where the rivers spread out into reed beds and black water, and the only dry ground was a scatter of low islands that you could reach by boat or by secret paths.

On one of those islands, at a place called Athelney, the island of the princes, he dug in and built a fort.

He had almost nothing left.

No towns.

No treasury.

No army worth the name.

His family was with him, his wife and small children, in a damp camp in the reeds with the winter rain coming down.

And the sickness had not taken the winter off.

This is where the most famous story about him comes from.

You probably know it.

The king, disguised and on the run, takes shelter in the hut of a swineherd.

The swineherd’s wife sets him to watch her loaves baking by the fire while she goes about her work.

Alfred, sitting by the hearth, lost in his worries about his kingdom, lets them burn.

The woman comes back, sees the blackened bread, and scolds him furiously, telling him he is happy enough to eat the loaves but too lazy to turn them, never guessing that the useless man by her fire is the king of the West Saxons.

It is a wonderful story.

It is very probably not true.

It appears for the first time about a hundred years after his death, in the life of a saint.

But there is a reason it stuck.

It tells a truth about Athelney that the dry records only hint at.

A king sitting by someone else’s fire, in somebody else’s house, so tired and so sick and so beaten that he could not even watch the bread.

Through the rest of that winter, from his island, he sent out small raids against the Danes.

Hit and run.

Kill a few men, steal back a few cattle, disappear into the marsh.

It kept him alive.

It kept the idea of a West Saxon king alive.

And then, in the spring, he sent out word.

—

## Seven weeks after Easter

The message went out across the shires that were still English in their hearts, even if they were Danish on the ground.

The king was alive.

The king was calling.

Come.

In the seventh week after Easter, in May 878, Alfred rode out of the marshes to a place called Egbert’s Stone, east of Selwood.

Nobody is entirely sure today where it was.

But the Chronicle says that the men of Somerset came to him there, and the men of Wiltshire, and the men of Hampshire who had not fled over the sea, and that when they saw him they were glad.

They had thought he was dead.

Two days later, near a place called Edington, the West Saxon army formed a shield wall against the great army of Guthrum, and fought it, and broke it.

Asser describes Alfred’s men fighting “with a dense shield wall,” for a long time, stubbornly, until at last the Danes turned and ran.

Alfred chased them back to their fortified camp, probably at Chippenham, the same place they had taken from him on Twelfth Night, and he laid siege to it.

For two weeks he sat outside the walls while the Danes inside grew hungry, and cold, and afraid.

Then they sent out messengers and asked for peace.

The terms were unlike anything anyone expected.

Guthrum, the Danish king who had nearly destroyed Wessex, agreed to leave.

And he agreed to something more.

He would be baptized a Christian.

Three weeks later, at Aller, close to the marshes of Athelney where Alfred had hidden all winter, Guthrum and thirty of his chief men came to the font.

Alfred himself stood as Guthrum’s godfather and raised him out of the water as his spiritual son.

At a royal estate called Wedmore, the newly Christian Danes stayed twelve days as Alfred’s guests, and he gave them rich gifts.

It was the turning point of English history, and almost nobody alive at the time could have predicted it.

Five months earlier, Alfred had been a fugitive in a marsh with a sick body and a handful of men.

Now he had made the most dangerous man in England kneel in a church.

—

## How a sick man rebuilt a kingdom

Winning a battle was one thing.

Making sure there would never be another Twelfth Night was another.

In the years after Edington, Alfred did something that very few kings of his age even thought of doing.

He redesigned his whole kingdom so that it could never again be taken by surprise.

He built a network of fortified towns, called burhs, across Wessex, placed so that almost nobody in the kingdom lived more than a day’s march from a wall.

Some of those towns are still there, still laid out on Alfred’s grid of streets.

Winchester.

Wallingford.

Wareham.

He divided his army in two, so that half the men were always at home working their farms while the other half were on duty, and no army could catch the English all at home again.

He built ships, bigger than the Danish ones, to fight them at sea.

In 886 he took London, and handed it over to be governed by his son-in-law.

And then, in his late thirties, sick and tired and with a kingdom to run, he decided to learn to read Latin.

He gathered scholars from all over Britain and from across the sea.

He set them reading to him at every spare moment of the day and night.

When he could manage it himself, he began translating the books he thought every educated Englishman ought to know into the English language, so that the young men of his kingdom would never have the excuse he had had, that there was no one to teach them.

Some of those translations survive, with prefaces in which Alfred himself speaks to us, more than eleven hundred years later, about the ruin he saw around him and the learning he wanted to bring back.

There is one small invention of his that tells you more about the man than any battle.

Alfred wanted to give exactly half his time to God.

Not roughly half.

Exactly half.

But in an age without clocks, how do you measure time on a cloudy day, or in the dark?

So he had his chaplains make candles of a precise weight of wax, each one marked in inches, six of them to burn through a whole day and night, one after another.

When he found that the drafts in his halls and tents made the candles flicker and burn unevenly, he had lanterns made for them, with sides of thin, scraped horn that let the light through but kept the wind out.

A sick man, measuring out his hours in candle wax so that not one of them would be wasted.

He did all of it, Asser tells us, while the pain never let him go.

He fought the Danes again when a new army landed in the 890s, and every bit of it was done by a man who woke every morning not knowing whether his own body would let him work at all.

And in 885 or so, a monk from St David’s in Wales came to his court, and the king began to talk.

—

## What he told the Welsh monk

Asser was a scholar and a priest, and Alfred wanted him badly.

He offered him rich estates and begged him to stay for half of every year.

Asser agreed.

The two men read together and talked late into the night.

And Alfred told him things.

That is why we know about the book of poems, and the prayer on the church floor, and the hunt in Cornwall, and the wedding feast.

Asser did not invent those stories.

He says, again and again, that he heard them from “his lord,” from the king himself.

Some of them he says he heard many times.

In 893, Asser sat down to write all of it into a book about Alfred’s life, while Alfred was still alive.

And in the middle of it, in the section about the wedding, he set down the strangest confession a medieval king ever made about his own body.

The young Alfred had asked God for an illness.

He had asked to be given something that would keep him from his own weakness, something that would not show and would not make him useless.

He had been given the first sickness, the hidden one.

He had then lain down on the floor of a church in Cornwall and asked for it to be taken away and replaced by something else.

And at his own wedding feast, in front of the whole crowd, the something else had come.

In Alfred’s mind, and in Asser’s, the two prayers and the two sicknesses were linked.

The pain that dropped him on his wedding day was not a random cruelty.

It was an answer.

He had made a bargain with heaven, as a frightened, devout teenager, and heaven had held him to it for the rest of his life.

There is no anger in the way Asser tells it.

That is what is so striking.

Alfred does not seem to have blamed God for the pain.

He seems to have seen it as the price of being the kind of man he wanted to be: humble, watchful, never too comfortable, never able to forget that his body was not his own.

Asser even says that the fear of the pain made him more devout, more patient, more careful with his time.

The candles, the books, the endless work.

You can read all of it as the life of a man who knew exactly how fragile he was and decided to waste none of what he had.

Was it really a bargain with heaven?

A modern reader will say no.

A modern doctor will say Crohn’s disease, or something like it, appearing at exactly the age such diseases appear, by bad luck, on a day when the whole world happened to be watching.

But Alfred did not live in our world.

He lived in his.

And in his world, a young man who asked God for a sickness and got one had to live with what he had asked for.

He lived with it for thirty-one years.

—

## Six nights before All Hallows

The end, when it came, was quiet.

The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, the record that Alfred’s own court had begun, gives it a single sentence.

In the year 899, it says, Alfred son of Æthelwulf died, six nights before All Hallows’ Mass.

That is the twenty-sixth of October.

He was about fifty years old.

He had been king of the West Saxons for twenty-eight and a half years, the Chronicle notes, and “king over all the English people except the part that was under Danish rule.”

That is all.

No deathbed scene.

No last words.

No description of the illness at the end.

Asser’s book stops in 893, six years before the king died, as if the writer simply put down his pen one day and never picked it up again.

Nobody wrote down whether the old pain flared at the end, or whether something new took him, or whether, after thirty years of fear, he died in his sleep without warning.

We do not know where he died.

We know only where they buried him.

They took him to Winchester, the old royal city of Wessex, and laid him in the Old Minster, the great church of the town.

He did not stay there.

—

## Where the bones went

The story of Alfred’s body after his death is almost as restless as his life.

His son Edward built a new church right next to the Old Minster, the New Minster, and moved his father there.

His wife Ealhswith, who died a few years after him, was buried there too, and later his son.

After the Norman Conquest, the monks of the New Minster moved to a new abbey at Hyde, just outside the walls, and took their royal dead with them.

Around 1110, Alfred, his wife and his son were carried in procession to Hyde Abbey and laid before the high altar.

There they rested for more than four hundred years.

Then Henry VIII closed the monasteries.

In 1538 Hyde Abbey was dissolved, and its buildings were pulled down for their stone.

The graves before the altar were left in the ground, unmarked, as the church above them disappeared.

In 1788, the town of Winchester decided to build a new prison on the site.

The convicts set to dig the foundations struck stone coffins.

According to the accounts of the time, the coffins were broken up, their lead was sold, and the bones inside were scattered and thrown aside.

Nobody knew, or cared enough to find out, whose they were.

Alfred the Great, the king who had rebuilt England, was lost in a building site.

It took more than two centuries for anyone to look properly.

In 2013, archaeologists opened an unmarked grave at the nearby church of St Bartholomew, where some of the scattered bones from Hyde were believed to have been reburied in Victorian times.

Most of what they found came from the wrong centuries.

But the next year, going back through bones that had been dug up at the abbey site itself in the 1990s and stored in boxes, they found a single fragment of a man’s pelvis, dated to the right period, from the right part of the abbey.

It may be Alfred.

It may be his son Edward.

Nobody can be certain.

A piece of bone in a museum box, from the body that had carried a sickness for thirty years without ever once giving up its work.

—

## The stone

Go back one last time to the yard in Mercia, to the ring of straw and the hot yellow dust.

The young man in the wine-red tunic is on one knee with his arms around a rock.

The galleries have gone quiet.

A thegn is pointing, white-faced, and the bridegroom is whispering through his teeth that something has torn inside him.

He does not know yet what it is.

He does not know that it will never leave.

He does not know that in three years he will be king, in ten years he will be hiding in a swamp, and that same spring he will make a Danish warlord kneel in a church.

He only knows that he tried to lift the stone, and it broke him instead.

Everything we remember him for came after that moment.

The battles, the towns, the books, the candles burning in their horn lanterns through the night.

All of it was done by a man who had been brought to his knees in front of everyone he knew on the happiest day of his life, and who got up, and kept getting up, for the next thirty-one years.

That is why he is the only English king anyone ever called great.

Not because the stone never beat him.

Because it did, and he went on anyway.

—

## What the record actually says, and what is legend

**The main source:** Almost everything we know about Alfred’s illness comes from one book, the *Life of King Alfred* written in Latin by Asser, a Welsh monk from St David’s who joined Alfred’s court in the mid-880s and wrote in 893.

Asser says repeatedly that he heard these stories from the king himself.

A few historians have argued it is a later forgery; most scholars accept it as Asser’s work, while reading it as a portrait of an ideal Christian king.

**The two illnesses:** Asser describes a first affliction in Alfred’s youth, which he calls *ficus* (usually translated as piles), that Alfred had prayed for and that was cured after he prayed at the church of St Gueriir in Cornwall, where St Neot was later buried.

He then describes a second, far worse pain that struck suddenly at Alfred’s wedding feast in Mercia, “in the presence of the whole people,” which no physician could identify, and which tormented him from his twentieth year to his forty-fifth (the year Asser was writing) and, by implication, beyond.

Asser records the theories of the time: the “fascination” (evil eye) of the crowd, the envy of the devil, or an unusual fever.

The link Alfred and Asser saw between his prayers and his sufferings is in Asser’s text; Asser says the young Alfred prayed for an affliction to help him resist the desires of youth.

**What it was:** No one can diagnose a disease from a ninth-century description.

Crohn’s disease is the suggestion made most often (age of onset, sudden severe abdominal pain, lifelong flares); others include chronic bowel infections and illnesses with a large psychological element.

All are guesses.

**The stone and the games:** Asser says only that the pain struck suddenly during the wedding feast, before the whole crowd, after a feast that lasted day and night. **The stone-lifting game, the yard and the galleries, and everything Alfred says in our opening scene are our reconstruction.** Trials of strength were part of feasts in this warrior culture, but there is no record of what Alfred was doing at the moment the pain came.

The lines Alfred speaks in the opening and in the feast scene (“Stand back. I lift my own stone.” / “Something has torn inside me.” / “I can lift it. Give me one moment, and I can lift it.” / “Get me out of here before my bride sees her husband on his knees.”) are our wording.

**The wedding:** The marriage to Ealhswith, daughter of the Mercian ealdorman Æthelred Mucel of the Gaini, in 868, is recorded.

The exact place in Mercia is not known for certain.

**The burnt cakes:** Legend; first found about a century after Alfred’s death, not in Asser or the Chronicle.

**Ashdown, Athelney and Edington:** The Twelfth Night attack of 878, Athelney, Egbert’s Stone, Edington, Guthrum’s baptism at Aller and the twelve days at Wedmore are in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle and Asser; the “wild boar” charge and the thorn tree at Ashdown are Asser’s.

**The candles:** Asser describes the six marked candles burning through a day and night and the horn lanterns made to protect them from drafts.

**Death and burial:** The Chronicle dates his death to six nights before All Hallows’ Mass, 26 October 899.

Neither the place nor the cause of death is recorded.

His burial at the Old Minster, the move to the New Minster, the transfer to Hyde Abbey around 1110, the dissolution in 1538 and the disturbance of the graves when a prison was built in 1788 are documented.

The pelvis fragment identified in 2014 may belong to Alfred or to his son Edward the Elder; the identification is not certain.

**What the source video gets wrong:** The YouTube video this story is drawn from claims that Alfred injured himself lifting a stone at a victory feast, that he governed for decades from a throne with a hole cut through the seat, that he could not ride and never led his armies, that ambassadors refused to visit his court, and that he died sitting on that throne.

None of this is in any historical source.

Alfred led his armies in person through the 870s and beyond, rode constantly, and was visited by envoys from across Europe.

We have left those claims out.

**About the video:** The short clip with this story is a modern AI reconstruction in the style of an old oil painting, not a historical image.

The arcaded galleries and the yellow cloud of dust behind the king are the painter’s choices.

You Might Also Enjoy