News

16 Carmelite Nuns Were Sent To The Guillotine In Paris On July 17, 1794, For Refusing To Give Up Their Vows. They Sang Until The Last Voice Stopped, And Ten Days Later Robespierre Fell

A pale summer sky over the rooftops of Paris.

There is a picture that is meant to show the last afternoon of the Carmelite nuns of Compiègne, and this is what it shows.

In the middle of it stands a guillotine, built of heavy, weathered timber, with a slanted steel blade hanging high at the top of its frame.

At the foot of the machine, a young nun is kneeling.

She wears a dark brown habit, a white linen wimple tight around her face, and a black veil falling over her shoulders.

Her hands are folded in front of her, and her face is turned upward, past the blade, toward the sky.

She is not crying.

Her lips are closed, and her eyes are very calm.

On the left side of the picture, a tall man in a black coat and a black three-cornered hat stands beside the frame of the guillotine.

One of his hands grips a thick rope that runs up toward the blade.

He is looking down at the kneeling woman, and his face shows nothing at all.

On the right side stands another man, older, in a long blue coat with a gold waistcoat and a white lace cravat, his gray hair powdered and curled at the sides.

He has the stiff, watchful face of a man who has come to make sure that things are done properly.

And behind the young nun, in a long, straight row, stand the others, a whole line of women dressed exactly like her, in brown habits and white wimples and black veils, their hands folded, their faces turned toward the scaffold.

Beyond them, the roofs and towers of the city fade into the light.

Nobody in the picture is being hurt.

Nobody is touching her.

There is only a young woman on her knees, a machine above her, two men watching, and her sisters waiting their turn.

It is an artist’s picture, made long after the fact, and some of it is invented.

Nobody painted the real scene, and nobody knows what the men who stood beside the scaffold looked like.

The neat row of nuns in the background is a later idea of how it might have looked, and the man in the blue coat has no name.

But the heart of it is true.

On the evening of July 17, 1794, at a square on the eastern edge of Paris, sixteen women from the Carmelite convent of Compiègne went to the guillotine one by one.

They went in the religious habits the Revolution had banned.

And they went singing.

The youngest of them was about twenty-nine.

The oldest was seventy-eight.

They had been offered their lives if they would give up their vows, and every one of them had said no.

When the first of them climbed the scaffold, the crowd that had come to watch went quiet.

By the time the last of them climbed it, the square was so silent that people who were there spoke about that silence for the rest of their lives.

Ten days later, the man whose government had sent them there would be arrested by his own colleagues.

The day after that, he would go to the guillotine himself.

And within weeks, the worst period of the French Revolution, the time people still call the Terror, would come to an end.

Nobody can prove that one thing caused the other.

But for more than two hundred years, people have told this story as if the sixteen women knew something about that summer that the men around them did not.

—

## A convent at Compiègne

Compiègne is a quiet town about fifty miles north of Paris, on the edge of a great forest where the kings of France used to hunt.

For more than a hundred years before the Revolution, a community of Carmelite nuns had lived there behind high walls, close to the royal château.

The Carmelites were one of the strictest orders in the Catholic Church.

The nuns lived enclosed, which meant that once a woman made her vows, she would almost never leave the convent again.

They rose before dawn.

They prayed and sang the Divine Office at fixed hours of the day and night.

They kept long silences, ate simply, and worked with their hands.

They did not teach in schools or nurse the sick.

Their work, as they understood it, was prayer itself.

By the late 1780s, the community at Compiègne numbered around twenty women.

Most were from ordinary families.

A few were from the minor nobility.

Some were choir nuns, who sang the Office in Latin.

Others were lay sisters, who did the heavy physical work of the house, the cooking, the laundry, the garden.

Two more, a pair of real sisters named Catherine and Thérèse Soiron, were not nuns at all, but externs, women who lived just outside the enclosure and ran errands into the town for the community.

In 1786, the community elected a new prioress.

Her name was Madeleine-Claudine Lidoine, and in religion she was called Mother Teresa of Saint Augustine.

She was in her early thirties, the daughter of a modest Paris family, and she had nearly not been able to enter the convent at all, because her family could not afford the dowry that convents expected.

According to the community’s own history, part of that dowry was paid by a royal patron, and the name usually given is Queen Marie Antoinette.

Whether or not that story is exactly right, Mother Teresa was clever, warm, and well educated, and she would lead her sisters through everything that was coming.

Among the youngest women in the house was a novice from Saint-Denis, just north of Paris.

Her name was Marie-Geneviève Meunier, and in the convent she was called Sister Constance.

She had come to Compiègne in her early twenties, against the wishes of her family, who later tried to bring her home.

She was still a novice when the Revolution began.

She would never be allowed to make her final vows.

—

## The Revolution comes to the cloister

When the Revolution broke out in 1789, few people in France imagined that it would reach into convents like Compiègne.

At first it was about taxes, bread, and the power of the king.

But the new National Assembly needed money, and the Church owned enormous amounts of land.

In November 1789, Church property was declared to belong to the nation.

In February 1790, the Assembly went further.

It stopped recognizing religious vows altogether.

No new vows could be made.

Men and women already living in monasteries and convents were told they were free to leave, and many houses were to be closed.

That was why Sister Constance could never make her profession.

The law no longer allowed it.

In the summer of 1790, local officials came to the convent at Compiègne to question the nuns.

Each woman was asked, privately, whether she wished to stay or to leave and return to the world.

By the community’s own account, every one of them said she wished to stay and to live and die as a Carmelite.

For two more years, the nuns stayed in their house, under growing pressure.

The Revolution grew harder and more suspicious.

Priests who would not swear an oath to the new order were driven out, imprisoned, or deported.

Religious symbols were stripped from public life.

In the spring of 1792, war broke out between France and the monarchies of Europe, and anything that looked like loyalty to the old order began to look like treason.

—

## The offering

Around Easter of 1792, Mother Teresa gathered her community and proposed something that none of them would ever forget.

She asked whether they would be willing to offer their lives to God for the sake of France.

She did not ask them to seek death.

Carmelites were not supposed to go looking for martyrdom.

She asked them to accept it, if it came, and to offer whatever happened to them as a prayer that the violence tearing the country apart might stop, and that peace might be given back to the Church and to France.

According to the history later written by one of the sisters, two of the older nuns drew back.

The idea frightened them.

They were not ready to say yes to something like that.

Mother Teresa did not press them.

She told them to pray and think.

The same history says that within hours, the two came back, in tears, and asked to be included.

From then on, the whole community made the offering together.

Every day, they renewed it.

They did not know when, or whether, it would be accepted.

—

## September 14, 1792

In August 1792, the monarchy fell.

The king was imprisoned, and the government ordered the remaining convents of women to be closed.

On September 12, officials arrived at Compiègne and took an inventory of the convent’s furniture, books, and religious objects, to be seized for the nation.

Two days later, on September 14, 1792, the nuns were put out of their house.

They were ordered to wear ordinary clothes.

They were forbidden to live together as a community.

They could not get new clothes easily.

Many of them had worn nothing but their habits for decades.

They borrowed what they could, and patched together dresses from whatever fabric they could find.

Mother Teresa would not let her community be scattered.

She found four small apartments in the town, close to one another.

The sisters divided into four groups and moved in.

They lived like any other poor women of Compiègne, quietly, without attracting notice.

But inside those apartments, they kept the life they had always kept.

They rose early.

They said the Office.

They kept silence.

They met when they could.

And they kept renewing the offering they had made.

In Paris, that same September, mobs broke into the prisons and murdered more than a thousand prisoners, among them many priests.

In January 1793, the king was guillotined.

In October, the queen followed him.

The Terror had begun.

—

## Two years in hiding

For almost two years, the Carmelites of Compiègne lived in this half-hidden way.

It was not really a secret.

The town knew who they were.

Their neighbors could see the women coming and going from the four apartments, and could guess what they did there.

For a time, the local authorities seem to have let them be.

But the Terror was spreading outward from Paris.

In 1793 and 1794, a network of revolutionary committees reached into every town in France, and every committee was expected to find enemies.

Neighbors were encouraged to report on one another.

Letters were opened.

A rosary, a crucifix, a holy picture could be used as evidence.

A woman who still lived as a nun, even in a borrowed dress, was living outside the law.

—

## June 22, 1794

On June 22, 1794, revolutionary officials came for them.

The apartments were searched over two days.

The officials took their letters, their prayer books, their papers.

Among the things they found were letters to and from priests who had refused the revolutionary oath, and pictures of the Sacred Heart of Jesus.

To the men searching the rooms, the Sacred Heart was not just a devotion.

In the west of France, the royalist rebels of the Vendée had worn it as a badge on their coats.

A picture of it in a nun’s room could be read as a sign of rebellion.

A man named Mulot de la Ménardière, a friend of the community who had helped them, was arrested with them.

The sixteen women still living in the four apartments were taken to a prison in the town.

It was another former convent, the house of the Visitation nuns, which had been emptied and turned into a jail.

The irony was not lost on anyone.

Women who had been thrown out of their convent were now locked inside one.

Three members of the community escaped arrest only because they happened to be away from Compiègne.

One of them, Sister Marie of the Incarnation, would later write the history that preserved most of what we know about the others.

—

## The English nuns next door

The Carmelites were not the only nuns in the prison at Compiègne.

A community of English Benedictine nuns, who had lived for generations in exile in the French town of Cambrai, had also been arrested and brought there.

The English nuns watched the Carmelites closely in the weeks that followed.

They saw a community that kept its hours even in prison.

The Carmelites rose early, said their prayers together, and spoke to one another with a calm that the English sisters found hard to understand.

The English nuns survived the Terror.

In 1795, they were allowed to leave France and go home to England, where their community eventually settled at Stanbrook.

They took with them a few small things the Carmelites had left behind, the patched civilian clothes the sisters had been wearing before they were taken to Paris.

Stanbrook kept those clothes as relics for generations.

—

## The washing

In July, the order came to move the Carmelites to Paris, to stand trial before the Revolutionary Tribunal.

There is a small detail about that day that almost every version of the story keeps, because it is so ordinary.

When the order came, the nuns’ civilian clothes had just been washed and were not yet dry.

They had only one other set of clothes.

They had kept their habits.

So, for the journey to Paris, the sixteen women put on the brown habits, the white wimples, and the black veils that the law had forbidden them to wear.

They would wear them for the rest of their lives, which was now a matter of days.

They traveled in carts, their hands tied, along the road south to Paris.

Some people along the way shouted at them.

Others only stared.

When they reached the capital, they were taken to the Conciergerie, the old prison inside the Palace of Justice on the Île de la Cité.

It was the last stop for prisoners of the Tribunal.

Marie Antoinette had waited there for her own trial only nine months before.

—

## A song in the Conciergerie

The Conciergerie in July 1794 was crowded and full of fear.

Prisoners were called out every day, tried in a few minutes, and sent to the guillotine the same afternoon.

Many could not sleep.

Some fell apart.

The Carmelites kept to their hours.

According to the community’s history, one of them, Sister Julie Louise of Jesus, a widow who had entered the convent late in life, even wrote a hymn while they were there.

She set it to the tune of the most famous song of the Revolution, the Marseillaise.

The words were not about marching against tyrants.

They were about joy, and about going toward God.

Other prisoners noticed them.

They were the strangest prisoners in the building, women who seemed to be preparing for something, not dreading it.

—

## Fanaticism

On July 17, 1794, the sixteen Carmelites were brought before the Revolutionary Tribunal.

They had no lawyer.

The prosecutor was Antoine Quentin Fouquier-Tinville, the man who had prosecuted Marie Antoinette and who sent thousands of people to their deaths that year.

The charges against them were what the Tribunal usually used.

They were accused of plotting against the Republic, of corresponding with enemies of the Revolution, of hiding royalist objects, and, above all, of fanaticism.

In the language of the Terror, fanaticism meant religion.

One story from the trial has been told ever since.

It was not Mother Teresa who spoke first, but one of the younger choir nuns, Sister Henriette of Providence, who was thirty-four.

When she heard the word fanaticism, she asked the court what it meant.

She asked it as if she truly did not know.

By the account that has come down to us, Fouquier-Tinville answered that he meant their attachment to childish beliefs and silly religious practices.

Sister Henriette turned to her sisters.

Now they knew, she told them, why they were being condemned.

Not for plots, and not for politics, but for their faith.

She said they should rejoice.

Another story says that when the court accused them of hiding weapons for the enemies of France, Mother Teresa held up a small crucifix and said that this was the only weapon they had ever had.

And another says that she tried, in the courtroom, to take the whole blame on herself, saying that she alone was responsible and that the others had only obeyed her.

The court did not listen.

All sixteen women were sentenced to death, along with Mulot de la Ménardière.

The sentence was to be carried out that same day.

—

## The road across Paris

That evening, the condemned were loaded into open carts outside the Conciergerie.

The guillotine was no longer standing in the great square in the center of the city.

Weeks earlier, people living near it had complained, and it had been moved out to the eastern edge of Paris, to a square then called the Place du Trône-Renversé, the Square of the Overthrown Throne.

Today it is called the Place de la Nation.

The ride across the city took a long time, perhaps two hours.

The carts rolled slowly through narrow streets, past shops and windows and crowds of people who had come out to watch, as Parisians did almost every evening that summer.

And the Carmelites sang.

They sang the Miserere, the old psalm asking God for mercy.

They sang the Salve Regina, the evening hymn to the Virgin Mary that Carmelites had sung at the end of every day of their lives.

They sang parts of their evening prayers and of the prayers for the dead.

People who saw them pass remembered it.

A cart full of condemned prisoners was nothing new in Paris that summer.

People had grown used to the sight, and some had grown used to jeering.

But this was a cart full of women in forbidden habits, singing in Latin, as if they were in their own chapel and not on their way to die.

Many of the people watching fell silent.

—

## At the foot of the scaffold

When the carts reached the square, it was crowded.

The scaffold stood in the middle of it, with the tall wooden frame of the guillotine and the slanted blade at the top.

The sixteen women climbed down from the cart and gathered at the foot of the steps.

Before anything else happened, they knelt together and sang the Veni Creator Spiritus, the ancient hymn that begins, “Come, Holy Spirit.”

It was the hymn sung when a Carmelite made her vows.

Then, together, they renewed those vows out loud, as if they were making them for the first time.

What happened next is told in many versions.

In the best known, Mother Teresa took her place at the foot of the steps.

She held in her hand a small clay statue of the Virgin Mary.

One by one, each sister came to her, knelt, and asked her permission to die, as a Carmelite would ask her prioress’ permission for anything.

Each one kissed the little statue.

And each time, the prioress gave her blessing and let her go.

Some of the details may have grown in the telling.

But the order of what happened is not in doubt.

The youngest went first.

The prioress went last.

—

## Constance

The first to climb the steps was Sister Constance.

She was about twenty-nine.

She had lived in the convent for several years, but she had never been allowed to make her final vows.

In the eyes of the law, and even in the strict eyes of her own order, she had never become a full Carmelite nun.

Now, at the foot of the scaffold, she had just made those vows with the others.

The story says she knelt before her prioress and asked for permission to die.

Then she stood up and went to the steps.

When the executioner’s assistants moved to help her up, she did not need them.

She climbed by herself.

As she climbed, she began to sing.

The psalm she chose was the shortest one in the whole Bible, Psalm 117, which in Latin begins “Laudate Dominum, omnes gentes,” “Praise the Lord, all you nations.”

It was, by tradition, the psalm Carmelites sang when a new convent was founded.

The other sisters took up the psalm below her.

Then her voice stopped.

—

## One voice fewer

After Constance, the others went, one at a time.

The ones who were left went on singing.

Each time a sister climbed the steps, the singing went on below her.

Each time a voice stopped, there was one voice fewer, and the others did not stop.

Among them were the lay sisters, women who had spent their lives doing the hardest physical work of the house and who sang the Latin hymns from memory.

There were Catherine and Thérèse Soiron, the two sisters from the town who were not even nuns, and who could have gone free if they had wanted to separate themselves from the community.

They did not.

There was Sister Charlotte of the Resurrection, seventy-eight years old, frail, who had served for years as the convent’s sacristan.

And there was Sister Marie of Jesus Crucified, also seventy-eight.

According to the community’s history, she told the men at the scaffold that she forgave them as heartily as she hoped God would forgive her.

Sister Henriette, the young nun who had asked the court what fanaticism meant, is said to have stayed near the steps to help the older sisters up toward the platform, one after another.

She was the second-to-last to go.

And then there was only one.

Mother Teresa of Saint Augustine had sent every one of her sisters ahead of her.

She had given her blessing fifteen times.

Now there was no one left to give her permission, and no one left to sing with her.

She climbed the steps last.

When she was gone, the square was silent.

People who were there said that the crowd did not cheer, did not shout, did not do any of the things that crowds at the guillotine usually did.

They stood still.

And then they went home.

—

## The pit at Picpus

The bodies of the sixteen Carmelites were not given graves.

Like everyone executed at the Place du Trône-Renversé that summer, they were carted a short distance away to a garden that had once belonged to a convent of Augustinian canonesses, at a place called Picpus.

There, in a pit dug in the sandy ground, they were buried together with everyone else who had died on the scaffold that day.

Between the middle of June and the end of July 1794, more than thirteen hundred people were guillotined at that square.

Their bodies all went into the pits at Picpus.

Years later, the families of some of the victims bought the land, and it became a small private cemetery.

It is still there today, behind walls, on a quiet street in the twelfth arrondissement.

Many Parisians have never been inside.

The names of the dead are carved on plaques in the chapel nearby.

Sixteen of them belong to the women from Compiègne.

—

## Ten days

On July 27, 1794, ten days after the Carmelites died, Maximilien Robespierre was shouted down in the National Convention and arrested by his own colleagues.

Robespierre had been the most powerful man on the Committee of Public Safety, the government that ran the Terror.

He had not personally sentenced the nuns.

But the laws that made their trial possible, the laws that let the Tribunal condemn people on suspicion and without witnesses or defense, had been passed while he dominated the government, and with his support.

He was guillotined on July 28, 1794, together with many of his closest allies.

The guillotine had been moved back to the center of the city for him, to the Place de la Révolution, the square now called the Place de la Concorde.

So he did not die on the same scaffold as the Carmelites.

But he died on the same machine.

Within weeks, the prisons began to open.

The Revolutionary Tribunal was reorganized and then abolished.

Fouquier-Tinville, the prosecutor who had told the nuns what fanaticism meant, was himself put on trial and guillotined in May 1795.

Was there any connection between the death of the sixteen Carmelites and the fall of Robespierre ten days later?

Historians will say there was none, that his fall came from quarrels and fears inside the Convention that had nothing to do with a group of nuns from Compiègne.

That is almost certainly true.

But the Carmelites themselves had offered their lives, two years earlier, so that the violence would end.

And the violence ended.

For the people who loved them, that was enough.

—

## The three who were away

The story of the Carmelites of Compiègne might have been lost, like the stories of so many others who died that summer, if not for the three members of the community who were not arrested.

One of them, Sister Marie of the Incarnation, lived for decades afterward.

She gathered every letter, every memory, every account she could find.

She wrote the history of her community, and it was eventually published in 1836.

Almost everything told about the sisters’ last two years, the offering, the hesitation of the two older nuns, the washing, the songs, comes from her work and from the people she spoke to.

She was the one who had to carry the knowledge that she had lived because she was not there.

—

## From a novella to an opera

In the twentieth century, the story of the sixteen nuns found a new audience in a way none of them could have imagined.

In 1931, the German writer Gertrud von le Fort published a short novel about them.

Its title in German means “The Last One at the Scaffold.”

She invented a central character, a frightened young aristocrat named Blanche, who enters the convent to escape her own fear and who, in the end, finds the courage to follow her sisters to the guillotine.

The French writer Georges Bernanos, near the end of his life, wrote dialogue based on that novel for a film.

After his death, his text was turned into a stage play.

And in the 1950s the composer Francis Poulenc turned it into an opera, Dialogues of the Carmelites, which was first performed in Milan in 1957.

It ends with the nuns singing the Salve Regina as they go to the guillotine one at a time, and with the sound of the blade cutting off one voice after another, until only one is left.

It is still performed in opera houses all over the world.

Most of the people who have wept at the end of that opera have no idea that it happened.

—

## Saints

The Catholic Church took its time.

For more than a century, the sixteen were remembered mostly in France, and mostly by the Carmelites themselves.

On May 27, 1906, Pope Pius X declared them blessed in a ceremony at Saint Peter’s Basilica in Rome.

And on December 18, 2024, Pope Francis declared them saints.

He did it through a rare procedure, without the usual requirement of a new miracle, which the Church uses when a person’s holiness has been honored for so long that further proof is not needed.

It had been two hundred and thirty years since the evening at the Place du Trône-Renversé.

Every year, on July 17, a small group gathers at Picpus.

They light candles in the chapel, and they sing the same hymns the sisters sang on the road across Paris.

—

## The words nobody wrote down

The lines below are imagined, rendered in English, to give a voice to the moment in the picture.

Only the first comes from the story as it is usually told, and even that is a tradition rather than a record taken down at the time.

The young nun kneels at the foot of the scaffold and looks up at the woman she has obeyed for years.

“Permission to die, Mother?”

She waits for the answer, then lifts her chin.

“We will sing to the end.”

Then she rises and begins the psalm, and the others take it up behind her.

“Laudate Dominum, omnes gentes.”

Nobody at the Place du Trône-Renversé took down what the sixteen women said that evening.

The history written by Sister Marie of the Incarnation preserves the order in which they died, the hymns they sang, and a handful of words passed on by people who were there.

The rest is silence.

—

## The picture, once more

Look at the picture again.

The young nun on her knees at the foot of the guillotine, her hands folded, her face turned up toward the sky.

The man in the black coat with his hand on the rope.

The man in the blue coat, watching.

The row of women in brown and white and black, waiting their turn.

Now it is possible to say what is true in it.

The habits are true.

They were never supposed to be wearing them, and they wore them only because their other clothes had been washed that morning.

The kneeling is true.

Before any of them climbed the steps, they knelt together at the foot of the scaffold and sang.

The calm on her face is true, as far as the people who saw it could tell.

What the picture leaves out is everything around that moment.

It leaves out the crowd that went quiet, the singing that went on, voice after voice, and the prioress waiting at the foot of the steps until she was the only one left.

It leaves out the two years in four small apartments, and the offering made every morning, and the court that told them what fanaticism meant.

In the picture, the blade is still at the top of the frame, and nobody has climbed the steps yet.

In the story, they all did, singing, and when the last voice stopped, Paris had nothing to say.

You Might Also Enjoy