1540: What Was an Evening Like for a Tudor Noblewoman at Hampton Court
The candles in the queen’s rooms were beeswax, and you could smell them before you saw them.
That was how you knew you were somewhere that mattered.
Down in the kitchens and the servants’ passages, the light came from tallow, rendered animal fat that smoked and stank and left a greasy film on the walls.
Up here the flames burned clean and steady, with a faint scent of honey, and they threw small pools of gold across the tapestries, the silk sleeves and the faces of the women gathered around them.
It was an evening in the winter of 1536, at the court of Henry VIII.
Supper had been served hours ago, at four in the afternoon, each woman seated exactly where her rank allowed.
Now the music had started.
Someone was playing the virginals, the notes small and bright under the low ceiling.
A few of the younger women were waiting to be asked to dance.
Others had settled at a table with cards, and the soft slap of painted cards on the board went on under the music like rain on a window.
In a corner, a young woman of twenty sat with a book open on her knee and a pen in her hand.
She was not reading it.
She was writing in it.
The book was nothing grand to look at.
It was a gathering of paper that went quietly from hand to hand among the queen’s women and the young men who visited them.
In it they copied poems: love poems, complaints, riddles, verses by the courtier Thomas Wyatt, lines borrowed from Chaucer, lines that nobody signed.
Some of the pages were in her handwriting.
Some of them, in time, would be in his.
That was the clever thing about a book like that.
It did not need two people to be in the same room.
You wrote a line.
You passed the book on.
Days later, it came back to you with an answer inside.
Her name was Lady Margaret Douglas.
She was the daughter of the king’s elder sister, which made her Henry VIII’s niece, and within a few months that single fact would matter more than anything she ever wrote.
His name was Lord Thomas Howard.
He was the younger half-brother of the Duke of Norfolk, the most powerful nobleman in England.
They had made each other a promise.
Nobody had asked the king.
By the end of that summer, both of them would be prisoners in the Tower of London.
Only one of them would ever walk out.
—
## Why would a love story end in a law?
What happened to Margaret Douglas and Thomas Howard over the next eighteen months is one of the saddest stories of Henry VIII’s court, and very few people outside England have ever heard it.
Part of it survives in their own words.
Poems they sent each other while they were prisoners are still sitting in that same book, now kept in the British Library in London.
And the young woman Henry locked away for loving the wrong man would go on to do something nobody in that candlelit room could have imagined.
She would outlive the king, outlive his son, outlive one of his daughters, and be sent to the Tower twice more before she was done.
Every king and queen who has sat on the British throne since 1603 is descended from her.
To understand how that happened, you have to go back to a cold stone castle on the Scottish border, where she was born while her mother was running for her life.
—
## Why was the king’s niece born in a border fortress?
Harbottle Castle stood in the hills of Northumberland, a few miles from Scotland, a squat, half-ruined stronghold built for war and not for comfort.
In October 1515 it held a queen.
She was Margaret Tudor, the elder sister of Henry VIII.
Two years earlier her first husband, King James IV of Scotland, had died fighting the English at the Battle of Flodden.
She had been left as regent for their baby son, now King James V. Then she had made a decision her Scottish lords never forgave.
She married a handsome young nobleman named Archibald Douglas, Earl of Angus.
The marriage cost her the regency.
The lords brought in the Duke of Albany to rule in her place, and by the late summer of 1515 Margaret Tudor, heavily pregnant, had fled across the border into her brother’s kingdom.
On October 8, 1515, at Harbottle, she gave birth to a daughter.
The birth was hard.
Margaret Tudor was so ill afterward that for weeks she could not travel.
The baby was named Margaret, after her mother, and christened almost at once, because babies born in places like Harbottle did not always live long enough for a grand ceremony.
Her father did not stay.
Angus went back to Scotland to make his own peace with the men who had driven his wife out.
It was the first sign of something the little girl would learn very early.
In her family, love was not the thing that decided where you lived.
Later, back in Scotland, the people who should have protected the child went to war with each other.
—
## How did a little girl become a prize in her parents’ war?
In Scotland, the marriage of Margaret Tudor and the Earl of Angus fell apart almost completely.
Angus, it was said, had taken up with another woman, Lady Janet Stewart of Traquair, and was living off his wife’s lands and rents.
Margaret Tudor wanted him gone.
For years she fought for an annulment, and in 1527 she finally got one from the pope.
She married again almost immediately.
Their daughter was caught between them.
For much of her childhood she lived with her father, the Douglas side of the family, in grim fortresses like Tantallon, a red stone castle on a cliff above the North Sea where the wind never seemed to stop.
Her father, for a few years, was the most powerful man in Scotland.
He had taken control of her half-brother, the boy king James V, and ruled in his name.
Then, in 1528, the teenage king escaped.
James V broke free of the Douglases and turned on them with a fury that never really cooled.
Angus was declared a traitor.
His castles were besieged.
And he did what his wife had done thirteen years earlier.
He fled south, into England, and he took his daughter with him.
She was about thirteen.
She came out of Scotland a refugee, the daughter of an outlawed earl, with a mother who had remarried and a half-brother on the Scottish throne who hated her father.
One question hung over her that would follow her for the rest of her life.
With her parents’ marriage annulled, was she even legitimate?
The answer, as it turned out, depended on what her uncle in England needed her to be.
And her uncle was about to turn his own family upside down for a woman named Anne Boleyn.
—
## Why did Henry VIII keep his niece so close?
Henry VIII seems to have liked his niece very much.
By around 1530 she was living in the household of his daughter, Princess Mary.
The two girls were almost exactly the same age.
Margaret had been born in October 1515, Mary in February 1516.
They were first cousins, both granddaughters of Henry VII, and both, in their different ways, girls whose fathers had made their lives very complicated.
The friendship that started then lasted the rest of their lives.
But Mary’s world was about to collapse.
When Henry broke with Rome and married Anne Boleyn in 1533, and Anne gave birth to Princess Elizabeth that September, Mary was declared illegitimate.
Her household was broken up.
She was sent to serve her baby half-sister.
Margaret went in another direction.
She was taken into the household of the new queen, Anne Boleyn, where her rank as the king’s niece put her close to the top.
It was a strange position.
Her closest friend was Mary, the girl Anne was pushing out of the succession.
Her mistress was Anne.
And her own value, in the eyes of everyone at court, rested on a single fact.
She was royal.
A royal niece was a marriage piece on the board of Europe.
She could be offered to a foreign prince to seal a treaty.
She could be married to a Scottish lord to pull Scotland toward England.
The imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who wrote home about nearly everything that happened at court, described her as beautiful and highly esteemed.
The king gave her clothes and jewels and a place of honor.
What he did not give her was the right to choose her own husband.
That right belonged to him.
Which is exactly why what she did next was so dangerous.
—
## What really happened after the candles were lit?
To understand how a love affair could grow in the middle of the most watched court in Europe, you have to understand what an evening at that court was really like.
The rhythm hardly changed across Henry’s reign.
One of the clearest pictures we have comes from Hampton Court a few years later, in the summer of 1540, and almost all of it applies to the court where Margaret Douglas was twenty.
The day had two meals.
The first came at ten in the morning.
The second, supper, was served at four in the afternoon, and that was when the evening really began.
A strict set of household rules laid down by the Lord Chamberlain decided where every person sat and what they were allowed to eat.
Clerks of the kitchen stood where the food was served out and sent the dishes to each table according to rank.
If your portion began to shrink, or your seat drifted further from the high table, nobody needed to explain it to you.
The women of the queen’s household usually ate in or near the queen’s own rooms.
The food was meant to impress: game birds, venison pies, roast lamb, sometimes eel or even porpoise.
Between courses came the subtleties, sculptures of sugar shaped like castles and animals, made by specialists in the palace confectionery from sugar shipped in from the Mediterranean.
The real conversations happened later.
After supper came the music.
Henry was a gifted musician who played several instruments and wrote songs of his own, and the singers of his Chapel Royal were among the best in England.
For the women of the queen’s household, music was not a pastime.
It was part of the job.
You were expected to sing, to play the lute or the virginals, and to perform when you were asked.
Then there was dancing.
It opened slowly, with a pavane, stately and measured, the partners barely touching hands.
Then the musicians would quicken into a galliard, faster and more athletic, full of leaps and turns.
Every step had been practiced.
The king watched, and the king remembered who danced well.
On quieter nights there were cards and dice.
The great game at Henry’s court was primero, and the king was famously bad at it.
Between 1529 and 1532, by one count, he lost more than three thousand pounds gambling, at a time when a gentleman living away from court could live comfortably on about twenty pounds a year.
And then, as the evening wore on, the circle grew smaller.
The queen withdrew to her inner rooms.
Guards stood at each doorway, and only the king, the queen’s own women and a few privileged visitors went through.
Her ladies slept close by, some of them on low truckle beds that were pushed under the larger beds during the day.
When a woman walked back to her own lodging from the queen’s chambers, she carried a single candle down long stone corridors, a small island of light with darkness ahead and behind, listening to footsteps and doors closing somewhere she could not see.
It was in these hours, in rooms full of music and candlelight and people who were all watching each other, that the court played its favorite game.
They called it courtly love.
It was a performance of longing, carried on in verses and glances and riddles, a game in which a gentleman could declare himself dying of love for a lady, and the lady could answer with a poem of her own, and everyone understood that none of it was meant to be real.
For most of the people playing it, it stayed a game.
For Margaret Douglas, at some point in the winter of 1535 and 1536, it stopped being one.
—
## Who was the young man writing back to her?
Lord Thomas Howard was about twenty-five.
He came from the most ambitious family in England.
His father, the second Duke of Norfolk, was the old soldier who had won the Battle of Flodden in 1513, the battle in which Margaret’s mother had lost her first husband.
His much older half-brother was now the third Duke, Henry VIII’s leading nobleman, a hard, careful survivor.
And the Howards were everywhere at Henry’s court.
Thomas was a half-uncle of the queen herself, because Anne Boleyn’s mother had been a Howard.
His nephew was Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, already writing the poems that would make him famous.
His niece, Mary Howard, had been married to the king’s illegitimate son, Henry FitzRoy, Duke of Richmond.
These young Howards and their friends were at the center of the group that shared the book.
Historians today call it the Devonshire Manuscript, because it spent centuries in the library of the Dukes of Devonshire before it came to the British Library.
It holds close to two hundred poems and fragments, written in many different hands.
Some are poems by Thomas Wyatt, the finest poet at court.
Some are lines copied from Chaucer.
Some seem to be the readers’ own work, or other people’s poems quietly changed to fit a private situation.
Three young women in particular left their mark on its pages.
One was Mary Shelton, a cousin of Anne Boleyn.
One was Mary Howard, Thomas’s niece.
And one was Margaret Douglas.
Reading it now is a little like opening someone’s phone.
Lines are underlined.
Names are hinted at.
A poem about a lover’s cruelty turns up with someone’s initials beside it.
A verse that is perfectly innocent on its own suddenly looks different when you know who copied it, and for whom.
Somewhere in those pages, the game between Margaret and Thomas turned into something else.
They agreed to marry.
—
## What did it mean to promise yourself without a priest?
To a modern reader, a secret engagement sounds romantic and not very serious.
In 1536 it was deadly serious.
Under the church law of the time, two people did not need a priest, a wedding or the permission of their families to be bound to each other.
If a man and a woman exchanged promises in words of the present tense, the equivalent of “I take you as my husband” and “I take you as my wife,” that promise could be treated as a binding contract of marriage.
It could be enough, in the eyes of the church, to block either of them from marrying anyone else.
Henry VIII knew this law better than almost anyone in England.
He had spent years arguing about marriages and the promises that came before them.
He would one day use an earlier promise of exactly this kind to escape his marriage to Anne of Cleves.
Margaret and Thomas seem to have made their promise in the spring of 1536, perhaps around Easter.
Later questioning suggested they had exchanged tokens and gifts, the way betrothed couples did.
Thomas, it was said, had visited her in her rooms.
It is hard now to know exactly what was in their minds.
It is easy to guess what was in their hearts.
In the poems that survive, the strongest feeling is not fear or calculation.
It is something much simpler.
Two young people who had found each other in a court full of performance believed, for a little while, that this one thing was real.
They had chosen a terrible moment.
That May, the woman they both served fell.
Anne Boleyn was arrested at Greenwich, accused of adultery and treason, and taken to the Tower.
Within three weeks she and five men had died.
Her household was broken up.
Thomas Howard’s half-niece was gone, and Margaret Douglas had lost her mistress.
But the fall of one queen had done something else, something Margaret may not have understood at first.
It had moved her several steps closer to the throne.
—
## How did one queen’s fall put Margaret in danger?
Eleven days after Anne Boleyn’s death, Henry VIII married Jane Seymour.
A new Act of Succession followed that summer.
It declared that both of Henry’s daughters were illegitimate.
Mary had already been set aside.
Now Elizabeth was set aside too.
Only children born to Jane would inherit, and Jane did not yet have any.
The act gave Henry the power to name his own heir if he had no lawful children.
The king had a son, Henry FitzRoy, but FitzRoy was illegitimate, and by that summer he was seriously ill.
So who was next?
By blood, the nearest heirs after Henry’s own children were the descendants of his sisters.
His elder sister’s son was James V of Scotland, but James was a foreign king, born outside England, and many English lawyers believed that ruled him out.
That left his half-sister, born in an English castle, raised at the English court, unmarried and in her early twenties.
Margaret Douglas.
To some observers that summer, she looked very much like the nearest English-born heir to the throne.
And she had secretly bound herself to a Howard.
Exactly how the secret came out is not known.
In early July 1536 the king found out, and his reaction was immediate.
Thomas Howard was arrested and taken to the Tower of London.
Margaret was taken there too.
Men from their households were questioned about the gifts that had passed between them and about the times Thomas had come to her rooms.
The answers were written down and carried to the king.
To Henry, it did not look like a love story.
It looked like the Howards, the family that had already given him one disastrous queen, reaching for the crown through his niece.
His answer was not a trial.
It was a new law.
—
## Why did Parliament write a law for one young man?
On July 18, 1536, Parliament passed an Act of Attainder against Lord Thomas Howard.
An attainder was a law aimed at a single person.
It did not need witnesses, a jury or a defense.
Parliament simply declared a man guilty, and the sentence followed.
The act described Thomas in the harshest terms.
In substance, it said that he had been led astray by the devil, that he had secretly contracted himself to the king’s niece without the king’s knowledge, and that he had done it because he hoped, through her, to aspire to the throne itself.
Then the act went further.
It made it treason, from then on, for any man to marry, or to try to marry, the king’s children, his sisters, his aunts or his nieces without the king’s permission.
The law Henry wrote for Thomas Howard was a law about all of them.
Thomas was condemned to death.
But the sentence was not carried out.
He was left where he was, in the Tower, a man the law said should die, waiting to find out whether the king meant it.
Margaret was not attainted.
Henry spared his niece the legal ruin he had brought down on her lover.
But she was not free either.
Five days after the act was passed, on July 23, Henry FitzRoy died at St James’s Palace, at the age of seventeen.
The young man who had been married to Thomas Howard’s niece was gone.
The succession had narrowed again.
And in the Tower, with stone walls between them, Thomas and Margaret started writing to each other again.
—
## What did they write to each other through the walls of the Tower?
Some of the most moving pages of the Devonshire Manuscript seem to belong to that imprisonment.
A group of poems in the book is usually linked to Thomas Howard and his months in the Tower.
The voice in them is a man who has been forced away from everything he loved.
He mourns that he has been driven from his delight.
He cannot see the one he calls his lovely mate.
He complains of the men who have parted them.
And again and again he promises that whatever happens to him, his heart will stay where it is.
Other poems answer him in a woman’s voice, and they are usually read as Margaret’s.
In them, she refuses to be sorry.
Whatever the world says, she writes, she has chosen well.
In one of the best known, she says, in the spelling of the time, that she has taken to her part “the faithfullest lover that ever was born.”
How the poems traveled is a mystery.
Perhaps servants carried scraps of paper between their rooms.
Perhaps the verses were written in the Tower and copied into the book later by a friend, Mary Shelton or Mary Howard, who wanted to keep them safe.
But the feeling in them is unmistakable.
These are not courtly love games anymore.
Nobody is performing for an audience.
The court is not watching, because the court has moved on.
These are two people in their twenties who have been locked in a fortress for promising to marry, trying to keep that promise alive with nothing but paper and ink.
Then, as the year turned toward winter, Margaret fell ill.
—
## What did she promise Thomas Cromwell?
The Tower in winter was damp, cold and full of the smell of the river.
As Margaret’s health got worse, the king agreed to move her.
Late in 1536 she was taken out of the Tower and sent upriver to Syon Abbey, a house of Bridgettine nuns on the banks of the Thames at Isleworth, west of London.
For Margaret it was a softer prison, with gardens and the sound of bells instead of soldiers and stone, but it was still a prison.
She was there because the king wanted her there, she was watched, and the size of her household was decided by other people.
The man who decided most things now was Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister.
At some point during her time at Syon, Margaret wrote to him.
The letter survives.
In it, she thanks Cromwell for his kindness to her.
She says she knows she has displeased the king.
And she gives up Thomas Howard.
In substance, she asks Cromwell not to think that any fancy for Thomas remains in her, and she promises that she will not set her heart on him again.
Did she mean it?
Nobody can know.
She was a young woman alone in a convent, writing to the most feared man in England, about a man the law had already condemned to death.
She had seen what happened to Anne Boleyn.
She had every reason to say whatever would keep her alive and bring her back into her uncle’s favor.
But it is hard to read those words without thinking about the other ones, the ones in the book, about the faithfullest lover that ever was born.
She could write herself out of the story.
In the Tower, Thomas Howard had no letter that could save him.
—
## Why did the bells for a prince never ring for him?
October came to London in 1537 with rain and wind off the river.
Thomas Howard had been in the Tower for more than a year.
He was still a condemned man.
The act passed against him had never been reversed.
He had not been taken to the scaffold, but nobody had come to tell him he would be released either.
Every morning he woke up as a man the law said should die, in a fortress where he had seen what usually happened to men like him.
He had watched one queen go to her death there.
He had seen the men who died with her.
And now, the autumn damp was getting into his lungs.
On October 12, 1537, at Hampton Court, the new queen gave birth to a son.
After twenty-eight years on the throne, after two broken marriages, after everything he had broken to get here, Henry VIII finally had a legitimate male heir.
The baby was named Edward.
Within hours the news was racing down the Thames toward London.
The city went wild.
Church bells rang across London.
Bonfires were lit in the streets.
A solemn service of thanks was sung at St. Paul’s.
And at the Tower, according to one London chronicler, the guns were fired again and again in celebration, shot after shot, so many that the walls must have shaken with them.
Inside those walls was a sick man who had been condemned for trying to marry into the royal family.
It is not hard to imagine what that sound meant to him.
Every gun fired for the baby prince was a reminder of why he was there.
The king’s line was safe now.
The question of who would inherit, the question that had made his love for Margaret look like treason, had been answered in a nursery at Hampton Court.
It changed nothing for Thomas.
Three days later, on October 15, the prince was christened in the chapel at Hampton Court, by torchlight, in a ceremony that went on long into the night.
Princess Mary stood as godmother.
Little Princess Elizabeth, four years old, was carried in the procession holding the christening robe.
Hundreds of courtiers crowded the galleries and the chapel.
The same court that had danced and played cards and copied poems by candlelight was all there, dressed in its best, celebrating the future.
Margaret Douglas was not there.
Thomas Howard was not there.
Then, as quickly as the joy had come, it turned.
The queen fell ill after the birth.
For days she grew weaker.
On the night of October 24, 1537, Jane Seymour died at Hampton Court, twelve days after giving her husband the son he had waited a lifetime for.
The bells of London rang again, but slowly now.
They were tolling for the queen.
The city that had lit bonfires for the prince went into mourning.
Black cloth went up.
Masses were said for Jane’s soul in every church.
The king shut himself away at Windsor.
And in the Tower, Thomas Howard was dying.
We do not know exactly what illness took him.
The records describe it only vaguely, the kind of fever that killed so many prisoners in damp, cold rooms.
We do not know whether anyone sat with him, whether a priest was brought, whether he was allowed to write a last letter or a last poem.
We do not know what he said, or whether he said her name.
We know the date.
On October 31, 1537, Lord Thomas Howard died in the Tower of London.
He was about twenty-six years old.
He had not been sent to the block.
He had not stood on Tower Hill in front of a crowd.
The king had never needed to carry out the sentence.
He had simply left him in the Tower until the Tower did it for him.
His body was handed over to his mother, Agnes, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk.
According to the usual account, the king gave permission for her to bury him on one condition: there was to be no ceremony and no display.
He was laid to rest quietly, it is said in the Howard family’s burial place at Thetford Priory in Norfolk.
At Syon, at about the same time, Margaret Douglas was set free.
The exact day is uncertain.
Some accounts place her release just before Thomas died, and some just after.
Either way, the timing is cruel.
The young woman who had promised herself to him was released into a world that no longer had him in it.
There is no letter from her about his death.
There is no poem we can be sure she wrote for him afterward.
She is said to have been heartbroken, and nothing about the rest of her life suggests that she ever forgot him.
But she did what women at the Tudor court had to do.
She went back.
—
## Was Margaret allowed back into the same candlelit rooms?
By 1539 Margaret Douglas was back at court, and back in favor.
When Henry’s fourth bride, Anne of Cleves, arrived in England at the end of that year, Margaret was among the great ladies chosen to serve her.
That marriage fell apart within six months.
In the summer of 1540 Henry married again.
His new queen was a young Howard, Catherine Howard, the niece of the Duke of Norfolk and, as it happens, the half-niece of the man Margaret had lost.
In August 1540 the king presented Catherine as queen at Hampton Court.
And so Margaret Douglas, now twenty-four, found herself in exactly the world the evening at Hampton Court was built around.
The palace on the Thames was a small city that summer, housing somewhere between eight hundred and twelve hundred people.
The great hall, with its carved hammerbeam roof sixty feet high, had been finished only a few years before; on some of its carvings, the initials and badges of Anne Boleyn had still not been replaced.
Margaret was no longer one of the youngest women in the room.
The maids of honor were teenagers.
She was a senior lady, the king’s niece, a woman who had been to the Tower and come back.
She would have known every rule of the evening.
Supper at four.
The seats by rank.
The music, the pavane and the galliard, the cards and the dice.
The guarded inner rooms.
The long walk back with a single candle.
She would also have known how quickly it could all go wrong.
And yet it happened again.
In 1541 Margaret became involved with another young Howard.
His name was Charles Howard.
He was the queen’s own brother, and he was also the half-nephew of Thomas Howard, the man she had loved five years earlier.
How far it went is unclear.
There was no secret marriage this time, as far as anyone could prove.
But there was enough, apparently, for the court to notice.
In November 1541 the queen’s world collapsed.
Archbishop Cranmer was given information about Catherine Howard’s life before her marriage, and the king’s investigators went through her household one woman at a time, asking who had come through which door, which letters had been burned, who had kept watch.
In the middle of that terrible autumn, Margaret’s own affair came to light.
The king did not send her to the Tower this time.
He sent her away from court, under watch, first to Syon again, according to some accounts, and then to the Duke of Norfolk’s house at Kenninghall.
The council instructed Cranmer to speak to her sharply about her conduct.
According to the usual summary of those instructions, she was told that she had now behaved foolishly twice, and that she should beware the third time.
Charles Howard left the court and, by most accounts, England.
The queen he served, Catherine Howard, died on Tower Green in February 1542.
Margaret was twenty-six.
She had loved two men.
Henry had taken both of them away.
The third time, he did not wait for her to choose.
—
## Who did Henry finally let her marry?
In 1544 the king found Margaret a husband.
He was Matthew Stewart, Earl of Lennox, a Scottish nobleman with a royal claim of his own who had fallen out with the Scottish government and come over to Henry’s side.
England and Scotland were at war again, and Henry wanted a powerful Scot in his pocket.
Marrying him to the king’s niece was the price of his loyalty.
The wedding took place at St. James’s Palace in the summer of 1544.
Margaret was twenty-eight.
It was a political match, arranged by the same uncle who had locked her away.
And yet, by every sign we have, it became a real marriage.
The letters he wrote to her that survive are tender and full of longing when they were apart.
Years later, when he died, she would grieve for him openly.
They lived much of the time at Temple Newsam, a great house in Yorkshire.
She had at least eight children.
Most of them died young, as so many children did.
Two sons survived.
The elder, Henry Stewart, Lord Darnley, was born in 1545.
The younger, Charles, came about ten years later.
After Henry’s death, his daughter Mary, Margaret’s childhood friend, became queen and treated her with great honor.
Then Mary died, and Elizabeth became queen.
Margaret Douglas had a tall, handsome, beautifully trained son with royal blood on both sides.
And she had a plan for him.
—
## How did her son end up married to Mary, Queen of Scots?
In the early 1560s the most eligible woman in Britain was a widow in Edinburgh.
Mary, Queen of Scots, had come home from France after the death of her first husband.
She was young, she was a queen, and she needed a husband.
Margaret Douglas looked at the map of royal blood and saw her son in the middle of it.
Both were great-grandchildren of Henry VII.
Married, they would join two royal claims to the English throne into one.
Elizabeth I understood that perfectly.
It was why she distrusted Margaret.
In 1565 Darnley was allowed to travel north to Scotland.
Mary fell for him quickly.
On July 29, 1565, they were married at Holyrood in Edinburgh.
Elizabeth was furious.
Darnley’s father was in Scotland with his son, out of reach, but Margaret was in England.
So the queen did what her father had done.
Margaret Douglas was sent to the Tower of London.
Nearly thirty years after she had first been locked up there for an unauthorized marriage, she was back, for another one.
While she was in the Tower, in June 1566, her grandson was born at Edinburgh Castle.
He was named James.
It should have been the triumph of her life.
Instead, the marriage in Scotland went bad almost at once.
Darnley was arrogant, jealous and violent, and within a year Mary could barely stand him.
In February 1567 the house where he was staying, at Kirk o’ Field in Edinburgh, was destroyed by an explosion in the night.
Darnley was found dead in the garden nearby.
He was twenty-one.
The news reached his mother in the Tower.
Elizabeth released her soon afterward.
Margaret blamed Mary, at least at first, and demanded justice for her son.
Her husband Lennox became regent of Scotland for their baby grandson in 1570, and the next year he was shot and died during a raid on Stirling.
She had lost her first love to the Tower, her son to a mystery in Edinburgh, and her husband to a gunshot.
She was not finished being punished.
—
## Why was she sent to the Tower a third time?
In 1574 Margaret did it again.
Her younger son, Charles, was traveling north with her when they stopped as guests of the most formidable woman in England, Bess of Hardwick.
Within days Charles was married to Bess’s daughter, Elizabeth Cavendish.
Elizabeth I had not been asked.
It was, once again, the thing Henry VIII’s law had been written to stop: a royal relative marrying without the monarch’s consent.
The queen was furious with both mothers.
Margaret was sent back to the Tower, for at least the third time in her life, and held there for some months.
In 1575 the young couple had a daughter, Arbella Stuart, who would one day become a royal claimant in her own right.
The next year Charles died of an illness.
Of all Margaret’s children, not one was still alive.
She had a granddaughter in England and a grandson in Scotland who was being raised as a king, and she would never see him.
By the end, she had very little left.
She lived at Hackney, outside London, short of money and in debt.
In March 1578, after a short illness, Lady Margaret Douglas, Countess of Lennox, died.
She was sixty-two.
According to the usual accounts, Elizabeth paid for a grand funeral.
And she was buried in the most royal place in England.
—
## What was carved on the tomb of the woman Henry locked away?
Walk into Westminster Abbey today and go to the far east end, into the soaring chapel Henry VII built for himself.
In its south aisle, among the most royal tombs in the country, lies Margaret Douglas.
Her tomb is alabaster, painted and gilded.
Her own effigy lies on top, in the robes of a countess.
Around the sides kneel small carved figures of her children, the sons and daughters she outlived, lined up as if in prayer.
One of the kneeling figures is Darnley.
Above his head the sculptor placed a crown, because he had been, briefly and disastrously, king consort of Scotland.
The inscription sets out her royal connections one after another, a list of kings she was bound to by blood: her grandfather, her uncle, her cousin, her brother, her son, her grandson.
It reads like a family tree carved into stone.
She is not alone in that aisle.
Her great-grandmother, Lady Margaret Beaufort, the mother of Henry VII, lies there too.
And a few steps away is the tomb of another woman whose life was tangled up with hers: Mary, Queen of Scots, her son’s wife and her grandson’s mother, whose body was moved there years after her death.
The man who moved it there was her grandson.
—
## How did the girl in the Tower become the ancestor of kings?
On March 24, 1603, Elizabeth I died at Richmond Palace.
She had no children.
The Tudor line that Henry VIII had fought so hard to protect came to an end with her.
The man who rode south to take her throne was James VI of Scotland, the baby born while his grandmother was in the Tower.
He became James I of England.
His claim came through Henry VIII’s elder sister, Margaret Tudor, and it came through her twice.
Through his mother, Mary, Queen of Scots, he was Margaret Tudor’s great-grandson.
Through his father, Lord Darnley, he was her great-grandson as well, by way of Margaret Douglas.
From James came the Stuart kings, Charles I and Charles II and James II, and the queens Mary II and Anne.
From his daughter Elizabeth came Sophia of Hanover, and from Sophia came George I and every British monarch after him, Victoria, the Windsors, Elizabeth II, Charles III.
Every one of them is descended from Margaret Douglas.
In 1536 Henry VIII had a law passed to stop his niece’s love from reaching toward the throne.
He made it treason to marry her without his permission.
He let the man she chose die in his prison.
Within a lifetime, her grandson was sitting on Henry’s throne.
Within two lifetimes, her descendants were the only royal family Britain had.
—
## The book is still there
Go back to that winter evening in 1536, to the beeswax candles and the music and the slap of cards on the table.
A young woman sits in the corner with a book on her knee.
She is the king’s niece, and she has no right to choose her own husband.
She dips her pen and writes a line, and passes the book along, and waits for an answer.
The court where she sat is gone, and the young men and women who passed that book from hand to hand are long dead.
Thomas Howard never came out of the Tower.
But the book did.
It is in the British Library now, its pages brown with age, its poems still in the handwriting of the people who copied them.
Somewhere in it is a young man saying he cannot see his lovely mate.
Somewhere in it is a young woman answering that she has found the faithfullest lover that ever was born.
Nobody had asked the king.
In the end, it was her line that wore his crown.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Lady Margaret Douglas was born on October 8, 1515, at Harbottle Castle in Northumberland, the daughter of Margaret Tudor, Queen of Scots, and Archibald Douglas, sixth Earl of Angus.
She came to England after her father’s fall in 1528, lived in the household of Princess Mary, and served in the household of Anne Boleyn.
The Devonshire Manuscript (British Library, Add MS 17492) contains poems in several hands, including those of Margaret Douglas, Mary Shelton and Mary Howard, Duchess of Richmond.
The poems linked to Thomas Howard’s imprisonment and Margaret’s replies are attributed by most scholars, but who composed, copied or adapted each poem is still debated.
The phrase “faithfullest lover that ever was born” is quoted here from memory in modern spelling.
Her secret betrothal to Lord Thomas Howard, discovered in July 1536, led to their imprisonment in the Tower and to the Act of Attainder of July 1536, which also made it treason to marry the king’s close female relatives without his consent.
The wording of the act is paraphrased here.
The date of the betrothal, around Easter 1536, is approximate.
Her move to Syon Abbey and her letter to Thomas Cromwell renouncing Thomas Howard are documented; the letter is paraphrased, not quoted.
Thomas Howard died in the Tower on October 31, 1537, after an illness.
The burial at Thetford and the condition of “no pomp” follow the usual account.
The exact date of Margaret’s release is uncertain.
Her affair with Charles Howard in 1541, her removal from court and the warning delivered through Cranmer are recorded in council papers; the exact places she was sent are given differently by different historians.
Her marriage to the Earl of Lennox in 1544, Darnley’s marriage to Mary, Queen of Scots, in 1565 and her death in March 1578 are well documented; the exact dates of her later spells in the Tower, in 1565 to 1567 and after the Cavendish marriage of 1574, vary between accounts.
Her tomb, with the kneeling figures of her children, is in the south aisle of Henry VII’s Lady Chapel in Westminster Abbey.
The evening details (meal times, seating, music, gambling, sleeping arrangements) follow descriptions of Hampton Court around 1540.
The candlelit evening of early 1536 that opens this story is a reconstruction built from them, not a documented scene.