News

1540: What Was a Day Like for a Tudor Noblewoman at Court

The visitor came up from the river in the first days of March 1542, when the ground inside the Tower of London was still hard with frost.

He did not come with guards.

He came with a small box.

He was the king’s secretary, one of the two men in England who held Henry VIII’s private correspondence in their hands, and the errand he had been given was the kind of errand that made a man walk a little faster.

He was taken through the gates, past the green, up the stairs to the rooms where an old man had been held for almost two years.

The prisoner was an old man, somewhere in his late sixties or seventies; nobody had ever been quite sure of the year he was born.

He had once been tall, handsome and famous for his good temper.

Now he was thin, and he had spent twenty-two months waiting to be told the date of his death.

The secretary opened the box.

Inside was a diamond ring, sent by the king himself.

And the message that came with it was the one the old man had stopped allowing himself to hope for.

You are innocent.

The king knows it.

You are restored to his favor, and you will be set free.

The prisoner’s name was Arthur Plantagenet, Viscount Lisle.

He was Henry VIII’s uncle.

He had been arrested on suspicion of treason, kept in the Tower while three queens rose and fell, and investigated down to the last scrap of paper in his house.

Nothing had been found against him.

Now the king had sent him a diamond.

Within days, and by some accounts within hours, Arthur Plantagenet was dead.

To understand how a pardon could do what two years of prison had not, you have to understand who he was, why he had been locked up, and the household of women in Calais whose letters, seized as evidence against him, would become the most detailed record of daily life in the whole Tudor century.

And you have to understand what had happened, three weeks earlier, a few hundred yards from his window.

—

## The king’s uncle nobody talks about

Arthur Plantagenet was a royal bastard, and nobody ever pretended otherwise.

He was the son of King Edward IV, born some time in the 1460s or early 1470s, almost certainly in Calais, to a mother whose name has never been settled.

The most likely candidate is a woman named Elizabeth Wayte.

Edward IV had many mistresses and several children by them, and the court of Edward IV was not a place where illegitimate children were hidden.

Arthur was raised as a member of the extended royal family.

That made him something unusual.

He was half-brother to Elizabeth of York, Edward’s eldest daughter, the princess who became the wife of Henry VII and the mother of Henry VIII.

When the Tudors won the crown in 1485, Arthur did not lose everything the way many Yorkists did.

His half-sister was queen.

In 1501 he joined her household.

When she died in 1503, he moved into the household of her husband, Henry VII.

So when the young Henry VIII came to the throne in 1509, he found among his attendants a cheerful, athletic, middle-aged man who was his own mother’s brother.

Arthur became one of the new king’s companions.

He was an esquire of the king’s bodyguard.

He jousted.

He served at sea, and in 1514 commanded a ship called the Trinity Sovereign.

He rose to be vice-admiral of England.

He was at the Field of the Cloth of Gold in 1520, among the hundreds of English lords who glittered across the fields of northern France while Henry VIII and Francis I tried to outshine each other.

In 1523 he was made Viscount Lisle.

In 1524 he was made a knight of the Garter, the highest honor in the kingdom.

He was, by every account, likeable.

He was generous, good-humored, loyal, and not especially clever.

The historians who have read his letters describe him as honest and conscientious, but not particularly competent.

In the court of Henry VIII, those qualities could carry a man a very long way.

As long as nothing went wrong.

—

## The woman from Devon who ran everything

Arthur’s first wife was Elizabeth Grey, the widow of Edmund Dudley, a minister of Henry VII who had been sent to the block by the young Henry VIII as one of his first acts as king.

They had three daughters together.

That first marriage gave Arthur a stepson whose name would echo through the rest of the century.

Elizabeth Grey’s son by Edmund Dudley was a boy named John Dudley, about six years old when his father was put to death.

He grew up in Arthur’s household.

He would become one of the most powerful men in England: Duke of Northumberland, ruler of the country in all but name during the reign of the boy-king Edward VI, the man who tried to put Lady Jane Grey on the throne, and the father of Robert Dudley, the great favorite of Elizabeth I.

The good-natured royal bastard had raised the most ambitious politician of the age.

She died in 1529, and Arthur married again.

His second wife was Honor Grenville.

She came from an old and proud family of the West Country, and she was a widow too, with seven children from her first marriage to Sir John Basset.

She was about thirty-six when she married Arthur.

She was clever, energetic, devout, ambitious for her children, and almost certainly the stronger personality of the two.

In 1533, Arthur was appointed lord deputy of Calais.

Calais was the last piece of France still held by the English crown, a walled port town across the Channel with its own garrison, its own merchants and its own small, gossipy court.

The deputy was the king’s man there.

It was a position of honor and of endless trouble.

The town needed money that never came, soldiers who were never paid on time, and constant reports to London about the French, the Flemish, the religious radicals and the price of wheat.

To understand the Lisle household, it helps to picture the town.

Calais had been English since 1347, when Edward III starved it into surrender, and for almost two centuries it had been the gateway for England’s most valuable export, wool.

The merchants of the Staple, who controlled that trade, had their headquarters there.

The town was ringed by thick walls and guarded by a permanent garrison, with outlying forts at Guînes and Hammes and a strip of English-held countryside called the Pale.

English was spoken in the streets, alongside French and Flemish.

English coin was spent in the shops.

Ships crossed constantly to Dover, carrying wool and soldiers one way and letters and gossip the other.

For anyone at the English court, Calais was the first stop on any journey to the continent.

Ambassadors passed through it.

Brides passed through it; Anne of Cleves would spend more than two weeks there in December 1539, waiting for the weather to let her cross, and it was Lord and Lady Lisle who entertained her.

Kings passed through it on their way to war.

And the man in charge of it all was expected to know everything that happened there, report it promptly, and spend money he had not been given.

Lord Lisle wrote to London constantly.

So did his wife.

And Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, who received a great many of those letters, grew more and more impatient.

He rebuked Lisle in writing for bothering the king and council with trivial matters.

He hinted, not very gently, that the deputy was being run by Lady Lisle, and that people were laughing about it.

They probably were.

Honor Lisle did not intend to stop.

She had children to place.

—

## How do you get your daughter into the queen’s household?

For a noble family in the 1530s, the most valuable thing a daughter could have was a place in the household of the queen.

It meant being at the center of the court.

It meant being seen by the king, by the great lords, and by the sons of every family that mattered.

It meant the chance of a good marriage, gifts, influence, a voice in the right ear.

It also meant being watched every minute of the day.

A young woman in the queen’s service rose early, dressed with the help of a maid if she had one, and presented herself in the queen’s chambers.

Her clothes were armor and advertisement at once: a fine linen smock next to the skin, then a kirtle, then a gown, with sleeves pinned on separately so they could be changed, and a hood whose shape told everyone at court which way she was leaning.

In 1540, the English gable hood, angular and severe, was still the standard for respectable women.

The French hood, the softer crescent worn further back on the head and showing more hair, was fashionable, and slightly daring.

The young woman would attend the queen at mass, accompany her to dinner, sew with her, read with her, walk with her in the gardens, and play cards with her in the afternoons.

Gambling was everywhere at court, at every level, and young women lost money at it as easily as young men.

We know this partly because of Honor Lisle’s daughters.

Her daughter Anne Basset, sent as a girl to live in a noble household in France to learn manners and French, wrote home asking her mother for money to play at cards.

Lady Lisle sent her some coins, and told her to play only under her mistress’s eye, and that she would rather Anne spent her time practicing her music.

It is the kind of exchange a mother and daughter could have today.

We only know it happened because, years later, every letter in the Lisle household was taken away by the king’s men.

In 1537, Lady Lisle achieved what she had been working toward for years.

Queen Jane Seymour agreed to take one of her daughters into her household.

There were two Basset girls in the running, Anne and Katharine, and the queen chose Anne.

The letters show what happened next in loving, anxious detail.

Anne needed new clothes.

The queen did not like the French fashions the girl had grown up wearing.

She was to wear the English hood, with a bonnet and frontlet of velvet, and the right number of pearls, and her mother would have to pay for all of it.

There is something almost unbearably human about those letters, with their lists of fabrics and their worries about the price of velvet.

And there is another detail in the same year that brings the queen herself into the room.

That spring, Jane Seymour was pregnant with the son Henry VIII had waited for.

She developed a craving for quail.

Lady Lisle, in Calais, made sure that quail were sent across the Channel to the queen, and kept sending them.

Some historians have wondered whether the quail and the place for Anne were connected.

Of course they were.

That was how it worked.

Jane Seymour died that October, after the birth of Prince Edward.

Anne Basset survived the shock and kept her position at court.

She served Anne of Cleves when the king’s fourth bride arrived in January 1540.

She would serve Catherine Howard after her.

And she caught the king’s eye.

Henry gave her a horse and a saddle.

He took an interest in her well-being.

People began to talk.

For a mother like Honor Lisle, it was the best and the most dangerous news imaginable.

—

## A day in the queen’s rooms, 1540

It is worth stopping to imagine what one of those days actually looked like for a young woman like Anne Basset, in the first half of 1540, when the queen was Anne of Cleves.

The day began early, in the dark in winter, with the bells of the chapel.

The young woman slept in a shared room near the queen’s apartments, sometimes in the same bed as another maid of honor.

She washed her face and hands in a basin of cold water, rubbed her teeth with a linen cloth, and combed her hair, which she would hide again under her hood before anyone outside the room saw it.

A maid of her own, if her family could afford one, helped her into her layers: smock, petticoat, kirtle, gown, sleeves, partlet at the neck, and the hood.

Then she went to wait on the queen.

The morning was mass, attended in the queen’s closet, followed by the first meal of the day at around ten or eleven.

There was a lot of standing.

Maids of honor stood while the queen ate, carried things, held things, fetched things, and above all looked well.

The afternoons were for music, needlework and conversation.

A girl who could play the lute or the virginals was valuable; a girl who could sing was more valuable still.

They read aloud, played chess and cards, gambled modest sums and sometimes not so modest ones, and walked in the gardens when the weather allowed.

Supper came in the late afternoon, around four or five.

The evening might bring dancing, a masque, or simply more cards by candlelight.

And all day long, every word was weighed.

The new queen in 1540 spoke almost no English when she arrived from Germany in January.

The king had found her unattractive from their first meeting at Rochester, and by the spring everyone close to the court knew the marriage was in trouble.

The women around Anne of Cleves were in an impossible position.

They served a queen who might not be queen for long.

Some of them would later be asked to give evidence about what the queen had said to them about her wedding nights, and that evidence would help the king end the marriage.

In July 1540, the marriage was annulled.

Anne of Cleves accepted it calmly, took the title of the king’s sister, and kept her houses and her income.

The maids of honor simply moved on to the next queen.

It was that kind of court.

You went to bed in the service of one queen, and woke up, sometimes, in the service of another.

—

## The chaplain who ran to Rome

While the Lisle women were working their way into the queen’s chambers, the deputy’s household in Calais was hiding a problem.

His name was Gregory Botolph.

He was one of Lord Lisle’s chaplains, a clever, restless priest of the old faith.

In the spring of 1538, Botolph got permission to travel, and did not come straight back.

He went to Rome.

There, it was later alleged, he met Cardinal Reginald Pole.

Pole was the most hated Englishman in Europe as far as Henry VIII was concerned.

He was a cousin of the king, a member of the old royal family, and he had written a book calling Henry a robber and a murderer and an enemy of Christianity.

His mother, Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, was at that very moment under suspicion in England.

According to the story the investigators later put together, Botolph and Pole discussed a plan to betray Calais, letting the pope’s allies into the town through a gate at night.

How serious the plot really was is still argued about.

Some historians think it was little more than talk.

Some think it was invented, or at least inflated, by Thomas Cromwell, who had reasons of his own to want Lord Lisle weakened.

What is not in doubt is that Botolph was a member of Lisle’s household, that his associates in Calais were real men, and that when the government finally started to pull the thread, it led straight to the deputy’s door.

On August 4, 1540, two of the men accused alongside Botolph, a gentleman of Calais named Clement Philpot and a priest named Edmund Brindholme, were put to death in London as traitors.

Botolph himself was out of reach abroad.

Philpot had been a member of the deputy’s own household.

There was no evidence that Lisle knew anything.

In Henry VIII’s England, that was not always enough.

—

## The day they came for Lord Lisle

In the spring of 1540, Arthur was summoned to England.

He came across the Channel, and in April he took his place at the court and at the gatherings of the Order of the Garter.

He must have thought the summons was routine.

On May 19, 1540, he was arrested and taken to the Tower.

The date had a grim echo.

Four years earlier to the day, Anne Boleyn had died on the scaffold inside the same walls.

Arthur was not told the charges in detail.

In Calais, the king’s commissioners moved into his house.

They took everything: his accounts, his papers, his wife’s letters, his daughters’ letters, letters from agents and servants and friends, about three thousand documents in all.

They were looking for treason.

They found instead the most complete record of a sixteenth-century noble family that has survived anywhere in England.

We can only imagine the scene in Calais.

Strangers going through chests and cupboards.

Bundles of letters being tied with string and labeled.

Servants questioned one by one about who had visited, who had written, who had spoken with the chaplain before he left.

A household that had lived for seven years at the center of English Calais suddenly turned into a crime scene.

Lady Lisle and her daughters were placed under house arrest in Calais.

And something happened to Honor Lisle that her family never fully recovered from.

According to the martyrologist John Foxe, as soon as her husband was arrested she fell distraught of mind, and remained so for many years after.

Whatever the exact nature of her illness, the woman who had run a household, a town and half the gossip of the English court by letter now could not run anything at all.

Meanwhile, back in England, the man who had been needling her husband for years was about to fall himself.

On June 10, 1540, three weeks after Lisle’s arrest, Thomas Cromwell was arrested at a meeting of the council.

The badge of the Garter was torn from his neck.

He went to the Tower too.

He wrote letters to the king begging for mercy.

On July 28, 1540, he was put to death on Tower Hill, and on the same day the king married a teenage girl named Catherine Howard.

Lord Lisle was in the Tower when Cromwell died.

He stayed there.

—

## Two years inside the walls

For a man with Arthur’s blood, the Tower was not just a prison.

It was a family history.

His two young half-brothers, Edward V and Richard, Duke of York, the sons of his own father, had been lodged in the Tower in 1483 and never seen again.

His cousin Edward, Earl of Warwick, the last legitimate Plantagenet male, had spent most of his childhood and youth locked inside it, and in 1499 had been led out and put to death on Tower Hill.

Arthur would have known all of these stories, not as legends, but as things that had happened to people he had grown up around.

He was the son of a king of the house of York.

He had lived a long and comfortable life because he was a bastard, and bastards were not a threat.

Now, at the end of that life, the Tudors had put him in the place where the Plantagenets went to disappear.

It is worth pausing on what a high-ranking prisoner’s life in the Tower looked like, because it was not the dungeon of popular imagination.

A man like Arthur Plantagenet would have had rooms, not a cell.

He would have had a servant, furniture, books, and food bought with an allowance from his own money or the king’s.

He could walk in a small yard or along a stretch of wall when his keepers allowed it.

He could see, from his windows, the river, the boats, the comings and goings of the fortress.

The man responsible for him was the lieutenant of the Tower, Sir Edmund Walsingham, an old soldier who had held the post for twenty years and had seen more famous prisoners come and go than any man alive.

The lieutenant’s people brought the meals, kept the keys, and reported to the council on the prisoners’ health and behavior.

A prisoner of rank paid for his own comforts: his wood for the fire, his candles, his wine, his servant’s wages.

Two years of that was ruinous even for a viscount whose lands were not yet forfeit.

What he could not do was leave.

And he could not know.

Every morning in the Tower began without any certainty that it would not be the last.

In the summer of 1540, he heard about Cromwell.

In the spring of 1541, there was another prisoner within the walls who must have made every old Yorkist in the Tower shiver.

Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, sixty-seven years old, the mother of the cardinal Lisle’s chaplain had supposedly met in Rome, was being held in the Tower too.

She was a Plantagenet like him.

Her father was Edward IV’s brother; she and Arthur were first cousins.

On May 27, 1541, she was taken out early one morning and put to death on a low block in the Tower precincts, by an inexperienced headsman, in a scene so terrible that the imperial ambassador wrote about it in horror.

If Arthur heard about it, and almost certainly he did, he would have understood exactly what his blood was worth to the king.

Then came the winter of 1541.

In November, the news broke across the court that the young queen, Catherine Howard, was being accused of having lovers before and after her marriage.

Thomas Culpeper and Francis Dereham were put to death in December.

And in February 1542, the queen herself was brought by river to the Tower.

On the morning of February 13, 1542, Catherine Howard was led out onto the green inside the walls and put to death.

Immediately after her came Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford, the lady-in-waiting who had helped arrange her meetings.

Arthur Plantagenet was a few hundred yards away.

One of the women who had served that queen was his own stepdaughter.

Anne Basset had been in Catherine Howard’s household.

She had been at court through the whole nightmare of the investigation.

She had walked through the same rooms that were being searched, answered the same questions, kept the same silences.

She had survived it.

And in the weeks after, the court’s gossip turned to the king’s next wife.

Some of that gossip, reported by foreign ambassadors, mentioned her.

—

## The rumor about the king’s next wife

The first weeks of 1542 were a strange season at Henry VIII’s court.

The king was fifty and had just lost his fifth queen in the most humiliating way possible.

Parliament had passed an act declaring it treason for an unchaste woman to marry the king without confessing her past.

Wits at court joked that few ladies would be in a hurry to put themselves forward.

And yet the king was clearly looking.

He gave suppers and entertainments where the ladies of the court were seated near him.

Ambassadors watched who he spoke to, who he danced with, and whose health he asked after.

One of the names that came up, in the reports of the foreign diplomats, was Anne Basset.

She was young, she was pretty, and she had been at court long enough to know exactly how dangerous it was to be noticed.

There is no evidence that the king ever seriously proposed to her.

But the rumor alone would have been enough to change the way people looked at her family.

If the king’s eye had fallen on the stepdaughter, could the stepfather stay in prison?

Nobody can say for certain that Anne Basset’s position played any part in what happened next.

The timing is all we have.

—

## Why the king changed his mind

Nobody wrote down the exact moment Henry VIII decided Lord Lisle was innocent.

But the outline is clear.

The investigation had gone on for almost two years.

The papers from Calais had been read, sorted and examined by the king’s men.

Botolph’s associates had been tried and put to death.

And nothing connected Lisle to the plot except that the plotter had been his chaplain.

The legal machinery had also run its course.

Unlike Margaret Pole or Thomas Cromwell, Lisle had never been condemned by an act of attainder.

He was not under sentence.

He was simply being held, at the king’s pleasure, while the king made up his mind.

It meant that he could be released without anyone having to reverse anything.

It also meant that he could have been held forever.

In January 1542, a sign appeared.

Lisle’s collar of the Garter, the chain that marked him as one of the king’s chosen knights, was given back to him.

To a man in the Tower, it could only mean one thing.

The king was thinking about him, and the king was thinking kindly.

The weeks went by.

February brought the death of the queen on the green.

Then, at the very start of March, the decision came.

Perhaps Henry, in the bleak weeks after Catherine Howard’s death, wanted to see one familiar face from the old days released rather than ruined.

Perhaps the evidence had simply run out.

Perhaps, if the gossip about Anne Basset meant anything, the king did not want her stepfather in prison.

We do not know.

We know what he sent.

—

## The diamond ring

The account that has come down to us, repeated by later historians and genealogists, goes like this.

Early in March 1542, the king sent his principal secretary to the Tower to visit Lord Lisle.

The secretary carried a diamond ring from the king’s own hand, as a token.

And he carried a message: that the king was now satisfied of Lisle’s innocence, that he restored him to his liberty and to his favor, and that he would soon be free.

It is easy to imagine the scene that the old accounts compress into a single sentence.

The secretary would have been received with ceremony; even a prisoner kept the courtesies of rank.

He would have delivered the king’s greeting first, the formal words that came before any royal message.

Then the token.

Then the news.

Picture the room.

A chamber with stone walls and wooden shutters, the fire banked low, the light grey and thin through a narrow window.

A bed with curtains.

A table with whatever books and papers the prisoner had been allowed.

An old man rising from his chair, perhaps too quickly, to greet a visitor from court.

For twenty-two months, every visitor might have been the one who brought the date.

He had watched the fortress take Cromwell.

He had watched it take his cousin Margaret.

He had watched it take a queen and her lady three weeks before.

Now the visitor was smiling.

Now there was a box, and a ring in it, and the words he had been waiting to hear.

How do you hold in your hand the thing you have stopped letting yourself want?

What does a heart that has been braced for two years do when the weight is suddenly lifted?

Perhaps he laughed.

Perhaps he wept, the way old men weep when the strain of years goes out of them all at once.

Perhaps he asked for a pen, to write to his wife in Calais, the first letter in two years that would carry good news.

Perhaps he simply sat down again and could not speak.

We do not know.

What we know is that the night came, the way nights came in the Tower, with the bells and the changing of the guard and the river noise under the walls.

And at some point in the darkness, his heart, which had kept beating through the arrest, the questioning, the long months and the deaths of so many around him, gave out.

The chroniclers of the period had a simple answer.

They wrote that his joy was so great that it overcame him.

Some accounts say he died that same night.

Others say he lingered a day or two.

The date that the records give for his death is March 3, 1542.

In the morning, the servants would have found him.

Word would have gone to the lieutenant, and from the lieutenant to the council, and from the council to the king.

Somewhere in Whitehall or Greenwich, Henry VIII would have been told that the uncle he had just pardoned had not lived to enjoy it.

Nobody recorded what he said.

And somewhere across the Channel, a few days later, a letter would have reached a house in Calais where a woman who had been out of her mind with fear for two years was still under guard.

The king had forgiven her husband.

Her husband was dead.

It is hard to imagine a crueler pair of sentences to receive together.

He never walked out of the gate.

He never saw Calais again.

He never saw his wife, who was still under guard across the Channel, and who may not have been in a state to understand the news when it reached her.

He died inside the Tower, a free man on paper, with the king’s diamond somewhere in the room.

Later writers called it a heart attack.

The men of the sixteenth century called it an excess of joy.

Either way, a royal pardon had done in a single afternoon what nearly two years of royal suspicion had not.

A seventeenth-century genealogist, writing about the Plantagenets, summed it up in a line that has been quoted ever since.

Henry VIII’s mercy, he wrote, was as fatal as his judgments.

—

## The burial no one had planned

Arthur Plantagenet was buried in the Tower, in the little church of St. Peter ad Vincula.

There is no record of his funeral.

There would have been a priest and a few servants, perhaps an officer of the Tower, perhaps a herald if the king remembered to send one.

In the 1870s, when Queen Victoria ordered the chapel restored, workmen lifted the floor of the chancel and found jumbled bones from centuries of burials.

Some remains were identified, at least tentatively, as those of Anne Boleyn and Margaret Pole.

Nobody claimed to have found the king’s uncle.

He was buried among the people he had watched go before him.

Within those walls, under that floor, lay Anne Boleyn, his nephew’s second wife.

Lay Margaret Pole, his first cousin.

Lay Catherine Howard and Jane Boleyn, carried in three weeks earlier.

There was no state funeral.

There was no effigy.

There was no procession through London of the kind his half-sister Elizabeth of York had been given in 1503.

He had served her household as a young man.

Now he lay in the same chapel where her coffin had once rested on the night after her death, under five hundred candles.

It is very unlikely that anyone lit five hundred for him.

—

## What happened to the women in Calais

Lady Lisle was eventually released.

Her husband’s death made her a widow for the second time, and the investigation that had swallowed her letters had also swallowed much of her peace of mind.

She returned to England and lived quietly in the West Country, at Umberleigh in Devon, among her Basset children and grandchildren.

She lived until 1566, outliving Henry VIII by almost twenty years.

There is no evidence that she was ever again the force she had been in Calais.

Her sons made their way in the world.

James Basset, the youngest, entered the household of Bishop Stephen Gardiner and later served Queen Mary, a Catholic in the service of a Catholic queen, just as his mother would have wished.

Her eldest son, John Basset, had married one of Lord Lisle’s own daughters, Frances, so that the Plantagenet blood of the old royal bastard ran on into the Basset family of Devon.

Her daughters’ lives went on.

Anne Basset did not become the sixth wife of Henry VIII.

That role went the following year to Catherine Parr.

But Anne stayed at court and kept the king’s favor for the rest of his reign.

Many years later, in the reign of Queen Mary, she married a gentleman named Sir Walter Hungerford.

She died a few years after the wedding, still young.

The rumors about her and the king have never been proven, and there is no solid evidence that she was ever his mistress.

What is clear is that she was one of a small number of women who came through the whole of the 1530s and 1540s at Henry VIII’s court, served four of his queens, watched two of them destroyed, and survived it.

—

## The chest of letters

In the end, the most important thing to come out of the Lisle disaster was not a verdict.

It was a box of paper.

The three thousand or so letters taken from the deputy’s house in Calais in 1540 were never returned.

They were kept by the government as evidence, and then, as the case collapsed, simply kept.

They ended up in the state archives, where they still are, in the collection now held at the National Archives in London.

For centuries, historians dipped into them for details.

In the twentieth century, a scholar named Muriel St. Clare Byrne spent decades transcribing, translating and explaining them, and in 1981 she published them in six volumes as “The Lisle Letters.”

They are one of the great treasures of Tudor history.

They are where we learn about Purkoy.

Purkoy was a little dog that Lady Lisle sent as a gift to Queen Anne Boleyn in the early 1530s, at a time when a well-chosen present could open doors.

The queen adored it.

Then one day the dog fell from a window and was killed, and, according to a letter in the collection, nobody dared to tell the queen.

In the end, it was the king who broke the news to her.

They are where we learn about the price of velvet for a girl’s hood.

About the quail sent to a pregnant queen.

About a daughter in France asking for money for cards and being told to practice her music instead.

About a lord deputy being scolded by Cromwell for wasting the king’s time.

About the hopes of a mother who worked for years to put her daughters in the queen’s rooms.

They were seized to prove that a man was a traitor.

They proved instead that he was a husband, a stepfather, an anxious official, and a man who wrote home.

—

## The ring in the box

Go back to that room in the Tower in March 1542, to the secretary and the small box.

Henry VIII sent rings all the time.

Rings were how a Tudor king said things he did not want to put in writing.

A ring could be a promise, a pardon, a sign of favor, a warning.

When Thomas Cromwell was in the Tower in 1540, there was no ring.

When Catherine Howard was in the Tower in 1542, there was no ring.

When Margaret Pole was in the Tower, there was no ring.

Arthur Plantagenet was one of the very few prisoners of Henry VIII who ever received one.

He was the king’s mother’s brother.

He was the man who had ridden beside the young king in the tiltyard, the uncle at the Field of the Cloth of Gold.

The king remembered that, in the end.

He remembered it a few hours too late to matter.

There is a strange symmetry in it.

Henry VIII’s mother, Elizabeth of York, had died in the Tower in 1503, nine days after giving birth to a child she had hoped would secure the dynasty.

Thirty-nine years later, her half-brother died in the same fortress, a few hours or days after being told that he had been forgiven.

Both of them were Plantagenets of the house of York.

Both of them had served the Tudors loyally.

Both of them died inside the walls that had swallowed so many of their family.

And both of them were remembered, in the end, more by the paperwork they left behind than by any monument.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

Arthur Plantagenet’s parentage as an illegitimate son of Edward IV, his career at sea and at court, his creation as Viscount Lisle in 1523, his appointment to Calais in 1533, his arrest on May 19, 1540, and his death in the Tower on March 3, 1542, are all well documented.

There was no evidence connecting him to the plot organized around his former chaplain Gregory Botolph, and historians still disagree about how serious that plot was.

The story of the diamond ring and the message of release comes from later historical accounts, including the Victorian “Dictionary of National Biography,” which drew on older sources.

The exact wording of the king’s message is not recorded.

Accounts differ on whether he died the same night or a day or two later.

The sixteenth-century explanation that he died of joy, and the modern guess of a heart attack, are both attempts to explain a sudden death that nobody recorded in medical detail.

The identity of the secretary who brought the ring is not given in the sources used here.

The line about Henry VIII’s mercy being as fatal as his judgments comes from the genealogist Francis Sandford.

Lady Lisle’s breakdown is recorded by John Foxe, who wrote that she “fell distraught of mind” when her husband was arrested.

The details of Anne Basset’s place with Jane Seymour, the queen’s demands about her clothes, the quail sent to Jane Seymour, and Anne’s request for gambling money all come from the Lisle Letters as edited by Muriel St. Clare Byrne.

The rumors that Henry VIII might marry Anne Basset after Catherine Howard’s fall were reported by foreign diplomats; they were never more than rumors.

The description of daily life for a noblewoman at court in 1540 is drawn from what is known of the households of Henry VIII’s queens in general.

You Might Also Enjoy