1536: What Was Dinner Like for Henry VIII in His Private Chambers
On the 24th of January, 1536, King Henry VIII rode out in full armor to run at the tilt at Greenwich Palace, and he went down hard.
His horse fell with him.
Man and beast, both in steel, crashed into the ground together, and for a long, terrible stretch the king did not move.
One report written for the Emperor’s court said he lay for two hours without speaking, while other witnesses played it down.
Either way, it was a frightening moment for a kingdom whose king had no legitimate son.
Five days later, his wife, Queen Anne Boleyn, miscarried a child.
She is said to have blamed the shock of hearing about his fall.
Henry got up again.
He was forty-four years old, and he would live for another eleven years.
But the year that began with that fall would be one of the most violent of his whole reign, and by the end of it almost everything around him had changed.
His queen would be dead.
His closest companions would be dead.
His body would be on its way to becoming the huge, limping figure people picture when they hear his name.
And through every week of it, someone still had to cook the man his dinner.
Not a banquet, but the real thing: the private meal, served behind guarded doors, in the small rooms where hardly anyone was allowed to go.
This is what that meal looked like, and what it cost the people who served it.
—
## A year that would not stop
It helps to see how crowded 1536 was before we sit down at the table.
On the 7th of January, Catherine of Aragon, Henry’s first wife, died at Kimbolton Castle in Huntingdonshire.
He had put her aside years before to marry Anne Boleyn, and she had never stopped calling herself his true wife.
Her death removed the last great obstacle to Anne’s position, and the chronicler Edward Hall wrote that the king and queen dressed in yellow when the news came.
Some have read the yellow as a color of celebration, others as a color of mourning in Spain, and nobody can be sure what Henry meant by it.
Less than three weeks later came the fall at Greenwich.
On the 29th of January, the day Catherine was buried at Peterborough, Anne lost her baby.
Imperial reports said it would have been a boy.
From that moment, many historians believe, her enemies at court began to sense that she could be brought down.
By May, she was in the Tower of London.
By the end of that month, Henry had married again.
All of that happened while the royal kitchens went on lighting their fires every morning before dawn.
—
## Not a feast, but a private meal
The popular picture of Henry VIII at dinner is a man in a great hall, surrounded by hundreds of guests, throwing bones over his shoulder.
That is not what most of his meals were like.
Henry did hold enormous feasts, for ambassadors, for weddings, for Christmas and for the great days of the church year.
But on an ordinary day, the king usually did not eat in public at all.
He preferred to eat in his own rooms, alone or with a handful of people he had chosen.
To make that possible, his household ran one of the largest and most carefully controlled food operations in England.
And the best place to see it is the palace that has kept its Tudor kitchens almost intact: Hampton Court.
—
## The palace he took from a cardinal
Hampton Court began as the great house of Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, Henry’s chief minister through the 1510s and 1520s.
Wolsey rebuilt it on a scale that rivaled anything the king owned.
That was not a wise thing for a servant to do.
In 1528 Wolsey handed the palace over to Henry, and when the cardinal fell from favor in 1529, the king took it fully into his own hands.
He began to enlarge it at once.
Wolsey’s kitchens had already been big.
Henry’s became gigantic.
By the time he had finished, the kitchen complex had grown to around fifty-five rooms, covering roughly three thousand square meters, well over thirty thousand square feet.
Around two hundred people worked there.
They were organized into departments, each one under a sergeant, with yeomen, grooms and pages beneath him, and laborers and scullions doing the heaviest and dirtiest work at the bottom.
Between them they could put out something like six hundred meals at a sitting, twice a day, when the court was in residence.
—
## Hot, crowded and loud
Working in those kitchens was not pleasant.
The fires in the great roasting hearths were enormous, and in summer the heat must have been almost unbearable.
A Spanish visitor who saw them in 1554, in the reign of Henry’s daughter Mary I, called the kitchens veritable hells, such was the noise and bustle in them.
He added, with some amazement, that the English drank more beer than would fill a river back home in Spain.
The men at the bottom of the ladder had a reputation of their own.
The household rules issued in Henry’s name in 1526 complained that the scullions went about naked, or in clothes so filthy they were hardly better, and that they slept on the floor by the kitchen fires at night.
The rules ordered them to stop.
It is one of the odder facts of Tudor history: the King of England, in a formal document, had to tell his kitchen boys to put their clothes on.
The rooms themselves were laid out like a production line.
There was a flesh larder for raw meat.
There was a wet larder for fish.
There was a dry larder for grain, peas, beans and other dry stores.
There was a boiling house with huge cauldrons where joints of meat could be part-cooked before they went to the spits.
There was a pastry house, because the Tudors baked an astonishing number of pies.
There was a bakehouse, a spicery for the precious imported spices, a confectionery for sweet things, and a scullery where the pewter dishes were washed and stored.
And there was a narrow courtyard called Fish Court, running north to south between tall walls, so that little direct sun ever reached the storerooms along its sides.
The stone and the shade kept them cool.
It was, in a sense, a refrigerator made of architecture.
—
## A court that ate the countryside
The court did not stay at Hampton Court all year.
Henry moved between his palaces, at Greenwich, Whitehall, Windsor, Richmond, Eltham and others, and in summer he often went on progress through the countryside.
A king who was seen by his people was a king who was remembered, but there was a practical reason too.
A court of several hundred people, with all their servants and horses, stripped the surrounding district of food and fodder in a matter of weeks.
Moving on gave the land time to recover, and gave the empty palace time to be cleaned.
When the court was at Hampton Court, its main meals came twice a day.
Dinner, the main meal, was served late in the morning, around ten or eleven o’clock.
Supper came in the late afternoon, around four or five.
Everyone with a right to eat at court, from great lords down to humble grooms, had a fixed allowance, known as bouge of court, which set how much food, drink, firewood and candles they were entitled to.
Figures often quoted from the household records of Henry’s reign give the court’s yearly consumption as roughly 1,240 oxen, 8,200 sheep, 2,330 deer, 760 calves, 1,870 pigs and 53 wild boar.
The same accounts are said to show around six hundred thousand gallons of ale drunk in a year, and wine by the tens of thousands of gallons.
Nothing that came back from the tables was supposed to go to waste.
Leftovers were gathered up and given out as alms to the poor at the palace gates, under the eye of the king’s almoner.
—
## Upstairs, away from the hall
The great hall at Hampton Court, with its splendid hammerbeam roof, was where most of the court ate.
It could seat hundreds of people at long tables.
Henry rarely sat down among them.
On formal occasions he might dine in his Presence Chamber, a grand room that was half public and half private.
There he would sit alone at a high table under a canopy of state, the cloth of estate that marked the place of the king, while courtiers stood and watched.
But most days, and especially at supper, he ate further in.
He ate in his Privy Chamber.
That was a suite of private rooms deep inside the palace, behind a chain of guarded doors and outer chambers.
The Presence Chamber was crowded with people hoping to be noticed.
The Privy Chamber was where a few people actually were.
—
## The king’s own kitchen
Because the king ate privately and at times that suited him, his food could not simply come up from the great kitchens with everyone else’s.
It had its own kitchen.
The king’s privy kitchen was smaller, better equipped and more exclusive, and it lay close to his own lodgings so that the food could reach him quickly.
Anne Boleyn had been given a privy kitchen of her own in 1533, set beneath her rooms.
The king’s kitchens had their own senior staff.
Records name John Bricket as the king’s master cook, a man of real standing who received valuable grants from his master.
They also name a French cook, Pero Doux, who worked in the privy kitchen as a cook for the king’s mouth, which meant that he cooked the food the king himself would eat.
By one count from the household accounts, Pero was paid something over twenty pounds a year.
That was a very good wage for a cook in the 1530s.
The food that went up to the king was made to his own taste, by people he trusted.
—
## From the fire to the table
Cooking the meal was only half the work.
Getting it to the king was a ceremony of its own.
The dishes left the privy kitchen covered, to keep them hot and to keep them safe.
They were carried along passages and through courtyards to a staging point known as the serving place, where they were arranged and checked.
From there they were brought up through the outer rooms to the Privy Chamber, passing guarded doors on the way.
The food must not arrive cold.
It must not arrive uncovered.
And it must not be touched by anyone whose job did not give them the right to touch it.
Every step was set down in writing.
The rules for the king’s private rooms were laid out in the Eltham Ordinances, drawn up in January 1526 under Wolsey’s direction.
The ordinances named the staff of the Privy Chamber and said exactly what they could and could not do.
Six gentlemen of the Privy Chamber were to be in attendance by seven o’clock every morning, ready to dress the king.
Below them came two gentlemen ushers, four grooms, a barber and a page.
No one else was to lay hands on the king or his clothes unless he ordered it.
The same small group waited on him at table.
—
## Carving, pouring and watching
When Henry ate in his Privy Chamber, the table was laid with fine white linen.
The dishes were silver and gilt, or good pewter, and the wine came from the royal cellars, much of it shipped from Gascony, the Rhineland and the Mediterranean.
The rooms were hung with tapestries and warmed by fires, and when the light failed they were bright with candles.
The noise of the great hall was far away.
For the king, this was as close to privacy as life ever came.
His gentlemen did not simply stand around.
Each had a task.
One served as the carver, cutting the meat placed before the king.
Another was the cupbearer, who poured the wine and presented the cup.
Others brought and removed the dishes in their proper order.
A pen-and-ink drawing from the circle of Hans Holbein the Younger, now in the British Museum, is usually described as showing exactly this: the king seated at his table in a private room, with gentlemen attending him, one of them carving.
It is often said to be the only picture we have of Henry eating in private.
There was a saying in the Tudor court that sums up why these quiet moments mattered so much.
Getting into the Presence Chamber was a struggle that many people fought.
But real influence lay in getting into the Privy Chamber.
If you wanted to change the king’s mind, you needed to be in the room where he ate, rested and talked without an audience.
—
## The man with the key
The most important of all the men in those rooms carried an unlikely title.
He was the Groom of the Stool.
The name came from the job’s original duty, which was to attend the king when he used his close stool, his private toilet.
By Henry’s reign the post had grown into something much greater.
The Groom of the Stool was the head of the Privy Chamber.
He controlled who could come near the king in private.
He could carry a letter to the king’s hand, or keep it away.
He could choose the moment for a word in the king’s ear.
In 1536, the Groom of the Stool was Sir Henry Norris.
He had held the post since 1526, when he followed Sir William Compton into it, and he was one of the king’s oldest and closest friends.
He was rich, trusted and powerful, and he stood within arm’s reach of the king at his most unguarded moments, including at his private meals.
—
## Tasted first
Before any dish reached the king, it had to be made safe.
Poison was a real fear for every ruler in Europe, and Henry was no exception.
Food for the king was checked before it left the kitchen, and the custom of the assay, in which servants tasted the food and drink to prove it harmless, was part of royal dining across the period.
Only when a dish had passed these checks did it set off on its journey through the passages and outer rooms to the king’s table.
The most powerful man in England sat down to eat surrounded by men whose job included making sure the meal would not kill him.
—
## What was on the plate
So what did the king actually eat?
The household records include lists headed as the diet for the king’s majesty, setting out the dishes for his dinner and supper.
The first course alone was a meal in itself.
There was bread of two qualities, the everyday cheat bread and the fine white manchet.
There was ale, beer and wine.
There was meat for pottage, a thick, rich stew or broth.
There were chines of beef, venison in a sweet, spiced sauce, joints of veal, and, to round it off, custard or fritters.
And that was only the first course.
More followed.
What strikes a modern eater most is that the sweet things were not kept for the end.
Custards, tarts and fritters came to the table alongside the meats, so the king might move from roast beef to a sweet custard and back to a venison pie without any sense that he was doing anything odd.
On an ordinary day, a dozen or more dishes might be set before him, most of them meat.
Roast game was everywhere, served plain or baked into great raised pies.
There was lamb and mutton, chicken and capon, partridge, pheasant and quail, and a range of birds that would startle a diner today.
Swan was a delicacy.
So was peacock, sometimes served dressed again in its own feathers.
Conger eel appeared on special occasions, and porpoise, which the church counted as a fish, is recorded at royal tables.
Fish itself was a regular sight.
On Fridays, on other fast days and through the whole of Lent, the church forbade meat, and the kitchens turned to trout, carp, pike, salmon, herring and much else, fresh or salted, according to the season.
—
## Spices, sugar and subtleties
The ingredients told a story of their own.
In Tudor England, what was in your spice cupboard said exactly how rich and well connected you were.
The royal kitchens used pepper, cinnamon, ginger, cloves, nutmeg and saffron, brought across the known world from Asia and Africa through the great trading ports of Europe.
Sugar came in from the Mediterranean and the Atlantic islands.
Almonds, olive oil, dates, figs, raisins, oranges and lemons were shipped north from the warmer south.
Every guest at a royal table understood the message.
Food was politics.
Between courses at great feasts, the confectioners brought in subtleties: elaborate sculptures made of sugar and almond paste, shaped as castles, animals, ships or coats of arms.
They were made to be admired, and sometimes eaten, and their whole purpose was to show off.
No ambassador who had watched a sugar castle carried to the king’s table went home doubting that the English crown had money to spend.
—
## A worry about raw fruit
There is one Tudor habit that runs against the picture of endless excess.
Doctors of the time were suspicious of raw fruit and vegetables.
Medical thinking was built on the theory of the four humors, and raw produce was believed to be cold and moist and likely to upset the body’s balance.
Fruit eaten unripe or past its best, in an age without refrigeration, could and did make people ill.
Fruit was eaten, but usually cooked, baked or preserved in sugar, and the king’s table was dominated by roast and boiled meat, pastry, rich sauces, bread, ale and wine, with very little that was fresh and green.
It was a diet enormous in calories and badly out of balance, even by the standards of the time.
That mattered a great deal for a man whose body was about to change.
—
## The athlete and the fall
Before 1536, Henry had been one of the most famous sportsmen in Europe.
He was tall, a little over six feet by most estimates, broad in the shoulder, and proud of his strength.
He jousted, hunted, wrestled, played tennis and danced, and he loved to be seen doing all of it.
Armor made for him as a young man shows a trim figure, with a waist of around thirty-two inches.
Even in his forties, when most men had long given up the tiltyard, he kept riding in tournaments, because being a warrior king was part of who he believed he was.
The fall at Greenwich was not the beginning of his health problems.
He had suffered from an ulcer on his leg since the late 1520s.
But after 1536, his legs seem to have grown much worse.
Painful ulcers would trouble him for the rest of his life, breaking open, needing to be dressed and drained, and sometimes leaving him unable to walk.
Some historians have also wondered whether the fall injured his head, and whether that might help to explain the darkening of his temper in later years.
That idea is a theory, not a fact, and others think his character simply hardened with age, pain and power.
What is clear is that he could no longer burn off what he ate, yet the kitchens kept sending up the same food.
Modern writers have estimated that his daily meals could have added up to something like five thousand calories, though any figure like that is a guess built on menus, not on what he actually swallowed.
—
## A sweet tooth
Henry was fond of sweet things.
Fritters, custards, spiced tarts and jellies all appear on the royal tables, and one favorite of the age was a jelly made with hippocras, a spiced, sweetened wine.
Ale and beer were the ordinary drinks of everyone from the king downward, though popular figures for how much Henry himself drank, such as seventy pints a week, are guesses.
Tudor households also made warm, thick drinks such as ale-berry, a mixture of ale, bread, sugar and spices, the kind of thing that might be brought to a great man at night when he could not sleep.
Over the years that followed, the king’s waist grew.
Armor made for him around 1540, now in the Royal Armouries, shows a waist of a little over fifty inches.
By the end of his life he could barely walk, and he had to be carried and hoisted about his palaces.
Doctors today have suggested many possible causes for his decline, from type 2 diabetes to gout to other conditions, but nobody can diagnose a man who has been dead for nearly five hundred years.
—
## May 1536
The change in the king’s body was only half of the story of that year.
The other half happened in the very rooms where he ate.
On May Day, 1536, Henry watched a tournament at Greenwich.
He left suddenly, and on the ride back to Westminster he is said to have questioned Sir Henry Norris closely.
Norris was arrested.
He was accused of adultery with Queen Anne.
Other men from the king’s inner circle followed him into the Tower.
Sir Francis Weston, a young gentleman of the Privy Chamber.
William Brereton, a long-serving groom of the Privy Chamber.
Mark Smeaton, a musician who played for the king and queen, and the only one who confessed, very likely under pressure.
And George Boleyn, Lord Rochford, the queen’s own brother.
Most historians today believe the charges were false.
The fall of Anne Boleyn is still argued over, but the common view is that it was a political operation, driven by the king’s wish to be rid of her and helped along by Thomas Cromwell and by the faction around the Seymour family.
Norris denied everything.
It made no difference.
On the 17th of May, 1536, all five men were executed on Tower Hill.
Two days later, on the 19th of May, Anne Boleyn was executed inside the walls of the Tower of London.
Think about what that meant for the private dining room.
The man who had stood closest to the king while he ate, the head of the Privy Chamber, his old friend, was taken from those rooms and put to death.
So was a young gentleman who had served him there.
So was a groom who had waited on him there.
So was the musician who had played for him there.
The faces that had filled the king’s most private spaces were gone within a few weeks.
Norris’s place as Groom of the Stool went to Thomas Heneage, who stepped into what had just proved to be one of the most dangerous jobs in England.
—
## A new woman at the table
On the 20th of May, the day after Anne’s death, Henry was betrothed to Jane Seymour.
On the 30th of May, eleven days after the execution, they were married at Whitehall.
Jane was in her late twenties, from a Wiltshire gentry family, and had served as a lady-in-waiting to both Catherine of Aragon and Anne Boleyn.
She was proclaimed queen at the start of June.
The food was the same.
The ritual was the same.
The rooms were the same.
But the people in them had changed, and everyone who remained knew what the change had cost.
The woman who now sat at the king’s side was very different from the one before her.
Anne had been sharp, quick and outspoken, a queen who argued with her husband as something like an equal.
Jane took as her motto a phrase that has been quoted ever since: Bound to obey and serve.
Whether she was truly as meek as her reputation, or simply wise, nobody can now say.
There is one story that hints at how carefully she had to tread.
In the autumn of 1536, when rebellion broke out in the north in the rising known as the Pilgrimage of Grace, Jane is reported to have knelt before the king and begged him to restore the abbeys he was closing.
According to a report sent home by a French agent, Henry told her to get up, that he had often told her not to meddle in his affairs, and that she should remember what had happened to the queen before her.
It is secondhand, as most court gossip is.
But it is the kind of thing a woman in her position would never have forgotten.
—
## What the table might have sounded like
No one wrote down what was said at the king’s private supper on any ordinary evening in 1536.
The words below are imagined, put together from what the records do tell us about the rooms, the rules and the people in them.
Picture the Privy Chamber at Hampton Court, late on a summer afternoon, with the sun still in the windows and the candles already lit.
The king sits at his table with his bad leg propped on a cushioned stool, and the new queen comes to take the place beside him.
He looks around the room, at the gentlemen standing where other men stood only weeks before.
“Sit, Jane. There are new faces at my table,” he says.
She glances at the silent gentlemen, carving and pouring with their eyes on the dishes.
“They are very quiet, my lord,” she says.
“Quiet men live long at my table,” he answers.
She lowers her eyes and smooths the linen in front of her.
“Then I shall be very quiet indeed.”
Far below, in the heat of the privy kitchen, the master cook lifts the cover from a dish of custard and calls a yeoman to his side.
“Taste every dish. Nothing goes up to him untasted.”
And later, when the king’s mood darkens over some piece of news, and he turns his eyes on her, the new queen answers him in the only safe way she knows.
“I will not meddle, my lord. I have learned that.”
—
## Sugar plums and a pudding house
One tale, repeated in many modern books, says he once threw sugar plums at the people dining with him.
It may be true, but it is hard to trace it to any reliable record, and it is best taken as part of the legend.
Even as a playful gesture, it would not have felt light to the people at that table.
Everyone in the room was watching the king’s mood, all the time, and in 1536 a wrong word at dinner could end in the Tower.
Another story is better documented, though still not certain.
The Elizabethan historian John Stow, describing the streets of London around Aldgate, wrote of a fine house there that Henry VIII had granted to a widow named Mistress Cornwallis and her heirs.
It was commonly said, Stow wrote, that the king gave it to her as a reward for the excellent puddings she had made for him.
Stow was careful to call this what people said, not what he could prove.
But if it is true, it is a strange, almost tender detail.
The same king who had his wife and his closest servants put to death could also stop to thank the woman who made his puddings.
—
## The food kept coming
Through all of it, the machine below the royal apartments never stopped.
Clerks of the Board of Green Cloth, the office that ran the household accounts, checked every cartload of meat, fish, grain and firewood against their books, counting the cost at a table covered in green cloth.
The fires were lit before dawn, the spits turned, and the courtiers filed into the great hall twice a day.
And up in the Privy Chamber, the gentlemen carved and poured, and the covered dishes kept arriving.
From the outside, nothing had changed.
On the inside, everything had.
The king was heavier.
His legs were bound in linen dressings.
The faces around his table were new, and every one of them knew what had happened to the faces that had been there before.
—
## The meal and the man
Henry had always used food as a tool of power.
But in his private rooms, away from the audience and the trumpets, dinner was something more personal.
It was the daily routine of a man whose body was failing, whose temper was growing harder, whose circle of trusted companions was shrinking, and whose appetite, for food and for control, only seemed to grow.
Picture it as it stood in the summer of 1536.
A ritual of carving, pouring and tasting, carried out by gentlemen who knew that being close to the king was both their greatest advantage and their greatest danger.
A table loaded with venison and swan, spiced wine and custard.
And at the head of that table, a king who could no longer move as he once had, who had just had the people closest to him put to death, and who had already seated a third wife beside him in that room.
Jane Seymour would give him the son he wanted, Edward, at Hampton Court in October 1537.
She died less than two weeks later.
Henry lived on until January 1547, through three more marriages, growing heavier and more unpredictable, and still the covered dishes came up from the privy kitchen every day.