1536: What Was a Christmas Feast Like at Henry VIII’s Greenwich Palace?
The trumpets came first.
Then the torches.
Then, down the length of the hall at Greenwich, a procession of servants carried in a silver platter so heavy that two of them walked with their arms locked under it.
On it sat the head of a wild boar, roasted until the skin cracked, glazed until it shone, a bright apple jammed between its tusks.
Holly and ivy hung from every beam.
The smoke of a great log rolled along the ceiling.
Somewhere a choir began the old carol about the boar’s head, and the whole room, hundreds of people who had barely touched meat in four weeks, leaned toward the smell.
At the far end of the hall, under a canopy of cloth of gold, sat the King of England.
Henry VIII was forty-five that Christmas.
He was heavier than he had been, and a wound on his leg from a fall earlier in the year had not properly healed.
Beside him sat a new queen, married barely seven months.
Below them, the court ate and drank and laughed as if this had been an ordinary year.
And among the guests was a man who should not have been there at all.
He was a lawyer from Yorkshire, in his mid-thirties, blind in one eye.
A few weeks earlier, he had stood at the head of the largest armed rising England had seen in living memory, tens of thousands of men marching behind a banner of Christ’s wounds.
His followers had said openly that they wanted the king’s chief minister removed and punished.
Now he was eating the king’s food.
Wearing clothes the king had given him.
Listening to the king’s choir.
His name was Robert Aske.
And the question that hangs over that Christmas is simple.
Why would Henry VIII invite the man who had raised an army against him to his own Christmas table?
—
The answer is in the letters Henry wrote that winter, the promises he made with a smile, and one order he sent north just two months later, in words so cold that historians still quote them.
By the next summer, the man at the Christmas table would be taken back to York, the city he had once entered as a hero.
And there, outside a stone tower on a green mound that still stands today, Henry VIII would make him into a lesson.
To understand how it happened, you have to go back to the year that made that feast necessary.
Because the Christmas of 1536 was not a celebration.
It was a performance.
—
## The year that nearly broke a king
On January 7, 1536, Catherine of Aragon died at Kimbolton Castle, still calling herself Henry’s true wife.
She had been his queen for more than twenty years.
He had spent seven of them trying to get rid of her.
When the news reached court, the king and Anne Boleyn are reported to have dressed in yellow.
The chronicler Edward Hall wrote that Anne wore yellow for the mourning.
Others at court did not see mourning in it at all.
Rumors that Catherine had been poisoned spread almost before her body was cold.
Seventeen days later, on January 24, Henry rode in a joust at Greenwich.
He was forty-four, a big man in full armor on a big horse, and when he was thrown, the horse came down on top of him.
One report sent abroad claimed he lay without speaking for two hours.
Historians still argue over how serious the fall really was.
What is not in doubt is the wound it left on his leg, which would open and weep for the rest of his life.
Five days after that, Anne Boleyn miscarried.
The child, people whispered, had been a boy.
By the beginning of May, Anne was in the Tower of London, accused of adultery with five men, one of them her own brother.
On May 19, she knelt on a scaffold inside the Tower walls and was beheaded by a swordsman brought over from Calais.
The next day, Henry was formally betrothed to Jane Seymour.
On May 30, they were married.
A new Act of Parliament declared both of Henry’s daughters illegitimate.
Mary, who was twenty, had already lost the title of princess years before.
Elizabeth, not yet three, now lost hers too.
Then, in July, Henry’s only son, the illegitimate Henry Fitzroy, Duke of Richmond, died at seventeen, probably of a lung disease.
The king who had torn apart his country to get a male heir now had no son at all.
All through that year, something else had been happening, something that mattered more to ordinary people in the north than any queen.
Royal commissioners were riding from county to county, closing the smaller monasteries.
Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, had pushed through an act that dissolved every religious house worth less than two hundred pounds a year.
The buildings were stripped.
The lead came off the roofs.
The plate went to London.
Monks and nuns who had lived in the same place for decades were turned out with a small payment or sent to bigger houses.
In the south, where the king’s power was close, people grumbled.
In the north, where the abbeys were often the only hospital, school, inn and almshouse for miles, they did something else.
In early October 1536, they rose.
—
## How a one-eyed lawyer ended up leading forty thousand men
The trouble began in Lincolnshire.
On October 1, at the church of St. James in Louth, a crowd gathered around the parish treasures, convinced that the king’s men were coming to take them.
Within days, many thousands of men were on the march to Lincoln.
That rising collapsed in under two weeks.
The Duke of Suffolk was approaching with royal troops, and a stern message from the king told the crowds to go home or face the consequences.
But the spark had already jumped the Humber.
Robert Aske was on his way south to London when it happened.
He was a younger son of Sir Robert Aske of Aughton, a village near Selby in the East Riding of Yorkshire.
His family was old Yorkshire gentry.
His mother was a Clifford, from one of the great northern families.
Through her, as it happens, he was a distant cousin of Jane Seymour, the new queen.
He had trained as a lawyer at Gray’s Inn and practiced in London.
He had lost the sight of one eye.
People who met him remembered a clever, forceful man who could talk a crowd into silence and a nobleman into agreement.
He did not set out to lead a rebellion.
He later told the king’s interrogators that he had been caught up by the rebels and forced to swear their oath.
Whether that was the whole truth or not, within days he had stopped being a captive and become the captain.
By October 10, the men of the East Riding were calling him their chief.
On October 16, Aske led around nine thousand men into York.
There was no siege and no battle.
The city simply opened its gates.
He pinned a proclamation to the door of the Minster.
He ordered that the monks and nuns who had been turned out should be allowed back into their houses.
And he gave the rising a name.
He called it a pilgrimage.
The Pilgrimage of Grace for the Commonwealth.
Every man who joined swore an oath.
It began, “Ye shall not enter into this our Pilgrimage of Grace for the Commonwealth, but only for the love that ye do bear unto Almighty God.”
It went on to promise loyalty to the king and his children, and to call for the removal of “evil councillors,” which everyone understood meant Thomas Cromwell.
The marchers wore a badge showing the Five Wounds of Christ.
They carried the banner of St. Cuthbert from Durham.
Priests walked with them.
Some of the rebels’ leaders were lords and knights who had gone over to them, willingly or not.
Lord Darcy, an old soldier in his seventies, handed over Pontefract Castle, a royal fortress, almost without a fight.
By late October, the pilgrims gathered near Doncaster numbered somewhere between thirty and forty thousand men.
On the other side of the River Don, the Duke of Norfolk had perhaps eight thousand.
Many of his own men sympathized with the rebels.
Henry VIII was not used to being outnumbered by his own subjects.
He was furious.
His letters from London that autumn demanded punishment, threatened burning and slaughter, and complained that he had been badly served.
But Norfolk was standing on the actual riverbank, looking at the actual army, and he knew what would happen if it came to a battle.
So Norfolk did what the king’s servants often did.
He talked.
—
## The pardon that was really a stopwatch
The first truce came in late October, at Doncaster Bridge.
Rain had swollen the river, and neither side much wanted to cross it.
The pilgrims sent two of their leaders south with a list of grievances.
The king kept them waiting for weeks.
Then, in early December, the rebels met at Pontefract and drew up a full list of their demands.
They wanted the old religion protected.
They wanted the suppressed abbeys restored.
They wanted heretical bishops punished and Cromwell removed.
They wanted Princess Mary restored to her place.
And they wanted a Parliament held in the north, at York, where northern grievances would actually be heard.
On December 6, Aske and the other leaders met Norfolk again at Doncaster.
Norfolk had the king’s authority to offer something remarkable.
A free and general pardon for everyone who had taken part.
A Parliament to be held in the north.
The suppressed abbeys left alone until that Parliament met.
Henry would later suggest that Queen Jane might be crowned at York, a sign of royal favor the north had never been shown.
For Aske, it looked like victory.
In front of the assembled leaders, he knelt and asked that he no longer be called their captain.
Witnesses said he pulled off the badge of the Five Wounds and declared that from now on they would wear no badge but that of their sovereign lord the king.
Then he sent the army home.
That was the moment that mattered.
Not a battle.
Not a siege.
Thirty thousand men walking back to their farms and villages in the dead of winter, trusting the king’s word.
What Aske did not know was what Henry was writing in private.
Even as the pardon was being offered, the king’s letters show a man who regarded the whole affair as an insult that had to be punished.
He agreed to the pardon because his army could not win.
He did not agree to forget.
And a few days later, a message reached Aske in Yorkshire.
The king wanted to see him.
In person.
In London.
For Christmas.
Aske went.
—
## The winter the Thames turned to stone
That December was savagely cold.
England was in the long run of hard winters that historians now call the Little Ice Age, and the winter of 1536 was one of the worst anyone in London could remember.
The Thames froze.
The great river that carried most of the city’s traffic, from barges of firewood to the king’s own gilded boats, simply stopped.
Old London Bridge helped.
Its nineteen stone arches stood on wide footings that slowed the current to a crawl, and in a hard frost the slow water above the bridge locked solid.
The chronicler Edward Hall wrote that the Thames was “all frozen over.”
The court was moving downriver to Greenwich for Christmas.
Normally the king and queen would have gone by water, in the royal barge, with musicians playing.
That year, the water was ice.
So on December 22, Henry and Jane rode instead, on horseback, through the City of London to Greenwich, with the court strung out behind them.
Hall records that the king’s majesty rode through the city with his “beautiful spouse,” Queen Jane.
Some later retellings have them galloping across the frozen river itself, or gliding down it in a sleigh.
The chronicles say only that they went by land because the river could not be used.
It was striking enough.
Princess Mary was with them.
She had spent most of the year in disgrace, and only that summer had she finally signed the document admitting her mother’s marriage had been unlawful and her father the head of the Church.
It had nearly broken her.
Jane had worked hard to bring her back to court, and this Christmas Mary was given a place of honor again.
For anyone watching from the snowy streets, it was a picture of a royal family made whole.
A king, a gentle new queen, a daughter forgiven.
The palace they rode toward was Henry’s birthplace.
Greenwich stood on the riverbank east of London, a long brick palace of towers and galleries looking out over the water.
Henry had been born there in 1491.
He had married Catherine of Aragon there.
Anne Boleyn had given birth to Elizabeth there.
Only eight months earlier, Anne had been arrested there, after watching a May Day joust from the palace windows.
Now the court came back to the same rooms to celebrate Christmas.
And somewhere on the frozen roads from the north, Robert Aske was riding toward them.
He had been promised safe conduct.
He was a lawyer, and he knew exactly what a royal promise was worth on paper.
What he could not know was what it was worth in Henry’s mind.
He would find out at the dinner table.
—
## Inside the kitchens that fed a thousand mouths
To feed the court at Christmas, the king’s household needed something closer to a town than a kitchen.
Greenwich Palace is gone now, pulled down in the seventeenth century.
But the kitchens Henry built at Hampton Court still stand, and they show exactly how the king’s food was made in those years, because it was the same household that moved from palace to palace, carrying its cooks, its clerks and its rules along with it.
At Hampton Court, the kitchens covered some fifty-five rooms.
About two hundred people worked in them.
There were cooks and sergeants, grooms and pages, clerks who checked every cart, and at the very bottom the scullions and turnspits who did the hardest, hottest work of all.
Every delivery came in at a gate and was counted.
Every carcass, every barrel of salt fish, every sack of flour was written down.
Then it passed through a chain of specialized rooms.
There was a boiling house, where a great copper cauldron simmered stews and the thick broths the Tudors called pottage.
There were larders for meat, for fish, for dry goods.
There was a spicery, kept under lock and key, because pepper, cinnamon, ginger, cloves, nutmeg and saffron arrived from the other side of the world and cost a fortune.
There was a pastry house with enormous ovens, and a confectionery where sugar was boiled and molded.
And then there was the great kitchen itself.
Picture a room open almost to the roof, with six huge fireplaces along the walls.
In front of each one, iron spits turned slowly with whole joints of beef, mutton and pork.
Boys sat for hours turning the handles, faces scorched red, eyes streaming from the smoke.
Fat dripped and spat into the flames.
The heat was so fierce that in midwinter, with the Thames frozen outside, the people inside were drenched in sweat.
The work was brutal enough that it needed rules.
In 1526, a set of household regulations, known as the Eltham Ordinances, ordered that the scullions should no longer go about the kitchens naked or in rags, nor lie at night on the floor by the fires.
The lowest workers in the richest household in England had been sleeping on the hearthstones because it was the only warm place they had.
The drink was on the same scale.
Water was used mostly for cooking.
The court drank ale and beer, hundreds of thousands of gallons of it in a year, and wine shipped in from France and stored in cellars that were locked and guarded.
Nobody touched the king’s own wine without a warrant.
The household accounts of Henry’s court list numbers that seem impossible.
Over a year, more than a thousand oxen.
Thousands of sheep.
Hundreds of calves and deer.
Pigs, boars, geese, capons, rabbits, swans.
Christmas pushed every number higher.
And yet for four weeks before Christmas, almost none of it had been eaten.
The Church required everyone to observe Advent, the season of fasting before the Nativity.
No rich meat.
No feasting.
Fish, bread and plain fare.
By Christmas morning, the entire court, from the king to the kitchen boys, was hungry for flesh.
That was part of the point.
The fast made the feast hit harder.
On the afternoon of Christmas Day, the doors to the kitchens opened.
—
## What came out of the doors on Christmas Day
The boar’s head came first, because it was meant to.
Hunting wild boar was dangerous, a sport for the nobility, and a boar’s head on a platter said something about the court that killed it.
It was carried in with ceremony, to music and torchlight, and presented first at the high table.
A carol for it had been printed in London in 1521, its Latin refrain sung as the platter came in.
It is still sung in some colleges at Christmas today.
After it came wave after wave of food.
Roast beef and mutton.
Capons, geese, swans and peacocks, sometimes served dressed back in their own feathers so that the bird seemed to sit alive on the dish.
Venison from the royal parks.
Brawn, the spiced and pressed meat of the boar or pig, which everyone from the king to the lowest groom expected at Christmas.
Pies filled with minced meat, dried fruit and spices, far closer to a meat pie than to anything sold as a mince pie today.
Spices were everywhere.
Not because the Tudors could not taste their food, but because spice was money.
A dish loaded with ginger, cinnamon and saffron told every diner exactly how rich the host was.
Seating followed strict rules.
Food was served in “messes,” a set of dishes shared by a small group of diners.
The closer you sat to the king, the more dishes reached your table and the finer they were.
The further away you sat, the plainer it got.
It was bad manners to clear the table.
What was not eaten was gathered up and given away as alms to the poor who waited at the palace gates.
A great household that failed to feed the poor at Christmas would have been talked about for years.
Between courses came the subtleties.
These were sculptures of sugar and marzipan, molded and painted into castles, ships, animals, coats of arms, scenes from myth and scripture.
Some were meant to be admired.
Some were meant to make people laugh.
All of them said the same thing.
Only a king could afford to turn the most expensive substance in his kitchens into a joke.
The king himself usually ate apart, in his private rooms, with food prepared by his own privy kitchen.
On great feast days he might dine in public, under the canopy of state, served on bended knee, his food tasted before it reached him.
What he actually chose to eat from the dishes set before him, nobody wrote down.
The image of Henry tearing at a turkey leg is a modern invention.
Turkey had barely arrived in England.
For a Tudor king, the message was never how much he ate.
It was how much he could put on the table.
And that Christmas, Henry had a very particular guest to show it to.
—
## The king’s welcome, and the rebel’s answer
We do not know exactly what day Robert Aske arrived at court.
We know he was there over Christmas, and that he left in early January.
We also know how Henry treated him.
With warmth.
A Spanish account of Henry’s reign, written by a London merchant years later and not always reliable, gives a vivid version of their meeting.
In it, the king rises to greet the rebel and says, “Be you welcome, my good Aske,” and invites him to ask, before the council, whatever he wishes.
In the same account, Aske answers that the king lets himself be governed by a tyrant named Cromwell.
Whether those exact words were spoken, we cannot be sure.
The rest is better recorded.
Henry asked Aske to write him a full account of the rising: how it began, who led it, what the people wanted.
Aske did.
It survives, a long and careful document in which he defended the abbeys and the men who had marched for them.
He told the king plainly what the north had lost.
Elsewhere, in his later testimony, Aske described the abbeys as “one of the beauties of this realm.”
For him, they were not a matter of theology.
They were the guesthouses where travelers slept, the hands that fed the poor, the places where the gentry’s daughters were educated and the old were cared for.
Henry listened.
The king also gave him gifts.
One chronicle says Henry received him into favor and gave him apparel and rewards.
Some later retellings go further and describe the king’s present as a jacket of crimson silk or satin.
Either way, Aske was clothed at the king’s expense and sent away with royal favor.
He came out of those meetings believing he had won.
All around him, the Twelve Days of Christmas went on.
The officers of the revels had planned entertainment for every night between Christmas Day and the feast of the Epiphany on January 6.
There were masques, in which courtiers performed in costume and disguise, dancing and acting out allegories under the candlelight.
There were plays.
There were dances that went on long after midnight.
There were cards and dice, and Henry was a famous gambler who lost large sums without blinking.
And there was the Lord of Misrule.
He was a figure chosen to preside over the festive chaos, often a servant or a minor courtier with a gift for nonsense.
For the Twelve Days, he held mock authority over the court.
He issued absurd decrees, staged mock trials, and gave orders to his betters.
Servants could command their masters.
Jesters could mock the great.
The world, for a few days, was turned upside down.
Somewhere in those crowded rooms, a rebel captain was sitting at the king’s table.
Nobody needed a Lord of Misrule to see the world was upside down that year.
On New Year’s Day, the court exchanged gifts.
Every courtier gave the king a present, and the king gave one in return.
Each was recorded, and the value of each was noted.
A rich gift from the king meant favor.
A poor one was a warning.
On Twelfth Night, the last great feast, a cake was baked with a bean hidden inside.
Whoever found the bean became king for the night.
For one evening, the humblest guest could wear a paper crown.
Then midnight came, the Yule log was allowed to burn out, and Christmas was over.
Robert Aske rode north.
He went home with the king’s goodwill, the king’s gifts and the king’s promises.
A Parliament at York.
A coronation for the queen.
A fair hearing for the north.
Within a few weeks, every one of those promises would be gone.
—
## Ten days after Twelfth Night
On January 16, 1537, a Yorkshire gentleman named Sir Francis Bigod rose in arms.
Bigod did not trust the king’s pardon.
He believed, with some reason, that Henry meant to come north with an army as soon as the weather allowed and take his revenge.
He tried to seize Hull and Scarborough before that could happen.
The rising was small and badly planned.
It collapsed within days.
Aske had nothing to do with it.
He wrote to the commons urging them to stay at home and keep faith with the king’s pardon.
Other leaders of the Pilgrimage helped to round up Bigod’s men.
It did not matter.
To Henry, Bigod’s rising was the gift he had been waiting for.
A fresh rebellion meant the December pardon no longer protected anyone who could be tied to new trouble.
And almost anyone could be tied to new trouble, if the right questions were asked.
In February, the commons of Cumberland and Westmorland rose and attacked Carlisle.
They were scattered.
This time, Norfolk was not negotiating.
He declared martial law.
Around seventy men were hanged in the area of Carlisle alone, many of them in their own villages.
Then came the king’s letter.
In it, Henry ordered Norfolk to cause “dreadful execution” upon the people of every town and village that had offended, and to hang them on trees, in the places where they lived, so that they would be a “fearful spectacle” to anyone thinking of rebellion in the future.
Some historians add that, in another letter, he complained that bodies had been left whole when they should have been quartered.
These were the same weeks in which Queen Jane, at court, would have come to know she was pregnant.
In March, Aske received another summons from the king.
He went south again.
This time he did not come home.
By April 1537, he was a prisoner in the Tower of London.
So was Lord Darcy, the old soldier who had given up Pontefract Castle.
So was Sir Robert Constable, another of the northern leaders.
Lord Hussey, who had been caught up in the Lincolnshire rising, was arrested too.
They were questioned for weeks, separately, in long sessions that were written down.
Aske answered at length, as a lawyer would.
He did not deny what he had done in October.
He insisted that everything since the pardon had been loyal.
Darcy was older and angrier.
When he was brought before the council, he turned on Thomas Cromwell himself.
According to the record of that day, he told Cromwell that he was the very cause of all the rebellion and mischief, and warned him that even if he struck off every nobleman’s head in the realm, there would remain “one head” that would one day strike off his.
It was the kind of thing a man says when he knows he is already dead.
In May, the trials began at Westminster.
They were not long.
On May 16, 1537, Robert Aske was found guilty of high treason.
One account says his own brother sat on the jury that convicted him.
The sentence for treason was the worst the law allowed: to be hanged, cut down alive, disemboweled and quartered.
Henry had something else in mind for Robert Aske.
He would not be put to death in London, where the crowds had never seen him.
He would be sent home.
—
## The road back to York
The summer of 1537 was as warm as the winter had been cold.
On June 30, Lord Darcy was beheaded on Tower Hill.
Lord Hussey died at Lincoln.
Sir Robert Constable was taken north to Hull, the town Bigod had tried to seize, and there, over the Beverley Gate, he was hanged in chains above the road.
Robert Aske went north with him.
Picture the journey.
A man who had ridden south in December with safe conduct and a royal invitation now rode the same roads under guard, a prisoner of the Crown, with the summer dust on his face instead of snow.
The villages he passed had marched behind him eight months before.
Some of their men were already hanging from trees, as the king had ordered.
Nobody wrote down what Aske saw on that road, or what he felt.
He knew the law.
He knew what the sentence for treason was.
He must also have known why he was being taken to York rather than put to death in London.
York was where he had been greeted as a deliverer.
It was where he had pinned his proclamation to the Minster door.
It was where nine thousand men had walked in behind him without a shot being fired.
Henry wanted York to watch.
The Duke of Norfolk was in charge in the north.
On July 3, he wrote to Cromwell about the arrangements.
Aske was to suffer at York, Norfolk reported, on a Friday about a week away.
The place chosen was York Castle.
The castle stood at the edge of the city, where the River Foss joins the Ouse.
Its keep sat on top of a steep, round, man-made mound, a squat stone tower shaped like a four-leaved clover, built in the thirteenth century.
People called it the Clifford’s Tower, possibly after a Clifford hanged from it two centuries earlier.
Aske’s mother was a Clifford.
It was the highest point for some distance.
It could be seen from much of the city.
That was the reason it was chosen.
On or about July 12, 1537, Robert Aske was brought out to the foot of the mound.
There was no axe, no sword, no block.
That was the mercy reserved for lords like Darcy.
There was a rope, and there were iron chains, made by a smith to the measure of a man’s body.
The crowd that gathered would have included people who had marched with him.
Craftsmen and merchants of York, their wives, their apprentices.
Monks who had already lost their houses, now in plain clothes.
Soldiers sent to keep order, just in case.
Accounts of Tudor executions usually record that the condemned man spoke.
He asked forgiveness of God and the king, confessed that he had offended, and asked the people to pray for him.
That was what was expected, and almost everyone did it, whatever they believed.
Aske probably did too.
But no eyewitness account of his last words has come down to us.
What has come down is the method.
He was hanged in chains from the tower.
A chain was not a noose.
A body hanged in chains was fastened into an iron frame and left there, above the crowd, for days, weeks, sometimes much longer.
It was meant to be seen by everyone who came into the city.
Anyone who looked up would remember what happened to a man who led the north against its king.
How he died is one of the questions historians still argue over.
Some historians believe Aske was hanged with a rope until he was dead, and only then put into the chains.
A London chronicle written at the time says he was hanged in chains at York “till he died.”
Others take that to mean exactly what it seems to say, that he was left alive in the chains and that death came slowly, over hours or perhaps days, in full view of the city.
There is a story, repeated in later books, that Aske had asked one thing only: that he be dead before the chains were put on him.
And that he had been told it would be so.
Nobody can now say for certain what was promised, or whether the promise was kept.
What we know is what York saw.
A man raised high on the walls of the tower in iron, while the river traffic went past below and the market carts rolled in and out of the city.
The people who had once cheered him had to walk past him, and look, and keep walking.
No one in the crowd could have missed the message.
The pardon.
The safe conduct.
The Christmas welcome.
The king’s own gifts.
All of it had led here.
Seven months earlier, Robert Aske had sat in the king’s hall while the boar’s head was carried in to the sound of trumpets.
Now, in the July heat, he hung above York as a warning.
—
## What Henry bought with a Christmas dinner
When you look at that winter with hindsight, the invitation to court stops looking like a strange act of mercy and starts looking like what it was.
In December 1536, Henry VIII could not win a war in the north.
Norfolk had told him so.
The rebels outnumbered his troops several times over, and some of his own men sympathized with them.
If thirty thousand men had crossed the Don, nobody can say how far they might have gone.
So the king gave them something to go home with.
A pardon.
A Parliament.
A coronation.
And for their leader, a seat at his Christmas table, a hearing before the council, a fine set of clothes.
It worked.
The army went home.
The leaders believed they had won.
And once they were scattered across the snow, they could be picked off one by one.
Not one of the great promises was kept.
There was no Parliament at York.
The abbeys the pilgrims had fought for were not saved.
The smaller houses stayed closed.
Within three years, the great abbeys were gone as well.
Fountains, Rievaulx, Jervaulx, Whitby, St. Mary’s in York itself, all of them surrendered and stripped by 1540.
The ruins you can visit in Yorkshire today are what is left of them.
Queen Jane was never crowned, at York or anywhere else.
In October 1537, three months after Aske died, she gave Henry the son he had wanted for nearly thirty years.
Twelve days later, she was dead.
Henry did not come north himself until 1541, when he made a great progress to York with his fifth wife, Catherine Howard.
The gentlemen of Yorkshire were made to kneel before him and beg forgiveness for the rising of five years earlier.
Aske had been dead for four years.
And Darcy’s prophecy came true.
On July 28, 1540, Thomas Cromwell, the man the pilgrims had marched to remove, was beheaded on Tower Hill.
He had fallen out of favor after arranging Henry’s disastrous marriage to Anne of Cleves.
The king who had refused to give him up to rebels in 1536 gave him up to his enemies at court four years later.
On the same day, Henry married Catherine Howard.
The Duke of Norfolk, who had made the promises at Doncaster and then carried out the king’s revenge, lived long enough to be condemned to death himself at the end of Henry’s reign.
He was saved only because the king died first.
Most historians put the number of people put to death after the Pilgrimage of Grace and the risings that followed at around two hundred, among them lords, knights, abbots, monks, priests and many ordinary men whose names were never recorded.
Robert Aske is one of the few whose name survived.
—
## The tower, the plaque and the letters in the ceiling
Clifford’s Tower still stands on its mound in York.
It is a ruin now, roofless for centuries after a fire in 1684, cared for by English Heritage.
Tourists climb the steep steps to walk around the top of the walls and look out over the rooftops of the city.
On a clear day, you can see the towers of the Minster, where Aske once pinned his proclamation.
At the foot of the mound, set in the grass, there is a blue plaque.
It says that near this place, Robert Aske, leader of the Pilgrimage of Grace, died for his faith in 1537, “martyred by Henry VIII.”
It is a short sentence.
It took almost five hundred years to put it there.
Greenwich Palace, where he ate the king’s Christmas feast, is gone.
It was demolished in the late 1600s, and the grand buildings that now stand on the site, the old Royal Naval College, were built over it.
Visitors walk across lawns and courtyards where the Tudor palace once stood, mostly unaware of what lies under their feet.
Hampton Court, though, still stands, and its Tudor kitchens still fill with the smell of roasting meat at Christmas, when costumed cooks recreate the dishes of Henry’s court over open fires.
And in the Great Hall at Hampton Court, completed around the time that Anne Boleyn was queen, there is a detail that most visitors walk straight past.
Henry had the hall decorated with his initials entwined with Anne’s, an H and an A carved in the woodwork.
After her death, workmen were sent to remove them and put Jane’s in their place.
They were thorough, but not thorough enough.
If you know where to look, some of the H and A initials are still there, high in the carved woodwork.
They are a reminder of how that court worked.
A king could change his mind about anyone, a wife, a minister, a rebel he had welcomed at his table, and the evidence of his old favor would be scraped away.
But not always all of it.
—
## The jacket and the chains
Go back, one last time, to that hall at Greenwich in December 1536.
The trumpets.
The torches.
The boar’s head on its silver platter, the holly on the beams, the frozen river outside the windows.
The king at the high table, smiling down at his guests.
And a one-eyed lawyer from Yorkshire, wearing the clothes the king had given him, believing that he had saved the abbeys of the north.
He was not foolish.
He was a man who had been trained to believe that a promise made in writing, in the king’s name, meant something.
Everything he had done since October had been built on that belief.
He had sent thirty thousand men home on the strength of it.
The king had smiled at him across a Christmas table.
Seven months later, the people of York looked up at Clifford’s Tower and saw what that smile had been worth.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
**What is well documented.** The Pilgrimage of Grace broke out in October 1536 after the Lincolnshire rising and was led by Robert Aske, a Yorkshire lawyer of Gray’s Inn who was blind in one eye.
The rebels occupied York, gathered an army of roughly thirty to forty thousand near Doncaster, and dispersed in December 1536 after the Duke of Norfolk offered a general pardon and the promise of a Parliament in the north.
Aske was invited to court over Christmas 1536, met the king, and wrote him an account of the rising.
After Bigod’s rising in January 1537 and the attack on Carlisle in February, Henry ordered harsh reprisals.
Aske was arrested in the spring, convicted of treason at Westminster in May 1537, and hanged in chains at York Castle (Clifford’s Tower) in July 1537, usually dated July 12.
Lord Darcy was beheaded on Tower Hill on June 30, 1537, and Sir Robert Constable was hanged in chains at Hull.
**Where the court spent Christmas.** The court celebrated Christmas 1536 at Greenwich, not Hampton Court.
Edward Hall’s chronicle records that the Thames was frozen that December and that the king and Queen Jane rode through the City of London to Greenwich.
The popular story that they crossed the frozen river itself, on horseback or by sleigh, is not what the chronicle says.
The kitchen details in this article come from the surviving Tudor kitchens at Hampton Court, which served the same royal household.
**The king’s gift.** A chronicle records that Henry gave Aske apparel and rewards.
The specific detail of a crimson jacket appears in later histories and retellings, and we have not been able to check it against an original document.
**The king’s words.** The greeting “Be you welcome, my good Aske” and Aske’s reply about Cromwell come from a Spanish chronicle of Henry’s reign, written years later and known for errors.
Treat them as a story told at the time, not as a transcript.
Henry’s orders for “dreadful execution” and a “fearful spectacle” come from his letter to Norfolk in early 1537.
Darcy’s warning to Cromwell comes from the record of his examination; it is quoted in slightly different wording in different editions.
**How Aske died.** No eyewitness account of his last hours has survived.
A contemporary London chronicle says he was hanged in chains “till he died,” and historians disagree over whether he was dead before he was put in chains.
The story that he asked to be dead first is repeated in later books but cannot be confirmed.
**The feast.** No menu survives for Christmas 1536 specifically.
The dishes, customs and entertainments described here are drawn from the household records of Henry’s court and from what is known of Tudor Christmas in great households.
Several popular claims about Tudor Christmas are later inventions: carols such as “Good King Wenceslas” and “The First Nowell” were written or first printed centuries later, and the great Abraham tapestries now at Hampton Court were woven in the 1540s, after this Christmas.
The carved “eavesdroppers” in the Great Hall roof and their supposed warning against gossip belong to tradition rather than to any recorded instruction.
**Other details.** The report that Henry lay unconscious for two hours after his fall in January 1536 comes from a single letter and is disputed.
Queen Jane conceived her son within a few weeks of this Christmas; Edward was born on October 12, 1537.
The figure of about two hundred people put to death after the risings is the most commonly cited estimate; some historians count more.