News

Why Henry VIII Didn’t Divorce Her but Killed Her?

The king was so desperate for a son that he broke from the Catholic Church divorced his decades long wife and married another woman but when his second wife fails to give him a son he doesn’t just divorce her he cuts off her head?

Why did Henry VIII execute Anne Boleyn but never dared to harm Catherine of Aragon both women refused to give him what he wanted both stood in his way both defied him publicly yet one lost her head on a scaffold while the other died peacefully in her bed still calling herself the true Queen of England.

Was it love with the Spanish princess?

Was it fear or?

Was it something far more calculated.

The answer reveals a dark truth about power pride and the deadly game of Tudor politics May 19th, 1536, Tower Green. a woman climbs the scaffold she wears a fine gown trimmed with ermine her hair is pinned beneath a white cap the crowd watches in silence this is Anne Boleyn Queen of England and she’s about to die she speaks calmly.

She praises the king’s goodness she praises his mercy she asks everyone to pray for her then she removes her gown she kneels an expensive French executioner swings his sword one clean blow her head falls but this is no ordinary execution this is the execution of the Queen of England accused of adultery of lying with five different men one of them was her own brother charged with plotting to kill the king this was the woman Henry VIII had waited seven years to marry the woman he’d abandoned his first wife for.

The woman he’d revolutionized England’s church for three years of marriage that’s all it took then her head was off.

But here’s what makes this story even stranger just four months earlier another queen had died Catherine of Aragon Henry’s first wife the woman Anne had replaced Catherine had also refused to give Henry what he wanted she wouldn’t accept the divorce she wouldn’t step aside quietly she fought him for six years she defied him publicly she challenged his authority at every turn yet Catherine died peacefully in her castle.

She died alone yes separated from her daughter but she died in her bed she died still claiming her title still calling herself the true Queen of England two Queens two very different endings?

What made the difference between the scaffold and a peaceful death.

To understand this mystery we need to meet both women we need to see what protected one and condemned the other.

Let’s start with the woman who couldn’t be touched Catherine of Aragon wasn’t just anyone she was born a Spanish infanta her mother was Isabella of Castile.

Her father was Ferdinand of Aragon these weren’t minor nobles these were the rulers who had united Spain the ones who’d funded Christopher Columbus the ones who’d driven the Moors out of Granada Catherine grew up in palaces she learned six languages she studied philosophy and theology she was trained from birth to be a queen.

But here’s what really mattered her family connections her nephew was Charles the 5th and Charles the 5th was the most powerful man in Europe maybe the most powerful man in the world at that time.

He was the Holy Roman Emperor he ruled Spain Germany Austria the Netherlands parts of Italy and vast territories in the New World if Henry harmed Catherine Charles could invade England this wasn’t an empty threat everyone knew it Henry knew it his advisors knew it even Catherine knew it.

In 1534 something happened that showed just how untouchable she was the Bishop of Durham came to see her Henry had just declared himself head of the church of England he wanted Catherine to acknowledge this to accept his authority over the popes.

She refused the bishop lost his temper he threatened to hang her Catherine didn’t flinch she looked him straight in the eye?

Who will be the hangman? she asked if you have permission to execute this penalty on me I am ready the bishop said nothing he left because she was right they wouldn’t dare but Catherine’s Protection went deeper than just her nephew’s armies the English people loved her this is remarkable when you think about it the English were famous for hating foreigners they mocked French accents they distrusted Spanish merchants.

They resented foreign influence at court but they adored their Spanish queen for 24 years Catherine had been the perfect queen she was pious she prayed for hours every day she wore simple clothes she gave to the poor she was intelligent and dignified she never caused scandals she never complained when Henry went to war in France in 1513 he left Catherine in charge as regent the Scots invaded while he was gone Catherine didn’t panic she organized the defense of the realm she sent money artillery and troops north.

Her forces led by the Earl of Surrey crushed the Scots at the battle of Flodden the Scottish king himself died on the battlefield Catherine sent Henry the dead king’s blood stained coat as a trophy the people saw her as a living saint so when Henry tried to divorce her the reaction was explosive women guarded her palace with pitchforks they blocked the commissioners Henry sent to force her out in the streets crowds shouted death to your enemies when Catherine passed by one man was beaten nearly to death by his female parishioners.

Just for praying for Queen Anne instead of Queen Catherine Henry knew what killing Catherine would mean riots rebellions maybe even civil war and that’s before Charles V got involved Charles V himself called Henry’s divorce attempt the lust of a foolish man he told the pope that a good and blameless queen shouldn’t suffer because of Henry’s desires if Catherine died violently she’d become a martyr churches would make her a saint paintings would show her as a holy victim her story would inspire rebellions for generations.

Henry couldn’t risk that but Catherine had one more shield one more layer of Protection and this one was brilliant she used Henry’s own argument against him Henry claimed their marriage had never been valid he said that marrying his brother’s widow violated God’s law he insisted Catherine had never really been his wife therefore their daughter Mary was illegitimate Catherine listened to all this then she made her move I am no English woman but a Spaniard born she declared think about what this meant if their marriage wasn’t valid.

As Henry claimed then she wasn’t his wife if she wasn’t his wife she wasn’t his subject if she wasn’t his subject English law didn’t apply to her she was a Spanish princess living in England a foreigner and foreigners could appeal to Rome they could go over the king’s head to the pope which is exactly what Catherine did.

In 1529 Henry established a court in England to adjudicate the marriage Cardinal Wolsey would preside the outcome was supposed to be certain Henry would get his annulment Catherine refused to attend.

She said I will not be judged by you I appeal to Rome Henry’s lawyers were furious but?

What could they do? by Henry’s own logic she wasn’t bound by English law this made Henry so furious that.

In 1534 with Thomas Cromwell’s help he passed new laws no one could appeal to Rome anymore all religious authority belonged to the king Catherine ignored him she said I’m not the king’s subject these laws don’t apply to me and she kept writing to the pope it was legal genius she’d turned Henry’s divorce argument into a shield.

She’d made herself legally untouchable so Henry had a problem he couldn’t execute her without starting a war he couldn’t legally force her to obey he couldn’t even make her stop calling herself Queen all he could do was isolate her move her to smaller and smaller castles keep her away from her daughter hope she’d die naturally and eventually she did but?

What about the woman who had none of these protections Anne Boleyn came from a very different world she was born in England to a minor noble family her father was Thomas Boleyn.

A diplomat ambitious clever but not powerful not by royal standards Anne had no royal blood she had no foreign army backing her she had no emperor for an uncle everything she became she became because of Henry and what Henry gave Henry could take away Anne spent her teenage years in France she served in the French court she learned French manners French fashion French wit when she returned to England in her early 20s she stood out she was sophisticated sharp different Henry noticed her Anne Boleyn was serving as a lady in waiting.

To Queen Catherine when the king’s eyes fell on her at first he wanted her as a mistress just as he had taken her sister Mary Boleyn before her but Anne had seen what her sister endured praised used and forgotten she wanted no part in that so she left the court and returned to her family home at Hever Castle hoping the king’s interest would fade but it didn’t Henry began to write her letters love letters filled with passion devotion and promises he sent her gifts in Tudor England saying no to a king was dangerous.

Yet Anne stood her ground she refused to be his mistress if he truly wanted her he would have to make her his wife it was a bold move part resistance part survival but Henry didn’t take it as rejection he took it as a challenge his desire turned to obsession if he couldn’t have her as a mistress he would have her as his queen seven years that’s how long Anne made him wait seven years of negotiations with the pope seven years of arguments with advisors seven years of turning England upside down finally in 1533.

They married that same year she was crowned Queen of England she was pregnant surely this child would be the son Henry desperately wanted the baby was a girl Elizabeth Henry tried to hide his disappointment there would be other children other chances but Anne’s position was always precarious because everything about her situation was different from Catherine’s she had no powerful family to protect her the Boleyns had risen because of Anne if Anne fell they’d fall with her they couldn’t save her because they only existed.

Through her connection to Henry and then there was her reputation while Catherine was seen as a saint Anne was seen as well something very different most people saw her as the woman who’d destroyed a good marriage the woman who’d seduced the king away from his faithful wife the woman who’d caused Catherine’s suffering they called her the king’s whore they called her the scandal of Christendom even in Rome the pope’s court spoke of her with disgust calling her a woman sent to lead England into sin foreign Queens refused to meet her.

When Henry and Anne traveled to Calais to meet the French court King Francis welcomed them but his wife Queen Eleanor refused to receive Anne so did his sister Queen Marguerite of Navarre Anne was left waiting in Calais humiliated while Henry met with the French court alone in England the hatred was even worse when Anne appeared in public crowds turned their backs women shouted curses from the streets some even threatened to drag her down people muttered prayers for Queen Catherine and called Anne the usurper queen.

Everywhere she went she could feel the eyes of a nation that wanted her gone nobody loved Anne enough to fight for her and when the accusations came adultery incest treason people were ready to believe them of course she did it what else would you expect from the king’s whore even people who hated her doubted the charges but they chose not to protest the Spanish ambassador Chapuys had hated Anne for years he’d called her every terrible name he could think of but even he admitted later that the evidence against her seemed weak.

That most of the men accused with her probably hadn’t confessed to anything that only Mark Smeaton the musician had admitted to sleeping with her yet Chapuys didn’t speak up for her why would he she’d been his enemy Catherine’s tormentor let her face her fate so when Henry turned on Anne she had nowhere to run she was English undeniably completely English no foreign citizenship to claim no legal loopholes to exploit no court in Rome to appeal to English law applied to her fully and English law said that adultery by a queen.

Was treason treason meant death Anne was trapped in England trapped by her nationality trapped by her reputation trapped by her complete dependence on Henry when Anne died no foreign power stepped in France and the empire didn’t mourn her they smirked from afar pleased to see England weaken itself by executing its own queen but?

Why did Henry choose execution?

Why not just end the marriage quietly he could have divorced her exiled her or even locked her away like King Henry the second once did to his defiant wife.

Eleanor of Aquitaine so why kill her that’s where the story turns truly dark Henry had options with Anne easy options he could have annulled the marriage the grounds were there he’d slept with Anne’s sister Mary before marrying Anne by church law that was incest it made the marriage invalid or he could have used the precontract Anne had been informally engaged to Henry Percy years earlier that engagement had never been properly dissolved another ground for annulment or he could have sent her to a convent made her a nun the marriage would be over.

Elizabeth could remain legitimate in fact when Anne was imprisoned in the tower she begged for exactly this she said she’d go to a convent she’d give up everything just let her live Henry refused it had to be an execution it had to be adultery and treason it had to be the ultimate punishment?

Why?

Let’s look at the reasons the cold calculations behind a queen’s death.

The first option annulment was the one Henry couldn’t stomach if he admitted the marriage was invalid because he’d slept with Anne’s sister Mary Boleyn it would destroy his own image.

He’d look like the sinner not the victim and Henry couldn’t bear that he wanted to appear innocent misled by a deceitful woman in Henry’s mind if Anne was guilty then he was pure again the devoted king who’d been tricked by lust and witchcraft the victim not the villain this is the main reason for Anne’s fast trial he wanted her gone and he wanted it fast in favor of Henry Anne already had the reputation of the king’s whore people already thought the worst of her when Henry accused her of sleeping with five men.

Including her own brother many people thought well what did you expect Henry needed people to believe a story and this story is the only story that will work with Anne.

The second main reason pride this is the key this is what explains the execution instead of annulment Henry had fought for seven years to marry Anne he’d defied the pope he’d broken with Rome he’d made himself a whole new church structure just to make Anne his wife he’d made himself a laughing stock across Europe ambassadors had mocked him foreign courts had condemned him.

And he’d done all this while claiming he was right and god wanted him to marry Anne that his first marriage to Catherine had been invalid because it violated divine law if Henry now annulled his marriage to Anne?

What would that prove? that he’d been wrong all along that he’d thrown away his first marriage alienated the pope and revolutionized England’s church for nothing for a woman he shouldn’t have married in the first place his ego couldn’t accept that so instead he changed the story he wasn’t wrong to marry Anne.

She’d deceived him she’d seduced him she’d betrayed him she was the villain not him I was bewitched he told one courtier some people have taken this to mean he thought she’d used witchcraft but it probably just meant he’d been obsessed with her fooled by her either way the message was clear this wasn’t his fault it was hers with Catherine his ego demanded that she recognize the annulment that she admit their marriage had been wrong but he couldn’t force her so he accepted the stalemate she’d stay queen in her own mind fine.

With Anne his ego demanded that she be guilty that she be the betrayer that he is the victim and since he could force that narrative he did.

And the last reason love and anger Catherine never challenged Henry except on the divorce matter she has always been submissive she’d accepted his authority without question she’d been a good wife for 20 years she’d supported him she’d advised him she’d loved him genuinely yes he was frustrated with her angry that she wouldn’t agree to the divorce but it wasn’t personal hatred.

It was political frustration Anne was different Henry had promised Anne the world and Anne had promised him sons she’d said she’d give him the male heir he desperately wanted she’d been so confident and she’d failed three pregnancies one living daughter one miscarriage one stillborn son to Henry this felt like betrayal she’d lied to him she’d promised what she couldn’t deliver and Anne unlike Catherine had been sharp tongued she’d argued with him she’d been jealous when he looked at other women she’d been proud and difficult.

Henry felt personally betrayed by Anne in a way he never felt betrayed by Catherine after Anne’s execution Henry destroyed everything connected to her every portrait every letter every gift he erased her from the palace he commanded that no one speak her name he’d done nothing like that with Catherine he’d kept her things he was visibly affected when she died according to Ambassador Eustache Chapuys Henry showed some sorrow the rage he felt toward Anne was personal visceral and when rage combined with opportunity.

It meant death but there’s one more piece to this puzzle one more thing that sealed Ann’s fate.

By 1536 Anne Boleyn wasn’t just an unloved wife she was a political problem her last miscarriage had been a boy the son Henry had prayed for when he died unborn the court began whispering that god had cursed the king even worse Anne had made enemies everywhere nobles priests even her own allies the Boleyn family once untouchable was losing its grip on power in their place rose the Seymours led by the quiet and obedient Jane Seymour.

A woman who represented everything Anne wasn’t while Anne argued with ministers and mocked Henry in public Jane bowed curtsied and waited the contrast humiliated Henry it reminded him that the fiery queen who once thrilled him now challenged him.

Then came Thomas Cromwell once Anne’s ally in reform he’d turned against her they clashed over church wealth and foreign alliances Anne wanted friendship with France Cromwell wanted peace with the emperor Catherine’s nephew to keep his own power Cromwell needed Anne gone.

And he knew exactly how to do it he built a case so shocking that no one dared question it adultery incest treason five lovers including her own brother impossible charges but perfectly believable to a court that already despised her we’ve seen all the pieces now let’s put them together Henry had loved Anne once obsessively but he loved Catherine too in a different way for longer but it wasn’t about love love didn’t kill Anne and lack of love didn’t save Catherine it wasn’t about Defiance both women defied Henry.

Catherine refused the divorce for six years Anne well Anne didn’t even commit the crimes she was accused of she’d argued with Henry she’d been difficult she’d criticized his affairs with other women but she was not unfaithful both women stood up to him only one died for it the difference was power Protection possibility.

And here’s the final truth the darkest one Henry could kill Anne without consequences but Catherine was his equal in royalty a Spanish princess daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella the most powerful monarchs in Europe.

She wasn’t some court woman he could discard she was a queen born of kings Catherine knew this she used every advantage she had that’s why she dared the Bishop of Durham to execute her she knew they wouldn’t she knew she was untouchable Anne never had that chance she probably knew it too in the end when they came to arrest her when they brought her to the tower when they accused her of impossible crimes she knew that everything she depended on was Henry’s favor when that favor vanished she was defenseless but history has been kinder to Anne than her own time was.

We remember her now as Elizabeth the First’s mother as the woman whose daughter became England’s greatest queen we questioned whether the charges against her were true most historians think they weren’t but at the time at the time she was just a woman who’d risen too high and fallen too fast a cautionary tale a scandal to be forgotten Catherine meanwhile is remembered as Henry’s true wife the one who never surrendered the one whose daughter eventually wore the crown she lost the battle but won the war.

Two women two fates.

One king the difference wasn’t character it wasn’t virtue it wasn’t even guilt or innocence the difference was bloodline the difference was who would fight for them when the king turned against them.

You Might Also Enjoy