What Was Philip II Of Spain Hiding?
King Philip II of Spain ruled over a time of immense prosperity. But his people didn’t realize he kept a disturbing secret locked away in his palace. The so-called golden age of Spain had many secrets. And Philip II was behind the darkest of them.
Cold, cruel, and inflexible in his ways, he viewed himself as the pious hero of Roman Catholicism. But behind closed doors, his actions were nothing short of depraved.
Philip’s father was the imperious and intimidating Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor, and at the time of Philip’s birth in 1527, Spain had only just started exploiting the colonial resources of the New World, and they intended to keep it going through their heir. As Philip grew up, his parents molded him into a terrifying absolute monarch, giving him lessons in conflict, statecraft, and being a strict Catholic. The young prince emerged from his pre-teen years as a serious, studious young man. But those who knew him best were alarmed by how cold and calculating he could be.
When Philip was 16, his father dropped a weighty responsibility in his lap. Seeing how seriously his son was taking his monarch studies, Charles gave him regency over all the kingdoms of Spain as a kind of starter pack for absolute rule, then left him to his own devices as he continued looking after the rest of the Holy Roman Empire.
Philip and his family belonged to the House of Habsburg, an Austro-Spanish dynasty infamous for its commitment to inbreeding its members to keep the so-called sanctity of their royal blood. So when it came time for Philip to marry, his parents looked no further than his own cousin, Maria Manuela, Princess of Portugal. On July 8th, 1545, Maria gave birth to a boy named Carlos, fulfilling her duty as Philip’s wife, then promptly died of a hemorrhage.
As Carlos grew into a young man, it became clear that something was very, very wrong. The boy was constantly sick, and there didn’t seem to be many lights on upstairs. Perhaps understandable when he only had six great-great-grandparents out of a possible 16. Such was the extent of the family’s inbreeding.
According to lore, Carlos took pleasure in tormenting animals and serving girls alike, once ordering that a housemaid be whipped for his enjoyment at the tender age of 11. By all accounts, he grew up as an arrogant and spoiled brat, leading one dignitary to call him ugly and repulsive, though probably not to his face.
Philip, perhaps doubting his son’s ability to follow in his footsteps, began looking for another bride in the 1550s. His father’s cousin was none other than Queen Mary I of England, the eldest daughter of Henry VIII, and she was looking for a husband. Mary was 37 years old, somewhat sickly, and had never been what anyone would have called comely. She quickly grew obsessed at the thought of tying the knot with her Spanish prince, even going against the prevailing opinion of her ministers that she should marry an Englishman.
In mid-July of 1554, Mary and Philip finally met for the first time. Philip couldn’t speak English. In fact, he never truly learned, and the so-called lovebirds had to work around the barrier with a hodgepodge of other languages. Two days later, they made it official in a wedding ceremony at Winchester Cathedral.
In September of that same year, Queen Mary was experiencing morning sickness and weight gain. To everyone at court, it seemed like the country was about to get a new heir. While all the court doctors fussed over Mary, Philip thought something was off. He wrote to his brother-in-law expressing doubts about whether Mary’s pregnancy was real. In July of 1555, after 10 months of experiencing symptoms of a pregnancy, Mary’s abdomen finally receded, revealing that Philip’s doubts had been justified all along. The Queen had likely suffered from a phantom pregnancy.
As soon as he was sure that Mary wasn’t pregnant, Philip left England to tend to matters of state and Flanders, leaving his still-recovering wife, who was by one account now extraordinarily in love with him, to the vipers in her court.
One of the reasons Mary’s ministers were hesitant about allowing her to marry Philip was their fear that as an even more pious Catholic than herself, he would push her towards intolerance of other religions, particularly Protestantism. They were right to worry. Dejected at Philip leaving, Mary began to believe her phantom pregnancy was a punishment from God because she tolerated heretics. Soon enough, she began persecuting Protestants, eventually earning her the infamous nickname Bloody Mary.
In 1556, Philip finally achieved his destiny. That year, his elderly father, Charles V, abdicated his throne, and he officially became King Philip II of Spain at last. Even so, he didn’t return to Mary. In fact, he stayed away from his wife for nearly two years, only returning in 1557 when he wanted her to help him raise an army. He convinced Mary to enter into a conflict with France, one that went disastrously. By the end of it, England had lost Calais, its last remaining territory on mainland Europe.
Philip’s return to England, which included at least one conjugal visit, raised Mary’s hopes that she was pregnant again. But something was different this time. She realized her health was failing, and if she did have a child, she likely wouldn’t be around to see it grow up. Knowing this, she drew up documents making Philip the child’s regent in the event of her death.
Although Mary had expected to give birth in March of 1558, once again, this didn’t happen. She had possibly experienced another phantom pregnancy and was now suffering intense pain in her uterus. After the stark realization that she wouldn’t have any heirs, she arranged for her sister Elizabeth to succeed her.
In November of 1558, Queen Mary I died, probably from uterine cancer. As if to underscore just how indifferent he was to the wife that adored him, Philip wrote to his sister, saying, “I felt a reasonable regret at her death.” As if that wasn’t the most romantic thing you’ve ever heard.
Philip then sent a marriage proposal to Mary’s sister, now Queen Elizabeth I. After all, with Mary gone, Philip was no longer the king of England, and he very much wanted to be. Elizabeth I didn’t go down in history as a fool, for good reason. She declined his proposal, but Philip’s eye had already landed on another potential bride.
In 1559, Philip married Elizabeth of Valois, one of the daughters of French King Henry II and Queen Catherine de’ Medici. Over the next five years, Philip and Elizabeth tried to have more heirs as backups to the sickly Carlos. First, the 15-year-old Elizabeth gave birth to a stillborn son. Then in 1564, she miscarried twins.
In 1562, Carlos fell and cracked his head while chasing a servant girl down some stairs. For days, he lay on the brink, experiencing severe pain and delusions. It was only after a good old-fashioned trepanning, drilling a hole into his head, that Philip’s son showed signs of recovery. Carlos had never been a model prince, to say the least, but after this he became even more unpredictable and violent.
In 1566 and 1567, Elizabeth gave birth to two daughters in succession, Isabella Clara Eugenia and Catherine Michaela. While Philip was rejoicing in the birth of his second daughter, Carlos went off the deep end. He attempted to throw a servant who displeased him out of a window. He tried to kill two of his father’s men. Then, in a fit of insanity and paranoia, he barged into the rooms of Philip’s half-brother, John of Austria, and tried to shoot him. When he realized that a wary servant had unloaded his gun, he proceeded to try to throttle John with his bare hands. Philip could ignore it no more. He needed to deal with his son.
For weeks, Philip kept Carlos from receiving any correspondence and refused to let anyone visit him. Then, in the midnight hours of January 17th, 1568, Philip entered his son’s room in full armor and with a full complement of men at his back and told his son he was now a prisoner. With his mentally unstable, only son locked up in his room, Philip went to desperate measures to protect his good name. He told no one and made excuses for his son’s absences. He might have pulled it off if catastrophe hadn’t struck first.
In the summer of 1568, Carlos died, likely from his attempts to starve himself, although many rumors at the time claimed that Philip had his troublesome son killed. Just after Carlos’s suspicious death, a bitter twist of fate came once more for the king of Spain. In October of 1568, his wife, Elizabeth of Valois, miscarried a baby girl and then succumbed to complications of her bloody labor. Philip was now in his 40s, a widower again after his third marriage, and had no male heir.
In search of a new bride and a replacement son, Philip really dialed up the creep-o-meter. Anna of Austria, the daughter of the new Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian II and Maria of Spain, was more than two decades younger than Philip and she was his niece. They married in 1570. Despite everything about their relationship being weird, Philip and Anna of Austria seemed to be very happy, with Philip very likely keeping no mistresses at this time. Apparently the highest compliment any medieval man could pay his wife.
After a lifetime of struggling to sire healthy, mentally balanced boys, Anna gave Philip four sons in a row, plus one girl for good measure over the course of a decade. However, all this good fortune was something of a monkey’s paw. Only one of those children, the future King Philip III of Spain, made it to adulthood. And Anna of Austria herself died of the flu in 1580 at just 30 years old. Philip was staring down the barrel of his mid-50s and alone again.
Perhaps that’s why some of his final decisions quickly lit his legacy aflame. For decades, Philip had maintained cordial, if chilly, relations with his ex-sister-in-law, Elizabeth I. He’d spent his reign putting down Protestant insurrections, particularly in the Spanish-held Netherlands, and still viewed himself as the protector of the one and only true religion, Catholicism. So when the Protestant Elizabeth started helping the Dutch rebels in 1585, Philip infamously turned on her.
In 1588, desperate to keep Catholic supremacy in Europe, Philip turned his Spanish Armada towards England with the express intent of putting a Catholic on the English throne. That didn’t happen.
The Spanish attempt at invading England went catastrophically. After being outmaneuvered in various battles and lacking supplies, a series of brutal storms all but destroyed the Spanish fleet. Philip had to retreat without ever taking a bite of England, and then the whispers started.
In this war of religion, it was extremely bad PR for nature to stymie Philip’s ambitions. Indeed, Protestants around Europe cheered at the storm’s destruction of the Armada, believing that it was God showing his will to the people. Philip, for his part, reportedly complained, “I sent my fleet against men, not against the wind and the waves.”
Philip continued to desperately try to hammer at England’s shores and sent further fleets in 1596 when he was approaching his 70s and then again in 1597. Each of them failed, as did Philip’s ambition for one last golden victory for his golden age.
By the end of his life, bouts of malarial fever and gout had crippled Philip and turned him into a shadow of his former self. In order to bear the pain and still govern his nation, he took to strapping himself to a chair for the last three years of his life. He lived long enough to watch his son and heir, Prince Philip, grow into a young man. He was deeply disappointed in what he saw. After the Carlos debacle, he tried to give his son the finest, most progressive education the crown could buy. But it was nonetheless clear to everyone, probably Philip most of all, that the boy, while studious, had no political mindset.
Philip ruled over what many historians call the golden age of Spain, thanks mostly to the masses of gold and silver coming in from the New World Philip had inherited. Yet, when he finally succumbed to cancer in 1598, he might as well have been ruling over a kingdom of ash. In his son, Philip likely saw no glimmer of hope to take Spain to greater heights. And he was right. The nation declined during Philip III’s reign and Spain lost the Netherlands and their fight with Protestantism within 50 years of the old king’s end.