What Really Happened to Catherine of Aragon’s Lost Children?
What Really Happened to Catherine of Aragon’s Lost Children?
Some of the babies were buried quietly at night in unmarked graves.
Others were completely erased from official records as if they had never existed.
Catherine of Aragon’s pregnancies sometimes resulted in children so unusual that witnesses were paid large sums to stay silent.
By the end of this video, you’ll understand the medical reasons behind these cases and what likely happened to the missing bodies.
The surviving records tell a disturbing story.
Shortly after certain royal births at Richmond Palace in Greenwich, servants were ordered to burn specific documents in the Queen’s chambers, but fire doesn’t destroy everything.
Centuries later, a fragment found in the ruins of the palace revealed three Latin words written by a court physician, “born against nature.”
What could have been so shocking that experienced doctors, men who had seen all kinds of illness and death, abandoned medical language and turned to something almost supernatural?
To understand this, we need to remember that Tudor physicians were familiar with stillbirths and infant deaths.
They had clear terms for birth defects, premature births, and complications.
Yet, in some of Catherine’s cases, they avoided those medical terms and instead used language suggesting something unnatural or even demonic.
This wasn’t simple ignorance or superstition.
These were educated professionals trying to describe something they had never encountered before.
Court records show that after certain births, several physicians requested to leave the royal court immediately without giving any reason.
One notable example is Thomas Linacre, founder of the College of Physicians and Henry VIII’s personal doctor, who withdrew from court life after attending one of Catherine’s deliveries in 1513.
He never practiced medicine again.
The secrecy around these births was highly organized and extremely expensive.
Midwives were paid between 50 and 200 pounds, huge amounts at a time when a skilled worker might earn only 10 pounds a year.
These payments appear in partial financial records with vague descriptions like “services to her majesty” or “discretion in royal matters.”
But, the timing of these payments matches exactly with Catherine’s known failed pregnancies.
The way physical evidence was removed so quickly suggests this was more than just normal royal secrecy.
When Catherine’s pregnancies ended badly, entire rooms were stripped and completely redecorated.
Birthing chairs were burned instead of being stored.
Linens and blankets were destroyed rather than washed and reused, even though reusing them was standard practice, even in royal households.
Household records also show unusual purchases of quicklime right after certain births.
In Tudor England, quicklime was mainly used to speed up the decomposition of organic material.
What makes this silence even more unsettling is how far it spread.
Foreign ambassadors in England, whose job was to report everything happening at court back to their own countries, left behind letters that still exist in European archives.
In a coded message from 1514, the Venetian ambassador mentioned an event so disturbing that he refused to write down the full details, even in code.
The Spanish ambassador, who had direct access to Catherine and represented her homeland, wrote to the heirs of Ferdinand and Isabella about a tragedy that went far beyond normal birth complications.
These were experienced diplomats who had seen many royal courts across Europe and were not easily shocked.
Yet, something about Catherine’s situation made them unwilling or unable to describe exactly what happened, even in private encrypted letters.
The silence was widespread, coordinated, and complete.
But, silence creates gaps and gaps raise questions.
By 1516, when Catherine finally gave birth to a living child, Princess Mary, the relief at court wasn’t just about securing the line of succession.
It was also about proving that Catherine could give birth to a healthy, normal child, something that could be openly acknowledged and celebrated.
However, that sense of relief didn’t last.
Whatever was causing these tragic outcomes hadn’t disappeared.
In fact, it seemed to be getting worse.
What happened in Catherine’s next pregnancy would make everything before it seem almost mild in comparison.
At first, the pattern developed slowly, but then it started repeating with frightening consistency.
Catherine of Aragon’s first pregnancy began in early 1510, shortly after her marriage to Henry VIII.
She was 24 years old, reportedly in good health, and hopeful about giving birth to the male heir Henry desperately wanted.
But, in January 1510, only a few months into the pregnancy, Catherine miscarried.
The official announcement was short and intentionally vague, simply stating that the Queen had lost the child and was recovering.
No further details were given, nothing about how far along she was, what caused the loss, or whether the fetus showed any abnormalities.
At first glance, this might seem like typical royal privacy, but in reality, it set a pattern that would repeat, each time becoming more unsettling.
11 months later, in January 1511, Catherine gave birth to a living son named Henry, Duke of Cornwall.
For 52 days, England finally had a male heir.
The celebrations were huge.
Tournaments were held, church bells rang across London, and Henry VIII was overjoyed.
Then, the baby died.
The cause was simply recorded as infant mortality, a vague term in Tudor times that could mean almost anything.
But, what happened next was unusual.
Normally, the body of a royal child would lie in state as expected for a Prince of England.
Instead, the funeral was rushed, held within 24 hours with very few people present and no public viewing of the body.
So, why the urgency?
Why the secrecy?
Infant deaths were sadly common in the 16th century.
There would have been no reason to hide anything unless there was something specific about this child that needed to be concealed.
Between 1511 and 1514, Catherine had two more known pregnancies.
The first, in late 1513, ended with a stillborn son in December.
Records show the Queen was devastated, but once again, important details are missing.
The second pregnancy, in 1514, ended the same way, another stillborn child in late December.
Two stillbirths in a row, both in December, both boys, both buried quickly and with little ceremony.
Even the timing raised suspicion.
A December birth suggests conception in March or April, meaning these pregnancies had almost reached full term before ending.
The Venetian ambassador reported that palace staff seemed frightened and unwilling to talk about what had happened.
The French envoy observed that the Queen’s ladies-in-waiting received unusually generous gifts after the 1514 stillbirth, payments that strongly resembled hush money.
Perhaps most telling, the Spanish ambassador, who had regular access to Catherine, stopped mentioning her pregnancies in his reports altogether after 1514.
Then, in 1516, there was finally a successful birth.
Catherine gave birth to a living daughter, Mary, on February 18th.
The sense of relief at court was obvious.
Even though Henry had wanted a son, Catherine had proven she could carry a pregnancy to full term and deliver a healthy child.
Princess Mary was completely healthy and showed no abnormalities.
But, this one success was surrounded by repeated failures, failures that were becoming harder to ignore.
In 1518, Catherine became pregnant once again.
She was now 33 years old, and this would be her final pregnancy.
In November of that year, she gave birth to a stillborn daughter.
This time, there was no public announcement at all.
The birth was completely left out of official records.
We only know it happened because of private letters between Henry’s advisers and a few scattered notes in household accounts.
The baby was never buried in a royal tomb.
There’s no record of where or how the burial took place.
It’s as if the child was erased from history entirely.
Six pregnancies in eight years, one living child and five deaths.
What makes Catherine’s story so disturbing isn’t just the number of losses.
It’s what happened to the bodies of those children and the fact that those who witnessed the births were never allowed to speak about them.
By 1518, rumors spreading across European courts had taken on a darker tone.
People were no longer just talking about stillbirths.
They were whispering about something far more frightening.
The turning point came during the winter of 1513.
Catherine was eight months pregnant and the court doctors were cautiously optimistic.
But, when labor began in early December, something went wrong almost immediately.
The delivery was long and extremely painful, lasting over 18 hours, and Catherine’s screams echoed through the palace.
When the baby was finally delivered, those waiting outside noticed something strange.
Instead of the usual sounds of grief after a stillbirth, there was an eerie silence.
Then came hurried whispers, followed by the sound of someone becoming violently sick.
Three midwives and two physicians had been present.
Within an hour, one of the midwives was removed from the palace by guards, crying uncontrollably as she was taken away.
The senior midwife, a woman named Agnes, who had delivered many noble children, stayed behind, but she refused to talk about what she had seen.
Years later, in 1563, on her deathbed, she finally broke her silence while confessing to a priest.
The priest recorded her words, and his writings were hidden in church archives for centuries.
According to his account, Agnes described the baby from the 1513 stillbirth as something not formed as it should have been.
She said the child was full-sized and mostly developed, but had severe abnormalities that made it clear why it couldn’t survive.
She described a skull that hadn’t fully closed and limbs that were malformed.
Modern medical historians who have studied this centuries-old account believe it describes severe neural tube defects, possibly anencephaly or a similar condition where the brain and skull do not develop properly.
Babies born with these conditions usually survive only a few hours, if at all.
In Catherine’s case, the child was already dead at birth.
Agnes also said this wasn’t the first time she had seen such abnormalities in royal births, and it wouldn’t be the last.
She mentioned being present again in 1514, where she witnessed similar deformations, though not exactly the same.
Neural tube defects can have different causes, such as a lack of folic acid, genetic factors, or exposure to certain toxins.
But in Tudor England, none of these explanations were understood.
Instead, a troubling question spread through the court.
Was Catherine cursed, or was there something wrong with the royal bloodline itself?
By 1527, the religious explanation for Catherine’s repeated pregnancy losses had become impossible to ignore.
This was when Henry VIII began seriously seeking an annulment.
His argument to the Pope was based on a passage from Leviticus, which claimed that a man who marries his brother’s widow will remain childless.
Catherine had previously been married to Henry’s older brother Arthur, who died in 1502.
Henry argued that their marriage had been cursed from the beginning, and that the deaths of their children were proof of God’s disapproval.
Catherine had no trouble becoming pregnant.
She had conceived at least six times, possibly more.
But she was only able to carry one healthy child to term.
To people at the time, this didn’t seem like bad luck or a medical issue.
It looked like a sign of divine judgment.
If God was punishing the marriage, then the dead or deformed infants were seen as warnings.
Because of this belief, the way their bodies were handled changed.
Children thought to be signs of a curse were not given proper royal funerals or buried in important consecrated places.
Instead, they were hidden, buried quietly, and often left out of official records.
However, some physical evidence that survived tells a different story.
Catherine of Aragon was buried at Peterborough Cathedral on January 29th, 1536.
Henry VIII ordered that she be buried not as a queen, but as the Princess Dowager of Wales, a title she had always refused to accept.
Today, her grave is marked by a simple stone slab in the cathedral’s north choir aisle, though she is now recognized as a former queen of England.
Banners showing the coats of arms of England and Spain hang above her grave.
But Westminster Abbey also has a darker link to Catherine’s story.
Architectural surveys carried out in the 19th century revealed at least three small, unidentified burial sites in areas connected to Tudor infant burials.
These graves were unusual.
They were placed deeper than normal, used simple wooden coffins instead of the lead-lined ones reserved for royalty, and were set apart from the main royal burial groups.
They were clearly there, but never officially acknowledged.
Officials at Westminster Abbey have refused requests to investigate these sites, citing the need to preserve them and respect the dead.
But if modern forensic science were allowed to examine these remains, it could finally answer questions that have troubled historians for centuries.
Were these children affected by genetic disorders?
Do their skeletons show patterns that point to specific medical conditions?
The answers may still be there, hidden beneath the stone.
And these secret burials weren’t limited to Westminster.
Research into church and parish records around London and royal residences has uncovered strange gaps and inconsistencies across the region.
At the Church of Greenwich Palace, records show a payment for the burial of a royal infant in 1514, but there’s no matching entry in the official burial register.
At Richmond Palace, similar evidence appears.
A church warden’s personal account book from 1515 mentions providing materials for the quiet burial of a royal child in December, yet no royal birth is recorded for that time.
Even more unsettling are records linked to Hampton Court.
One document refers to an infant of noble birth buried beneath a chapel floor at night in 1513.
It notes that the burial followed Christian rites, but was done without public attention, and that the child’s appearance required a closed casket.
A report from the Spanish ambassador to King Ferdinand in 1514 mentions that the queen had given birth again to a child who did not survive.
He adds that the situation was so disturbing he could not describe it in writing, even to his own king, and would explain it in person as soon as possible.
This is remarkable.
What could have been so shocking that it couldn’t even be written down in a private diplomatic report?
The French ambassador, writing to Francis I, also referred to rumors of something unusual surrounding Catherine’s failed pregnancies.
He noted that English officials maintained strict silence, suggesting that the issue was being treated as a matter of state secrecy.
Why would Catherine’s stillbirths be treated as matters of state security, unless they revealed something politically dangerous, something that foreign powers could use against Henry and England?
To understand this, we need to look at what modern medicine suggests was actually happening in Catherine of Aragon’s body.
The truth is less mysterious than people at the time believed, but in many ways, it’s even more tragic.
The most widely accepted explanation among medical historians is Rh incompatibility.
This condition wasn’t discovered until 1940, but it fits Catherine’s pattern of pregnancies with striking accuracy.
Here’s how it works.
Blood types aren’t just A, B, AB, or O.
They also include something called the Rh factor, which can be either positive or negative.
If a mother is Rh negative and the father is Rh positive, there’s about a 50% chance their child will be Rh positive.
During pregnancy, and especially during childbirth, a small amount of the baby’s blood can enter the mother’s bloodstream.
If the baby is Rh positive and the mother is Rh negative, her immune system sees the baby’s blood as foreign and starts producing antibodies against it.
This usually doesn’t affect the first pregnancy too much, because the body takes time to build up those antibodies.
But in later pregnancies, if the baby is again Rh positive, the mother’s immune system is already prepared, and it attacks the baby’s blood cells much more aggressively.
This condition is known as hemolytic disease of the newborn, and it tends to get worse with each pregnancy.
The first baby might be fine.
The second might develop mild anemia.
By the third, fourth, or later pregnancies, the babies often die in the womb or are born too severely affected to survive.
This pattern closely matches Catherine’s experience.
Her first recorded pregnancy ended in miscarriage.
Her second resulted in Prince Henry, who was born alive but died after 52 days.
Babies with this condition can seem healthy at first, then rapidly decline.
Her third and fourth pregnancies ended in stillbirths, which becomes more likely as antibody levels increase.
Then came Mary in 1516, but why did she survive?
One explanation is that Mary was Rh negative like her mother, so there was no blood incompatibility.
Catherine’s final pregnancy in 1518 ended in another stillbirth, likely because the baby was Rh positive and overwhelmed by the high level of antibodies in Catherine’s body.
But here’s the disturbing part.
Severe hemolytic disease doesn’t just cause death.
It can also lead to serious physical complications in the baby.
It can also cause very noticeable physical deformities.
Babies with this condition often develop something called hydrops fetalis, where fluid builds up throughout the body, leading to extreme swelling.
They can appear severely enlarged, with swollen abdomens, distorted facial features, and skin that takes on unusual colors, yellow or even greenish, due to intense jaundice.
Their skulls may look misshapen because of fluid buildup and possible brain damage.
Internal organs like the liver and spleen can become so enlarged that they are visible through the stretched skin of the abdomen.
If you were a Tudor era midwife or physician delivering a baby with severe hydrops fetalis, what would you see?
A baby with a human shape, but unnaturally swollen, with discolored skin, distorted features, and an abnormally large abdomen.
You wouldn’t have any medical understanding that this was caused by a blood disorder.
You wouldn’t have the language to explain why the baby looked so different.
All you would know is that something about the child seemed deeply unnatural, almost cursed.
In that context, the Latin phrase born against nature makes complete sense.
The physicians were simply describing what they saw using the limited knowledge they had.
The condition also worsens over time.
With each pregnancy involving an Rh positive baby, the effects become more severe.
By Catherine’s later pregnancies, the babies would likely have shown extreme abnormalities, so severe that even experienced doctors would have been shocked.
This helps explain the secrecy, the destruction of records, the traumatized witnesses, and the hidden burials.
However, there is another medical theory that some historians find even more troubling.
One that points not to Catherine, but to Henry VIII.
There is evidence suggesting that Henry may have had syphilis, possibly contracted early in his adult life.
At the time, syphilis, often called the great pox, was widespread across Europe and not uncommon among the nobility.
If Henry had the disease and passed it to Catherine, it could explain the tragic pattern of her pregnancies.
Congenital syphilis, passed from mother to child during pregnancy, can cause severe and devastating outcomes.
Babies may be stillborn or die shortly after birth.
Those who survive often show serious abnormalities, including skeletal deformities, especially in the skull and long bones, skin lesions, enlarged liver and spleen, and significant neurological damage.
Babies born with congenital syphilis can develop what’s called a saddle nose deformity, where the bridge of the nose collapses and the face looks flattened.
They may also develop saber shins, where the lower leg bones curve outward in a severe and unnatural way.
Their skulls can form abnormally as well, often with unusually shaped or prominent foreheads.
The theory that syphilis played a role isn’t based only on Catherine’s failed pregnancies.
Henry’s later wives also had repeated difficulties carrying pregnancies to term.
If Henry was the source of infection, it would explain why different women experienced similar reproductive problems after marrying him.
Henry’s own health later in life also matches symptoms of advanced syphilis.
He suffered from leg ulcers that never healed, drastic personality changes, violent mood swings, and a gradual mental decline.
Doctors in the Tudor period did recognize syphilis.
They called it the pox and often treated it with mercury, which Henry is known to have received.
However, they may never have connected the king’s illness to the queen’s pregnancy losses, especially since making that connection would have been politically dangerous.
If this theory is true, then the real horror of the cover-up isn’t what it hid about Catherine, but what it hid about Henry.
The deformed infants weren’t just tragic medical cases.
They may have been physical evidence that something was wrong at the very core of the Tudor dynasty.
Modern forensic science could potentially determine which theory is correct or whether both were involved.
Rh incompatibility and congenital syphilis are not mutually exclusive.
It’s possible Catherine was Rh negative and also infected with syphilis, creating a devastating combination that affected every pregnancy.
But confirming this would require examining the remains.
So far, the Church of England and Westminster Abbey have consistently refused requests for any invasive investigation of Tudor era graves.
The official reasons are preservation and respect for the dead.
Still, such an investigation could reveal a deeply uncomfortable truth.
That one of England’s most famous kings may have unknowingly caused the deaths of his own children through disease while blaming and discarding the women he held responsible for failing to give him an heir.
Even centuries later, that’s a difficult story to confront.
By 1527, Catherine of Aragon was 42 years old and hadn’t been pregnant for 9 years.
Henry had already lost patience.
He wanted a son.
He wanted Anne Boleyn, and he wanted Catherine out of the picture.
The annulment process officially began in 1527.
Henry based his case on the Book of Leviticus, arguing that his marriage to his brother’s widow had been condemned by God from the beginning.
He also used Catherine’s dead children as proof of divine punishment.
However, the Pope was in a very difficult political position.
Catherine was the aunt of Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, who had strong influence over the papacy.
Because of this, the Pope delayed the decision again and again, and the process dragged on for 6 years.
Throughout this time, Catherine fought to defend her marriage.
She fully understood what was at stake.
If the marriage was annulled, her daughter Mary would be declared illegitimate and removed from the line of succession.
The final blow came in 1533, when Henry completely broke away from Rome, declared himself the supreme head of the Church of England, and annulled the marriage without the Pope’s approval.
Catherine was stripped of her title as queen and reduced to the status of Princess Dowager of Wales.
She was separated from her daughter Mary and moved between increasingly isolated and uncomfortable residences.
Out of six wives and multiple known pregnancies, Henry VIII had only three children who survived to adulthood: Mary, Elizabeth, and Edward.
This very low success rate across different wives strongly suggests the problem may have been Henry himself, not the women he married.
Despite this, Catherine carried all the blame.
Her body and the deaths of her children were used as evidence of divine disapproval and as justification for ending the marriage.
Catherine of Aragon died on January 7th, 1536 at Kimbolton Castle, where she had effectively lived under confinement in her final years.
She was 50 years old and had been worn down by years of stress, grief, and declining health.
The official cause of death was recorded as cancer of the heart, a vague term that could have referred either to heart failure or an actual tumor.
Her embalmer later reported that her heart appeared darkened and covered with an unusual growth, possibly consistent with cancer or the effects of toxins.
She was buried in Peterborough Cathedral, where her tomb still stands today in the north choir aisle.
For centuries, it remained relatively simple and unadorned.
It wasn’t until the 20th century that Queen Mary of Teck, the consort of George V, ordered that her royal status be properly recognized again.
Today, visitors often leave pomegranates on her tomb, and flowers are almost always present.
The cathedral also holds an annual memorial in her honor, which is attended each year by the Spanish ambassador.
The biggest irony in Catherine’s story is that her daughter Mary eventually became Queen of England despite everything Henry tried to do to stop that from happening.
After the sickly Edward VI died at just 15 without any children, and following the short and chaotic 9-day reign of Lady Jane Grey, Mary became Mary I of England in 1553.
She ruled for 5 years, and like her mother, she became obsessed with producing a Catholic heir to secure the throne.
Also like her mother, she experienced what appeared to be phantom pregnancies.
Twice her abdomen enlarged and she believed she was feeling movement, but no child was ever born.
Both times ended in disappointment and public humiliation.
Mary died childless in 1558, and the crown passed to her Protestant half-sister Elizabeth, the daughter of Anne Boleyn, the woman Henry had chosen over Catherine.
In the end, everything Catherine fought for and suffered to protect was still lost.
The truth about her children remains only partly known because the full evidence no longer exists.
What we have are fragments, gaps in the records, and accounts from people who saw things they couldn’t explain and were not allowed to speak about.
Modern medicine gives us possible explanations for what may have happened, but we can’t confirm anything with certainty without examining remains that no institution currently allows access to.
So, how should we understand Catherine of Aragon’s story after 500 years?
She was a woman who went through repeated trauma, losing child after child in ways that were terrifying to witness and impossible for her to understand.
She lived in a time when the death of mothers and infants was sadly common.
Yet, she was still blamed for a supposed divine curse, when in reality, she may have been suffering from medical conditions that wouldn’t be understood until centuries later.
She was shamed and stripped of her status because her body could not do something it was biologically unable to do.
And later, her daughter endured a similar experience, suggesting that whatever was affecting Catherine’s pregnancies may have had a biological cause that carried into the next generation.
If Westminster Abbey ever allows scientific study of the unidentified infant graves, or if Tudor medical records are ever fully recovered, we might finally get clear answers.
Until then, we are left with an incomplete story, part history, part medicine, and part unresolved mystery, still surrounded by uncertainty about what was really happening inside the royal chambers 500 years ago.