News

The Utes K*lled Every Man at White River – What They Did to the Women Was W*RSE (1879)

A telegram lies on a desk at the Indian office in Washington dated September 10th 1879. It comes from the White River Agency in Northwest Colorado and it asks for soldiers. In less than 3 weeks the man who sent it will be dead and so will every man who works for him. The message is short and every line of it is afraid:

“I have been assaulted by a leading chief Johnson, forced out of my own house and injured badly. Life of self, family, and employees not safe. Want protection immediately.”

Washington sends him what he asks for. Nearly 200 men start south toward his agency. 19 days after the telegram, the agent Nathan Meeker is dead. For the women at the agency, what comes next is worse. The soldiers he begged for never reach him; they are pinned down in a valley about 25 miles away. At the agency, the buildings are burning, the men are lying in the fields, and the women and children are gone. Most tellings stop at the smoke, but the record keeps going.

The fight that began that September would cost the Utes most of their land in Colorado—about 12 million acres, more land than the whole of Switzerland. And it started with a farm tool. How did plowing start a war? The answer is sitting in Meeker’s own letters, in the army’s reports, and in the words of the Ute men who were there. A plow, a pasture, and a racetrack are at the bottom of all of it.

And there is a second question in the files: Josephine Meeker, 22, the agent’s daughter, was one of the women taken. When the man sent to free her asked whether she had been harmed, she said:

“Oh no, Mr. Adams, nothing of that kind.”

Weeks later under oath, her answer changed. Even the name of what happened at White River is still argued over. The old Colorado histories called it the Meeker Massacre. Many Utes and some museums today call it the Meeker Incident. The difference is the whole argument in two words. Here is where this goes: the plow, Milk Creek, the Ute camps, the testimony. We will follow the paper trail from that telegram to the hearing rooms of Congress and see what the women said when they finally told it, and what Colorado did with their words.

To understand that telegram, go back to the spring of 1878 and to a newspaper man who had already built one town in Colorado and who believed he could build another on land that belonged to someone else. Meet the agent Nathan Cook Meeker. He was born in Ohio in 1817. He spent most of his life in newspapers and for years he was the farm editor of Horace Greeley’s New York Tribune, a man who wrote about the right way to plant wheat for readers all over the country.

In 1870, with Greeley’s backing, he led a colony of settlers to Colorado. The colonists wanted to name their new town after Meeker; he suggested Greeley instead. It was a fine gesture and it would not be the last time a Colorado town took a man’s name. But money troubles followed him. Horace Greeley died in 1872, and 5 years later Greeley’s executives wanted their money back. His daughters sued Meeker for $1,000.

So in the spring of 1878, at 61, Nathan Meeker took a government job for $1,500 a year. The job was Indian agent at the White River Agency in northwest Colorado. It sat inside the reservation of the White River Utes, mountain hunters and horsemen who had lived in this country long before there was a Colorado to put on a map. Their rights were written down: the treaty of 1868 promised the Utes absolute and undisturbed use and occupation of their reservation and kept white settlers out. On paper, the land was theirs.

Meeker came with a different idea of what paper meant. To the White River Utes, horses were wealth—Chief Douglas alone owned about a hundred. Horse racing was sport, betting, and pride all at once, and by one account only about half of the supplies promised by treaty ever arrived. Meeker saw all of this and wanted to change it. In a letter to his superiors he put it in so many words:

“This horse business is a powerful obstacle to progress.”

He believed the Utes should give up hunting and horses, settle down, and farm. He had spent his life telling Americans how to farm; he never seems to have asked whether the Utes wanted to learn or what it would cost them to try. The historian Marshall Sprague found Meeker’s own account of one of his arguments with the Utes, published in the Greeley Tribune:

“The land belongs to the government and is for your use.”

If you use it, use it—in his mind meant one thing: plow.

The people who were about to be caught in the middle: his daughter came out to help him in July 1878. Josephine Meeker was 21; she kept the agency books, worked as its teacher, and served as its doctor for $750 a year. Her school for Ute children started with three pupils. Her mother, Arvilla, was in her 60s and still weak from a broken thigh 2 years before. And there was a young family on the agency payroll too: Shadrach Price was the agency plowman, his wife Flora Ellen was still in her teens, with a little girl named May about three and a baby boy Johnny.

On the Ute side, three men mattered most: Chief Douglas, also called Quinkant, was the older chief of the White River Band; Chief Jack, called Nikkagat, was younger, a war leader who had scouted for General Crook against the Sioux; the third was Johnson, called Canavish, a medicine man with large herds of horses. His wife Susan was Chief Ouray’s sister, and Ouray was the head chief of all the Utes living far to the south. Remember Susan; she will matter more than anyone expects.

The Utes did try the official road first. Jack rode all the way to Denver to ask Governor Pitkin to remove the agent. The Greeley Museum’s history of the affair tells what happened next: the governor read him a letter from Meeker accusing Jack of burning a house—a house Jack had seen standing. Jack called the agent’s statements lies.

In the fall of 1878, Meeker decided to move the agency about 12 miles down the river to a valley called Powell Park. It had the best grass on the reservation; it was the place where the Utes wintered their horses. Douglas objected; Meeker moved anyway. Then he ordered the pasture plowed—40 acres by one count, about 30 football fields; 50 by another—of the land where the Utes grazed their horses and raced them. To Meeker, it was a field. To the Utes, it was their wealth, their sport, and their winter feed being turned into dirt.

Someone fired a shot at the plowman. Meeker later wrote that it was Johnson’s son, and he warned the Utes he could call the army to make arrests:

“The opposition to plowing is wide.”

On September 8th, 1879, Johnson came to the agency house to complain about the plowing. As one historian reconstructed the scene, Meeker told him that the trouble was simple:

“You have too many ponies. You had better shoot some of them.”

Johnson threw him out of the house and against the hitching rail on the porch. That is Meeker’s version. Johnson later said that he only took the agent by the shoulder and told him to leave. Either way, an old man was hurt and a chief had laid hands on a government agent.

2 days later, on September 10th, 1879, Meeker sent the telegram. It ended with one more line: he had asked Governor Pitkin, he wrote, to confer with General Pope. The machinery was moving now and nothing at the White River agency could stop it.

The army gave the job to Major Thomas Thornburgh. On September 21st, he marched south out of Fort Fred Steele in Wyoming with cavalry, infantry, wagons, and teamsters—close to 200 men in all. His orders were to reach the agency and support the agent. In a letter to Meeker, Thornburgh promised to arrive on the 29th and to make arrests at your suggestion.

Meeker sent one more telegram on the 26th: if the soldiers arrest Indians and go away, he wrote:

“I must go with them. Soldiers must stay.”

The same day, Thornburgh wired that the Utes did not understand why the soldiers had come:

“Do not anticipate trouble.”

On September 26th, the war leader Jack rode north to meet the soldiers. He had one warning and he gave it plainly:

“If the troops crossed onto the reservation the Utes would take it as war.”

The column was heading for a stream on the reservation line called Milk Creek. Jack offered a way out:

“Let five soldiers ride to the agency with five Utes, and talk.”

Milk Creek was about 25 miles north of the agency, about the length of a marathon, and Ute leaders feared another Sand Creek, the Cheyenne and Arapaho camp that soldiers had attacked 15 years earlier.

Meeker understood the danger. On the 27th he wrote to Thornburgh himself:

“The Indians seem to consider the advance of troops as a declaration of real war. In this I am laboring to undeceive them. The first object now is to allay apprehension.”

It is the morning of September 29th, 1879. The column reaches Milk Creek at the northern edge of the reservation. The creek is nearly dry and the horses and mules need water. To find it, Major Thornburgh leads his men across the line. On a ridge above them, Jack is waiting with his warriors. Later he described the moment to Charles Adams:

“I was with General Crook the year before fighting the Sioux, and I knew in a minute that as soon as this officer deployed his men out in that way it meant fight, so I told my men to deploy also.”

Jack says he waved to show he only wanted to talk, and the soldiers take it as a signal to fight. The two sides will never agree on who fired first. Within minutes the shooting is everywhere and Major Thornburgh is dead, killed almost as soon as it begins.

Captain J. Scott Payne takes command. The soldiers drag their wagons into a circle and dig in behind them and behind the bodies of their own horses and mules, which the Ute rifles are killing by the hundreds. By nightfall the smell of dead animals hangs over the whole valley.

25 miles to the south, the same day, Nathan Meeker has eaten lunch with Chief Douglas at the agency. Around 1:00 he writes a note for Thornburgh; in the copy that survives it says that things are peaceable and that Douglas is flying the United States flag.

About half an hour later, at about 1 that afternoon of September 29th, Douglas’s men open fire on the agency. Out in the field, the plowman Shadrach Price is shot. Then the shooting moves from building to building and the fires begin. By most counts 11 men die at the White River agency that afternoon: Nathan Meeker, the plowman Shadrach Price, and the rest of the men on the agency payroll. Some lists have fewer names. Not one of the men who worked there is listed as a survivor.

The women have run into the milkhouse and hidden there while the shooting goes on. When the flames come close they run for the brush and the bullets follow. Arvilla Meeker is hit, and she later said it plainly:

“One struck me on the thigh, plowing through the flesh just under the skin.”

She also remembered her daughter in the middle of all that gunfire and drifting smoke:

“Keep all together.”

And the girl was as cool as if she were receiving callers in a parlor. They do not get far; the Utes catch them in the juniper woods at the edge of the clearing.

So how did plowing start a war? The riddle has an answer now: the plow tore up the Utes’ wealth and broke a promise written into their treaty. Meeker answered their anger by calling the army, and to the Utes, as Meeker himself had written, the soldiers were the declaration of war.

But answering the first question does nothing for the three women being led away from the agency. Before they were led away, Arvilla saw her husband lying near the burning buildings:

“The face looked as peaceful and natural as in life, but blood was running from the mouth.”

Stay with that image for a moment: a widow’s last look at her husband. Then she was put on a horse.

When soldiers finally reached the agency nearly 2 weeks later, they described something very different. They wrote of a chain around his neck and a barrel stave driven through his throat. The widow’s account and the soldiers’ account have never been reconciled.

The Ute side of it survives too. In March 1880, as her testimony was later quoted, Chipeta, the wife of Chief Ouray, was asked about the agent in Washington:

“They said he was a bad man… that he talked bad and some of them claimed that he was always writing to Washington and giving his side of the case.”

Always writing to Washington—the telegram that started this video was one of those letters. To the Utes at White River, every message sent was another step towards soldiers on their land, and every soldier was a reason to fear another Sand Creek.

Down at Los Pinos, Chief Ouray heard the news and tried to stop it. On October 2nd he sent a written order to the White River Utes:

“You are hereby requested and commanded to cease hostilities against the whites.”

But by then the fight at Milk Creek had been going for 4 days. That same day, by most counts, a company of Buffalo soldiers from the 9th Cavalry, about 35 men under Captain Francis Dodge, rode through the Ute lines into the trapped camp. They lost 38 of their 42 horses. One of them, Sergeant Henry Johnson, later received the Medal of Honor.

On October 5th Colonel Wesley Merritt arrived with hundreds more soldiers and the Utes were gone. The siege had lasted six days. Count the dead and every list disagrees: somewhere between 11 and 17 soldiers by different counts, somewhere between 19 and 37 Utes. By then nobody at Milk Creek was asking where the women were; the soldiers were burying their own.

And somewhere to the south, moving deeper into the mountains every day, three women and two small children were learning what the war meant for them.

This part of the story happens far away from the battlefield, in the Ute camps to the south along the rivers. For 23 days the camps were the whole world for Josephine, Arvilla, Flora Ellen, and the two children. They ride south toward the Grand River and Plateau Creek day after day with little food and less water. Arvilla, wounded and 64, rides without a proper saddle. A dust storm comes through, then two days of rain.

In camp, Josephine is put to work cooking and baking for the men who took her. The women are split up: Josephine goes to the lodge of a man named Persoon; Arvilla is held by Douglas and later by Johnson; Flora Ellen is taken first to Jack’s camp and then to Johnson’s. Each woman is alone among strangers and none of them knows where the others are.

An account printed in 1880 says Douglas pressed a loaded gun against Josephine’s forehead three times. Josephine later wrote that she had already decided what she would do:

“I made up my mind that I would fight the moment there was any insult offered me, and I would keep up the fight until they had killed me.”

In her written accounts she told the strangest detail of the whole captivity about Persoon, the man whose lodge she lived in:

“Persoon led her horse to her and knelt down on his hands and knees for her to mount from his back.”

Later he treated her, she wrote:

“With respect and considerable kindness.”

Hold that sentence for later; it is what Josephine said in print in 1879 in a pamphlet published under her name. It is not the only thing she said, and the difference between the two is the reason this story was argued about for years. There was kindness in those camps too, and Josephine named exactly the person it came from. Later histories say that Johnson’s wife Susan, the sister of Chief Ouray, argued against killing the captives when the warriors debated it:

“We all owe our lives to the sister of Chief Ouray.”

In Washington, the Secretary of the Interior, Carl Schurz, made a choice that probably kept the women alive: he held back the army until they were free. Instead of more soldiers he sent one man, Charles Adams, a former Ute agent the Utes knew.

On October 10th Josephine managed to get a message out:

“I do not think they will let us go of their own accord.”

11 days later, on October 21st, Charles Adams rode into a Ute camp near Plateau Creek with an offer and a warning. Adams told Congress what he saw when he rode in:

“I went to the lower end first, and by inquiring I saw Miss Meeker peeping out of a tent.”

Then he had Mrs. Meeker and Mrs. Price brought up out of the brush. After 23 days the captives were free.

Before they left, Adams asked the women the question newspapers would soon be asking: he asked Josephine whether the Utes had offered her any indignity to her person. Her answer came quickly:

“Oh no, Mr. Adams, nothing of that kind.”

Flora Ellen Price gave him the same answer: “No.”

Then the women and children rode south for 6 days, about 40 miles a day, to Chief Ouray’s house near the Los Pinos Agency—a house with carpets and lamps. When they left, Chapeta, Ouray’s wife, cried.

From there they went by wagon and stagecoach over mountain passes more than 11,000 ft high toward the railroad. When Arvilla saw the first telegraph poles, according to an account published soon after, she said:

“Now I feel safe.”

Captivity stories usually end at the rescue; this one does not. The women were about to be questioned again and again by men in suits about the 23 days.

In November 1879 a government commission sat at the Los Pinos agency to investigate everything that had happened at White River. The women were called to testify. Adams later told Congress that Josephine did not want to:

“She thought that she ought not to be made to tell all these matters.”

But she was made to, and under oath the answer she had given at Plateau Creek changed. The second question from the beginning gets its answer here: in her sworn statement, as the Colorado Encyclopedia quotes it, Josephine described what she called outrageous treatment at night. She was asked whether she had been forced against her will; she answered yes. By her testimony and by Adams’s account of Flora Ellen, that was what had been done to the women at White River.

Flora Ellen Price’s story came out through Adams. The man who captured her on the first day, Adams testified, had outraged her person and then had given her away or sold her—she did not know which—to the chief Johnson. She was a teenager with two small children, and she was about to walk out of the record entirely.

And Arvilla Meeker, who had told the newspapers in 1879 that she escaped outrage, gave the investigators a very different account—historian Marshall Sprague found—of what Douglas had demanded of her.

For Josephine, it was no in the camp and yes under oath. Josephine never explained the difference herself, but in 1879 a woman who said yes on the record could expect to be talked about for the rest of her life. Under oath Josephine was made to say it anyway, and the man who would make the most of their captivity was already waiting in Denver.

Much later, a Ute elder would answer all of it in three words. We will hear them before the end.

What Colorado did next was not about the women at all. The words they had tried to keep private were about to become an argument for taking a whole people’s land. This is what Colorado did with the testimony: the official papers used gentle words for all of it, the kind of words that let a clerk write it down without blushing—indignity to her person, outraged her person, abused. That was the language of the hearing room.

The newspapers used a very different language. On January 5th, 1880, the Sacramento Daily Union told its readers that the women had been forced under threats of torture and slow death to yield to the lust of their hideous captives. Josephine never accused anyone in public; her private testimony had leaked anyway.

The governor of Colorado, Frederick Pitkin, had wanted the Utes out of the state from the day he took office. In his first speech as governor in January 1879 he called for the immediate extinguishment of the Indian title, that is how a modern account reports it. On October 22nd, 1879, the day after the women were freed, Pitkin sent a telegram to Carl Schurz:

“Unless the troops move against the Indians, the Indians will move against the settlers. They are savages, they take no prisoners except women.”

Across Colorado a slogan was spreading, printed in the papers and repeated at rallies:

“The Utes must go.”

The women’s worst days had become a campaign argument used by men who had never met them.

And the men the women had named: Douglas was held at Fort Leavenworth in Kansas; he was never charged, and in February 1881 he was released untried and unpunished. No Ute was ever convicted for the killings at the agency or for what happened in the camps.

The Utes paid in a different currency. On March 6th, 1880, Ouray and other Ute leaders signed an agreement that gave up most of their land in Colorado. That summer, on August 24th, 1880, Ouray died at 47, still traveling to gather signatures for it.

On August 28th, 1881, under cavalry escort, about 665 White River Utes were moved out of Colorado to a reservation in Utah. The whole band went—women, children, and old people along with the men. The land behind them was open to settlers.

The people in this story scattered in different directions. Jack was killed in Wyoming in 1882 in a fight with soldiers. Josephine Meeker went to work in Washington at the Interior Department and as a secretary to Senator Teller; she died on December 20th, 1882. She was 25.

Flora Ellen Price, the teenage widow of the plowman, gave her testimony, took her two children, and walked out of the record. Her later life and the lives of May and Johnny do not appear in the sources; she is the survivor of White River whose ending nobody wrote down. Some names simply vanish.

Trace it backward and every step leans on the one before: the treaty of 1868 promised the land; in 1878 the agent arrived; in 1879 the plow went into the pasture and the soldiers crossed the creek; by 1881 the removal had emptied the valley of the people the treaty was written for.

So how did plowing start a war? It cut into the one thing the White River Utes could not afford to lose, and when they pushed back the agent called for soldiers, and the soldiers were the war. Everything after that—the killings, the camps, the testimony—followed in a line.

One fact in the record turns this story around: back in 1870 Meeker named his first town Greeley after his patron. Today the town near the old agency is called Meeker. The county seat carries the name of the agent, and the White River Valley has no Ute reservation at all.

A Ute elder named Clifford Duncan, more than a century later, said it like this:

“We’re Colorado people, but we have no connection whatsoever, only in memory.”

Northwest Colorado kept the names and lost the people who lived there.

At Milk Creek today there are two monuments side by side. One honors the soldiers; the other was built by Ute tribal members in the 1990s for the warriors who fought there. The fight that started with a plow has two memorials and they stand within sight of each other.

There are more files like this one from other agencies, other telegrams, and other women whose first answer was no. We will open the next one soon. But first, one last look at that desk in Washington: a telegram lies there dated September 10th, 1879.

“Want protection immediately.”

The agent got his soldiers sent; he did not get his protection. His daughter got her freedom, and then she had to give up her silence in a hearing room.

You Might Also Enjoy