News

The Untold Shadows Behind Marilyn Monroe, JFK, and the Photograph Kept Hidden for Decades

 

There is one photograph in this story that cannot be argued with. It was taken after midnight in a townhouse on the east side of Manhattan on the 19th of May, 1962. Three people stand close together in it. The President of the United States, his brother, the Attorney General, and a woman in a dress that had to be sewn onto her body.

 It is the only picture ever taken of the three of them at the same time, and it was kept out of sight for decades until everyone in the frame was long dead. Ask yourself why a photograph that innocent was held back. There is no embrace in it, no scandal, just three people standing in a room. What made it dangerous was never what it showed.

 It was the fact that it existed at all in the hands of a photographer who worked for the White House. Understand what that photograph is before we go any further. It is the only hard physical evidence this story has ever produced. Everything else you have heard, every affair, every midnight visit, every phone call, every diary, every cover-up, every murder, rests on what somebody remembered years later, sometimes 25 years later, sometimes for money, sometimes for reasons that had nothing to do with the truth. So, this is not a story about a

secret she announced on a stage. It is a story about the night a president’s private life walked into the same room as his public life with 15,000 witnesses and one camera. By the end of this, you will know what that night exposed, what it did not, and why the difference still matters. To understand what that evening really was, you have to understand how those three lives got there.

 And they started from opposite ends of the same country. On the 29th of May, 1917 in Brookline, Massachusetts, a boy was born into a family that expected things from its sons. John Fitzgerald Kennedy was the second of nine children born to Joseph Kennedy and Rose Fitzgerald. His father was a man with money, ambition, and a long plan.

 His childhood was spent in large houses at Cape Cod in competition. Sailing races, dinner table arguments, a scoreboard of who was winning that kept running whether anyone liked it or not. Nine years later and a continent away, on the 1st of June, 1926, a girl was born at the Los Angeles County General Hospital, a public hospital where the city’s poor were treated.

 Her birth certificate read Norma Jeane Mortenson. She was baptized Norma Jeane Baker. Neither name would be the one the world learned. Her mother, Gladys Pearl Baker, cut film negatives in a Hollywood laboratory, trimming the images of actresses other people would become. Nobody has ever settled who her father was. Gladys could not raise her.

 By the age of seven, the girl had been raised by a foster family in Hawthorne, then briefly by her mother, then not by her mother at all. Gladys spent much of the rest of her life in and out of institutions. A friend of hers, Grace Goddard, became the guardian of record. And for close to 2 years in the mid-1930s, the girl lived in the Los Angeles Orphan’s Home on El Centro Avenue, a matter of blocks from the studios her mother had worked in.

One of these children was taught that the world belonged to him. The other learned that she could be moved at any time, to any house, by anyone. The war years gave them each a story. Kennedy went into the Navy and commanded a patrol torpedo boat, PT 109, in the Solomon Islands. In August 1943, a Japanese destroyer, the Amagiri, cut the boat in half.

 He led his surviving crew to an island. The newspapers turned it into legend, and it was the first thing most Americans ever knew about him. He ran for Congress in 1946 and won. He was 29 years old. Her war years were a marriage. In June 1942, at 16, she married a neighbor’s son, James Dougherty. He went to sea with the Merchant Marine.

 She worked the assembly line at a plant in Van Nuys, building drone aircraft. In 1944, a photographer from the Army’s first motion picture unit, David Conover, came through the plant to shoot women war workers for a morale feature. He photographed her. Those frames started everything. And then, in 1944, the Kennedy family got the news that rearranged its plans.

Joseph Kennedy Jr., the son their father had been preparing for the White House, was killed on a bombing mission over Europe. The future that had been built for one brother was handed to the next one. In 1946, the same year John Kennedy won his first election, a girl named Norma Jean signed with the Blue Book modeling agency, lightened her hair, divorced her husband, and signed a short contract with 20th Century Fox.

 At Fox, a studio chose her name for her. Monroe was her mother’s maiden name. Marilyn was invented. So, the girl who was born Mortensen and baptized Baker was now, for business purposes, Marilyn Monroe. Two people entering public life in the same 12 months. One from a seat in Washington, one from a studio wardrobe department, with no reason on Earth to expect their names would ever land in the same sentence.

The next few years were cruel to her and kind to him. The studio dropped her in 1947. She spent months looking for work, took small parts, and got noticed in two 1950 pictures, The Asphalt Jungle and All About Eve, that were strong enough for the studio that had fired her to bring her back on a 7-year contract.

Then, in 1952, a nude calendar photograph she had posed for in 1949, when she was broke, surfaced across the country. She admitted it flatly, without apology, and the scandal made her more famous instead of less. In 1953, Fox released three films in a row with her at the top, Niagara, Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, and How to Marry a Millionaire.

That June, she pressed her hands and feet into wet cement in the courtyard of Grauman’s Chinese Theatre. The girl from the orphanage had her prints in the pavement. He married Jacqueline Bouvier in Newport in September 1953 and moved to the Senate. His brother Robert, born in 1925, had married Ethel Skakel in 1950 and was building a reputation of his own as counsel on Senate committees, including the one that investigated organized crime and the Teamsters.

That work is the beginning of the part of this story that actually matters. Now meet the man who glued these two worlds together because none of it would have been possible without him. Peter Lawford was a British actor under contract at MGM when, on the 24th of April 1954, he married Patricia Kennedy, Jack and Bobby’s sister.

A working Hollywood actor became the brother-in-law of a United States Senator. He and Patricia had a beach house in Santa Monica. He also ran with Frank Sinatra’s crowd, Dean Martin, Sammy Davis Jr., Joey Bishop, the group that made Ocean’s 11 in 1960. So for a few years in the early 1960s, that house on the shoreline of Santa Monica was where the film business and the political business genuinely mixed.

In 1960, it stopped being a social arrangement and became a campaign. Kennedy announced for president in January. Bobby managed the campaign. Sinatra re-recorded High Hopes as a campaign song and threw his weight behind the candidate. The beach house, the Rat Pack, the casino tables in Las Vegas, all of it got folded into a presidential run.

Kennedy won in November by one of the narrowest margins in American history. And here is where the paper trail runs out and I need you to stay with me for this part because it is exactly what separates this story from every version you have ever heard that claims to know what happened. The first meetings between Marilyn Monroe and John Kennedy have no date.

Biographers have placed them at the Lawford’s beach house or at gatherings around it, somewhere between the late 1950s and the start of the 1960s. They do not agree on when. And the reason they do not agree is not laziness. It is that there is no letter, no diary entry, no dated document, nothing carrying a timestamp that fixes a single one of those meetings.

 What is solid is much narrower. She was close to Peter and Patricia Lawford, and the man who would become president moved in and out of that same orbit. Everything past that point is recollection, and the recollection arrived late. The books that built this legend were mostly published in the 1980s and 90s, written from interviews with people recalling things 15 to 25 years after they happened.

 Peter Lawford gave different versions of his own story at different times. He divorced Patricia Kennedy in 1966 and died in 1984, and a great deal of what is credited to him reached print through other people’s books after he could no longer be asked to explain it. Read one of those biographies and then the next, and you will find accounts that agree in outline and contradict each other in detail.

The writers were not being careless. The evidence itself is memory, and memory is not a document. Now add the thing people prefer to skip. While Jack Kennedy was disciplined in public, he was reckless in private, and in private he was not only seeing actresses. In March 1962, J. Edgar Hoover, the director of the FBI, had lunch with the president at the White House.

According to the Senate committee that later investigated intelligence abuses, the Church Committee, which reported in 1975, the bureau had learned that a woman named Judith Campbell had been in contact with both John Kennedy and Sam Giancana, a Chicago organized crime figure. The committee noted that White House telephone logs recorded a call between her and the White House hours after that lunch.

Judith Campbell, later Judith Campbell Exner, confirmed the relationship publicly years afterward. Sit with that for a moment. In the spring of 1962, the president of the United States was linked by the FBI to a woman who was also linked to the mob. That is not a rumor. That is in the Senate record. That same March, a smaller story played out in the desert.

As several biographers tell it, the president was due in Palm Springs and was expected to stay at Frank Sinatra’s house, which had been prepared for him. At the last moment, it changed. He stayed at Bing Crosby’s nearby instead, and Peter Lawford was the one sent to tell Sinatra. The details vary between tellings.

The shape does not. Keep that in your head. It is the same instinct that will shape everything that comes next. After her divorce from Arthur Miller, granted in Mexico on the 20th of January 1961, the same day Jack Kennedy was sworn in, she came back to Los Angeles. The months before had been bad. In February 1961, she had been admitted to a psychiatric clinic in New York, and the man who helped get her transferred out, unexpectedly, was Joe DiMaggio, her former husband.

 He was the one who came when it counted. By early 1962, she was back in the city where she had been born in a charity ward 35 years earlier, doing something she had never done in her life. She was buying a house. Not a hotel suite, not a rented apartment, not a husband’s home, her own. A single-story Spanish-style house at 12305 5th Helena Drive in Brentwood, behind a wall on a quiet street.

 It is generally described as the only house she ever bought on her own. In February, she flew to Mexico to buy furnishings. In March, she accepted a Golden Globe as the world’s favorite film actress. There is a detail in that house that has haunted people for 60 years. Set into the porch at the entrance were tiles bearing two Latin words, cursum perficio, roughly, I complete the course.

 Nobody knows whether she chose the tile or inherited it with the property. The words were on the house before they were ever part of a story about her. Remember that tile. We are coming back to it. By April, she was supposed to be working. Something’s got to give, directed by George Cukor with Dean Martin, had started shooting in April 1962 and had almost immediately gone wrong.

She was absent repeatedly. Illness was the studio’s explanation. The delays stacked up and the money burned. She was still in the middle of that mess when an invitation arrived from the East Coast. She was asked to sing at a Democratic Party fundraiser marking the president’s 45th birthday. His birthday was May 29.

 The event was May 19. If there is a reason for the 10-day gap, it is not in the record. She flew to New York against the studio’s wishes. The venue was the old Madison Square Garden on 8th Avenue. 15,000 people filled it. The bill, by all accounts, included Ella Fitzgerald, Jack Benny, Peggy Lee, Maria Callas, and Henry Fonda.

 Jacqueline Kennedy was not there. She was reported to be at a horse show in Virginia that day. The dress was designed by Jean Louis and sketched by his young assistant, Bob Mackie. It was made of a sheer, flesh-colored fabric covered with around 2,500 hand-sewn rhinestones cut so tightly to her body that the widely repeated account says she had to be sewn into it.

Is that last part true? It is repeated by almost everyone who tells this story. It may be the most repeated unverified detail of the entire evening. Treat it the way you should treat everything else here, as the story everyone tells, not as a document. Then Peter Lawford walked to the microphone.

 Think about what that means for 1 second. The president’s brother-in-law, a Hollywood actor, warming up a crowd of 15,000 for a performance by the president’s alleged mistress at a fundraiser for his own party 10 weeks after the Attorney General had been handed a warning about the mob. He teased the room for a while, pretending she was delayed.

 Then, when she finally appeared under a single spotlight, he introduced her with four words, “The late Marilyn Monroe.” The room laughed. She let a white fur coat drop, and then she sang Happy Birthday to the President of the United States In a voice that was doing something nobody had asked it to do in public. When she finished, she went into a second verse set to the melody of thanks for the memory with new lyrics written for him. The crowd applauded.

 The president came to the stage and with a birthday cake being wheeled out behind him, he made a joke that he could now retire from politics after having had happy birthday sung to him in such a sweet wholesome way. That line is one of the very few things Jack Kennedy and Marilyn Monroe are documented saying to each other.

Everything else between them is memory. Then the crowd went home and the real evening began. There was a private reception at the townhouse of Arthur Krim, the United Artists executive who had chaired the fundraiser on East 69th Street. Guests arrived in the small hours. And inside that house, a White House photographer named Cecil Stoughton raised his camera and took a picture of Marilyn Monroe standing with John Kennedy and Robert Kennedy.

That is the photograph from the beginning of this story. One frame. The president, the attorney general, and the actress on the night she sang to him. It was not published for decades. It is the only proof that they were ever all in one room. She was back on a sound stage nine days later and at the end of May filmed the poolside sequence of Something’s Got to Give, her last footage for it.

Her birthday came on the 1st of June. She turned 36. The studio’s patience ran out within days. On the 8th of June, 1962, 20th Century Fox fired her and sued her over the absences. Dean Martin refused to continue with anyone else in her role. Without its two leads, the production shut down. Later there were talks about bringing her back.

 Nothing was settled before the summer ended. The last weeks of her life were photographed more than almost any other period of it. In June, Bert Stern shot her for Vogue at the Hotel Bel Air. In July, George Barris photographed her on a beach in Santa Monica near the same stretch of coastline where Peter Lawford’s house stood a little further along.

On the 3rd of August, Life magazine published a long interview with her by Richard Merryman, in which she talked about fame and about what she believed the public wanted from her. It landed in print a day and a half before she died, and it has been quoted more than anything else she ever said for a magazine.

On the weekend of the 28th and 29th of July, she was at Lake Tahoe at Cal Neva Lodge, a place that straddled the California and Nevada state line, and in which Frank Sinatra held an interest. There are photographs of her there. What happened beyond those photographs is disputed, and none of the versions in print rest on any document.

 That lodge has its own documented ending, though. In 1963, Nevada gaming regulators moved against Sinatra’s license after a man named Sam Giancana was reported to have been a guest there, and Sinatra gave up his interests. Two summers, two men, one address. And other stories were circulating that year. Some writers, working years later, placed Robert Kennedy at her house in the weeks before she died.

 People close to her and people close to him denied it flatly. A private investigator named Fred Otash claimed openly that recordings had been made at her home. In 60 years, no such recording has ever been produced. Here is what the record actually holds. On Saturday, August 4th, 1962, she was at home at Fifth Helena Drive.

Peter Lawford said afterward that he spoke to her on the telephone that evening, that she sounded drowsy, and that she seemed to him to be saying goodbye. He told that story more than once, and the details changed each time he told it. In the early hours of Sunday, August 5, her housekeeper, Eunice Murray, could not rouse her.

 The bedroom door was locked. Her psychiatrist, Ralph Greenson, arrived and got in by breaking a window. Marilyn Monroe was dead. She was 36. Police were called at around a quarter past 4:00 in the morning. The autopsy was performed that day by Thomas Noguchi, then a deputy medical examiner, later known as the coroner who handled the deaths of Robert Kennedy and Natalie Wood.

On August 17th, Chief Coroner Theodore Curphey announced the findings. Acute barbiturate poisoning, manner of death, probable suicide. The drugs involved, a barbiturate and a sedative, had all been prescribed to her. A panel of specialists had reviewed her state of mind in the weeks before her death in what came to be called a psychological autopsy.

Notice that one word, probable, not certain. The coroner’s own language left the door open, and everything you have ever heard about this case came through that door. There were other things. No pill residue was found in her stomach, a fact used by generations of writers to argue that she did not swallow what killed her.

There was a gap between when she was found and when the police were called, and Eunice Murray changed her account of the night more than once. She was buried on August 8th at Westwood Village Memorial Park in a small chapel at a private service arranged by Joe DiMaggio. Lee Strasberg gave the eulogy. Very few of the people who had photographed her, worked with her, or written about her were in the room.

For years afterward, according to widely repeated reports, DiMaggio had roses delivered to her crypt several times a week. 15 months later in Dallas, John Kennedy was killed. In June 1968, Robert Kennedy was killed in Los Angeles. Within 6 years of that night at Madison Square Garden, every person in that photograph was dead.

So, here is the honest answer to the question this story’s title asks. There is no document that shows Marilyn Monroe stood on that stage and revealed a secret. There is no transcript, no recording, no letter, no diary entry in any archive that has ever been produced showing that she threatened anyone with what she knew.

The idea that she exposed something in public that night is a story people have told for 60 years. It has never been shown to be true. What the night exposed was not a sentence. It was a pattern. Look at what was actually in that building on May 19th, 1962. The president, his brother, the attorney general, who ran the Justice Department, and who was, at that very moment, waging a war on organized crime.

His brother-in-law, an actor at the microphone, his alleged mistress on stage, and sitting at the back of the record, the fact that the FBI had, 10 weeks earlier, carried to the White House the name of a woman simultaneously connected to the president and to the mob. That is what the evening made visible. The overlap, the compartmentalized life and the public office standing in the same spotlight in front of 15,000 people and one camera.

 The president’s joke about retiring was funny precisely because everyone in that room understood what they were watching, and nobody was going to say it out loud. That is not a secret. That is a room full of people agreeing not to look. And then the theories came because a case with an open word in the verdict never closes. In October 1975, a journalist named Anthony Scaduto published an article claiming she had kept a red diary in which she wrote down confidential political information she had heard from the Kennedy brothers.

In time, an investigator named Milo Speriglio claimed he had seen that diary and that it had disappeared. Where is it? Nobody has ever produced it. Not in six decades, not a page. That diary is the single most repeated object in this entire story, and it has never been confirmed to exist. In July 1964, the FBI sent memos to Robert Kennedy warning him about a forthcoming book by Frank Capell called The Strange Death of Marilyn Monroe, which alleged that Kennedy had had an affair with her and had been in her apartment when she died. Those same

memos state that Kennedy was in San Francisco with his wife when she died, and the FBI’s own assessment of Capell’s material was that it was of a very questionable nature and not subject to corroboration from a man who refused to reveal his sources. The warning was real. The book was real. The relationship inside it was never proven.

In 1982, because the theories would not die, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office reviewed the whole case and reported in December that there was no credible evidence of foul play and no reason to overturn the original finding. But that report also admitted, in plain language, that factual discrepancies and unanswered questions remained.

 It did not claim to have solved anything. It claimed to have found nothing that would hold up. And that is where it still sits, more than 60 years later. Two questions left open. Whether the acquaintance between her and John Kennedy was a brief thing that meant little, as some who knew her insisted, or something much longer, as other writers described.

 And whether Robert Kennedy came to that house in the summer of 1962, as some witnesses swore and others denied. No document settles either one. The recording that was said to exist has never surfaced. The people who could have answered are gone, and most of them left behind only what they were later asked to remember.

 And so we come back to the tile. Cursum perficio. I complete the course. Two words said into the porch of the only house she ever bought for herself, in front of a door that a psychiatrist had to break a window to get through. Nobody knows if she chose them. They may have been there before her. They were certainly there after her.

The dress, on the other hand, is still here. In November 2016, it went to auction in Los Angeles and sold for $4.8 million to the Canadian businessman Jim Pattison and is now displayed to the public by Ripley’s Believe It or Not. 1999 had already pushed that same garment past a million. A dress that may or may not have been sewn onto her body is now one of the most expensive pieces of clothing ever sold, and it is the only object left from that night that anyone can actually touch. The photograph is the evidence.

The diary is the legend. The tile is the truth, and the truth is only this. A woman bought a house, put a Latin sentence on the step, and lived in it for a few months. If you have stayed with me this long, you already know more about this than most people who repeat it. So, I will leave you with the one question that has never been answered and probably never will be.

 Do you believe she was silenced, or do you believe a woman who had been failed by almost everyone in her life simply ran out of the strength to keep going? Both versions have believers. Only one of them has documents. Tell me which one you think wins, and tell me why in the comments, because I read them.

 

You Might Also Enjoy