News

The Tragic Life of the Habsburg Princess Who Was ‘Bred to Death’

 

A healthy boy had just been born in the Imperial Vienna Palace. His mother, Maria Antonia, was 23, the emperor’s daughter, and by Spain’s own reckoning heir to its empire. Within days, she had a fever, then pain, and a deep melancholy. She died on Christmas Eve, leaving a will that cut her husband out. Her mother had died at 21, pregnant again, and geneticists later ranked Maria Antonia the most inbred Habsburg of all.

That baby would soon be named heir to the entire Spanish Empire. We’ll get to what that did to him. But first, the title. Bred to death can mean two things here, and both deserve a fair test. The first is breeding in the genetic sense, a family that married its own nieces and cousins for generations. The second is breeding in the dynastic sense, young women married off to produce sons, pregnancy after pregnancy, until their bodies gave out.

Maria Antonia’s life touches both. Whether either one actually killed her is a harder question, and I’m not going to pretend it’s settled. To understand any of it, though, you have to start with her mother. Her mother was Margarita Teresa of Spain. If that name means nothing to you, her face probably does. She’s the little blonde girl at the center of Velázquez’s painting, Las Meninas, the 5-year-old princess in the wide skirts, surrounded by maids of honor.

She was born in Madrid in 1651, the daughter of King Philip IV, and her parents were already a problem. Philip had married his own niece, Mariana of Austria, who was nearly 30 years younger than him. So, Margarita was the child of an uncle and his niece. That’s the starting point. Keep it in mind, because the pattern is about to repeat.

Margarita had a younger brother who would become King Charles II of Spain. He was sickly from birth and nobody expected him to have children. That made his sister valuable. In Spain, unlike in much of Europe, a woman could inherit the crown if there was no son. So, whoever married Margarita might one day control Spain, its Italian kingdoms, the Spanish Netherlands, and most of the Americas.

The man chosen for her was Leopold I, the Holy Roman Emperor in Vienna. He was her mother’s brother, which made him her uncle. He was also her father’s nephew, which made him her cousin. She was promised to him at 8 years old. The marriage contract was signed in Madrid in December 1663 and two details in it stand out.

First, the dowry it promised was never actually paid. Second, and this was the real headline in diplomatic circles, nobody asked Margarita to give up her rights to Spain. Her older half-sister, who had married King Louis XIV of France, had been forced to renounce them. Margarita was not. Her German biographer calls this a political sensation across Europe and you can see why.

The Austrian Habsburgs now had a direct line to the Spanish throne. While she grew up, her future husband watched her grow on canvas. Velázquez painted a series of portraits of the young Infanta and several were sent to Vienna to show the emperor how his bride was developing. Three of them still hang in Vienna’s Kunsthistorisches Museum.

Leopold kept pressing for her to be sent. Her father kept delaying. Only after Philip IV died in September 1665 and her mother took over as regent of Spain did the wedding finally move forward. She left Madrid in the spring of 1666 at 14 and traveled for months through Barcelona, Milan, the Tyrol, and Carinthia. On the 26th of November, she finally met her husband at Schottwien, a small town on the road into Vienna from the south.

The wedding in Vienna followed in December. She was 15, he was 26. By the accounts that survive, the marriage was surprisingly warm. Both loved music, and Leopold was deeply musical himself. She surrounded herself almost entirely with Spaniards, her secretaries, confessors, and doctors, and hardly learned German.

And throughout the marriage, she called him “uncle”, the German word for uncle, not as a joke. That was simply what he was to her, and it was a family habit, not an oddity. Her own mother had married an uncle, too. The celebrations went on for almost 2 years. For her 17th birthday in July 1668, Leopold staged a famous opera, Il Pomo d’Oro, the golden apple, in an open-air theater built near the palace.

It became the most talked about theatrical event of the age. Everything about it announced that this teenage empress was the center of the court. But the court wanted something specific from her, and it wasn’t opera. It wanted a son. Leopold had no male heir. If he died without one, his branch of the family was in trouble.

A Spanish infanta married to the emperor was supposed to solve that, and quickly. She did her part almost immediately. Her first child, a boy named Ferdinand Wenzel, was born in September 1667, when she was 16. For a few months, the dynasty had what it wanted. Then, in January 1668, the baby died. He was less than 4 months old, so the pressure started again.

Margarita became pregnant again, and on the 18th of January, 1669, in the Hofburg Palace in Vienna, she gave birth to her second child. It was not the son everyone was waiting for. It was a girl. In Vienna, where the Habsburg lands passed to sons, a daughter solved nothing. In Spain, a daughter of Margarita might one day matter enormously.

They named her Maria Antonia. Nobody at that moment could possibly have known that she was the one child of this marriage who would grow up. There’s a portrait from around 1670 painted by the court artist Jan Thomas that shows Margarita with her small daughter. It still hangs in the Hofburg today. Two years later, in 1672, the family appeared together again.

This time on an altarpiece in Vienna’s Franciscan Church with Margarita kneeling alongside Leopold and the little girl. In both pictures, Maria Antonia is not the heir anyone hoped for. She is simply the child who is still alive. Because the babies kept coming and they kept dying. On the 20th of February, 1670, Margarita gave birth to a son, Johann Leopold.

He came early. He died the same day. During that frightening premature birth, according to her German biographer, Margarita made a religious vow. If she survived, the Jews would be expelled from Vienna and its lands. She survived. That summer, the expulsion went ahead. The Vienna synagogue was torn down. A church dedicated to Saint Leopold was built in its place and the district has been called Leopoldstadt ever since.

It’s a grim reminder that a single difficult birth in the palace could reshape the lives of thousands of people outside it. Then, in February 1672, a daughter, Maria Anna, she lived only about 2 weeks. Between these births, there were at least two miscarriages. In 6 years of marriage, Margarita had been pregnant six times.

Childbirth in her household was treated as a matter of state. Even the question of which midwife should attend the Empress was discussed, as one study puts it, at the highest diplomatic level, and she had never been strong. Since her youth, she had suffered from a goiter, a swelling of the thyroid gland in the neck.

By early 1673, she was pregnant for the seventh time. That winter, she caught bronchitis. According to her biographer, the infection and the goiter together proved fatal. She suffocated. Margarita Teresa died in the Hofburg on the 12th of March, 1673. She was 21 years old. Maria Antonia was four. What happened next tells you a lot about the court she was growing up in.

The Swedish envoy in Vienna, Esaias Pufendorf, wrote a report on the Imperial Court in these years. In it, he noted that people commonly regarded Margarita’s death as a stroke of luck for the Austrian branch of the family. A young woman had just died in her seventh pregnancy, and the gossip was that the dynasty had come out ahead.

The reasoning was cold, but simple. She had not produced a surviving son, and a new wife might. Leopold himself seems to have grieved genuinely. He remembered her as his unica Margarita, his only Margarita. But grief and dynasty ran on separate tracks. Her biographer notes that even while Margarita was still alive, Leopold had kept open the option of marrying another relative, Archduchess Claudia Felicitas, from the Tyrolean branch of the family.

Four months after Margarita’s death, he announced that he would marry her. Before the year was out, he had. So, within a few months, the four-year-old in the Hofburg had lost her mother and gained a stepmother. And something else had changed, something she could not possibly understand yet. Her value had multiplied.

Remember that Margarita had never renounced her rights to Spain. Her brother, King Charles II, was still childless, and most people doubted he ever would have children. In Madrid, the royal government now regarded the four-year-old Maria Antonia as the legitimate heir to the Spanish crown, not Leopold, not any son Leopold might have with a new wife, her.

That position, as one recent historian has shown, would be defended by Madrid for the rest of her life, despite constant complaints from Vienna and Paris. Spanish law let a daughter inherit. Austrian Habsburg custom put sons first. Maria Antonia sat exactly on the fault line between the two. Now, about that word in the title.

In 2013, two geneticists at the University of Santiago de Compostela, Francisco Ceballos and a colleague, published a study of inbreeding across the whole Habsburg dynasty. They built family trees covering more than 4,000 people over more than 20 generations and calculated something called the inbreeding coefficient for each person.

Here’s the plain English version. The coefficient estimates the chance that the two copies of a given gene a person inherits are identical because both came down from the same ancestor. The child of unrelated parents scores close to zero. The child of first cousins scores about 0.06. The child of a brother and sister or a parent and child scores 0.25.

Charles II, the famously frail last Spanish Habsburg came out at 0.254. Leopold Maria Antonia’s father was the most inbred of all the emperors at 0.1568. And the highest figure anywhere in the dynasty belonged to the little girl in those family pictures. Maria Antonia’s coefficient was 0.3053. Higher, the authors pointed out, than the expected figure for a child born of incest.

The reason is the knot we’ve already traced. Her father was her mother’s uncle and cousin. Her mother’s parents were uncle and niece. Generation after generation, the same few bloodlines folded back on themselves. Two cautions, though, before this number carries more weight than it can bear. First, it is a calculation from family trees, which the authors assembled partly from online genealogical sources.

It describes her pedigree, not her body. Second, the same study found that inbreeding lowered children’s chances of surviving infancy and childhood across 71 Habsburg families as a whole. That is a pattern across more than 500 pregnancies. It does not tell us why any single person lived or died. And Maria Antonia, against the odds of that pedigree, lived.

Of Margarita’s children, she was the only one who did. Which meant that everything Margarita had been to two empires, she now was. So, what was she like? This child who carried two empires worth of expectations. The honest answer is that we know less than we’d want. Her entry in the standard German national biography sums her up in a single line.

From childhood, she was quiet and reserved, no beauty, but striking. Another Habsburg reference work puts the central contradiction of her life even more bluntly. Leopold loved his daughter, it says, and sacrificed her to reasons of state all the same. The household around her kept changing. Her first stepmother, Claudia Felicitas, gave Leopold two daughters and neither survived infancy.

Then, in 1676, Claudia Felicitas died, too, at just 23. Leopold was now desperate for a son, and he married a third time without delay. His new wife was Eleonor Magdalena of Palatinate-Neuburg, intensely pious and, by the accounts of the court, a harmonious match for him. Decades later, the English writer Lady Mary Wortley Montagu met her in Vienna and was struck by her devotion.

The empress, she wrote, was always performing extraordinary acts of penance without having ever done anything to deserve them. That was the new tone of the household. Maria Antonia was seven. She had already lost her mother, four baby siblings and half-siblings, and a stepmother. That same year, 1676, something else was decided for her.

At the urging of the court in Vienna, a marriage contract was concluded between 7-year-old Maria Antonia and King Charles II of Spain. Just look at that relationship for a moment. Charles was her mother’s brother, her uncle. The plan was to marry the girl to her mother’s brother, exactly as her mother had been married to her own mother’s brother, and her grandmother before that to an uncle as well.

The logic from Vienna’s point of view was tidy. Charles was the last male Spanish Habsburg. Maria Antonia was the next in line after him. Marry them and the Spanish inheritance would stay inside the family no matter what happened. The aim, as her biographer puts it, was to secure the unity of the whole House of Austria.

Whether a 7-year-old girl and a 14-year-old king with lifelong health problems were a good idea for each other did not enter into the paperwork. And this was the girl who, as the geneticists would later calculate, already carried the most folded-in family tree in the dynasty. It never happened. In Madrid, the balance of power shifted.

Factions rose and fell around the young king, and other European courts pushed their own candidates. In 1679, Charles married someone else entirely, Marie Louise of Orléans, a niece of Louis XIV of France. Historians count it a clear diplomatic victory for France. For Maria Antonia, it meant she would not be marrying her uncle after all.

You might expect that to make her less important. It did the opposite. In 1678, Leopold’s third wife gave him what three marriages had been chasing, a healthy son, Joseph. More sons followed, including a boy named Charles in 1685. For Leopold, this should have solved everything. But it created a new problem, and Maria Antonia was standing right in the middle of it.

Here’s why. Leopold’s new sons were not descended from Philip IV of Spain. Their claim to Spain came only through Leopold’s own mother, a Spanish princess of an earlier generation. Under Spanish rules of succession, the line of Margarita, Philip IV’s daughter, came first. That meant Maria Antonia stood ahead of her half brothers.

If Charles II died childless, Spain would not go to Leopold’s sons. It would go to her, and then to her children, whoever their father turned out to be. So, the question in Vienna quietly changed. It was no longer how to keep her in the family, it was how to get her out of the way. Leopold wanted Spain for his sons.

To do that, he would need his daughter to give up her own rights, and he would need to marry her to someone who would accept that. The whole plan rested on a signature she had not yet given. Meanwhile, she was simply growing up at a court she had known all her life. There’s a portrait of her painted around 1684 by Benjamin von Block, now in Vienna’s Kunsthistorisches Museum.

She’s about 15 in it. It’s the picture her biographers point to when they describe her. Not a beauty by the standards of the day, but a face you remember. A year before that portrait, in the summer of 1683, the war had come to Vienna itself. An Ottoman army laid siege to the city. On the 12th of September, 1683, a relief army broke the siege in the Battle of the Kahlenberg, on the heights above Vienna.

Among the commanders was a 21-year-old prince who had brought the Bavarian army with him. Maximilian II Emmanuel, Elector of Bavaria. Everyone called him Max Emmanuel. He was young, brave in battle, and admired across Europe for his courage. His father had spent years leaning toward France. The emperor badly needed him to lean toward Vienna instead, and to keep sending troops against the Turks.

The emperor’s diplomats had already been working on him. Since 1682, the imperial envoy in Munich, Count Dominik Andreas Kaunitz, had been keeping the young elector on the emperor’s side. And that same year, Kaunitz hosted him in his own house in Vienna and on his estates in Moravia. They had also worked out what Bavaria might want in return.

As a historian of the period notes, Maria Antonia had become an object of dynastic diplomacy at the age of 13. Her hand had been held out to Bavaria as a prize. The girl promised to her uncle at 7:00 was now about to be offered to the hero of Vienna. There was only one difficulty. The hero of Vienna had his eye on somebody else.

The other woman, as far as the sources tell us, was a pretty daughter of the Duke of Saxe-Eisenach. Max Emanuel had noticed her, and she came from a far smaller German house with nothing to offer in Spain. According to the historians of the Bavarian State Archives, it took real effort from his own privy councilors to talk him round.

They kept laying out the political advantages of the emperor’s daughter before he was finally convinced. He had help being persuaded from a less official direction, too. The Imperial Envoy, Count Kollowrat, had a wife, Maria Eleonore, whom his biographer describes as witty and beautiful. Through her, the biographer says, Kollowrat exercised a long and important influence over the young elector.

The marriage to the emperor’s daughter is credited in particular to her powers of persuasion. That’s the documented version of events, and it’s worth noticing what it does and doesn’t say. It does not claim an affair. It says the woman who talked Max Emanuel into this marriage was somebody else’s charming wife.

By April 1684 at the latest, Max Emanuel formally asked for Maria Antonia’s hand. Her biographer is blunt about what kind of match this was, a purely political marriage. The price Bavaria paid was clear. It would turn away from France, which Max Emanuel’s father had favored for years, and it would keep fighting the Turks for the emperor.

In return, Max Emanuel got the emperor’s daughter, and with her a stake in the biggest inheritance question in Europe. That last part was exactly the problem in Vienna. Leopold’s advisers wanted Bavaria’s soldiers. They did not want a Bavarian on the Spanish throne. So, before any wedding, Maria Antonia would have to give up her rights to Spain.

The emperor’s men tried to do this properly. They sent the plan to Madrid suggesting that Charles II sweeten her renunciation by handing the Spanish Netherlands, roughly modern Belgium and Luxembourg, to the couple. Madrid’s reaction was mostly hostile. Spain’s ministers would not hear of a renunciation at all.

The succession, they said, was a Spanish matter, and they would thank the emperor not to interfere. So, Vienna went around Madrid. On the 15th of May, 1685, the marriage contract between Max Emmanuel and Maria Antonia was concluded in Vienna. Its figures were generous. Her dowry was set at 100,000 guilders. Max Emmanuel matched it with a further 100,000 as a marriage settlement and promised her a morning gift, the traditional present to a bride after the wedding night, of 50,000 more.

Her biographer adds that her trousseau was valued at 200,000 guilders. One small detail in the contract says a great deal. The papal dispensation was still pending. This couple, as so often in these families, were related closely enough to need the church’s permission. Max Emmanuel’s grandmother was Leopold’s aunt.

The contract also covered death. If Maria Antonia died, the eighth article said, her children would remain in her husband’s care and her estate would remain with him. Keep that clause in mind. And the official contract was only half the business that day. Outside it, in a separate and secret document, Maria Antonia gave up her rights to the Spanish monarchy.

The The archivist’s account says she did so under pressure from her father with the consent of her future husband. There was one exception, the Spanish Netherlands. Though she kept, and Leopold promised, that if he or his sons ever inherited Spain, the couple would rule the Netherlands as sovereigns. He also promised to try to get Charles II to give Max Emmanuel the government there as soon as possible.

She was 16. We have no letter, no diary entry, no reported words of hers about what she signed that day. What we have is the arrangement itself. A teenage girl signing away an empire because her father needed it for his sons. Max Emmanuel, for his part, signed with a light heart, as her biographer puts it, and he had his reasons.

His wife was still a Spanish infanta by birth. And the renunciation had procedural weaknesses that meant it could be challenged later. According to that same account, his near goal was the Spanish inheritance, and his distant goal, the Austrian one. He was not giving up anything he believed he had truly lost. He turned out to be right, at least about Madrid.

When the emperor’s side finally presented the secret document there, in May 1687, Charles II firmly rejected it. The Spanish king never accepted his niece’s renunciation as valid. In Madrid’s eyes, nothing had changed. Maria Antonia was still the heir. So, consider where that left her. Her father had pressed her to give up Spain.

Her husband had accepted it while privately expecting to get around it. And the king whose crown it was had declared the whole thing worthless. Everyone involved was using her claim, and nobody actually agreed on whether she still had it. The wedding took place in Vienna in July 1685. Most sources give the 15th.

The inscription later engraved on her coffin says the 12th. She was 16. He was 23, already a famous commander. The Latin on that coffin would later remind readers that by the time of the wedding, he had defeated the Turks in Hungary again and again. A medal was struck for the occasion. It shows Max Emanuel in armor, standing on trophies of war, receiving a laurel wreath from his bride, who stands on flowers.

Around them runs the motto, “Mars et Venus omnia vincunt.” Mars and Venus conquer all. It was a lovely piece of propaganda. War and love, the hero and his bride. The question was, what this particular Venus was actually getting. Just outside Munich, a palace was already going up for her. It had been commissioned for the marriage, and its decoration would celebrate the goddess of the hunt.

The palace was called Lustheim, and it still stands in the park of Schleißheim, north of Munich. Max Emanuel’s court architect, Enrico Zucalli, designed it as an Italian-style garden villa on its own little island, with a grand banqueting hall and suites for the electoral couple on either side. The Bavarian Palace Administration describes the motive as romantic.

A building commissioned for his marriage to the emperor’s daughter. Her biographer adds that he had ordered it long before the wedding itself, with the bride still in Vienna. It was built quickly, between 1684 and 1688. Then you look up at the ceilings. The fresco cycle there honors Diana, the goddess of the hunt.

Lustheim was a hunting lodge. It was built for the wedding, but it was built around his pleasures. Even the bridal carriage has a story. It was made, apparently in Paris, in the workshop of a saddler named Saunier. A small detail, but a slightly ironic one for a man who had just promised the emperor to turn his back on France.

On the 9th of October, 1685, the couple made their ceremonial entry into Munich. The court celebrated with full Baroque splendor, including a new opera, Servio Tullio, by the composer Agostino Steffani. Max Emanuel’s envoy to Madrid, sent to announce the marriage, was in a hurry to get home that autumn so he could help prepare the Archduchess’s solemn entry.

Spain, for its part, planned an embassy of its own to Munich to congratulate the couple and, as it turned out, to offer Maria Antonia condolences on the death of her step-grandmother, the Dowager Empress. And then, the marriage had to be lived. Her biographer doesn’t soften it. The couple had little in common. She was shy and delicate.

He was temperamental, admired as the Blue King for his bravery, and he loved his festivals. She was not made, in that account’s words, to be the radiant center of a court that ran on an unbroken round of parties. She could not keep her husband’s mistresses away from court. And then comes the sentence that stops you. On the contrary, it says, “Max Emanuel treated her in an unbearable manner.

” We don’t know the names of the women in those years. Some modern retellings supply one, but without a reliable source, so I’m leaving it out rather than inventing a rival for this story. What the historians agree on is the pattern. A modern account from the Bavarian State Archives describes him as a lover of life who thought little of marital fidelity.

She, by the same account, became sickly and depressed. He was also simply absent a great deal. Max Emanuel had promised the emperor soldiers, and he delivered himself along with them. It was Kaunitz again who had helped persuade him to go to Hungary as a commander. He spent the campaigning seasons fighting the Turks there, and in 1688, he took Belgrade.

A 19th-century Austrian reference work listing his marriage to Maria Antonia introduces him as the conqueror of Belgrade. That was his public identity, and it was a glorious one. Hers was the emperor’s daughter he had married. Then, there was the money. Remember Margarita’s dowry, the one promised in Madrid and never paid? It didn’t vanish.

Maria Antonia was her mother’s heir, so the claim passed to her. When Maria Antonia married, Leopold assigned her that unpaid Spanish dowry, 500,000 gold escudos, plus all the interest it should have earned since 1666. On paper, that was an enormous fortune. In practice, it meant the couple would have to extract it from Charles II themselves.

So, in September 1686, Max Emmanuel sent an envoy to Madrid, a man named Lancier, whose main job was to collect it. It went badly from the start. His rank was so unclear to the Spanish court that, as he complained in his letters, ambassadors and ministers would not even give him their hand. He stayed in Madrid for more than 10 years.

He never got the money. Nobody did. The dispute dragged on for decades, and after a death we’ll come to, it became one more quarrel between Bavaria and Vienna. According to the historian Rotheo Martinez Lopez, the Bavarian government was still demanding payment of that dowry at the beginning of the 19th century.

Maria Antonia’s mother had been promised it as a child in 1663, and well over a century later, her family was still waiting. Spain, meanwhile, continued to treat her as its heir. The court in Madrid had rejected her renunciation and her rights remained, in its eyes, intact. Diplomats could argue about her claim forever.

Only a living child could turn it into a throne. Everything depended on one thing she alone could provide, a child. And for a long time, there wasn’t one. They married in July, 1685. A year passed with no child, then two, then three. For a woman whose entire value to both Bavaria and Spain lay in producing an heir, every one of those years mattered.

Her own mother had become pregnant within months of her wedding. Maria Antonia, through no fault anyone could have named, did not. Toward the end of 1688, she finally was pregnant. Max Emmanuel’s reaction tells you how he saw the news. As the Bavarian archivist’s account puts it, he immediately began reminding Vienna of the emperor’s old promise about the Spanish Netherlands.

His wife was carrying a possible heir to Spain. That made his claim to Brussels more pressing, and it left Leopold, as the archivist put it, in an awkward situation. So, the pregnancy was, from the very beginning, also a negotiating position. The baby was due in the spring of 1689, almost 4 years after the wedding.

For the first time, Maria Antonia was about to give both of the courts that had bargained over her exactly what they had married her to produce. On the 22nd of May, 1689, Maria Antonia gave birth to a son. They named him Leopold Ferdinand. For the elector, this was the heir to Bavaria. For the court in Madrid, it was a possible future king of Spain.

For Maria Antonia, after almost 4 years of waiting, it was her first child. He lived only a few days. The sources disagree slightly on exactly how many. A 19th century Austrian reference work gives his death as the 24th of May. The Bavarian State Archives say 3 days. Either way, the boy who had been a diplomatic argument before he was born was buried within the week.

She became pregnant again. On the 28th of November, 1690, she gave birth to a second son, Anton. This time there was no doubt about the danger. He was given an emergency baptism, the kind performed when a newborn was not expected to survive long enough for the full ceremony. He died the same day. Two sons, two graves in 18 months.

She was 21. It is tempting, after everything we’ve heard about her family tree, to draw a straight line from that inbreeding figure to these two small coffins. Let’s be careful about that line. The Habsburg study did find something relevant. Across the dynasty, babies born to more closely related were less likely to survive their first year.

And in the later period, the 1600s and 1700s, that effect on infants did not fade. But that is a statistical pattern across many families. Babies in every European family of the time died at rates we would find horrifying today. Nobody can tell us why Leopold Ferdinand and Anton died. What we can say is that the dynasty that married its nieces paid on average in exactly this currency.

What it did to her, the sources only sketch. The Bavarian archivist’s account describes her in these years as sickly and as depressed by an unhappy marriage to a man who cared little for fidelity. She was barely 22 and she had already done what her mother had done, carried children for the dynasty and buried them.

Meanwhile, the stakes in Spain had shifted under her feet. Charles II’s first wife, the French princess, died in 1689 after 10 years of marriage childless. He married again, and his new queen was Maria Anna of Neuburg. That name matters. She was the sister of Leopold’s third wife, Eleonore, which meant that the new queen of Spain was the aunt of Maria Antonia’s half-brothers, the very boys Leopold wanted on the Spanish throne instead of her.

Maria Antonia’s claim now had a rival inside the Spanish royal household. Max Emanuel, for his part, was thinking about Brussels. For years he had been pressing for the government of the Spanish Netherlands, the prize promised in her secret renunciation. Toward the end of 1691, the post came open. The governor general in Brussels resigned. Max Emanuel didn’t wait for Vienna this time.

He applied directly to Madrid. Spain was at war with France, the Netherlands were the front line, and the Spanish Council of State wanted a capable soldier. They gave him the job. Max Emanuel was 29. His envoy Baumgarten reached Madrid on the 20th of March, 1692, to thank the king for the appointment, and to ask, while he was at it, for more money and more troops.

It was, as one historian puts it, a step full of promise. And there was a further advantage that the archivists spell out clearly. Her renunciation had changed nothing in Madrid’s official position. As the wife of Spain’s new governor in Brussels, Maria Antonia was still, in Spanish eyes, in line for the throne.

Max Emanuel now had a foot in the door of the Spanish monarchy and a direct line to the king. On the 26th of March, 1692, Max Emanuel arrived in Brussels to take up his post. He arrived without his wife. She was, by then, pregnant again. At first, she stayed behind in Munich. And now comes the one moment in this story where Maria Antonia does something that nobody had planned for her.

She refused to stay. The Bavarian archivists put it plainly. Maria Antonia was not willing to live alone in Munich for good. She left Bavaria and went back to her father’s court in Vienna. Her husband ordered her to return to Munich. The Bavarian estates, the assembly of nobles, clergy, and towns that spoke for the country added their own urgent pleas.

An electress belonged in her husband’s capital, and an heir to Bavaria belonged on Bavarian soil. None of it moved her. She stayed in Vienna. We have no letter in which she explains herself. We only have what she did. Her biographer frames it the same way. When Max Emanuel finally became governor of the Netherlands, his pregnant wife did not go with him to Brussels.

She went to her father instead. Some popular accounts claim he took a mistress with him to Brussels, or that everyone assumed the marriage was finished. Those claims circulate without solid sources, so I’ll leave them aside. The documented facts are striking enough. A 23-year-old woman who had been bargained over since she was seven, who had signed away an empire under her father’s pressure, who had buried two infant sons, finally said no to the two institutions that had run her life, her husband and his country. But there’s an irony in

where she went. She did not go somewhere free. She went home, to the palace where her mother had died in pregnancy at 21, to the father who had pressed her into the renunciation. Of all the places open to her, the Hofburg was the one she chose. And so the next heir to Bavaria, and possibly to Spain, would be born not in Munich and not in Brussels, but in Vienna.

Nothing like it had ever happened before. For Bavaria, this was a genuine problem. The birth of an elector’s child abroad was, as the Bavarian archivist put it, a novelty. If the electress would not come to the heir’s homeland, the homeland would have to come to her. Representatives of the Bavarian estates and of the Munich court traveled to Vienna so that they could be present at the delivery and witness it.

Two people were put in charge of her care. One was Dr. von Walther, the head of Munich’s College of Physicians. The other was a woman with her own reason to remember Vienna, Countess Maria Antonia della Perusa. Her husband, a Bavarian officer, had died of dysentery on the 26th of September, 1683, in the Bavarian army camp outside the city during the campaign that relieved the siege.

Nine years later, his widow was back in Vienna, watching over the electress through the last months of her pregnancy. Keep an eye on the countess. She is about to become one of the most important people in this story. The Bavarian court kept its own office in Vienna during the electress’s stay, a branch of its secret chancellery, and that office kept a diary.

Its entry for the birth begins with the date and the feast day, the 28th of October, the feast of Saints Simon and Jude. Then it notes the time. At half past two in the morning, while the sky still showed clear and full of stars, the alarm went up at court in the electress’s rooms. The archivists who published that passage remarked that it reads almost like the opening of an Alpine Christmas story, hopeful, confident, nothing in it suggests what was coming.

At 4:00 in the morning, Maria Antonia gave birth to a son. The delivery was quick and uncomplicated. The baby was strong and healthy. He was baptized the same day and the list of his names survives on a separate sheet in the Bavarian archives. Joseph Ferdinand Leopold Anton Francis Cajetan Simon Thaddeus and Ignatius.

Some names came from the two families, others honored saints including the two whose feast it was. His godparents tell you exactly what this child was for. Emperor Leopold stood godfather but as a stand-in for an absent sponsor, King Charles II of Spain. The Empress and Leopold’s eldest son joined him.

The boy was carried to his baptism in the arms of Countess de la Perouse. So within hours of his birth, the King of Spain had been made by proxy godfather to the child that Madrid’s government already regarded as a future heir to his crown. We’ll call that child by the first two of his names, Joseph Ferdinand. Bavaria celebrated from a distance with its Electress in one foreign capital and its Elector in another, the estates commissioned a medal.

On one side, the baby prince stands on a pedestal wrapped in a lion skin wearing a prince’s hat with the coats of arms of Bavaria and Habsburg leaning against his feet. In one tiny hand he holds a scepter, in the other the orb that stands for worldly rule. On the reverse, the orb rests on top of the globe under the words Deo auspice, under God’s protection.

For a few days everything looked right. The child she had fought to bear in her own father’s house had arrived safely. This time she had produced what her first two deliveries had not, a son who lived. Then Maria Antonia fell ill. The Bavarian archivist’s account is short and specific and I’m going to stay close to it because this is where the temptation to embellish is strongest.

A few days after the birth, she developed a fever. She complained of headaches and of pains in her abdomen. She became melancholic, the period word for a deep persistent low mood, and she began to doubt that she would get better. We’ll come back to what those symptoms might and might not tell us. That last detail is the closest we come to hearing her.

Not a quoted sentence, but a recorded attitude. The people around her noticed that she no longer believed she would recover. None of the doctors treating her could help, the Munich physician included. Her biographer describes the same weeks from another angle. After the birth, she recovered only with great difficulty and then fell into melancholy.

She never regained her strength. October turned into November and November into December. Through all of it, her son was healthy, feeding from a wet nurse, watched over by the countess. The Bavarian delegates who had come to witness a birth now found themselves watching a death unfold. We don’t know exactly what she was told or what she asked for in most of those weeks.

But we do know she was not passive at the end of her life. She left a last will. And in it, as we’ll see, she did something that ran directly against the marriage contract her father had signed for her seven years earlier. Maria Antonia, Electress of Bavaria, Archduchess of Austria, died in the Hofburg in Vienna on the 24th of December, 1692, Christmas Eve.

The inscription later engraved on her coffin records the hour as half past five. It doesn’t say whether in the morning or the evening. She was 23 years old. Her son was eight weeks old. The archivist’s phrase for how she died is the old one, in childbed. She died in the same palace where her mother had died. The two deaths were 19 years apart.

Margarita had been 21, Maria Antonia was 23. And her husband? Max Emanuel was in Brussels governing the Spanish Netherlands and fighting the French. The sources I’ve worked from record no word of his reaction to her death. What they do record, very clearly, is what he did next. But before we get to that, we need to look at what she had decided about him.

Remember the eighth article of her marriage contract? If Maria Antonia died, her children would stay in her husband’s care and her estate would stay with him. That was the arrangement her father and her husband had signed in 1685. Her last will did the opposite. I haven’t seen the text of the will itself, so I’m relying here on her biographer’s summary in the German National Biography, which is clear and specific.

She disinherited Max Emanuel. Her private property was to go to her baby son. If the boy died, it was to pass to the emperor, her father, and his family. Only a few keepsakes were to remain permanently with the House of Bavaria. Everything else, the husband was to lose. Her biographer reads it in one sentence, “Even in the face of death, she did not forgive her husband.

” That’s an interpretation, not a quotation from her, but it’s hard to read the will any other way. After 7 years of what that same biographer called unbearable treatment, the only document in this story that seems to carry her own decision cuts him out. There’s a second clause, though, and it’s more complicated.

In the same will, she renounced the Spanish monarchy once again for herself and for her heirs. Think about who that helped. Not her husband, whose whole strategy depended on her claim, not obviously her son, who would inherit through her. On its face, it helped her father, who wanted Spain for his sons by his third wife.

She was dying in Leopold’s palace, under his roof, surrounded by his court. Whether this was her own conviction, her father’s influence, or simple loyalty to the family she had come home to, the sources don’t say, and I won’t pretend to know. What we can say is that her last will cut out the husband who had humiliated her and confirmed the plan of the father who had pressed her to sign it away in the first place.

As we’ll see, Madrid would have something to say about that renunciation, too. The will contained one more wish, and this one is quoted directly. The Capuchin Crypt in Vienna, the burial vault of the Habsburgs, explains why she lies there rather than in Bavaria. A contemporary record says it was because her will made known that she wished to be laid beside her lady mother in the Capuchin Church. So she was.

Maria Antonia was buried in the Imperial Crypt in Vienna next to Margarita. Her coffin was made by a craftsman named Thomas Koch from Munich out of lead alloy. Its lid is oddly high and sloped. A crucifix runs the entire length of it with a skull and crossed bones beneath. And it is covered in Latin inscriptions, which the crypt has published.

Read them and you notice what they choose to say about her. The main inscription lists her titles and her death in Vienna in 1692, and then calls her a princess most illustrious by birth, by marriage, by childbirth, and by death. Ortu, coniugio, partu, morti. One side panel records her wedding to Max Emanuel, adding that by then he had often defeated the Turks gloriously.

The other records, in its words, a most happy birth, the son she bore to the hope of the fatherland and of the house of Bavaria, and at the head the final image. She met death, it says, with the same Austrian piety with which she had lived, 2 months after giving birth, like the dawn which brings forth the sun for the world and then is extinguished.

It is a genuinely beautiful line. It is also, if you sit with it, a precise description of what she was used for: birth, marriage, childbirth, death. The dawn exists to deliver the sun. So, what actually killed her? Here’s what the record gives us. Fever beginning a few days after a quick and easy delivery, headaches, abdominal pain, a deepening low mood, and death about 8 weeks later.

The Bavarian archivists say she died in childbed fever. An abdominal pain in the days after giving birth fit the pattern that doctors later called childbed fever, usually an infection of the womb after delivery. Before antibiotics, it killed enormous numbers of new mothers in palaces as well as cottages.

That’s a reasonable possibility. It is not a diagnosis. These symptoms can come from other causes, too, and nobody examined her in a way that could settle the question. The melancholy is just as tricky. Some modern writers suggest postpartum depression. Maybe. But a young woman with weeks of fever, who has buried two babies and senses she is dying, does not need a psychiatric label to explain despair.

The honest answer is that we have a period word and no way to look behind it. You’ll find a further claim online, stated confidently, that a particular bacterium killed her and that her inbred genes made the infection worse. I haven’t found a solid source for either part, so treat it as speculation. Which brings us back to the title, was she bred to death? In the genetic sense, she was certainly bred.

Her coefficient, the highest in the dynasty, is a real calculation from a real family tree. But the study behind it looked at whether children survived, not whether mothers did, and it cannot tell us why one woman died at 23. Nobody can honestly say that her pedigree killed her. In the other sense, the case is stronger and simpler.

Her mother was married at 15 and died at 21 in her seventh pregnancy. Maria Antonia was married at 16 and died at 23 weeks after her third delivery in about 3 and 1/2 years. Two women in the same palace, 19 years apart, used up producing heirs for the same family. And the heir she died producing was still alive, 8 weeks old, in a palace his father now considered dangerous.

Max Emanuel did not come to Vienna. But from Brussels he gave an order, his son was to be brought to Munich. The Bavarian archivists explain why. After Maria Antonia’s death, he feared for the baby’s safety at the Imperial Court for dynastic reasons. Leopold wanted Spain for his own son Charles.

A Bavarian grandson with a better Spanish claim might look to the emperor less like family and more like competition. Max Emanuel wanted the boy out of Leopold’s reach. So moving a baby barely 6 months old was planned like a military operation. A memorandum of the 20th of March, 1693, weighed four ways of moving him. By boat up the Danube and the Inn, by coach, by carried chair, or in a litter slung between mules.

The river was rejected because, as the memo put it, the water at that time of year was still cold and damp and might harm the electoral prince’s health. Coaches might overturn, porters might stumble, mule litters won. Inside, the baby was held in someone’s arms the whole way. Three physicians traveled with him.

Max Emanuel personally insisted that one of them, Dr. Karl Ferdinand Vacquiery, trained in Padua and trusted from the Turkish wars, be placed in charge of the boy’s health. Countess de la Perouse carried a traveling pharmacy prepared specifically for him. They left Vienna on the 7th of May, 1693, and reached Munich on the 7th of June.

At the Bavarian border, a delegation of the estates was waiting. At the shrine of Altötting, the baby was carried into the holy chapel, and his uncle Joseph Clemens, Max Emanuel’s younger brother and Elector of Cologne, traveled there just to see him. His father did not come. And by then, his father was already thinking about a new wife.

According to Poland’s Wilanów Palace Museum, by January 1693, within weeks of Maria Antonia’s death, plans were taking shape for Max Emanuel to marry Teresa Kunigunda Sobieska, the daughter of the Polish king Jan Sobieski, who had led the relief of Vienna in 1683. The marriage took place by proxy in Warsaw in 1694. So, the boy grew up in Munich without either parent.

Because his father lived in Brussels, and every post carried a report on the boy, his childhood is unusually well documented. He had a suite of three rooms in the Munich Palace. The countess raised him. She, in the archivist’s words, took on the role of the main woman in his life. The letters give us glimpses of a real small child.

In March 1693, still in Vienna, he was already having trouble with his teeth, and the countess had masses said to Saint Apollonia, the patron saint of toothache. He took his first steps at 15 months. Before he turned two, he was scribbling with pen and ink, and one sheet of his scribbles was saved and sent to Brussels as the electoral prince’s first letter to his father.

There’s a report from the feast of Saint Nicholas in December 1695. The 3-year-old walked up to the saint, kissed his hand, recited the Our Father and the Hail Mary, and was praised and scolded in turn. The scolding for being restless and willful at mass. Then came the presents. Some of them, the report notes, came from his mother’s estate.

What delighted him most were drums, tournament heads, and toy lances. Among his treasures was a rattle. It was gilded and set with diamonds, with little bells, a whistle built into the handle, and a badger’s claw on a chain to ward off harm. Leopold gave it to him at his birth, and according to the archivist who cataloged it, it had probably been made for the birth of his mother back in 1669.

Her rattle had become his. His father wrote to him, too. In November 1697, the 5-year-old sent a written request, an adult guiding his hand, asking for a pardon for a company of guards. Max Emanuel granted it. His reply opened, “Mein Herz Liebste Sohn.” My dearly beloved son, and came with fatherly instructions.

“Fear God, obey, study hard, and tame your temper.” Meanwhile, Madrid was choosing a king. At the Spanish court, the boy’s great-grandmother, the old queen mother Mariana, became his most powerful champion. She considered Margarita’s line, and so this child, the rightful one. In 1696, mere months after Mariana’s death, Charles II fell seriously ill and signed a will naming Joseph Ferdinand his universal heir.

Then, in January 1698, the boy fell dangerously ill in Munich. His doctors briefly feared it was smallpox. He recovered, but the scare poisoned his father’s relations with Vienna. Max Emanuel, the archivist writes, “became deeply suspicious and believed the emperor’s people wanted the child dead.” He resolved to bring his son to Brussels.

In May 1698, at Turnhout, Max Emanuel met his son for the first time. He was five and a half. At the father’s own request, they met alone. That autumn, the great powers decided they could live with him. On the 24th of September, 1698, France, England, and the Dutch Republic secretly agreed that Joseph Ferdinand should receive Spain itself, the Netherlands, and most of the empire overseas.

And on the 11th of November, 1698, Charles II signed a new will. It named his heir as the electoral prince, the only son of the archduchess Maria Antonia, his niece. The scribes even got the boy’s name slightly wrong, calling him Joseph Maximilian, but one phrase was unmistakable. “He was to be king,” the will declared, “notwithstanding any renunciations made to the contrary, since they lacked just reasons and proper solemnities.

” The renunciation she had signed at 16 under her father’s pressure and repeated in her will had just been brushed aside by the one man whose crown it concerned. Her son was now Prince of Asturias, heir to the entire Spanish empire. In Brussels, at first, he thrived. Dr. Vacquier noted that for 6 weeks the electoral prince had seemed better than ever before.

Then, in In second half of January, 1699, something changed. For about 2 weeks, the doctor wrote, “The boy’s spirit was not as cheerful and lively as usual. His sleep was uneven, and his face showed a certain weariness.” Everyone assumed new teeth were coming. Then, from the night of the 24th of January, he was clearly ill, slightly feverish, restless, talking in his sleep.

He began to vomit, and he kept vomiting. He fought the purges and enemas his doctors prescribed as hard as a 6-year-old could. Reading Vaccari’s report today is hard because everyone in it is trying so hard. On the 2nd of February, deciding the trouble lay in his stomach, the doctors gave him chocolate served in a tiny cup with two drops of essence of ambergris to strengthen his stomach and nourish him.

He could not keep it down. They gave him a consecrated slip of paper dedicated to the Immaculate Conception to swallow, a devotional remedy of the time. He said he was hungry. Nothing stayed in. On the 5th of February, he was weak, his pulse faint, but cheerful and clear-headed enough that his doctors and attendants took hope.

That afternoon, for the first time, he struggled to breathe. That evening, his hands trembled. The doctors reassured his frightened father. Around 10:00, all three agreed the fever had dropped, and Maximilian went back to his own rooms relieved. At half past 10:00, the boy asked eagerly for something to drink and was given bread water with a little burgundy wine.

He drank it with pleasure. At a quarter to 11:00, the convulsions began. Nothing the doctors tried stopped them. At a quarter to 2:00 in the morning of the 6th of February, 1699, Joseph Ferdinand died. He was 6 years, 3 months, and 9 days old. Vacquieri, who had cared for him almost daily since he was a few weeks old, wrote that it was as if the sun had gone down.

His mother’s coffin compared her to the dawn that gives birth to the sun. Now, the doctor who had watched that sun every day of its short life used the same image for its setting. Vacquieri performed the autopsy himself in front of the other physicians and the Bavarian Privy Counselor, Prielmayer. He found a body wasted by the long illness, a narrowed outlet from the stomach, which he judged had blocked his food, and fluid in the brain, which he blamed for the convulsions.

Otherwise, he wrote, the body was so finely proportioned that but for that stomach, the boy might have lived to the age of Nestor, the oldest of the Greek heroes. He also found the stomach coated with thick, blackish mucus. That detail fed rumors that the prince had been poisoned. Max Emmanuel himself, the archivist say, secretly believed his son had been poisoned with the help of the emperor’s people.

No evidence has ever confirmed it. The archivists who studied the medical reports are cautious. The real cause can no longer be determined, though several infections ending in heart and circulatory failure seem likely. In Vienna, Leopold wrote to his son-in-law that he had learned, with the greatest dismay, that God had called his beloved grandson from this world.

He was, he said, so overwhelmed with grief that he could express nothing more. The Imperial Court ordered no official mourning. By custom, it explained, mourning was not worn even for the emperor’s own children if they died before the age of 12. The Bavarian Counselor, Prielmayer, saw the larger consequence immediately.

This blow, he wrote, struck not only the House of Bavaria, but almost all of Europe which had seen the boy as the means by which the great inheritance could be divided in his words without a sword stroke. He was right. Charles II persuaded that only France could keep his empire together signed a final will on the 2nd of October, 1700 leaving everything to Philip of Anjou, a grandson of Louis XIV.

A month later Charles was dead. Leopold refused to accept it. The War of the Spanish Succession began in 1701 and dragged on until 1714. Max Emanuel sided with France. In 1704 he was defeated at Hochstadt, the battle the English call Blenheim, and spent years in exile while Imperial armies occupied Bavaria. And the Spanish dowry he had married into according to the historian Martinez Lopez, Bavaria was still demanding it at the start of the 19th century.

It was never paid. The boy’s death had turned it into one more quarrel between Bavaria and Vienna. And under Maria Antonia’s will, if her son died, her property was to pass not to her husband but to her father. Now her son was dead. Joseph Ferdinand was buried on the 8th of February, 1699 in a vault before an altar in Brussels’ Cathedral of St. Michael and St. Gudula.

His heart and his inner organs stayed in Brussels, too. He was never brought home to Bavaria and never taken to Vienna. So the family ends up scattered. The father died in Munich in 1726. The son still lies in Brussels. And in the Imperial Crypt in Vienna, as she asked in her will, Maria Antonia lies beside her mother, Margarita.

One was married to her uncle at 15 and died in her seventh pregnancy at 21. The other was promised to her uncle at seven, married at 16, and died eight weeks after giving birth at 23. Whether her extraordinary pedigree played any part in her death, no one can honestly say. What the record does say is written on her own coffin in the words chosen to remember her.

A princess most illustrious by birth, by marriage, by child birth, and by death.

You Might Also Enjoy