News

The Tragic Fate of Eduard Einstein: The Brilliant Son Consigned to Silence and Shadow

 

In 1930, a 20-year-old medical student in Zurich was reading everything he could find about the human mind. He wanted to become a psychiatrist. Within 2 years, he would be a patient in the very hospital where his own illness had been given its name. So, today we’re telling the tragic story of Eduard Einstein, the schizophrenic son of Albert Einstein, the boy they called Tet.

He was born in Zurich on the 28th of July, 1910, the second son of Albert Einstein and Mileva Marić. His father was 31 and not yet famous. The papers that would change physics had been published 5 years earlier, in 1905, but the world had not caught up with them. Albert was still a working academic with a young family, moving from post to post, and the household in Zurich was ordinary in the way that households are before history arrives.

There was already an older brother. Hans Albert had been born in 1904, sturdy, practical, the kind of child who took things apart to see how they worked. And before either of the boys, there had been a daughter, Liesl, born in 1902, whose fate has never been established. She disappears from the family’s letters when she is barely a year old, and no record has ever been found of what became of her.

That absence sits at the very beginning of this family, unexplained, and it never gets explained. The new baby was small and frail. His mother gave him a nickname almost immediately, Tet, taken from the French word for little, and it stuck for the rest of his life. Even in his 50s, in letters and hospital notes, he was still Tet.

He was sick constantly. Ear infections, fevers, one illness rolling into the next. Where Hans Albert was out-climbing things, Eduard was indoors, propped up in bed being read to. Trips the family planned had to be canceled or taken without him. Doctors were consulted, then more doctors. A good part of his early childhood was spent being carried between physicians and rest homes, while his parents tried to work out what was wrong with him, and no one ever came up with a satisfying answer.

But something was developing in all that time spent indoors. He read. He read far more than a small child ought to be able to, and he understood what he read, and he began to talk about it in a way that startled adults. He had a memory that seemed to hold everything. He sat down at the piano and something happened there, too.

Not the dutiful practice of a child being made to learn, but real playing, the kind people stop and listen to. He played until the neighbors complained, and he kept doing that for the rest of his life, in flats and in hospital day rooms, wherever there happened to be an instrument. The family’s pattern was set early, the strong one and the delicate one, the practical son and the strange, gifted, breakable one.

His father worried about him constantly, and not in a vague way. There are letters from those years in which Albert frets over the boy’s health with real anxiety, asks after him in every message home, and at one point wonders aloud a child so persistently unwell could ever grow into a fully formed man. That was written when Eduard was still small.

It is an ugly sentence to read now, knowing what came later, and it seems to have sat somewhere in the back of Albert’s mind permanently. A private verdict he reached early and never quite revised. In 1914, when Eduard was four, his father took a prestigious position in Berlin and moved the family there. It was a decision that would take almost everything apart within a matter of months.

The family comes apart. Mileva hated Berlin from the moment she arrived. She was Serbian. She had trained in physics and mathematics at the Zurich Polytechnic. One of the very few women in Europe doing that at the time. And she had met Albert as a fellow student there. She had been his intellectual equal in the classroom.

In Berlin, she was a foreign wife in a city that had no use for her. Watching her husband become someone she recognized less and less. There was also Elsa. Albert’s cousin living in Berlin. And by then something more than a cousin. The marriage had been struggling for years. In Berlin, it stopped struggling and simply ended.

Within months of arriving, Mileva packed up the two boys and went back to Zurich. Albert stayed. He wrote to them. He wrote to them a great deal in fact. And the letters that survive are not the letters of a man who had stopped caring. But he was in Berlin. And they were 400 miles away in Switzerland. And a father who writes is not a father who is there.

The separation also came at the worst possible moment historically. The First World War began in the summer of 1914. Weeks after Mileva took the boys back to Zurich. Germany and Switzerland were on opposite sides of a closed border for the next four years. Travel became difficult. Then in stretches nearly impossible.

 And correspondence was slow and unreliable. Whatever chance there had been of Albert remaining a regular physical presence in his sons’ lives was removed by events neither parent controlled. For most of Eduard’s early childhood, his father was a signature at the bottom of a page. Hans Albert took it hardest at first.

He was 10, old enough to understand exactly what had happened, and to place blame. There are letters from Albert in 1916 asking his elder son why he no longer replies. Three letters in a row with no answer. Wondering whether they are ever going to see each other again. At the end of one of them, he sends a kiss to Tait, almost as an afterthought.

 The small brother, 6 years old, still too young to be part of the argument. The divorce came through on the 14th of February, 1919. Eduard was eight, and attached to it was one of the strangest financial arrangements in the history of science. Albert had no money to speak of. What he had was an expectation, a widespread assumption in the physics world that a Nobel Prize was coming to him sooner or later.

So, he offered it. The entire prize money, whenever it arrived, would go to Mileva. She agreed to the divorce on that basis. He was awarded the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics, announced in late 1922, and the money reached Mileva the following year. She used it to buy three apartment buildings in Zurich, lived in one of them on Huttenstrasse, and rented out the other two.

She had a home, an income, and two sons to raise on her own. For a while, it very nearly worked. The boy who read too much. The Zurich years were the good years, and everyone involved seemed to know it even at the time. Mileva raised the boys largely alone, and put everything into their education. Hans Albert went into engineering, the sensible path, the one you could build a life on.

He would eventually become a professor of hydraulic engineering at Berkeley, one of the leading authorities in the world on how rivers move sediment, and he would spend his career quietly refusing to trade on his surname. Edward went the other way entirely. He wrote poetry. He wrote a great deal of it, and it was not the sunny verse of a schoolboy.

It was dark, sharp, unusually adult stuff. He read philosophy. He devoured Goethe and Shakespeare. He played the piano with an intensity that people who heard it described as almost frightening, not showing off, but something closer to being consumed by it. And he wrote to his father long, dense, demanding letters full of arguments and questions and opinions sent off to Berlin from a boy who had barely started shaving.

Albert wrote back. Their correspondence went on for years, and it is one of the few genuinely warm things in this story. He sent his son advice about health in one letter from 1918 telling him to take plenty of walks and to put some of his reading aside and save it for when he was grown. He argued with him about music, at one point scolding him affectionately for having no time for Haydn.

When Edward developed a fascination with Sigmund Freud, Albert, who knew Freud personally, wrote to him about it seriously, as one adult to another, rather than dismissing it. Edward hung a picture of Freud in his room. It is worth pausing on the choice because it says something about him. Psychoanalysis in the 1920s was new, disreputable in respectable medical circles, and thrilling to anyone under 25.

Edward did not want to be a physicist. He did not want to compete on his father’s ground, where he could only ever lose. He wanted the other frontier, the interior one, the thing nobody had mapped yet. The mind, and what happens when it goes wrong. He read Freud closely. He argued about him. He wanted to spend his working life sitting across from people whose thinking had come apart, and helping them.

 But there was a difficulty in the boy that grew as he did, and it had to do with the name. By the mid-1920s, Albert Einstein was not merely a famous physicist. He was the most famous human being alive, a face in every newspaper, mobbed in the street, the closest thing the 20th century had produced to a secular saint. And in Zurich, there was a teenager with that surname trying to work out what he was going to do with his life.

Eduard put it down on paper himself, and it was one of the most honest things he ever wrote, that it can be difficult to have such an important father, because it leaves you feeling that you don’t matter very much. He was clever enough to see the trap, and not clever enough to get out of it. There is another line of his from around the same period, more cutting still, in which he observes that people who spend their lives absorbed in intellectual work tend to bring nervous, sickly children into the world.

He was describing his father, and he was describing himself in the same breath. And he was 19 or 20 when he wrote it. That was the household he had grown up in, a brilliant, absent father, a brilliant, thwarted mother who had given up her own scientific career, and watched her husband’s arrive. And two boys raised in the gap between them.

He graduated from his secondary schooling in 1929, at 19, with an outstanding record, and he chose his direction, medicine at the University of Zurich, with the intention of becoming a psychiatrist. His father approved of the choice and wrote to him about it with evident interest. He had one good year, possibly the best year of his life.

Then he fell in love. 1930 The details of the relationship are thin and deliberately so. The family did not talk about it and what survives comes second-hand. What is generally reported is that Eduard, at 20, became involved with a woman considerably older than himself and that it ended badly. There is an obvious echo in that and everyone in the family would have heard it.

His own father had fallen for an older student at the Zurich Polytechnic 30 years earlier. Mileva was four years Albert senior and had married her against his family’s wishes. Eduard was walking a road he had grown up hearing about. In his case, it went nowhere. He did not take it the way a young man normally takes a broken relationship.

What followed was a collapse and it was frightening. In the aftermath, he tried to end his own life. He survived and he was taken for treatment. And from that point, the family were dealing with something they had no framework for at all. Because it became clear fairly quickly that the heartbreak had not caused this.

It had uncovered it. Over the following weeks and months, doctors in Zurich observed a young man whose thinking had begun to come apart in a specific and recognizable way. He heard things that were not there. His speech, which had always been rapid and brilliant, started to leave the rails following connections that made sense only to him.

He became suspicious, then convinced of things that could not be true. The mood swung violently. The piano playing turned from intense to something closer to a compulsion. Schizophrenia typically announces itself in exactly this window. Late teens to mid-20s. Most often in the years when a person is supposed to be starting their adult life.

It arrives, in other words, at the precise moment somebody has the most to lose. Eduard was 1 year into the degree he had chosen, in the field he loved, with a mind that had never let him down. And the illness had a family history, though nobody assembled the picture until much later. Mileva’s younger sister, Zorka, had her own long struggle with mental illness and spent years unable to manage on her own.

Whatever had reached Eduard had almost certainly come down his mother’s side of the family, which is a thing Mileva would eventually work out for herself, and which cannot have been anything but agonizing to sit with. In 1930, at the age of 20, Eduard Einstein was diagnosed with schizophrenia. It is worth being clear about what that word meant then, because it did not mean what it means now.

There were no antipsychotic medications. The first of them, chlorpromazine, would not be introduced until 1952, 22 years later. In 1930, a diagnosis of schizophrenia was not the beginning of a treatment plan. It was, for most patients, a description of the rest of their life. Mileva took him home and cared for him herself, and for 2 years she managed it.

Those 2 years deserve more attention than they usually get. She was 55. She had no medical support at home, no respite, no relatives nearby, and a son who could be lucid and funny one week, and unreachable the next. She fed him, sat with him, kept him occupied, and absorbed the bad days privately. She had spent her 20s as one of the only women in Europe studying theoretical physics, and she spent her 50s doing this.

 And there is no record of her ever once complaining about the exchange. Then, in 1932, she couldn’t. Burghölzli. The Burghölzli was not just any hospital, and this is where the story turns genuinely strange. It sits on a hill above Zurich, the psychiatric clinic of the University of Zurich, and in the early 20th century, the single most important institution in the world for the study of severe mental illness.

Eugen Bleuler ran it. It was Bleuler who, in 1908, invented the word schizophrenia, coined it, defined it, and gave the field its vocabulary for the condition. Carl Jung had worked there under him, doing the research that made his name, before he and Freud ever fell out. If you were a young man in Zurich in the 1920s who wanted to become a psychiatrist, the Burghölzli was the summit.

It was where you hoped to end up. Edward would have known its reputation before he knew what it meant to be a patient. He may well have walked past it as a student and thought about working there. Consider what that means for a moment. The word for his condition had been invented in that building, roughly 2 miles from the flat he grew up in, 2 years before he was born.

The doctors who examined him were the professional descendants of the man who coined it. He had read their work. He had wanted to join them. And he arrived instead as the thing they studied. There is no version of this story in which that irony is comfortable. In 1932, he was admitted to it. He was 22. It was the first of what would become many admissions, and it ended his studies.

He never returned to the university. The career in psychiatry, the plan, the ambition, the thing he was going to be, simply stopped. And he was on the other side of the door instead. The Burgholzli of that period was not a cruel place by the standards of the time. It was a serious research hospital staffed by people who genuinely wanted to help.

Patients were talked to rather than merely warehoused, which was not universal in European asylums of the era. Bleuler’s own view, unusual for his generation, had been that these patients were not beyond reach, and that a doctor’s job was to try to understand what the person in front of him was actually experiencing.

That is part of what makes what happened next so difficult, because the treatments available to them were about to change dramatically. And the men who developed those treatments believed, with total sincerity, that they had found the answer. The cures. In the 1930s, psychiatry went through a period of extraordinary desperation dressed up as progress.

The reasoning ran roughly as follows. Doctors had noticed that some patients with severe mental illness seemed to improve after a high fever or a seizure. If a seizure could be induced deliberately, perhaps the improvement could be induced, too. Nobody could explain why this should work. It was tried anyway, on an enormous scale.

Insulin shock therapy arrived first, developed by Manfred Sakel, and introduced in 1933. Patients were given large doses of insulin to drive their blood sugar down until they lost consciousness, sometimes for hours, sometimes over dozens of sessions across weeks. It was dangerous. Some patients did not come out of it.

Then, in 1938, came electroconvulsive therapy, passing a current through the brain to produce a seizure. In its early form, it was administered without anesthetic and without muscle relaxants, and the convulsions it produced were severe enough to cause injuries. Eduard Einstein was a patient in a leading Swiss clinic through exactly the years these methods swept through European psychiatry.

None of it was quackery in the eyes of the people administering it. These were mainstream treatments, published in respectable journals, delivered by qualified physicians in good faith in the total absence of anything better. That is the part worth holding on to. Nobody in this story was a villain. They simply had a devastating illness, no effective medicine for it, and a professional obligation to do something rather than nothing.

Precisely which treatments Eduard received and how often is not fully documented in public sources. What is documented is what his family believed about the results. Hans Albert was in no doubt at all. He believed that the electroconvulsive treatment his brother received had damaged him. That it had taken his memory and blunted the mind that had once absorbed everything.

He said so, plainly, and he went on saying it for the rest of his life. Biographers of Albert Einstein have made the same point in more careful language, that the cures of the period may well have done Eduard more harm than the illness did. And there is something to compare against because we know what he had been, the boy who wrote intense poetry at 15, who argued philosophy with the most famous scientist alive, who played the piano so fiercely it unsettled people.

Photographs and accounts from later years describe a heavy, slow, quiet man who had trouble holding a thread of conversation. Some of that is the illness. Schizophrenia does that on its own. But his brother, who had known him before, and who watched the whole thing happen, was certain that a good deal of it was the treatment.

 Meanwhile, 800 miles away in Berlin, Eduard’s father was running out of time. 1933. By the beginning of 1933, Albert Einstein was in serious danger. He was Jewish, he was the most visible intellectual in Europe, and he had spent years speaking publicly against militarism and nationalism. When the Nazi government came to power that January, his position became untenable within weeks.

His property in Germany was seized. His work was attacked in the press and later burned in public. He was out of the country when it happened, and he made the decision not to go back. That autumn, he left Europe for the United States and took up a position at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey.

Before he went, he traveled to Zurich to see his son. It was not their first meeting since the diagnosis, but it would be their last meeting of any kind. Accounts of the visit describe the two of them making music together. Albert with the violin he took everywhere, Eduard at the piano. The thing they had always been able to do without words.

It is a strange scene to sit with. A father who had never been much good at being present, and a son who could no longer reliably hold a conversation, in a room where the one thing that still worked between them was music. They had argued about composers by letter for a decade. Now they simply played because playing did not require either of them to explain anything.

Neither of them knew it was the last time. Albert may have suspected. It has been reported that during this period in the wreckage of the breakdown Edward told his father he hated him. It is not hard to see where that would have come from. He had been eight when the marriage was formally ended. He had grown up with a father who existed mostly as handwriting on paper.

And now, at the worst moment of his life that father was leaving the continent. Albert did try to bring him. He urged Hans Albert to follow him to America and Hans Albert eventually did in 1938. He wanted Edward to come, too. But Edward was too unwell to travel and the United States had immigration rules that would not admit a man with his diagnosis in any case.

It was not going to happen and both of them must have understood that. He got on the boat carrying his violin case and he never set foot in Europe again. Albert Einstein lived another 22 years. He never saw his son again. They did keep writing. The letters carried on across the Atlantic and he continued to send money for Edward’s care for the rest of his life.

But there is a note he’d written about his younger son years before in one of his bleaker moments saying that he did not believe Edward would ever become a fully developed person. He appears to have made peace with that early and it is difficult to read. Behind him in Zurich he left a woman in her late 50s with a sick son, three houses and no help at all.

Mileva alone. What happened to Mileva Marić over the following 15 years is the part of this story that gets skipped, and it shouldn’t be. She was a trained physicist and mathematician who had spent her life in a small apartment in Zurich giving private lessons for money. She had been divorced by the most famous man in the world, and she had one son on another continent, and another son in and out of a psychiatric hospital.

The money went first. Eduard’s care was expensive, and it was not a temporary expense. It was a permanent one, invoiced month after month, year after year. By the late 1930s, the cost had eaten through what the Nobel Prize had bought. She was forced to sell two of the three houses. In 1939, to keep from losing the last one, she signed the Huttenstrasse property over to Albert’s ownership while retaining the right to manage it.

He sent regular payments from Princeton for her and for Eduard both. The family losses came next, and they came in a row. Her father died in 1922. Her mother in 1935. Her sister Zorka, who had her own long history of mental illness, died in 1938. That same year, Hans Albert took his family and emigrated to America, which was the correct decision with a war coming, and which left Mileva alone in Switzerland with Eduard.

In 1936, casting around for anyone who might help, she wrote to Carl Jung. He was the most celebrated psychiatrist in Europe. He had trained at the Burgholzli, in that very building, on exactly this illness. She wrote asking for his advice about her son. He never replied. Whether the letter was lost or arrived at a bad moment, or was simply set aside, nobody knows.

Jung was 61, world-famous, and buried in correspondence. But, it is difficult to read that silence and not feel it. A mother writing to the one man in Europe who had spent his early career on precisely this illness, in precisely this hospital. Asking for help with her son, and getting nothing back at all. Then came the war.

Switzerland stayed neutral and surrounded on every side, rationed and tense for 6 years. And Mileva stayed in Zurich. And Edward moved between the clinic and home, depending on how he was. The good stretches could last months. The bad ones were very bad. His condition worsened over the years, and caring for him at home became physically hard for a woman now in her 70s.

She was also by then quite alone in a way that is hard to overstate. Her parents were dead. Her sister was dead. Her elder son and her ex-husband were both on the far side of an ocean crossed by submarines. The letters and the money still came from Princeton, but letters and money are not company. Whatever she was carrying through those years, she carried it in a flat in Zurich with a sick man in the next room.

She kept doing it anyway, right up until the summer of 1948. August 1948. Edward had a severe episode that year. Reports describe him becoming violent during it, which happened at intervals throughout his illness, and which his mother had managed alone for the better part of two decades. In the aftermath of it, Mileva collapsed.

She was taken to a hospital. She did not recover, and after some weeks there, she died in Zurich on the 4th of August, 1948, at the age of 72. The cause was recorded as a stroke. She had been in poor health for some time and had partial paralysis in her final period. And the accounts that survived describe a woman who had simply reached the end of what one person can carry.

Albert learned of it in Princeton. He had not seen her in decades. Whatever passed between them in the end passed on paper, as everything in this family eventually did. She was buried at the Nordheim Cemetery in Zurich. Her grave went largely unmarked and largely unvisited for over half a century. It was only in the 2000s that the site was properly identified and marked for the public.

She had been the whole of Eduard’s world, not just his mother, his advocate, his interpreter, the one who fought about the invoices and argued with the doctors and wrote to Jung and took him home when he was well enough to come home. She was the reason there had been a home to come to at all. It is worth saying plainly what she gave up.

Mileva Marić was one of the first women in Europe to complete a full course of study in physics and mathematics. She sat in the same lecture halls as Albert Einstein and was regarded by the people around her as formidable. What she did with the second half of her life was teach private lessons for money and look after her son who would never recover.

Whatever she might otherwise have become, this is what she chose instead, and she did it for 18 years without an audience. He was 38 years old when she died. His father was in New Jersey. His brother was in California. Both of them were 4 and 1/2 thousand miles away, and neither of them was coming. And that is where the last part of this story begins.

 The 17 years in which Eduard Einstein simply disappeared from view. The long silence. He did not spend all of it in the hospital, and that matters. After his mother’s death, he was placed for a time with foster families in Switzerland. Private households paid to take in patients like him, which was a recognized part of Swiss psychiatric care.

By the accounts that exist, these were reasonable years. He was looked after. He had a room. He kept a piano when he could. But in 1957, he was hospitalized again. And what was intended as a temporary move became permanent when his foster mother herself fell ill and could no longer take him back. He was 47. From that point, he lived at the Burghölzli continuously.

 And he lived there for the rest of his life. His father died first. Albert Einstein died in Princeton on the 18th of April, 1955, at 76. He had gone on writing to Eduard and paying for his care until the end. They had not seen one another in 22 years. Hans Albert, in California, arranged and paid for his brother’s care after that.

He never brought him to America. It is easy to be hard about that from a distance, and harder when you consider what would actually have been involved. Moving a severely ill man who spoke only German across an ocean, out of a system that knew him, into a country that had refused him entry once already. So, Eduard stayed on the hill above Zurich.

And here is the thing that keeps this from being merely sad. He did not stop. Through all of it, the decades, the treatments, the emptying out, he kept writing. He wrote poems. He wrote aphorisms, small compressed observations, the sort of thing he had been writing since he was a teenager. He drew. He talked about Freud to anyone who would listen. He played the piano.

One of the poems he left is called lonely end. And it is about exactly what its title suggests. A man watching his own life get carried off. Everything he planted blown away by the wind. Everything he held washed downstream until there is nothing left to show he was there. It was written by someone who understood his situation completely.

That is the cruelty of it. The illness took a great deal from him. But it never took his ability to see where he was. Eduard Einstein died at the Burghölzli on the 25th of October, 1965. He was 55. The cause was a stroke. The same thing that had taken his mother 17 years earlier. He was buried at the Hönggerberg Cemetery in Zurich in a different graveyard from his mother in the city where all three of them had lived.

His death notice identified him as the son of the late Professor Einstein. His mother’s name was not mentioned. She had carried him for 38 years and it did not make the notice. He had been a poet, a pianist, a formidably intelligent man who wanted to spend his life helping people whose minds had failed them.

 And none of that made it either. In the end, he was recorded as a footnote to somebody else. Which was the exact fear he had written down as a teenager. Arriving at last in print after he was gone. Today, the Einstein family is sometimes cited in discussions of the heritability of schizophrenia. The illness ran through Mileva’s family as well as appearing in her son.

And Eduard’s name comes up in that context far more often than in any other. It is not much of a legacy for a man who had a considerable mind of his own. But there is one photograph worth ending on. Zurich, the early 1930s. A father and a son sitting together, the violin and the piano between them, before the treatments and the ocean and the 22 years of letters.

Neither of them looking at the camera. Just two people making music on an ordinary afternoon with no idea it was the last one. If you enjoyed this video, please like and subscribe to our channel so you never miss out on more fascinating stories.

 

You Might Also Enjoy