News

The Toxic Relationship Between Henry VIII’s Children – Two Sisters

Two Sisters, Two Queens

Two sisters, two queens. At first glance, the daughters of Henry VIII could not be more different.

The relationship between Elizabeth and Mary is a very difficult one to read. There’s an enormous age gap, for one thing. Mary’s childhood was steeped in the Catholic Church. Everything about her life was about religion. Elizabeth had a Protestant upbringing, so Mary seemed probably somewhat old-fashioned. Diametrically opposed, too, on issues of religion. Society at the time of their rule was ill-equipped to accept a female sovereign.

England is a patriarchal society. Women are believed to be ruled by their emotions rather than reason. They’re very much the weaker sex. It was believed that they were incapable of ruling as effectively as men.

One’s reign was short, the other’s long. One was Catholic, the other Protestant. One was allied to Spain; the other’s greatest triumphs came in defying them.

There’s no doubt that Elizabeth gets to learn from Mary’s mistakes and borrow from her example. Elizabeth’s decision not to marry is a pragmatic and calculated decision. She’s seen how wrong it can go with Mary. She’s the kind of queen of spin before spin was invented, and one of the things she was so successful at is erasing Mary’s legacy. Many people forget the fact that actually Mary was the first crowned queen of England.

One was reviled as Bloody Mary; the other was celebrated as Gloriana, the Virgin Queen. But more unites these half-sisters than many realize.

Mary was born in Greenwich on the 18th of February, 1516. Her mother was Henry VIII’s first wife, Catherine of Aragon.

Catherine of Aragon was the aunt of the Holy Roman Emperor. She was a Spanish lady. She was deeply steeped in the Catholicism of Spain. Catherine of Aragon had come from a family of very impressive women.

Catherine of Aragon’s mother, Isabella of Castile, was a real warrior figure, and she educated Catherine of Aragon and her children essentially on the battlefield. I mean, she was very, very keen on educating all her children, male and female, and Catherine of Aragon was one of the most educated, accomplished women in Europe.

Although not the hoped-for son, Mary was a relief to her parents. They had been married almost seven years, but a series of miscarriages and stillbirths had denied them an heir. Mary was proof they could have children. With Catherine only just 30 and Henry even younger, there was still hope that a younger brother would one day join Mary.

As a child, Mary was fair and ruddy-cheeked, just like her father. Henry loved children and doted on his daughter. She had the finest education a girl could expect at this time.

Mary, as far as Henry was concerned, should be brought up to be a good wife. But actually, Mary’s mother, Catherine of Aragon, didn’t want to settle for that. She was brought up very largely by her mother to be a Spanish-speaking, Spanish-believing, Spanish Catholic. She’s surrounded by an army of attendants, the best tutors. She’s brought up to be able to dance and to sing. She’s extraordinarily accomplished even by a very young age.

It’s not really until 1525, when Mary is sent to Ludlow as the de facto Princess of Wales and goes to rule Wales effectively for her father, that she gets a proper formal education in things like Latin and Greek and strategy, the things you need to be a monarch.

Mary’s education stood her in excellent stead. She believed that she was just as intelligent as any man. She believed that she had the abilities, the intellect of her father, and also the reflection, the consideration and the religious knowledge of her mother.

Above all, her education was preparation for her future as a royal bride. A princess was a valuable commodity in 16th-century Europe. Arranged marriages could make or break treaties and alliances. They could change the course of history.

If you were a king in the 16th century and you had children, they had two functions. If you had a son, his function was to succeed you and be a strong male ruler. If you had a daughter, she was a bargaining chip, and Mary was quite a valuable chip to put down on the gaming table.

Every time Henry VIII decided to make a peace treaty or a trade treaty with another monarch, he usually said, “You could have my daughter. She can be a wife.” And she was an incredible prize. She’s betrothed a number of times to different Valois princes. She’s betrothed to members of the Habsburg family a couple of times, but it’s really just a political, dynastic maneuver. It’s not necessarily going to be set in stone. The first time she was betrothed was at about two, so, so young, but it was a symbol of an alliance. And so, right from a very, very early age, she was this pawn in a game of European diplomacy.

During Mary’s adolescence, her life would change forever. In 1525, her beloved mother Catherine turned 40. It only confirmed what had seemed likely for some time: she would never give Henry the son he desired.

Henry had a fanatical desire for a son. He was fixated on it. But you’ll understand why. He’d been married since 1509, since the very beginning of his reign, so that was several years of disappointments. And we must remember Henry VIII was only the second Tudor king. He had a job to do in securing the dynasty.

It’s important that we think of the Tudor dynasty without hindsight, and we understand that for a long time it was quite precarious. Henry was surrounded by enemies. Scotland, Wales hated him; Ireland, France, Spain, the Holy Roman Emperor, they all were vying to get their hands on the throne. Everything depended on succession.

The main job of a monarch was to preserve the dynasty, to pass on the dynasty, because otherwise there would be civil war. It’s very important to Henry that he not only has a male heir, but then he hopefully has two or three of them. He became so obsessed with having a son, he’d consider everything, anything and everything. His whole mind was focused on having a child. There was nothing else that mattered.

Henry’s affections abandoned Mary’s mother. He had become obsessed with one of the queen’s ladies-in-waiting, Anne Boleyn. The king had taken mistresses before, but never like this. Henry fell passionately in love with Anne. He was convinced she would give him a son. He had to marry her. Catherine had to go.

Catherine and Henry had had a very happy marriage for 20 years, but once she was beyond childbearing years, their marriage really did fall apart. Henry became obsessed by the idea that he was cursed, and he blamed the fact that Catherine had been married to his brother, who had died before she’d married Henry.

Henry decided that this particular verse in the Book of Leviticus meant that his marriage was incest, and that he should therefore be allowed to declare that the marriage was null and void, that it had never taken place. There were tremendous argy-bargies about it between the various ecclesiastics involved.

Catherine refused to cooperate, and the Pope was unwilling to grant an annulment. The process dragged on for almost a decade. The adolescent Princess Mary was caught in the middle.

Determined to break Catherine’s resistance, in May 1531 Henry banned Mary from seeing her mother. They could see each other, the king decreed, only if both declared their support for the annulment. It was a cruel thing for Henry to impose on a daughter he had once doted upon, and it was ineffective. Catherine still did not bend.

This is heartbreaking for Mary. Mary had a very difficult adolescence anyway. She was often ill. She suffered from low spirits. So the fact was, her father was trying to declare her illegitimate. He was trying to divorce her mother and really push her aside and push her, it seemed, out of the line to the throne. So nothing could have been worse for Mary, and it really did form the woman she became.

It was a profound humiliation, but it was also very, very shocking to these two Spanish Catholics, Catherine and Mary, to watch the way out that Henry chose, which was to side with the burgeoning movement of Protestantism, something he’d always hated and denounced.

So determined was the king to secure his annulment, the formerly devout Catholic Henry broke with the Roman Church. He declared himself supreme head of the Church in England. The new Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, soon granted him the annulment.

In January 1533, Henry married Anne Boleyn. She was already pregnant. That summer, she was crowned Queen of England in a lavish coronation. Just weeks later, Anne went into labour. On the 7th of September, she gave birth, not to the son she had promised Henry, but to a daughter, Elizabeth.

Despite this disappointment, Elizabeth was a delight to her parents. She was proof to the court, to England and to all of Europe that Anne was fertile and that Henry’s seed was strong. Surely it would not be long before a son was born to the couple.

The arrival of a half-sister was no cause of celebration for Mary. Instead, it heralded a new phase in her humiliation.

On the 7th of September 1533, Henry VIII’s second daughter was born at Greenwich Palace. She was named Elizabeth after the king’s mother and declared the high and mighty Princess of England. But the birth meant demotion and humiliation for Elizabeth’s half-sister. The seventeen-year-old Mary was now pretty much a forgotten, illegitimate daughter.

Henry orders for all of the sort of badges of honour to be removed from Mary’s household. She loses that status. She loses her own livery. She has all of the trappings of a princess taken away from her.

Not only was Mary displaced, not only was she stripped of the title of Princess of Wales, she was humiliated by her father. She was made to work as a maid of honour in her little sister’s court. Elizabeth was the princess. Elizabeth was the heiress. Elizabeth was the one who had the wonderful court. And indeed, Mary was increasingly used as Elizabeth’s, pretty much, lady-in-waiting.

There was relentless pressure on the teenager to admit that she was illegitimate, to recognize Anne as queen and Elizabeth as the heir. It was a miserable time for Mary, and things were about to get worse.

On the 7th of January 1536, her mother Catherine died at Kimbolton Castle in Huntingdonshire. Her supporters suspected foul play. Rumours of poison swirled through the land, but Catherine had been ill for some time. To the very end, she refused to recognize Henry’s new marriage. Catherine always insisted she was the true Queen of England.

The king had also kept his word. Mother and daughter never met, and Henry’s cruelty towards Mary did not cease with her mother’s death. He refused her permission to attend Catherine’s funeral as well.

It was an act of incredible cruelty from her father, but he was a man who expected absolute submission, and he didn’t care how he got it.

When Catherine of Aragon died, Mary was really the main figurehead for the old religion, as it was called. And so, for as long as she stood out and refused to acknowledge her father’s new marriage, then the traditional Catholics had an advocate. If she could be forced to submit to Henry, that sort of loose cannon that Mary represented could have been neutralized.

At court, the king and queen celebrated the death of Catherine. The infant Elizabeth was proudly paraded in public. But Anne’s triumph was short-lived. Within months, she had fallen from favour and power. Accused of adultery, incest and treason, Anne Boleyn was executed at the Tower of London on the 19th of May 1536.

Anne Boleyn fell because she couldn’t give Henry a son, and increasingly Henry was weary of her. All the things he’d found rather attractive in her as a mistress, he didn’t find attractive in a wife.

Having gone to great lengths to annul and then forcibly dissolve the marriage between Catherine of Aragon and himself, and establish the Church of England, he soon fell out of love with Anne Boleyn. And she’s accused of adultery with her musician, Mark Smeaton, and a number of the nobles of court, including her brother. And they are all sent to the Tower.

Henry, he was looking for a way out at this point, and was maneuvered by the factions at court, ends up accepting those charges, and of course Anne Boleyn is executed.

Henry was already in love with the woman who had become his third wife, Jane Seymour. They were married just days after the execution of Anne Boleyn.

It was at this time that Mary finally caved. Still mourning her mother, she was desperate to regain the love of her father, and she was frightened of what he might do to her. She finally recognised Henry as head of the Church of England and acknowledged that she was an illegitimate child of incest. Mary regretted it for the rest of her life.

The rewards for her sacrifice were slight. She was allowed back to court, but the new Act of Succession did not restore Mary as his heir. Instead, it stripped Mary’s half-sister, the infant Elizabeth, of her titles and status, and it made any child of the new queen, Jane Seymour, next in line to the throne.

That child came in the autumn of 1537. Henry finally got what he had long craved: a son, Edward.

The new prince was born at Hampton Court Palace, which was the ever-expanding home of King Henry VIII’s vast court.

He’s delighted. He’s thrilled. Everything has been vindicated. And the two sisters, well, they’re pretty much forgotten. For him, they’re irrelevant. They’re members of the court, but he has no more interest in them. The whole court was about Edward.

Edward’s birth is actually probably one of the best things that can happen to Elizabeth and Mary because it takes the pressure off them. Edward’s birth was a source of unity for the two sisters. They already had their illegitimacy, as Henry saw it, in common. But now they had a brother, and there was every expectation that that meant neither sister would be queen. So, if they had felt some competitiveness between them, that surely would have dissolved.

Elizabeth starts to receive a degree of education in her own household and indeed later on will join the household of her half-brother and receive a much better education. And then, for Mary, she’s invited back to court, so she spends an awful lot more time at court with Jane Seymour. She becomes reacquainted with her father, so her fortunes take a massive upswing.

Queen Jane died soon after Edward’s birth. Three other wives would follow for the king over the next decade, but there were no more siblings for Mary and Elizabeth. For the rest of their father’s life, they shared the same uncertain status.

Henry VIII died on the 28th of January 1547. A new Act of Succession had passed a few years earlier. Henry’s two daughters, though still officially illegitimate, were restored to the line, but first would come their young brother Edward.

Edward came to the throne when he was very young, and he had what we call regencies, protectorates, pretty much a succession of powerful men pulling the strings, pushing the country in a Protestant way. But also, Edward himself was a very keen Protestant, and a lot of what was happening during his reign was at his behest.

He was described as a lusty child, well fed. You only have to look at the early portraits of him to see he was thriving. He was very sporty. He was a good horseman. He was a good athlete. He aspired to, as his father had done, fight in tournaments. There’s no evidence to suppose that he was a weakling in any way.

Historians have increasingly identified that although Edward was still a boy king, he gradually is becoming much more interested and able and keen to assert himself. So the king remains an important figure, even though he’s a boy.

The reign of Edward VI would prove a difficult time for the two sisters. The teenage Elizabeth was placed in the household of Henry’s last wife, Catherine Parr. There, it is thought she was sexually abused by Parr’s new husband, Thomas Seymour. Mary, meanwhile, clashed with her brother’s government over its religious reforms.

She refused the new English prayer books. Her household maintained the traditions of the old religion. She’s at loggerheads with the council for much of Edward’s reign over her right to have Catholic Mass said in her household.

Edward is saying, you know, “You will submit to me. I am king.” And Mary says, “You know, you’re my little brother. I’m certainly not going to take orders from you.” So they have these really quite full-on spats.

Mary was not a softly-softly sort of person, and there was a terrible Christmas when they had a stand-up row in front of the whole court, and both of them burst into tears over religion, over the fact that Mary disagreed. Mary thought what he was doing was wrong, and he thought what she was doing was wrong. And the Catholic Mass, there was no way of finding common ground between them.

The reign of Edward VI would be a short one. Early in 1553 he fell ill. On the 6th of July that year, the 15-year-old king died. The death was kept secret by his government for days. There was a plan to fix the succession.

Edward was more than aware Mary was waiting in the wings and had every intention of restoring Catholicism, so all the work that had been done in establishing the Protestant Church would be immediately undone.

Edward doesn’t have time to go to Parliament. He’s too ill. So, in the April before his death, he writes the Device for the Succession, which excludes both of his sisters, Mary and Elizabeth, from the line of succession. He changed the succession to ensure his first cousin once removed, Lady Jane Grey, who happened to be married to the son of his protector, the great and powerful Northumberland, would succeed him. She was a girl that really no one had heard of, and he thought it was a secure succession. It would be a Protestant country forever and ever.

The Lady Jane Grey accession was a Protestant coup. That was the point. Word of the king’s death spread. From her vast estates in East Anglia, Mary began raising an army. England was on the brink of civil war.

In the summer of 1553, England was in crisis. Its boy king, Edward VI, had died, but who would rule after him? In his dying days, Edward had anointed his teenage cousin, Lady Jane Grey, as his successor. The Protestant king hoped to exclude his Catholic sister Mary from inheriting the crown.

About three days before Edward’s death, Mary is riding to court to see her brother and believing that, you know, he’s been unwell, he’s now better and she’s been invited to court. She was going to be seized and imprisoned so that Lady Jane ascends the throne.

They had fundamentally underestimated Mary. She got as far as Hertfordshire, and she got a tip-off from a supporter at court saying, “Do not come. There’s a plan, basically, to catch you.” She didn’t have much good luck in her life, but this was good luck. One of her supporters rode like billy-o through the night and got to her and told her that she was the Queen of England.

She turns around and rides with all of her retainers into East Anglia and starts to muster her troops. It was an area in which Mary held extensive estates, so she could call on a great deal of support. She thought that this is her chance. God has protected her through all of her life to take her place on the throne and to restore Catholicism. So this was absolutely her divine mission.

Mary was absolutely determined and prepared to fight for her throne if she needed to, and that’s where this sort of pigheaded, stubborn attitude comes in.

On the 10th of July, Edward’s council, led by the ambitious Duke of Northumberland, declared Lady Jane Queen of England. The council seemed to hold all the cards. They had London, its Tower and its armoury. Northumberland set about raising forces to apprehend Edward’s sisters, Mary and Elizabeth.

The minute he left, all the people started saying, “Hmm, is that really a good idea?” The Privy Council suddenly starts to panic. When she’s proclaimed queen, there’s a stony silence around London. It’s sort of an eerie experience that nobody’s cheering for Queen Jane. They saw her for what she was: she was a usurper, albeit an unwilling one. They wanted the daughter of Henry VIII to be queen. The people wanted the correct person to be queen, and that was Mary.

There would be no civil war, no armed conflict at all. As the frightened Jane waited in the Tower of London, people across the country declared their allegiance to Mary instead. Even Northumberland himself was soon forced to face the inevitable. Six days after leaving London to arrest Mary, he recognized her as queen.

At once, Mary marched on London to begin her reign. Her sister Elizabeth was left in a precarious situation. She was Mary’s heir. She could be an ally or a threat.

In early August, Elizabeth met her sister outside London. Accompanying her were a thousand horsemen, her gentlemen dazzling in green and white Tudor livery. It was a statement of support for Mary, but also a reminder of Elizabeth’s own status and power. Together, the two sisters rode into London.

London had been waiting. They’d swept the streets, they’d covered the buildings with tapestries, and Mary came in looking every inch a queen. She is dressed all in purple, royal, regal colours. She’s festooned with jewels and pearls. She’s really presenting herself in the most spectacular fashion so that people immediately understand that she is the centre of attention.

Mary didn’t have a stage presence. She was awkward, she was shy. But nevertheless, it was a magnificent spectacle as this rightful queen, who was going to restore unity and peace, came into London, followed by the statuesque, tall, by now strangely ethereally beautiful sister Elizabeth.

Both Mary and Elizabeth had a very keen sense that they were both Henry’s daughters. There was a real sort of sense of Tudor legitimacy flowing through their veins. Now, this was a show of solidarity. That’s what it was intended as: to show off the strength of the Tudor dynasty. But there was an awful lot more simmering beneath the surface of this display.

Elizabeth was above all a politician, and she wanted political influence for herself and to protect her interests. And she knew the best way was to throw herself behind her sister. When she rode in, yes, it was all about Mary the queen, but it was all about Elizabeth behind her, the second in line to the throne.

Mary was crowned on the 1st of October. She started as she meant to go on. It was a Catholic service. She made it clear from the outset she wanted England to forget that little blip of Protestantism and return to being a Catholic country.

When she comes to the throne, Mass is still illegal. You can’t celebrate a Catholic Mass. But over the next few years, she’s pushing quite gently, actually, for the reintroduction of Catholic practices.

The chief obsession of Mary Tudor was to restore the Catholic faith to England, and it was that aim which determined all her political life, all her foreign policy, everything. They were going back to the Catholicism of her youth. Britain was now a Catholic country, and everyone had to obey that, and if you did not obey that, you would be punished.

But if the Catholic faith was to be restored in England permanently, Mary would need a child. For that, she needed a husband. Her choice stunned advisers and the nation. He was to be Prince Philip of Spain, heir to the Habsburg dynasty, which ruled much of Europe. They married on the 25th of July 1554. They had met just two days earlier.

Mary is always facing a difficult position when she has to choose a bridegroom. She can’t easily marry a subject, an Englishman, because he will be elevated above her, so the rest of the nobility won’t be happy to follow him. And if she marries a foreign prince, she essentially puts England into the hands of a foreign power. So she’s really damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

Mary had had Spanish support when she had been excluded from the throne. She wants to pay them back, and above all she wants to make this great dynasty, to be like her mother, her mother the Spanish princess, to marry once more into Spain, create this unity, just like her father and mother.

In some ways, it’s very sensible. It’s a strong dynastic match with a Catholic power. Philip himself isn’t a bad prospect either. A very advantageous marriage treaty was drawn up, what we might describe as a prenup these days, which basically said Philip had very little role in government. He couldn’t introduce new languages into government. He couldn’t, you know, make appointments. He couldn’t take Mary out of the country. England couldn’t just naturally be drawn into his wars.

However, many people feared the marriage to Spain, when Mary was a woman, would basically mean England getting swallowed up in the Spanish Empire, and that Philip would end up running the show.

Poor Mary never grasps this fact. She never grasped how important it was in the eyes of her subjects and in the eyes of the ruling class, how important it was not to have foreigners ruling England. The horror of England being subservient to a Catholic country, to a foreign power, to a very powerful foreign power who had links to the Holy Roman Empire, well, that was just too much.

A plot was hatched to force Mary from the throne and replace her with her half-sister Elizabeth. Led by Sir Thomas Wyatt, it was a group of very, very determined Protestants who wanted Mary off the throne.

Wyatt gets two to three thousand people who are all willing to fight for Elizabeth, but everything else sort of collapses. Nobody else really raises any troops. They were repelled while trying to get into London, and they were put down by the queen’s forces. The ringleaders of the rebellion are all sentenced to death and executed very publicly to show the power of Mary’s regime.

The rebellion may have only briefly threatened Mary’s grip on power, but its failure was a far graver threat to Elizabeth. Many suspected her involvement in the plot.

What we don’t know is how much Elizabeth knew about it. Certainly, the Wyatt rebellion had approached many of those around her, some of her confidants, and it may have been that the news did get back to her. It was believed that she was at the very least aware of what was going on and had been informed by the rebels of their plan.

Elizabeth was in a very awkward position because she was the champion of her father’s reformed religion, and she was the figurehead that the more extreme Protestants were going to use against Mary. So she had to play a very delicate game. She’s questioned repeatedly by the Privy Council, and she protests her innocence repeatedly and vehemently.

Elizabeth was taken to the Tower, and she was put in the same apartments that her mother, Anne Boleyn, had had before she was executed. She knows that it’s really only a hair’s breadth that holds her off from having the same fate.

Mary’s advisers had a warrant drawn up for Elizabeth’s execution, and it’s said that Mary almost signed it. Her hand was hovering over the warrant when she had an attack of conscience.

Mary spared her sister. Perhaps she was moved by the letter Elizabeth sent begging for mercy, or perhaps Mary did not wish to inflame divisions in the country further by ordering her execution. Instead, she imprisoned Elizabeth for a few months before releasing her. Mary, after all, had other pressing matters to attend to.

By the end of 1554, the people of England had been formally absolved from their break from Rome. Catholic doctrine reappeared in English churches. Religious orders were re-established, and heresy acts returned, allowing the trial and execution of Protestants.

Mary has gone down in history as Bloody Mary. She sent many hundreds of Protestants to the flames. But was she more brutal than her peers, her predecessors? I don’t think so. The 16th century isn’t noted for kindly monarchs. Mary isn’t alone in having killed people for their religious faith.

What was notable about Mary’s reign is the ferocity of the burnings. The persecution period was small, and over a few years 287 men, women and children were burned. Mary hadn’t expected that she’d need to burn so many. She really felt that a few would set an example to the rest.

There’s this belief in the 16th century that if you allow heretics to live, then you will be damned alongside them. So Mary has a responsibility and a duty to remove these heretics from England. It’s not considered bloodthirsty. It’s considered a necessity.

In late 1554, Mary believed she was pregnant. The following spring, she summoned Elizabeth to court so she could witness the birth. It was a child who would displace Elizabeth from the line of succession and confirm England as a Catholic nation. Everything was going Mary’s way.

It was a moment of great misery for Elizabeth, for all the Protestants, because they really felt that Mary was going to gain what she wanted: a Catholic succession and England Catholic forevermore.

But of course it doesn’t turn out as planned, and this assumed pregnancy turns out to be a phantom pregnancy. It went on and on and on, and everyone waited at the court for the expected due date, but no baby arrived. Mary then has to emerge from her bedchamber and face the humiliation of saying, “Oh, I wasn’t actually pregnant,” even though the whole of England, the whole of Europe, had been holding its breath waiting for an announcement of an heir.

Mary had never enjoyed good health. There are many reports of her having stomach pains, often feeling faint, feeling sick, even from her early childhood. Now, it’s very possible that in fact Mary was suffering from ovarian cancer towards the end of her life. This would have explained the swelling in her stomach that was taken for pregnancy.

Poor Mary was humiliated, was heartbroken, and Elizabeth, well, she was back in the game.

The false pregnancy changed everything. Mary’s Spanish husband Philip withdrew. He left England to deal with other crises in the Habsburg Empire. In September of 1555, he leaves England, and he’ll only return, really, a few months before Mary dies for a brief spell. And it really marks the end of their marriage, which is painful, I think, for Mary.

It was perfectly obvious to everyone except herself that he didn’t love her and that he was bored by her. Mary adored Philip. She was obsessed with him, but her feelings weren’t reciprocated. And he waited around for the baby, and once he found there was not one, he was pretty angry, pretty embarrassed, and stormed off back to Spain to look at his ships instead. So Mary was doubly humiliated.

It was far from the only setback for Mary. She had hoped a Catholic England would be welcomed back into the embrace of Rome. Instead, the country was increasingly isolated. Habsburg wars in Italy had made Mary’s husband Philip an enemy of the Pope, the austere and authoritarian Paul IV. Mary’s dream of an England united with Rome lay in tatters.

She was nearing 40. She was childless, and her husband was absent. England’s future seemed certain. It was the Protestant Elizabeth who would be queen. Catholicism was once again under threat.

Mary entered a mental and physical decline. By mid-1558, her ill health was widely known.

Increasingly, she’s unable to do as much as she did in the early years of her reign because her health isn’t allowing her to do so. I think you can see her judgment going. She couldn’t accommodate people of different points of view. She didn’t know how to play one person off against another. She was beginning to lose it.

The country doesn’t like a sickly, weak monarch. They feel as if it’s judgment on them. And because they thought she was dying, that meant that everyone began to think, “Maybe it’s time to move our loyalties over to Elizabeth.” And Mary could even see this happening.

People look to, you know, the rising rather than the setting sun. And so you see courtiers kind of moving to Hatfield, trying to ingratiate themselves with the new expected monarch. People were intelligent enough to work out which way the power was going to go, and so Elizabeth has a growing number of people paying court to her. She’s gathering her supporters around her.

Just five years after her triumphant entry into London, Mary died on the 17th of November 1558. She was 42.

Elizabeth was well prepared. With her secretary, William Cecil, she put her plans into action. It was the most peaceful transition of power England had seen in more than a century.

Elizabeth would rule for the next 45 years. She would reject the advances of Mary’s widower, Philip. She would beat back the Armada after she turned against Spain, and she would oversee a golden age of cultural expression.

Elizabeth I’s reign saw a kind of printing revolution, a cultural revolution, a revolution in ideas, a revolution in the way in which ideas are communicated. It was the glory age of our literature. It produced Edmund Spenser, Sir Philip Sidney, William Shakespeare, Christopher Marlowe, John Donne. She was just the best ruler this country has ever had. There’s no question about it.

Of course, what Elizabeth doesn’t do is marry, and so she fashions a whole different identity over time of an unmarried monarch, which managed to be fashioned or spun in a way that was a sign of strength. When you look at the way that Queen Elizabeth ruled, the absolute authority with which she confronted the problems of her day, you can see that this was the role that she’d been made for.

Elizabeth glorifies herself by making her own image bigger, brighter and shinier than anything that’s gone before.

History often tries to make us see a clean break, which we never saw, between Elizabeth and Mary. But really, Elizabeth inherited a lot, certainly the dull but important things like fiscal reform and the development of the navy. This is all stuff that Mary is beginning. She lays all of the groundwork.

Mary was very, very interested in expanding British exploration. She encouraged explorers to go to Russia and the Baltic. She wanted them to go to America. She was keen on the northern explorations, Northwest Passage and things like that.

Elizabeth took what her sister Mary had started and made it her own. But during the course of her reign she never married and never had children. The dynasty begun by her grandfather ended with her.

There were no more Tudor monarchs. The crown instead passed peacefully to Elizabeth’s cousin, the Scottish King James VI. This first Stuart king of England saw to it that the two sisters, the two queens, Mary and Elizabeth, were buried together. They lie in a monumental tomb in Westminster Abbey.

But the two women, different in so many ways, share more than just a final resting place. Each had been a celebrated heir to the kingdom. Each had been a child denied by their father. Each had struggled through a sibling’s reign, and each had faced the challenge of ruling as a woman.

It was Mary that actually first articulated female sovereignty, who talked about a queen being the mother of the nation, all things that are sort of later attributed to Elizabeth. Even though she wasn’t a shining example, she had that kind of hard initial work to do in order to convince the people of England that queens weren’t a bad thing.

Mary passes a law that says that regnant queens have all the authority of kings. Elizabeth benefits from that. You know, queens have power and authority because her sister’s already been there and established what a regnant queen can and cannot do.

Both of them showed that a woman could do the job just as well as a man, and they were just as clever, and they were just as open to political intrigue and to political deception. Without them, you don’t get Victoria. You don’t get Elizabeth II. You would always have that idea that a woman would be lesser than a man when it came to the monarchy.

It can be easy to assume, when we look at the current British monarch, that a queen is commonplace. But the familiarity of a ruling female monarch can be traced back to the groundwork which was set nearly 500 years ago by Mary and Elizabeth, two extraordinary sisters.

You Might Also Enjoy