News

The short life of KATHERINE HOWARD | Henry VIII’s fifth wife | The most tragic Tudor Queen

 

She was the fifth wife of Henry VIII and perhaps the most tragic queen of the Tudor era.  A minor member of one of England’s most distinguished families, she rose unexpectedly to the top of society, but less than 18 months later fell from grace in the most brutal manner , ultimately meeting a horrific end in the Tower of London.

This is the life of Catherine Howard.  For a woman who became Queen of England, married to perhaps the most famous monarch, we know surprisingly little about almost all of Catherine Howard’s life.  She was the daughter of Lord Edmund Howard, younger son of the 2nd Duke of Norfolk, and Jocasta , or Joyce Lee, née Colepepper .

Her father’s sister was Lady Elizabeth Howard, mother of Anne Boleyn, making Catherine and Anne first cousins .  We do not know for sure where Catherine was born , although one biographer, Gareth Russell , claims that it was the parish of Lambeth in Surrey, where her father worked.  Lady Antonia Fraser suggests that her early childhood may have been spent in Oxenhoath, where her mother’s brother lived.

The earliest definite evidence of her existence dates from mid- 1527, when she appeared in the will of her maternal grandmother, Isabel Lee, who left her 20 shillings.  However, other evidence generally suggests that she was probably born sometime between 1521 and the fall of 1523.  I already have a video that goes into detail about this issue, which I’ll leave a link to on the screen and below for you if you want to better understand why I stopped at these dates.

Despite her distinguished lineage, Catherine was not wealthy by aristocratic standards.  She came from a large family, with five half- siblings from her mother’s first marriage and five to ten full siblings.  Different books I’ve read give different numbers.  Her father was also quite hopeless, always in debt and unable to support his wife and large offspring.

Her mother died in 1528 or 1529 , and she had a stepmother named Dorothy of Troyes, who probably died in the summer of 1530.  Her father obtained a job in Calais, and in 1531 he set off for France, marrying for the third time and leaving Catherine and her brother Henry in the care of their stepmother, Agnes, Dowager Duchess of Norfolk.

The Duchess lived at Chesworth in the village of Horsham, Sussex, and at her London residence, Norfolk House in Lambeth.  Catherine’s time with the Duchess was to be devoted to acquiring an education worthy of a lady of her rank and learning the refinements necessary to one day make her way at court. After all, in addition to being descended from the Howard family, she was also a cousin of the king’s mistress and future queen.

Unfortunately, the years spent in Agnes’s home ultimately proved fatal to her.  She and the other noble girls under Agnes’ care slept together in a kind of dormitory, instead of having their own rooms.  And years later it turned out that they didn’t behave like ladies at all. In fact, David Starkey calls it like a carelessly run mixed boarding house.

Although Antonia Fraser more gently calls it a high-class graduate school. One of the tutors hired for the girls in 1536 was a young man named Henry Mannox, who taught music alongside another man named Barnes.  However, despite this accompaniment, at some point Manox and Catherine began a romantic relationship. The Duchess found out about this when she accidentally saw them kissing near Chesworth Chapel, slapped Catherine, and ordered them both to end their relationship and not be alone.

They did not comply with his demand and were still the subject of controversy in early 1538, when Mannox made the disgusting but telling comment: ” I have possessed her with a word which I cannot utter, lest I be delivered of the demonism , and I knew it among the hundred, and she loves me, and I love her, and she told me that I would take her maidenhood, though it would be painful to her, no doubt, but I would be kind to her after this.

”  This shows that they haven’t slept together yet.  And when Catherine heard what Mannock said about her , she broke off the relationship.  Gareth Russell argues that he was probably no more than five years older than Catherine, and that this relationship, in an era when girls were considered to be of marriageable age at 12, did not amount to violence, even if he was not particularly chivalrous in his dealings with her.

However, this issue continues to be debated, given her youth at the time.  By 1538, she was still no more than 17, and perhaps only 15. One thing can be said : Agnes must have… taken much better care of her young charges. Catherine soon moved away, and her next lover was her grandmother’s secretary, Frances Durham .

With him, the physical relationship was apparently much more serious than with Mannock, although both he and she told one of the other girls living in the house, Lambeth in this case, who expressed concern about what they were doing, that they knew how to make sure Catherine didn’t get pregnant. Catherine made a copy of the key to the girls’ room so that Derham and the other men in the household could visit her and the other girls in their free time.

And the extent and voluntary nature of the relationship with Derem is beyond doubt, as it took place in front of other young women who shared the bedroom.  They even continued to talk, if you know what I mean, when one of Catherine’s neighbors was in bed with them , for young women often shared their beds, although of course there were not supposed to be any men there with them.

Eventually, the whole family knew about Catherine and Derham, and it didn’t last long .  before they had problems.  Mannix was jealous that his ex had moved on to a seemingly better life, and made a failed attempt to warn the Duchess with a vague and anonymous letter.  But eventually Agnes, who seemed to be extremely inattentive, did find out about the couple when she found them hugging.

She hit them both and got angry, but didn’t seem to realize how far their relationship had gone. And, as with Mannix, she did not remove Durham from his position or send Catherine away.  This was another serious oversight on her part. The couple continued to see each other, exchanging small gifts and even calling each other husband and wife.

Of course, there was no chance that a common servant would be allowed to marry Howard, but as Russell correctly points out, their talk of marriage, as well as the consummation of their relationship, might have been enough by 16th- century standards for them to get married.  Although later both denied this. However, Fraser suggests that they may have been married beforehand , and that Catherine probably, quote, considered herself engaged.

to Dereham.  Eventually, she realized she was not interested in being tied to him and ended their relationship in 1539, much to his chagrin, as he seemed to consider her his own.  However, very many people knew about this complicated relationship.  And they, like the flirtation with Menska, will return to haunt the future queen in just a few years.

The year 1539 proved to be a turning point in Catherine’s life in other aspects as well.  Her father died in March, leaving her an orphan.  Then, at the end of the year, her uncle, the Duke of Norfolk, secured her the position of lady-in-waiting to the last of Henry VIII’s wives, Anne of Cleves.  Catherine was probably at court by November, ready to receive her new mistress, although due to bad weather, Anna did not arrive until December , and the marriage took place on 6 January 1540.

It was immediately obvious that this was a disaster. Henry was offended by Anna from the first meeting, and in fact tried to avoid the wedding altogether. When that failed, he conducted it with great reluctance, and it seems the wedding was never consummated. Instead, Henry’s feelings almost immediately focused on Catherine herself, and her stepmother later claimed that he desired her at first sight.

But what did Henry see when he looked at Catherine?  Again , I have a whole video about potential portraits of her, which I’ll leave a link to on the screen and below for you.  But the ones that are most likely hers are two versions of the same image.  One is kept at Windsor Castle, the other at the Duke of Buccleuch.

They show her with brown hair, a pale complexion , squinted eyes, and wearing the Tudor necklace, which can also be seen in images of most of Henry’s other wives.  These paintings, now held at the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Yale Center for British Art, may also depict her.  One of those who saw her in person, the French ambassador Charles de Marillac, described her in August 1540 as moderately…

pretty, but with unsurpassed grace.  She was small and slender, with a charming face.  And, like her cousin Anne before her, she loved to dress in the French style, as we see in this portrait, where the model wears a French hood.  It seems that Henry saw a pretty and lively teenage girl. Maybe not very beautiful, but certainly quite pleasing to the eye.

The king did not immediately fall in love with Catherine. Remember, he was supposed to see her in November, but it wasn’t until January that he realized he wasn’t interested in his new German wife.  So she was not long a lady-in-waiting with an annual salary of 10 pounds.  She lived with the Queen, which meant she was initially at Greenwich Palace .

And it was during her stay at Anna’s house that she met two people who would ultimately play a key role in her downfall, but we don’t have photos of either of them.  One of them was another lady-in-waiting who was also Catherine’s cousin, Jane Boleyn, Viscountess Rochford, widow of George Boleyn, whose sister Anne was. Boleyn.

The other was a very distant cousin named Thomas Culpepper, one of the king’s gentlemen in the Privy Chamber, a man who seems to have been previously accused of murder and having an affair with a married woman, unless the source recounting these crimes was mistaken or confused with someone else. Catherine seems to have flirted with Thomas very quickly , and rumors that they were going to marry reached Francis Dereham.

Although in reality, it seems that Thomas did not pursue her as much as Francis did, and Catherine dismissed any talk of marriage when asked about it , saying that it was all news to her .  If the king’s initial interest in her had not been rekindled after the marriage at Cleves Palace failed, it is likely that these courtships of Culpepper would never have mattered.

Russell makes an interesting conclusion that while Catherine’s family, especially her uncle Norfolk, are often accused of putting her before Henry and using her to rebuild their fortunes after the loss of Anne Boleyn, in reality, if they had had a plan to get one of their women into his bed, it was not she, with her dishonorable past, who would ultimately have put them all in danger.

Instead, it seems that Henry followed her solely of his own free will, and the Howards were forced to react to the situation as it developed, rather than manage it. It is easy to say now that if she or her family had been wiser, they would have informed Henry, perhaps even anonymously, that she was not chaste enough to be considered for the position of Queen of England, and blamed their failure to do so on the allure of the throne.

But on the other hand, it was practically impossible to refuse the king.  Catherine was able to break off relations with Mannock and Dereham whenever she wanted, and her flirtation with Culpepper seemed to have come to naught, but with Henry, her only viable option , when he was proposing to her, would be to reveal information that would destroy her.

I would say she was in a catch-22 and was much more stuck in her relationship with him than with previous men. At least Derham left. He left for Ireland angrily and without the Duchess’s permission as soon as he learned that the King was interested in Catherine .  So he left her the considerable sum of 100 coins , which showed that he still considered her bound to him, even though she was not his wife.

Mannock remained in Agnes’ service, while Culpepper, as we have seen, was at the royal court. Catherine’s position as the king’s new mistress became apparent to onlookers by April 1540, when she was given the property of two convicted criminals .  He also bought her other gifts, and soon, for the sake of appearances, her family took her back to Lambeth, where the king visited her.

He left Anne in June , annulled the marriage in mid-July, and Parliament quickly passed a law allowing him to marry a woman even if he was already in a relationship with her or any of her close relatives.  This helped the couple resolve the issue that Henry had previously been married to Catherine’s cousin, Anne Boleyn, and had at least a liaison, if not a full-blown affair, with another cousin, Mary.  Boleyn.

This may also indicate that Henry and Catherine themselves acted tactlessly.  Fraser certainly believes that the relationship was consummated while Henry was still married to Anne of Cleves, and in July there were false rumors that Catherine was already pregnant.  They were secretly married on the 28th of that month at Outlands Palace in Surrey.

Henry was 49 years old, Catherine was at most 19, or possibly 16, depending on the year of her birthday.  On their wedding day, his former favorite, Thomas Cromwell, was beheaded because he had played an important role in the alliance of the Field Brethren of Cleves. The couple went hunting on their honeymoon , and the marriage was announced publicly on August 8.

After the honeymoon, Catherine spent most of her early marriage on royal travel.  They did not return to Windsor Castle until October 20, 1540. Henry seemed incredibly happy with her .  Eyewitnesses noted that he courted her much more than her predecessors, and showered her with gifts while she…as her motto the phrase “None shall be free but Him.

”  ” She was never a political being like Catherine of Aragon, Anne Boleyn, and later Catherine Parr.”  She also had no such interest in religion or their renowned intellectual prowess.  She was apparently taught reading, writing, music, and dancing, and was probably raised Catholic, but we cannot go any further in discussing her education.

She showed little interest in carefully managing the estates given to her after marriage to provide for her own income, although this is hardly surprising since she was not taught how to manage such property and had no opportunity to see her parents or ex-husband do so. She showed some inclination towards charity, interceding in the spring of 1541 for the release from the Tower of London of two prisoners, including Thomas Wyatt, who was known to be in love with Anne Boleyn, instead of execution.

On New Year’s Day 1541, an awkward reunion took place at Hampton Court Palace when Anne of Cleves, now given the honorary title of the King’s sister, arrived at court for the celebrations.    The former queen’s former maid of honor was now her boss, and Catherine was initially unsure of the etiquette for this unprecedented event.

Keep in mind that none of Henry’s other wives ever had to formally welcome their predecessors, and his actual sisters were queens consorts of Scotland and France.  Anne, it was now claimed , never held such a title in England.  Both women chose to be overly polite, with Anna addressing the woman who had placed her on her lap, even as Catherine begged her to stand.

Together they managed to get through it before Henry came in and invited them to dinner .  After that, he went to bed, and his ex-wife and his current wife danced together all night.  They did the same the next night, and Catherine even gave Anne two puppies and the engagement ring that the king had just given her.

If only things had gone as smoothly with the other adult female royal Catherine had to deal with. Henry’s eldest daughter Mary was several years older than the new queen, and they had a difficult relationship.  Mary did not treat Catherine with the same respect as Catherine. believed she deserved it, and the queen retaliated, nearly removing two of Mary’s maids from service.

Initially, the princess managed to smooth things over and keep her ladies , but it seems that relations quickly deteriorated again, and Catherine did remove the two women in early 1541.  Shortly thereafter, one of them died, causing Mary great grief. The relationship with her other stepdaughters, who were actually children and therefore easier to manage, was much better.

Princess Elizabeth, of course, was also the daughter of Catherine’s cousin, so she may have felt greater affection for her.  She visited a 7-year-old girl in May 1541 at the Old Palace in Chelsea and gave the little girl some inexpensive necklaces.  By the way, I know that Mary and Elizabeth were not called princesses at that time, but for the sake of clarity, I will call them that.

As for Prince Edward, who was then three years old, Catherine met him a few days later at Waltham Hall Cross in Essex, where he was then living with Princess Mary.  And again everything went well.  Other areas of Catherine’s life were also successful. She left Hampton Court in March 1541, to enter London for the first time officially on the 19th of that month, for which a grand river festival was held for her on the Thames.

She then settled in Greenwich Palace , and in April told Henry what he undoubtedly wanted to hear most.  She thought she was pregnant.  Unfortunately for her, as a successful pregnancy with a boy would likely have secured her the position, little was heard about it , and it appears she either made a mistake or had an early miscarriage.

The possibility that she was lying seems unlikely to me , since she had so little to gain from a lie that would have been so quickly exposed and potentially called her fertility into question.  There was never any serious talk of her getting pregnant again, and if you watch my video on the fertility problems of Henry and his queens, you can hear the discussion of potential problems on the king’s part.

This pregnancy rumor was also the only time there was actual talk of Catherine being crowned queen, an event that ultimately never happened.  Her youth , the lack of supervision she experienced as a child, and the absence of courtiers. Kateryna’s experience was evident in her relationships with her households. She did not reprimand one of her ladies-in-waiting, Dorothy Bray, for having an affair with a married man, even though she should have cared about the morals of her ladies and helped them find good marriages.  When they

behaved badly, it reflected badly on her.  The young wife evidently did not understand or care what was expected of her and was prepared to let her ladies carry on as they had at Horsham and Lambeth, without considering that she was now Queen of England and had to hold herself to much higher standards. Catherine’s past caused her much greater problems than her lack of preparation for court behavior, but until now they had been well hidden.

When one of her old friends from the Duchess’s household, Joan Bulmer, learned that she was to become queen, she wrote a letter asking to be brought to London to serve in the royal court. Russell argues that while most historians have taken this letter as evidence that Catherine did indeed make this unwise appointment of a woman who knew all her dirty secrets, there is actually no evidence that Bulmer was employed.

However, other servants from Chesworth and Lambeth were gradually drawn into royal service with the help of the Duchess of Norfolk and Catherine’s aunt, the Countess of Bridgewater. Perhaps this was done to buy their silence, making their own success and safety dependent on Catherine’s success and safety, but in the end it backfired.

Lady Rochford also remained at court, now as one of Catherine’s many female attendants .  Far more problematic was the reappearance of the talkative and impulsive Francis Dereham, whose past the Howard family had tried to cover up by rehiring him, although, according to Russell, not as Catherine’s secretary, as some previous historians had claimed.

She agreed to meet with him, perhaps to try to calm him down and keep his mouth shut, but he didn’t join her household , at least not yet. Also in her circle was Thomas Culpepper, and in the spring of 1541 their initial fascination changed and grew into something more.  Before we get into the details, if you enjoyed watching this content, please give the video a like and subscribe to the channel by turning on the notification bell to get a little bell every time I upload a video.

You can also join me on Patreon to receive bonus content, including early access to ad-free videos, tons of podcasts and blog posts, and my catalog of bonus items. This week, my regular fans will also get my review of the biography of Catherine Howard, written by Russell.  Finally, I have an Amazon store where I have compiled recommendations for books, TV shows, movies, and other items on historical themes.

Links to both materials are provided in the description box below, as well as to my Instagram account.  Also, thank you to those of you who donate funds to the channel using the thank you button under the video, as your generosity is always greatly appreciated.  Catherine and Culpeper met on Maundy Thursday, April 14, 1541 , at a meeting arranged by Lady Rochford.

And Catherine gave him the cap, although he wasn’t particularly grateful and asked why she hadn’t shown this much interest in…him before marriage.  This indifferent reaction pushed her away from him for a while, but by the end of spring, Catherine began sending him trays of food when he fell ill.    At the end of June 1541, the king and queen set off on a journey to the north of England, and during this time their relationship with Culpeper also developed.

While in Lincoln in early August, Catherine met him one evening in her apartments with the help of Lady Rochford and talked with him until morning.  So long that Jane fell asleep.  The next night they met again and confessed their love to each other. It’s hard to imagine how they could have spent enough time together for it to be true love and not just passion, but either way, they were both almost in the most dangerous waters and were foolish to let things get this far.

Russell specifically rejects any idea that Culpepper blackmailed Catherine into seeing him, believing the relationship to be entirely consensual.  And Starkey and Fraser don’t mind.  As the trip progressed into September, the couple continued to see each other and exchange gifts.  Although the practical difficulties of organising and holding their meetings and the stress they created for the Queen, who was keenly aware of how dangerous her actions were, meant that her strange orders and fiery temper were noticed by her servants, who

found it strange that none of her ladies, apart from Jane Rochford, were allowed to enter her chambers unless summoned.  It was to Culpeper that Catherine’s only surviving letter was addressed, and although it is undated, Russell believes it comes from this trip, when they were on a close relationship, although Starkey and Fraser both experience a period of his illness in the spring.

It reads: “Master Culpeper, I can hardly recommend myself to you, I beg you to send me news of your affairs.  I was informed that you were ill, which worried me greatly , until I received an answer from you, I beg you to send me news of your affairs.  Because I have never wanted anything so much as to see you and talk to you, which I hope will happen soon .

It comforts me greatly when I think about it.” And when I think again that you will leave me again, my heart freezes.  From the thought of how lucky I am that I can’t be with you all the time. However, I always hope for you to be as you promised me.  And I still rely on this hope .  So I beg you to come when my Lady Rochford is here .

Because then I can best carry out your orders.  Thank you for promising me to be so kind to this poor man, my husband, and this is one of the sorrows I feel at being separated from him. Because then I don’t know anyone I would dare trust to send you.  And so I beg you to take him to your place, so that I may hear from you someday .

I beg you for one thing : give me a horse for my husband.  Because I tried so hard to get it.  And therefore I beg you to send me one through him, and with this, as I have said, I bid you farewell, hoping to see you again soon.  And I wish you were with me right now, so you could see the pain I feel writing to you.  Yours for the rest of your life, Catherine.

I forgot one thing, namely: to order my husband to stay here with me, because he says that whatever you order him, he will do. It is difficult to overstate how dangerous the situation that Catherine allowed to develop became.  Their letters suggest that she and Culpepper never actually made a deal, but their behavior was reckless, and while I agree that much of her actions before the marriage can be forgiven for her youth, and that Duchess Agnes should have taken better care of her, I think that at this stage in her life she was

old enough and experienced enough to know better, and Doates deserves a good deal of the blame for the Culpepper affair.  The way she tried to hide it also shows that she knew very well that she was very wrong.  This is not to say that I believe she deserved her ultimate fate, because I don’t, but there is a tendency in the 21st century to portray her as a complete and utter victim with no agency whatsoever.

Although in reality, I think it’s a bit more complicated, and I don’t believe she was completely innocent.  I know this idea won’t be popular with some people, but think about it.  Henry VIII’s sister, Mary, who was first married to the King of France, married his friend, Henry’s friend, Charles Brandon, against her brother’s wishes, when she was just under 19 and Brandon was about 31.

This means she was about the same age or perhaps even younger than Catherine in 1541, and I’m not aware of any major movement to claim that Mary, also Queen Consort, was a puppet in Brandon’s power and didn’t know what she was doing.    It is generally believed that she was the one who pushed through this second wedding, and she is credited with being old enough to know what she was thinking and understand what she was doing.

Why is one woman so often portrayed as a victim, battered by people and events completely beyond her control, while another is a free spirit who takes responsibility for her own fate and dictates it herself? Just something to think about.  But let’s get back to Catherine.  As if her actions in 1541 weren’t enough, in the latter part of the summer her past also caught up with her.

According to Russell, it was on August 25 that Francis Derham suddenly appeared during the royal trip .  Although Starkey says he came back into Catherine’s life a little earlier this year in London.  Whatever the case , she invited him to her home, probably in a desperate attempt to keep him quiet. But it seems strange to those around him that this rude man, who quarreled with other servants, took liberties unrelated to his position, such as hovering over her at dinner when he should have declined, and who seemed to appear out of nowhere, was so

quickly assigned to her staff.  It didn’t help that he had hinted at his previous relationship with the Queen and seemed determined to show that he was on a close relationship with her.  In short, Francis Derham was a talkative, ill-mannered idiot who had not learned to keep his mouth shut , even when Catherine, who was hardly a paragon of prudence or wisdom herself, begged and even paid him to do so.

Everything began to unravel, and within months it was to end in disaster for both the queen and some of her closest associates.    The royal party returned to Windsor on October 26, then set off for Hampton Court a few days later.  This is where the beginning of the end for Catherine came. She continued to meet with Culpepper and continued to arouse suspicion in her servants, sending them to Lady Rochford with strange, incomprehensible questions that elicited equally strange answers.

Then, in early November, a man named John Lascelles came to see the Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer. John’s sister, Mary, was a maid at Lambeth when Catherine was there, and she told her brother of the queen’s numerous premarital humiliations. “No,” he told Cranmer.  Cranmer set out the charges in a letter he left for the king in his chapel at Hampton Court on 2 November.

At first, Henry claimed that he did not believe the stories about his wife, but nevertheless ordered a quiet investigation into the matter.  Over the course of 3 days, everyone from John Lascelles and his sister to Henry Mannox was interviewed.  Mannox, in particular, revealed everything, revealing far more details than Mary was able to provide.

Although, as Russell says, he seems to have been unaware that Mary was the source of information for his interviewer , so he could not have tailored his answers to what only she knew.  He admitted that, and I quote, he felt more about Catherine’s body than was comfortable, but he swore that things didn’t go any further than that.

Durham was also quickly arrested, sent to the Tower of London, where he was tortured for several weeks, and soon revealed incredibly devastating details about his time with Catherine and how far their relationship had gone. No doubt he regretted not having stayed in Ireland, or at least not having been foolish enough to pursue her and force his way back into her life.

More and more people from the queen’s past were questioned, and the substantial uniformity of the stories they told independently of each other made it clear that these stories were true, especially considering that it would have been in most people’s best interests to lie and not admit that they knew the king was marrying a loose woman.

On November 6, just 4 days after Henry read Cranmer’s letter, he was informed that all the accounts of the queen’s former life were accurate and even worse than initially suspected. Henry burst into tears. Catherine was now locked in her apartments at Hampton Court Palace, and rumors were spreading about what was happening.

By this time, Durham’s detention in the Tower had become increasingly well-known. There is a legend that at some point she escaped and ran screaming down the gallery, actually this gallery if I’m not mistaken, trying to reach Henry to beg for mercy, but it is unclear whether this story is true. And Starkey writes that Henry left the palace, never to see her again , even before Catherine realized what was happening.

On Sunday the 6th she was examined by Cranmer and others, and charged with having been previously imprisoned with Francis Derham. Catherine denied everything, but over the next few visits she confessed. Sometimes she was in utter hysterics with fear, and Cranmer described her in such a state of pity and gravity that I have never seen in any creature, so that any man in the world would have been sorry to look at her.

Henry sent her a message saying he would show her mercy in exchange for the truth, which increased her guilt, and eventually it all came out in a series of conversations with the Archbishop.  Her first confession is lost.  The other two survived.  As Russell says, the second is the less frequently cited of the two and indicates that Catherine’s relationship with Dereham was consensual.

This is because the third and final confession is quoted more often, in which Catherine began to backtrack completely and say that Dereham had aggressively pursued and repeatedly assaulted her, but the story that she had been horribly abused gained such credibility.  I tend to agree with Russell’s assessment that the very initial admission of a consensual relationship has a certain tinge of truth, especially given that it is supported by all the independent testimony of those who saw them together over an extended period of time.  Catherine’s decision to rehire

him also called into question her version of events from the investigators’ perspective and gave the impression that she was once again setting him up as her lover.  Now, looking at things from a 21st century Western perspective , we could still argue that Mannox and Lederer Durham were very wrong given Catherine’s age, but it simply wouldn’t be viewed that way back then.

After all, Henry VIII actually married her when she was no more than 19 years old, and he had previously had a teenage mistress in the person of Bessie Blount when he was in his early 20s.  So, while I, and I’m sure many of you, find the men’s treatment of Catherine to be, to say the least, very distasteful, and I think they were using her for their own pleasure, their actions at a time when a girl was considered marriageable at 12 simply would not have been considered abhorrent or inherently wrong .

And when Catherine was honest, she didn’t present them as such either .  Her youth, lack of good advisors, and the fact that she couldn’t really refuse Henry’s offer or tell him about her past without him would absolve her of virtually all guilt for her teenage mistakes if she were alive today.  Although, as I said, I think she was definitely old enough to understand the Culpepper case better at the time .

But they didn’t give her that kind of freedom of action in the 16th century.  She now wrote to Henry, confessing her affairs with Manx and Durham and begging for mercy.  But what was her legal position at that time?  Well, consensual premarital relations were not a crime, and if Catherine was indeed Derham’s wife, then she was guilty of adultery with him, but that in itself would not have led to her death.

However, she was not a lawyer and probably did not realize that this could be her loophole .  In any case, considering that her cousin Anne Boleyn was executed on trumped-up charges, I do n’t think for a minute that if she had confessed to her bigamy and not to the real queen, Henry would have let her or her lovers live. Whatever the case, she never claimed to be Francis’ wife.

However, she did not admit to adultery after her marriage to Mannox or Durham, which is why the affair with Thomas Culpepper became so important. Catherine mentioned Culpepper in passing to Cranmer, saying that she had spoken to Francis Durham about Thomas’s interest in her in late 1539 or early 1540.  This hinted to the Archbishop that there might be a third man worth investigating, and Durham soon remembered his rival as well.

This put Catherine in much greater danger, as the implication was now that she had committed adultery with Henry. Culpepper was arrested on November 12th or 13th , and his rooms were searched on the 14th .  That’s why we have the letter I showed you, which Catherine wrote to him.  When investigators came to question Catherine about the couple’s meetings during the summer move, she immediately blamed everything on Lady Rochford, who had encouraged her to meet him, thereby deciding the fate of her maid of honor.

Lady Rochford was spoken to on the 13th, although of course she placed more blame on her mistress than on herself, as both women claimed to have wanted to separate Catherine from Thomas. Jane said that Catherine and Thomas slept together, but Thomas said that they never did, even though both wanted to and intended to.

This confession alone was enough to write him a death sentence.  He was imprisoned in the Tower, as was Lady Rochford, although she quickly had a nervous breakdown and had to be placed under the care of Sir John and Anne Lady Russell to bring her to her senses before she was killed, as it was illegal to execute a mad person.

There is an ongoing debate about who was telling the truth.  Did Catherine commit adultery with Thomas or not?  We’ll never know for sure, but you can share your thoughts in the comments below.    The queen’s court was disbanded, a very ominous sign that there was no way back for her, and on November 14 she was sent to the abandoned Abbey of Sion.

Thanks to the English Reformation, there were no longer any nuns there, and it was in decline.  She was given a tiny three-room suite and allowed to take only a small retinue of servants and possessions, including just six dresses and six deliberately rather plain and unadorned French hoods. The strain on her was immense, and she began to break down under it, refusing to eat, crying constantly, and disturbing her guards to the point that they took away anything they thought she might hurt herself with.

On November 22, she was stripped of her title of queen.  Virtually everyone she had known before and during her marriage now turned against her, including family members such as her uncle, the Duke of Norfolk, who even said he hoped she would be burned alive, and her half-sister and former lady-in-waiting, Isabella Bainton.

She and her husband were effectively the former queen’s jailers, and Isabella received land grants from Henry shortly after Catherine’s disgrace, which Russell believes indicates that she provided information against her sister.  More than a dozen of Catherine’s family and former friends were imprisoned in the Tower, including the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk and the Countess of Bridgewater, but all were eventually forgiven.

Catherine had no choice but to wait.  According to Spanish Ambassador Eustace Chapuis, after a few weeks she recovered, started eating and having fun again. However, she still expected to end her life on the scaffold.  She was not mistaken.  Henry Mannox escaped punishment, but on 1 December Thomas Culpepper and Francis Dereham were tried for their involvement with the Queen and found guilty of high treason.

Both were executed at Tyburn on December 10. Culpepper was beheaded, but Dereham fared much worse.  After further torture between trial and death, he was eventually hanged, crushed, and quartered, despite his pleas for a quicker and more merciful execution.  However, he did not have the same high social standing as Culpepper, and Henry seems to have been particularly angry with the man who he believed had his wife before him.

The heads of both men were impaled on stakes on London Bridge. If they were guilty, then by default Kateryna was also guilty.  However, unlike her cousin Anne, she did not have a separate trial, and was instead convicted by an act of forced murder introduced in the House of Lords on 21 January 1542 , as was Lady Rochford.

The bill received the royal seal of approval by letters patent on February 11.  By then, Catherine had already been moved to the Tower, having to be physically dragged into a boat to get there, and passing under the rolling heads of Francis and Thomas on her journey.  It was within its walls on February 13 that she and Jane Boleyn met their deaths.

The night before, Kateryna asked for a block of wood to be brought to her so she could practice resting her head on it.  Then, between 7:00 and 9:00 a.m. the next day, different sources give different times, she met her fate. According to the French ambassador Charles de Mariac, she was so weak that she could barely speak.

But she died peacefully and with dignity, dying from an axe, not from the sword under which Anne Boleyn died. The only surviving eyewitness account of what happened was written by a man named Otwell Johnson in a letter to his brother John two days later.  It says: “ Know that even according to my notes of last Sunday, I see the Queen and Lady Rochford suffering in the Tower the next day.

Whose souls, I have no doubt, are with God. For they made the most pious and Christian end that has ever been heard of, I think, since the creation of the world.  Expressing their living faith in the blood of Christ alone, and with kind words and an unwavering countenance , they desired that all Christians should consider their worthy and just punishment of death for their transgressions and vileness against God from their youth, in breaking all his commandments, and also in a very dangerous way infringing upon the King’s Royal Majesty.

Therefore, being justly condemned, as they said, by the laws of the kingdom and parliament to death, they required the people, I say, to take from them an example to amend their wicked lives, and to joyfully obey the King in all things, for whose preservation they earnestly prayed and desired that all men should do so, commending their souls to God and earnestly beseeching mercy from Him, I beseech you to grant us grace with such faith, hope, and charity, when we depart from this miserable world, to attain the fruit of His Divinity in

everlasting joy.  Amen .  Otwell’s letter combines their last words, so we don’t know who said what, but both, following the conventional wisdom, admitted that they deserved to die.  Catherine, of course, did not say the famous line often attributed to her that she died a queen, but rather would have preferred to die Culpepper’s wife.

We can gather some additional details from other sources, even if they were not written by witnesses. Catherine died first, after which her body was covered with a black cloak and pushed aside before Jane followed her former lover to her death.  A law was quickly passed authorizing the execution of the insane.  After their deaths, they were probably buried under the altar in the nearby chapel of St.

Peter ad Vincula, where Catherine’s cousins, Anne and George Boleyn, already lay. However, when the Victorians repaired the floor in the 1870s, no bones believed to belong to the Queen were found, although a few fragments were. it is believed that it was Lady Rochford. I have a video of what may have happened to Catherine’s remains, which I’ll leave a link to for you, so I’ll just say here that there is no reason to believe she dissolved in lime, as the Victorians believed.

 

You Might Also Enjoy