The Dark Truth Behind Joan Crawford: Hollywood Legend, Secret Pain, and the War That Divided a Family
Joan Crawford. The dark truth behind Mommy Dearest. On the 10th of May 1977, in an apartment high above East 69th Street in Manhattan, one of the most famous women of the 20th century died of a heart attack. There were no cameras. There were no crowds. For nearly 3 years, she had barely left that apartment.
4 days before she died, she had given away her beloved little shiu, a dog named Princess Lotus Blossom because she no longer had the strength to look after her. Her name was Joan Crawford. She had made more than 80 films. She had won an Academy Award. At the height of her fame, she had been one of the highest paid women in the United States, a star so powerful that her name alone could sell a picture anywhere in the world.
and she died a recluse in a small apartment surrounded by the relics of a life that had once been lived at full volume. 7 months earlier, she had signed her will. Most of it was ordinary. There were gifts to charities she had supported for years. The USO, the American Cancer Society, the Musculardrophe Association, a home for retired film workers, a school for troubled boys.
There was money for her loyal secretary of nearly 50 years. There was an inheritance for her two youngest daughters, the twins Kathy and Cindy. And then there was one sentence, cold and final, that would echo for decades. She wrote that she was making no provision for her son Christopher or her daughter Christina for reasons which were well known to them.
18 months later, the world thought it had found out what those reasons were. In the autumn of 1978, Christina Crawford published a memoir called Mommy Dearest. It described a childhood of fear, of rages in the night, of punishments that seemed designed to humiliate, and of a mother who treated her children as props in a public performance.
It became one of the most sensational bestsellers of its time. 3 years later, it became a movie starring Fay Dunaway, and one hysterical scream from that movie about wire hangers became so famous that for millions of people, it is now the only thing they know about Joan Crawford at all. But here is the problem with the story. Most people think they know.
The movie is not the book. The book is not the whole family. And the family itself was split right down the middle. Two of Joan Crawford’s children said she was cruel. Two of her children said she was a loving mother, and they said it loudly and consistently for the rest of their lives. Her friends lined up on both sides.
One of her daughters took another to court over what she had said in public. And behind all of it sits a trail of facts that rarely makes it into the famous version. About a baby Joan Crawford was forced to give back, about a notorious adoption agency in Tennessee, and about the kind of childhood that shaped the woman at the center of it all.
Today we are going to try to separate what is documented from what is alleged, what is rumor from what is record and what the famous movie invented from what the people who were actually there said happened. This is not a story with a clean hero or a clean villain. It is something messier, sadder, and far more human.
Before we go any further, if you enjoy these deep dives into the real stories behind Hollywood’s biggest legends, please take a moment to subscribe to the channel and turn on notifications so you never miss one. And tell me in the comments right now. Before today, what did you believe about Joan Crawford? Monster, misunderstood, or something in between? Tell me where you are starting.
And by the end of this video, let us see whether you still feel the same way. To understand Joan Crawford, we have to go back to a little girl who did not yet have that name into a childhood that almost nobody in Hollywood would ever hear about. She was born Lucille Fea Lassur in San Antonio, Texas on the 23rd of March.
The year is uncertain and that is not an accident. The most careful biographers believe it was 1904. Over the course of her life, however, the year drifted to 1905, 1906, 1908, and even 1909, depending on who was asking and what the studio needed. When she enrolled at college in 1922, she gave her birth year as 1906. When she died, the crypt that received her ashes listed it as 1908.
Christina would later write that her grandmother told her the true year was 1904. From the very beginning, Joan Crawford’s life was a story she edited. Her father was Thomas Lassour, a construction worker from Tennessee. Her mother was Annabelle Johnson, who was probably still a teenager when her first children were born.
Lucille had an older brother, Hal, and a halfsister named Daisy, who died when she was only a small child, and then her father left. Thomas Lassur walked out on the family when Lucille was about 10 months old. He eventually settled in Abalene, Texas. She would have no memory of him at all. Her mother remarried.
In 1909, Anna wet a man named Henry Kassen, and the family settled in Lton, Oklahoma, where Kassen ran a theater called the Ramsay Opera House. It was a real stage, one that booked touring acts from across the country, and it brought names as grand as the ballerina Anna Pavlova and the vaudeville star Eva Tangway to a small Oklahoma town.
For a little girl, it was pure magic. She went by the name Billy Cassen, and she spent every moment she could watching the vaudeville axe from the wings of her stepfather’s theater. She called Henry Kassen daddy. According to her biographers, she did not know he was not her real father until her brother eventually told her the truth.
Imagine learning as a child that the man you have always called your father is not your father at all and that your real father simply walked away. It is the kind of discovery that teaches a child the ground beneath her can move at any moment. What little Billy wanted most in the world was to dance. And there is a small telling story from these years.
One day trying to escape a piano lesson, she leapt from the front porch and landed on a broken milk bottle, cutting her foot badly. According to her biographers, it took three operations to repair, and for about 18 months, she could not attend school or take dance lessons. The child who dreamed of dancing had to learn to walk properly again first.
She did, and then she danced anyway. In 1917, the family’s life in Lton fell apart. Henry Kassen was accused of embezzlement. He was acquitted, but the scandal ruined his name in the town and the family moved to Kansas City, Missouri. Before long, Anna and Henry separated. And here, the childhood of the future, Joan Crawford, takes its darkest turn.
Kassen, who was Catholic, had placed Billy at a Catholic school in Kansas City called St. Agnes’s Academy. When her mother and stepfather separated, she did not leave. She stayed on as what was called a work student, a child who earned her place by laboring for it. By the accounts of her biographers, she spent far more of her time working, mostly cooking and cleaning, than she ever spent studying.
Later, she moved to another school, Rockingham Academy, again as a working student. Think about what that meant daytoday. While the other girls went to their lessons, she scrubbed. While they ate, she served. She was the poor girl, the one who cleaned up after everyone else. Because her family life was so unstable, her schooling never really went beyond the primary level.
Her whole early life taught her that every scrap of security had to be earned and that it could be taken away at any time. Later in life, Joan Crawford would become famous and infamous for her obsession with cleanliness and order. She scrubbed floors herself, even when she was a millionaire with a household staff. She insisted on spotless rooms, perfect closets, and rigid routines.
Many of the most disturbing scenes in Mommy Dearest revolve around cleaning, around children made to scrub and polish and put things in perfect order. It is impossible to read about the girl who scrubbed floors to pay her way through St. Agnes’s Academy and not see a connection. None of this excuses anything that may have happened later in her own home, but it helps explain where the obsession came from.
Her teenage years were a scramble. She had her first serious romance with a trumpet player named Ray Sterling, who reportedly encouraged her to take her studies more seriously. In 1922, she enrolled at Stevens College in Columbia, Missouri. She lasted only a few months before withdrawing.
Realizing she simply was not ready for college. What she was ready for was the stage. Under her birth name, Lucille Lassour, she began dancing in the choruses of traveling reviews. In Detroit, she was spotted by the powerful Broadway producer Jacob J. Schubert, who put her in the chorus line of his 1924 show, Innocent Eyes, at the Winter Garden Theater in New York. Broadway.
The girl who had scrubbed floors at a Kansas City convent school was dancing in a Broadway chorus line and she wanted more. She approached a well-connected publicist named Neils Granland who got her work with the singer Harry Richmond and arranged a screen test that was sent to a producer in Hollywood.
On the 24th of December 1924, Christmas Eve, the answer came. Metro Goldwin Mayor was offering her a contract at $75 a week. She was back at her mother’s home in Kansas City when the telegram arrived. She borrowed $400 for the journey and she headed west. She was about 20 years old. She had almost no education, no family money, no connections, and a past she would spend the rest of her life trying to outrun.
What she had was hunger, a ferocious, bottomless hunger to never be the poor girl again. When Lucille Lassour arrived at MGM in early 1925, she was one of hundreds of pretty young hopefuls on the payroll, and the studio did not quite know what to do with her. Her very first film credit came that year in a picture called Lady of the Night, and her job in it tells you exactly where she stood.
She was the body double for Norma Shearer, MGM’s most popular actress. The camera saw the back of her head while Shearer got the close-ups. It was the beginning of a rivalry that would last for years. Normashir was not just MGM’s leading lady. She was married to Irving Falberg, the studios head of production, and she had first pick of the scripts.
The girl from Kansas City watched Sheerer get the roles she wanted and did not hide how she felt about it. A remark attributed to her in those years, bitter and funny in equal measure, suggested that competing with Sheerer was impossible because Sheerer was married to the boss. Then there was the matter of her name.
MGM’s publicity chief Pete Smith believed she had the makings of a star, but he felt her name was all wrong. According to the story he told, Lassour reminded him of a sewer. So, the studio ran a contest in a fan magazine called Movie Weekly, inviting readers to name the new starlet. The first choice was Joan Ardan, but another actress already had a claim to it, so the runnerup was chosen, Joan Crawford.
She did not love it at first. She reportedly said the surname reminded her of Crawfish, and she wanted her first name pronounced Joanne, but she also admitted she liked the security that came with it. A new name chosen by strangers owned by a studio for a woman who wanted to leave her past behind. It was almost perfect. Lucille Lassour, Billy Cassin, the work student at St. Agnes’s Academy.
All of them could be folded away. From now on, there was only Joan Crawford. What happened next tells you everything about her. The small parts kept coming and they were not enough. So Joan Crawford decided to make herself a star. She threw herself into a campaign of self-promotion unlike anything the studio had seen.
She went out dancing almost every afternoon and evening at hotel ballrooms around Hollywood and on the amusement peers by the beach. And she won dance contests doing the Charleston and the Black Bottom. She made sure she was seen. She made sure she was photographed. She answered her fan mail personally, a habit she kept for the rest of her life.
A screenwriter at MGM in those years, Frederria Sagor Moss later summed it up in a line that has been quoted ever since. In her view, nobody decided to make Joan Crawford a star. Joan Crawford decided to become one. It worked. In 1925, she made an impression in a film called Sally, Irene, and Mary. In 1926, she was named one of the year’s Wampus Baby stars, a publicity honor given to promising young actresses alongside future legends like Janet Gainor, Mary Aster, and FA Ray.
In 1927, she played opposite the great Lawn Cheney in the unknown. And she later said she learned more about acting from watching Cheney than from anyone else in her career. And in 1928 came the role that made her. In Our Dancing Daughters, she played a wild, free-spirited society girl named Diana Medford, dancing on tabletops with a joy that seemed to leap off the screen.
Overnight, Joan Crawford became one of the defining flappers of the jazz age, a rival to Clara Bo, the original ITG girl. The novelist F. Scott Fitzgerald, the great chronicler of the era, singled her out as perhaps the best example of the flapper type, the glamorous, dancing, laughing young woman with hurt eyes.
She had her own more cutting way of describing her screen image. If audiences wanted to see the girl next door, she once said they could go next door. When sound came to the movies at the end of the 1920s, it destroyed the careers of many silent stars. Voices that did not match their faces, accents that audiences could not follow, performers who simply could not adjust.
Joan Crawford was determined that it would not happen to her. She had a southwestern accent and she set out to erase it. By her own account, she would lock herself in her room and read newspapers, magazines, and books aloud, listening to every sound she made with a dictionary by her side. When she found a word she could not pronounce, she looked it up and repeated it correctly again and again until it was perfect.
She also studied singing with a respected voice teacher in New York, Estelle Leebing. It was the same girl who had scrubbed floors to earn her place at school, now scrubbing her own voice to earn her place in the talkies. And it worked. She made a successful transition to sound in 1929 with a picture called Untamed.
That same year, on the 3rd of June 1929, she married Douglas Fairbanks Jr., the handsome son of Douglas Fairbanks, the swashbuckling king of silent film, and the stepson of Mary Pigford, America’s sweetheart. It was a Hollywood royal wedding and the royal family was not pleased.
Fairbanks senior and Pikford reportedly disapproved of the marriage and did not invite the couple to their famous estate, Pigfair, for months afterward. The girl from the convent school had married into the most glamorous family in Hollywood, and the family made sure she knew she did not belong. The relationship with her in-laws did warm over time.
Fairbanks senior eventually took to calling her Billy, her childhood nickname. But the marriage itself did not last. In 1933, Joan divorced Douglas Fairbanks Jr., citing mental cruelty and describing his jealousy of her friends and their endless arguments late into the night. Years later, after Mommy Dearest came out, he would be one of those who defended her, saying the woman in the book was not the Joan Crawford he had known.
Through the early 1930s, her career soared. She was paired with Clark Gable, MGM’s rising male star, in one hit after another. Dance, Fools Dance, Laughing Sinners, Possessed. She was part of the dazzling all-star cast of Grand Hotel in 1932 alongside Greta Garbo, John and Lionol Barrymore, and Wallace Berry. And the film won the Academy Award for best picture.
A dress she wore that same year in a film called Lety Linton, designed by the great costume designer Adrien with enormous ruffled sleeves, became such a sensation that Macy’s department store copied it. When exhibitors published their first poll of the stars who made the most money at the box office in 1932, Joan Crawford was third in the nation.
She played working girls, shopg girls, stenographers, and dance hall hostesses, women who clawed their way up from nothing to love and money. Depression era audiences, especially women, adored her for it. She was playing her own life and they could feel it. In 1935, she married again, this time to Francho Tone, a cultured stage actor from New York.
They built a small theater at her home in Brentwood and staged classic plays for their friends. For a while, it seemed to be a marriage of genuine intellectual partnership, but it too went wrong. Her biographers record that during the marriage she suffered two miscarriages and they record something darker. That tone allegedly began drinking and became physically abusive.
She filed for divorce and it was granted in 1939. And yet in one of the stranger turns in her private life. The two later rebuilt their friendship. By the accounts of her biographers, Tone even proposed in 1964 that they marry again. They did not. But when he died in 1968, it was Joan Crawford who arranged for his cremation and for his ashes to be scattered in the Muskoka Lakes region of Canada.
The woman who could cut people out of her life with frightening finality could also sometimes hold on to them long after everyone else had let go. Think about what that means for the story we are about to tell. By the end of the 1930s, Joan Crawford had lost two pregnancies. She had been through two failed marriages, the second one reportedly violent.
She had no children, and there is every sign that she desperately wanted them. And at the same time, her career was sliding. Her films were still earning money, but less of it, and her salary was enormous. In 1937, Life magazine proclaimed her the queen of the movies. The very next year, the throne collapsed. In May of 1938, a group of independent theater owners took out an advertisement in the Hollywood Reporter listing stars whose high salaries they argued were not justified by their ticket sales.
The list included some of the greatest names in film history. Greta Garbo, Marlene Dietrich, Katherine Hepburn, May West, and Joan Crawford. They were branded in a phrase that would follow them all, box office poison. She fought back. In 1939, she stole scenes as the scheming shopgirl Crystal Allen in The Women opposite her old rival Normashira.
In 1941, she gave a powerful performance as a woman with a disfigured face in a woman’s face, but MGM was losing interest in her. After 18 years at the studio, she asked to be released from her contract. In June of 1943, MGM agreed and paid her to go. She was nearly 40, by the studio calendar, a little younger.

In the Hollywood of the 1940s, that was a dangerous age for an actress. Most people assumed her time was over. They were wrong. She signed with Warner Brothers and she waited for the right part. It came in the form of a novel by James M. Kaine about a hard-working mother who builds a restaurant empire to give her spoiled daughter everything only to be betrayed by her. The film was Mildred Pierce.
The director, Michael Curtis, reportedly wanted Barbara Stanwick for the role and did not think Joan Crawford was right. So, she did something that stars of her stature almost never did. She agreed to a screen test and she won the part. Mildred Pierce was released in 1945 and it was a triumph.
Joan Crawford won the Academy Award for best actress. According to the well-known story, she was at home in bed on the night of the ceremony, reportedly ill, and the Oscar was brought to her there, where she posed for photographers holding it. Whether she was truly sick or simply too nervous to face the crowd has been debated ever since, but the comeback was complete.
The box office poison of 1938 was the best actress of 1945, and there’s a painful irony in the film that made her comeback. Mildred Pierce is the story of a mother who gives her daughter everything and gets nothing but contempt in return. Joan Crawford won her Oscar for playing a devoted mother betrayed by an ungrateful child.
Decades later, her own daughter would tell the world a story about the Crawford home that turned that picture completely upside down. To understand what happened inside Joan Crawford’s home, we have to go back a few years to the moment she became a mother. because the way her children came to her is one of the least known and most revealing parts of her story.
By 1940, Joan Crawford was divorced, childless, and had lost two pregnancies. She wanted a family, but there was a problem. Under California law at the time, a single woman could not adopt a child within the state. So, Joan Crawford did what wealthy, determined people often did in those years. She went around the rules.
The baby girl who would become Christina was born in Los Angeles on the 11th of June 1939. Her birthother was a young unmarried woman of about 19. According to accounts of the adoption, the arrangement was made through a baby broker and the adoption itself was finalized in Las Vegas, Nevada, where the laws were looser.
At first, Joan named the little girl Joan. Then she changed her mind and renamed her Christina. It is worth pausing on that detail because it says something about the kind of household the child was entering. Christina arrived as a baby with one name, was given her new mother’s own name, and then had it changed again. From the very beginning, she was a child whose identity was being written by someone else.
Her mother knew exactly what that felt like. She had been Lucil and Billy and finally Joan. All names chosen for her by other people. The next part of the story is one that almost nobody knows and it may be one of the saddest chapters in Joan Crawford’s life. In 1942, Joan married her third husband, an actor named Philip Terry. They married on the 21st of July 1942, just after midnight, only about 6 weeks after their first date.
But even before that marriage, Joan had set out to give Christina a brother. A baby boy born in June of 1941 came to her through another private arrangement. She named him Christopher. Then everything went wrong. According to the accounts that have emerged, the baby’s birth mother was a married woman who had become pregnant during an affair.
When she discovered that her son had been placed with one of the most famous women in America, she saw an opportunity. She reportedly tried to extract money from Joan Crawford. And rather than be blackmailed, Joan gave the baby back. What happened to that little boy afterward is heartbreaking. According to the account that later came out, the man his birthother was married to treated the child cruy and eventually the boy was placed for adoption again and raised [clears throat] by another family who by his own account loved him. Decades
later, as an adult, he wrote a memoir about his life called The Other Side of My Life. Years after Joan’s death, he spoke with her twin daughters, and they told him how deeply Joan had grieved over losing him. According to the family’s account, the subject was so painful to her that none of her other children dared to bring it up.
Think about that. The woman, who would later be portrayed to the world as a cold, cruel mother, had once lost a baby son she had already named and taken home. And the loss hurt her so much that it became a forbidden subject in her house. She did not give up. In 1943, Joan and Philip Terry adopted another baby boy.
At first, he was named Philip Terry Jr. According to the accounts, the same birthother from the earlier adoption later tried to claim that this child was hers as well, and the matter ended with her in a psychiatric hospital. When Joan’s marriage to Philip Terry ended in 1946, she changed the boy’s name.
From then on, he was Christopher Crawford. So once again, a child in Joan Crawford’s household had his name taken away and replaced. And it is worth noting how little Philip Terry features in this story. By most accounts, he was the least significant of her husbands. And once the marriage ended, he largely disappeared from the lives of the children.
Then came the twins. On the 13th of January 1947, in a hospital in Dyresburg, Tennessee, a 21-year-old woman named Theta Cotton, gave birth to twin girls. They were premature and needed hospital care for several weeks. Their father, a young man named JW Jordan, was not with her. According to what the twins later learned, he had panicked when he found out she was pregnant.
Theta knew she could not care for the babies. She placed them with an adoption agency and 7 days after they were born, she died of kidney failure. The agency was the Tennessee Children’s Home Society in Memphis. And here we have to stop because that name carries a very dark history. The Memphis branch of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society was run by a woman named Georgia Tan.
For decades, she operated what investigators later described as a baby selling operation. Children were placed with wealthy families across the country, many of them in Hollywood and New York for large fees. Some birth parents were deceived. Records were falsified. In some cases, poor families were pressured or tricked into giving up children they never intended to lose.
In September of 1950, the state of Tennessee announced an investigation into the operation. Georgia Tan died of cancer within days of that announcement before she could be held to account. Her crimes became one of the great adoption scandals in American history. So, it is a documented fact that Kathy and Cindy Crawford were adopted through the agency Georgia Tan ran.
But here, the record is just as clear on another point, and it matters. There is no evidence that the twins themselves were taken improperly. Their mother placed them with the agency herself, knowing she could not care for them, and she died a week later. Their father, by his own later account, did not know where they had gone.
Joan Crawford adopted them in the summer of 1947, a year after she had won her Academy Award, and she brought them home to Brentwood. She named them Catherine and Cynthia, called Kathy and Cindy. There is one more small detail from those years that says something about Joan Crawford’s fears. According to Cindy speaking to a Memphis newspaper in 1995, her mother was so afraid that the birth family might try to reclaim the girls that she often told people they were not really twins.
Remember what had happened with her first son? She had already lost one child to a birth mother. She was determined it would never happen again. That small lie would come back to haunt the family half a century later in a courtroom. So by 1947, Joan Crawford had four children in her home. Christina about 8, Christopher about four, and the infant twins.
The family lived in a large, beautiful house in Brentwood. There were servants, a pool, beautiful clothes, famous visitors, and a mother who was one of the most celebrated actresses in the world. And here’s where the two versions of the story begin to split apart. Everyone who knew the household agrees on some things. Joan Crawford ran her home with iron discipline.
There were rules for everything. The children made their own beds. They helped with chores. They were expected to be polite, to stand when adults entered the room, to answer their mother’s fans, to keep their rooms and their belongings in perfect order. Punishments for breaking the rules were real.
There was a routine for every hour of the day, and the home was, in many ways, a showplace. magazines photographed Joan Crawford with her children. The family was part of her public image, the glamorous star who was also a devoted mother. Even the people who defended Joan Crawford later acknowledged that she was strict. The actress Helen Hayes and the director Vincent Sherman both wrote in their memoirs that they thought she was too strict to parent.
The actress June Allison recalled in her autobiography seeing Joan put Christina in a kind of timeout and forbid her from attending a friend’s birthday party as a punishment. The actor James the MacArthur who spent a weekend with the family as a child remembered seeing little Christopher strapped into his bed at night with a harness.
That harness became one of the most disturbing images associated with the family. But there is another side to it. Years later, Christopher’s own daughter said that her father had a condition we would today recognize as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and that the family doctor had recommended the harness, a product sold in stores at the time to keep the restless boy from wandering out of bed at night and possibly falling into the swimming pool.
Whether that explanation fully accounts for what the children experienced is something we cannot know, but it is a good example of how the same fact can look completely different depending on who is telling the story. None of the witnesses who described Joan strictness said they ever saw anything they would call outright abuse.
But those were visitors, friends, colleagues. They saw the household for an afternoon or a weekend. The children lived in it every day. And two of those children would eventually tell the world that what happened behind closed doors was far worse than anything the visitors ever saw. We are halfway through the story now and this is where it becomes genuinely hard.
Before we go on, I want to hear from you. Do you think it is possible for two children to grow up in the same house with the same mother and have completely different childhoods? Have you seen that happen in your own family or in a family you know? Tell me in the comments because that question is going to sit at the heart of everything that comes next.
And if you are finding this story worthwhile so far, please hit the like button and subscribe because the second half is where the book, the movie, and the courtroom all come in. Let us start with what Christina Crawford said happened because her account is the reason we are here. In Mommy Dearest, Christina describes a childhood in which love and fear were tangled together so tightly she could never tell which one was coming next.
She describes a mother who could be charming and affectionate in front of guests and photographers and then when the door closed turned cold, furious, and frightening. She describes being punished severely for small things, sometimes for things she did not understand. She describes what she called night raids, episodes in which her mother would descend on the children’s rooms late at night in a rage over some imperfection, a closet out of order, a floor not clean enough.
She describes being made to scrub and clean as punishment. She describes her mother destroying things in fits of anger. And she describes a household where the children’s lives were arranged around their mother’s image, where they were brought out to be photographed, presented at parties, and expected to perform the role of a perfect family, whatever was happening in private.
The most famous scene, of course, involves wire hangers. In Christina’s telling, her mother discovered wire hangers in her closet among the nicer hangers Joan insisted on, and flew into a violent rage. It is worth noting that one entertainment history account has suggested a possible reason for Joan’s hatred of wire hangers.
That as a girl, she had seen her mother working in a laundry and cheap wire hangers reminded her of the poverty she had spent her whole life trying to escape. Whether that explanation is true, we cannot say for certain, but once again, a detail from the poor girl’s past seems to cast a long shadow over the rich woman’s home.
Christina also describes her adolescence and early adulthood as a continuing battle with her mother, a struggle for control that followed her into boarding school, into her first attempts at an acting career, and into her own adult life. Christina was not the only child to describe a painful childhood. Her brother Christopher did, too, though in fewer words and with less public attention.
In an interview with the Los Angeles Times in 1978, around the time the book came out, Christopher described his relationship with Joan in bleak terms. He said that he honestly did not believe she had ever cared for him. He told of a childhood of running away from home, being expelled from schools, and eventually being sent to a military academy.
In another account, he described being punished in a way that burned his hand. and he told a story about his daughter that is painful to hear. In 1961, he said he brought his 6-week old baby girl to meet Joan at a hotel in Miami. According to his account, Joan held the baby for only a few seconds, told him she was nobody’s grandmother, and that the child should call her Aunt Joan, and then handed the baby back with a cutting remark.
Years later, when another of his daughters was born seriously ill and needed blood, he said he called Joan for help and she reminded him that he was adopted and that the baby was not her grandchild. He said he slammed down the phone so hard he broke it. After that, he said it was over between them. We have only Christopher’s side of those conversations, but they are specific and they are consistent with the picture Christina paints of a mother who could be cold and wounding, especially toward the two children with whom her
relationship had broken down. So those are the accusations. Now let us look at what was happening in Joan Crawford’s own life while her children were growing up because it matters to the story. After Mildred Pierce, her career rolled on through the late 1940s and into the 1950s.
She earned another Academy Award nomination for Possessed in 1947 and a third for the thriller Sudden Fear in 1952. She starred in the strange, fierce western Johnny Guitar in 1954, which has since become a cult classic. She was still a star, but she was also getting older in an industry that was brutal to aging actresses, and she knew it.
The children were growing up in these years, and their paths were already diverging. Christina was sent to boarding schools and after graduating from a Catholic girls academy went east to study drama. First briefly at the Carnegie Institute of Technology in Pittsburgh and then at the neighborhood playhouse in New York. She wanted to be an actress like her mother.
Christopher, meanwhile, was repeatedly in trouble. He ran away from home more than once, was expelled from several schools, and spent his high school years at a military academy. He married at 18, and had his first child a year later. The twins were still little girls, and they were growing up in what, by their own later accounts, was a very different emotional climate from the one their older brother and sister remembered.
In 1955, she married for the fourth and final time. Her husband was Alfred Steele, the president of the Pepsi Cola Company, a powerful, energetic businessman. They married on the 10th of May, 1955 at the Flamingo Hotel in Las Vegas. By most accounts, this was the happiest of her marriages. Steel was her equal in drive and ambition, and he took on a father figure role for her children, especially the twins, who were still young.
With Steel, Joan Crawford became something new, the glamorous face of a global corporation. She traveled the world on Pepsi’s behalf, appearing at bottling plants and promotional events, bringing Hollywood glamour to a soft drink company. The twins were sent to boarding school, visiting home on weekends and holidays. Then in April of 1959, Alfred Steele died suddenly of a heart attack.
He was only in his 50s. Joan was devastated. And then came a second shock. The couple had spent lavishly, including on a luxurious apartment in New York, and by the accounts of her biographers, Steele’s death left Joan in serious financial trouble. An Associated Press story in June of 1959 carried a headline in which she said in effect that she was broke.
Here again, she did what she had always done. She went back to work. The board of Pepsi Cola elected her to fill her late husband’s seat, making her the first woman on the company’s board of directors. She became the company’s goodwill ambassador, and by her own estimate, in the mid 1960s, she was traveling more than a 100,000 m a year for Pepsi.
She took the job seriously, too. In 1963, Pepsi gave her its annual Pali Award, a bronze statueette shaped like a Pepsi bottle, presented to the person judged to have contributed most to the company’s sales that year. The girl who had never finished school was now being honored as a corporate saleswoman, and she took a small supporting role in a film called The Best of Everything, released in 1959, simply because she needed the work.
Then at the start of the 1960s came one more remarkable chapter. The director Robert Aldrich sent her a script for a psychological thriller about two aging sisters. Both former stars living together in a crumbling Hollywood mansion. One sister is disabled and trapped in her room. The other is mentally unstable, bitter, and cruel.
The film was Whatever Happened to Baby Jane. Joan Crawford would play the disabled sister, Blanch. and for the role of the cruel sister, Jane. The film cast the one actress in Hollywood whose name was most often linked with Jones as a rival, B. Davis. Their rivalry was already legendary. The two women had been competing in one way or another since the 1930s, and there was a long history of perceived slights between them.
Remarkably, according to the accounts of the production, it was Joan herself who suggested B. Davis for the role. In public, both women insisted there was no feud. In private, by most accounts, the tension on the set was intense. Stories have circulated for decades about their behavior toward each other during filming. Some of them almost certainly exaggerated, and neither woman ever fully confirmed the most lurid versions.
Whatever Happened to Baby Jane was released in 1962, and it was a huge hit. It reportedly earned back its costs within about 11 days of its nationwide release. It revived both women’s careers. And then came the Academy Awards. B. Davis was nominated for best actress for her performance as Jane. Joan Crawford was not nominated.
What happened next has become one of the most famous stories in Oscar history. According to the widely told account, Joan contacted the other nominated actresses and offered to accept the award on their behalf if they could not attend. When the winner was announced in April of 1963, it was Anne Braftoft for The Miracle Worker and Braftoft was not there.
So, Joan Crawford walked onto the stage and accepted the Oscar in her place, while B. Davis, who many believed had wanted that award badly, watched from the wings. Whether Joan’s intention was generosity or revenge has been argued ever since. Most people who tell the story assume it was both. The two women were cast together again in a follow-up. Hush, hush, sweet Charlotte.
But after what was described as a campaign of harassment from Davis on location in Louisiana, Joan returned to Hollywood and checked into a hospital. After her prolonged absence, Aldrich replaced her with Olivia De Havland. Joan later described hearing the news on the radio from her hospital bed and crying for hours.
Whatever you believe about Joan Crawford, it is worth noticing how often in her life she was replaced, discarded, or pushed aside by a father, by a stepfather, by a studio, by a husband, by a rival, and how fiercely she fought every time. It is also worth noticing that the people she could not control, she sometimes cut out of her life entirely.
In October of 1968, something happened that would become one of the most disputed episodes between Joan and Christina. Christina, by then in her late 20s, was working as an actress in New York playing a role on a CBS soap opera called The Secret Storm. She suddenly needed emergency surgery for a serious gynecological condition.
While Christina was in the hospital, Joan Crawford, in her 60s, stepped into her daughter’s role on the show for a short run, playing a character who was supposed to be in her late 20s. In Mommy Dearest, Christina presents this as her mother stealing her role, humiliating her and making even her illness about herself.
But the show’s producer, Gloria Monty, told a very different story. She said that the network had asked Joan to fill in and that Joan agreed only so that Christina would not be permanently replaced by another actress while she recovered. Monty said she had watched Joan do everything she could to save her daughter’s job and even her life.
Two people, the same event, two completely different stories. It is a pattern that repeats again and again in the history of this family and it is exactly why the truth is so hard to pin down. By the late 1960s, Joan Crawford’s career was winding down, and the roles were getting smaller and stranger.
In 1964, she played an axe murderer in a horror film called Straight Jacket. In 1965, she appeared in another thriller, I Saw what you did. In 1967, she played the owner of a circus in Berserk. These were the kinds of pictures that aging stars of her generation were often offered once the studios had moved on to younger faces.
Low-budget horror films that traded on their names. There were still flashes of the old magic. In February of 1968, she appeared as herself on an episode of The Lucy Show with Lucille Ball. By several accounts, she struggled during rehearsals, but on the day of the taping, she was letter perfect, danced the Charleston, and received two standing ovations from the studio audience.
In 1969, she starred in the pilot film for the television series Night Gallery, and her segment was directed by a young man making his professional debut. His name was Steven Spielberg. In February of 1970, she received the Cecil B. Deil award at the Golden Globes presented to her by John Wayne and in 1970 she made what would be her final feature film.
It was a science fiction horror movie called Trogue in which she played a scientist studying a caveman creature. It was not a distinguished end to a career that had included Grand Hotel and Mildred Pierce. After a few more television appearances, the last of them in 1972, Joan Crawford stopped acting. Her career had lasted around 45 years and produced more than 80 films.
She also wrote in 1962 she published an autobiography, a portrait of Joan and in 1971 a book of advice on style, grooming, and living called My Way of Life, which is full of her rules about order, cleanliness, entertaining, and self-discipline. Reading it now, knowing what her daughter would later write, is a strange experience.
It is the voice of a woman who believed completely that control and routine were the keys to a good life. There is one more subject that we have to address honestly because it runs through the darker accounts of these years. Alcohol in Mommy Dearest Christina describes her mother as an alcoholic especially in the later years.
It is fair to say that several people who knew Joan Crawford have acknowledged that she drank heavily in the later part of her life, and her biographers have written about it. Heavy drinking does not create cruelty out of nothing, and it does not excuse anything, but it is a part of the picture, and it may help explain why the worst of the accounts of her behavior come from the children who were with her during certain years and not others.
In April of 1973, Joan Crawford made one of her last great public appearances. She was the guest in a series called Legendary Ladies at the Town Hall in Manhattan, where audiences watched clips from a star’s career and then asked her questions in person. The 1500 seats were sold out.
When she left, about 200 fans surrounded her car and would not let it move for several minutes. Even then, she could still stop traffic. That same year, she retired from the Pepsi Cola board at what was officially recorded as the age of 65. It was one more piece of evidence that her real age was still a closely guarded secret because by the reckoning of most biographers, she was older than that.
And in September of 1973, she moved from her large apartment into a smaller one next door in the same building on East 69th Street. Her final public appearance came on the 23rd of September 1974 at a party she hosted for her old friend, the actress Rosalind Russell at the Rainbow Room in New York.
Photographers took pictures of her as she left, and by the accounts of her biographers, she was so unhappy with how she looked in those photographs that she withdrew almost completely from public life. Think about that for a moment. The woman who had spent 50 years fighting to control her image, who had built her face and her voice and her name from nothing, saw a photograph she could not control and simply disappeared.
For the last years of her life, she saw only a small circle of people. She answered letters. She talked on the phone. But the world did not see Joan Crawford anymore. In the last months of her life, she was clearly unwell. On the 6th of May 1977, she gave away her dog because she could no longer care for her.
And 4 days later, on the 10th of May 1977, Joan Crawford died of a heart attack in her apartment. Her age was reported as 69. If the most likely birth year is correct, she was 73. Her funeral was held in New York a few days later, and her ashes were placed in a crypt at Ferncliff Cemetery in Hartsdale, New York, beside her husband, Alfred Steel.
A memorial service at All Souls Unitarian Church in New York brought out old friends including MNA Ly and the actor Cliff Robertson who spoke about her and the singer Pearl Bailey who sang. Another memorial organized by the director George Cukor was held at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in Beverly Hills and then the will was read.
Her estate was valued at about $2 million. She left $77,500 to each of the twins, Kathy and Cindy. She left $35,000 to her secretary and friend of nearly 50 years, Betty Barker. She left money to her charities, and she left nothing to Christina or Christopher for reasons she said were well known to them.
Both of them challenged the will, and they eventually received a settlement of $55,000. There was something else that came to light after her death, and it is almost never mentioned in the Mommy Dearest version of her story. For years, Joan Crawford had quietly paid for hospital rooms and medical specialists for people who could not afford care, many of them men and women from the film industry who had fallen on hard times.
She never publicized it. By the accounts of her biographers, she did not want the public or the patients to know it was her. Throughout her life, she had also given enormous sums to charity. In 1942, after her friend Carol Lombard was killed in a plane crash, Joan donated her entire salary from a film called They All Kissed the Bride, more than $100,000 to charities in Lombard’s memory.
Her charity work went far beyond that one gesture. During the Second World War, she volunteered at the Hollywood Canteen in Los Angeles, serving and entertaining servicemen, and she helped raise money through war bond drives. She volunteered with the American Women’s Voluntary Services, supporting nurseries for the children of servicemen.
In 1965, the USO named her its woman of the year for her years of support for American troops. And in the 1960s, she visited military hospitals to cheer up soldiers wounded in Vietnam. From 1966 to 1973, she appeared on the annual muscular distrophe tellathon, urging viewers to pledge money. In 1971, she accepted an honorary chairmanship to help raise funds for the Negro Ensemble Company, the celebrated black theater company in New York.
In 1972, she served as national chairwoman for the American Cancer Society. None of this proves anything about what happened inside her home. Plenty of people who are generous in public are cruel in private, and the reverse is true, too. But it is part of the record, and it belongs in any honest account of who she was.
That is the paradox of Joan Crawford. A woman who could be generous in secret to strangers and yet by the testimony of two of her own children, cold and punishing at home. A woman who never wanted anyone to see her give and who could not bear anyone to see her fall. The disinheritance in the court of public opinion became a kind of verdict.
If she had nothing to hide, people asked why would she cut two of her children out of her will. But it is worth looking at that question carefully. She did not disinherit all of her children. She provided for the two daughters who defended her. The break was with the two children whose relationships with her had collapsed.
That tells us beyond any doubt that those relationships were deeply broken. It does not by itself tell us whose fault that was or whether every detail of what Christina would later write was true. There is one more fact about the timing that matters. According to the biographer Fred Lawrence Guiles, Christina had already begun writing her book before her mother died.
Guiles suggested that Joan may have known what was coming and that this knowledge may have been one of the reasons she left Christina out of her will. If that is right, then the famous sentence in the will may not have been the cause of the book. It may have been a response to it. In October of 1978, thousands of copies of Mommy Dearest began appearing in bookstores ahead of its official release date in November.
The publisher, William Morrow, had printed and shipped them in enormous numbers, and the demand was immediate. The book became a sensation. It went to the top of the bestseller lists. It was discussed on television, in newspapers, in magazines, at dinner tables across the country. It is hard to overstate how shocking it was at the time.
In 1978, the idea that a beloved movie star might have abused her children behind closed doors was not something the public had been asked to consider before. Hollywood had spent decades selling the image of stars as ideal parents, and Joan Crawford, with her magazine spreads and posed family portraits, had been one of the most enthusiastic sellers of that image.
Now, her own daughter was saying it had all been a lie. The book is often credited with opening the door to a whole new genre, the celebrity tell all written by the children of the famous. Within weeks, it had become part of the culture. In December of 1978, only a couple of months after the book appeared, Saturday Night Live aired a sketch parodying it with Jane Curtain as Joan Crawford and Gilda Rner as an exaggerated version of the young Christina.
Before the movie was even made, Mommy Dearest was already a punchline. But the reaction to the book was not one-sided. From the very beginning, a long list of people who had known Joan Crawford lined up to dispute it. Her first husband, Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. said that the Joan Crawford described in Mommy Dearest was not the woman he had known.
Friends and colleagues including Van Johnson, Katherine Hepburn, Caesar Romero, Bob Hope, Barbara Stanwick, and Anne Bliss were among those reported to have disputed the portrait. Betty Barker, her secretary for nearly 50 years, said that while Joan was strict, Christina and Christopher had never been abused. The actress Mna Loy, a longtime friend, was especially blunt.
In her 1987 autobiography, she suggested that Christina had wanted to be Joan Crawford, that this was the root of the book, and that she had seen for herself the fantasy world Christina’s mind had created. Christina’s own former husband, the producer Harvey Mlinsky, said publicly that he had only good things to say about Joan Crawford, and that she had always been kind to him and to Christina while they were married.
And perhaps the most surprising defender of all was B. Davis, the woman who had been Joan’s great rival, who had battled her on the set of Baby Jane, said that while she had never been Joan’s biggest fan, she respected her talent and that Joan did not deserve what she called that detestable book.
It is worth adding in fairness that Davis also made some famously cruel remarks about Joan after her death. But on the question of the book, she came down on Joan’s side. And in one of the strange echoes of this story, B. Davis’s own daughter would later publish a memoir in 1985 portraying Davis herself as a difficult, hard-drinking mother.
The gossip columnist Liz Smith, who had followed Joan’s career for years, offered what might be the most balanced verdict of all. She wrote that she was inclined to believe Joan had been misguided in her attempts to mold her children and vain and self-absorbed like most great stars, but that the stories of beatings and near madness were, in her view, over the top. Christina had her supporters, too.
Her brother Christopher, as we have heard, backed her account and said he did not believe Joan had ever cared for him. And the witnesses who defended Joan were almost by definition people who saw her from the outside. visitors, friends, colleagues, employees. Abuse when it happens usually happens where visitors cannot see it.
That is precisely why the question has never been settled. But there were two people who were not visitors. Two people who grew up inside that house with that mother everyday for years, and they were furious. Kathy and Cindy Crawford spoke out against the book almost immediately, and they never stopped.
In 1979, Cindy told a reporter that she could not understand how people believed what she called the stupid stuff Christina had written. In October of 1981, People magazine ran a story about the war within the family. Kathy told the magazine that Christina said Joan was rotten and that she, Kathy, said Joan was a good person.
She acknowledged that their mother had been tough and that a child might get a SWAT now and then, but the beatings the book described, she said, did not happen. On the 28th of May, 1981, Kathy appeared on the national morning program Good Morning America to defend her mother on live television.
She described Joan as a very warm person who was always there when her children needed her, a working mother who still made time for them. and she delivered a line that would be quoted for decades. She called mommy dearest a great work of fiction and said Christina must have been living in another household. Years later, when the biographer Charlotte Chandler interviewed her for a book about Joan Crawford published in 2008, Kathy was just as firm.
She told Chandler she did not know where Christina got her ideas and that in her view, their mother was the best mother anyone ever had. Through Chandler’s work, Cathy shared memories of a childhood full of warmth, holidays, family trips, bedtime stories, a mother who was strict but loving and present. She described Joan as wise, caring, realistic, and a good friend.
So, which daughter was telling the truth? That is the question that has haunted this story for almost 50 years. And before we go on, it is worth thinking about it seriously rather than simply picking a side. One possibility is that Christina invented or wildly exaggerated her story out of bitterness at being disinherited or out of a lifelong rivalry with her famous mother or for money.
That is what many of Joan’s defenders believed. Maoy clearly thought so. And the timing of the book published after Joan could no longer answer struck many people as suspicious. Another possibility is that Christina told the truth and that Joan simply behaved differently with different children. There’s a real basis for this.
Christina was the first child adopted in 1940 when Joan was single, recently divorced, and fighting for her career at MGM. She grew up during the most turbulent years of her mother’s life. The collapse at MGM, the box office poison label, The Lost Baby Son, a third failed marriage. The twins arrived years later after the Oscar when Joan’s career had recovered and they spent much of their childhood in the years of her happiest marriage to Alfred Steel.
It is entirely possible that they genuinely knew a calmer, gentler mother than Christina and Christopher did. There is also the matter of personality. Christina, by most accounts, was strong willed and rebellious. In many ways, a lot like her mother. Christopher was restless, ran away repeatedly, and was expelled from schools.
The twins, by most accounts, were more compliant. A rigid, controlling parent who cannot tolerate defiance may treat an obedient child very differently from a defiant one. Two children can grow up in the same house and truly live in different households. And there is a third possibility, perhaps the most likely of all, that both daughters were telling the truth as they experienced it.
that Joan Crawford was capable of both warmth and cruelty. That the loving mother of Cathy’s memories and the frightening mother of Christina’s memories were the same woman on different days in different years. Whatever the truth, the book had done its work. Joan Crawford’s reputation would never be the same.
And then Hollywood made it worse. Paramount Pictures bought the film rights to Mommy Dearest. And in 1981, the movie arrived. It starred FA Dunaway as Joan Crawford and it was directed by Frank Perry. On paper, it was a prestigious project. Dunaway was one of the most acclaimed actresses in Hollywood, an Oscar winner herself for the 1976 film network.
By several accounts, she took the role seriously and threw herself into it completely, transforming her face, her voice, and her body to become Joan Crawford. According to the film historian A. Ashley Hoff, who wrote a book about the making of the movie, Dunaway had hoped to bring balance to the story to show something of what Joan Crawford was going through as an aging actress rather than simply presenting her as a monster.
That is not how it turned out. The film compressed and dramatized events from the book, combining separate incidents into single scenes and heightening the violence. The most famous example is the wire hanger scene. In the movie, Dunaway’s Joan, her face covered in white cold cream, discovers wire hangers in her daughter’s closet at night and explodes into a screaming physical rage.
According to Hoth’s research, Dunaway was deeply uncomfortable with the violence of that scene and did not want to be seen striking the young actress playing Christina Marael, so stand-ins were used for the actual blows. The movie also includes a scene in which Joan, having been dropped by MGM, storms into her garden at night and hacks down a tree in a fury.
In the book, the destruction of the garden was presented as one of Joan’s erratic nighttime episodes. The film turned it into a direct, almost theatrical reaction to losing her studio contract. When Mommy Dearest opened in 1981, audiences did something no one had planned for. They laughed. The film’s oporatic intensity, Dunaway’s enormous performance, and the melodramatic style struck many viewers as so extreme that it tipped over into camp.
Critics largely savaged it. Audiences began quoting its lines, especially the scream about wire hangers with delight rather than horror. And over the following decades, the movie became a cult classic, a staple of midnight screenings, drag performances, and parodies. The line about wire hangers became one of the most quoted in movie history.
It turned up in comedy sketches, in music videos, and in countless jokes. The rock band Blue Oyster Cult even released a song called Joan Crawford in 1981. Commercially, the film did well, but for nearly everyone involved, it was a disaster of another kind. For FA Dunaway, it became something she was widely reported to regret, a performance that overshadowed much of the serious work of her career and that she has long been reluctant to discuss.
For Joan Crawford’s Defenders, the film was a second assassination. If the book had damaged her reputation, the movie buried it under a cartoon. For millions of people who never read the book, never saw Mildred Pierce, and never knew anything else about her, Joan Crawford simply became the woman screaming about wire hangers. For the twins, the film was painful on every level. They disliked it deeply.
And there was an added insult. Kathy and Cindy were written out of the movie entirely. The story of the Crawford household was told as though the two daughters who had loved their mother did not exist. And perhaps most surprisingly of all, Christina Crawford herself came to reject the film.
She has said repeatedly over the years that the movie did not accurately depict her life. She has said that key scenes, including the tree chopping scene and the wire hanger scene were taken out of context and exaggerated, and she has criticized the way the movie turned her mother into a caricature. By some accounts, she felt that even Joan had not deserved to be portrayed that way.
For a woman who had wanted the world to take her suffering seriously, watching audiences roar with laughter at a dramatization of her childhood must have been a bitter experience. So, here is something that almost nobody who quotes the wire hanger scene knows. The author of Mommy Dearest does not stand behind the most famous version of Mommy Dearest.
The image of Joan Crawford that lives in popular culture today is not quite Christina’s version either. It is Hollywood’s version filtered through a camp sensibility that nobody intended. Repeated so many times that it has replaced the real woman almost entirely. And for the next two decades, the feud between Joan Crawford’s children would continue in public.
In 1997, nearly 20 years after the original book, Christina released a 20th anniversary edition of Mommy Dearest through a smaller publisher. Having bought back the rights, it added around a 100 pages of new material, dropped some of the original named people who had not been named in the first edition, and expanded on her adult relationship with her mother and on what had happened to her brother.
She promoted it energetically, including appearances at screenings of the film. And it was during that promotion that the war between the sisters went to court. According to a lawsuit Kathy filed on the 20th of July 1998, Christina had claimed in interviews during the anniversary tour that Kathy and Cindy were not biological sisters and that their adoption had never been legal.
Remember that small lie Joan had told years earlier out of fear that the birth family might try to reclaim the girls when she told people the twins were not really twins. Half a century later, that lie seems to have fed a story that wounded the twins deeply. Kathy sued Christina for defamation.
She attached copies of the twins birth certificates and their adoption documents to the lawsuit to prove that both claims were false. The case was settled in 1999 with Christina paying Cathy $5,000 plus court costs. The twins lawyer said afterward that they had proved their point. $5,000 is not a large sum, but the money was never the point.
For Kathy, it was about the record. It was about being able to say with legal documents in hand that her sister had said something untrue about her and that the truth about her own birth and her own family mattered. And by then, Kathy and Cindy knew much more about the truth of their own beginnings than they ever had as children. because a few years earlier they had gone looking for it.
Kathy and Cindy had always known they were adopted. Joan had never hidden that from them. By Cindy’s account, their mother had even once talked about taking them back to Memphis to visit the little red brick building of the agency where their story began. She never made that trip. And for most of their lives, the twins knew almost nothing about the people who had brought them into the world.
Their adult lives had taken them far from Hollywood. In August of 1968, Kathy married a Navy petty officer named Jerome Loland in Alexandria Bay, New York. The head of Pepsi Cola, Herbert Barnett, gave her away, and Cathy designed and sewed her own wedding dress. She settled in Pennsylvania, raised two children, and later worked as a teacher’s aid.
Cindy’s road was harder. She married in 1967 and moved with her husband into a trailer in Deuke, Iowa. Remarkably, the man she married was named Jordan, the same surname as the biological father she did not yet know existed. The marriage lasted about 9 years and produced two sons before it ended. Afterward, according to her own account to a Memphis newspaper, she earned about $150 a week working in a shoe store and lived partly on the money her mother had left her.
In 1984, a job offer drew her to Jackson, Mississippi. But the work dried up after 6 months, and she found herself on welfare and without a place to live. The Salvation Army and her friends helped her through. She worked and saved until she could afford an apartment again. She later said she had simply survived.
The daughter of one of the richest and most glamorous women in Hollywood, a child who had grown up in a Brentwood mansion, had known what it was to have nothing. In a strange way, her life had echoed her adoptive mother’s beginning. In June of 1990, Kathy saw a television program about the Tennessee Children’s Home Society and the scandal of Georgia Tan. Something clicked.
With the help of an advocate named Denny Glad, who led a search group helping people adopted through the agency trace their birth families, the twins began looking. The search took about 18 months and ended with a court order to open Cathy’s adoption records. What they found was both heartbreaking and wonderful. They learned that their birth mother, Theta, had died just a week after they were born.
and they learned that their birth father, JW Jordan, was alive, living in an old white farmhouse near a little town called Friendship in West Tennessee. Kathy was so nervous that it took her about 3 weeks to work up the courage to call him. She was afraid of being rejected. When she finally did, she said he was dumbfounded. Then Cindy called him, too.
By her account, she asked him whether he was sitting down and then told him she was his other daughter. A friend drove Cindy to friendship for their first meeting. She found him by a small pond where he had been fishing. By her account, neither of them knew what to do. And then her father simply asked her to give him some sugar, the old southern way of asking for a kiss, and she kissed him.
He told them he had panicked when he learned that their mother was pregnant. After they were born, he had asked about them, but by then they were gone. He had later married and divorced, and he never had any other children. For more than 40 years, he had known he had two daughters somewhere in the world, and he had no idea who they were or where they had gone.
In 1991, Cindy moved to Memphis to be close to him and to the rest of her newly found family. She visited him often at the old farmhouse, borrowing his car on weekends, going out to dinner with him, meeting his old friends. her mother’s side of the family who asked not to be named publicly welcomed her too and helped her build a new life in Memphis.
An aunt gave her a job in the family business, but the time they had together was short. In 1992, JW Jordan learned he had stomach cancer. He died the following year. The daughters who had spent their whole lives wondering about him had found him and then almost immediately lost him. In a 1995 interview, Cindy described her life as having gone from riches to rags to riches and then explained that the riches she meant were not money.
They were the people around her, the family she loved. On the walls of her small Memphis apartment, she kept pictures of both of her families, photographs of Joan Crawford alongside photographs of her Tennessee relatives. She did not see any contradiction in loving them all. And in the same interview, both twins spoke again about their adoptive mother.
Joan was their mother, Kathy said. Cindy said Joan had been very good to them and that she believed Joan had been good to all four of her children in her way. Cindy Crawford Jordan died on the 14th of October 2007. She was 60 years old. Christopher Crawford, the son who had told the world that his mother never cared for him, had died the year before in 2006.
He never reconciled with the woman who raised him. By the accounts of the family, he had long been estranged from his sisters as well. Kathy Crawford Loland lived on. She kept defending her mother for the rest of her life. In January of 2020, after a long battle with lung cancer, she died at her home in Pennsylvania at the age of 72.
Her obituary described her as the daughter of Academy Award-winning actress Joan Crawford and Pepsi Cola chief executive Alfred Steel and said that she had been grateful all her life for the opportunities, the travel, the education, and what it called a nurturing upbringing. With her death, the last of Joan Crawford’s children who had publicly defended her was gone.
And Christina, she has never backed down from her account. In a rare interview with the Observer newspaper in 2008, she made it clear she would never forgive her mother. In the years since, she has written other books, spoken about child abuse, performed a onewoman show about her experiences, and worked on a stage musical based on her memoir.
Whatever else anyone says about her, she has told the same story consistently for nearly half a century. Meanwhile, the film legacy that the wire hanger jokes had buried slowly began to resurface. Her handprints and footprints had been pressed into the forcourt of Groman’s Chinese Theater in Hollywood all the way back in September of 1929, and she has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
In 1999, the American Film Institute named her the 10th greatest female screen legend of classic American cinema. New Generations discovered Mildred Pierce, Johnny Guitar, and What Ever Happened to Baby Jane, and found an actress of real power, not a punchline. In 2017, a television drama series about her rivalry with B.
Davis brought her story to millions of new viewers. And while it took its own dramatic liberties, it presented her as a frightened, complicated human woman rather than a cartoon villain. So, where does all of this leave us? Let us start with what we can say for certain. Joan Crawford was a woman who came from abandonment and poverty, who scrubbed floors as a child to earn a place at school, and who spent her entire life terrified of losing the security she had fought so hard to win.
She was controlling, perfectionist, and obsessed with order and image. And even her strongest defenders agreed she was a strict and demanding parent. Her relationships with her two eldest children collapsed completely. Her relationships with her two youngest daughters endured with love until the end of her life and beyond.
She could be secretly remarkably generous to strangers, and she drank heavily in her later years. Now, let us say what we cannot know. We cannot know exactly what happened inside that house in the 1940s and 1950s. We have one daughter’s detailed account supported in general terms by her brother.
We have two other daughters who said it was untrue and who grew up in the same house in later years. We have a crowd of friends, colleagues, and employees who saw strictness but not abuse and who, by the nature of things could only see what happened when they were present. We have a producer who said one of the book’s key episodes was false.
We have a movie that the author herself says distorted the story. And we have a woman who died before any of it was published, who never had the chance to answer. Here is what seems most likely, and it is not the answer people usually want. Joan Crawford was not the camp monster of the movie, but she was also probably not the flawless mother her youngest daughters remembered.
She was a deeply wounded woman who loved her children, needed to control them, and treated them differently depending on the year, the child, her circumstances, and quite possibly how much she had been drinking. For two of her children, that meant a childhood they described with warmth and gratitude.
For the other two, it meant a childhood they described as a nightmare. Both of those things can be true of the same woman. There is a final irony in all of this. Joan Crawford spent her entire life controlling her own story. She changed her name, her age, her accent, her face, and her past. She built an image so polished that it lasted for 50 years.
And after her death, she lost control of her story completely. First to her daughter, then to Hollywood, then to a culture that turned her into a joke. The woman who had fought so hard never to be laughed at is now for millions of people simply a punchline about wire hangers. The real Joan Crawford is somewhere behind that punchline.
She is the little girl in Oklahoma watching Vaudeville from the wings of her stepfather’s theater. She is the work student scrubbing floors in Kansas City. She is the chorus girl who borrowed $400 to chase a dream to Hollywood. She is the Oscar winner, the Pepsi executive, the rival of B. Davis. She is the mother who grieved a baby son so deeply his name could not be spoken in her house.
She is the mother Kathy remembered as warm and wise. And the mother Christina remembered as terrifying. And she is the old woman alone in a New York apartment giving away her little dog because she could no longer care for it 4 days before the end. She was all of them. And no single story, not the book, not the movie, not the defense has ever been big enough to hold her.
If this story changed the way you think about Joan Crawford or complicated something you thought you knew, please subscribe to the channel and turn on notifications because there are many more stories like this one on the way. And now I want to hear from you in the comments. After everything we have walked through, where do you land? Do you believe Christina? Do you believe the twins? Or do you think both of them were telling the truth as they lived it? There are no wrong answers here, only honest ones, and I read every comment. Share this
video with someone who loves old Hollywood, and I will see you in the next one.
The Secret Life of Joan Crawford: Hollywood’s Darkest Scandal – YouTube
Transcripts:
Joan Crawford. The dark truth behind Mommy Dearest. On the 10th of May 1977, in an apartment high above East 69th Street in Manhattan, one of the most famous women of the 20th century died of a heart attack. There were no cameras. There were no crowds. For nearly 3 years, she had barely left that apartment.
4 days before she died, she had given away her beloved little shiu, a dog named Princess Lotus Blossom because she no longer had the strength to look after her. Her name was Joan Crawford. She had made more than 80 films. She had won an Academy Award. At the height of her fame, she had been one of the highest paid women in the United States, a star so powerful that her name alone could sell a picture anywhere in the world.
and she died a recluse in a small apartment surrounded by the relics of a life that had once been lived at full volume. 7 months earlier, she had signed her will. Most of it was ordinary. There were gifts to charities she had supported for years. The USO, the American Cancer Society, the Musculardrophe Association, a home for retired film workers, a school for troubled boys.
There was money for her loyal secretary of nearly 50 years. There was an inheritance for her two youngest daughters, the twins Kathy and Cindy. And then there was one sentence, cold and final, that would echo for decades. She wrote that she was making no provision for her son Christopher or her daughter Christina for reasons which were well known to them.
18 months later, the world thought it had found out what those reasons were. In the autumn of 1978, Christina Crawford published a memoir called Mommy Dearest. It described a childhood of fear, of rages in the night, of punishments that seemed designed to humiliate, and of a mother who treated her children as props in a public performance.
It became one of the most sensational bestsellers of its time. 3 years later, it became a movie starring Fay Dunaway, and one hysterical scream from that movie about wire hangers became so famous that for millions of people, it is now the only thing they know about Joan Crawford at all. But here is the problem with the story. Most people think they know.
The movie is not the book. The book is not the whole family. And the family itself was split right down the middle. Two of Joan Crawford’s children said she was cruel. Two of her children said she was a loving mother, and they said it loudly and consistently for the rest of their lives. Her friends lined up on both sides.
One of her daughters took another to court over what she had said in public. And behind all of it sits a trail of facts that rarely makes it into the famous version. About a baby Joan Crawford was forced to give back, about a notorious adoption agency in Tennessee, and about the kind of childhood that shaped the woman at the center of it all.
Today we are going to try to separate what is documented from what is alleged, what is rumor from what is record and what the famous movie invented from what the people who were actually there said happened. This is not a story with a clean hero or a clean villain. It is something messier, sadder, and far more human.
Before we go any further, if you enjoy these deep dives into the real stories behind Hollywood’s biggest legends, please take a moment to subscribe to the channel and turn on notifications so you never miss one. And tell me in the comments right now. Before today, what did you believe about Joan Crawford? Monster, misunderstood, or something in between? Tell me where you are starting.
And by the end of this video, let us see whether you still feel the same way. To understand Joan Crawford, we have to go back to a little girl who did not yet have that name into a childhood that almost nobody in Hollywood would ever hear about. She was born Lucille Fea Lassur in San Antonio, Texas on the 23rd of March.
The year is uncertain and that is not an accident. The most careful biographers believe it was 1904. Over the course of her life, however, the year drifted to 1905, 1906, 1908, and even 1909, depending on who was asking and what the studio needed. When she enrolled at college in 1922, she gave her birth year as 1906. When she died, the crypt that received her ashes listed it as 1908.
Christina would later write that her grandmother told her the true year was 1904. From the very beginning, Joan Crawford’s life was a story she edited. Her father was Thomas Lassour, a construction worker from Tennessee. Her mother was Annabelle Johnson, who was probably still a teenager when her first children were born.
Lucille had an older brother, Hal, and a halfsister named Daisy, who died when she was only a small child, and then her father left. Thomas Lassur walked out on the family when Lucille was about 10 months old. He eventually settled in Abalene, Texas. She would have no memory of him at all. Her mother remarried.
In 1909, Anna wet a man named Henry Kassen, and the family settled in Lton, Oklahoma, where Kassen ran a theater called the Ramsay Opera House. It was a real stage, one that booked touring acts from across the country, and it brought names as grand as the ballerina Anna Pavlova and the vaudeville star Eva Tangway to a small Oklahoma town.
For a little girl, it was pure magic. She went by the name Billy Cassen, and she spent every moment she could watching the vaudeville axe from the wings of her stepfather’s theater. She called Henry Kassen daddy. According to her biographers, she did not know he was not her real father until her brother eventually told her the truth.
Imagine learning as a child that the man you have always called your father is not your father at all and that your real father simply walked away. It is the kind of discovery that teaches a child the ground beneath her can move at any moment. What little Billy wanted most in the world was to dance. And there is a small telling story from these years.
One day trying to escape a piano lesson, she leapt from the front porch and landed on a broken milk bottle, cutting her foot badly. According to her biographers, it took three operations to repair, and for about 18 months, she could not attend school or take dance lessons. The child who dreamed of dancing had to learn to walk properly again first.
She did, and then she danced anyway. In 1917, the family’s life in Lton fell apart. Henry Kassen was accused of embezzlement. He was acquitted, but the scandal ruined his name in the town and the family moved to Kansas City, Missouri. Before long, Anna and Henry separated. And here, the childhood of the future, Joan Crawford, takes its darkest turn.
Kassen, who was Catholic, had placed Billy at a Catholic school in Kansas City called St. Agnes’s Academy. When her mother and stepfather separated, she did not leave. She stayed on as what was called a work student, a child who earned her place by laboring for it. By the accounts of her biographers, she spent far more of her time working, mostly cooking and cleaning, than she ever spent studying.
Later, she moved to another school, Rockingham Academy, again as a working student. Think about what that meant daytoday. While the other girls went to their lessons, she scrubbed. While they ate, she served. She was the poor girl, the one who cleaned up after everyone else. Because her family life was so unstable, her schooling never really went beyond the primary level.
Her whole early life taught her that every scrap of security had to be earned and that it could be taken away at any time. Later in life, Joan Crawford would become famous and infamous for her obsession with cleanliness and order. She scrubbed floors herself, even when she was a millionaire with a household staff. She insisted on spotless rooms, perfect closets, and rigid routines.
Many of the most disturbing scenes in Mommy Dearest revolve around cleaning, around children made to scrub and polish and put things in perfect order. It is impossible to read about the girl who scrubbed floors to pay her way through St. Agnes’s Academy and not see a connection. None of this excuses anything that may have happened later in her own home, but it helps explain where the obsession came from.
Her teenage years were a scramble. She had her first serious romance with a trumpet player named Ray Sterling, who reportedly encouraged her to take her studies more seriously. In 1922, she enrolled at Stevens College in Columbia, Missouri. She lasted only a few months before withdrawing.
Realizing she simply was not ready for college. What she was ready for was the stage. Under her birth name, Lucille Lassour, she began dancing in the choruses of traveling reviews. In Detroit, she was spotted by the powerful Broadway producer Jacob J. Schubert, who put her in the chorus line of his 1924 show, Innocent Eyes, at the Winter Garden Theater in New York. Broadway.
The girl who had scrubbed floors at a Kansas City convent school was dancing in a Broadway chorus line and she wanted more. She approached a well-connected publicist named Neils Granland who got her work with the singer Harry Richmond and arranged a screen test that was sent to a producer in Hollywood.
On the 24th of December 1924, Christmas Eve, the answer came. Metro Goldwin Mayor was offering her a contract at $75 a week. She was back at her mother’s home in Kansas City when the telegram arrived. She borrowed $400 for the journey and she headed west. She was about 20 years old. She had almost no education, no family money, no connections, and a past she would spend the rest of her life trying to outrun.
What she had was hunger, a ferocious, bottomless hunger to never be the poor girl again. When Lucille Lassour arrived at MGM in early 1925, she was one of hundreds of pretty young hopefuls on the payroll, and the studio did not quite know what to do with her. Her very first film credit came that year in a picture called Lady of the Night, and her job in it tells you exactly where she stood.
She was the body double for Norma Shearer, MGM’s most popular actress. The camera saw the back of her head while Shearer got the close-ups. It was the beginning of a rivalry that would last for years. Normashir was not just MGM’s leading lady. She was married to Irving Falberg, the studios head of production, and she had first pick of the scripts.
The girl from Kansas City watched Sheerer get the roles she wanted and did not hide how she felt about it. A remark attributed to her in those years, bitter and funny in equal measure, suggested that competing with Sheerer was impossible because Sheerer was married to the boss. Then there was the matter of her name.
MGM’s publicity chief Pete Smith believed she had the makings of a star, but he felt her name was all wrong. According to the story he told, Lassour reminded him of a sewer. So, the studio ran a contest in a fan magazine called Movie Weekly, inviting readers to name the new starlet. The first choice was Joan Ardan, but another actress already had a claim to it, so the runnerup was chosen, Joan Crawford.
She did not love it at first. She reportedly said the surname reminded her of Crawfish, and she wanted her first name pronounced Joanne, but she also admitted she liked the security that came with it. A new name chosen by strangers owned by a studio for a woman who wanted to leave her past behind. It was almost perfect. Lucille Lassour, Billy Cassin, the work student at St. Agnes’s Academy.
All of them could be folded away. From now on, there was only Joan Crawford. What happened next tells you everything about her. The small parts kept coming and they were not enough. So Joan Crawford decided to make herself a star. She threw herself into a campaign of self-promotion unlike anything the studio had seen.
She went out dancing almost every afternoon and evening at hotel ballrooms around Hollywood and on the amusement peers by the beach. And she won dance contests doing the Charleston and the Black Bottom. She made sure she was seen. She made sure she was photographed. She answered her fan mail personally, a habit she kept for the rest of her life.
A screenwriter at MGM in those years, Frederria Sagor Moss later summed it up in a line that has been quoted ever since. In her view, nobody decided to make Joan Crawford a star. Joan Crawford decided to become one. It worked. In 1925, she made an impression in a film called Sally, Irene, and Mary. In 1926, she was named one of the year’s Wampus Baby stars, a publicity honor given to promising young actresses alongside future legends like Janet Gainor, Mary Aster, and FA Ray.
In 1927, she played opposite the great Lawn Cheney in the unknown. And she later said she learned more about acting from watching Cheney than from anyone else in her career. And in 1928 came the role that made her. In Our Dancing Daughters, she played a wild, free-spirited society girl named Diana Medford, dancing on tabletops with a joy that seemed to leap off the screen.
Overnight, Joan Crawford became one of the defining flappers of the jazz age, a rival to Clara Bo, the original ITG girl. The novelist F. Scott Fitzgerald, the great chronicler of the era, singled her out as perhaps the best example of the flapper type, the glamorous, dancing, laughing young woman with hurt eyes.
She had her own more cutting way of describing her screen image. If audiences wanted to see the girl next door, she once said they could go next door. When sound came to the movies at the end of the 1920s, it destroyed the careers of many silent stars. Voices that did not match their faces, accents that audiences could not follow, performers who simply could not adjust.
Joan Crawford was determined that it would not happen to her. She had a southwestern accent and she set out to erase it. By her own account, she would lock herself in her room and read newspapers, magazines, and books aloud, listening to every sound she made with a dictionary by her side. When she found a word she could not pronounce, she looked it up and repeated it correctly again and again until it was perfect.
She also studied singing with a respected voice teacher in New York, Estelle Leebing. It was the same girl who had scrubbed floors to earn her place at school, now scrubbing her own voice to earn her place in the talkies. And it worked. She made a successful transition to sound in 1929 with a picture called Untamed.
That same year, on the 3rd of June 1929, she married Douglas Fairbanks Jr., the handsome son of Douglas Fairbanks, the swashbuckling king of silent film, and the stepson of Mary Pigford, America’s sweetheart. It was a Hollywood royal wedding and the royal family was not pleased.
Fairbanks senior and Pikford reportedly disapproved of the marriage and did not invite the couple to their famous estate, Pigfair, for months afterward. The girl from the convent school had married into the most glamorous family in Hollywood, and the family made sure she knew she did not belong. The relationship with her in-laws did warm over time.
Fairbanks senior eventually took to calling her Billy, her childhood nickname. But the marriage itself did not last. In 1933, Joan divorced Douglas Fairbanks Jr., citing mental cruelty and describing his jealousy of her friends and their endless arguments late into the night. Years later, after Mommy Dearest came out, he would be one of those who defended her, saying the woman in the book was not the Joan Crawford he had known.
Through the early 1930s, her career soared. She was paired with Clark Gable, MGM’s rising male star, in one hit after another. Dance, Fools Dance, Laughing Sinners, Possessed. She was part of the dazzling all-star cast of Grand Hotel in 1932 alongside Greta Garbo, John and Lionol Barrymore, and Wallace Berry. And the film won the Academy Award for best picture.
A dress she wore that same year in a film called Lety Linton, designed by the great costume designer Adrien with enormous ruffled sleeves, became such a sensation that Macy’s department store copied it. When exhibitors published their first poll of the stars who made the most money at the box office in 1932, Joan Crawford was third in the nation.
She played working girls, shopg girls, stenographers, and dance hall hostesses, women who clawed their way up from nothing to love and money. Depression era audiences, especially women, adored her for it. She was playing her own life and they could feel it. In 1935, she married again, this time to Francho Tone, a cultured stage actor from New York.
They built a small theater at her home in Brentwood and staged classic plays for their friends. For a while, it seemed to be a marriage of genuine intellectual partnership, but it too went wrong. Her biographers record that during the marriage she suffered two miscarriages and they record something darker. That tone allegedly began drinking and became physically abusive.
She filed for divorce and it was granted in 1939. And yet in one of the stranger turns in her private life. The two later rebuilt their friendship. By the accounts of her biographers, Tone even proposed in 1964 that they marry again. They did not. But when he died in 1968, it was Joan Crawford who arranged for his cremation and for his ashes to be scattered in the Muskoka Lakes region of Canada.
The woman who could cut people out of her life with frightening finality could also sometimes hold on to them long after everyone else had let go. Think about what that means for the story we are about to tell. By the end of the 1930s, Joan Crawford had lost two pregnancies. She had been through two failed marriages, the second one reportedly violent.
She had no children, and there is every sign that she desperately wanted them. And at the same time, her career was sliding. Her films were still earning money, but less of it, and her salary was enormous. In 1937, Life magazine proclaimed her the queen of the movies. The very next year, the throne collapsed. In May of 1938, a group of independent theater owners took out an advertisement in the Hollywood Reporter listing stars whose high salaries they argued were not justified by their ticket sales.
The list included some of the greatest names in film history. Greta Garbo, Marlene Dietrich, Katherine Hepburn, May West, and Joan Crawford. They were branded in a phrase that would follow them all, box office poison. She fought back. In 1939, she stole scenes as the scheming shopgirl Crystal Allen in The Women opposite her old rival Normashira.
In 1941, she gave a powerful performance as a woman with a disfigured face in a woman’s face, but MGM was losing interest in her. After 18 years at the studio, she asked to be released from her contract. In June of 1943, MGM agreed and paid her to go. She was nearly 40, by the studio calendar, a little younger.
In the Hollywood of the 1940s, that was a dangerous age for an actress. Most people assumed her time was over. They were wrong. She signed with Warner Brothers and she waited for the right part. It came in the form of a novel by James M. Kaine about a hard-working mother who builds a restaurant empire to give her spoiled daughter everything only to be betrayed by her. The film was Mildred Pierce.
The director, Michael Curtis, reportedly wanted Barbara Stanwick for the role and did not think Joan Crawford was right. So, she did something that stars of her stature almost never did. She agreed to a screen test and she won the part. Mildred Pierce was released in 1945 and it was a triumph.
Joan Crawford won the Academy Award for best actress. According to the well-known story, she was at home in bed on the night of the ceremony, reportedly ill, and the Oscar was brought to her there, where she posed for photographers holding it. Whether she was truly sick or simply too nervous to face the crowd has been debated ever since, but the comeback was complete.
The box office poison of 1938 was the best actress of 1945, and there’s a painful irony in the film that made her comeback. Mildred Pierce is the story of a mother who gives her daughter everything and gets nothing but contempt in return. Joan Crawford won her Oscar for playing a devoted mother betrayed by an ungrateful child.
Decades later, her own daughter would tell the world a story about the Crawford home that turned that picture completely upside down. To understand what happened inside Joan Crawford’s home, we have to go back a few years to the moment she became a mother. because the way her children came to her is one of the least known and most revealing parts of her story.
By 1940, Joan Crawford was divorced, childless, and had lost two pregnancies. She wanted a family, but there was a problem. Under California law at the time, a single woman could not adopt a child within the state. So, Joan Crawford did what wealthy, determined people often did in those years. She went around the rules.
The baby girl who would become Christina was born in Los Angeles on the 11th of June 1939. Her birthother was a young unmarried woman of about 19. According to accounts of the adoption, the arrangement was made through a baby broker and the adoption itself was finalized in Las Vegas, Nevada, where the laws were looser.
At first, Joan named the little girl Joan. Then she changed her mind and renamed her Christina. It is worth pausing on that detail because it says something about the kind of household the child was entering. Christina arrived as a baby with one name, was given her new mother’s own name, and then had it changed again. From the very beginning, she was a child whose identity was being written by someone else.
Her mother knew exactly what that felt like. She had been Lucil and Billy and finally Joan. All names chosen for her by other people. The next part of the story is one that almost nobody knows and it may be one of the saddest chapters in Joan Crawford’s life. In 1942, Joan married her third husband, an actor named Philip Terry. They married on the 21st of July 1942, just after midnight, only about 6 weeks after their first date.
But even before that marriage, Joan had set out to give Christina a brother. A baby boy born in June of 1941 came to her through another private arrangement. She named him Christopher. Then everything went wrong. According to the accounts that have emerged, the baby’s birth mother was a married woman who had become pregnant during an affair.
When she discovered that her son had been placed with one of the most famous women in America, she saw an opportunity. She reportedly tried to extract money from Joan Crawford. And rather than be blackmailed, Joan gave the baby back. What happened to that little boy afterward is heartbreaking. According to the account that later came out, the man his birthother was married to treated the child cruy and eventually the boy was placed for adoption again and raised [clears throat] by another family who by his own account loved him. Decades
later, as an adult, he wrote a memoir about his life called The Other Side of My Life. Years after Joan’s death, he spoke with her twin daughters, and they told him how deeply Joan had grieved over losing him. According to the family’s account, the subject was so painful to her that none of her other children dared to bring it up.
Think about that. The woman, who would later be portrayed to the world as a cold, cruel mother, had once lost a baby son she had already named and taken home. And the loss hurt her so much that it became a forbidden subject in her house. She did not give up. In 1943, Joan and Philip Terry adopted another baby boy.
At first, he was named Philip Terry Jr. According to the accounts, the same birthother from the earlier adoption later tried to claim that this child was hers as well, and the matter ended with her in a psychiatric hospital. When Joan’s marriage to Philip Terry ended in 1946, she changed the boy’s name.
From then on, he was Christopher Crawford. So once again, a child in Joan Crawford’s household had his name taken away and replaced. And it is worth noting how little Philip Terry features in this story. By most accounts, he was the least significant of her husbands. And once the marriage ended, he largely disappeared from the lives of the children.
Then came the twins. On the 13th of January 1947, in a hospital in Dyresburg, Tennessee, a 21-year-old woman named Theta Cotton, gave birth to twin girls. They were premature and needed hospital care for several weeks. Their father, a young man named JW Jordan, was not with her. According to what the twins later learned, he had panicked when he found out she was pregnant.
Theta knew she could not care for the babies. She placed them with an adoption agency and 7 days after they were born, she died of kidney failure. The agency was the Tennessee Children’s Home Society in Memphis. And here we have to stop because that name carries a very dark history. The Memphis branch of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society was run by a woman named Georgia Tan.
For decades, she operated what investigators later described as a baby selling operation. Children were placed with wealthy families across the country, many of them in Hollywood and New York for large fees. Some birth parents were deceived. Records were falsified. In some cases, poor families were pressured or tricked into giving up children they never intended to lose.
In September of 1950, the state of Tennessee announced an investigation into the operation. Georgia Tan died of cancer within days of that announcement before she could be held to account. Her crimes became one of the great adoption scandals in American history. So, it is a documented fact that Kathy and Cindy Crawford were adopted through the agency Georgia Tan ran.
But here, the record is just as clear on another point, and it matters. There is no evidence that the twins themselves were taken improperly. Their mother placed them with the agency herself, knowing she could not care for them, and she died a week later. Their father, by his own later account, did not know where they had gone.
Joan Crawford adopted them in the summer of 1947, a year after she had won her Academy Award, and she brought them home to Brentwood. She named them Catherine and Cynthia, called Kathy and Cindy. There is one more small detail from those years that says something about Joan Crawford’s fears. According to Cindy speaking to a Memphis newspaper in 1995, her mother was so afraid that the birth family might try to reclaim the girls that she often told people they were not really twins.
Remember what had happened with her first son? She had already lost one child to a birth mother. She was determined it would never happen again. That small lie would come back to haunt the family half a century later in a courtroom. So by 1947, Joan Crawford had four children in her home. Christina about 8, Christopher about four, and the infant twins.
The family lived in a large, beautiful house in Brentwood. There were servants, a pool, beautiful clothes, famous visitors, and a mother who was one of the most celebrated actresses in the world. And here’s where the two versions of the story begin to split apart. Everyone who knew the household agrees on some things. Joan Crawford ran her home with iron discipline.
There were rules for everything. The children made their own beds. They helped with chores. They were expected to be polite, to stand when adults entered the room, to answer their mother’s fans, to keep their rooms and their belongings in perfect order. Punishments for breaking the rules were real.
There was a routine for every hour of the day, and the home was, in many ways, a showplace. magazines photographed Joan Crawford with her children. The family was part of her public image, the glamorous star who was also a devoted mother. Even the people who defended Joan Crawford later acknowledged that she was strict. The actress Helen Hayes and the director Vincent Sherman both wrote in their memoirs that they thought she was too strict to parent.
The actress June Allison recalled in her autobiography seeing Joan put Christina in a kind of timeout and forbid her from attending a friend’s birthday party as a punishment. The actor James the MacArthur who spent a weekend with the family as a child remembered seeing little Christopher strapped into his bed at night with a harness.
That harness became one of the most disturbing images associated with the family. But there is another side to it. Years later, Christopher’s own daughter said that her father had a condition we would today recognize as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and that the family doctor had recommended the harness, a product sold in stores at the time to keep the restless boy from wandering out of bed at night and possibly falling into the swimming pool.
Whether that explanation fully accounts for what the children experienced is something we cannot know, but it is a good example of how the same fact can look completely different depending on who is telling the story. None of the witnesses who described Joan strictness said they ever saw anything they would call outright abuse.
But those were visitors, friends, colleagues. They saw the household for an afternoon or a weekend. The children lived in it every day. And two of those children would eventually tell the world that what happened behind closed doors was far worse than anything the visitors ever saw. We are halfway through the story now and this is where it becomes genuinely hard.
Before we go on, I want to hear from you. Do you think it is possible for two children to grow up in the same house with the same mother and have completely different childhoods? Have you seen that happen in your own family or in a family you know? Tell me in the comments because that question is going to sit at the heart of everything that comes next.
And if you are finding this story worthwhile so far, please hit the like button and subscribe because the second half is where the book, the movie, and the courtroom all come in. Let us start with what Christina Crawford said happened because her account is the reason we are here. In Mommy Dearest, Christina describes a childhood in which love and fear were tangled together so tightly she could never tell which one was coming next.
She describes a mother who could be charming and affectionate in front of guests and photographers and then when the door closed turned cold, furious, and frightening. She describes being punished severely for small things, sometimes for things she did not understand. She describes what she called night raids, episodes in which her mother would descend on the children’s rooms late at night in a rage over some imperfection, a closet out of order, a floor not clean enough.
She describes being made to scrub and clean as punishment. She describes her mother destroying things in fits of anger. And she describes a household where the children’s lives were arranged around their mother’s image, where they were brought out to be photographed, presented at parties, and expected to perform the role of a perfect family, whatever was happening in private.
The most famous scene, of course, involves wire hangers. In Christina’s telling, her mother discovered wire hangers in her closet among the nicer hangers Joan insisted on, and flew into a violent rage. It is worth noting that one entertainment history account has suggested a possible reason for Joan’s hatred of wire hangers.
That as a girl, she had seen her mother working in a laundry and cheap wire hangers reminded her of the poverty she had spent her whole life trying to escape. Whether that explanation is true, we cannot say for certain, but once again, a detail from the poor girl’s past seems to cast a long shadow over the rich woman’s home.
Christina also describes her adolescence and early adulthood as a continuing battle with her mother, a struggle for control that followed her into boarding school, into her first attempts at an acting career, and into her own adult life. Christina was not the only child to describe a painful childhood. Her brother Christopher did, too, though in fewer words and with less public attention.
In an interview with the Los Angeles Times in 1978, around the time the book came out, Christopher described his relationship with Joan in bleak terms. He said that he honestly did not believe she had ever cared for him. He told of a childhood of running away from home, being expelled from schools, and eventually being sent to a military academy.
In another account, he described being punished in a way that burned his hand. and he told a story about his daughter that is painful to hear. In 1961, he said he brought his 6-week old baby girl to meet Joan at a hotel in Miami. According to his account, Joan held the baby for only a few seconds, told him she was nobody’s grandmother, and that the child should call her Aunt Joan, and then handed the baby back with a cutting remark.
Years later, when another of his daughters was born seriously ill and needed blood, he said he called Joan for help and she reminded him that he was adopted and that the baby was not her grandchild. He said he slammed down the phone so hard he broke it. After that, he said it was over between them. We have only Christopher’s side of those conversations, but they are specific and they are consistent with the picture Christina paints of a mother who could be cold and wounding, especially toward the two children with whom her
relationship had broken down. So those are the accusations. Now let us look at what was happening in Joan Crawford’s own life while her children were growing up because it matters to the story. After Mildred Pierce, her career rolled on through the late 1940s and into the 1950s.
She earned another Academy Award nomination for Possessed in 1947 and a third for the thriller Sudden Fear in 1952. She starred in the strange, fierce western Johnny Guitar in 1954, which has since become a cult classic. She was still a star, but she was also getting older in an industry that was brutal to aging actresses, and she knew it.
The children were growing up in these years, and their paths were already diverging. Christina was sent to boarding schools and after graduating from a Catholic girls academy went east to study drama. First briefly at the Carnegie Institute of Technology in Pittsburgh and then at the neighborhood playhouse in New York. She wanted to be an actress like her mother.
Christopher, meanwhile, was repeatedly in trouble. He ran away from home more than once, was expelled from several schools, and spent his high school years at a military academy. He married at 18, and had his first child a year later. The twins were still little girls, and they were growing up in what, by their own later accounts, was a very different emotional climate from the one their older brother and sister remembered.
In 1955, she married for the fourth and final time. Her husband was Alfred Steele, the president of the Pepsi Cola Company, a powerful, energetic businessman. They married on the 10th of May, 1955 at the Flamingo Hotel in Las Vegas. By most accounts, this was the happiest of her marriages. Steel was her equal in drive and ambition, and he took on a father figure role for her children, especially the twins, who were still young.
With Steel, Joan Crawford became something new, the glamorous face of a global corporation. She traveled the world on Pepsi’s behalf, appearing at bottling plants and promotional events, bringing Hollywood glamour to a soft drink company. The twins were sent to boarding school, visiting home on weekends and holidays. Then in April of 1959, Alfred Steele died suddenly of a heart attack.
He was only in his 50s. Joan was devastated. And then came a second shock. The couple had spent lavishly, including on a luxurious apartment in New York, and by the accounts of her biographers, Steele’s death left Joan in serious financial trouble. An Associated Press story in June of 1959 carried a headline in which she said in effect that she was broke.
Here again, she did what she had always done. She went back to work. The board of Pepsi Cola elected her to fill her late husband’s seat, making her the first woman on the company’s board of directors. She became the company’s goodwill ambassador, and by her own estimate, in the mid 1960s, she was traveling more than a 100,000 m a year for Pepsi.
She took the job seriously, too. In 1963, Pepsi gave her its annual Pali Award, a bronze statueette shaped like a Pepsi bottle, presented to the person judged to have contributed most to the company’s sales that year. The girl who had never finished school was now being honored as a corporate saleswoman, and she took a small supporting role in a film called The Best of Everything, released in 1959, simply because she needed the work.
Then at the start of the 1960s came one more remarkable chapter. The director Robert Aldrich sent her a script for a psychological thriller about two aging sisters. Both former stars living together in a crumbling Hollywood mansion. One sister is disabled and trapped in her room. The other is mentally unstable, bitter, and cruel.
The film was Whatever Happened to Baby Jane. Joan Crawford would play the disabled sister, Blanch. and for the role of the cruel sister, Jane. The film cast the one actress in Hollywood whose name was most often linked with Jones as a rival, B. Davis. Their rivalry was already legendary. The two women had been competing in one way or another since the 1930s, and there was a long history of perceived slights between them.
Remarkably, according to the accounts of the production, it was Joan herself who suggested B. Davis for the role. In public, both women insisted there was no feud. In private, by most accounts, the tension on the set was intense. Stories have circulated for decades about their behavior toward each other during filming. Some of them almost certainly exaggerated, and neither woman ever fully confirmed the most lurid versions.
Whatever Happened to Baby Jane was released in 1962, and it was a huge hit. It reportedly earned back its costs within about 11 days of its nationwide release. It revived both women’s careers. And then came the Academy Awards. B. Davis was nominated for best actress for her performance as Jane. Joan Crawford was not nominated.
What happened next has become one of the most famous stories in Oscar history. According to the widely told account, Joan contacted the other nominated actresses and offered to accept the award on their behalf if they could not attend. When the winner was announced in April of 1963, it was Anne Braftoft for The Miracle Worker and Braftoft was not there.
So, Joan Crawford walked onto the stage and accepted the Oscar in her place, while B. Davis, who many believed had wanted that award badly, watched from the wings. Whether Joan’s intention was generosity or revenge has been argued ever since. Most people who tell the story assume it was both. The two women were cast together again in a follow-up. Hush, hush, sweet Charlotte.
But after what was described as a campaign of harassment from Davis on location in Louisiana, Joan returned to Hollywood and checked into a hospital. After her prolonged absence, Aldrich replaced her with Olivia De Havland. Joan later described hearing the news on the radio from her hospital bed and crying for hours.
Whatever you believe about Joan Crawford, it is worth noticing how often in her life she was replaced, discarded, or pushed aside by a father, by a stepfather, by a studio, by a husband, by a rival, and how fiercely she fought every time. It is also worth noticing that the people she could not control, she sometimes cut out of her life entirely.
In October of 1968, something happened that would become one of the most disputed episodes between Joan and Christina. Christina, by then in her late 20s, was working as an actress in New York playing a role on a CBS soap opera called The Secret Storm. She suddenly needed emergency surgery for a serious gynecological condition.
While Christina was in the hospital, Joan Crawford, in her 60s, stepped into her daughter’s role on the show for a short run, playing a character who was supposed to be in her late 20s. In Mommy Dearest, Christina presents this as her mother stealing her role, humiliating her and making even her illness about herself.
But the show’s producer, Gloria Monty, told a very different story. She said that the network had asked Joan to fill in and that Joan agreed only so that Christina would not be permanently replaced by another actress while she recovered. Monty said she had watched Joan do everything she could to save her daughter’s job and even her life.
Two people, the same event, two completely different stories. It is a pattern that repeats again and again in the history of this family and it is exactly why the truth is so hard to pin down. By the late 1960s, Joan Crawford’s career was winding down, and the roles were getting smaller and stranger.
In 1964, she played an axe murderer in a horror film called Straight Jacket. In 1965, she appeared in another thriller, I Saw what you did. In 1967, she played the owner of a circus in Berserk. These were the kinds of pictures that aging stars of her generation were often offered once the studios had moved on to younger faces.
Low-budget horror films that traded on their names. There were still flashes of the old magic. In February of 1968, she appeared as herself on an episode of The Lucy Show with Lucille Ball. By several accounts, she struggled during rehearsals, but on the day of the taping, she was letter perfect, danced the Charleston, and received two standing ovations from the studio audience.
In 1969, she starred in the pilot film for the television series Night Gallery, and her segment was directed by a young man making his professional debut. His name was Steven Spielberg. In February of 1970, she received the Cecil B. Deil award at the Golden Globes presented to her by John Wayne and in 1970 she made what would be her final feature film.
It was a science fiction horror movie called Trogue in which she played a scientist studying a caveman creature. It was not a distinguished end to a career that had included Grand Hotel and Mildred Pierce. After a few more television appearances, the last of them in 1972, Joan Crawford stopped acting. Her career had lasted around 45 years and produced more than 80 films.
She also wrote in 1962 she published an autobiography, a portrait of Joan and in 1971 a book of advice on style, grooming, and living called My Way of Life, which is full of her rules about order, cleanliness, entertaining, and self-discipline. Reading it now, knowing what her daughter would later write, is a strange experience.
It is the voice of a woman who believed completely that control and routine were the keys to a good life. There is one more subject that we have to address honestly because it runs through the darker accounts of these years. Alcohol in Mommy Dearest Christina describes her mother as an alcoholic especially in the later years.
It is fair to say that several people who knew Joan Crawford have acknowledged that she drank heavily in the later part of her life, and her biographers have written about it. Heavy drinking does not create cruelty out of nothing, and it does not excuse anything, but it is a part of the picture, and it may help explain why the worst of the accounts of her behavior come from the children who were with her during certain years and not others.
In April of 1973, Joan Crawford made one of her last great public appearances. She was the guest in a series called Legendary Ladies at the Town Hall in Manhattan, where audiences watched clips from a star’s career and then asked her questions in person. The 1500 seats were sold out.
When she left, about 200 fans surrounded her car and would not let it move for several minutes. Even then, she could still stop traffic. That same year, she retired from the Pepsi Cola board at what was officially recorded as the age of 65. It was one more piece of evidence that her real age was still a closely guarded secret because by the reckoning of most biographers, she was older than that.
And in September of 1973, she moved from her large apartment into a smaller one next door in the same building on East 69th Street. Her final public appearance came on the 23rd of September 1974 at a party she hosted for her old friend, the actress Rosalind Russell at the Rainbow Room in New York.
Photographers took pictures of her as she left, and by the accounts of her biographers, she was so unhappy with how she looked in those photographs that she withdrew almost completely from public life. Think about that for a moment. The woman who had spent 50 years fighting to control her image, who had built her face and her voice and her name from nothing, saw a photograph she could not control and simply disappeared.
For the last years of her life, she saw only a small circle of people. She answered letters. She talked on the phone. But the world did not see Joan Crawford anymore. In the last months of her life, she was clearly unwell. On the 6th of May 1977, she gave away her dog because she could no longer care for her.
And 4 days later, on the 10th of May 1977, Joan Crawford died of a heart attack in her apartment. Her age was reported as 69. If the most likely birth year is correct, she was 73. Her funeral was held in New York a few days later, and her ashes were placed in a crypt at Ferncliff Cemetery in Hartsdale, New York, beside her husband, Alfred Steel.
A memorial service at All Souls Unitarian Church in New York brought out old friends including MNA Ly and the actor Cliff Robertson who spoke about her and the singer Pearl Bailey who sang. Another memorial organized by the director George Cukor was held at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in Beverly Hills and then the will was read.
Her estate was valued at about $2 million. She left $77,500 to each of the twins, Kathy and Cindy. She left $35,000 to her secretary and friend of nearly 50 years, Betty Barker. She left money to her charities, and she left nothing to Christina or Christopher for reasons she said were well known to them.
Both of them challenged the will, and they eventually received a settlement of $55,000. There was something else that came to light after her death, and it is almost never mentioned in the Mommy Dearest version of her story. For years, Joan Crawford had quietly paid for hospital rooms and medical specialists for people who could not afford care, many of them men and women from the film industry who had fallen on hard times.
She never publicized it. By the accounts of her biographers, she did not want the public or the patients to know it was her. Throughout her life, she had also given enormous sums to charity. In 1942, after her friend Carol Lombard was killed in a plane crash, Joan donated her entire salary from a film called They All Kissed the Bride, more than $100,000 to charities in Lombard’s memory.
Her charity work went far beyond that one gesture. During the Second World War, she volunteered at the Hollywood Canteen in Los Angeles, serving and entertaining servicemen, and she helped raise money through war bond drives. She volunteered with the American Women’s Voluntary Services, supporting nurseries for the children of servicemen.
In 1965, the USO named her its woman of the year for her years of support for American troops. And in the 1960s, she visited military hospitals to cheer up soldiers wounded in Vietnam. From 1966 to 1973, she appeared on the annual muscular distrophe tellathon, urging viewers to pledge money. In 1971, she accepted an honorary chairmanship to help raise funds for the Negro Ensemble Company, the celebrated black theater company in New York.
In 1972, she served as national chairwoman for the American Cancer Society. None of this proves anything about what happened inside her home. Plenty of people who are generous in public are cruel in private, and the reverse is true, too. But it is part of the record, and it belongs in any honest account of who she was.
That is the paradox of Joan Crawford. A woman who could be generous in secret to strangers and yet by the testimony of two of her own children, cold and punishing at home. A woman who never wanted anyone to see her give and who could not bear anyone to see her fall. The disinheritance in the court of public opinion became a kind of verdict.
If she had nothing to hide, people asked why would she cut two of her children out of her will. But it is worth looking at that question carefully. She did not disinherit all of her children. She provided for the two daughters who defended her. The break was with the two children whose relationships with her had collapsed.

That tells us beyond any doubt that those relationships were deeply broken. It does not by itself tell us whose fault that was or whether every detail of what Christina would later write was true. There is one more fact about the timing that matters. According to the biographer Fred Lawrence Guiles, Christina had already begun writing her book before her mother died.
Guiles suggested that Joan may have known what was coming and that this knowledge may have been one of the reasons she left Christina out of her will. If that is right, then the famous sentence in the will may not have been the cause of the book. It may have been a response to it. In October of 1978, thousands of copies of Mommy Dearest began appearing in bookstores ahead of its official release date in November.
The publisher, William Morrow, had printed and shipped them in enormous numbers, and the demand was immediate. The book became a sensation. It went to the top of the bestseller lists. It was discussed on television, in newspapers, in magazines, at dinner tables across the country. It is hard to overstate how shocking it was at the time.
In 1978, the idea that a beloved movie star might have abused her children behind closed doors was not something the public had been asked to consider before. Hollywood had spent decades selling the image of stars as ideal parents, and Joan Crawford, with her magazine spreads and posed family portraits, had been one of the most enthusiastic sellers of that image.
Now, her own daughter was saying it had all been a lie. The book is often credited with opening the door to a whole new genre, the celebrity tell all written by the children of the famous. Within weeks, it had become part of the culture. In December of 1978, only a couple of months after the book appeared, Saturday Night Live aired a sketch parodying it with Jane Curtain as Joan Crawford and Gilda Rner as an exaggerated version of the young Christina.
Before the movie was even made, Mommy Dearest was already a punchline. But the reaction to the book was not one-sided. From the very beginning, a long list of people who had known Joan Crawford lined up to dispute it. Her first husband, Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. said that the Joan Crawford described in Mommy Dearest was not the woman he had known.
Friends and colleagues including Van Johnson, Katherine Hepburn, Caesar Romero, Bob Hope, Barbara Stanwick, and Anne Bliss were among those reported to have disputed the portrait. Betty Barker, her secretary for nearly 50 years, said that while Joan was strict, Christina and Christopher had never been abused. The actress Mna Loy, a longtime friend, was especially blunt.
In her 1987 autobiography, she suggested that Christina had wanted to be Joan Crawford, that this was the root of the book, and that she had seen for herself the fantasy world Christina’s mind had created. Christina’s own former husband, the producer Harvey Mlinsky, said publicly that he had only good things to say about Joan Crawford, and that she had always been kind to him and to Christina while they were married.
And perhaps the most surprising defender of all was B. Davis, the woman who had been Joan’s great rival, who had battled her on the set of Baby Jane, said that while she had never been Joan’s biggest fan, she respected her talent and that Joan did not deserve what she called that detestable book.
It is worth adding in fairness that Davis also made some famously cruel remarks about Joan after her death. But on the question of the book, she came down on Joan’s side. And in one of the strange echoes of this story, B. Davis’s own daughter would later publish a memoir in 1985 portraying Davis herself as a difficult, hard-drinking mother.
The gossip columnist Liz Smith, who had followed Joan’s career for years, offered what might be the most balanced verdict of all. She wrote that she was inclined to believe Joan had been misguided in her attempts to mold her children and vain and self-absorbed like most great stars, but that the stories of beatings and near madness were, in her view, over the top. Christina had her supporters, too.
Her brother Christopher, as we have heard, backed her account and said he did not believe Joan had ever cared for him. And the witnesses who defended Joan were almost by definition people who saw her from the outside. visitors, friends, colleagues, employees. Abuse when it happens usually happens where visitors cannot see it.
That is precisely why the question has never been settled. But there were two people who were not visitors. Two people who grew up inside that house with that mother everyday for years, and they were furious. Kathy and Cindy Crawford spoke out against the book almost immediately, and they never stopped.
In 1979, Cindy told a reporter that she could not understand how people believed what she called the stupid stuff Christina had written. In October of 1981, People magazine ran a story about the war within the family. Kathy told the magazine that Christina said Joan was rotten and that she, Kathy, said Joan was a good person.
She acknowledged that their mother had been tough and that a child might get a SWAT now and then, but the beatings the book described, she said, did not happen. On the 28th of May, 1981, Kathy appeared on the national morning program Good Morning America to defend her mother on live television.
She described Joan as a very warm person who was always there when her children needed her, a working mother who still made time for them. and she delivered a line that would be quoted for decades. She called mommy dearest a great work of fiction and said Christina must have been living in another household. Years later, when the biographer Charlotte Chandler interviewed her for a book about Joan Crawford published in 2008, Kathy was just as firm.
She told Chandler she did not know where Christina got her ideas and that in her view, their mother was the best mother anyone ever had. Through Chandler’s work, Cathy shared memories of a childhood full of warmth, holidays, family trips, bedtime stories, a mother who was strict but loving and present. She described Joan as wise, caring, realistic, and a good friend.
So, which daughter was telling the truth? That is the question that has haunted this story for almost 50 years. And before we go on, it is worth thinking about it seriously rather than simply picking a side. One possibility is that Christina invented or wildly exaggerated her story out of bitterness at being disinherited or out of a lifelong rivalry with her famous mother or for money.
That is what many of Joan’s defenders believed. Maoy clearly thought so. And the timing of the book published after Joan could no longer answer struck many people as suspicious. Another possibility is that Christina told the truth and that Joan simply behaved differently with different children. There’s a real basis for this.
Christina was the first child adopted in 1940 when Joan was single, recently divorced, and fighting for her career at MGM. She grew up during the most turbulent years of her mother’s life. The collapse at MGM, the box office poison label, The Lost Baby Son, a third failed marriage. The twins arrived years later after the Oscar when Joan’s career had recovered and they spent much of their childhood in the years of her happiest marriage to Alfred Steel.
It is entirely possible that they genuinely knew a calmer, gentler mother than Christina and Christopher did. There is also the matter of personality. Christina, by most accounts, was strong willed and rebellious. In many ways, a lot like her mother. Christopher was restless, ran away repeatedly, and was expelled from schools.
The twins, by most accounts, were more compliant. A rigid, controlling parent who cannot tolerate defiance may treat an obedient child very differently from a defiant one. Two children can grow up in the same house and truly live in different households. And there is a third possibility, perhaps the most likely of all, that both daughters were telling the truth as they experienced it.
that Joan Crawford was capable of both warmth and cruelty. That the loving mother of Cathy’s memories and the frightening mother of Christina’s memories were the same woman on different days in different years. Whatever the truth, the book had done its work. Joan Crawford’s reputation would never be the same.
And then Hollywood made it worse. Paramount Pictures bought the film rights to Mommy Dearest. And in 1981, the movie arrived. It starred FA Dunaway as Joan Crawford and it was directed by Frank Perry. On paper, it was a prestigious project. Dunaway was one of the most acclaimed actresses in Hollywood, an Oscar winner herself for the 1976 film network.
By several accounts, she took the role seriously and threw herself into it completely, transforming her face, her voice, and her body to become Joan Crawford. According to the film historian A. Ashley Hoff, who wrote a book about the making of the movie, Dunaway had hoped to bring balance to the story to show something of what Joan Crawford was going through as an aging actress rather than simply presenting her as a monster.
That is not how it turned out. The film compressed and dramatized events from the book, combining separate incidents into single scenes and heightening the violence. The most famous example is the wire hanger scene. In the movie, Dunaway’s Joan, her face covered in white cold cream, discovers wire hangers in her daughter’s closet at night and explodes into a screaming physical rage.
According to Hoth’s research, Dunaway was deeply uncomfortable with the violence of that scene and did not want to be seen striking the young actress playing Christina Marael, so stand-ins were used for the actual blows. The movie also includes a scene in which Joan, having been dropped by MGM, storms into her garden at night and hacks down a tree in a fury.
In the book, the destruction of the garden was presented as one of Joan’s erratic nighttime episodes. The film turned it into a direct, almost theatrical reaction to losing her studio contract. When Mommy Dearest opened in 1981, audiences did something no one had planned for. They laughed. The film’s oporatic intensity, Dunaway’s enormous performance, and the melodramatic style struck many viewers as so extreme that it tipped over into camp.
Critics largely savaged it. Audiences began quoting its lines, especially the scream about wire hangers with delight rather than horror. And over the following decades, the movie became a cult classic, a staple of midnight screenings, drag performances, and parodies. The line about wire hangers became one of the most quoted in movie history.
It turned up in comedy sketches, in music videos, and in countless jokes. The rock band Blue Oyster Cult even released a song called Joan Crawford in 1981. Commercially, the film did well, but for nearly everyone involved, it was a disaster of another kind. For FA Dunaway, it became something she was widely reported to regret, a performance that overshadowed much of the serious work of her career and that she has long been reluctant to discuss.
For Joan Crawford’s Defenders, the film was a second assassination. If the book had damaged her reputation, the movie buried it under a cartoon. For millions of people who never read the book, never saw Mildred Pierce, and never knew anything else about her, Joan Crawford simply became the woman screaming about wire hangers. For the twins, the film was painful on every level. They disliked it deeply.
And there was an added insult. Kathy and Cindy were written out of the movie entirely. The story of the Crawford household was told as though the two daughters who had loved their mother did not exist. And perhaps most surprisingly of all, Christina Crawford herself came to reject the film.
She has said repeatedly over the years that the movie did not accurately depict her life. She has said that key scenes, including the tree chopping scene and the wire hanger scene were taken out of context and exaggerated, and she has criticized the way the movie turned her mother into a caricature. By some accounts, she felt that even Joan had not deserved to be portrayed that way.
For a woman who had wanted the world to take her suffering seriously, watching audiences roar with laughter at a dramatization of her childhood must have been a bitter experience. So, here is something that almost nobody who quotes the wire hanger scene knows. The author of Mommy Dearest does not stand behind the most famous version of Mommy Dearest.
The image of Joan Crawford that lives in popular culture today is not quite Christina’s version either. It is Hollywood’s version filtered through a camp sensibility that nobody intended. Repeated so many times that it has replaced the real woman almost entirely. And for the next two decades, the feud between Joan Crawford’s children would continue in public.
In 1997, nearly 20 years after the original book, Christina released a 20th anniversary edition of Mommy Dearest through a smaller publisher. Having bought back the rights, it added around a 100 pages of new material, dropped some of the original named people who had not been named in the first edition, and expanded on her adult relationship with her mother and on what had happened to her brother.
She promoted it energetically, including appearances at screenings of the film. And it was during that promotion that the war between the sisters went to court. According to a lawsuit Kathy filed on the 20th of July 1998, Christina had claimed in interviews during the anniversary tour that Kathy and Cindy were not biological sisters and that their adoption had never been legal.
Remember that small lie Joan had told years earlier out of fear that the birth family might try to reclaim the girls when she told people the twins were not really twins. Half a century later, that lie seems to have fed a story that wounded the twins deeply. Kathy sued Christina for defamation.
She attached copies of the twins birth certificates and their adoption documents to the lawsuit to prove that both claims were false. The case was settled in 1999 with Christina paying Cathy $5,000 plus court costs. The twins lawyer said afterward that they had proved their point. $5,000 is not a large sum, but the money was never the point.
For Kathy, it was about the record. It was about being able to say with legal documents in hand that her sister had said something untrue about her and that the truth about her own birth and her own family mattered. And by then, Kathy and Cindy knew much more about the truth of their own beginnings than they ever had as children. because a few years earlier they had gone looking for it.
Kathy and Cindy had always known they were adopted. Joan had never hidden that from them. By Cindy’s account, their mother had even once talked about taking them back to Memphis to visit the little red brick building of the agency where their story began. She never made that trip. And for most of their lives, the twins knew almost nothing about the people who had brought them into the world.
Their adult lives had taken them far from Hollywood. In August of 1968, Kathy married a Navy petty officer named Jerome Loland in Alexandria Bay, New York. The head of Pepsi Cola, Herbert Barnett, gave her away, and Cathy designed and sewed her own wedding dress. She settled in Pennsylvania, raised two children, and later worked as a teacher’s aid.
Cindy’s road was harder. She married in 1967 and moved with her husband into a trailer in Deuke, Iowa. Remarkably, the man she married was named Jordan, the same surname as the biological father she did not yet know existed. The marriage lasted about 9 years and produced two sons before it ended. Afterward, according to her own account to a Memphis newspaper, she earned about $150 a week working in a shoe store and lived partly on the money her mother had left her.
In 1984, a job offer drew her to Jackson, Mississippi. But the work dried up after 6 months, and she found herself on welfare and without a place to live. The Salvation Army and her friends helped her through. She worked and saved until she could afford an apartment again. She later said she had simply survived.
The daughter of one of the richest and most glamorous women in Hollywood, a child who had grown up in a Brentwood mansion, had known what it was to have nothing. In a strange way, her life had echoed her adoptive mother’s beginning. In June of 1990, Kathy saw a television program about the Tennessee Children’s Home Society and the scandal of Georgia Tan. Something clicked.
With the help of an advocate named Denny Glad, who led a search group helping people adopted through the agency trace their birth families, the twins began looking. The search took about 18 months and ended with a court order to open Cathy’s adoption records. What they found was both heartbreaking and wonderful. They learned that their birth mother, Theta, had died just a week after they were born.
and they learned that their birth father, JW Jordan, was alive, living in an old white farmhouse near a little town called Friendship in West Tennessee. Kathy was so nervous that it took her about 3 weeks to work up the courage to call him. She was afraid of being rejected. When she finally did, she said he was dumbfounded. Then Cindy called him, too.
By her account, she asked him whether he was sitting down and then told him she was his other daughter. A friend drove Cindy to friendship for their first meeting. She found him by a small pond where he had been fishing. By her account, neither of them knew what to do. And then her father simply asked her to give him some sugar, the old southern way of asking for a kiss, and she kissed him.
He told them he had panicked when he learned that their mother was pregnant. After they were born, he had asked about them, but by then they were gone. He had later married and divorced, and he never had any other children. For more than 40 years, he had known he had two daughters somewhere in the world, and he had no idea who they were or where they had gone.
In 1991, Cindy moved to Memphis to be close to him and to the rest of her newly found family. She visited him often at the old farmhouse, borrowing his car on weekends, going out to dinner with him, meeting his old friends. her mother’s side of the family who asked not to be named publicly welcomed her too and helped her build a new life in Memphis.
An aunt gave her a job in the family business, but the time they had together was short. In 1992, JW Jordan learned he had stomach cancer. He died the following year. The daughters who had spent their whole lives wondering about him had found him and then almost immediately lost him. In a 1995 interview, Cindy described her life as having gone from riches to rags to riches and then explained that the riches she meant were not money.
They were the people around her, the family she loved. On the walls of her small Memphis apartment, she kept pictures of both of her families, photographs of Joan Crawford alongside photographs of her Tennessee relatives. She did not see any contradiction in loving them all. And in the same interview, both twins spoke again about their adoptive mother.
Joan was their mother, Kathy said. Cindy said Joan had been very good to them and that she believed Joan had been good to all four of her children in her way. Cindy Crawford Jordan died on the 14th of October 2007. She was 60 years old. Christopher Crawford, the son who had told the world that his mother never cared for him, had died the year before in 2006.
He never reconciled with the woman who raised him. By the accounts of the family, he had long been estranged from his sisters as well. Kathy Crawford Loland lived on. She kept defending her mother for the rest of her life. In January of 2020, after a long battle with lung cancer, she died at her home in Pennsylvania at the age of 72.
Her obituary described her as the daughter of Academy Award-winning actress Joan Crawford and Pepsi Cola chief executive Alfred Steel and said that she had been grateful all her life for the opportunities, the travel, the education, and what it called a nurturing upbringing. With her death, the last of Joan Crawford’s children who had publicly defended her was gone.
And Christina, she has never backed down from her account. In a rare interview with the Observer newspaper in 2008, she made it clear she would never forgive her mother. In the years since, she has written other books, spoken about child abuse, performed a onewoman show about her experiences, and worked on a stage musical based on her memoir.
Whatever else anyone says about her, she has told the same story consistently for nearly half a century. Meanwhile, the film legacy that the wire hanger jokes had buried slowly began to resurface. Her handprints and footprints had been pressed into the forcourt of Groman’s Chinese Theater in Hollywood all the way back in September of 1929, and she has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
In 1999, the American Film Institute named her the 10th greatest female screen legend of classic American cinema. New Generations discovered Mildred Pierce, Johnny Guitar, and What Ever Happened to Baby Jane, and found an actress of real power, not a punchline. In 2017, a television drama series about her rivalry with B.
Davis brought her story to millions of new viewers. And while it took its own dramatic liberties, it presented her as a frightened, complicated human woman rather than a cartoon villain. So, where does all of this leave us? Let us start with what we can say for certain. Joan Crawford was a woman who came from abandonment and poverty, who scrubbed floors as a child to earn a place at school, and who spent her entire life terrified of losing the security she had fought so hard to win.
She was controlling, perfectionist, and obsessed with order and image. And even her strongest defenders agreed she was a strict and demanding parent. Her relationships with her two eldest children collapsed completely. Her relationships with her two youngest daughters endured with love until the end of her life and beyond.
She could be secretly remarkably generous to strangers, and she drank heavily in her later years. Now, let us say what we cannot know. We cannot know exactly what happened inside that house in the 1940s and 1950s. We have one daughter’s detailed account supported in general terms by her brother.
We have two other daughters who said it was untrue and who grew up in the same house in later years. We have a crowd of friends, colleagues, and employees who saw strictness but not abuse and who, by the nature of things could only see what happened when they were present. We have a producer who said one of the book’s key episodes was false.
We have a movie that the author herself says distorted the story. And we have a woman who died before any of it was published, who never had the chance to answer. Here is what seems most likely, and it is not the answer people usually want. Joan Crawford was not the camp monster of the movie, but she was also probably not the flawless mother her youngest daughters remembered.
She was a deeply wounded woman who loved her children, needed to control them, and treated them differently depending on the year, the child, her circumstances, and quite possibly how much she had been drinking. For two of her children, that meant a childhood they described with warmth and gratitude.
For the other two, it meant a childhood they described as a nightmare. Both of those things can be true of the same woman. There is a final irony in all of this. Joan Crawford spent her entire life controlling her own story. She changed her name, her age, her accent, her face, and her past. She built an image so polished that it lasted for 50 years.
And after her death, she lost control of her story completely. First to her daughter, then to Hollywood, then to a culture that turned her into a joke. The woman who had fought so hard never to be laughed at is now for millions of people simply a punchline about wire hangers. The real Joan Crawford is somewhere behind that punchline.
She is the little girl in Oklahoma watching Vaudeville from the wings of her stepfather’s theater. She is the work student scrubbing floors in Kansas City. She is the chorus girl who borrowed $400 to chase a dream to Hollywood. She is the Oscar winner, the Pepsi executive, the rival of B. Davis. She is the mother who grieved a baby son so deeply his name could not be spoken in her house.
She is the mother Kathy remembered as warm and wise. And the mother Christina remembered as terrifying. And she is the old woman alone in a New York apartment giving away her little dog because she could no longer care for it 4 days before the end. She was all of them. And no single story, not the book, not the movie, not the defense has ever been big enough to hold her.
If this story changed the way you think about Joan Crawford or complicated something you thought you knew, please subscribe to the channel and turn on notifications because there are many more stories like this one on the way. And now I want to hear from you in the comments. After everything we have walked through, where do you land? Do you believe Christina? Do you believe the twins? Or do you think both of them were telling the truth as they lived it? There are no wrong answers here, only honest ones, and I read every comment. Share this
video with someone who loves old Hollywood, and I will see you in the next one.