News

“THE BLUES IS TOO SIMPLE TO PLAY, ANYONE COULD LEARN IT”: At 83, Andy Summers Reveals The 4 Greatest Guitarists Of All Time

“THE BLUES IS TOO SIMPLE TO PLAY, ANYONE COULD LEARN IT”: At 83, Andy Summers Reveals The 4 Greatest Guitarists Of All Time

When you hear the shimmering, suspended chord voicings of Every Breath You Take or the razor-sharp reggae-infused attack of Roxanne, you are listening to a man who fundamentally redefined how the electric guitar operates within modern pop architecture.

For over four decades, Andy Summers served as the sonic mastermind behind The Police, weaving lush chorus pedals, jazz harmonies, and classical precision into multi-platinum stadium anthems.

Yet long before he conquered global arenas alongside Sting and Stewart Copeland, Summers was an obsessive student of harmony cutting his teeth in the smoke-filled, claustrophobic clubs of 1960s London.

Now, at 83 years old, looking back over a career that spans more than six decades of groundbreaking recordings and global tours, Summers has pulled back the curtain to reveal the four greatest guitarists he ever encountered.

He does not care about modern shredding acrobatics, lighting-fast sweep-picking, or clinical technical exercises that merely impress listeners for five fleeting minutes.

To Summers, true guitar mastery is about the rare human beings who completely altered the atmosphere of a room the second their fingers touched the fretboard.

He talks about the icons who forced you to put your drink down, stop whatever you were doing, and listen to a brand-new musical reality unfolding before your eyes.

His reflections are remarkably candid, occasionally ruthless, and refreshingly devoid of the polite industry mythology that has dominated rock journalism for decades.

From an extraterrestrial demigod who wiped out British guitar royalty in an instant to a two-million-dollar vintage guitar regret, here is Andy Summers’s unfiltered breakdown of the four greatest guitar players who ever lived.

The Alien in Buckskin: Jimi Hendrix and the Complete Annihilation of the British Hierarchy

When young Andy Summers walked through the doors of London’s Cromwellian Club in the late autumn of 1966, he assumed he was in for another routine evening of young English players trying to impress each other.

The London scene was bursting with hungry white musicians practicing their best B.B. King bends, all trying desperately to prove their authenticity on the club circuit.

Then, standing in the doorway surrounded by dark wood and thick cigarette smoke, Summers froze dead in his tracks.

On the small stage stood an American musician who looked like he had stepped straight out of a collective hallucination.

He had a massive, sprawling Afro, wore an all-white buckskin outfit with trailing leather fringes, and held a reversed white Fender Stratocaster in his mouth.

He was literally plucking notes with his teeth at deafening volume, commanding feedback loops that sounded like an alien spacecraft landing inside the venue.

Summers recalls that his feet were practically glued to the floorboards as he stared in complete disbelief, wondering what kind of creature he was witnessing.

It was not merely loud; it felt as though the entire room had been rewired by a cosmic architect who understood electricity on a cellular level.

Up until that exact evening, the London guitar aristocracy—Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck, and Jimmy Page—sat comfortably atop an untouchable mountain of critical worship.

According to Summers, the arrival of Jimi Hendrix did not just trigger a competitive challenge; it was a total and instantaneous demolition.

The standards and hierarchies that British guitarists had spent years constructing simply evaporated overnight.

Summers notes with total candor that everyone realized the small planet they had been living on was completely eclipsed by someone arriving from a different galaxy.

Yet what struck Andy even more than the stage pyrotechnics was the jarring contrast between Hendrix’s public myth and his private vulnerability.

Backstage, when Summers actually spoke to him, Hendrix was remarkably quiet, painfully soft-spoken, and almost withdrawn from the world around him.

Summers realized that Hendrix was a man who only truly became fully alive when he slung a guitar across his shoulder; the rest of the time, he was merely waiting for the instrument to give him a human voice.

Years later, during an impromptu jam session at a studio in Los Angeles with drummer Mitch Mitchell, Hendrix walked into the room, casually picked up a bass guitar, and began laying down grooves with Summers.

After ten minutes of playing, Hendrix turned to Andy with immense humility and politely asked if he minded switching instruments so Jimi could play guitar for a while.

That gentle, polite request from the man who had permanently shattered the limits of the electric guitar remains etched in Summers’s memory as the ultimate hallmark of a true genius.

The Five-Note Scale and the Two-Million-Dollar Blunder: Eric Clapton

When it comes to Eric Clapton, Andy Summers offers an evaluation that cuts directly against the grain of mainstream rock-and-roll mythology.

While the graffiti across 1960s London famously proclaimed “Clapton is God,” Summers viewed his contemporary through the critical lens of a disciplined jazz purist.

The two players shared the same circuit, haunting the dark basement of the Flamingo Club in Soho and checking each other’s gear during soundchecks with John Mayall’s Bluesbreakers.

Summers was well aware of Clapton’s fiery phrasing, but he harbored a secret, controversial opinion about the entire British blues boom.

To Summers, who spent his youth transcribing the intricate modal lines of Thelonious Monk and Wes Montgomery, the blues felt like an extraordinarily small room inside a very large musical house.

Summers boldly observed that Clapton’s celebrated style was built on a simple five-note minor pentatonic scale that anyone with basic discipline could easily learn.

He felt that the endless copying of Clapton’s blues runs across London was creatively limited, arguing that true harmonic exploration lay in the complex chord substitutions of modern American jazz.

Yet despite his philosophical reservations about Clapton’s minimalist palette, Summers found himself at the center of one of the most famous guitar transactions in rock history.

Summers had purchased a rare, pristine 1958 Sunburst Gibson Les Paul from a shop in London, an instrument that immediately caught Clapton’s eye during a Flamingo soundcheck.

After Clapton’s own Les Paul was stolen, he began calling Summers relentlessly, begging and pleading with him to sell the Sunburst model.

Summers finally relented and delivered the Les Paul directly to Advision Studios, where Clapton was recording the landmark Fresh Cream album alongside Jack Bruce and Ginger Baker.

As Andy handed the case over in the foyer, he heard Clapton plug it straight into a roaring Marshall amplifier through the studio monitors, shouting with sheer joy at the screaming sustain.

Summers walked away into the chilly London afternoon with two hundred pounds in his pocket, completely unaware that he had just handed over an instrument that would become central to classic rock history.

Today, that exact vintage Sunburst Les Paul is estimated to be worth upwards of two million dollars on the international collector market.

With a laugh, Summers reflects that if he had possessed any business foresight, he would have bought two of them and held onto both forever.

Even so, Summers never envied Clapton’s stylistic road, acknowledging that while Eric built a career making simplicity sound like sacred scripture, his own heart was already journeying toward broader harmonic horizons.

The Cerebral Architect from Bournemouth: Robert Fripp and the War on Blues

Few fans realize that long before progressive rock or new-wave pop existed, the creative lives of Andy Summers and King Crimson mastermind Robert Fripp were deeply intertwined.

Both men grew up in the quiet seaside town of Bournemouth, sharing the exact same local musical circuit and competitive teenage ambitions.

When Summers was sixteen years old, he landed a coveted residency playing guitar at a local Bournemouth luxury hotel.

However, young Andy was promptly fired from the job for spending too much time flirting with attractive girls in the front row instead of watching the bandleader.

In a twist of cosmic irony, the teenage guitarist hired to replace him was none other than Robert Fripp.

Years later, when Summers returned to England from a stint in California broke and looking for work, an established Fripp returned the favor by helping Andy secure essential London gigs.

That lifelong bond eventually culminated in two fascinating, experimental collaborative albums: I Advance Masked in 1982 and Bewitched in 1984.

Recording those projects presented Summers with an immense creative and intellectual hurdle that tested his limits as a musician.

Fripp did not play like any ordinary rock guitarist; he utilized complex multi-meter cross-picking, strict polyrhythmic discipline, and a clinical, almost mathematical precision.

Most strikingly, Fripp was an anomaly in British rock history because he had never played a single blues lick in his entire life.

Summers recognized that while he possessed the versatile technique to play jazz, classical, folk, and rock across the board, Fripp possessed an unyielding, single-minded purity that could never be taught.

They recorded inside a peculiar, eccentric facility in their hometown of Bournemouth, inhaling pipe smoke while constructing intricate interlocking guitar tapestries that defied commercial trends.

When Fripp had to depart before the completion of Bewitched, Summers took complete control of the production board, mixing and sculpting the project alone.

For Andy, who spent years navigating the intense interpersonal power struggles and rigid pop structures of The Police, making that record was a form of creative therapy.

It proved to the world—and to himself—that his artistic voice could thrive outside the shadow of Sting’s radio-friendly songwriting.

Summers remains immensely proud of those collaborative records, marveling at how two working-class lads from the same seaside town could invent an entirely new sonic dialect together.

The Freaky Virtuoso Across the Ocean: Eddie Van Halen’s Joyful Revolution

Of all the legendary guitarists in Andy Summers’s pantheon, his perspective on Eddie Van Halen is arguably the most surprising and nuanced.

Summers never shared a backstage green room with Eddie, never jammed with him at a soundcheck, and never met the California prodigy face-to-face.

Yet when Eddie burst onto the airwaves in 1978 with the explosive pyrotechnics of Eruption, Summers listened with the discerning ear of an experienced composer.

While the general public fixated on Eddie’s dazzling two-handed fretboard tapping, whammy bar dives, and high-speed shredding, Summers heard something far deeper.

He heard an uncommonly soulful, blues-rooted musician whose rhythmic pocket and natural phrasing were vastly superior to the endless army of imitators who followed him.

Summers has long expressed fatigue toward generic heavy metal shredders, pointing out that fast scales without musical intent become utterly exhausting to the human ear after five minutes.

Eddie was entirely different because he integrated revolutionary technical mechanics into a cohesive, joyful musical vocabulary rather than treating them like cheap circus tricks.

However, an ironic public dialogue erupted between the two guitar heroes during the height of the new-wave era in 1982.

During a magazine interview, Eddie Van Halen was asked for his honest thoughts on Andy Summers’s distinctive guitar sound in The Police.

Eddie gave a brutally candid assessment, remarking that it sounded like all Andy ever did was click on an MXR flanger and an Electro-Harmonix phaser pedal until his sound hit a wall.

Yet rather than delivering an angry, defensive insult, Eddie immediately laughed at himself, adding that people probably accused his own guitar playing of the exact same repetitive tricks.

When informed of Eddie’s critique, Summers did not take offense; in fact, he respected Van Halen immensely for his candid honesty and humor.

Summers acknowledged that Eddie was entirely right: Andy was leaning heavily into modulated textures to carve out sonic space between Sting’s basslines and Copeland’s hi-hats.

Both men were having the time of their lives inventing distinct sonic signatures that reshaped the sound of the 1980s from opposite ends of the musical spectrum.

Summers’s only enduring regret regarding Van Halen is that he never had the opportunity to stand in an arena, lean against an amplifier, and watch Eddie ignite a room in person.

He recognized Eddie as a true one-off, an American original who arrived like a comet, rewired the instrument’s vocabulary, and reminded everyone that playing guitar should look like pure joy.

The Common Thread: Arriving with an Original Voice

When you examine the four guitarists Andy Summers chose to canonize at age 83, the underlying thread that connects them becomes blindingly obvious.

It was never about who could execute the cleanest scales, who owned the most expensive gear, or who sold the most commercial records.

Jimi Hendrix arrived like an otherworldly shaman who turned volume and feedback into a living emotional language.

Eric Clapton demonstrated the power of absolute restraint, proving that three carefully chosen notes could anchor an entire generation of rock.

Robert Fripp rejected established traditions entirely, engineering an architectural, polyrhythmic universe through sheer intellectual devotion.

And Eddie Van Halen shattered the physical boundaries of the instrument, injecting an infectious, soulful joy into the heart of hard rock.

None of these four men sounded like anybody else on the planet, and none of them apologized for the unique path they chose to walk.

Andy Summers spent his life navigating those exact same artistic crossroads, defying conventional guitar roles to craft the atmospheric textures that made The Police immortal.

He reminds us that technique can always be studied, scales can always be memorized, and vintage gear can always be purchased.

Yet true immortality belongs exclusively to the rare, uncompromising players who arrive with their own voice and change the room forever.

You Might Also Enjoy