News

Mick Jagger MOCKED Dylan’s Guitar Skills — Jimi Hendrix’s Reaction Humiliated Him

 

The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson ran on a different fuel than most television.  It wasn’t the set, which at best was functional.  It wasn’t the budget.  It was the electricity that arises when really famous people gather in a room and are told to wait.  The green room at NBC’s Rockefeller Center studios in New York in the early 1970s was a long, low-ceilinged space with couches where everyone sat and the broadcast was projected.

There was a coffee table.  There was a tray of food that no one had touched.  There was a television monitor in the corner showing the broadcast in progress.  The desk, the sofa, Carson’s face doing what he did when a guest said something he didn’t expect.    On a Tuesday night in the spring of 1970, three musicians were scheduled for the same recording.

It was not unusual.  Carson liked musicians, their unpredictability, the way they filled the silence differently than actors or politicians.  His producer, a prudent man named Gerald Marsh, had given notice of the booking three days in advance. “You have Dylan, Jagger and Hendrix in the same room,” Gerald had said.

Carson looked up from his notes. “I know,” he said.  “That’s what I know,” Carson said again.  He picked up the pen.  “Make sure the coffee is good.”  Two hours later, Gerald would be standing outside the door of the green room listening to a silence he didn’t like.  If you were Gerald that night, would you have opened the door?  Bob Dylan came first.

He always arrived first, not because he was punctual, which he wasn’t particularly, but because he preferred to be already settled in when the others arrived.  He sat down in the corner chair, the one with its back against the wall, put his jacket on his knees and looked at the door .  He had the harmonica in his shirt pocket.

I always had it somewhere .  It wasn’t an accessory, it was something you turned to when you needed to think and had to do something with your hands.  A production assistant brought coffee.  Dylan accepted it, left it on the table, and didn’t drink it.  Jimi Hendrix arrived 17 minutes later.  He entered with the calm and measured movements of someone who had long since stopped getting nervous in rooms.

A purple silk shirt, rings on several fingers.  He scanned the green room like a musician scans a stage , instinctively checking sight lines, acoustics, and exits.  Her eyes fell on Dylan. “Hello,” Hendrix said.  “Hello,” Dylan said.  That was it for a moment.  The silence between them was the kind that makes you feel comfortable.

The silence of two people who understand the same language and don’t need to prove it. Hendrix sat on the sofa opposite Dylan.  He bent over with his elbows on his knees.  “Have you been playing?” Hendrix said.  Dylan thought about it.  “A little,” he said.  Hendrix picked up a guitar he had left leaning against the wall, a studio loan, nothing special, and turned it over in his hands without touching it, simply holding it as one holds something familiar.

“I’ve been working on something,” Hendrix said.  “One of yours.”  Dylan looked at him.  Something stirred behind his eyes: interest, recognition.  “Which one?” Dylan said. “The one from…”, Hendrix began to say.  And that’s exactly when everything changed.  The door opened and Mick Jagger walked in.

Mick Jagger didn’t enter rooms silently.  It was the result of a decade of going on stage and understanding at a cellular level that the moment you appear is the moment everything changes.  You can’t unlearn that.  It becomes your way of moving.  He entered with two people, an assistant and someone who appeared to be his representative, talking as they observed the room and cataloged its contents.

Her eyes first found Dylan and then Hendrix.  “Well,” said Jagger.  She smiled the smile that had appeared on magazine covers since 1964. “Here we all are.”  Dylan said nothing.  Hendrix raised a hand. Jagger settled onto the sofa, crossed his legs, and accepted a coffee.    He seemed comfortable, like those who have been rich for a long enough time seem comfortable.

Not exactly relaxed, but as if discomfort were not an option.  “Bob,” he said.  ” How much time has passed?”  Dylan thought about it.  “A while.”  “Newport?” “No, that was before.”  “The Isle of Wight?” ” Probably.”  Jagger turned to Hendrix.  “And you? I’ve heard about the Fillmore concerts. People are still talking about them.

”  Hendrix smiled, but said nothing.  If you ‘ve ever watched three people in a room decide, without saying a word, what kind of conversation they were going to have, you know exactly how those first few minutes felt.  There was a story that had been circulating for years: Dylan had once told Keith Richards that he could have written Satisfaction, but that the Stones could never have written one of their own.

Jagger had never mentioned it .  For a few minutes, the room found its rhythm.  A trivial chat, the careful circular conversation of people well-known enough to maintain a kind of permanent performance even in private.  It lasted about 4 minutes.  It started, as is often the case with these things, with something small.

A production assistant came in with a printed program and handed out copies.  Jagger looked at his own and then at Dylan’s jacket.  “Are you playing tonight?” he said.  “A song,” Dylan said.  “Guitar?”.  “Yeah”. Jagger tilted his head, in a small private amusement, the kind that a man enjoys when he has just been reminded of something he finds moderately funny.

—You know—he said in a casual tone, without addressing anyone in particular—, I always found it interesting.  Dylan.  The songs are extraordinary, obviously.  Words, there no one touches him.  He paused.  But the guitar paused again, a half-smile.  It works, doesn’t it?  It’s there.  It does its job.  Like a very reliable piece of furniture.

He said it casually.  The tone of a man offering a casual observation, not an insult.  The tone of a man who understands that the most effective goodbyes are those disguised as compliments.  The room fell silent .  Not the comfortable silence of before.  A different kind of silence.  The one that occurs when everyone in a space hears the same thing and processes it at the same time.

Think about that for a second.  A room full of people, a man you respect, and a word like a piece of furniture. What would you have said?  The production assistant looked at her clipboard. Jagger took a sip of coffee.  Dylan did n’t move.  He stared at a point somewhere between Jagger and the back wall.

Very still, like some people stay still when… Something has landed and they are deciding what to do with it.  Dylan did not respond.  Someone else did it.  Jimi Hendrix had been holding the studio’s borrowed guitar, still unplayed, turning it over in his hands.  When Jagger finished speaking , he stopped dwelling on it.

He put down the guitar.  She left it carefully, the way you leave something when you need your hands free for what comes next. He stared at Jagger for a long moment .  And Jimi Hendrix, who communicated most of what he needed to communicate through the instrument he had just left on the floor, used words instead.

Have you ever tried to play like him?  Jagger blinked.  Sorry?  Like Dylan, Hendrix said.  Have you ever tried to play what he plays, the way he plays it ?  “I’m not suggesting it because I’ve done it myself,” Hendrix said quietly, without aggression.  And I couldn’t.  The room was silent.  “I couldn’t do what he does,” Hendrix continued.

“I can play a lot of things, you know that. But what he does with three chords, the rhythm, the space, the way he leaves things out, that’s not furniture. That’s architecture.” He picked up the guitar again.  “The furniture holds things up,” Hendrix said.  “Architecture makes you feel something.”  He played a single chord, open G, and let it ring.

Then he looked at Jagger.  And that’s when Mick Jagger realized he had made a very serious miscalculation.  If you felt something just now, share it with someone who understands what it means when one musician stands up for another musician.  They will know exactly why this moment is important.  The silence that followed Hendrix’s chord was one of those that has weight and direction.

Those that everyone in the room feels pressured from a specific angle.  Jagger uncrossed his legs.  She crossed them again to the other side.  He looked at his coffee.  Dylan hadn’t moved, but something in his posture had changed, almost imperceptibly, like a man’s posture changes when someone he respects has just defended him. Jagger did what he always did when people turned against him .  She smiled.

But it was a different smile, smaller, recalibrated. “I didn’t mean it as an insult,” he said.  ” Obviously”.  “I know,” Hendrix said. Now he was playing, a pattern Dylan recognized after two bars, the beginning of All Along the Watchtower, the way only Hendrix played it .  That was what made it interesting. Jagger looked at Dylan.

Dylan was looking at Hendrix.  There was something about Dylan’s face at that moment, not exactly gratitude, the expression of a man who has spent 10 years watching people misunderstand what he does and has just heard someone explain it to him correctly.  “Ten years ,” he thought, “of people telling him what he was, and the first to get it right was the best guitarist alive.

”  He reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out the harmonica.  He didn’t touch her, he just held her.  “Architecture,” Dylan said, not addressing anyone in particular. Hendrix smiled without looking up. Outside the door, someone had been listening.  If you felt something just now , share it with someone who plays or has played before.

Gerald Marsh had been producing television long enough to know when something was wrong in a green room.  She had a reason for it , a particular tightness in her chest that she had learned to pay attention to over the years.  I felt it now, standing outside the door of the green room, listening to a silence that had lasted for 3 seconds too long.  He opened the door.

The three musicians looked at him.  “We’re about 12 minutes away,” Gerald said.  “The order will be Jagger, then Dylan, then Carson wants the three of them to sit together on the couch, if everyone agrees .”  The three of them, together, on the sofa on national television.  Gerald had never produced a segment where he genuinely didn’t know what would happen next.  Jagger looked at Dylan.

Dylan looked at the harmonica he was holding.  Hendrix looked at the guitar.  ” Sure,” Dylan said.  “Good,” said Jagger .  Her voice sounded calm.  I’d been doing this for a long time.  Hendrix simply nodded.  Gerald looked at them all once more.  He had the feeling of a man who had just agreed to drive a car and wasn’t entirely sure where the brakes were.

I only had 10 minutes to figure out what was going to happen on that sofa .  What would you have done with 10 minutes like that?  Johnny Carson had a habit that his staff knew about. Before each segment, he would read his notes once, put them down, and never look at them again .  He had explained it to a young writer.

“The cards are for the version of the conversation I ‘ve planned. The interesting conversations are the ones that aren’t on the cards.”  Tonight, I knew what I was supposed to ask Dylan.  The new album, the tour schedule.  Jagger, the Stones, the next album.  Hendrix, the guitar, always the guitar.  I knew nothing about the green room.

Gerald stepped through the curtain and caught Carson’s eye. The look that meant something had happened, I’ll tell you about it in 30 seconds.  Carson nodded.  He straightened his tie.  And Carson would have to decide, on air, whether to ask about it .  Mick Jagger was good on television.  She had been doing interviews since before most of the production staff started their careers.

And he understood the medium as a carpenter understands wood.  Its vein, its limits, where it stands and where it splinters.  He left to a great and genuine round of applause.  He sat down .  She smiled.  In 30 seconds, he was exactly the version of himself that the audience had come to see. Carson asked about the Stones, about the tour.  Jagger spoke.

Smooth, professional , refined to the point that it no longer seemed like a performance.  Then Carson said, “You’ve got some interesting company backstage tonight .”  Jagger smiled.  —Well, I’ve realized .  —Dylan leaves later.  And Hendrix.  -Yeah.  —Have you spent time with them?—A little—said Jagger—. Earlier, in the green room.

-AND?  Jagger remained silent for half a second.  Less than almost everyone would notice.  More than Carson would overlook.  —They are extraordinary musicians—he said—. Both.  Obviously.  It was a cautious response.  The response of a man who had reconsidered something in the last 45 minutes.  Carson looked at him for a moment longer than the script required.

If you ever see someone choose their words that carefully on television, you know exactly what Carson knew at that moment.  I knew something had happened. He decided to ask about it.  Dylan left to a different kind of applause.  Not stronger, but in a different way.  The kind of applause that contains a slight uncertainty.

The public’s awareness that they are applauding someone who might do something amazing, and their pleasure at not knowing what.  He sat down.  He had his guitar. He had the harmonica stand around his neck.  The chrome frame and the small rectangle of the harmonica.  What had appeared in a thousand photographs.

Carson asked him about the new album.  Dylan spoke about him indirectly, with short phrases, with the occasional unexpected image that made the audience laugh and then think about what they had laughed at.  Carson asked for directions.  “The road is the road,” Dylan said.  “It goes where it goes .”  Carson waited.  There was nothing more.

“You’re going to play something for us tonight,” Carson said.  “Yeah”.  “What are you going to play ?”  Dylan thought about it.  “Something that needs to be played.”  The audience laughed.  Carson smiled.  “That seems sufficient to me,” Carson said.  He didn’t play the song everyone was expecting.  He played “It’s All Right, Ma I’m Only Bleeding.

”  Not the album version, nor the Newport version.  A version that only existed in that room that night.  Slower, with a space between each chord in which you could feel the audience leaning in, filling it with their own held breath.  The harmonica entered after the second verse, deep and unadorned.

“It wasn’t embellishment,” he said.  Eddie Malone, a session guitarist who was watching from the sidelines, would later say: “I’ve been in rooms with a lot of guitarists. I know what the competition sounds like. What Dylan does isn’t that. It’s like watching someone having a conversation with the room. And the room always responds.

”  In the green room, backstage, on the monitor, Jimi Hendrix watched the performance without speaking.  And Mick Jagger, sitting next to him, also watched without speaking.  And there was a look on Jagger’s face during those 3 minutes, a look that his assistant saw and never forgot.

There was something very similar to the look of a man who had just been shown something he didn’t understand before.  If you ‘ve ever watched someone perform and felt that specific silence in the room, leave a comment below.  Tell me the artist.  Tell me where you were.  I want to know.  Carson brought the three of them together.  The audience responded with the kind of noise that television studios rarely produce.

The noise of 200 people simultaneously understanding that they are witnessing something that will never happen again.  Dylan sat at one end of the sofa, Hendrix in the middle, and Jagger at the other end.  Carson looked at the three of them.  “Gentlemen,” he said, “this is going to be either the best television I’ve ever made or a complete disaster.

”  The audience laughed.  “Probably both, ” Hendrix said.  Carson leaned back .  He left his letters.  “I want to ask something directly,” he said.  “The three of you have been in the same business at the same level for almost a decade. You’ve influenced each other musically. What do you really think of each other? Not the diplomatic version, the real one.

”  There was silence.  Then Jagger said, “That’s a dangerous question.”  “I know,” Carson said.  Jagger looked at Dylan.  Dylan looked at the table.  Hendrix looked at Carson. “I’ll start,” Hendrix said.  And that’s when Mick Jagger knew that the night wasn’t going to end as he expected. “Dylan changed what a song could be,” Hendrix said, “without preamble, without the usual caveats.

Before him, a song had to do certain things, tell a story in a certain way, end in a certain place. He broke all that. And he broke it so completely that most people don’t even know it was ever fixed.”  He looked at Dylan.  And then he continued.  He didn’t break it even once.  He broke it again and again every time people thought they understood what he was doing.

That’s not guitar skill.  That’s not vocal skill.  That’s something else.  Carson nodded. “And the guitar, specifically?” “The guitar, specifically, is exactly the right one for what he needs it to do,” Hendrix said.  “A guitar can do a lot of things. It can show off. It can command a room. It can tell you how awesome the person playing it is.

Your guitar doesn’t do any of that. It stays out of the way of the song. And staying out of the way of the song”—he paused—” is the hardest thing there is.”  The audience was very quiet.  In 20 years of television, Carson had learned to read the atmosphere.  He read this.  Carson looked at Jagger.  Jagger had been listening with his arms crossed and a carefully neutral expression.

“Now he’s uncrossed them.” Jimmy said it better than I could .  He said, “I’m sure you can add something.”  Carson said.  A pause . —Dylan  Jagger spoke and then stopped .  He tried again. I said something earlier tonight backstage that “he stopped again.” I said something careless and Jimmy corrected me as efficiently as possible.

He glanced briefly at Hendrix, then back at Carson.  And he was right.  The audience pondered that for a moment.  Carson said nothing.  He was very good at saying nothing.  Dylan was staring at a point somewhere above the desk.  Then he looked at Jagger.  ” You weren’t wrong.”  “Dylan said. Everyone looked at him.”  The guitar is functional.

” said”.  I never learned it the way that —he pointed to Hendrix—.  I didn’t study.  I discovered what I needed and stopped there.  That’s true.  —But Hendrix started it—.  But—Dylan said— that’s not the same as bad. Functional might be exactly right.  A hammer is functional. You wouldn’t call a hammer bad just because it’s a hammer.  —A pause—.

“That’s the most I’ve ever heard you say at once,” Jagger said.  Dylan stared at him for a long second.  Then he did something that the cameras almost never caught him doing.  Dylan smiled.  Not a big smile.  Not a fake smile.  The small, genuine, and slightly reluctant smile of a man who has just decided to find something funny.

And Jagger, after half a second, smiled back.  And Hendrix, looking at them both, said: “Now I feel like I’ve started something.”  “The audience erupted. If you’d been in the audience and seen all three of them laughing at the same time, what would you have felt? Let me know in the comments. If you know anyone who plays guitar— any guitar, any style— share them right now.

They already know exactly what Hendrix meant. The cameras stopped rolling. The conversation didn’t. Television ends at a specific moment. The moment the red camera light goes off. But the conversations in the hallway afterward don’t end. Gerald Marsh watched the three of them leave the stage. Dylan was the first, quick, no-nonsense, head down, already somewhere else in his mind. Hendrix came out and stopped.

He turned and looked at the stage, the sofa, the desk, the empty chairs. Then he turned to Jagger, who had come out right behind him. ‘ Are you okay?'”  “Hendrix said. Jagger looked at him. There was something in his expression that his assistant had never seen before, something that seemed like genuine uncertainty.

”  “I said something stupid,” Jagger said.  “Yes,” Hendrix said. “You did it.”  Another pause. “The thing is,” Hendrix said, “you’re not wrong that there’s a difference between what Dylan does and what, say , I do. The difference is real . You just described it wrong.” ” How should I have described it?” Hendrix thought about it.

“You should have said, ‘Dylan plays what the song needs. I play what I need.’ Neither is better. They’re just different hungers.” Jagger looked at him for a long time. ” Different hungers,” he repeated. ” Yes.” “That’s going to annoy me for a while,” Jagger said. “Good,” Hendrix said. He smiled. “That’s the point .

” He walked down the corridor toward the exit. Jagger stood there a moment longer. Then he found his assistant. “Get me a car,” he said. “I need to get back to the hotel and think of something.” A month later, a reporter asked Jagger about the show that evening. Jagger would say, “It was a good gig.”  The reporter asked if anything unexpected had happened.

Jagger paused longer than usual.”  “I learned something,” he finally said, “about the difference between a tool and an instrument.”  The reporter asked what the difference was.  Jagger looked out the window .”  “A tool does what you need,” he said.  An instrument does what music needs.  “It’s not always the same performers.

”  He did not give any further details.  It wasn’t necessary.  If you know a musician who plays for the music, not for the applause, send them this.  “He’ll understand every word.” Three months later, someone finally asked Dylan about it. Part 15, what Dylan said. Three months after the recording, a journalist ran into Dylan outside a recording session in New York.

The interview was supposed to be about the upcoming album.  “I found out about Carson’s show,” the journalist said.  I found out that something happened behind the scenes.”  “There’s always something going on behind the scenes,” Dylan said. Jagger said something about your guitar.” A pause. “Yes,” Dylan said.

“Does that bother you?”  Dylan remained silent for a moment.  “I was looking at the studio floor, the worn boards, the dust, the cables taped together in parallel lines.” “No,” he said. ” Why not?”  “.”  He thought about it for a long time. “Because he wasn’t wrong,” Dylan said. “He just stopped short of the right place.

” “What is the right place?”  Dylan looked at the journalist. The right place, he said, is that wrong is okay. Wrong in the right context is the point. Most of the great stuff I’ve played was technically wrong. Wrong note, wrong time, wrong chord, but it was right for the song.  He paused. “Mick plays what’s right.

He’s very good at what’s right. I play what’s necessary.”    They are not the same.  And Hendrix?  Dylan smiled, the same small, genuine smile from the television studio.  ” Jimmy plays what is true,” he said.  That ‘s something completely different.  ” He returned to the studio.”  And that, he said without turning around, is the reason why nobody sounds like him.

The journalist stood for a moment in the empty corridor. He had one more question he never got around to asking. That September, Jimi Hendrix died in London. He was 27. Part 16, the last part. There’s a photograph, which hasn’t circulated much, taken by an NBC staff photographer, of the three of them in the green room before the recording. Jagger is standing.

His posture is relaxed, practiced. He holds his coffee with the comfortable authority of a man who’s always been in rooms like this. Hendrix is ​​sitting, leaning forward, elbows on his knees. He’s looking at something off- camera. There’s a concentration in his face that’s visible even in a still image. Dylan is in the corner.

He’s wearing his hat. His hands are in his jacket pockets. He’s not looking at the camera, or at the other two men, but halfway off, the place Dylan has always looked when he hears something the rest of the room ca n’t yet hear. Three men in the same room, each in a different place. If you’ve ever been in a room and felt that  Something was going to happen, you know what that photographer saw.

The caption the photographer put on the print when he filed it was “Three musicians waiting .” That was all it said. Years later, when the photograph was published , an editor suggested a different caption, something more dramatic , something that told the story. The photographer said no. “Three musicians waiting,” he said, “that’s the story.

” He was right. The story is never the famous event that happened. The story is the moment before, the green room, the borrowed guitar, the comment that seemed small but wasn’t, the chord that meant everything. The story is Hendrix putting down the guitar . The story is the look on Jagger’s face in the hallway.

The story is Dylan, three months later in New York, saying, “Jimmy plays what’s true.” Dylan rarely spoke of Hendrix after that, but years later, he admitted something about “All Along the Watchtower.” Since Jimmy died, Dylan said, “I’d been playing in Jimmy’s style.”  Three musicians waiting for something. And then, when the moment came, each of them did exactly what they had to do, which is, if you think about it, everything.

If you made it to the end, you’re the kind of listener these men were playing for.  Subscribe and ring the bell.  Each week, a story from the rooms where the music really came to be.  The green rooms, the corridors, the moments that no one planned.  The music never stops.    It simply moves to a different room.

You Might Also Enjoy