News

Frank Sinatra Dared Michael Jackson to Sing “My Way” Live — Her Broken Voice Left Him Frozen

 

Frank Sinatra held the microphone out over the sofa like someone offering the last cigarette in the pack. “You sing everyone’s songs, kid,” he said.  “I want to hear you sing mine.”  Michael Jackson looked into the microphone.  He didn’t take it.  The studio laughed because Frank said it with that little tilt of his head, because he was Frank, and when Frank Sinatra joked with someone on television, you laughed.  That was the rule.

Ed McMahon laughed louder than anyone else, a resounding sound from the end of the sofa.  Doc Severinsen’s gang gave a quick metallic clang, the kind they used when a joke worked, but Frank wasn’t joking, not at all.  “Which?”  Michael asked.  Her voice was so soft that the giraffe microphone had to lower itself a few centimeters to pick it up.  Frank smiled.

“You know which one.”  The 300 people in the audience at NBC’s Studio One in Burbank also knew which one.  A murmur rippled through the seats, half gasp and half giggle, the sound of a crowd that had just realized it might be witnessing something it would be talking about at breakfast for the next 30 years.

Johnny Carson had a pencil in his right hand.    He had been tapping the rubber band against his desk all night, as he always did.  The blows stopped. “Frank,” said Johnny, “the young man came here to talk about his tour.”  “The tour is over,” Frank said.  “He told us himself , so he has the night off. Let’s hear him do something with her.

”  More laughter, louder this time, relieved .  Frank leaned back on the golden sofa and crossed one leg over the other, his dark suit perfect, the white handkerchief in his pocket impeccably folded.  He was 69 years old.  He had turned 69 just a few days before and someone in the audience had shouted, “Happy birthday, Frank!” when he came out, and he pointed at them and winked at them as if they were old friends.

Michael was sitting on the adjacent cushion wearing a white suit with his hands clasped on his knee .  He was 26 years old.  He had sold more records that year than any other living person.  His album Thriller had been on top of the world for so long that people had stopped being surprised.  He had won eight Grammy Awards in a single night that February.

She danced in a television special and changed the way a whole generation of kids walked down the hallways.  And at that moment, before all of America, he looked like a child who had been called on in class and didn’t know the answer.  “Mr. Sinatra,” Michael said, “that’s your song.”  “I couldn’t.”  “Of course I could.

”  “Nobody sings that song better than you.”  ” A lot of people sing it,” Frank said.  ” Every drunk in every bar from here to Jersey sings it. I ask you to sing it as if you were serious.”  There it was.  The room fell silent. Johnny looked at Ed. Ed looked down at his hands.  Up in the booth, the director leaned towards his monitors and said something to the cameramen through their headsets.

Something like: “Stay with Michael. Stay with Michael. Don’t you dare change the shot.”  Because everyone who worked on the show knew the difference between Frank the joker and Frank the serious one.  And this was the serious one, disguised as the joker. Michael finally extended his hand. He took the microphone from Frank’s hand .

His fingers were long and very thin, and Johnny noticed, as only someone who had been behind that desk for 22 years could notice everything, that they weren’t entirely firm.  Then Michael did something no one expected.  He didn’t laugh about it .  He wasn’t joking.  He turned and looked to one side of the stage, towards the dark side where the guests enter, as if he were checking if anyone was there.

There was nobody there.  He looked at Frank again.  ” Okay,” she said quietly, “but I’m going to sing it the only way I know how.”  Frank shrugged.  “That’s all I ask.” Neither of them knew yet that this was not true.  Frank was asking for much more than that, and Michael was about to give him something he had never given to anyone.

Not on a stage, not in a studio, not even in a room alone with his own mother.  The night had begun like any other great night on The Tonight Show.  It was December 1984. Outside in Burbank, the air was cool and dry and smelled faintly of the eucalyptus trees from the studio .  Inside, the place was filled with excitement because the guest list had been leaked to the newspapers the day before, and people were lining up on the sidewalk of Alameda Avenue before lunchtime.

Frank Sinatra and Michael Jackson on the same couch. Nobody could really imagine it. Frank was the old world.  It was a tuxedo in Las Vegas and the smoke from a cigarette under a single spotlight.  It was the voice that came from every kitchen radio in the United States during World War II.  She had survived teenage fans, rock and roll , the Beatles, disco music, and three or four people who had announced in the press that her career was over.

Michael was the new world.  He was the glove, the moonwalk, and the music videos that MTV aired every hour.  He was a young man who had been famous since the age of 11, the little one at the front of the Jackson 5, the boy with the big voice and the even bigger smile, standing in front of his four older brothers on the Ed Sullivan Show in 1969.

Johnny had hired them for different reasons .  Frank was there because he had a new album and because Frank, at 69 years old, was still filling every venue he performed in.  Michael was there because the Victory tour had just ended.  That tour had been the biggest musical event of the entire year.

Michael and his brothers, all six of them together, in football stadiums from Kansas City to Philadelphia and Dallas.  55 shows, more than 2 million tickets.  The press wrote about it every week, about the money, the arguments over ticket prices, and the fights between the businessmen surrounding the family.  And then, less than two weeks ago, on the final night of the tour at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, Michael walked to the front of the stage and said something that made 40,000 people fall silent.

He said this was their final goodbye, that it was the last time the brothers would perform together in that way.  His brothers found out in the same way as the audience, standing behind him under the lights.  The press had a field day.  Some said it was cold. Others said he was brave.  Some said he was finally a grown man forging his own path.

Michael hadn’t said a word to any of them.  He hadn’t given a single interview since that night until Johnny Carson called.  Johnny introduced him at the start of the second half.  The band played a few bars of Billie Jean, Michael came out from behind the curtain and the audience went wild .

People stood up on their seats.  A girl in the third row screamed so loudly that Doc’s trumpet player lowered his instrument and laughed.  Michael waved briefly , gave a small bow, and sat down on the sofa next to Frank, who had been introduced first and now leaned in to shake his hand.  “Nice to meet you, kid,” Frank said, loud enough for the microphones.

“It’s an honor, sir,” Michael replied.  Frank seemed to like the “sir”.  He patted Michael on the knee. For the first 15 minutes, it was delightful television.  Johnny asked Michael about the tour, and Michael talked about the stage they had built, how big it was, and how they had to transport it from city to city in dozens of trucks .

He told a funny story about a pet snake he had at home, a boa constrictor named Muscles, and Johnny pretended to climb onto his desk in horror.  The audience laughed.  Frank laughed.  Then Johnny asked about the last night, the farewell.  Michael’s smile changed.  It didn’t disappear, but it did retreat a little.

“It was about time,” was all he said.  “Was it difficult?” Johnny asked.  Michael looked at his hands.  “I believe that everything worthwhile is difficult.”  And that’s when Frank Sinatra leaned forward.  “Do you know what you need, kid?”  Frank said.  “You need a song for nights like that. A song for when you walk away from something and everyone is watching you.

”  The audience knew what was coming.  You could feel it.  A few people started applauding even before Frank said it.  “I have just the right one, ” Frank said, and reached across Michael’s lap, picked up the handheld microphone from the small table where an assistant had left it during the break, and offered it to him.

If you’re watching this right now , tell me in the comments where you’re watching from tonight, and whether you grew up with Frank’s records or Michael’s, or maybe both.  I read each one of them and I love seeing how far these stories go. However, what happened behind the scenes before the show is the part that no one in the audience knew about.

About an hour before the recording, Frank Sinatra walked down the long beige hallway behind Studio One, which has framed photos of past guests along both walls.  He liked to walk before a show.    He said it settled his stomach. Two of his men walked a few steps behind him, silently, as they always did.

At the end of the corridor, outside dressing room number four, he saw a young man sitting on the floor.  Not in a chair.  On the ground.  With your back against the wall and your knees drawn up.  He wasn’t wearing his white jacket yet, just a simple shirt and a hat pulled down to his eyes.  It took Frank a second to recognize him.

Michael Jackson was sitting on the floor of an NBC hallway with a small transistor radio pressed to his ear.  The volume was so low that Frank couldn’t make out what was playing. Michael had his eyes closed.  Her lips barely moved, as if she were singing silently, without making a sound.  Frank stopped. He looked at him for a moment.

Then Michael opened his eyes, saw who it was, and stood up so fast he almost dropped the radio.  Mr. Sinatra, I’m sorry.  I don’t… Sit down, sit down, said Frank.  No problem.  What are you listening to?  Michael hesitated.  Then she turned the radio around so Frank could see it, as if that explained anything.

It was old, the plastic was yellowed, and it had a crack in the dial that someone had repaired with adhesive tape.  Just one station, Michael said.  It’s an old radio.  I’ve had it since I was little.  Frank looked at her. He looked at the adhesive tape.  She looked at the young man holding her, the most famous artist on the planet, standing in a hallway in his socks.

Where are your people?  Frank asked.  In the dressing room.  I just wanted to be in a quiet place for a while.  Frank nodded slowly.  He knew very well what it was like to want to be in a quiet place. I had spent 40 years trying to find one.  “I read what you did at the stadium,” Frank said.  The farewell.

Michael’s body remained motionless.  It took courage, Frank said.  Or something like that.  Or something like that. Michael repeated very softly.  Frank studied it for another long moment.    He was a man who made a living reading atmospheres, reading the public, reading the faces of orchestra conductors, studio heads, and men at poker tables deciding whether or not to match a bet.

And what he read in Michael Jackson’s face that night was something he recognized to the very depths of his being.  It was the face of someone who had just walked away from the only thing he had ever known and wasn’t sure he had done the right thing.  Frank had worn that face once, a long time ago, in 1942. He said nothing more.

He simply touched the old radio with one finger, nodded, and continued walking down the hall.  But by the time she got to her own dressing room, she had already decided what she was going to do on the show that night.  I was going to give that kid a microphone and make him sing My Way.  Not to embarrass him.

That’s what everyone in the studio would think, and Frank knew it.    I was going to do it because a song like that is proof.  Either you can stand up , sing it and believe every word, or you ca n’t.  And if you can’t, Frank thought , then it’s better to find out now at 26 than at 69. What he didn’t know, while he was in that dressing room adjusting his cufflinks, was what was playing on that little radio.

And I had no idea what that meant to Michael.  This story is about to take a turn that no one expected.  Back on the sofa, Michael held the microphone in his lap for a moment without lifting it. Johnny leaned over the desk. “You don’t have to do this, Michael.” He said, and the audience laughed again, but more nervously now.

“Frank has been doing this to people since the Truman administration.”  ” Eisenhower”.  Frank corrected him.  The laughter was louder.  Frank was good at that.  He could deflate a room with one word and then reinflate it with the next. Michael smiled slightly at that.  Then he leaned towards Doc Severinsen, who was standing at the front of the orchestra with his trumpet under his arm and a shiny jacket that looked like it was sewn from pieces of a disco ball.

” Doc”.  Michael said, “Could you have the piano play it slow? Just piano and deeper, much deeper than Mr. Sinatra does.”  Doc raised his eyebrows.  “How serious?” .  Michael thought about it.  “Enough so that I can’t hide.”  Doc didn’t laugh.  He glanced at Michael for a second, nodded, and walked over to the pianist, a gray-haired man named Ross, who had been with the band for years.  They spoke in low voices.

Ross nodded and moved his hands over the keys without pressing them, searching for the right tone.  Frank observed all this with a slightly furrowed brow.  It wasn’t what I expected.  I had expected the boy to make a joke, maybe dance a little, sing the first line in a funny voice, and then hand the microphone back.

That’s what most of them did when Frank pressured them.  I had seen grown men with Oscars on their shelves do exactly that.  Michael didn’t do any of that.  He sat up straight on the sofa.  He placed his feet flat on the ground.  He closed his eyes.  “Ready?”. Doc asked. “No,” Michael said.  That also provoked a laugh.  A small one, but Michael wasn’t joking, and after a second, the laughter died away on its own.

“But go ahead,” he said.  Ross played the introduction.  It didn’t sound like the record. In Frank’s version, there is a grandeur at the beginning, strings with an epic sweep, as if the curtain were rising over a man’s entire life. What Ross played was more tranquil, just a few soft, low, slow chords, with space between them.

It sounded like someone sitting alone at the kitchen table late at night. Michael raised the microphone.  Before I tell you what came out of there, if you ‘re enjoying this story so far , press the like button. Honestly, it helps more than you think.  And stay, because what Frank Sinatra did when this song fell apart is something that no one in that building ever forgot.

The first notes Michael sang were almost a whisper.  People who were there that night later said they had to lean forward in their seats to hear him.  He didn’t sound like Michael Jackson.  He didn’t sound like the boy with the hiccups, the screams, and the high-pitched voice on the radio.

He sounded younger than that, somehow, and at the same time more mature. The tone Doc had chosen was at the very bottom of his register, where his voice was thin and a little raspy, and he did n’t try to make it bigger than it was.  He sang the first verse as if he were telling a story to someone in a hospital bed, about the approaching end, about facing the final curtain, about a friend he wanted to explain something to.

Frank’s eyebrows rose.  I had heard “My Way” sung a thousand times by a thousand people.  I had heard it at weddings, funerals, and retirement parties.  I had heard it in Japanese, Spanish, and Italian.  I had heard Elvis perform it wearing a white suit with a full orchestra blasting behind him.  Most people who sang that song did it like a victory lap, chest out, grand finale, look at me, look what I did.

Michael was singing it as a confession.  Johnny put his pencil down on the desk.  Ed McMahon, who used to fill every silence on that show with a giggle or a “hi-yo”, remained perfectly still with his large hands on his knees. Michael moved on to the second verse.  Her voice was finding its balance now, rising only slightly, and there was something so careful about how she handled each word that it was almost painful to listen to her.

He wasn’t acting .  There were no movements.  There was no dancing.    He sat on a sofa wearing a white suit and sang with his eyes closed and his free hand pressed against his chest.  The audience, which had been buzzing and laughing five minutes earlier, was now completely silent.  Not a cough, not a whisper.

A woman in the second row covered her mouth with her hand.  Frank shifted on the sofa. Now he was observing Michael’s face very closely.  The small smile she wore when handing him the microphone had disappeared.  Then Michael got to the part of the song about regrets.  Everyone knows the phrase, the one where the man says he’s had some, but too few to bother talking about them.

Frank had sung it 10,000 times with a hint of indifference in his voice, like someone brushing a speck of dust off their sleeve.  Michael started that sentence and his voice completely broke down.  It wasn’t a small crack.  It wasn’t the kind of hesitation that a singer covers up with a breath or a small embellishment.

It broke like a plate breaks when it falls on a tiled floor.  The note simply melted in her throat.    It stopped.  Ross continued playing for another measure, not knowing what to do, then left his hands still on the keys.  Michael opened his mouth to try again.  Nothing came out.    She closed her eyes tighter.

His hand was still pressed against his chest , and now everyone could see that he was trembling.  He tried once more. He managed to say two words.  In the third one, her voice cracked again, worse this time, a high-pitched, broken sound that the microphone picked up and sent directly to the speakers and 10 million living rooms across the United States.

Then he lowered the microphone to his lap and sat there with his head down. Nobody moved.  That’s the moment that everyone who was in the studio still talks about, not the singing, but the silence that followed.  Johnny Carson, who had handled every kind of live disaster imaginable, drunken guests, wild animals, and a man who once set his own sleeve on fire, sat behind his desk without saying a word.

The red light on camera two remained on.  In the control booth, the director had his hand on the commercial cut button, and he didn’t press it. And Frank Sinatra, who had started it all, who had smiled and extended that microphone as a challenge, remained seated on that golden sofa, completely frozen.    I wasn’t looking at the audience.

I wasn’t looking at Johnny.  He looked at the young man beside him, and the expression on his face was one that those who had known Frank for decades said they had seen only a handful of times in their entire lives.  He looked scared.  Not for himself .  For the boy.  Michael was breathing in small gasps, like someone trying not to cry in public and failing.  -Hey.

Frank said in a low voice.  His voice came out hoarse.  He cleared his throat.  —Hey, kid. Michael didn’t look up.  Frank moved closer , so close that their shoulders almost touched.  The giraffe microphone above them lowered a little.  The sound technician would later say that he thought about removing it to give them privacy, but decided that whatever was going to be said should be heard.

-What’s happening? Frank asked.  —What happened? For a long moment, Michael did not respond.  When she did, her voice was so weak that Johnny had to lean over his desk to hear her.  “I can’t sing that part,” Michael said, “because it’s not true.”  —What isn’t true?  Michael raised his head.  Her eyes were moist.

He looked at Frank, not at the cameras, not at the audience, only at the old man beside him.  —The whole song is about a man who did it his way—Michael said.  —Every choice, every mistake, all yours.  And I was sitting here singing it and I realized…—he paused and swallowed.  —I don’t think I’ve ever done anything my way, not even once.

Not in my entire life.  Frank said nothing.  He just waited.  —I was 5 years old the first time I sang in front of people— Michael said.  —I didn’t choose that.  I was 8 years old when we started rehearsing every day after school.  I didn’t choose that either.  I didn’t choose the songs.  I didn’t choose the steps.

I did n’t choose the clothes, the cities, or the hotels.  Someone always chose for me.  The audience was so quiet you could hear the buzzing of the studio lights.  —Last week at Dodger Stadium— Michael continued—, was the first time I decided something big on my own.  And I did it in front of 40,000 people, and I didn’t even tell my brothers first, because I knew that if I did , someone would talk me out of it.

Someone always makes me change my mind.    She looked down at the microphone in her lap.  —And I’ve been waiting all week to feel like it was something of mine , that I did it my way, but I don’t feel that.  I just feel like I hurt everyone.  Frank Sinatra closed his eyes for a second.  When he opened them, he no longer looked like the chairman of the board .

It looked like what it was underneath it all .  A 69-year-old man from Hoboken, New Jersey, who had made many decisions in his life and knew exactly how much some of them had cost.  “Kid,” he said , “can I tell you something that nobody knows? ” But before Frank could say another word, Michael said something else , something about that little radio in the hallway, and it would leave Frank Sinatra speechless in front of the entire country.

” You saw my radio,” Michael said, ” backstage.”  Frank nodded.  ” You asked me what I was listening to.” Michael let out a small, embarrassed laugh through his tears.  “He wasn’t listening to any stations. He has a cassette player on the side. It’s broken, but it still plays a cassette .

It’s been there since he was a little boy. He reached into the inside pocket of his white jacket. Everyone was watching. He pulled out the old radio, the cracked yellow one with tape over the dial. He’d had it with him the whole time. He held it with both hands.”  “When we lived in Gary, Indiana,” Michael said, “we had a small house, two bedrooms, and nine children.

” My father worked at the steel factory operating a crane, and when he came home, we would rehearse every day, for hours.  If we missed a step, we started again.  If we sang a note wrong, we started again .  “She turned the radio over in her hands. Across the street was a park with a baseball field. And in the summer, I could see the other kids playing outside from our window while we rehearsed.

I used to watch them. I would sing and dance, and watch out the window as they ran the bases. And sometimes I would cry because I desperately wanted to be out there. A woman in the audience made a soft sound, and the man next to her hugged her.”  “My mother knew,” Michael said. “She always knew. And at night, after everyone was asleep, she would come and sit by the bed I shared with my brothers, and let me listen to this radio with an earpiece in.

She would say, ‘You choose. Whatever you want to listen to . It’s your turn to choose.'”  “He turned up the radio a little.”  That was the only thing in my entire childhood that I got to choose, Michael said.  What was playing on this little radio at night?  He looked at Frank.  And what I chose most nights was you.

Frank Sinatra did n’t move.  My mother had one of his records, Michael said.  I don’t know where he got it.  I didn’t have much money for records.  It was an old one from the 50s. He recorded it on a cassette so he could listen to it in bed, and this is the tape.  He tapped the radio gently.  This is what I was listening to in the hallway tonight, that same tape.

I’ve had it since I was seven years old.  Johnny Carson had taken off his glasses.  She held them with one hand on the desk.    ” I used to lie there and listen to him,” Michael said, “and I thought that man could sing whatever he wanted.”  Nobody dictates his steps.  Nobody tells him to start over.  He just stands there, sings, and everyone listens.

And I thought that she must be the freest person in the whole world.  Her voice wavered again and then steadied.  So when he handed me that microphone tonight , Michael said, I wasn’t afraid of the song.  I was afraid because it was you .  Because you were the man on the tape and I didn’t want you to find out that I’ve never been free at all.

Nobody in that studio was breathing.  Frank stared at the small yellow radio in Michael’s hands. For several seconds, he seemed unable to take his eyes off her. Then something happened that the team members would talk about for years afterward.  Frank Sinatra’s eyes filled with tears.  She covered her face with one hand for a moment, pressing her fingers against her eyelids.

When she withdrew it, her jaw was tense.  “Fine,” he said, and his voice sounded hoarse.  Now, I must say, since we’re on the subject, before I tell you what Frank said next , I would love for you to subscribe if you have n’t already.  Stories like this are what we do here every week, and I’d hate for you to miss the next one.

And if Michael’s story about that little radio touched you, leave a heart in the comments.    I see them all.  Frank leaned back against the sofa.  He looked up at the lights for a second as if they could help him find the words.  That song, he said, My Way.  Do you know how many times I’ve sung it?  Michael shook his head .  “Me neither. Thousands. Every concert.

Every night. People expect it. If I don’t sing it, they think someone’s sick.”  A few people in the audience laughed softly, grateful , because it gave them something to do with all that pent-up breath.  “And do you want to know a secret? I can’t stand her .”  Johnny actually turned around in his chair.  “Frank”.

“That’s true,” Frank said .  “I’ve told my pianist. I’m telling America now. I hate that song. Everyone thinks it’s the story of my life, and every time I sing it, I feel like a liar.” Michael was looking at him now, really looking at him, his own tears forgotten for the moment.  “That sentence,” Frank said, “the one you couldn’t finish , about regrets, about having only a few, too few to mention.

”  He laughed, but there was no fun in it.  “Man, I have more regrets than this studio has seats.”  “I only learned to sing that phrase quickly so that no one would notice.”  The audience had fallen completely silent again .  “Do you know what I did in 1942?” Frank asked. “I was singing with Tommy Dorsey, the best band in the country.

Tommy took me in when I was a skinny nobody from Hoboken. He taught me how to breathe. He taught me how to hold a note so long people thought I had a third lung. Everything I know about phrasing, I learned standing next to that man, watching him play the trombone.” He shook his head slowly. “And then I left him.

I wanted to go it alone. And he wouldn’t let me go, and it got ugly. Lawyers, money, lots of money. Things were said that couldn’t be taken back. Everyone wrote that I was brave, that I was a big shot, Frankie going solo, Frankie doing it his way.” He glanced down at his own hands; the large gold ring on his pinky caught the light. “I wasn’t brave,” Frank said.

“I was 26 and scared to death , and I hurt a man who had been good to me. And I spent years telling myself it was…”  the right thing to do so you don’t have to feel that way.” Michael whispered, “26?”  “Just like you,” Frank said.  “Exactly the same age.”  The two looked at each other.

Something happened between them that the cameras could see but couldn’t fully capture.  Something like recognition.  So when I saw you in that hallway tonight, Frank said, sitting on the floor with your little radio, I saw that face and I recognized it.  I recognized it because I wore it.  And I thought, I’m going to give this song to the boy to see if he can sing it, because if he can sing it sincerely and feel it, then it’s okay.

So he has something that I didn’t have.  He paused.  “And you couldn’t sing it,” Frank said.  And that’s the best thing you could have done.  Michael frowned, confused. Because?  “Because you’re honest,” Frank said. I sang it for 15 years and never had the courage to stop halfway through and tell the truth.

You did it in front of the whole country on your first try.    He leaned over and placed his hand on Michael’s shoulder.  It was a large, heavy hand, the hand of an old man, and Michael did not move away.  “Let me tell you about another regret,” Frank said more gently.  Since we’re telling the truth tonight.  He took a breath.  “My mother,” Frank said.

Her name was Dolly.  Everyone in Hoboken knew her.  She was a small, tough woman, about this height.  He held his hand at the arm of the sofa.  She ran the whole neighborhood, she ran my father, she ran me.  When I was a child, she was the one who motivated me. She wanted me to be an engineer, to go to university, to do something respectable.

And when I said I wanted to sing, he threw a shoe at me.  The audience laughed, and Frank smiled a little, his gaze distant.  Then, when he saw that I was serious, he pushed me in the opposite direction.  He pressured me harder than anyone else.  He got me into every club, every competition, every radio program he could find.  He never let me quit.

Never.  Michael nodded slowly. I understood that type of mother.  I understood that kind of pressure from both sides .  In January 1977, Frank said, “I was opening at Caesar’s Palace in Las Vegas, and I wanted her to be there.”  She didn’t like to fly.  She was afraid of airplanes her whole life, and I convinced her anyway.

I chartered a small jet to take her from Palm Springs to Las Vegas, 20 minutes in the air.  I told her, “Mom, it’s nothing.” “You’ll be there before you know it .”  Her voice lowered in pitch.  The plane crashed into a mountain in a snowstorm.  They couldn’t find him for 3 days.  Nobody in the studio made a sound.

Every night since then, Frank said, “I go out on stage, someone in the band starts playing that song, and I have to stand there and sing about how I did everything my way.”  And do you know what my way did?  My way put my mother on that plane.  His hand tightened on Michael’s shoulder.  So do n’t sit here thinking you’re the only one who can’t sing that line, he said.  I can’t sing it either.

Except I never stopped long enough for anyone to see it.  Johnny Carson moved a little away from the camera. Ed McMahon reached into his jacket pocket for a handkerchief and didn’t even try to hide it.  Michael stared at Frank for a very, very long time. Then he did something no one expected. He raised his own hand and placed it on Frank’s hand, which was on his shoulder , and held it there.

“I’m sorry about your mother,” Michael said.  Yes, Frank said. Me too, dude.  Me too.  For a moment, neither of them said a word.  The band stood still.  The audience remained still. Up in the booth, a producer named Fred de Cordova, who had run that show for over a decade and had seen almost everything, stood with his arms crossed and his headphones thrown back, and said, to no one in particular: Leave it.

Let it run.  Nobody touch anything. So they let him run.  Finally, Frank took a breath and sat up straight on the sofa.  When he spoke again, something of the old Sinatra had returned to his voice, the rasp and the click.  “Very well,” he said.  This is what we’re going to do.  Michael looked at him.

You’re going to sing it again .  Michael immediately shook his head .  Mr. Sinatra, I can’t .  “Not “My Way,” Frank said.  I’m done with “My Way”.  “My Way” has been sung to the point of exhaustion.  Sing it your way.  “I don’t have a way,” Michael said.  That’s what I’m trying to tell you .  “Of course you have it,” Frank said.

You had it when you were 7 years old in that bed in Gary, Indiana, with a headset on, choosing what you wanted to listen to.  That kid had a way with things. Nobody took it from her.  Except they haven’t allowed her to use it for a while. Michael remained silent.  Change the lyrics if you want, Frank said.

Change the tone.  Change the tempo.  Sing it backwards if you want.  But whatever comes out of your mouth this time, make it yours, not mine, not your father’s, not the record company’s, yours. He nodded towards the radio that was still on Michael’s lap.  “For that kid,” Frank said, “the one who watches the ball game through the window.

”  Before we find out what Michael did with that, let me ask you something.  Have you ever had a moment in your life when you realized you were living under someone else’s rules?  Let me know in the comments if you feel comfortable.  Some of the stories they share are more moving than anything I could ever write.  And if you know someone who needs to hear Frank’s words tonight, please share this video.

Michael held the microphone for a long time.  He looked down, then at the audience in the dark, and then at Doc Severinsen’s band.  Then he turned to Ross at the piano.  ” Could you start over?”  asked. “But this time, don’t play the chords from the record. Just play one low note and keep playing it; I’ll come in when I ‘m ready.”  Ross looked at Doc.

Doc nodded.  Ross pressed a single bass key and held it, let it resonate, then pressed it again, and another, steady, slow, like a heartbeat, like someone knocking very gently on a door.  Michael stood up.  The audience held their breath, just a little.  He hadn’t gotten up the first time.

He walked a few steps from the sofa to the front of the stage until he was alone in the open space between Johnny’s desk and the audience, his white suit under the lights.  He held the microphone in one hand and the old yellow radio in the other.  He listened to Ross’s note four or five times and then began to sing.    It did n’t start with the first verse.

That was the first thing people noticed.  It began somewhere in the middle, with a line about the man saying he planned every step of the way.  And she didn’t sing it as a statement, she sang it as a question, as if she were questioning whether that was true, whether someone really plans every step.  Her voice was still thin, low, still marked by having broken down a few minutes before, but it no longer trembled.

She just sounded tired and honest, like someone talking at 3:00 in the morning after the house has finally gone to sleep.  Ross, at the piano, began to add chords under the note very gently, following it rather than leading it. Then Michael went back to the beginning. He sang the opening verse again, but changed things on the fly, small things.

He lingered more on words that Frank had always skimmed over .  He stretched out a phrase so that it sounded almost like a gospel hymn, that kind of slow, ascending melody you’d hear in a small Baptist church in Gary on a Sunday morning.  She took a part that Frank always sang powerfully and performed it so softly that the microphone barely picked it up.

And the strange thing is, it worked.  It worked better than anyone in that room would have believed.  The song stopped sounding like a rich old man reminiscing about his triumphs and started sounding like a young man in his early days, trying to figure out how to become someone he could live with.  Frank sat on the sofa and watched him.

Her hands were clasped between her knees.  He didn’t move a muscle. Michael returned to the part about remorse.  Everyone in the studio held their breath.  Johnny’s hand was flat on the desk .  Ed had stopped drying his eyes with the handkerchief and was simply holding it.  Michael stopped walking.    He closed his eyes.

Ross kept a background chord playing and waited.  And then Michael did something that made Frank Sinatra lean forward on the couch as if someone had pulled him by a string.  He changed the lyrics.  He didn’t sing that he had few regrets.  He didn’t sing because there were too few of them to mention.

He sang, very slowly, in his own words, that he had had more than he could count.  And that I was going to mention each one of them. And that he was no longer afraid of them.  Her voice broke again on the last word. But this time he didn’t stop.  He let it break.  She sang through the break, and that broken note came out raw and real, and somehow more beautiful than any perfect note could have been.

Someone in the audience let out a sob.  It echoed in the silence.  Michael moved on. He sang about facing things alone. He sang about standing firm.  But every time the original song puffed out his chest, he took the air out of it.  Everywhere Frank would have marked a note, Michael held it gently, as if it were something that could break.

By the time he got to the last verse, he had turned the whole song into something completely different .  It was no longer a victory.  It was a promise.  A young man promising a child at a window that someday, somehow, things would be different.  He reached the last line, the big one, the one where Frank always opened his arms and the orchestra pounded like thunder.

Michael didn’t sing it.  It stopped.  Ross stopped. The entire room seemed to stop.  And Michael Jackson turned around, looked at Frank Sinatra on the sofa and handed him the microphone.    It took Frank a second to understand. Then Michael said in a low voice, picked up only by the boom microphone: “Will you sing the ending with me? But not like you always do.

Like you would if nobody was watching.”  Frank Sinatra stood up.  He was 69 years old , his knees weren’t what they used to be, and it took him a moment to straighten up. Then he crossed the stage, under the watchful eye of the band and the cameras, and stood next to Michael in the center of the floor.  He didn’t take the microphone.

She placed her hand on Michael’s, and together they held him .  Ross played the last chords again, very slowly.  And for the first time in 15 years, Frank Sinatra sang the last line of My Way without any struggle in his voice.  She sang it softly.  He sang it in a deep voice.  He let Michael carry the melody and sang a harmony underneath, just as Tommy Dorsey had taught him to position himself under a trombone line in 1940.

His voice, which by then had become raspy and dark with age, enveloped Michael’s young, thin voice and supported it from below.  It wasn’t strong.  There was no grand finale, no outstretched arms, no orchestra, just two men from two completely different worlds, one at the end of his journey and the other at the beginning of his, holding the same microphone and singing the same words in a way that neither of them had ever sung before.

The last note faded away.  Nobody applauded.  For a full 5 seconds , the entire studio remained silent.  Then the silence continued until 10, then 15. Johnny Carson would say years later that, in all his time hosting that show, he never heard such a silent audience after a song.  Then a woman in the back row stood up .  He did not applaud.  He just stood there.

Then the man next to him stood up, then a whole row, then the next one, and still no one was applauding.    They were just standing there, 300 people standing in absolute silence, staring at the two men in the middle of the stage. And then, suddenly, as if someone had opened a dam, the applause came.  It came like a wave.

He continued and continued.  People were crying and applauding at the same time.  Doc’s gang was standing.  The camera operators had come out from behind their cameras.  Ed McMahon was standing at the end of the sofa with his handkerchief in one hand, clapping against his own leg with the other.  Frank put his arm around Michael’s shoulders.

Michael rested his head for a moment against Frank’s shoulder, just for a second, like a tired child.  Then he straightened up and gave the audience a small, shy bow. Frank leaned towards him and said something that the giraffe microphone didn’t pick up, but a stagehand standing right behind them did.

And years later, he said that Frank’s words were: “That was yours, kid. All yours. Never let anyone take that away from you.”  If this moment gave you goosebumps, let me know by liking this video, and tell me in the comments, was there a song you listened to as a child that stayed with you for the rest of your life?  Because what happened next in that studio was unplanned, and it completely changed the ending of this story.

The applause was still going on when one of the producers rushed out from behind the curtain on the left side of the stage.  That never happened during a recording.  The producers stayed in the booth, but this guy came almost running, holding a small piece of paper, and went straight to Johnny’s desk and handed it to him.

Johnny read it, then he read it again.  He looked at Michael.  ” Michael,” Johnny said, “there’s a phone call for you in the booth. They want to know if you’ll take it on air.” Michael seemed confused.  “Who is it?”  Johnny looked at the paper one more time .  She’s your mother.  The audience made a sound.

Michael’s hands went to his face.  Katherine Jackson had been watching the show at home.  The family already had a large house in Encino on a street called Havenhurst, behind a gate, far away from the two-bedroom house in Gary.  She had been sitting in the living room in front of the television when her son collapsed on that sofa.

And by the time he pulled out that little yellow radio, she had gotten up and walked straight to the phone in the kitchen and started calling NBC.  It took him four attempts to get through the switchboard.  The network operator hadn’t believed him at first.  Johnny looked towards the control cabin.  Fred de Cordova, behind the glass, raised a hand and then gave a thumbs-up gesture.

Pass it on , Johnny said.  There was a crackle in the studio speakers, a pause, and then a woman’s voice, soft and warm, with the gentle accent of someone who grew up in Alabama and spent her life in Indiana.  Michael?  Michael stood very still in the middle of the stage.  “Mother,” he said.  Hello.  The audience fell silent again.

“I saw you, darling,” Katherine said.  I watched the whole program.  “I’m sorry,” Michael said quickly.  I didn’t want to talk about all that on television.  “I didn’t mean to…” Silence , said his mother.  You don’t have to apologize to me, not for that. Michael lowered his head.  “I’m calling,” Katherine said, “because there’s something you don’t know about that tape, and Mr.

Sinatra should hear it too if he’s there.”  Frank approached the loudspeaker. Here I am, ma’am.  There was a pause on the line.  When Katherine spoke again, her voice trembled slightly.  Mr. Sinatra, I want you to know that that record did n’t come from a store.  Frank frowned .  In 1965, Katherine said, we had nothing.

Joseph worked at the steel mill and played guitar on weekends, and we had eight children in two bedrooms.  I couldn’t buy records.  But there was a garage sale at a church in Gary one Saturday, and they had a box of old records for five cents each.  Most of them were scratched, and I found one of his at the bottom of the box, an old one.

It didn’t even have a case.  Frank listened very attentively.  “I bought it for five cents.”  Katherine said.  “I hid it because Joseph just wanted the children to hear the music he chose for them. He said it was business, and I understood. I really did. But I wanted my children to have something that was just for them.

So I borrowed a tape recorder from a friend, recorded his album onto a cassette, and gave it to Michael along with that radio. He was the youngest at the time and couldn’t sleep. He would stay awake. He always had so much on his mind.”  Michael dried his face with the back of his hand.  “And I want to tell you what he told me.

” Katherine continued.  “The first night he heard it, he was seven years old. I went to take the earphone out because I thought he had fallen asleep, he grabbed my hand and said, ‘Mom, can that man choose his own songs?'” Frank covered his mouth with one hand.  “And I said yes.”  Katherine said.  “I told him yes, darling.

That man chooses his own songs.”  And Michael said, ” Then, when I grow up, I want to choose my own.”  The studio was in absolute silence.  “So there you have it, Mr. Sinatra.”  Katherine said, and now her voice broke.  “My son has tried to sing it his way since he was seven years old. Not his song, his way. The way you chose.

That’s what he wanted his whole life, and tonight , when you told him to sing it his way.”  She stopped.  When she continued, it was barely a whisper.  ” Tonight is the first time I’ve heard him do it.”  Michael walked away from the cameras and covered his eyes with both hands.  Frank stood there in the middle of Johnny Carson’s stage, an old man in a beautiful suit who couldn’t say anything.  He tried it once.

He opened his mouth and nothing came out.  She closed it and looked at the ground.  Finally, he cleared his throat.  “Mrs. Jackson”. he said.  “You raised a good man.”  ” I know”.  Katherine said it, and part of the audience laughed through tears at the simplicity with which she said it.  “But thank you for saying it on national television.

His father might be watching.”  That provoked a bigger laugh, a warm one.  Even Michael laughed, a small, wet sound behind his hands.  “Michael,” said his mother.  ” Yeah?”.  “Your brothers called me tonight, before the show. All of them .”  Michael lowered his hands.  “They ‘re not angry anymore,” Katherine said.  ” Jermaine said to tell you that he understands.

Tito said to tell you to eat something. And Marlon said…” She paused, and you could hear her smiling.  “Marlon told me to tell you that he’s proud of you, that someone in this family had to be the first to choose their own song .”  Michael didn’t say anything for a while .  He just stood there nodding over and over again with his eyes closed.

“I love you, Mom,” he finally said.  “I love you too, darling. Now let the man finish his program.”  The line was cut.  Johnny Carson sat behind his desk for a few seconds without saying anything.  Then he looked directly at camera two, as he did at the end of each program when he said goodnight. But this time he didn’t say goodnight.

” Friends,” he said, “I’ve been sitting at this desk for 22 years and I don’t think I have a single joke for this.”  “So we’ll take a break, and when we come back, well, I don’t know what will happen when we come back.”  “Stay there.”  The band played softly during the commercial break, and for the next 3 minutes, while the network aired advertisements for detergent and cars, nobody in Studio One said a word.

Before we get to what happened in the dressing room after the show, I’d like to ask you a small favor.  If you haven’t subscribed yet, please do so.  It’s free, takes 1 second, and means you’ll be here for the next story, which I promise you won’t want to miss.  After the recording, the corridor behind studio one was as crowded as ever.

Assistants with folders, security guards, people from the chain in elegant suits trying to look like they hadn’t been crying.  Someone had already called the newspapers.  Frank Sinatra walked down the same beige hallway he had walked down before the show.  His two men walked behind him.  When he arrived at dressing room number four, he stopped.

The door was ajar.  He knocked on the door.  “Forward”.  a soft voice said .  Michael was sitting on the floor again.  Same place, same position, with your back against the wall.  Except this time she was inside the dressing room, on the carpet next to the makeup mirror, still wearing her white suit and with the old yellow radio on her lap.  Frank looked at him.

Then, slowly, with a small grunt, he got down and sat on the ground beside her.  One of Frank’s men looked at the other.  In 20 years, neither of them had seen Frank Sinatra sit on the floor.  Frank gestured for them to leave. They closed the door.  The two sat side by side in silence for a minute or two.

The only sound was the buzzing of the lights around the mirror.  “How old is that radio?”  Frank asked.  “19 years old.”  Michael said.  “Older than some of the guys in Doc’s band .”  Michael laughed a little.  “Can I hear it?”  Frank asked.  “The tape?”  Michael looked at him in surprise. Then he nodded and pressed the cracked button on the side of the radio.

There was a buzzing, a hissing, and, very faint and distorted, through a small speaker that vibrated on the low notes, a voice from long ago emerged.  A young Frank Sinatra, in his early thirties, singing a slow ballad from the 1950s, with the needle hissing on the old nickel record, the tape stretched and oscillating from having been played thousands of times.

Frank sat down and listened to his own voice from 30 years ago coming from a dented radio in the hands of a young man who had grown up listening to it.    He didn’t say anything until the song was over.  Then he stretched out his hand and pressed stop.  “I don’t sound so good anymore.”  said.  “You sounded good tonight.” Michael said.

“I sounded sincere tonight .”  said Frank.  “That’s different. It took me 69 years.”  They sat there a while longer.  “Can I ask you something ?”  Michael said.  “Shoot.” “When you left Tommy Dorsey, did things ever get better with him?”  Frank remained silent for a long time. “A bit.”  he finally said.  “Not entirely.

We worked together again a couple of times, shook hands, smiled for photos, but I never sat down with him to apologize. I kept thinking there would be time, and then he was gone . He suffocated in his sleep in 1956. I was on a film set when I found out.”  He looked at Michael.  ” Don’t do that,” Frank said.  “With your brothers, don’t wait.

You can distance yourself from the act. That’s your right. It’s your business. But don’t distance yourself from them. They’re two different things. I didn’t know that at your age. I’m telling you this so you don’t have to learn it like I did.”  Michael nodded slowly.  “And one more thing,” Frank said, and his voice changed.  She became a little tougher, more professional.

Do you know what I did in 1960?  Michael shook his head slightly.  “I founded my own record company,” Frank said.  Reprise.  Do you know why? Because I got tired of men in offices telling me what to sing, what songs, what arrangements, what band. So I had my own label.  After that, nobody chose my songs except me.

He tapped the ground with a finger for emphasis.  Your mother told you that a man chooses his own songs.  Well, that’s how he does it. He is the owner.  Can you hear me?  It is not enough to just write them down.  It is not enough to just sing them.  You have to own them.  The songs, the masters, the documents.

Whoever owns the paper, owns your path.  Never forget that. Michael looked at him with an expression that Frank couldn’t quite decipher. Then Michael smiled.  It was a strange, private smile.  “Actually, I’ve been thinking about that,” he said.  Yeah ?  “There’s a catalog of songs,” Michael said.  A big one.  Many old songs that I love.

I’ve been told it might be on sale next year.  Everyone says it’s too much money.  Everyone says I’m crazy. Frank smiled for the first time since the song, a true Sinatra smile , the one that had captivated people since 1943. “Boy,” he said, “everyone said I was crazy too.” Buy it.  Michael burst out laughing .

It was the first time all night that she had laughed like that, completely, holding nothing back .  Then Frank put his hand in his jacket pocket and pulled out something small and folded.  It was a single sheet of paper, folded many times, with smooth, gray edges. “Here,” he said.  I want you to have this. Michael carefully unfolded it.

It was a musical score.  My Way.  The original arrangement, the piano part, with pencil marks all over, small notes in the margins, breath marks, arrows.  And on the line about regrets, someone had drawn a dark, firm circle with a pencil, pressed so hard that it had almost torn the paper.  “That’s my copy,” Frank said, “of the first session in ’68.

”  I’ve taken her to every show since then.  It’s my lucky charm.  I suppose it’s superstition.  Michael touched the dark circle around the line of regrets.  What is this ?  “That,” Frank said, “is where I always remind myself to sing fast so no one notices I’m lying.” Michael just stared at him.  “I do n’t need it anymore,” Frank said.

You fixed that part tonight. Michael held the paper with both hands for a long time.  Then she took a pen from the makeup table.  He looked at Frank as if asking for permission.  Frank nodded.  Underneath the dark circle, in small, careful handwriting, Michael wrote one word: “everyone”.  Then he folded the sheet again and handed it to Frank .  “No,” Michael said, “you keep it.

” But now, when you get to that part, you’ll see that and you won’t have to sing it fast.  Frank unfolded the paper and stared at the word for a long moment.  All.  I’ve had them all, so to speak .  I will mention them all, every regret, each one.  He folded it again and put it in his pocket, right over his heart, and patted it .  “I’ll try,” he said.

They got up from the ground together. Frank’s knees creaked.  Michael laughed and offered his hand, and Frank took it.  At the door, Frank stopped and turned around.  Hey, kid.  Yes sir.  That baseball field across the street in Gary.  Michael’s face remained motionless.  “You’re 26 years old,” Frank said.

You have more money than God .  You could build yourself a whole baseball field, an entire park, a carousel , a train, whatever you want.  Michael looked at him for a moment, then smiled.  Maybe I will .  “Do it,” Frank said, “and then go out and play in it.”  It’s an order from the chairman of the board.  He went out into the hallway and the door closed behind him.

If you’re still here with me, thank you.  Really.  Leave the word “mall” in the comments so we know you made it to this part of the story.  You are the reason we keep counting them.  What happened after that night is now part of history.  The clip was never officially broadcast.  For years, people who were in the audience described it to their friends and children, but they failed to convince anyone.

A few people recorded it from television on their home video recorders, and copies of copies circulated, grainy and flickering, among fans on both sides.  In August 1985, less than a year later, Michael Jackson bought ATV’s music catalog for more than $47 million.  It contained thousands of songs, including most of the Beatles’ catalog.

Almost everyone in the music industry told him it was too much money.  He bought it anyway. When a reporter asked him why, he simply said that he had learned from someone he admired that a man should own his own songs.  He never said who.  In 1987, he released Bad.  It was the first album of his career in which he wrote most of the songs himself.

He chose them.  He chose the arrangements.  He chose the videos, the dancers, and the cities for the tour.  For the first time, from beginning to end, it was his.  And in 1988, Michael Jackson bought a ranch in the Santa Ynez Valley, in the hills north of Santa Barbara.  He called it Neverland.

He installed a train, a Ferris wheel, a carousel, a zoo, and a cinema.  He would invite children by the dozens, sick, poor and from children’s hospitals, and let them play all day.  Years later, Michael explained in interviews that he built it because he never had a childhood, because he saw others playing behind a window and wanted a place where that window no longer existed.

Those who knew him said that in his private office at Neverland, on a shelf behind his desk, there was an old, cracked, yellow transistor radio with tape on the dial.  No one was allowed to touch her.  As for his siblings, the Jacksons did reunite. Not every year, not all the time, but there were dinners, birthdays, and festivities at the Havenhurst house.

In 2001, the six brothers were together again on stage at Madison Square Garden in New York. Michael had insisted on it.  Frank Sinatra continued singing My Way until the end of his career.  But the musicians who accompanied him in his later years noticed something.  In the late 1980s, Frank began to sing the line about regrets differently.

It made her slower.  He stopped rushing.  He would let it float in the air for a second, sometimes two, and close his eyes.  And sometimes he would put his hand on his chest, right over the inside pocket of his tuxedo jacket.  A pianist who toured with him for years once said that Frank always carried an old, folded score in that pocket.

The pianist asked him about it one night in a hotel bar.  Frank took it out , unfolded it, and showed her a small word written in pencil in someone else’s handwriting under a dark circle.  Just that word.  ” All”.  What does that mean? the pianist asked.  Frank folded it again.    ” It means that a child taught me to sing my own song,” she said.

It took me 69 years to learn it.  Frank Sinatra died on May 14, 1998 in Los Angeles.  He was 82 years old.  Some time after the funeral, a reporter asked Michael Jackson about him.  Michael didn’t talk about the music, the records, or the movies.  He talked about a night on a television couch.  “He gave me a microphone,” Michael said, “and I thought he was trying to embarrass me.”  That wasn’t the case.

He was trying to give me something.  He was trying to give me permission.  Nobody had ever done that before, not in that way.  He stopped for a moment. People think “My Way” is a song about winning, Michael said.  It isn’t.  It’s a song about being honest about what it cost you. Mr.

Sinatra didn’t teach me that with his voice.  He showed it to me by letting me see him cry.  That night in Burbank began as a challenge, an old legend testing a young woman in front of the whole country, as old legends always have done .  Frank was expecting a laugh, a joke, maybe an awkward verse .  What he got was the broken voice of a young man and the truth behind it.

And when that voice broke, Frank Sinatra didn’t laugh.  He did not recover the microphone.  He didn’t sing about the silence to save the moment.  She sat down next to him.  He told his own truth.  And then she stood up and sang beneath that young man, low and soft, so that the young man could finally be heard. Because the bravest thing a legend can do is not to sing louder than everyone else in the room.

 

You Might Also Enjoy